All the examples with a kanji version (where applicable) and a translation: このコーヒー、おいしいね。 This coffee is tasty. このコーヒー、きのう スターバックスで かった。 このコーヒー、昨日スターバックスで買った。 I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday. わたしはきのうスターバックスでこのコーヒーをかいました。 私は昨日スターバックスでこのコーヒーを買いました。 I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday. このコーヒー、きのうスターバックスでかいました。 このコーヒー、昨日スターバックスで買いました。 I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday. たなかさん、さいきんちょうしどうですか？ 田中さん、最近調子どうですか？ Tanaka-san, how are you doing these days? たなかさん、ごはんたべました？ 田中さん、ご飯食べました？ Tanaka-san, have you eaten yet? たなかさん、かみのびましたね？ 田中さん、髪伸びましたね？ Tanaka-san, you grew your hair long didn't you? たなかさん、かおいろわるいですよ。 田中さん、顔色悪いですよ。 Tanaka-san, your face looks pale. たなかさん、いまからごはんたべにいきませんか？ 田中さん、今からご飯食べに行きませんか？ Tanaka-san, do you want to go eat together now? このほんおもしろいですか？ この本、面白いですか？ Is this book interesting? このほん、あんまりわたしは すきじゃありませんね。 この本、あんまり私は好きじゃありませんね。 I don't like this book much. このほん、わたしのともだはとてもおもしろいといっていましたよ。 この本、私の友達はとても面白いと言っていましたよ。 My friend said that this book was very interesting. でもわたしはあんまりおもしろいとおもいません。 でも私はあんまり面白いと思いません。 But I don't think it's interesting. このラーメンおいしいですね。 This ramen is tasty isn't it? このラーメン、ちょっとあじがうすいですね。 このラーメン、ちょっと味が薄いですね。 This ramen tastes a bit too light. このラーメン、ちょっとからすぎです。 このラーメン、ちょっと辛すぎです。 This ramen is a bit too spicy. そのめがね、どこでかいました？ その眼鏡、どこで買いました？ Where did you buy that glasses? このめがね、きのうパルコでかいました。 この眼鏡、昨日パルコで買いました。 I bought this glasses at Parco. このネール、どう？ How is my manicure? そのネール、かわいいね。 Your manicure is cute. このネール、きのうともだちがやってくれたんだ。 このネール、昨日友達がやってくれたんだ。 My friend made this manicure for me yesterday. このワイン、フランスのなになにさんのとてもたかいワインなんですよ。 このワイン、フランスの〜〜産のとても高いワインなんですよ。 This wine is a very expensive wine from Something-something place in France. このワイン、クソですね。 This wine is shit.
I remember when I first started learning Japanese, I thought having to read kanji would be useless since I had hiragana and katakana. But now that I’ve learned some kanji, reading full hiragana sentences just feels so unnecessary and long. So thanks for the kanji version!
In English those times I ... I was not the subject. I was the prospective. I am.. Are you... & so on. English uses prospective in many cases to establish the setting for a discussion.
Omg the Google English translation...sometimes all it does is romanize!! 'This wine is expensive from France's Nani Nani." From France's whaty what? Hahha 😂
you are so good at teaching japanese, and i noticed you've done a really good job of addressing some of the biggest problems english speakers face when learning the language. please keep making videos!
Bro, I’ve been watching Japanese language learning videos for about 10 years on and off. This is the first time I’ve heard someone mention dropping は and how to structure sentence so clearly 🙇🏻♀️
@@ananditotugarisman9122 Well, if you want your speech to match the occasion, it'd be best if you didn't drop anything from a sentence. Dropping the は is slang.
In English you can also *sometimes* change word order to emphasize the topic. "This coffee I bought at starbucks today." "This book I don't like very much." It sounds a bit awkward and isn't nearly as common as it is in Japanese, but it's understandable and demonstrates basically what's going on in Japanese.
@xg223 you can if you need to emphasize something like possession, for example, say you were talking about someone else's book and you need to talk about your book you can say 'watashi no hon' to specify that it's your book. Hope this helps. Or if you mean like 'this book i bought today' you can say 'kyo ni katta no hon' or something to that effect.
This omission of marker is simple at the core, it's like the progression from "Have you been well?" to "You been well?" To "Been well?" When we're talking to someone in the most casual way we can get ride of several words and it means exactly the same. If its more formal, people may tend to use は more
No, it doesn't "basically demonstrate what it going on in Japanese" because in Japanese that kind of word order makes sense *grammatically* and only implies correct language use, but if you did the same thing in English it would be done for some particular *emphasis*. Semantic emphasis and correct grammatical form and function are not remotely the same things.
@@Hooga89 people are so ignorant about how English isn't so much allowing for different grammar, as it has established practically dialects due to the number of people who speak both English and their other native language with each other. They've heard this sentence structure because it's used by many Asian people, but it's not accepted in English. I should add that it's silly that these things are treated as bad English given most of the world speaks English as a second language.
I struggled with Japanese sentence structure in college. My Japanese teacher refused to explain how sentence structure worked, she just expected us to know 😭 This made it so much easier, so I’m just going to self teach now.
Most " Teachers" are taught to teach only one method, I struggled alot in HS bcs they just didn't know. I've been learning japanese on my own for 1 year now and is best to do self-study. You know how your brain works and how to train it to learn. 😊
The "Topic-Comment structure" is indeed, ingenious.. I am hearing it for the first time and it makes so much more sense, Japanese language approaches Subject in a slightly different manner. I really liked your explanation especially with the example sentences that you used.
I think you may have just made me had an epiphany on how Japanese sentence structure works!! I've struggled with forming sentences for so long, this may be a breakthrough for me. Thank you!
Recently I was talking to a IT guy about the sentence structure in Japanese. First, it reminded us of object oriented programming. You start with an object and add call to a method of that object. Like circle.draw(). And then we realized that it's kind of revers polish notation for expressions. Instead of 3 * (1 + 2) one would write in UPN: 1 2 + 3 * (or even 3 1 2 + *).
Re-ordering sentences is one of my bigger struggles when I have an opportunity to speak Japanese. This is a fantastic way to make that switch in my mind!
I love the videos. Concise and precise. It doesn’t take you long to explain concepts that have a big impact, and you explain them well and with humor. They are interesting to watch. There are other UA-camrs out there making Japanese videos but they often waste time. Your face is fun to watch! Keep making videos!
It's really similar like ASL sentence structure, I tried Japanese but had to go to ASL and now I'm back to Japanese. This video really cleared up a lot of my confusion.
Depending on your native language (or if you know several languages) this is either super easy or very difficult to understand 😅. My native language is Romanian and we can use a verb to ask, answer or say what other people are doing. No subject needed, the verb will tell you all you need to know👌. Thank you for the lesson! ✨
In my case, my native language is portuguese, and we use the subject just like in english, but most of the times we dont. For example "eu fui ao parque" (i went to the park). We mostly just say "fui ao parque" since the subject is "eu". This is also very used while answering questions like "onde foste?" "fui ao parque" (where did you go? I went to the park) I know this is very useless and that i dont really know how to teach but i really just wanted to do so... Idk
My native language is Turkish and it's easier to understand Japanese structure than English. If we go from the examples in the video: "Tanaka, bu aralar (these days) nasılsın (how are you)?" "(Ben (I) -we don't have to add into to sentence-) Bu kitabı(this book) sevmedim (didn't like)." "Gözlüklerini (your glasses) nereden (from where) aldın? (you bought)"
Thank you, I am From Brazil, but your explanation is so great, far from the standard one the most people don't understand. Finally I can adjust some explanation even for Brazilian Portuguese. Thank you, Sensei. Please, keep making more videos.
This literally made Japanese so much easier for me to grasp INSTANTLY. I’ve struggled a lot with how to organize subjects, adjectives, nouns and verbs and I never even stopped to consider that those aren’t even a thing in Japanese. I’ve starting being able to actually pick up a lot of what is being said and I have a much better idea of how to respond. You’re amazing, thank you! If you ever write a language course on Japanese, I’ll buy it!
This is so realistic! As long as you know a lot of vocabs and know how to conjugate. Thanks for this. So timely! Feel tired of studying and yoir videos pop out.
Very glad to discover your awesome UA-cam channel. I have been learning Japanese for quite some time. I like the way you explain, it is so particular that much easier to understand. どうもありがとう先生。
Wow, you are a great Teacher, please make more videos explaining japaneses sentences structures. This is the first video that actually helped me to understand more about the order in the structure.
Thank you so much. Even after 1 year of learning japanese, somehow, this helped a lot clarifying something that made my speech sound so non fluent from native speakers even for the simplest things. Sounds like a simple video about a simple thing but it actually makes a huge difference in day to day. Many many thanks
It's now clicking why I've had a difficult time following podcasts at high speed - because I'm expecting the sentence structure I was taught in textbooks. Thank you for clarifying this fundamental concept!
I think one of the hardest things for English/European language speakers is that the verb is the last word. If I were to translate このコーヒー（は）スターバックスでかった directly, it would "this coffee, [yesterday] Starbucks (I) bought." For many English speakers, something that's really strange, (not really difficult, just strange) is that the subject is often inferred based on the topic. I'm sure this happens in English too, but it's veeeeerry uncommon, and even as a native English speaker, if they do speak in an ambiguous way, I always have to ask for clarification. Edit: I just realized I forgot to include きのう (yesterday) in the example sentence and rather than fixing the example I just changed the translation.
ohh yes! this makes it take a lot longer for me to comprehend what a sentence means even if i understand what all the words mean + after learning pretty basic amounts of dutch which also uses the SOV structure :’) it surely is a process getting used to the SOV structure alongside getting better at reading kana and kanji lol
@@yoshilovesyoshi yes!! the similarites between dutch and german are actually closer to how italian and spanish are similar, but i believe they share a lot of words! and they're also both germanic languages so that probably adds in haha
I want to point out something providing a literal translation of one of the aforementioned Japanese phrases so that you get the concept of the so called topic better: このコーヒー（は）スターバックスでかった if literally translated it's like : this coffee, I bought it at Starbucks/as for this coffee... So the topic + comment is also a thing in English (but it's not as frequently used as it is in Japanese tho). The phrases like well: as for me, I bought a new car today or well Tom, ...he got fired.( So the as for me and Tom are topics and the rest (I bought a new car today & he got fired) are comments like something that adds information to the topics) that is to say topic ≠ grammatical subject. Many falsely assume that wa always marks the subject of the sentence but topic is not the same as subject it's a bit different.
I've learned more from this video about Japanese grammar than I have in all the decades I've been interested in trying to somehow learn the language. Sensei, arigatou-gozaimasu. :D
These videos are insanely helpful! 🙏🏻 These are exactly the useful bits of info to help sound natural that textbooks rarely mention or explain at all. Also answers a lot of questions I’ve gotten while studying. Thank you! 👍🏻
Not gonna lie this is super fascinating to me. It’s like I’m realizing for first time, as a native English speaker, how by nature it seems like we are self centered. Just from the way we communicate because Japanese is not the only language I’ve encountered that uses rule in sentences
i was recommended this video and i'm surprised at how helpful it was! while japanese isn't my language of focus at the moment, i wondered for a while why when i listen to native speak that i hardly hear any of the basic sentence structures i learned from a while. i'm still a beginner with the language, but i still was confused by this until i watched this video. everything makes more sense now, thank you for the helpful info!
These videos are inadvertantly helping me to fill in my incomplete knowledge of kana along the way 😅 I recognize all the words verbally! And then seeing them written down just reinforces the few times I've sat through a Kana chart and then failed to get past the obstruent letters.
Oh thank you so much. This is a roadblock I've been having in my Japanese studies, and I didn't know how to find the information I needed. This is very useful for me!
I’m about to start immersion learning for Japanese, but I want to get a baseline understanding of the structure of the language and some basic words over the next week or so first. This is one of the first videos I’m watching in this goal. Thank you!
The japanese way of sentences structure actually makes more sense, you mention the topic and then add comments is much more efficient for brain to grasp, bit of like top-down approach.. I need to learn that way of thinking. As japanese is my 4th language, and none of my other 3 languages have that structure, I can see myself struggling, but also, this is also very exciting for me. It's like, opening a new way of thinking. Thank you Kaname Sensei.
Incredibly, this is exactly the same structure as British and Australian sign languages! Knowing that makes Japanese syntax a lot more sensible now immediately, compared to when I tried learning it years ago 😅
Gr8 video! For me this is the crux of learning japanese, I'm at it for a year and I've learned many phrases and words, but the structure, the freaking structure is STILL the most difficult thing, and there are very few videos actually adressing it. Cheers from Brazil!
this makes so much sense! I LOVE the way Kaname puts it as [ topic -> COMMENT -> final verb] ! And, actually, thinking about it, English is pretty weird in how it emphasizes the speaker and not the topic in conversation. Weird...
This is very interesting. English can be structured in a similar way, with the object presented first followed by the verb acting on it. It's not a common way to speak, but it's used from time to time. Its use can be a regional feature as well; you'll hear it in New York City much more than, say, London. "This bread, I got for a bargain," or "Him, I don't really like." It's perfectly grammatical in English. So, the idea of Japanese starting with the topic to be discussed is actually not that foreign to English speakers.
Thank you! You're very good at explaining and made it an easy thing to understand and remember. I've only been learning Japanese for about a month, I've got a long way to go but I'm very excited and committed. Kaname san, Arigato gozaimasu!
You see, I had always thought it was TIME, topic, comment, much like the coffee example: 昨日 は スターバﾂクス で この コｰヒｰ を 買いました。 I guess in Japanese language classes, they teach the “formal” way of doing things rather than the way it is actually said. In fact, the time, topic, comment format is easier for me to get my head around because American Sign Language is built on the same structure and I am pretty proficient at that…Now I have to ignore what I was taught in Japanese language school and go with topic, comment…😅. Thanks for the helpful and informative video! Two thumbs up!!
It's not bad to learn the formal way first. Then you understand what is being left out. You know the は is there whether they say it or not. I watch anime and Hololive for real Japanese. People say anime is not real Japanese. True. But it's way more real than what teachers teach. It's pretty close.
Ganz herzlichen Dank! Theoretisch wusste ich das, aber noch einmal so viele schöne Beispiele zu hören und diese ausführliche Erklärung, das hilft mir, mein Wissen auch anzuwenden.
Ich finde spannend, dass man da Parallelen zum Deutschen ziehen kann. Das Beispiel am Anfang mit dem Kaffee vom Starbucks wäre auf deutsch auch eher "Diesen Kaffee hab ich gestern bei Starbucks gekauft." mit dem Kaffee am Satzanfang, anstatt von "Ich habe gestern bei Starbucks diesen Kaffee gekauft." Mit dem Kaffee am Satzanfang wird der Kaffee als Thema aufgegriffen; mit dem Kaffee hinten im Satz wird er als neue Information eingeführt, die zuvor kein Thema war.
Wow! Hi! I’m from Argentina. I found your channel a couple days ago, and I like very much the way you teach I’m your videos. I study Japanese for 8 years. I found your channel very interesting. Thank you. Even so, I need to practice way too much… Hahaha
Thank you for your videos, they are very helpfull. While I am a native English speaker (Australian) I have previously hearned AusLan (Australian Sign Language for the deaf) & that communication uses the same grammar rules as you explain here (TTC - Topic Time Comment grammar) so this makes a lot of sense for me.
All the examples with a kanji version (where applicable) and a translation:
このコーヒー、おいしいね。
This coffee is tasty.
このコーヒー、きのう スターバックスで かった。
このコーヒー、昨日スターバックスで買った。
I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday.
わたしはきのうスターバックスでこのコーヒーをかいました。
私は昨日スターバックスでこのコーヒーを買いました。
I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday.
このコーヒー、きのうスターバックスでかいました。
このコーヒー、昨日スターバックスで買いました。
I bought this coffee at the Starbucks yesterday.
たなかさん、さいきんちょうしどうですか？
田中さん、最近調子どうですか？
Tanaka-san, how are you doing these days?
たなかさん、ごはんたべました？
田中さん、ご飯食べました？
Tanaka-san, have you eaten yet?
たなかさん、かみのびましたね？
田中さん、髪伸びましたね？
Tanaka-san, you grew your hair long didn't you?
たなかさん、かおいろわるいですよ。
田中さん、顔色悪いですよ。
Tanaka-san, your face looks pale.
たなかさん、いまからごはんたべにいきませんか？
田中さん、今からご飯食べに行きませんか？
Tanaka-san, do you want to go eat together now?
このほんおもしろいですか？
この本、面白いですか？
Is this book interesting?
このほん、あんまりわたしは すきじゃありませんね。
この本、あんまり私は好きじゃありませんね。
I don't like this book much.
このほん、わたしのともだはとてもおもしろいといっていましたよ。
この本、私の友達はとても面白いと言っていましたよ。
My friend said that this book was very interesting.
でもわたしはあんまりおもしろいとおもいません。
でも私はあんまり面白いと思いません。
But I don't think it's interesting.
このラーメンおいしいですね。
This ramen is tasty isn't it?
このラーメン、ちょっとあじがうすいですね。
このラーメン、ちょっと味が薄いですね。
This ramen tastes a bit too light.
このラーメン、ちょっとからすぎです。
このラーメン、ちょっと辛すぎです。
This ramen is a bit too spicy.
そのめがね、どこでかいました？
その眼鏡、どこで買いました？
Where did you buy that glasses?
このめがね、きのうパルコでかいました。
この眼鏡、昨日パルコで買いました。
I bought this glasses at Parco.
このネール、どう？
How is my manicure?
そのネール、かわいいね。
Your manicure is cute.
このネール、きのうともだちがやってくれたんだ。
このネール、昨日友達がやってくれたんだ。
My friend made this manicure for me yesterday.
このワイン、フランスのなになにさんのとてもたかいワインなんですよ。
このワイン、フランスの〜〜産のとても高いワインなんですよ。
This wine is a very expensive wine from Something-something place in France.
このワイン、クソですね。
This wine is shit.
I remember when I first started learning Japanese, I thought having to read kanji would be useless since I had hiragana and katakana.
But now that I’ve learned some kanji, reading full hiragana sentences just feels so unnecessary and long. So thanks for the kanji version!
In English those times I ... I was not the subject. I was the prospective. I am.. Are you... & so on. English uses prospective in many cases to establish the setting for a discussion.
Ah yes, a language where I can say a literal curse word politely
Hi
Omg the Google English translation...sometimes all it does is romanize!!
'This wine is expensive from France's Nani Nani."
From France's whaty what? Hahha 😂
you are so good at teaching japanese, and i noticed you've done a really good job of addressing some of the biggest problems english speakers face when learning the language. please keep making videos!
For Shure! easiest sub I've given lately
Bro, I’ve been watching Japanese language learning videos for about 10 years on and off.
This is the first time I’ve heard someone mention dropping は and how to structure sentence so clearly 🙇🏻♀️
But can we not mention は in a formal conversation?
My friend, didn't you notice something was missing in any of the japanese programming you probably watched?
Same. Been picking it up again recently and these are really clear videos.
@@ananditotugarisman9122
Well, if you want your speech to match the occasion, it'd be best if you didn't drop anything from a sentence. Dropping the は is slang.
@@_P2M_ Well sooner or later you will understand the real meaning of は and adding は to every sentence is going to offend people one day.
this was so easy to understand 🥺🥺 thank you!!!
wait i did not expect that wine comment at the end 😂😂😂
Nihongo complicated desu 😅
I think so too desu
@@kanamenaito oogoedewara, it's such a little hard gengo
Yayakoshi innit
むずかしいですね
Gaman 😊
I would 100% recommend this channel to everyone who has started learning Japanese. Your videos are easily understandable and straightforward!
I'm glad i've watched this video, some books and apps gave me headaches.
I'm liking for the algorithm and subscribing for myself. I don't know how this man doesn't have more views. Absolute gem of a channel
I am commenting for the algorithm and make sure my comment has at least 4 words. SUCH AMAZING CONTENT, come watch learners of Japanese!
Your videos are so clear and straightforward! This is rapidly becoming my favourite channel for learning conversational Japanese.
In English you can also *sometimes* change word order to emphasize the topic. "This coffee I bought at starbucks today." "This book I don't like very much." It sounds a bit awkward and isn't nearly as common as it is in Japanese, but it's understandable and demonstrates basically what's going on in Japanese.
@xg223 you can if you need to emphasize something like possession, for example, say you were talking about someone else's book and you need to talk about your book you can say 'watashi no hon' to specify that it's your book. Hope this helps. Or if you mean like 'this book i bought today' you can say 'kyo ni katta no hon' or something to that effect.
This omission of marker is simple at the core, it's like the progression from
"Have you been well?" to
"You been well?" To
"Been well?"
When we're talking to someone in the most casual way we can get ride of several words and it means exactly the same.
If its more formal, people may tend to use は more
No, it doesn't "basically demonstrate what it going on in Japanese" because in Japanese that kind of word order makes sense *grammatically* and only implies correct language use, but if you did the same thing in English it would be done for some particular *emphasis*. Semantic emphasis and correct grammatical form and function are not remotely the same things.
@@Hooga89 people are so ignorant about how English isn't so much allowing for different grammar, as it has established practically dialects due to the number of people who speak both English and their other native language with each other. They've heard this sentence structure because it's used by many Asian people, but it's not accepted in English.
I should add that it's silly that these things are treated as bad English given most of the world speaks English as a second language.
This is the most direct and clear explanation I've heard on Japanese sentence pattern.
I struggled with Japanese sentence structure in college. My Japanese teacher refused to explain how sentence structure worked, she just expected us to know 😭 This made it so much easier, so I’m just going to self teach now.
It is probably because she doesn't know it herself
People always say how to do something but never explain why it’s that way to begin with which is my problem with most teachings of Japanese.
Going through this right now in my 102 class lol
Most " Teachers" are taught to teach only one method, I struggled alot in HS bcs they just didn't know. I've been learning japanese on my own for 1 year now and is best to do self-study. You know how your brain works and how to train it to learn. 😊
The "Topic-Comment structure" is indeed, ingenious.. I am hearing it for the first time and it makes so much more sense, Japanese language approaches Subject in a slightly different manner. I really liked your explanation especially with the example sentences that you used.
I think you may have just made me had an epiphany on how Japanese sentence structure works!! I've struggled with forming sentences for so long, this may be a breakthrough for me. Thank you!
Same here! This is so useful!,
Recently I was talking to a IT guy about the sentence structure in Japanese.
First, it reminded us of object oriented programming. You start with an object and add call to a method of that object. Like circle.draw().
And then we realized that it's kind of revers polish notation for expressions. Instead of 3 * (1 + 2) one would write in UPN: 1 2 + 3 * (or even 3 1 2 + *).
you and onomappu have become two of my most heard voices everyday lol. i love the content sm. its exactly what japanese learners need, thank u sm man
Re-ordering sentences is one of my bigger struggles when I have an opportunity to speak Japanese. This is a fantastic way to make that switch in my mind!
I love the videos. Concise and precise. It doesn’t take you long to explain concepts that have a big impact, and you explain them well and with humor. They are interesting to watch. There are other UA-camrs out there making Japanese videos but they often waste time. Your face is fun to watch! Keep making videos!
要さんは日本語のいい先生だから、ありがとうございます。
You don't know how much I appreciate the occasional spaces between the words. So much easier to read. Thank you.
It's really similar like ASL sentence structure, I tried Japanese but had to go to ASL and now I'm back to Japanese. This video really cleared up a lot of my confusion.
うん、助かりました😊
Depending on your native language (or if you know several languages) this is either super easy or very difficult to understand 😅. My native language is Romanian and we can use a verb to ask, answer or say what other people are doing. No subject needed, the verb will tell you all you need to know👌. Thank you for the lesson! ✨
In my case, my native language is portuguese, and we use the subject just like in english, but most of the times we dont. For example "eu fui ao parque" (i went to the park). We mostly just say "fui ao parque" since the subject is "eu". This is also very used while answering questions like "onde foste?" "fui ao parque" (where did you go? I went to the park)
I know this is very useless and that i dont really know how to teach but i really just wanted to do so... Idk
My native language is Turkish and it's easier to understand Japanese structure than English. If we go from the examples in the video: "Tanaka, bu aralar (these days) nasılsın (how are you)?"
"(Ben (I) -we don't have to add into to sentence-) Bu kitabı(this book) sevmedim (didn't like)."
"Gözlüklerini (your glasses) nereden (from where) aldın? (you bought)"
I love your channel, thank you so much
Thank you, I am From Brazil, but your explanation is so great, far from the standard one the most people don't understand. Finally I can adjust some explanation even for Brazilian Portuguese. Thank you, Sensei. Please, keep making more videos.
This literally made Japanese so much easier for me to grasp INSTANTLY. I’ve struggled a lot with how to organize subjects, adjectives, nouns and verbs and I never even stopped to consider that those aren’t even a thing in Japanese. I’ve starting being able to actually pick up a lot of what is being said and I have a much better idea of how to respond. You’re amazing, thank you! If you ever write a language course on Japanese, I’ll buy it!
This is so realistic! As long as you know a lot of vocabs and know how to conjugate.
Thanks for this.
So timely!
Feel tired of studying and yoir videos pop out.
Very glad to discover your awesome UA-cam channel. I have been learning Japanese for quite some time. I like the way you explain, it is so particular that much easier to understand. どうもありがとう先生。
my japanese went so far in past week so i could understand whachu said! thanks for practice :D
(thank you very much, teacher)
このチャネル本当にいいです
Wow, you are a great Teacher, please make more videos explaining japaneses sentences structures. This is the first video that actually helped me to understand more about the order in the structure.
Thank you so much. Even after 1 year of learning japanese, somehow, this helped a lot clarifying something that made my speech sound so non fluent from native speakers even for the simplest things.
Sounds like a simple video about a simple thing but it actually makes a huge difference in day to day.
Many many thanks
You're a too good teacher, 本当にありがとうございます
It's now clicking why I've had a difficult time following podcasts at high speed - because I'm expecting the sentence structure I was taught in textbooks. Thank you for clarifying this fundamental concept!
I think one of the hardest things for English/European language speakers is that the verb is the last word. If I were to translate このコーヒー（は）スターバックスでかった directly, it would "this coffee, [yesterday] Starbucks (I) bought." For many English speakers, something that's really strange, (not really difficult, just strange) is that the subject is often inferred based on the topic. I'm sure this happens in English too, but it's veeeeerry uncommon, and even as a native English speaker, if they do speak in an ambiguous way, I always have to ask for clarification.
Edit: I just realized I forgot to include きのう (yesterday) in the example sentence and rather than fixing the example I just changed the translation.
German language has SVO with V2 going to the end every time, so, it`s kinda easier for german speakers to adapt to that SOV structure
@@sandpaper6095 Ohhh, I didn't know that. That's interestingggg...
ohh yes! this makes it take a lot longer for me to comprehend what a sentence means even if i understand what all the words mean + after learning pretty basic amounts of dutch which also uses the SOV structure :’) it surely is a process getting used to the SOV structure alongside getting better at reading kana and kanji lol
@@margaret77777 WOAH DUTCH is in SOV too??? I thought Dutch was just like, accented German (please forgive me)
@@yoshilovesyoshi yes!! the similarites between dutch and german are actually closer to how italian and spanish are similar, but i believe they share a lot of words! and they're also both germanic languages so that probably adds in haha
I want to point out something providing a literal translation of one of the aforementioned Japanese phrases so that you get the concept of the so called topic better:
このコーヒー（は）スターバックスでかった if literally translated it's like : this coffee, I bought it at Starbucks/as for this coffee... So the topic + comment is also a thing in English (but it's not as frequently used as it is in Japanese tho). The phrases like well: as for me, I bought a new car today or well Tom, ...he got fired.( So the as for me and Tom are topics and the rest (I bought a new car today & he got fired) are comments like something that adds information to the topics) that is to say topic ≠ grammatical subject. Many falsely assume that wa always marks the subject of the sentence but topic is not the same as subject it's a bit different.
i have never understood japanese so well until i spotted you.
ありがと先生！
I've learned more from this video about Japanese grammar than I have in all the decades I've been interested in trying to somehow learn the language. Sensei, arigatou-gozaimasu. :D
My first language is Spanish so i find this kind of similar to our way to structure sentences. Very helpful thank you!
These videos are insanely helpful! 🙏🏻 These are exactly the useful bits of info to help sound natural that textbooks rarely mention or explain at all. Also answers a lot of questions I’ve gotten while studying. Thank you! 👍🏻
You need to make a book and create a series. You explanations are so simple and relatable
かなめさん、三年間ぐらいの時、私は日本語を勉強していますから、あなたのビデオはとても有用な楽しいです。ありがとございます。
3:12 "When you get used to this sentence structure you'll be able to speak more natural Japanese - Mention the topic and talk about what about it."
Not gonna lie this is super fascinating to me. It’s like I’m realizing for first time, as a native English speaker, how by nature it seems like we are self centered. Just from the way we communicate because Japanese is not the only language I’ve encountered that uses rule in sentences
one of the best Japanese Language structure explanation.
Subscribed! One of the best Japanese language teachers on the internet. Naito sensei arigatou!
As a French, that last bit makes me laugh too much 😂
I have watched many videos that teach Japanese using Chinese or Japanese language. I find this channel to be very good as it clears many of my doubts.
This is awesome Kaname! It helps a lot getting understanding of how sentences are structured :)
i was recommended this video and i'm surprised at how helpful it was! while japanese isn't my language of focus at the moment, i wondered for a while why when i listen to native speak that i hardly hear any of the basic sentence structures i learned from a while. i'm still a beginner with the language, but i still was confused by this until i watched this video. everything makes more sense now, thank you for the helpful info!
2 lakh subs おめでとうございます先生
Best explanation of japanese sentence structure and word order I've seen so far!
These videos are inadvertantly helping me to fill in my incomplete knowledge of kana along the way 😅 I recognize all the words verbally! And then seeing them written down just reinforces the few times I've sat through a Kana chart and then failed to get past the obstruent letters.
Very clear and natural way of explaining it! This is great, thank you.
Oh thank you so much. This is a roadblock I've been having in my Japanese studies, and I didn't know how to find the information I needed. This is very useful for me!
I’m about to start immersion learning for Japanese, but I want to get a baseline understanding of the structure of the language and some basic words over the next week or so first. This is one of the first videos I’m watching in this goal. Thank you!
Nice, I first thought that duolingo a bit mad about all these variations, now I understand it better, really appriciate your explanation
Very interesting. Stuff like this helps a lot with forming basic sentences in a more natural-sounding way. Thanks!
The japanese way of sentences structure actually makes more sense, you mention the topic and then add comments is much more efficient for brain to grasp, bit of like top-down approach.. I need to learn that way of thinking. As japanese is my 4th language, and none of my other 3 languages have that structure, I can see myself struggling, but also, this is also very exciting for me. It's like, opening a new way of thinking.
Thank you Kaname Sensei.
Incredibly, this is exactly the same structure as British and Australian sign languages! Knowing that makes Japanese syntax a lot more sensible now immediately, compared to when I tried learning it years ago 😅
Realizing how egoless that sounds. Amazing! and thank you. This is very informative and is easy to understand
Thank you so much for explaining this. It helps me understand the struggles some of my English learners have. ありがとう！
Gr8 video! For me this is the crux of learning japanese, I'm at it for a year and I've learned many phrases and words, but the structure, the freaking structure is STILL the most difficult thing, and there are very few videos actually adressing it. Cheers from Brazil!
I have seen several videos about using Japanese words and phrases, but never learned basic sentence structure. Thanks for this :)
Not only does he explain Japanese stuff really well, but he also just pulled out a copy of 1Q84?
I'm falling in love.
I like how straightforward you are. Thank you sensei, you are the best
This is the best I've heard it explained. Glad to find this channel
Your videos make japanese looks much easir, after each class I understand more of the language. Thank you.
this makes so much sense! I LOVE the way Kaname puts it as [ topic -> COMMENT -> final verb] !
And, actually, thinking about it, English is pretty weird in how it emphasizes the speaker and not the topic in conversation. Weird...
I really appreciate your lessons!
Thank you for everything!
this was an awesomesauce review for summarizing and perfecting what I’ve learnt. The example sentences are very useful.
This is very interesting.
English can be structured in a similar way, with the object presented first followed by the verb acting on it. It's not a common way to speak, but it's used from time to time. Its use can be a regional feature as well; you'll hear it in New York City much more than, say, London.
"This bread, I got for a bargain," or "Him, I don't really like."
It's perfectly grammatical in English. So, the idea of Japanese starting with the topic to be discussed is actually not that foreign to English speakers.
Yeah, it’s definitely not an alien concept to English speakers despite the fact that it’s less popular.
This wine is shit 😂 got me
Thanks for the video, I'm Brazilian and this is something I've always had too many doubts.
Greetings from Brazil ❤
Thank you! You're very good at explaining and made it an easy thing to understand and remember. I've only been learning Japanese for about a month, I've got a long way to go but I'm very excited and committed. Kaname san, Arigato gozaimasu!
interesting, i never thought of it as "topic - comment" sentence structure before. That's actually a really helpful way of thinking about it.
Such a good and simple way to explain it, top tier
Excellent explanation, ありがとうございます!
This is so true! Kono/sono + subject.
Very clear, straightforward and actually funny as well. I couldn't help but laugh at the end 😂
You see, I had always thought it was TIME, topic, comment, much like the coffee example: 昨日 は スターバﾂクス で この コｰヒｰ を 買いました。 I guess in Japanese language classes, they teach the “formal” way of doing things rather than the way it is actually said. In fact, the time, topic, comment format is easier for me to get my head around because American Sign Language is built on the same structure and I am pretty proficient at that…Now I have to ignore what I was taught in Japanese language school and go with topic, comment…😅. Thanks for the helpful and informative video! Two thumbs up!!
It's not bad to learn the formal way first. Then you understand what is being left out. You know the は is there whether they say it or not.
I watch anime and Hololive for real Japanese. People say anime is not real Japanese. True. But it's way more real than what teachers teach. It's pretty close.
I'm Japanese and English grammar is hard for me, thank you for learning our language!!
best videos i've seen on conversational Japanese
1:09 "you can say that" omg his face when he says that line! lol i'm rolling, it's like the best "but WHY would you" face lol
I hope kaname san can start a podcast soon 🙏 I can understand everything clearly. Thank you
2:49 " In Japanese, the basic sentence structure is you mention the topic and then add comment about it."
really helpful 🎉🎉🎉🎉
you're amazing, thank you for this lesson & thanks for the written examples in the comments! 😊 really appreciated
Ganz herzlichen Dank!
Theoretisch wusste ich das, aber noch einmal so viele schöne Beispiele zu hören und diese ausführliche Erklärung, das hilft mir, mein Wissen auch anzuwenden.
Ich finde spannend, dass man da Parallelen zum Deutschen ziehen kann. Das Beispiel am Anfang mit dem Kaffee vom Starbucks wäre auf deutsch auch eher "Diesen Kaffee hab ich gestern bei Starbucks gekauft." mit dem Kaffee am Satzanfang, anstatt von "Ich habe gestern bei Starbucks diesen Kaffee gekauft." Mit dem Kaffee am Satzanfang wird der Kaffee als Thema aufgegriffen; mit dem Kaffee hinten im Satz wird er als neue Information eingeführt, die zuvor kein Thema war.
日本人ですが、すっごく納得しました。
Wow! Hi! I’m from Argentina. I found your channel a couple days ago, and I like very much the way you teach I’m your videos. I study Japanese for 8 years. I found your channel very interesting. Thank you.
Even so, I need to practice way too much… Hahaha
thank you! for keeping it simple
Watched it when it was released didn't understand a thing but now I understand the essence of it pretty clearly.
このビデオ上手ね～
This was very detailed but easy to understand. Subbed!
Thank you for your videos, they are very helpfull. While I am a native English speaker (Australian) I have previously hearned AusLan (Australian Sign Language for the deaf) & that communication uses the same grammar rules as you explain here (TTC - Topic Time Comment grammar) so this makes a lot of sense for me.
Thank you. Your explanation is simple and clear, better than my Japanese teacher.
so on point! love your videos so much!
Amazing. Wanna learn more.
This was really helpful, thank you!
Your lessons are superb. Please do more.
This is so helpful! Thank you so much!
thank you this heelps alot mentally for me as im teaching myself