Here’s the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! DeWalt: amzn.to/3ttniC8 Craftsman: amzn.to/3vDKJvf Sun Joe: amzn.to/3KlsY8f Greenworks: amzn.to/35wFQt9 Black & Decker: amzn.to/3vBHtAA Ryobi (tool only): amzn.to/3tyxZDk WORX: amzn.to/36WWRgx Oregon: amzn.to/3CmOu9S EGO: amzn.to/3pBFc4o Milwaukee: amzn.to/35wFliX
Love the fact that you now added the cost of a battery when some tools came without one and some had one. Please keep doing that, since it's the only fair way to evaluate price\performance.
There's almost no way to compare it fairly. For example the "most expensive" milwaukee pole saw is really a geared power unit. You can put a pole saw, weed whip, and landscape edger tool on the same power unit. So it unfairly gets called the most expensive pole saw and the most expensive weed whip. But it would be middle of the road on price for the top performing unit, assuming you wanted both, and would be on the price of a Walmart off brand if you had a use for all 3.
@@tech99070 Yes. The case that you describe is impossible to show on a chart, because then we need to know ANY other add-on possible, on any system, and try and include only the ones that are equal on all different systems. But....a battery is ALWAYS connected to a tool, no matter which one you have. Actually, I prefer going AGAINST sticking with one brand just to have compatible batteries (and I think many DIYers are the same) because: 1. Many times, same-brand tools come with different voltage batteries. I don't need a $250 20V drill for tiny things around the house, I prefer a lightweight $100 one. 2. If I commit to one brand, that brand just monopolized my life. So let's say I have a DeWalt drill, and now I need an impact wrench. I go to the store and the Milwaukee (just for example) performs better according to PF, and cost 20% less with a battery because it's on sale. Should I still get the DeWalt without a battery just because I have a battery already? No. Because if I buy the Milwaukee, every tool has a battery, so now I can use them both on the same project. If I commit and buy 4 DeWalt batteries from the start, I'm now a DeWalt "prisoner", and if a new DeWalt tool needs a different voltage battery then I'm screwed. So just showing battery price whenever a bare tool competes against a kit, is important. If he would have bought the DeWalt entire kit you talked about on the video, and compare the price of everything to the saw-only of the others, you'd say it isn't fair (and you'll be right), but he only bought the saw and battery, which is exactly what the others had.
Man I literally was looking at these a week ago. Awesome that you are testing these. Keep doing what you do! Any time you are feeling down just remember how much you have helped everyone with videos just like these!
I am a complete beginner and this is the first no BS, straight, simple facts and lots of comparison included video I found and I am so grateful! You have gained yourself a subscriber sir!
Agreed! Great video for beginners, like me. 🙂 Quickly tells AND SHOWS the differences among pole saw brands. Clearly explains "pole saw" statistics. Totally awesome video!
You’ve single handedly helped me pass my college science classes with straight A’s. I’ve watched you since day one, and I can easily translate your work over to the steps of the scientific method.
They really didn't expect much from you if understanding the scientific method was all it took to get straight A's... that's like day one of a basic science course.
@@Agispsi Yeap.. like I mentioned, I've been watching him since day one. To be great at science you have to be great at the basics, and that's why I succeed. However, I'm sure an expert like yourself already knows that.
I'm consistently impressed with your ability to come up with simple, straightforward, and practical tests that also show well on video. It's certainly not an easy thing to do for the variety of tools you test. Well done!
I've already standardized on Milwaukee batteries, so bought the pole saw with extension & without battery from HD. Looking forward to using it once the snow has melted! Thanks again for yet another great comparative review.
Milwaukee is amazing. Not to mention the fact that you can swap the end for a weed whip. I bought it for the pole saw but have most of the hours on it trimming weeds. Milwaukee is steadily eliminating tiny, temperamental gas engines from my life. I'm hoping they come out with an M18 chainsaw with a 10-12" bar soon. They have it in M12 but it seems to be underpowered. And the 10" bar on the M18 performs great as the video shows, but I don't actually want the pole always, such as preparing branches for chipping.
@@tech99070 - does the Milwaukee offer additional pole extensions, to be able to cut higher branches without having to use a ladder? (All those pole saws seem to say to not use a ladder, but none of them have adequate reach to get higher branches.) EDIT - I wrote that before hearing the video say an extension is available.
I would love to see a “Best Solar Panel” video. Especially with so many people going off grid. Lots of companies aren’t meeting that wattage that they claim! Apparently the Harbor Freight 100W panel is one of the best believe it or not!
My experience with this type of saw, is that the angled blade is less prone to binding when you’re cutting a branch above your head. Also avoid the saws that don’t have automatic oilers. Just my 2 cents.
Right the no oiler is crap if you want a great pole saw buy one that attaches to your weed eater lowes sells the oregon brand for 100 bucks it has 12ft reach 8in chain i use mine to cut down small trees but when i need one bigger i break out the big boy with 20in bar lol
Fantastic! Less than a week ago I asked about pole saws, and this test did not disappoint! Thank you for the comparison and all the work you put into your content. Really appreciated!!
Just keep doing what you are doing! Every time I see a new vid from you, it's a fresh wave of relief that you haven't sold out to the highest-bidding sponsor. It's nice to see that there are people out there with integrity.
That's my second favourite part about this whole channel, we all know it's a quality review purely for the people. First favourite would have to be the awesome test rigs ;)
I wasn't planning on finding much for a pole saw research when I typed it into the search. Found this, and I now know exactly what I want. Much appreciated
I was literally just listing my Husky petrol chainsaw because the professionals turned up next door and carved their way through the extensive tree-line that separates our two properties with a load of battery chainsaws, including a polesaw. I was impressed by the lack of noise, and the obvious lack of weight. I had a chat and they (three) said they'd never go back to petrol saws now. I have a load of DeWalt batteries so all I was after was a review which said "The DeWalt doesn't stink" and I think you've just confirmed that. Thanks again for your channel which is easily the best public service for consumers.
I’m already on the Milwaukee platform, so about a year ago I needed a pole saw and picked up the quick connect set with pole saw, string trimmer, edger and hedge trimmer. I’ve been happy with their performance and the convenience of a battery.
Perfect timing! I've been looking at cordless pole saws. You thought of and tested factors that I hadn't thoyght of and the manufacturers don't address, like POLE SAG. Brilliant!
Thanks for a great review, as always! Bought the DeWalt two weeks ago, and I agree with your assessment. Well constructed, decent performer and good value for the money, particularly if you already have DeWalt batteries. Runtime was also adequate for my work, even with the 1.7 Ah power stack battery. Very happy with the saw, but nice to know how it stacks up against the competition
I would like to say "thank you" for all of the work that you do. It really helps in choosing tools. You are GREAT! You are a national treasure for people trying to get work done. -Stonecarver.
I might sound a bit biased, but I love my collection of Ryobi cordless tools. I am aware that they're not the best on the market, and they're really only suitable for home use, but that's exactly where I use them, and they have always performed well above my expectations. I have owned higher end cordless tools, and for my purposes, I honestly can't justify the extra cost involved.
Yep. Once you've got say a 4Ah and maybe a 2Ah battery, you can power a whole shed full of tools. Picked up the Ryobi pole saw for just over $100 and for the few times a year I use it gets the job done. I have DeWalt 20V for smaller tools that get used much harder and longer and they are worth it. But for occasional homeowner maintenance, I'd rather have all the tools I need at an affordable price, than pick a more expensive tool line and not be able afford those extra tools you could use but aren't essential.
For home use that's perfect. Because I'm a tradesmen, the extra cost of purchasing DeWalt or Milwaukee tools is well worth the investment as we use them all the time and those two brands are always at the very top of most of Project Farm's reviews.
Yeah , i have a bit of ryobi stuff too , i have the ryobi pole saw , and small chain saw , and the ryobi 18 inch mower , and the bigger size ryobi whipper snipper and the grass/leaf blower and use them around home to keep our jungle in some sort of order :) . They do seem very reliable in my use , i`d call them solid , as Todd has shown probably not class leading , but they seem pretty good , and the thing that keeps me buying them more than anything else is , they have such a full array of tools , and if you have a few batteries you can get a lot of work done with the vast array of different tools. The saws work ok for light general duties , but if you where seriously cutting lots of hard timber every day as with any of these electric devices , i think you would probably spring for a much more expensive pro petrol device. Another thing that has grown on me with the electric tools , you put the battery in , press the button and go , none of this pull start stuff , and if you have old shoulder injuries or you are just an old fart ( or both, thats me ), not having to yank a pull start is very very nice . I didnt like the electric mower at first because it just did not have the torque of a petrol mower in the long grass , but once you get used to maybe just raising the blades a tad and or maybe taking a bit less of a cut , its pretty good , and they are light to push around , and again , put the battery in and push button and go , and no having to worry about filling up fuel tanks . i dont think you would buy one for daily serious heavy duty work though unless it was mostly light stuff .
Very nice comparison of cordless pole saws. I’ve been trimming palm and fruit trees at my house for 30 years. So far, I’m just on my second corded one. This second one seems to last forever, so it’s hard to retire it for a new cordless one. You tested the most important specs: cutting speed, length, and leverage weight. Pole saws are the most tiring tools I use because I’m having to carefully balance the saw while lifting 20 lbs sometime over my head, while on a shaking ladder! (In 30 years my palm trees have really grown high.) The Oregon will be my choice even though I have Dewalt 20V tools. Thanks for your dedicated work and attention to detail.
@Norm110ful - Which corded one do you have? I like the idea of not having another tool that uses a battery. I can always run a short extension cord to a portable generator if I am too far from an outlet on my property.
I'd be really interested to see additional brands tested. Stihl, Husqvarna and Toro pole saws to name a few. Excellent and unbiased testing. Thank you for everything you do!
@@ProjectFarm i would also be interested is seeing additional pole saws tested. I would especially like to see how my cordless Stihl polesaw compares with these. Thanks for doing these videos- they are always interesting!
I have to say that all the videos that I’ve seen you make are the most informative. I love every single one and they have helped me in making decisions on the tools that I purchased. Thank you. Keep the video coming. I’ll be watching them.
Another observation: When cutting rectangular wood, the angel of the blade to the surface has a large effect on the cutting speed. This is why all chainsaw cutting competitions use round logs. For these chainsaw comparisons, I would use round fence posts for accuracy, or make sure the saw is always parallel to one surface.
Thanks for the information as always. I just bought my parents the Green Works 60v of this saw. They have the string trimmer and lawn mower in the 60v system and I am very impressed. Now that they have a smaller yard, moving to electric is a game changer to people who need a low maintenance approach to yard care.
I've had pretty good luck with my millwakee. one nice thing about the millwakee other than already having plenty of batteries is the extensions. You can add as many as you can handle and there only about 45 bucks.Thanks for another great comparison.
@@johngaughan9399 ya I got the trimmer head also and my wife loves it. I wish they'd make a little cultivator attachment for the power head. I think that would be handy in the garden for clean up.
Love all your reviews given the approach and obvious attempt to give every product the same equal opportunity with reliable results and easy to compare illustrations. Thanks so much!
Hi tod, excellent demonstration as always, usually I buy my tools after watching your videos on a product I need, your awesome ty for your time and dedication, Bob,
I just bought that same Greenworks one the other day and I’d definitely echo your conclusion. Not a bad price and it does good work if you just need something to prune or chop down small trees/bushes once a season or so.
I've been use the Dewalt pole saw and love it. You have to let it cut. Don't force it... I noticed a difference on what battery you use though. The big 60v battery works the best and is a good counter weight on the end.
I used my brothers dewault and didn’t like how much weight was on the end and how much sag the pole had. I went with the Milwaukee and it fixed both of those issue. Dewault does have a new version out with a power head that should be much bettrr
I've already seen several comments requesting a follow-up video including some of the other brands, and I have to agree, seeing how Makita, Stihl, Kobalt, Skil, and other pole saw brands stack-up against the competition would be great information to have. With the number of saws in this video, this one had to be very expensive to do. At least these were all cordless, so you weren't spending even more money on that high-priced gasoline. I would also love to see a video testing work boot laces. I am destroying mine all the time, and I know I wish I had a go-to set of solid, reliable boot laces, and I suspect I'm not alone in that. Given the weather in a lot of places this winter season, I feel like a lot of people could also do with an informative video on ice melters, and their performance in the ice and snow, and additionally if certain ice melter brands have an affect on the yard and greenery afterward. I've heard that some truckers also make up their own ice melter/traction mixtures by mixing ice melter with various other things like sawdust, clay granules (cheap kitty litter or oil spill absorber), sand, rock salt, and just about anything that could help a tire obtain more traction. Thank-you for all the work you put into these videos every week. A lot of my purchasing decisions have been altered based upon the test results I've seen in your videos.
@@ProjectFarm we appreciate it. Maybe Lowes, Home Depot and 3rd party episodes and then one final championship so we can silence everyone for good by showing over and over how great Milwaukee is.
Might be worth researching which brands are essentially the same as well. Many Kobalt, MasterForce, and greenworks 80v tools are identical except for different notches in the battery.
I was already in the DeWalt 20v line when I got mine. I like the fact that the DeWalt (and probably others too but I didn't notice) has a 40" optional mid pole extension. If someone is thinking of buying one of these, which ever brand, it WILL put a huge smile on your face the first time you use it.
I bought the Harbor Freight brand pole saw almost 2 years ago and I'm very happy with it. Cost was the decider for me as they had a sale on it, buy the unit (it was on sale maybe 30$off) and a battery and get the charger free(30$value). With a full charge it out lasts me limbing trees so that I can brush hog under them without lowering the ROPS or getting a face full of tree branch. It's still going strong. Only issue is that if I don't make sure the bar oil tank is empty when I'm done it will quickly leak out leaving a mess when put away. It came with the scrench and a small starter bottle of oil.
@@waxhawcreek1717 Atlas 40v pole saw, house brand like the Pittsburgh tools are a Harbor Freight house brand. Currently pole saw is on sale for $80 tool only. My local store has additional sale( managers special) of buying tool, battery, and charger at the same time and the charger is free.
Suggestion: Please test different silicone oil sprays. I am mostly interested in lubricity, their ability to withstand washout, corrosion resistance (and maybe ability to withstand high temperatures, since the ones I have at home are suited for use in engine rooms).
Yes I'm also interested in this, specifically I'm trying to find a good product to lubricate the telescoping booms on a knuckle boom crane. It needs to fully dry so as not to attract dust into the slides and also needs to adhere strong enough to not be wiped off from the extreme pressure of the sliding pads. The pads themselves are plastic and are supposed to be self lubricating but I see heavy scoring on the steel booms and it gets very sticky in certain places.. Thanks
The fact that a pole saw was one of your very first videos speaks a lot about how much youve made your channel grow. Youve found your own style little by little without losing the objective of informing with your videos or using clickbaits on them. Congratulations!
Informative testing. My 13-year old Corded Oregon/Harbor Freight unit still works great and it has been worked, and not just limbing. I have cut down trees up to 10" caliper and not just a few. I'm still using the supplied chain, though, it is near its last sharpening. It does now leak a little of oil, but still performs as new. I more than got my $50.00 investment back. Very happy customer.
I also am on the EGO platform and bought that saw last spring. It did a very good job until the end of the summer the blade has become loose. I'll try and see if I can make tightening adj to use it this year without the chain coming loose. I also paid a lot less than $350 last year, so I'm not sure if I got it on sale or without battery and charger. I thought I spent in the $180-250 range. I already had batteries from string trimmer and lawn mower (2.5a, 5a). I did spend about $340 for a full chainsaw, 18 in with 5a battery and charger. only issue other than loose chains is the self oiling seems to leak slowly while storing. I wrapped a towel around neck of pole saw and placed towel under chainsaw to fix it.
As a follow-up to my last comment. I was able to correct the issue with the blade being loose and leaking is still minimal. Still a huge upgrade over manual sawing.
I got the hedge trimmers from a home Depot in Rhode Island a couple years back. I believe home Depot still sells ego at least here in Connecticut. Going into 2 years and will probably have to get a third battery for this coming season. I bought a secondary when I picked up the unit so that I could swap batteries and continue to hedge trim, for work, and that had worked great but I'm only getting about 45 minutes to an hour per battery now but, that's 2 years with almost daily use through two seasons for both batteries. 190 bucks a battery isn't a big deal. Love those trimmers man super lightweight and totally powerful enough to get through boxwood and privet no problem. Light weight so that they're easily manageable with doing intricate boxwood detailing
@@drfuck yeah I have some of those trimmers too. Hella powerful and plows though some decent size branches. My hint is to use the next larger size batteries in any E-GO they fit in. The battery that comes with anything is usually too small and they overload the amp draw limit and it stops. Man that's annoying. Like I use the lawnmower battery in the chainsaw and that chainsaw is a beast. 18 inch bar one for anyone interested.
EGo is not anyone’s house brand, but they did cut a drug deal early on to get their foot in the market. All of my EGo products are 4-5 years old with no problems. The self-propelled mower is awesome. I’ll never go back to gas.
I have been watching your test videos for a few years and I am still impressed by the diversity of subjects and the quality of the tests conducted. Well done ! I would like to suggest a test that would be out of the ordinary: we see a lot of videos on UA-cam of an electric generator which consists of an electric motor coupled to a generator, with or without a flywheel depending on the configuration, and which supposedly provides free energy. I'm very curious to see your test results on this type of machine. Keep up the good job !
I bought Oregon Pole Saw with your recommendation two year ago, I did not go wrong. This is the best UA-cam channel for DIY people. I have your recommendations stored in "Project Farm" list on Amazon, in case I have to buy a product in future.
The Milwaukee is definitely a very good saw, I bought it along with two additional extensions so has plenty of reach but does get heavy at that distance but normally you are going more vertical than horizontal which does help some.
@@MrCaribe65 I haven't noticed any loss of torque probably because they use solid steel shafts. I have cut branches all the way up to 8 inch without any power loss issues, just have to be careful of where they fall! 😀
@robK58 Ordering my extra extension. Thanks buddy. Oh, if you're interested, you can install 12 inch Oregon bar Part# 124MLEA041, with a corresponding 12 inch chain. I needed to, to get four thick branches on my monster oak trees. Worked well, as long as I let the saw do the work.
You did this video a few years ago. Great job, even two years later it helped me decide what I wanted to get for fathers day. I'm buying myself the Milwaukee brand. It's on sell now with the extensions tool only. Perfect, I have the rest.
I love my DeWalt pole saw. It rips through large branches pretty quickly without any stall. As you suggested, I have a bunch of DeWalt 20v tools already so it just made sense. Thankfully it also performs quite well. 😎
@@davparksoh, I got mine at Home Depot and I haven’t had any issues with it at all. You definitely have to keep an eye on the bar chain oil level so you don’t run it out empty. Keep that at a correct level at all times and you will not have any issues. I don’t think it matters where you get it as long as it’s an actual DeWalt made unit. Handy having all the 20v tools using the same battery. The hedger is quite strong as well and the blower is pretty strong for a handheld unit. But the pole saw is a real performer. The thing is a little brute!! 👍🏻😎👍🏻
@@Far2hip Thanks - appreciate your response - I was wondering though when you said it doesn't matter where it's bought, as long as it's an actual Dewalt made unit - not sure I follow you there - are there fake Dewalt knockoffs being sold as genuine Dewalt power tools? I get tools from Amazon, CPO & Lowes/H.D - I'm assuming those places are legit, right?
@@davparksoh, yes, those places you mention are definitely legit. On Amazon I would simply buy from the Dewalt company direct store they have in there. Honestly, I couldn’t tell you if there are actual knockoffs of the Dewalt tools. But with the number of resellers I’ve seen getting slammed with selling refurbished units as new in the past, I would always feel better about spending a few more bucks to buy right from the company or the big box names you mentioned. Places like Walmart and Home Depot won’t risk their reputations selling refurbished units without letting folks know what they are. Those type of outlets have pretty solid satisfaction/return policies. Actually, I have bought refurbished tools directly from Dewalt when they had their local company store about 10 mins away from me. Still have a few of them today 5-10 years later. Their stuff is solid. The pole saw as I said is a little brute and does a great job. A little heavy out front if holding it at flatter angles, but not unmanageable at all. 😎
I look forward to these videos all week, great tests, very impressive! You should test machetes and bow saws, if you haven't already. Also the little 1x30 inch belt sanders, those are super useful for lots of things and the cheaper ones are widely regarded as being the same quality as the expensive ones.
Great information as always. Would love to see a second video with the 60v dewalt, makita, Bauer, atlas, masterforce, kobalt. Thanks for the hard work you put into these videos!
Normally he stays 20v, but with this one being all over I was shocked to not see the dewalt 60v, but a follow up with the rest would be cool. Still want to see the dewalt 60v trimmer verses the rest.
No other YT product testing channel can compare to yours in terms of the shear volume of information packed into the minimum amount of watching time. Keep up the great work!
Just as a suggestion... Even though the worx can be used as a chainsaw you should have tested it with the pole, otherwise it's a chainsaw against a polesaw
@@lesleyboeder1798 Very likely the speed tests, since you can't apply anything like the amount of downward pressure with a pole saw that you can with a chainsaw held at the grips like that. It would have been significantly slower tested as a polesaw.
I appreciate the effort put into all of these videos. Just the quick construction he had to do for the pole extension test must have been a bit... interesting, at least in thought process. What I appreciate is that while Ryobi is almost never a leader, it also doesn't tend to be a loser. In general, it shows that it's a solid performer - just not a "Use it 12 hours a day, every day" brand. For me? I don't care if it takes 16 seconds to cut through something vs 7 seconds. I have the extra 9 seconds to spare, for my amount of use. In a case like this, I'd be trimming between one and twenty trees - in a year. Not a day. So, I have the time to do the cleanup. In fact, I used my portable "brushless reciprocating saw" with a 9" pruning blade to remove the bulk of the limbs from a fallen oak tree that was over 50 feet tall, and probably 20 years old. I made a mound of brush eight feet deep, five feet tall, and 25 feet long, and a number of them were cut at the point where they were 3-4" thick. Could I have done it faster with a "professional" brand? (or even a chainsaw) Sure - but my family couldn't drag it out any faster than I was cutting it with the Ryobi. In general, I have no hesitation in suggesting the 'middle of the range' products that PF lists, simply because they do the job they're designed for, without breaking the bank, for non-professionals. In fact - suggestion. Do a couple of "professional tool" showdowns. Make it very clear that it is a showdown for _expensive_, name brand professional tools. Then do the same and make it clear that you're doing commodity, home use tools. Maybe that'll quiet down the constant litany of "You need to spend lots of money on these tools for heavy usage, for your once a month jobs!" I'd call Ryobi a 'pro-sumer' brand. I use them for business, but my business is not construction. I use them when I have to do construction type work for my normal job.
I have the Ryobi but will be returning it. My intention is not to invalidate your points but I do find the heavy use of plastic concerning. In fact, I am returning mine because the back of the housing broke when I put it down with a little force. I decided to go with something that had metal in the vital areas the Ryobi was plastic. Just my 2 cents.
@@marios3163 - Unfortunately, anything portable enough to be really useful is plastic cased, no matter what the brand. Even a lot of gas powered units are plastic casings. If you're regularly dropping tools, I'd suggest looking for some older corded tools, and change out the power cords for grounded ones. (like the 1930-50's aluminum cased ones)
@@tailgatecarpenter26 - Comes from the same company that makes really "high end" stuff. The main reason a lot of people avoid it is the battery form factor. IT _is_ very bulky. (TTI? )
Great work, Mate. I have the Ryobi pole saw. It's a bit heavy, up front, but it helps with holding decent downward pressure, while cutting. It goes through large branches with no issues. As with the rest of us, the choice of saw was linked to the previous choice of battery commitment.
None of these tests actually show the saw in actual use of cutting a branch high up, and two things were ignored. The angled head allows you to cut the top of the branch which will allow it to fall cleanly from the tree. A straight head will only cut the side of the branch and can sometimes bind the saw into the tree. Another thing to consider is with the weight of the motor on the end of the pole it requires you less Force pulling down on the saw to actually cut the branch which is a benefit.
So you didn't learn anything from this video? The point is that it showed us how the products performed in a repeatable, scaleable experiment. It shows the comparative comparability between the products, not individual performance when used with human assistance and technique.
@@ProjectFarm Thanks for the reply and also for the video. If you still have these saws, possibly you can do a test on some lumber to simulate a branch at 6 ft, 10 ft, and 14 ft to get an idea of how these saws work in the position they're intended to be used at. I already have large DeWalt batteries, and a Remington pole saw with a straight blade which tends to hang up in the branches, so for me it would be the DeWalt with the angled head. As a homeowner with one acre, the little bit of slower cutting time is okay with me.
@@Ethan-mv2un Sorry, did I say I didn't learn anything? A pole saw is not meant to be used sideways, cutting parallel to the ground, unless you have a boom lift. This is something for the ordinary homeowner that will be cutting a branch above their head. The angle of the head, and the weight of the saw are very important factors, that happened to have been overlooked. I do not fault Project Farm for this, but would like to see the saws used in the actual manner that they are intended to be used and show how they work that way. On my 14' 110v pole saw the head comes off and I can use it as a chainsaw. The extra several pounds on the end of the pole allows me to just lean it up against the branch instead of adding extra Force and that is a huge plus. These saws also have different chains on them. Adding a premium Oregon equivalent chain to each one of them would also change the playing field as I have found out with ALL my saws. Some of these saws will probably do better irregardless of their slow RPM or low torque if they had a better chain. If each saw in this video had the exact same chain, the results may be quite totally different.
I got that Craftsman a few months ago, im very happy with it so far. Only downsides are the weight/bending at full length and having to manually oil the chain while also having to retighten the extensions now and then as they can loosen while the saw is being used.
Fantastic data comparison. Your tests are very applicable. My only questions are: 1) does one brand use oil faster that others? 2) Do all the units with oilers leak when not in use?
Once again PF delivers the most helpful, thorough, straightforward, and entertaining video. Great for any level of DIY guy looking into tools. I'm a veteran gigging musician of 20+years pre-covid now borderline homeless and forced into humiliating beginner handyman. I'm desperately throwing my name out there for all kinds of stuff wherever I go so Im constantly learning new skills as I grind out (no pun intended lol) all the headaches and keep my esteem just above the water. Different jobs require different tools obviously so I have to basically buy a tool whenever a job comes up and I do the research scramble. Project Farms videos have been my go-to for everything and is a real life-saver... Literally. Watching every video (all the way through is a must!) has changed my decisions like a game of ping pong though every single test run. This particular video changed my mind from settling for the budget Sun Joe and saved me the disappointment only because I have the battery Black n Decker (whew thanks), to the Greenworks or Worx saws. I've never seen Oregon tools in action before, I was super impressed! That would be my top choice given the $$$ by a landslide. The Ford and Chevy of the bunch (DeWalt and Milwaukee) tests were beyond expectation. And E-go's ego took a hit which I loved also because I thought that would come out in top 2 but didn't...watch all the way through guys n gals! Thanks again Jeff and keep them coming!
I have owned the DeWalt pole saw for two years and have not had any problems with it. It performs flawlessly. I think it is moderately priced which gives it the edge over some of the better performers.
Thanks for including the Worx. I Love all the Worx tools I have and was actually considering this saw as a Purchase. I think if I take the leap I will be getting the Oregon.
Particularly impressed with the testing on balance/sag here - that is such a huge factor with this type of saw. Power is useless, if you can't apply it to the cutting surface. Black & Decker... once an affordable brand that worked sufficiently, now an embarrassment to themselves- I felt like they were just taking up a place in this race, that could have been filled with something more deserving. The Oregon & Milwaukee were 'very impressive' !!
@@jman0870 agree, though i wouldn’t totally write off their spanner sets, perhaps. I still find B&D to be even worse, but looking back, Stanley have fallen from grace from a greater height. I will just stick to Milwaukee & live life much poorer, but without regret 👍🏻
I'd like to see a comparison on 1 man post hole auger. I just bought a 40v Ryobi and I think it did great. I like the fact that it has a reverse for when it gets stuck.
I just bought the DeWalt yesterday, August 9th 2023. Thank you for the recommendation, I looked at the Greenworks, but their price had gone up. This was at Tractor Supply for $229 with battery and charger, their extended warranty was the deciding factor, it covers accidents. Worked great for removing a tree that had landed on my roof.
Great video. I already have a pretty good sized Ryobi collection, but it's always nice to see what's actually the best. I'd love to see a little more of the lawn care type of tools. I enjoy these. Maybe an electric rototiller, hedge trimmer, weed whip, etc. As always, great job! I really enjoy and appreciate what you do!
Another shocking result with Milwaukee on top. I agree the Oregon is pretty nice too. I have a Sun Joe corded pole saw that cost $70 and works great (with an automatic oiler). Anything without an automatic oiler is pretty terrible.
@6:50 Surprised that the Worx brand was used as a Hand held saw, verses on the end of the Pole. You can apply much more force using it that way, than could be applied on the end of a long pole. Also, again @11:45 and also @13:50, the Worx is used as a hand held saw, and not on the end of the pole. ? was there an issue with the pole?
Yeah I was curious how well it would handle on the pole. A combination pole/handheld saw seems nice from a budget perspective I guess, but all that extra weight has got to be awkward at full length, right?
I am not sure how easy it would be to do, but I'd be really interested to see several battery operated lawn mowers tested. I have been looking into them and am struggling to make the leap from gas. I appreciate your videos.
@@mattchilders3123 that's not normal, u got 6 months warranty on the battery (at least here in Germany) Battery don't just dies cause of no reasons... I got all of my tools on Metabo batteries, but you can use almost every battery on every tool with an adapter 😅 never had problems...
I've owned the Oregon saw in this video for years now. At the time, there really wasn't much for decent pole says (WTH Makita) so I did tons and tons of research. I really like the pole and design of the Oregon and it's worked excellent for me over the years. I have the 6 ah battery which typically runs for about 4 hrs of trimming. That's about all I have in me for holding a pole saw up before I need a long break anyways so it's worked out well. I did one modification and that was glueing the red retainer for the main pole to the body with silicon as it kept sliding off. Haven't had an issue since. I've since bought their chain say and leaf blower and both of those have been excellent as well.
Years ago I purchased a Stihl body harness for my pole saw work. I used it a few times. You might consider buying a harness to help distribute the weight of the saw over your shoulders and back. My harness is easy to use and easy to adjust for the different reach required in cutting tree branches.
I trust your recommendations and it’s fun to see how much you like figuring out methods to test. Would you consider testing random orbit and palm sanders (corded and cordless) and wood stain brands?
You shouldn't trust him in this case. Read my comment in the main section. He intentionally avoided the two best brands and most used by arborists in the world: Husqvarna and STIHL. I strongly suggest that you do some research on your own and talk to the REAL expert using those machines on the field every day.
@@DiabloOutdoors You are free to do the research, buy the equipment, test the equipment, make your own video and run your own channel if you don’t like the way PF performs his tests. It’s always easier to criticize instead of doing your own work.
@@zakkaryzoah1386 Sir, the two most known brands, used by arborists all over the world, are not listed and tested: Husqvarna and STIHL. Second, who do you think you are to believe that you're the only one allowed to comment on UA-cam? END OF DISCUSSION.
@@DiabloOutdoors He means he purchased the saws with his own money. Not that he bought every cordless pole saw manufactured on earth. Use your brain...or don't. Please keep on commenting too. Best comedian here haha
Thanks for the videos! As a newer homeowner you've helped me pick out a lot of my tools. Even if I don't get the ones you tested, I at least get a better idea of what to look for. One thing I'd really like to see tested and compared are trigger clamps. There's a huge disparity in price between the cheap harbor freight/walmart/amazon ones and the Dewalt/Irwin/bessey clamps. I've always been told to just spring for the dewalts, but I'm not so sure. I'd really like to see them compared and they're something every DIYer needs.
I really could have used one of these when my grandparents' tree came down last summer! Thanks for the video! If possible, could you look into rotary tools like the Dremel?
Have the Milwaukee and it’s one of the few tools that I’m not impressed with. It’s too short without the extension and with the extension it makes the tool off balanced and difficult to maneuver. It’s front heavy so when completing a cut I struggle to keep the saw from hitting the ground. On top of that, the extension is difficult to attach failing to lock into its correct position. I have many Milwaukee tools that I absolutely love, but this one is a dud.
The more weight you put on the battery end the easier it will be to control. Use at least the 8Ah. I found using any strap with it gave less control. Anticipate when the cut will be nearly complete, and let off the trigger. Let the momentum of the chain complete the last bit of cutting.
Much appreciated video, but your testing confirms my own assessment that this type of tool isn't nearly as useful as advertised, for pruning fruit trees you're much better off using a manual pole-saw. Manual saws are much lighter and easier to control than any of these and good quality blades require a lot less force than you may think.
I agree I have both and my manual works so much easier plus I added a 18ft piece of pvc to make it really reach the top branches to thin out my 50 year old oaks while standing on a 12ft ladder
Anything thicker than 2” and the powered saw wins hands down for convenience. The cut isn’t quite as nice, but it’s effortless in comparison to the manual saw. I have a nice Fiskars pole saw that is much more effort when trying to hack off a large high overhead limb. We’re talking seconds vs a minute or more of sawing. And if a blade binds, that’s even more cursing. So glad I got the Dewalt powered pole saw.
@@bt5252 If it takes you a minute to get through a 2" thick branch your saw blade needs sharpening. I'm not a fan of Fiskars tools because of the unreasonably high prices, I'm using a Polish made saw blade that costs like 15$ and gets me through an entire season without requiring any maintenance. When it's time to maintain your saw, after sharpening give it a nice polish and a thin coat of WD40, it prevents both rusting and binding. Besides the handling problems, most electric saws (both chain and reciprocating types) are too rough for fruit trees, ripping off the bark and leaving an uneven stump that heals slower and is more exposed to fungi and parasites.
@@ProjectFarm Pittsburgh, Dewalt, ICON, Kobalt, Hart, Snap-Off, Husky, Hyper Tough, maybe even Amazon Basics if they have one... pretty much any brand that might be readily available to the common consumer.
@@ProjectFarm Lowe's sells Craftsman 120-tooth ratchets. I don't know if they are available as part of a set or not. I bought the 3/8 drive for the shorter swing, but would be curious to know if it suffers durability as a result.
As someone invested in Craftsman, Milwaukee, and Makita, I was really hoping to see a Makita one in this comparison. Either way, love these videos, and the honest comparison between them. Always unbiased in the testing, and a quick summary at the end. I'll have to decide which way I want to go. Cost effective (Craftsman) or performance (Milwaukee) when that time comes for me to invest. Would love to get away from the pole saw attachment for my gas trimmer head, since it's only used every couple years in general. Todd, do you have an online page where these results can be easily accessed in a spreadsheet format?
@@briankohlenberg 196101 attachment that fits the multitool 36v base unit. I use it with a 1 metre extension and can reach most things! DUX60Z for the multitool.
@@ProjectFarm I'm guessing that with the weight of the Worx, it would've needed a special jig to catch the power head so it wouldn't hit the ground after the chain finishes cutting through while on the end of its pole. I think you made the point about the weight of that Worx. The 2.5 lb test showed just how you had to carefully hover your left had above the handle to catch the saw when the cut was through. I also noticed you had your chaps on when you used that Worx. Hope you and your family stay safe and well.
@@thomasfogerty3515 Yes the last chainsaw I bought that i could afford was from China, with parts from all over the world. LOL except the United states !
@@thomasfogerty3515nope. Low wages in other countries, corporate profits, and a desire for cheap products pushed manufacturing overseas. On the high end of what I could find, factory workers only make about $13,000 and they work more hours. So unions are to blame that factory workers aren't working for minimum wage from 1997?
This guy is amazingly thorough as well as innovative in his testing. If he could add becoming a proficient "data miner" to the mix and present a relaxed "executive summary" to his audience more so than the "machine gun" presentation I think he would move up the the next level. Not dissing, I truly think he is the best. Just popping my penny's worth into the suggestion box. Your hard work is truly appreciated!
Very well laid out comparison !! Thank You ! I have the RYOBI that I bought NEW on Ebay for $75 !! Love it ! I've owned it for 5 years now and it works flawlessly. I was using it yesterday !
Thanks so much for your review. I ended up getting the DeWalt on sale from Ace, as already had their 4 Ah battery for my impact driver. I was pretty impressed with how it cruised through trimming our maple tree branches. For sure it's easier to manage when only using one of the extension poles, but also very nice that it reaches to about 15 feet with both. Was also surprised was pretty easy on the battery. I don't know exactly how long we used it, but we trimmed a number of branches off the tree, and then cut those up further to take to the road, and it only went down 1 dot from a full charge.
I hope your purchase last you a long time as most people are unaware that Black and Decker now owns DeWalt. When a cheap Chinese company purchases a quality company like DeWalt, I become Leary of them.
Hedgeapple -- if I'm not mistaken, it's the second hardest North American wood. We use it for fence posts. Lasts forever. Bends fence staples. That's a real test, there!
I love my Kobalt 80 volt 5 ah 10" chain pole saw. It works great on my south east Louisianna farm that a Hurricane went through and trashed all woods on my 20 acre property. Today I'll be cutting a 6 in limb of a tree out front.
I missed the release of this video for some reason. I decided to buy one and immediately went to your channel to see if a review was done. Once again, thank you sir for another great video.
Lucked out getting the Milwaukee pole saw and edger attachments for $19 each from Home Depot about a month ago. Putting the saw to work this weekend. Still want the m18 chainsaw. Waiting on a good deal. Thanks for the videos, most informative and scientific on UA-cam
I love this channel. What is challenging is buying separate brands, as each one has unique performance(s). If you want to go with one brand, so that you can use the same battery for multiple tools, which one collectively is the best brand to buy. So for example, do you buy ALL Milwaukee tools or ALL DeWalt tools, or ALL Ryobi tools. If you buy into one battery interchangeable system you save money in the long run.
Here’s the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you!
DeWalt: amzn.to/3ttniC8
Craftsman: amzn.to/3vDKJvf
Sun Joe: amzn.to/3KlsY8f
Greenworks: amzn.to/35wFQt9
Black & Decker: amzn.to/3vBHtAA
Ryobi (tool only): amzn.to/3tyxZDk
WORX: amzn.to/36WWRgx
Oregon: amzn.to/3CmOu9S
EGO: amzn.to/3pBFc4o
Milwaukee: amzn.to/35wFliX
Love the fact that you now added the cost of a battery when some tools came without one and some had one. Please keep doing that, since it's the only fair way to evaluate price\performance.
There's almost no way to compare it fairly. For example the "most expensive" milwaukee pole saw is really a geared power unit. You can put a pole saw, weed whip, and landscape edger tool on the same power unit. So it unfairly gets called the most expensive pole saw and the most expensive weed whip. But it would be middle of the road on price for the top performing unit, assuming you wanted both, and would be on the price of a Walmart off brand if you had a use for all 3.
@@tech99070
Yes. The case that you describe is impossible to show on a chart, because then we need to know ANY other add-on possible, on any system, and try and include only the ones that are equal on all different systems.
But....a battery is ALWAYS connected to a tool, no matter which one you have.
Actually, I prefer going AGAINST sticking with one brand just to have compatible batteries (and I think many DIYers are the same) because:
1. Many times, same-brand tools come with different voltage batteries. I don't need a $250 20V drill for tiny things around the house, I prefer a lightweight $100 one.
2. If I commit to one brand, that brand just monopolized my life. So let's say I have a DeWalt drill, and now I need an impact wrench. I go to the store and the Milwaukee (just for example) performs better according to PF, and cost 20% less with a battery because it's on sale. Should I still get the DeWalt without a battery just because I have a battery already? No. Because if I buy the Milwaukee, every tool has a battery, so now I can use them both on the same project. If I commit and buy 4 DeWalt batteries from the start, I'm now a DeWalt "prisoner", and if a new DeWalt tool needs a different voltage battery then I'm screwed.
So just showing battery price whenever a bare tool competes against a kit, is important. If he would have bought the DeWalt entire kit you talked about on the video, and compare the price of everything to the saw-only of the others, you'd say it isn't fair (and you'll be right), but he only bought the saw and battery, which is exactly what the others had.
Imagine buying a tool that require battery but the battery isn't included 🤣
It like you buy a cow for milk but it produces nafting
I agree but normally I'll stick with the same manufacturing company as I'll be able to use the same battery with most/all the products.
@@hasuo9749 That's why most big tools come with the option of a kit or tool only.
Man I literally was looking at these a week ago. Awesome that you are testing these. Keep doing what you do! Any time you are feeling down just remember how much you have helped everyone with videos just like these!
Perfect timing! Thank you!
@@ProjectFarm You rock keep it up!! Enjoy all the money you make from these videos too you deserve it!
@@orangehatmusic225 I think he spends most of it on new tools to review 😂
@@ryanjay6241 that might be true
@@ProjectFarm hold on! Didn't you once have a weed whaka with a circular saw blade on it? You should have used that as a control!!
How many of us appreciate Project Farm's hard work while standing in an isle at the store? 😆
Well done Project Farm!
Thanks!
I've been there more than once! Anytime I go to Home Depot or Lowes, I always think: "I wonder if Project Farm has a video about this?"
I appreciate the shit out of that mfkr
Yes, by far Project Farm is the best comparison channel. Thank you for all you do.
Just waiting for the day to hear his voice on someone else's phone in the tool aisle.
I am a complete beginner and this is the first no BS, straight, simple facts and lots of comparison included video I found and I am so grateful! You have gained yourself a subscriber sir!
Thanks for watching and subscribing.
Agreed! Great video for beginners, like me. 🙂 Quickly tells AND SHOWS the differences among pole saw brands. Clearly explains "pole saw" statistics. Totally awesome video!
You’ve single handedly helped me pass my college science classes with straight A’s. I’ve watched you since day one, and I can easily translate your work over to the steps of the scientific method.
Congratulations!
@@ProjectFarm this is the best compliment I've read. If I were Todd, I might shed a tear. Mission Accomplished.
They really didn't expect much from you if understanding the scientific method was all it took to get straight A's... that's like day one of a basic science course.
@@Agispsi Yeap.. like I mentioned, I've been watching him since day one. To be great at science you have to be great at the basics, and that's why I succeed. However, I'm sure an expert like yourself already knows that.
I'm consistently impressed with your ability to come up with simple, straightforward, and practical tests that also show well on video. It's certainly not an easy thing to do for the variety of tools you test. Well done!
Thank you very much!
I've already standardized on Milwaukee batteries, so bought the pole saw with extension & without battery from HD. Looking forward to using it once the snow has melted!
Thanks again for yet another great comparative review.
Great choice! It performs very well.
I have it mounted vertical on storage in the garage be careful it likes to leak a little chain oil. Not terrible but some
Milwaukee is amazing. Not to mention the fact that you can swap the end for a weed whip. I bought it for the pole saw but have most of the hours on it trimming weeds. Milwaukee is steadily eliminating tiny, temperamental gas engines from my life. I'm hoping they come out with an M18 chainsaw with a 10-12" bar soon. They have it in M12 but it seems to be underpowered. And the 10" bar on the M18 performs great as the video shows, but I don't actually want the pole always, such as preparing branches for chipping.
@@tech99070 - does the Milwaukee offer additional pole extensions, to be able to cut higher branches without having to use a ladder? (All those pole saws seem to say to not use a ladder, but none of them have adequate reach to get higher branches.)
EDIT - I wrote that before hearing the video say an extension is available.
@@stevebabiak6997 Yes, you can buy extender bars.
I would love to see a “Best Solar Panel” video. Especially with so many people going off grid. Lots of companies aren’t meeting that wattage that they claim! Apparently the Harbor Freight 100W panel is one of the best believe it or not!
.6.5.55
.6.5.55.
6 6 ...5
.6 6.5
6.555.
My experience with this type of saw, is that the angled blade is less prone to binding when you’re cutting a branch above your head. Also avoid the saws that don’t have automatic oilers. Just my 2 cents.
Thanks for the feedback.
Automatic oilers are messy and add complexity, for basic small jobs, less is more, if I want to make a mess i grab a real chainsaw 😁
Right the no oiler is crap if you want a great pole saw buy one that attaches to your weed eater lowes sells the oregon brand for 100 bucks it has 12ft reach 8in chain i use mine to cut down small trees but when i need one bigger i break out the big boy with 20in bar lol
@@tfaubus, does yours come with a 10 foot bar ?? Asking for a friend ...lol
@@arthilliker3721 lol, yeah, no
Fantastic! Less than a week ago I asked about pole saws, and this test did not disappoint! Thank you for the comparison and all the work you put into your content. Really appreciated!!
Just keep doing what you are doing! Every time I see a new vid from you, it's a fresh wave of relief that you haven't sold out to the highest-bidding sponsor. It's nice to see that there are people out there with integrity.
Thanks!
That's my second favourite part about this whole channel, we all know it's a quality review purely for the people.
First favourite would have to be the awesome test rigs ;)
I wasn't planning on finding much for a pole saw research when I typed it into the search. Found this, and I now know exactly what I want. Much appreciated
Thanks!
I was literally just listing my Husky petrol chainsaw because the professionals turned up next door and carved their way through the extensive tree-line that separates our two properties with a load of battery chainsaws, including a polesaw. I was impressed by the lack of noise, and the obvious lack of weight. I had a chat and they (three) said they'd never go back to petrol saws now.
I have a load of DeWalt batteries so all I was after was a review which said "The DeWalt doesn't stink" and I think you've just confirmed that. Thanks again for your channel which is easily the best public service for consumers.
Well at least you weren't figuratively listing it. I would have been confused had you not used "literally".
@@Joe_Blow215 Wow, another warrior
You are welcome!
what brand of saw were they using?
I’m already on the Milwaukee platform, so about a year ago I needed a pole saw and picked up the quick connect set with pole saw, string trimmer, edger and hedge trimmer. I’ve been happy with their performance and the convenience of a battery.
Nice! Thanks for sharing.
Mine came with the extension
Literally driving to Home Depot to buy a pole saw. Perfect timing for this to come out!
Excellent!
Watching this video again a year later. We can't thank you enough for your time and effort in these tests. Amazing stuff!
Thanks so much!
Perfect timing! I've been looking at cordless pole saws. You thought of and tested factors that I hadn't thoyght of and the manufacturers don't address, like POLE SAG. Brilliant!
Great to hear! Thanks!
Thanks for a great review, as always! Bought the DeWalt two weeks ago, and I agree with your assessment. Well constructed, decent performer and good value for the money, particularly if you already have DeWalt batteries. Runtime was also adequate for my work, even with the 1.7 Ah power stack battery. Very happy with the saw, but nice to know how it stacks up against the competition
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I would like to say "thank you" for all of the work that you do. It really helps in choosing tools. You are GREAT! You are a national treasure for people trying to get work done. -Stonecarver.
Thanks and you are welcome!
INTERNATIONAL MAN
Very technical, accurate analysis of pole chainsaws of various brands. You made it easy to choose the right polesaw. Thanks a lot.
I might sound a bit biased, but I love my collection of Ryobi cordless tools. I am aware that they're not the best on the market, and they're really only suitable for home use, but that's exactly where I use them, and they have always performed well above my expectations. I have owned higher end cordless tools, and for my purposes, I honestly can't justify the extra cost involved.
Yep. Once you've got say a 4Ah and maybe a 2Ah battery, you can power a whole shed full of tools. Picked up the Ryobi pole saw for just over $100 and for the few times a year I use it gets the job done. I have DeWalt 20V for smaller tools that get used much harder and longer and they are worth it. But for occasional homeowner maintenance, I'd rather have all the tools I need at an affordable price, than pick a more expensive tool line and not be able afford those extra tools you could use but aren't essential.
Thanks for the feedback.
Same here, Ryobi is great for a budget friendly brand. I have several.
For home use that's perfect. Because I'm a tradesmen, the extra cost of purchasing DeWalt or Milwaukee tools is well worth the investment as we use them all the time and those two brands are always at the very top of most of Project Farm's reviews.
Yeah , i have a bit of ryobi stuff too , i have the ryobi pole saw , and small chain saw , and the ryobi 18 inch mower , and the bigger size ryobi whipper snipper and the grass/leaf blower and use them around home to keep our jungle in some sort of order :) .
They do seem very reliable in my use , i`d call them solid , as Todd has shown probably not class leading , but they seem pretty good , and the thing that keeps me buying them more than anything else is , they have such a full array of tools , and if you have a few batteries you can get a lot of work done with the vast array of different tools.
The saws work ok for light general duties , but if you where seriously cutting lots of hard timber every day as with any of these electric devices , i think you would probably spring for a much more expensive pro petrol device.
Another thing that has grown on me with the electric tools , you put the battery in , press the button and go , none of this pull start stuff , and if you have old shoulder injuries or you are just an old fart ( or both, thats me ), not having to yank a pull start is very very nice .
I didnt like the electric mower at first because it just did not have the torque of a petrol mower in the long grass , but once you get used to maybe just raising the blades a tad and or maybe taking a bit less of a cut , its pretty good , and they are light to push around , and again , put the battery in and push button and go , and no having to worry about filling up fuel tanks .
i dont think you would buy one for daily serious heavy duty work though unless it was mostly light stuff .
Very nice comparison of cordless pole saws. I’ve been trimming palm and fruit trees at my house for 30 years. So far, I’m just on my second corded one. This second one seems to last forever, so it’s hard to retire it for a new cordless one. You tested the most important specs: cutting speed, length, and leverage weight. Pole saws are the most tiring tools I use because I’m having to carefully balance the saw while lifting 20 lbs sometime over my head, while on a shaking ladder! (In 30 years my palm trees have really grown high.) The Oregon will be my choice even though I have Dewalt 20V tools. Thanks for your dedicated work and attention to detail.
Thanks and you are welcome!
*Aisle
@Norm110ful - Which corded one do you have? I like the idea of not having another tool that uses a battery. I can always run a short extension cord to a portable generator if I am too far from an outlet on my property.
I'd be really interested to see additional brands tested. Stihl, Husqvarna and Toro pole saws to name a few. Excellent and unbiased testing. Thank you for everything you do!
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the video idea.
@@ProjectFarm i would also be interested is seeing additional pole saws tested. I would especially like to see how my cordless Stihl polesaw compares with these. Thanks for doing these videos- they are always interesting!
I believe Harbor Freight has a pole saw as well that could have been included.
Was patiently waiting for the Makita that never came. maybe next time.
@@ProjectFarm And if there's a round 2, you should include the weedeater you converted to a tree-eater in your very first video.
I have to say that all the videos that I’ve seen you make are the most informative. I love every single one and they have helped me in making decisions on the tools that I purchased. Thank you. Keep the video coming. I’ll be watching them.
Thanks so much!
Another observation: When cutting rectangular wood, the angel of the blade to the surface has a large effect on the cutting speed. This is why all chainsaw cutting competitions use round logs. For these chainsaw comparisons, I would use round fence posts for accuracy, or make sure the saw is always parallel to one surface.
Thank you for the feedback!
Thanks for the information as always. I just bought my parents the Green Works 60v of this saw. They have the string trimmer and lawn mower in the 60v system and I am very impressed. Now that they have a smaller yard, moving to electric is a game changer to people who need a low maintenance approach to yard care.
You are welcome! Nice!
I've had pretty good luck with my millwakee. one nice thing about the millwakee other than already having plenty of batteries is the extensions. You can add as many as you can handle and there only about 45 bucks.Thanks for another great comparison.
Great feedback on the Milwaukee. Thank you
Yah I bought three add on pieces and an extension. Bad to the bone
@@johngaughan9399 ya I got the trimmer head also and my wife loves it. I wish they'd make a little cultivator attachment for the power head. I think that would be handy in the garden for clean up.
I regularly use two extensions on my Milwaukee pole saw. Very capable, though unwieldy. I'm considering a third.
@@paulojanen5045 I've done 3 before and it's doable but difficult but it does come in handy.
I have had a Stihl pole saw for 20 years and it is superb. Always starts and is easy to use
Thank you for sharing!
I love how thorough you are with these comparisons. I also love how you almost always let us know where items are made.
Thank you very much!
Yes because none of us would know that almost everything on the market is made in China and then marked up to triple its value.
Love all your reviews given the approach and obvious attempt to give every product the same equal opportunity with reliable results and easy to compare illustrations. Thanks so much!
You are so welcome!
Hi tod, excellent demonstration as always, usually I buy my tools after watching your videos on a product I need, your awesome ty for your time and dedication, Bob,
Hi Bob, Thank you for the positive feedback!
I just bought that same Greenworks one the other day and I’d definitely echo your conclusion. Not a bad price and it does good work if you just need something to prune or chop down small trees/bushes once a season or so.
I have a greenworks and it's amazing. Took a whole medium sized downed tree apart in my neighbors yard on only 2 charges. The thing is a beast.
Thanks for sharing.
I've been use the Dewalt pole saw and love it. You have to let it cut. Don't force it... I noticed a difference on what battery you use though. The big 60v battery works the best and is a good counter weight on the end.
Great feedback on the DeWalt
It'd be cool to see all these piwer tools tests done with 12ah batteries as well
I got it in a black Friday sale and I agree. It cuts fantastic you just have to let it do the work.
I used my brothers dewault and didn’t like how much weight was on the end and how much sag the pole had. I went with the Milwaukee and it fixed both of those issue. Dewault does have a new version out with a power head that should be much bettrr
I've already seen several comments requesting a follow-up video including some of the other brands, and I have to agree, seeing how Makita, Stihl, Kobalt, Skil, and other pole saw brands stack-up against the competition would be great information to have. With the number of saws in this video, this one had to be very expensive to do. At least these were all cordless, so you weren't spending even more money on that high-priced gasoline.
I would also love to see a video testing work boot laces. I am destroying mine all the time, and I know I wish I had a go-to set of solid, reliable boot laces, and I suspect I'm not alone in that.
Given the weather in a lot of places this winter season, I feel like a lot of people could also do with an informative video on ice melters, and their performance in the ice and snow, and additionally if certain ice melter brands have an affect on the yard and greenery afterward. I've heard that some truckers also make up their own ice melter/traction mixtures by mixing ice melter with various other things like sawdust, clay granules (cheap kitty litter or oil spill absorber), sand, rock salt, and just about anything that could help a tire obtain more traction.
Thank-you for all the work you put into these videos every week. A lot of my purchasing decisions have been altered based upon the test results I've seen in your videos.
You are welcome! Thanks for the video ideas.
@@ProjectFarm Ryobi also makes a pole saw attachment for their Xpand it trimmer. I wonder how that one compares to this Ryobi?
@@ProjectFarm we appreciate it. Maybe Lowes, Home Depot and 3rd party episodes and then one final championship so we can silence everyone for good by showing over and over how great Milwaukee is.
Might be worth researching which brands are essentially the same as well. Many Kobalt, MasterForce, and greenworks 80v tools are identical except for different notches in the battery.
Just a quick Google search for a stihl saw makes me understand why he didn't buy one!
I was already in the DeWalt 20v line when I got mine. I like the fact that the DeWalt (and probably others too but I didn't notice) has a 40" optional mid pole extension. If someone is thinking of buying one of these, which ever brand, it WILL put a huge smile on your face the first time you use it.
Thank you!
I bought the Harbor Freight brand pole saw almost 2 years ago and I'm very happy with it. Cost was the decider for me as they had a sale on it, buy the unit (it was on sale maybe 30$off) and a battery and get the charger free(30$value). With a full charge it out lasts me limbing trees so that I can brush hog under them without lowering the ROPS or getting a face full of tree branch. It's still going strong. Only issue is that if I don't make sure the bar oil tank is empty when I'm done it will quickly leak out leaving a mess when put away. It came with the scrench and a small starter bottle of oil.
Thanks for sharing.
Brand?
@@waxhawcreek1717 Atlas 40v pole saw, house brand like the Pittsburgh tools are a Harbor Freight house brand. Currently pole saw is on sale for $80 tool only.
My local store has additional sale( managers special) of buying tool, battery, and charger at the same time and the charger is free.
Suggestion: Please test different silicone oil sprays. I am mostly interested in lubricity, their ability to withstand washout, corrosion resistance (and maybe ability to withstand high temperatures, since the ones I have at home are suited for use in engine rooms).
Thank you for the video idea!
Would be a good one, I like his oil and lubricant tests. Reminds me to go check a few out again.
Yes I'm also interested in this, specifically I'm trying to find a good product to lubricate the telescoping booms on a knuckle boom crane. It needs to fully dry so as not to attract dust into the slides and also needs to adhere strong enough to not be wiped off from the extreme pressure of the sliding pads.
The pads themselves are plastic and are supposed to be self lubricating but I see heavy scoring on the steel booms and it gets very sticky in certain places..
Thanks
Just make sure you get some superlube brand.
@Randy She interesting, I'll check it out
The fact that a pole saw was one of your very first videos speaks a lot about how much youve made your channel grow. Youve found your own style little by little without losing the objective of informing with your videos or using clickbaits on them. Congratulations!
Informative testing. My 13-year old Corded Oregon/Harbor Freight unit still works great and it has been worked, and not just limbing. I have cut down trees up to 10" caliper and not just a few. I'm still using the supplied chain, though, it is near its last sharpening. It does now leak a little of oil, but still performs as new. I more than got my $50.00 investment back. Very happy customer.
Thanks! Nice!
I am on the EGO platform and I'm always very pleased with how EGO does in your tests. Thanks for the video 👍
Our pleasure!
I also am on the EGO platform and bought that saw last spring. It did a very good job until the end of the summer the blade has become loose. I'll try and see if I can make tightening adj to use it this year without the chain coming loose. I also paid a lot less than $350 last year, so I'm not sure if I got it on sale or without battery and charger. I thought I spent in the $180-250 range. I already had batteries from string trimmer and lawn mower (2.5a, 5a). I did spend about $340 for a full chainsaw, 18 in with 5a battery and charger. only issue other than loose chains is the self oiling seems to leak slowly while storing. I wrapped a towel around neck of pole saw and placed towel under chainsaw to fix it.
@@frommatorav1 dripping oil during storage is normal for almost all of these pole saws. It has to do with the way the oil is applied to the chain.
I've been pleased with their mower and their weedwhacker in my yard. They seem to make pretty good stuff.
As a follow-up to my last comment. I was able to correct the issue with the blade being loose and leaking is still minimal. Still a huge upgrade over manual sawing.
Good to see our E-go did so well. We got ours back when home Depot carried the brand. We definitely didn't pay that much.
Jesus, I didn't even notice HD didn't sell them anymore. I never look, but I always knew it as HD's electric house brand.
Yeah I’m still sad about that.
I got the hedge trimmers from a home Depot in Rhode Island a couple years back. I believe home Depot still sells ego at least here in Connecticut. Going into 2 years and will probably have to get a third battery for this coming season. I bought a secondary when I picked up the unit so that I could swap batteries and continue to hedge trim, for work, and that had worked great but I'm only getting about 45 minutes to an hour per battery now but, that's 2 years with almost daily use through two seasons for both batteries. 190 bucks a battery isn't a big deal. Love those trimmers man super lightweight and totally powerful enough to get through boxwood and privet no problem. Light weight so that they're easily manageable with doing intricate boxwood detailing
@@drfuck yeah I have some of those trimmers too. Hella powerful and plows though some decent size branches.
My hint is to use the next larger size batteries in any E-GO they fit in. The battery that comes with anything is usually too small and they overload the amp draw limit and it stops. Man that's annoying. Like I use the lawnmower battery in the chainsaw and that chainsaw is a beast. 18 inch bar one for anyone interested.
EGo is not anyone’s house brand, but they did cut a drug deal early on to get their foot in the market. All of my EGo products are 4-5 years old with no problems. The self-propelled mower is awesome. I’ll never go back to gas.
I have been watching your test videos for a few years and I am still impressed by the diversity of subjects and the quality of the tests conducted. Well done !
I would like to suggest a test that would be out of the ordinary: we see a lot of videos on UA-cam of an electric generator which consists of an electric motor coupled to a generator, with or without a flywheel depending on the configuration, and which supposedly provides free energy. I'm very curious to see your test results on this type of machine. Keep up the good job !
Thanks, will do! Thanks for the video idea.
Good idea.
I bought Oregon Pole Saw with your recommendation two year ago, I did not go wrong. This is the best UA-cam channel for DIY people. I have your recommendations stored in "Project Farm" list on Amazon, in case I have to buy a product in future.
The sag and weight test of the pole was a great test. Thanks for all the work you put in to this.
You are welcome!
I have the Ryobi and would recommend it for light use. I was already in the Ryobi battery system, so it was a no-brainer for me.
Great feedback on the Ryobi.
Same here. Also have the 14" Ryobi 40V Chainsaw, Weed-Eater & Blower. Been very happy with all of them. The battery life is insane on the pole-saw!
I am in the ryobi 18v line and have that version of the pole saw. I would have liked to see the 18v one+ polesaw in this lineup
The Milwaukee is definitely a very good saw, I bought it along with two additional extensions so has plenty of reach but does get heavy at that distance but normally you are going more vertical than horizontal which does help some.
Thanks for the feedback.
Milwaukee rocks
How's the torque, with two extensions?
@@MrCaribe65 I haven't noticed any loss of torque probably because they use solid steel shafts. I have cut branches all the way up to 8 inch without any power loss issues, just have to be careful of where they fall! 😀
@robK58
Ordering my extra extension. Thanks buddy.
Oh, if you're interested, you can install 12 inch Oregon bar Part# 124MLEA041, with a corresponding 12 inch chain. I needed to, to get four thick branches on my monster oak trees. Worked well, as long as I let the saw do the work.
You did this video a few years ago. Great job, even two years later it helped me decide what I wanted to get for fathers day. I'm buying myself the Milwaukee brand. It's on sell now with the extensions tool only. Perfect, I have the rest.
Thanks for the feedback.
I love my DeWalt pole saw. It rips through large branches pretty quickly without any stall. As you suggested, I have a bunch of DeWalt 20v tools already so it just made sense. Thankfully it also performs quite well. 😎
Thanks for sharing!
Thinking of getting Dewalt pole saw - does it matter where you buy? Where'd you get yours?
@@davparksoh, I got mine at Home Depot and I haven’t had any issues with it at all. You definitely have to keep an eye on the bar chain oil level so you don’t run it out empty. Keep that at a correct level at all times and you will not have any issues. I don’t think it matters where you get it as long as it’s an actual DeWalt made unit. Handy having all the 20v tools using the same battery. The hedger is quite strong as well and the blower is pretty strong for a handheld unit. But the pole saw is a real performer. The thing is a little brute!! 👍🏻😎👍🏻
@@Far2hip Thanks - appreciate your response - I was wondering though when you said it doesn't matter where it's bought, as long as it's an actual Dewalt made unit - not sure I follow you there - are there fake Dewalt knockoffs being sold as genuine Dewalt power tools? I get tools from Amazon, CPO & Lowes/H.D - I'm assuming those places are legit, right?
@@davparksoh, yes, those places you mention are definitely legit. On Amazon I would simply buy from the Dewalt company direct store they have in there. Honestly, I couldn’t tell you if there are actual knockoffs of the Dewalt tools. But with the number of resellers I’ve seen getting slammed with selling refurbished units as new in the past, I would always feel better about spending a few more bucks to buy right from the company or the big box names you mentioned. Places like Walmart and Home Depot won’t risk their reputations selling refurbished units without letting folks know what they are. Those type of outlets have pretty solid satisfaction/return policies. Actually, I have bought refurbished tools directly from Dewalt when they had their local company store about 10 mins away from me. Still have a few of them today 5-10 years later. Their stuff is solid. The pole saw as I said is a little brute and does a great job. A little heavy out front if holding it at flatter angles, but not unmanageable at all. 😎
I look forward to these videos all week, great tests, very impressive!
You should test machetes and bow saws, if you haven't already. Also the little 1x30 inch belt sanders, those are super useful for lots of things and the cheaper ones are widely regarded as being the same quality as the expensive ones.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestions.
This is the original comment that "d" stole. Good comment my guy, too bad a bot is getting credit for your words.
Wow you're right, it's crazy how much time some people have on their hands.
Great information as always. Would love to see a second video with the 60v dewalt, makita, Bauer, atlas, masterforce, kobalt. Thanks for the hard work you put into these videos!
Thank you!
Normally he stays 20v, but with this one being all over I was shocked to not see the dewalt 60v, but a follow up with the rest would be cool. Still want to see the dewalt 60v trimmer verses the rest.
No other YT product testing channel can compare to yours in terms of the shear volume of information packed into the minimum amount of watching time. Keep up the great work!
Thank you!
Just as a suggestion... Even though the worx can be used as a chainsaw you should have tested it with the pole, otherwise it's a chainsaw against a polesaw
Well, as you can see in the video it's far from being good even in chainsaw form...
So what would have changed if he had uses the pole???
@@jean-philippechasse9431 True but I do think it would've been nicer if they were all tested the exact same way
@@ohioknifelover that's exactly what I mean
@@lesleyboeder1798 Very likely the speed tests, since you can't apply anything like the amount of downward pressure with a pole saw that you can with a chainsaw held at the grips like that. It would have been significantly slower tested as a polesaw.
Great video, I always enjoy seeing your testing process. I'd love to see a parts store oil showdown. O'Riley's, NAPA, AutoZone, ect.
Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.
Most of those are just rebranded name brand oils if you look on the back of NAPA oil you’ll see it says Valvoline.
I appreciate the effort put into all of these videos. Just the quick construction he had to do for the pole extension test must have been a bit... interesting, at least in thought process.
What I appreciate is that while Ryobi is almost never a leader, it also doesn't tend to be a loser. In general, it shows that it's a solid performer - just not a "Use it 12 hours a day, every day" brand. For me? I don't care if it takes 16 seconds to cut through something vs 7 seconds. I have the extra 9 seconds to spare, for my amount of use. In a case like this, I'd be trimming between one and twenty trees - in a year. Not a day. So, I have the time to do the cleanup.
In fact, I used my portable "brushless reciprocating saw" with a 9" pruning blade to remove the bulk of the limbs from a fallen oak tree that was over 50 feet tall, and probably 20 years old. I made a mound of brush eight feet deep, five feet tall, and 25 feet long, and a number of them were cut at the point where they were 3-4" thick. Could I have done it faster with a "professional" brand? (or even a chainsaw) Sure - but my family couldn't drag it out any faster than I was cutting it with the Ryobi.
In general, I have no hesitation in suggesting the 'middle of the range' products that PF lists, simply because they do the job they're designed for, without breaking the bank, for non-professionals.
In fact - suggestion. Do a couple of "professional tool" showdowns. Make it very clear that it is a showdown for _expensive_, name brand professional tools. Then do the same and make it clear that you're doing commodity, home use tools. Maybe that'll quiet down the constant litany of "You need to spend lots of money on these tools for heavy usage, for your once a month jobs!" I'd call Ryobi a 'pro-sumer' brand. I use them for business, but my business is not construction. I use them when I have to do construction type work for my normal job.
I have the Ryobi but will be returning it. My intention is not to invalidate your points but I do find the heavy use of plastic concerning. In fact, I am returning mine because the back of the housing broke when I put it down with a little force. I decided to go with something that had metal in the vital areas the Ryobi was plastic. Just my 2 cents.
@@marios3163 - Unfortunately, anything portable enough to be really useful is plastic cased, no matter what the brand. Even a lot of gas powered units are plastic casings. If you're regularly dropping tools, I'd suggest looking for some older corded tools, and change out the power cords for grounded ones. (like the 1930-50's aluminum cased ones)
@@tailgatecarpenter26 - Comes from the same company that makes really "high end" stuff. The main reason a lot of people avoid it is the battery form factor. IT _is_ very bulky. (TTI? )
Great work, Mate. I have the Ryobi pole saw. It's a bit heavy, up front, but it helps with holding decent downward pressure, while cutting. It goes through large branches with no issues. As with the rest of us, the choice of saw was linked to the previous choice of battery commitment.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
None of these tests actually show the saw in actual use of cutting a branch high up, and two things were ignored. The angled head allows you to cut the top of the branch which will allow it to fall cleanly from the tree. A straight head will only cut the side of the branch and can sometimes bind the saw into the tree. Another thing to consider is with the weight of the motor on the end of the pole it requires you less Force pulling down on the saw to actually cut the branch which is a benefit.
Thanks for the constructive feedback
So you didn't learn anything from this video? The point is that it showed us how the products performed in a repeatable, scaleable experiment. It shows the comparative comparability between the products, not individual performance when used with human assistance and technique.
@@ProjectFarm Thanks for the reply and also for the video. If you still have these saws, possibly you can do a test on some lumber to simulate a branch at 6 ft, 10 ft, and 14 ft to get an idea of how these saws work in the position they're intended to be used at. I already have large DeWalt batteries, and a Remington pole saw with a straight blade which tends to hang up in the branches, so for me it would be the DeWalt with the angled head. As a homeowner with one acre, the little bit of slower cutting time is okay with me.
@@Ethan-mv2un Sorry, did I say I didn't learn anything? A pole saw is not meant to be used sideways, cutting parallel to the ground, unless you have a boom lift. This is something for the ordinary homeowner that will be cutting a branch above their head. The angle of the head, and the weight of the saw are very important factors, that happened to have been overlooked. I do not fault Project Farm for this, but would like to see the saws used in the actual manner that they are intended to be used and show how they work that way. On my 14' 110v pole saw the head comes off and I can use it as a chainsaw. The extra several pounds on the end of the pole allows me to just lean it up against the branch instead of adding extra Force and that is a huge plus. These saws also have different chains on them. Adding a premium Oregon equivalent chain to each one of them would also change the playing field as I have found out with ALL my saws. Some of these saws will probably do better irregardless of their slow RPM or low torque if they had a better chain. If each saw in this video had the exact same chain, the results may be quite totally different.
@@descargaelbano that's not the point. The point is to test the hardware with the accessories it comes with in a repeatable, consistent experiment.
I got that Craftsman a few months ago, im very happy with it so far.
Only downsides are the weight/bending at full length and having to manually oil the chain while also having to retighten the extensions now and then as they can loosen while the saw is being used.
Thanks for sharing.
Fantastic data comparison. Your tests are very applicable. My only questions are: 1) does one brand use oil faster that others? 2) Do all the units with oilers leak when not in use?
I have the Oregon. It leaks, but you can store it upside down to prevent it from leasking (horizontally, not vertically). It is a great saw.
Once again PF delivers the most helpful, thorough, straightforward, and entertaining video. Great for any level of DIY guy looking into tools. I'm a veteran gigging musician of 20+years pre-covid now borderline homeless and forced into humiliating beginner handyman. I'm desperately throwing my name out there for all kinds of stuff wherever I go so Im constantly learning new skills as I grind out (no pun intended lol) all the headaches and keep my esteem just above the water. Different jobs require different tools obviously so I have to basically buy a tool whenever a job comes up and I do the research scramble. Project Farms videos have been my go-to for everything and is a real life-saver... Literally. Watching every video (all the way through is a must!) has changed my decisions like a game of ping pong though every single test run. This particular video changed my mind from settling for the budget Sun Joe and saved me the disappointment only because I have the battery Black n Decker (whew thanks), to the Greenworks or Worx saws. I've never seen Oregon tools in action before, I was super impressed! That would be my top choice given the $$$ by a landslide. The Ford and Chevy of the bunch (DeWalt and Milwaukee) tests were beyond expectation. And E-go's ego took a hit which I loved also because I thought that would come out in top 2 but didn't...watch all the way through guys n gals! Thanks again Jeff and keep them coming!
Thanks and will do, Todd!
I have owned the DeWalt pole saw for two years and have not had any problems with it. It performs flawlessly. I think it is moderately priced which gives it the edge over some of the better performers.
Thanks for the feedback.
I own the Dewalt since I have the batteries for their tools. I'm well pleased so far.
Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for including the Worx. I Love all the Worx tools I have and was actually considering this saw as a Purchase. I think if I take the leap I will be getting the Oregon.
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I love my Greenwork. Only complaint is that you need to readjust bar after a couple cuts.
Great feedback on the Greenworks
And keep oil in reservoir for chain.
Particularly impressed with the testing on balance/sag here - that is such a huge factor with this type of saw.
Power is useless, if you can't apply it to the cutting surface.
Black & Decker... once an affordable brand that worked sufficiently, now an embarrassment to themselves-
I felt like they were just taking up a place in this race, that could have been filled with something more deserving.
The Oregon & Milwaukee were 'very impressive' !!
Thanks for the feedback.
That’s because Stanley-Black and Decker owns DeWalt dude. DeWalt is the premium brand now. 🤷♂️
@@jman0870 just cos they have a premium brand in DeWalt, doesn’t mean the B&D gear has to be so bad though..
@@everyhandletaken have you bought Stanley tools lately? Anything that isn’t a hammer or tape measure is pretty much garbage 🤷♂️
@@jman0870 agree, though i wouldn’t totally write off their spanner sets, perhaps.
I still find B&D to be even worse, but looking back, Stanley have fallen from grace from a greater height.
I will just stick to Milwaukee & live life much poorer, but without regret 👍🏻
I'd like to see a comparison on 1 man post hole auger. I just bought a 40v Ryobi and I think it did great. I like the fact that it has a reverse for when it gets stuck.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I just bought the DeWalt yesterday, August 9th 2023. Thank you for the recommendation, I looked at the Greenworks, but their price had gone up.
This was at Tractor Supply for $229 with battery and charger, their extended warranty was the deciding factor, it covers accidents.
Worked great for removing a tree that had landed on my roof.
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
Great video. I already have a pretty good sized Ryobi collection, but it's always nice to see what's actually the best. I'd love to see a little more of the lawn care type of tools. I enjoy these. Maybe an electric rototiller, hedge trimmer, weed whip, etc. As always, great job! I really enjoy and appreciate what you do!
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the video idea.
Another shocking result with Milwaukee on top. I agree the Oregon is pretty nice too. I have a Sun Joe corded pole saw that cost $70 and works great (with an automatic oiler). Anything without an automatic oiler is pretty terrible.
Great point!
I have the corded sun joe also. Works just fine for what it is.
You're exactly right. NO OILER??? What are you supposed to do? Dip it in a bucket of oil?
@6:50
Surprised that the Worx brand was used as a Hand held saw, verses on the end of the Pole.
You can apply much more force using it that way, than could be applied on the end of a long pole.
Also, again @11:45 and also @13:50, the Worx is used as a hand held saw, and not on the end of the pole. ? was there an issue with the pole?
Yeah I was curious how well it would handle on the pole. A combination pole/handheld saw seems nice from a budget perspective I guess, but all that extra weight has got to be awkward at full length, right?
I agree. It really should have been tested as a pole saw.
Your channel is so useful. I really appreciate your time and effort. Many times it has helped me to make a wise decision. Thank you!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I am not sure how easy it would be to do, but I'd be really interested to see several battery operated lawn mowers tested. I have been looking into them and am struggling to make the leap from gas. I appreciate your videos.
Or battery operated lawnmower robots?
There are many different types of them, some aren't even water resistant 🤯 (killed mines with a sprinkler 😅)
would also love to see the ryobi 18v, 36v, and dual battery 36v (has 2x 18s) compared in that test
Thanks for the suggestion.
I wouldn't buy the Ryobi. I bought one that cost close to $330.00 at HD and the battery didn't last a month.
@@mattchilders3123 that's not normal, u got 6 months warranty on the battery (at least here in Germany)
Battery don't just dies cause of no reasons...
I got all of my tools on Metabo batteries, but you can use almost every battery on every tool with an adapter 😅 never had problems...
I've owned the Oregon saw in this video for years now. At the time, there really wasn't much for decent pole says (WTH Makita) so I did tons and tons of research. I really like the pole and design of the Oregon and it's worked excellent for me over the years. I have the 6 ah battery which typically runs for about 4 hrs of trimming. That's about all I have in me for holding a pole saw up before I need a long break anyways so it's worked out well. I did one modification and that was glueing the red retainer for the main pole to the body with silicon as it kept sliding off. Haven't had an issue since. I've since bought their chain say and leaf blower and both of those have been excellent as well.
Thanks for sharing.
Years ago I purchased a Stihl body harness for my pole saw work. I used it a few times. You might consider buying a harness to help distribute the weight of the saw over your shoulders and back. My harness is easy to use and easy to adjust for the different reach required in cutting tree branches.
has anyone used the makita polesaw and have thoughts?
Amazing job Tod 👍
Thank you very much!
Rookie DIYer here.. I am so grateful for these series..
Thanks!
I trust your recommendations and it’s fun to see how much you like figuring out methods to test. Would you consider testing random orbit and palm sanders (corded and cordless) and wood stain brands?
Thanks for the suggestion.
You shouldn't trust him in this case. Read my comment in the main section.
He intentionally avoided the two best brands and most used by arborists in the world: Husqvarna and STIHL. I strongly suggest that you do some research on your own and talk to the REAL expert using those machines on the field every day.
@@DiabloOutdoors You are free to do the research, buy the equipment, test the equipment, make your own video and run your own channel if you don’t like the way PF performs his tests.
It’s always easier to criticize instead of doing your own work.
@@zakkaryzoah1386 Sir, the two most known brands, used by arborists all over the world, are not listed and tested: Husqvarna and STIHL. Second, who do you think you are to believe that you're the only one allowed to comment on UA-cam? END OF DISCUSSION.
@@DiabloOutdoors He means he purchased the saws with his own money. Not that he bought every cordless pole saw manufactured on earth.
Use your brain...or don't.
Please keep on commenting too. Best comedian here haha
Thanks for the videos! As a newer homeowner you've helped me pick out a lot of my tools. Even if I don't get the ones you tested, I at least get a better idea of what to look for.
One thing I'd really like to see tested and compared are trigger clamps. There's a huge disparity in price between the cheap harbor freight/walmart/amazon ones and the Dewalt/Irwin/bessey clamps. I've always been told to just spring for the dewalts, but I'm not so sure. I'd really like to see them compared and they're something every DIYer needs.
You are welcome! Thanks for the video idea.
Todd, it would be interesting to see if the corded versions of these can keep up with the cordless ones.
Thanks for the video idea.
Cornered versions would likely smoke the cordless ones
However, I’d like to see that too
@@lordrayden3045 Yeah its not really fair, corded tools have ridiculous advantages. They just have that one giant disadvantage lol....
@@tech99070
Yes,
And I’d interested to see hiw they do vs each other and vs the cordless version
I love the way you labeled the time line. Please make all the videos. Beyond impressed.
Thanks!
I really could have used one of these when my grandparents' tree came down last summer! Thanks for the video!
If possible, could you look into rotary tools like the Dremel?
You are welcome! Thanks for the video idea.
Have the Milwaukee and it’s one of the few tools that I’m not impressed with. It’s too short without the extension and with the extension it makes the tool off balanced and difficult to maneuver. It’s front heavy so when completing a cut I struggle to keep the saw from hitting the ground. On top of that, the extension is difficult to attach failing to lock into its correct position. I have many Milwaukee tools that I absolutely love, but this one is a dud.
Great feedback on the Milwaukee. Thank you
All pole saws are awkward and unbalanced.
The more weight you put on the battery end the easier it will be to control. Use at least the 8Ah. I found using any strap with it gave less control. Anticipate when the cut will be nearly complete, and let off the trigger. Let the momentum of the chain complete the last bit of cutting.
Much appreciated video, but your testing confirms my own assessment that this type of tool isn't nearly as useful as advertised, for pruning fruit trees you're much better off using a manual pole-saw. Manual saws are much lighter and easier to control than any of these and good quality blades require a lot less force than you may think.
Agree. A Silky Gomboy ~$40 for low branches and Silky Zubat 13ft pole saw for high branches.
I agree I have both and my manual works so much easier plus I added a 18ft piece of pvc to make it really reach the top branches to thin out my 50 year old oaks while standing on a 12ft ladder
Anything thicker than 2” and the powered saw wins hands down for convenience. The cut isn’t quite as nice, but it’s effortless in comparison to the manual saw. I have a nice Fiskars pole saw that is much more effort when trying to hack off a large high overhead limb. We’re talking seconds vs a minute or more of sawing. And if a blade binds, that’s even more cursing. So glad I got the Dewalt powered pole saw.
@@bt5252 If it takes you a minute to get through a 2" thick branch your saw blade needs sharpening. I'm not a fan of Fiskars tools because of the unreasonably high prices, I'm using a Polish made saw blade that costs like 15$ and gets me through an entire season without requiring any maintenance. When it's time to maintain your saw, after sharpening give it a nice polish and a thin coat of WD40, it prevents both rusting and binding.
Besides the handling problems, most electric saws (both chain and reciprocating types) are too rough for fruit trees, ripping off the bark and leaving an uneven stump that heals slower and is more exposed to fungi and parasites.
I've already got a collection of Greenworks tools. I appreciate this review. Thanks much!
You are welcome!
Love the videos, could you do one over ratchet and sockets like which has the least arc swing and which can take the most torque before it snaps
Thank you for the video idea! Which brands would you like tested?
@@ProjectFarm Pittsburgh, Dewalt, ICON, Kobalt, Hart, Snap-Off, Husky, Hyper Tough, maybe even Amazon Basics if they have one... pretty much any brand that might be readily available to the common consumer.
@@CharlieTheTexan also Milwaukee and the part store brands like Carlyle and whatever auto zone and O’Riellys have
@@ProjectFarm Lowe's sells Craftsman 120-tooth ratchets. I don't know if they are available as part of a set or not. I bought the 3/8 drive for the shorter swing, but would be curious to know if it suffers durability as a result.
@@ProjectFarm gear wrench grey pneumatic duo sockets
As someone invested in Craftsman, Milwaukee, and Makita, I was really hoping to see a Makita one in this comparison. Either way, love these videos, and the honest comparison between them. Always unbiased in the testing, and a quick summary at the end. I'll have to decide which way I want to go. Cost effective (Craftsman) or performance (Milwaukee) when that time comes for me to invest. Would love to get away from the pole saw attachment for my gas trimmer head, since it's only used every couple years in general.
Todd, do you have an online page where these results can be easily accessed in a spreadsheet format?
Makita makes the best ope out of all of them.
I also would have loved seeing Makita in the running
Makita owner here, a very good bit of kit.
@@joshclayg which one do you have? Do you have the model number
@@briankohlenberg 196101 attachment that fits the multitool 36v base unit. I use it with a 1 metre extension and can reach most things!
DUX60Z for the multitool.
I'll be real honest. I'm not a large fan of the way you tested the worx compared to the others. Other than that great worm!
Thanks for the constructive feedback
@@ProjectFarm I wish to note my other comment. I do truly appreciate the chart at the end! I enjoy looking over them!
I'd 2nd that I thought it should be on the pole like the others, but the 2.5lb test was realistic. Loved everything though!
@@ProjectFarm I'm guessing that with the weight of the Worx, it would've needed a special jig to catch the power head so it wouldn't hit the ground after the chain finishes cutting through while on the end of its pole. I think you made the point about the weight of that Worx. The 2.5 lb test showed just how you had to carefully hover your left had above the handle to catch the saw when the cut was through. I also noticed you had your chaps on when you used that Worx.
Hope you and your family stay safe and well.
Shows one thing, we can't make anything in the United States anymore.
Never had. Delusional Americans
Nope because we have unions and that ruined us. We priced ourselves out of the market!
US BEEN trash at making things. Every other part is sourced from over sea and just put together here but let's claim it "made it in amerikkka" 🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@thomasfogerty3515 Yes the last chainsaw I bought that i could afford was from China, with parts from all over the world. LOL except the United states !
@@thomasfogerty3515nope. Low wages in other countries, corporate profits, and a desire for cheap products pushed manufacturing overseas.
On the high end of what I could find, factory workers only make about $13,000 and they work more hours. So unions are to blame that factory workers aren't working for minimum wage from 1997?
This guy is amazingly thorough as well as innovative in his testing. If he could add becoming a proficient "data miner" to the mix and present a relaxed "executive summary" to his audience more so than the "machine gun" presentation I think he would move up the the next level. Not dissing, I truly think he is the best. Just popping my penny's worth into the suggestion box. Your hard work is truly appreciated!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Very well laid out comparison !! Thank You ! I have the RYOBI that I bought NEW on Ebay for $75 !! Love it ! I've owned it for 5 years now and it works flawlessly. I was using it yesterday !
Glad I could help!
Thanks so much for your review. I ended up getting the DeWalt on sale from Ace, as already had their 4 Ah battery for my impact driver. I was pretty impressed with how it cruised through trimming our maple tree branches. For sure it's easier to manage when only using one of the extension poles, but also very nice that it reaches to about 15 feet with both. Was also surprised was pretty easy on the battery. I don't know exactly how long we used it, but we trimmed a number of branches off the tree, and then cut those up further to take to the road, and it only went down 1 dot from a full charge.
I hope your purchase last you a long time as most people are unaware that Black and Decker now owns DeWalt. When a cheap Chinese company purchases a quality company like DeWalt, I become Leary of them.
Hedgeapple -- if I'm not mistaken, it's the second hardest North American wood. We use it for fence posts. Lasts forever. Bends fence staples. That's a real test, there!
Thanks for the feedback.
I love my Kobalt 80 volt 5 ah 10" chain pole saw. It works great on my south east Louisianna farm that a Hurricane went through and trashed all woods on my 20 acre property. Today I'll be cutting a 6 in limb of a tree out front.
Thanks for sharing!
Not sure why Mr. Farm omitted Kobalt (Lowes) it works great!
I missed the release of this video for some reason. I decided to buy one and immediately went to your channel to see if a review was done.
Once again, thank you sir for another great video.
Thanks and you are welcome!
I got the 40v Greenworks as an xmas gift for my bf. It just got delivered today. HE LOVES IT! Works great! THANK YOU!!! 🎉🤗🎉👍
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
Lucked out getting the Milwaukee pole saw and edger attachments for $19 each from Home Depot about a month ago. Putting the saw to work this weekend. Still want the m18 chainsaw. Waiting on a good deal. Thanks for the videos, most informative and scientific on UA-cam
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
I like how you get to the point and move right along with the demonstration. This demo was very informative and helpful. Thank you!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Was going to buy one so clicked your link so you’d get a kick back. This channel influences my purchases and I appreciate your methodology. Great job!
Awesome! Thank you!
I love this channel. What is challenging is buying separate brands, as each one has unique performance(s). If you want to go with one brand, so that you can use the same battery for multiple tools, which one collectively is the best brand to buy. So for example, do you buy ALL Milwaukee tools or ALL DeWalt tools, or ALL Ryobi tools. If you buy into one battery interchangeable system you save money in the long run.
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
I've had a Greenworks for years and it truly is incredible!
Thanks for sharing.