Terrible Tenancy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- The plaintiff says her landlord, the defendant who lives above her, had a leaky radiator, and it ruined the plaintiff’s belongings as a result. The plaintiff is suing for the damages and emotional distress. The defendant insists none of the plaintiff’s belongings were damaged. Besides, the plaintiff failed to pay rent, and the defendant even tried to have the plaintiff evicted.
Good for Doug for calling out the slumlord that a quote is that bad!
She might be a slumlord but the plaintiff also knows how to pimp the system, which isn't any better.
His rebuttals are hilarious
@@jaycutie1909right I was shocked 😭
Doug telling that landlord the FACTS 😄Her trying to say "it's not that bad", what a joke!
💯💯💯
He is too funny. Always throwing shade
Loving Doug giving that landlord a reality check. She's definitely a slumlord.
The renter is pushing a lot of BS!
Most DEFINITELY a slumlord. She should be ashamed but you know she’s not. She doesn’t care.
@@shannysunshine8389 that's true, but there's no excuse for repairs not being made.
@@shannysunshine8389What about the pics?!? The facts speak for themselves! The Doug was right!
With a deadbeat tenant, so they are a good match👏👏
Doug is hilarious lmfao 🤣 “Oh it is that bad…in fact, it’s even worse.” He’s the real reason I watch the People’s Court.
Who keeps receipts for sheets!? This was a terrible ruling. Whether the plaintiff is pregnant or not, the ceiling in the room she was renting was a mess, and no one should have to live like that
Not only did she not have proof, but she had not paid a dime of rent in six months. She still wasn't moving, the defendant is having to evict her to force her out.
All the money she"saved" when not paying rent is her reimbursement for the old sheets!!!!
They're called failed litigants.
I highly doubt her sheets cost $159
Nobody has sheet receipts…
@@Judithestearsexactly. I only keep receipts for electronics or jewelry. More like very expensive things not sheets.
I’m dead at Doug’s comments to the defendant at the end 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I was weak as hell at his comments😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Love Doug 😂😂😂😂😂
The man is so savage and I love it!!!!!
@@sequrey he was literally going back and forth with her at the end when she was trying to walk away 😂
I know 😂 I had to rewind it 2 times 😂😂😂
I think Harvey's "He hardly knew 'er" line has reached its 1000th case.
I think you need to add at least one more "0" to the end of that. 😅
@@JayJay-me8zk one more... two more... I've lost count!
You could almost hear him rolling his own eyes as he said it. Lol
And I am TIREDDDD of it 😩😩
I think it’s the stupidest comment!
Judge knew she would NEVER wash sheets from a leak 🙄
Doug: do you live there?
Defendant: no I don’t
Doug: I’m not surprised!
Me: 😂😂😂😂😂
Doug, “Your house looks like a dump “. 😂
Doug!!!😂😂😂 I love him! He has no filter. Glad he called the landlord out! That place was awful, and a health hazzard for anyone, but especially for someone who is pregnant.
I’m in shock 😱 !!?? The ceiling felt on her head and she got NOTHING ???? Her stuff was ruined and who keeps receipts for sheets ??
I am confused with that ruling. That’s the most hazardous place I’ve ever seen in people’s court !
The judgment was not fair.
Doug was more right than that judge. The landlord should be fined and lose her right to be a landlord and rent places.
Because she is a liar. She was claiming for stuff that she did not have, such as the man sweat pants. Once you lie to a judge, they see you for who you are. She probably damaged the roof herself .
How did she lie?!? The pictures are proof, and who keeps receipts on sheets?!? Not all the time
@@misunderstood136 : she had pics of everything else; but none of the 7 sweat pants. Which judge is going to believe that she has no money to rent her own apartment; but she is splashing out on 7 sweat pants; and for someone who had been meticulously taking pics of all her damaged stuff, she did not have a single pic of the sweat pants. Judges can spot a liar and thief from a mile away. It is their job,. The tenant might have had some damaged goods, but she is an opportunists. She witheld the rent for 7 months, claiming that she did so because the repairs were not carried out; if this was the case, why did she not use the rent money to repair the room? Because she is a thief. She is the reason why landlords are exiting the rental market.
@@naturalanimals8902 use the rent to make the repairs? Are you daft? She's renting a ROOM. You think THAT landlord would have accepted or tolerated the tenant beneath her calling a plumber AND a dry waller and letting them into the landlord's portion of the house to make repairs?
You're flipping nuts.
And I highly doubt that the rent for that ROOM amounted to enough money to cover the cost of a plumber (in winter), or a dry wall repair let alone both.
The repairs weren't being carried out, it is the slumlord's house and her duty to do the repairs, not the tenants.
The plaintiff wasn't 100% on the up and up, I'm not implying she was, but to support this SLUMLORD's actions on any level is reprehensible, but since you do, I can say I am happy that you and people like you are "exiting the rental market".
I'm not a person who keeps receipts, but if I spent $150.00 on sheets, I'd have receipts and detailed pictures of the damaged sheets and clothes, she had no evidence. She also didnt pay a dime for rent in 6 months, it was a washed deal.
ASKING HER WHO SHE WAS PREGNANT BY IS RIDICULOUS!!!!
Bothers me when JM is too nosy
I agree. She was definitely out of line. That was not relevant to the case at all.
Yes, I agree &even though they know they’re just being nosy (& judgmental) they’ll act like it’s relevant to the case! -oh it helps me understand her “decision making skills” Smh
Has nothing to do with the case 😩😬
@@QueenRissa_34she’s a white
Woman ofc she feels entitled to know
When Doug in the hall speaks to the litigants, he pets their arm lol
The judge really screwed this case up. The pictures alone proves the case of gross neglect
The landlord wouldn't have messed with her if she was a paying tenant
That place was unlivable period. I wouldn't pay either in that case.🙄💯
The question is would you live there for free like the plaintiff did for six months. Guess it wasn't too horrible
@@JayJay-me8zk Exactly Jay Jay. The remedy is to move out.
@@JayJay-me8zklearn to listen…the terms of her parole needed to be APPROVED first. That may take some time. SMH
@@GrettaGouchieagreed. She should of moved out within 1-3 months not wait to be evicted. But she probably couldn't afford to go anywhere which is unfortunate and something having a semi roof over your head is better than having nothing.
@@jm8280not just that, where ever she moves to has to be approved by the parole board as well. Like you said not having the money, the new place having to be approved and not having any family there was her downfall and she couldn't just get out.
The judge seeing video and pictures of that leak and giving the plaintiff NOTHING for damaged property is exactly why people say she's prejudice. Regardless of a lack of receipts, some kind of monetary compensation for ruined property is in order. She could have given her $300 instead of $3k but to say she deserves nothing is crazy.
Precisely! I'm lookin at this case like....wtf
That girl saved THOUSANDS of dollars by not paying rent for multiple months so she's been compensated 😂 She's the one who went out and got pregnant by a jailbird dude with no money and had to rent a bedroom in a literal shack.
The problem is that the majority of the things the Plaintiff was suing for has no monetary value, just sentimental. Pictures, prison letters, etc. have no monetary value. The only thing she had was the one blanket, which was a year old. She wasn't suing for the dresser and the pants she sued for, she only had one picture of one pair. On top of that, the "damage" to those items are something that could be easily washed, which she hadn't attempted to do. The plaintiff ruined her own case by the lack of evidence, nothing to do with the Judge. 🤷🏽♀️
She hasn't paid rent in 6 months and is STILL living there! She's already benefited thousands of dollars!! Wtf?
Well, technically if she is being evicted, this balance will go onto her credit/civil record once the eviction processes. Even if she moved out of the home before the court date, the balance owing will hit her credit.
She should have gotten something, even without receipts.
Why? She didnt pay rent for 6 months, a washed deal
The defendant knows she would never live any place like that but she would rent out a place like that and collect rent is disgusting.
Lol.
.better than her last place....jail
Right
@@lostsoul1278 wtf does that have to do with that scum landlord not fixing that apartment? tf she did her time
So is the plaintiff who squatted for 6 months then had to come up with a story because she was being evicted. If she didn't want to live there she would have moved. The fact she isn't paying rent and hasn't left tells me she wants to live there. Plus she is fighting it in housing court. That is disgusting
@@AprilShowerzz-gr5nythe plaintiff needs to move if it was bad not squat
Alot of people want to be landlords who CANT AFFORD TO BE LANDLORDS smh
So true! My landlord is 93 and still insists on fixing everything himself but he just jury rigs it and seems to have issues/be annoyed when there’s viable issues in the place. We just said screw it and bought our own fridge because the one that came with the place crapped out like 5 months into living there and his advice was to just unplug it and plug it back in like it was a Wi-Fi router. He was on the roof this past august when it was like over 95 degrees patching it because it was leaking in the upstairs apartment and I was thinking OMG I’m going to have to call the paramedics. I mean god bless the man for still being so active at 93 but there’s a limit where you need to acknowledge you need outsider help. The reason I stay is because it’s super affordable, pretty big and it’s literally down the block from my job.
Plaintiff should've informed the landlord that the rent was deposited into an escrow account until everything was fixed.
my impression is that the plaintiff did not have that knowledge nor did she have friends who could have pointed her in the right direction to get the legal advice and support she clearly needed.
@@pmabroukI agree. The law is the law, unfortunately. So if you continue to live in an unhabitable environment and just don’t pay you sadly still owe if you’ve agreed to pay a monthly rent. I speak from experience. You can’t just not pay and continue to live there, that means the place is good enough for you to live in for free (which makes sense to a lot of people) but legally, you’re still responsible for paying, otherwise you’re squatting. Let’s say all the repairs were made in an ideal world, would she be able to furnish all the money owed to the landlord? I’m betting not.
As soon as the plaintiff said she was on Parole the just decided then!
No, her Boyfriend is.
Looks dead into the camera... it is worse than that, dont you think so Harvey.. 😂 I love Doug
I feel that judge Marilyn treated the plaintiff differently as soon as she found out she was on parole,the defendant is disgusting and should not be renting anything
I think it was more after she found out she lied about paying rent. Once you lie, I think you done.
@@elaine3642 yes that is so true
I don't understand how she got absolutely nothing. Like sure not $3000 but SOME of her stuff was obviously damaged. Shouldn't she at least get $5 for a binder? I don't get how the judge awards literally $0.
Because she lacks compassion when it comes to poor black litigants who she looks down on because of their lifestyle such as in this case. She’s very prejudiced. If this woman was not on parole and came in well spoken and educated etc she would’ve given her something and you know it. She does this all the time. I’m glad her show cancelled right along with Mathis who was only ruling based off of his emotions! They both have new shows with entirely new formats and the ratings are not as high nor will they be because you can tell the litigants on the new shows are actors. She rules by the book on those she looks down on.
MIlian once again shows how biased she is. I am so glad that they pulled this program from the air. I never watched it when it was on tv but now that it is on UA-cam I can watch episode after episode and you can see the consistency in her rulings and the bias. I am surprised she and the program were never sued.
She already saved up money by not paying rent for months
Ridiculous defendant. She wouldn’t live like that.
No, she would move out, not stay there and withhold rent.
I don't understand how the plaintiff didn't have enough evidence when she had all those pictures of inhabitablity??
Probably because she inhabited the place for so long, which gives the impression that it was habitable enough for her. She said she couldn't afford to leave at first, and that was probably true, but she has to prove it.
How long does a judge expect ppl to hold on to receipts ...like wtf
Could she not also Google the brand of sheets she had? With her picture, she could use that for the cost.
2 to 5 years as a general rule for anything more than $100
@@popeye82okay boomer. No one keep a file cabinet full of receipts in case they end up on the people’s court.
@@Tuturu708 obviously not. Take a pic and keep it in your dropbox... Microsoft lens. It doesn't take someone to be old to be organized in their life or just get the store to email the receipt.
@@brisigonzalez3718We all know Milian would say something like “ how will I know if you got these from goodwill or any thrift store or not “
Kudos to Doug for sticking some truth to the defendant! People like her Always try to take advantage of people like the plaintiff ( who is no prize, but is still worthy of basic safety and security like everyone else). She knew the plaintiff was in a bad way and was counting on her to feel worthless enough to just live like a gutter rat and pay rent so the defendant can buy more fancy sweaters. Bet her husband has some fancy clothes too, with all they save by not fixing that shack.....
I love Doug 🤣🤣🤣 He's gonna tell it like he sees it with NO filter!
It bothers me that Judge and Doug asked her why she didn’t leave. Obviously if she had the means to she would have. Unfortunately some people aren’t equipped to just pick up and move. It does not seem like this plaintiff has had much support and guidance. Also she’s on parole. I don’t think she’s allowed to just pick up and leave that easily. That lady was definitely a slumlord.
Exactly !! Nobody stays in a dumpster by choice. It’s like asking someone poor « why aren’t you making more money », it’s not that easy, we don’t all have the same amount of options, or knowledge about the possible solutions.
@@Goldniz It makes me very sad. I’m a firm believer that you control your situation. However not everyone has had the fortune to figure this out. Especially if they’ve been raised in poverty, abused, etc. There is probably a lot of obstacles she must conquered to better her living situation.
The plaintiff continues to make bad decisions. She tried to make it on her but knowing she is struggling hooked up with the jailbird and got pregnant. Her mother obviously is there to support since she is moving to NC however, her mother is probably tired of the decisions her daughter makes.
Doug is so savage 😂😂😂😂
She evicted her after the ceiling felt on her head… that landlord needs to be charged with something
JM is so judgemental and smug. I cant be the only that catches this
You’re not. I notice this also. She treats her litigants based on how well they speak, how they’re dressed, and what they do for a living most times. If it doesn’t measure up and check out on her checklist, she goes by the book, throws understanding and compassion out the door and starts over talking them, shaming and bashing them and hops on her high horse with the quickness. Mathis used to also act like this. They both have had their shows cancelled but have new setups on their new shows which don’t have as high ratings because the litigants are clearly actors now.
Only towards black folks
I’ve been noticing this too.
Im sorry, the ceiling fell on her head. She went to the hospital. And she got nothing?? It's one of the few cases where pain and suffering was actually applicable.... I guess JM felt that her not paying rent was enough rough justice.
I don’t know why people goes to her court she’s not going to help you!. See how she question the one that’s the victim smh this judge sucks 😡🤬🤯😠😤
Doug's always pushing someone's buttons. 😁
She’s dead wrong for renting out that trashy house. Nasty landlord
Who keeps receipts for sheets!! Also sheets arent cheap!! She said it wasnt just one set ruined it was more then that. Also, I wouldn't want to wash any sheets where the celing fell down on. Judge M was so wrong in this case. Seems like she was being bias towards the plaintiff!! She always says "who am i going to believe you or my lying eyes"!! The proof was in her face on pictures so she should have gotten SOMETHING!! That was terrible as hell.
Sheets from dollar tree or family dollar are $10. Unless she brought sheets 15 times, they are not that expensive. Common sense would be to move the bed or sleep on the couch. Why would you keep buying the sheets over and over knowing it would be damaged again?
If Harvey dont do nothing else, he will always take advantage of a "He hardly knew her" opportunity 😂
Unbelievable 7 months pregnant ,she is on parole her man is in prison she has no where to live and let’s get pregnant great ideal. 😮
FACTS that's how people live life think nothing out and have ur hand out
And then our tax dollars will support them. Complete BS
Because she know she will get government money, it’s a steady check
@@Nevaeh1The child will still get it.
There's no L at the end of IDEA. It's idea. No idea. Education is a joke.
13:56 Doug!! Got Me Screaming 💀😂 🙌🏾 that man kills me!! Lol 😆
😂😂😅😅 DOUG IS SO DAMN SHADY, AND I LOVE HIM!!! HE AINT EVEN LOWKEY ABOUT IT EITHER…
Your house is terrible!! 😫😂🤣🤣🤣
DOUG!!! YOUR THE BEST!!! SAVAGE!!! OH I LOVE HIM
Doug ROASTED the defendant!!! Love it😂😂
How is it she had all that damage and not get a penny. What happened to rough justice 🤦🏽♀️
Because she lived there free for 6+ months so she already saved over $3,000 from with-holding rent.
so if you don’t save receipts and if you try to sue what day you’re out of luck ?? that makes no sense!
Iove it when Doug goes off on the wrongdoers at the end 😂
Haha, Doug went in on that slumlord lady HARD! 😂
Douglas is messy… lol
“Do you live there?”
“No”.
“I can see why” as he scoffs
Doug roasted tf out of her! 🤣😂 I cannot stand Judge Milian. Who keeps receipts for sheets and clothes? Be for real. That place was so bad, the defendant should've paid her to live there. Rent should've been reversed in this case.
JM must be the type of person who keeps receipts for everything and never throw them away. I don't keep any of my receipts.
You are on parole. He’s in jail. You are living in a dump. You are not paying rent. Now you are moving in with your mother. But hey let’s bring a baby into this mess.
Who keeps receipts for bed sheets it’s outlandish to ask for proof of bedsheet cost smh
True unless you buy it online
Everyone. Sheets have warranties
Ive started just getting electronics receipts. So that’s helpful
I think the plaintiff should’ve got something. The judge saw that that place was uninhabitable. The judge could’ve did some rough justice and gave her something!!
The plaintiff did get something. She isn't paying rent which the defendant would have won. But the defendant said she would let it go. The plaintiff DIDN'T have to pay back rent. That's her getting something
That landlord is disgusting as a person to keep saying “it’s not that bad” 🤦🏽♀️
That place is so disgusting 🤮
Shame on the landlord
The plaintiff was very forthright and honest. She did a fine job considering her circumstances of documents the unconscionable conditions under which she was living. She is on parole and bound to stay in a specific location. She is pregnant. Clearly she lacks the means to move or I am sure being pregnant she would have. As typical, Milian exhibited her bias throughout the case. No one has receipts for sheets. I am sure Milian herself doesn’t either. The plaintiff’s photos clearly document a situation that is not habitable. In many other cases where Milian favors the plaintiff she would have played her game of ‘rough justice’ but not here.
“I gotta tell you it’s that bad. It’s even worse than that!” Lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Harvey's "He hardly knew her" bit is old and cringe at this point. 😂😂
Mice Traps, Constant Leakage, Falling Sheetrock, when you're a victim of having a criminal rap sheet, it severely limits your living options, SMH- SLUM VILLAGE 4 REAL 😮😮
"Victim of having a rap sheet" is an oxymoron. You choose to have a rap sheet.
The ONLY victim is the person who she hurt in order to get a conviction. She chose to commit a crime. Whatever happens is her fault
I know people can change but she's not a victim.
@@lookatyou5809 Before the wordplay game becomes a huge distortion to the point of my comment , everyone convicted of a criminal acts are not always 100% guilty, people are set-up in this country, ALL THE TIME , SMH 😠
@@Aceofwolves Actually two victims, the other is that baby she was about to bring into her poverty-filled dysfunctional life.
This place should be condemned..
“It is that bad…it’s even worse than that” why is Doug like this??😂😂😂😂
I can’t believe the judge ruled entirely for the defendant! I wouldn’t pay to live there under those conditions either.
😂 “it’s not that bad” it is that bad…. It’s even worse 😂
I love Doug! "It is that bad"😆
This show reminds me to keep all receipts
Im a landllord and this is bad . You need to take care of your property
I couldn’t believe that she would let her property get like that. That’s an investment…just a shame
Doug is hilarious!!!! love him❤
In my experience Landlords that rent rooms are the worse. They abuse the needy
I agree
The judge was wrong with the ruling. Although the plaintiff didn't have a $3,000 she definitely should of gotten something. I would have given her $500 for the property in $1,000 for emotional distress. Especially if she had to go to a hospital because of sheet rock falling on her head. Also the amounts the plaintiff was asking for was beyond reasonable. As long as she had proof that damage actually occured to her items she should of been award. Proof does always mean showing receipts for items brought a year ago but also involves proving it's more likely than not that the damage actually occur and it it dictates the amounts she was asking for which the plaintiff did. The house was move in livable condition that's why the landlord was suing for rent because she would of never been awarded it and she knows that.
That might have been the most desperate "He hardly knew her!" joke yet!
Not gonna lie, I'm surprised the plaintiff didn't get a token "rough justice" amount, that room was brutal!
These 'he hardly knew her jokes are ridiculous. Like, seriously... 🙄
@@michelehemlokhexwhite4310Amen. Got tired of them ten years ago!
No matter the case lol. He bought a junk car he hardly knew her 😂
I cringe every time they use that “he hardly knew her” joke. 😅
I was like how many times are they going to use this "He hardly knew her" tagline. This one was the absolute worse!!
Gotta love Doug for the reality checks! ALSO, for a landlord to see the conditions and say "It's not that bad"..... she shouldn't be able to rent out to people anymore.
I mean Doug was not letting up in that hallway😂😂😂😂. That was funny as hell😂😂😂
Renters insurance is $20 a month.. worth purchasing.
She has money to invest in her weave and outfit but doesn’t have money to invest into her property. “It has to be fixed”. Slum lord.
The defendant is a slum lord period and i hate when the judge asks for receipts most people do not keep receipts for clothes , bedding etc for a long period of time.
She knows that. She was going by the book on this plaintiff because she didn’t like her out the gate due to her not being well spoken, being on parole and pregnant and unwed to a guy in jail so instead of ruling on compassion and a little understanding just going off the video alone, she ruled out of bias and disgust for her lifestyle. Does it all the time. She could’ve awarded her something just based off the conditions of the place and the broken radiator with water spouting out the top of it.
Well you should have renters insurance
😂😂 Doug Dragged Both of them at the end 😂😂
Idk what the judge does but I don’t keep receipts for sheets, or sweat pants 🤦🏽♀️ this was a lousy ruling. And people on parole don’t get to be choosy
Shoutout to Doug!!!!!! Baby he READ HER FOR FILTH!!!!!!!
😂😂😂😂😂
Doug is so petty 😂😂 they may throw you out tomorrow night like what. Why are you saying that 😂😂😂
That leak is crazy ! Its not a drip ...its a down pour
Now why is she pregnant knowing her financial situation is what it is smdh.
They like the act of reproducing just not the responsibility.
Maybe the state she lives in requires her to have the baby by law.
Welcome to a post Roe v Wade world. So much more of these cases will come with women and families that can't afford to leave state to end an unwanted pregnancy. Not to mention those women dying from non-viable pregnancy that can't be aborted.
If women had proper healthcare and families got childcare, life would change in the US.
Please don't blame the woman.
Some dude got her pregnant. I don't see him here.
@@Tony_417EXACTLY. This is probably an older case, but your comment is exactly my sentiment (see above)!)
@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 soooo, it's the guy's fault that she is pregnant? No, ma'am, we're not gonna put it all on him. Women want to scream "my body, my choice" That also applies to PREVENTING pregnancy. Take care of your body then, too. Birth control is an actual thing. It's not 100%, we all know that, but it's damn close of you use it consistently. Those repeatedly getting pregnant just don't want to be bothered. That dude isn't going to do a thing for her or that baby and here we are with another preventable burden on tax payers. Don't try to make her some victim of the guy "getting" her pregnant...oh, please Smh
I love Doug!! 😂😂😂😂
Landlord is a clown and won’t put a penny into fixing the property
How old is she where she still needs to depend on her mom but is pregnant?
Doug is a riot... Its even worse than that lmbo. He ain't lying .
I love Doug 😂😂
Can't wash out black mold
Doug is a savage 😂
Love him😂😂
Dougggg you better read her 🤣
Doug is really good at insulting the parties in the wrong . He does it with such precision. Love it!
I mean oh so precise, lol
Bf is on parole and she is on parole. And she is pregnant. Good going. 😂😂😂😂
Yeah it is that bad😂😂😂
Doug was NOT playing with her ass 😭😂😂😂😂😂😂 when he asked her did she live there & she said no, that mfer holler IM NOT SURPRISED!!! 😭😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 i am CRYINGGGGG
“It’s that bad, it’s even worse than that” got me SCREAMIN 😂😂😂
Doug should have used "Locked Up and They Wont Let Me Out" as the case title!!!
Jm did her wrong! That apartment was horrible!
Doug is such a riot!!! I just love his reactions 😂
Good job Doug that place
is more then bad . She wouldn't live there her damn self smh