How Good Was Joe Montana Actually?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 852

  • @tshearn624
    @tshearn624 Рік тому +446

    You forgot one very important stat by Joe Montana. He never threw an interception in a Superbowl and never lost a Superbowl.

    • @jerryh1895
      @jerryh1895 Рік тому +6

      I can not wait for your mental gymnastics to explain why it is better to lose in the wild card game over losing a Superbowl.

    • @davenone7312
      @davenone7312 Рік тому +16

      @@jerryh1895 Much smaller Stage!!

    • @TravisMcGee151
      @TravisMcGee151 Рік тому +8

      @@jerryh1895Thank you Jerry. Montana won 4 Superbowls because he wasn’t good enough to get his team to 5. Brady got to…what 9-10 SB and came away with 7 rings. Not bad.

    • @ericross441
      @ericross441 Рік тому +18

      @@TravisMcGee151 He played twice as long, though lol

    • @jarrysciligo5395
      @jarrysciligo5395 Рік тому

      Tom Brady wouldn't have lasted two seasons in the 80s. If Dexter Manly didn't kill him Richard Dent would've. Or L Taylor.@@jerryh1895

  • @rsxfreak79
    @rsxfreak79 Рік тому +364

    Joe also played in an era where QBs were not protected as today.

    • @talmanes4589
      @talmanes4589 Рік тому +41

      Not just that, but overall the rules didn't favor the offense the way they do today.

    • @phonehomemahomes8831
      @phonehomemahomes8831 Рік тому +8

      Sure right

    • @davidfeltz8697
      @davidfeltz8697 Рік тому +24

      They were hunting for his head.

    • @cornonthecob1268
      @cornonthecob1268 Рік тому +4

      You got that right!

    • @TheMrlevelup
      @TheMrlevelup Рік тому +16

      I just watched the 1989 Super Bowl vs Bengals and he had like no time and it was intense. Straight trying to kill each other. This is a way different game. He ran for his life.

  • @myz06rocks
    @myz06rocks Рік тому +179

    4 SB wins, no losses and not even an INT in the big game. If I have to win, I’m taking Joe. All day.

    • @Warmaker01
      @Warmaker01 Рік тому +8

      The "not even an INT" for the super bowl is a notable thing to me as a 49er fan. In the 2012 Super Bowl between the 49ers and Ravens, Colin Kaepernick threw a colossally bad pass that sailed way over Randy Moss, resulting in Ed Reed picking it off. Phil Sims was one of the commentators for the big game and made a devastating comment, something along the lines of:
      "Kaepernick became the first 49ers quarterback to throw an interception in the super bowl. Montana never threw any in 4 games. Steve Young none. They got championships."

    • @myz06rocks
      @myz06rocks Рік тому +2

      @@Warmaker01 the facts speak for themselves don’t they. I’m definitely not a Shanahan fan but out of all the remaining teams, I’d like to see the 9ers take this one.

    • @marckellough529
      @marckellough529 Рік тому +1

      Well tell me how come he didn't make it to TEN Superbowls like Tom Brady?????

    • @myz06rocks
      @myz06rocks Рік тому +2

      @@marckellough529 I’m talking about Joe and why I’d take 100% success in the Super Bowl. Go back to the stats that matter to you and be happy.

    • @marckellough529
      @marckellough529 Рік тому +1

      @@myz06rocks The stats that really matter is 10 Superbowl appearances and 7 Superbowl rings both of which is more than any player in NFL history!! That's what really matters

  • @ericross441
    @ericross441 Рік тому +50

    I'm old enough to remember watching Joe play. It was like nothing you can describe. He was so smooth, so accurate and threw such a precise, catchable ball. To me, he's the best ever.

    • @defiverr4697
      @defiverr4697 11 місяців тому +6

      I stopped watching football after he left the sport. No one has done what he accomplished in the same given time frame of ten years. One and only on the summit.

    • @jscharleston7963
      @jscharleston7963 8 місяців тому

      First time I heard of Joe was watching the Clemson-ND game in Death Valley and Joe lead ND to a 4th quarter come from behind win. A stone cold killer on the field.

    • @PaulZink-k8d
      @PaulZink-k8d 4 місяці тому

      Exactly,and that's what people just don't get.

  • @themoneymovers
    @themoneymovers Рік тому +153

    He still is the greatest of all time. If I can pick one QB with the game on the line. It's Joe... hands down!!!

    • @terryporche9059
      @terryporche9059 11 місяців тому +1

      Joe was only as great as his receivers. A qb is great IF he has great receivers. His receivers and back has to have good hands.

    • @XIIICypherIIIX
      @XIIICypherIIIX 11 місяців тому +7

      @@terryporche9059 There's a Video on here of Joe's 50 best plays or something like that. Joe almost always put the ball in the easiest place for his receiver, while at the same time putting out of reach for defenders. His accuracy was just unreal. He also didn't have Jerry Rice or any real "elite" receivers during his first two super bowl runs.

    • @rayfinkle9369
      @rayfinkle9369 11 місяців тому +4

      @@terryporche9059 Joe had JJ Birden and Willie Davis as his WRs when he took the Chiefs to the Championship Game in 93.

    • @spartan6005
      @spartan6005 11 місяців тому

      If 58 where is his day it would have been over with that field goal

    • @elbowgang9715
      @elbowgang9715 10 місяців тому +5

      ​@@terryporche9059Joe had 2 super bowls before Jerry was even drafted. Have a seat ma'am

  • @Largecanyondog
    @Largecanyondog Рік тому +27

    Joe Montana is the embodiment of everything a winner should aspire to be.

  • @Emily_Paris
    @Emily_Paris Рік тому +60

    Joe Montana is my favorite QB of all time. I’ve been a 49er faithful since the 80’s, my children grew up watching 49ers (of course) and are also die-hard 49er fans and now my grandchildren. So being 49er fan in my family goes from generation to generation. It all started with watching Montana those many years ago.
    Faithful to the bay!!
    Let’s go Niners!!!!

    • @blacksheep_edge1412
      @blacksheep_edge1412 Рік тому +3

      Red & Gold until I'm dead and cold. Let's go faithful!

    • @OGmikeDtw5xL
      @OGmikeDtw5xL 11 місяців тому

      Hope you win at least
      The bowl stay in California and not with with Kielce and swift, hate it. Don’t like the niners but I prefer their red over kc

  • @johnkawash9950
    @johnkawash9950 Рік тому +56

    I will always remember when he made the comeback against Philadelphia. 4 touchdowns in the 4th quarter. I had move to Philadelphia from SF and was hearing slot of scrap but he came back and busted them up!!! Forever the greatest

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  Рік тому +2

      Neat memory John. Thank you for sharing!

    • @wingracer1614
      @wingracer1614 Рік тому +2

      Similarly the game that cemented Joe as my GOAT was another comeback, this time as a Chief against Buddy Ryan's Oilers in the playoffs. The oilers absolutely dominated the first half making Joe look old and washed up. He came out in the second half and just picked them apart. It was one of the most impressive dismantlings of a good defense I have ever seen

    • @nickamalfitano3613
      @nickamalfitano3613 5 місяців тому

      Eric Allen?

  • @wizard1687
    @wizard1687 Рік тому +103

    I'm still taking Montana as my GOAT QB

    • @ttestagr
      @ttestagr Рік тому +3

      Same. Brady struggles when dealing with defenses pressuring him and got beat twice in the Superbowl in an era that protects both QBs and WRs. Montana in this era would terrorize the NFL like no one has ever seen.

    • @XIIICypherIIIX
      @XIIICypherIIIX 11 місяців тому +6

      @@ttestagr With today's rules, and a prime Montana in this era, he's be the most feared QB in the entire league. He would OWN every defense he'd go up against, because there'd be no fear of getting demolished by a linebacker like in the 80's.

    • @kevinb3307
      @kevinb3307 11 місяців тому

      Of course you are, brady could of won another 2 or 3 and you would say the same thing. Why:
      Because you are a bias, idiot Niner fan.
      -Panthers fan.

    • @柒拾柒
      @柒拾柒 10 місяців тому

      Joe is goat

    • @susanrodriquez3757
      @susanrodriquez3757 5 місяців тому

      @@XIIICypherIIIXAll time great linebackers like Lawrence Taylor put the fear of God in every Quarterback when they came at them. Joe Montana was unfortunate enough to play during the age of the Linebacker/DE where there was little protection for QBs. Boy did he get lit up quite a lot too. Today it is simply not the same. You used to see body bag games where all the quarterbacks were taken out on stretchers from fearsome pass rushers (it was not a completely uncommon occurrence).
      Now there is simply too much money going around to see franchise quarterbacks get absolutely mauled like they did in the past and the league has shifted from favoring defense to gaudy offensive statistics and higher scores.

  • @robertbyrne6027
    @robertbyrne6027 Рік тому +31

    Joe is my favourite player of all time. Watching him cut the Dolphins apart in Super Bowl XIX is my favourite memory. But the run in 89 when he dropped 41 on the leagues no.1 Defense in the Vikings. Then 30 on the Rams. Then 55 in the Super Bowl against the no1 Defense in the AFC was magical. Don’t care about “GOATS” Joe is my favourite football player of my lifetime

  • @johnharris6655
    @johnharris6655 Рік тому +40

    In an era when Quarterbacks are getting their player's hurt, Jerry Rice said there were a lot of times where I thought I was open and Joe threw the ball to someone else. I was mad until I watched the film and a LB or safety was waiting to light me up.

    • @sasquatchhunter86
      @sasquatchhunter86 Рік тому +6

      Very important. Headhunting was no joke back then!

    • @shinjukucalling763
      @shinjukucalling763 11 місяців тому

      WR really are some of the most annoying human beings in history

    • @susanrodriquez3757
      @susanrodriquez3757 5 місяців тому +2

      Joe Montana protected his receivers on the field and his offensive line in public and in the media. You would often see clips of guys like Lynn Swann get knocked out cold making shoe string catches being hung out dry. He once mentioned he was envious of the fact that Montana protected his receivers so well and that he never would’ve needed to make those catches putting his health at risk if he had a guy like Montana as his quarterback. My son once met Lynn at Serra High school when he was a Sophomore (along with Barry Bonds and Tom Brady). They came by to talk to the football team and my son told me this. It was a great compliment for Joe coming from an eventual hall of fame receiver on a completely different Steelers team whose heyday was in the 70s.

  • @williamrodriguez7551
    @williamrodriguez7551 11 місяців тому +7

    Joe Montana Was Is And Always Will Be The Best Quarterback Ever In This And Or Any Lifetime To Play Football And Be On The Field May God Bless Him

  • @chicagodude8888
    @chicagodude8888 Рік тому +42

    In 4 Super Bowls, he went 4-0 completing 83/122 for 1163 yards 11 touchdowns to 0 ints and a 128.6 passer rating.

    • @genosim63
      @genosim63 Рік тому +3

      I'm forever a huge Montana fan and at 60 so lucky to have seen it directly. But to actually see those stats along with all the memories is just another level upon the foundation of the greatest all around QB. No disrespect to Brady, and I'm born n bred Bostonian, but with all else equal I take Joe over anyone. And naturally who was Brady's idol. 🤨😉 👍

    • @chicagodude8888
      @chicagodude8888 Рік тому +1

      @@genosim63 You root for a team 3.1k miles across the country over your hometown Patriots or are you a Patriots fan who love Joe Montana? I can’t imagine deriving satisfaction over a team from another city winning a Super Bowl.
      Even as a fan of the loser bears.

    • @genosim63
      @genosim63 Рік тому

      @@chicagodude8888
      I am a hometown fan. But when it was Montana in Superbowls I was all in for Joe. Just like I've been a big Patrick Mahomes Jr fan since his Texas Tech days. 👍

    • @chicagodude8888
      @chicagodude8888 Рік тому

      @@genosim63 So a Pats fan that appreciates greatness? Same here although I’d think Brady would be your guy not only with his ring count but doing so with your hometown Pats. I rooted for Peyton, he was my guy growing up, Pats and now Chiefs. Everyone hates “I’m sick of him/then winning”, what fun is a league without any distinguishing greatness and dynasties? Peyton had 2005, 2009 and 2012, one more ring where he isn’t carries by his defense and I’d give him the GOAT nod when we’re talking 7 all pros and 5 MVPS from 2003-13 while missing an entire season. If it were pre salary cap era or he’d taken Brady like pay cuts history might be different.
      Too bad his first superbowl win was vs the Bears.
      Another reason to appreciate Boston sports dominance winning 12 championships and 19 championship trips. I was too young to appreciate the Bulls dynasty, I hate the Whitesox so the Hawks and Cubs are all I have to stand on.

    • @genosim63
      @genosim63 Рік тому

      @@chicagodude8888
      WOW. You made a lot of points that are spot on! I've always thought Walter was the best all around RB that I have ever personally seen. And yes we've been very fortunate in Boston. After some lean years but then it came together! Was really happy for the Cubs finally breaking through. Caught a DH at Wrigley in the early 90s. What a great park, town and people. 👍👍👍

  • @courtneykelley516
    @courtneykelley516 Рік тому +13

    Growing up in the Bay it wasn't until later in life I realized how good he actually was. I would just expect our QB to casually win even in late/impossible situations,and in an era where the position wasn't coddled. Now when I look back I consider myself lucky to have grown up in the Bay and watch every game on local TV

  • @Tuck7326
    @Tuck7326 Рік тому +139

    Joe was and still is the best qb of all time. Even Brady would agree.

    • @LEBUMCHOKEDIN6FINALS
      @LEBUMCHOKEDIN6FINALS Рік тому +5

      Yup Montana was his idol

    • @Mncrr
      @Mncrr Рік тому +4

      Montana was a great basketball player too. Very athletic. Brady had a good not great arm and the body of a soccer dad. His thing was his football smarts

    • @TravisMcGee151
      @TravisMcGee151 Рік тому

      @@MncrrBrady heads and shoulders above Montana. Manning head and shoulders above Joe also. Montana not in the top 5.

    • @Mncrr
      @Mncrr Рік тому

      @@TravisMcGee151 I don’t put Brady at top though. He played for a great coach and always had a great line. Had 5.1 speed and the muscle of a soccer dad. Rated an average arm but had football instincts and intelligence second to none. I actually think manning was greater and if jimmy Johnson stayed at cowboys we might be talking aikman right there too not to mention Roger’s and Bree’s.

    • @bartsullivan4866
      @bartsullivan4866 Рік тому +4

      I agree if Jerry hadn't sacked Jimmy they probably would have won 1 or 2 more. Its hard to top Brady's record but he played in an era of powder puff football where if anyone even got 5 yards close to him he would cry like a baby for the ref to throw a flag. Joe was the opposite never whined and complained in an era where you could beat the living daylights out of a quarterback. I wouldn't want Brady or Joe to have the ball late in any ballgame though or Elway for that matter. @@Mncrr

  • @anthonyseal9832
    @anthonyseal9832 Рік тому +28

    Yeah when you think of joe you think of perfection like the 1972 miami dolphins, also rocky marciano being undefeated and don larsen perfect game in a world series game. Joe is 4 for 4 in superbowls with 11 touchdown passes 0 interceptions in those 4 games, which is insanity.

  • @logiclust
    @logiclust Рік тому +48

    GOAT. few today could take the punishment joe took

    • @marckellough529
      @marckellough529 11 місяців тому +1

      Why do you want to pretend that Montana was the the only quarterback that was getting hit hard.There were plenty of quarterbacks from that era who were getting hit just like Montana and they weren't always hurt like him. You're just using his era to justify the established fact that Montana was a fragile, brittle and injury prone quarterback so you can stop that excuse

  • @alfonsogomezfariasreynoso489
    @alfonsogomezfariasreynoso489 Рік тому +8

    The thing about Joe Montana was that, while he was on the field, you never feeled without a chance to win. He made you believe. He had that magic, and that is the rarest of talents. That is why he will forever be considered one of the greatest

  • @DanielFrost21
    @DanielFrost21 Рік тому +115

    If Montana and Brady came out of college at the same time, I'd pick Joe.

    • @joemamma137
      @joemamma137 Рік тому +9

      Joe took more hits in an average season than Brady took in his whole career.

    • @devmag52
      @devmag52 Рік тому +6

      @@joemamma137 totally. Whenever Tom took hits, his productivity nosedived

    • @ronaldharding3927
      @ronaldharding3927 11 місяців тому +2

      Brady played with a soft ball. His team liked to cheat.

    • @seasidescott
      @seasidescott 11 місяців тому +2

      I get your point on physicality but Joe was Brady's idol and I think he was the next iteration, took it farther with bigger comebacks than Joe ever managed. I got the same feeling watching the Superbowl where the Pats were down so much as I got watching Joe when I was a kid: "He's gonna do it, no question" and the Niners found a way.

    • @chrischapel9165
      @chrischapel9165 11 місяців тому

      Yeah you would and, you would obviously lose

  • @emerald3331
    @emerald3331 11 місяців тому +9

    It’s unbelievable how many comeback performances he was involved in.

  • @abadigital8
    @abadigital8 Рік тому +8

    Great video. I was lucky enough to be born into a Northern California family who were die hard 49ers fans. I was also lucky enough to be a 49er fan during the 80s! It was so amazing. I remember never panicking when they were losing with just a couple minutes left. Montana was the 2minute master. He would start throwing 10-15 yard. to John Taylor or Jerry Rice. I remember Jerry dragging the tips of his toes in bounds before going out of bounds. Then the clock would stop after every play !And a lot of the time they weren’t huge plays. I was just a kid, but I remember Montana (or “Big Sky” as my dad referred to him) just eating up the clock w/ these precision plays that 10-15-a twenty here and there. That’s how he would chew away the other teams lead.
    That being said, he was a master of the clock! What a cool thing to watch him as I grew up.
    He was so amazing. And he looked so fragile out there!!
    But he was freaking machine! ThT would be a cool video….. the theme of Montana getting the ball with less than 2 minutes to go. The fat lady was gargling salt water!!

  • @kevindelacruz_100
    @kevindelacruz_100 Рік тому +4

    The way he threw the ball & how perfect the spiral was it was nothing I’ve ever seen before so accurate & precise he was smooth i loved watching how cool he was too

  • @r.williamcomm7693
    @r.williamcomm7693 Рік тому +31

    Understand that this video is working with limited time but it’s missing the historical aspects of understanding the dominance of NFC which won every SB from the 1984 through 1996 seasons. The 49ers played VICIOUS NFC defenses & Montana was hurt in massive hits at times. With today’s rules in the 1980’s the 49ers might’ve won 5-8 Super Bowls. Montana NEVER threw an INT in a Super Bowl. 2 strike seasons marred the 1980s. Joe Cool was the first Tom Brady even though they ran different offenses. Montana was an assassin w/ice in his veins.

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  Рік тому +4

      Important take. Thank you for sharing that Mr. Williams.

    • @r.williamcomm7693
      @r.williamcomm7693 Рік тому +1

      @@thehalftimeshow Best wishes w/your channel. You make excellent videos. Film & content making is an art & you’re finding your voice. Enjoy.

    • @williamwarner9829
      @williamwarner9829 Рік тому

      Man, stop with the “he played in the stronger NFC” business. He also played in what was arguably the weakest division in the NFL. Folks back then tried to do the opposite you are doing and degrade him for that.
      None of that matters. Like the players themselves say, you play the teams on the schedule. That’s that. They don’t control what teams they play or when. They still have to perform.

    • @r.williamcomm7693
      @r.williamcomm7693 Рік тому +2

      @@williamwarner9829 Watch him getting hit by Jim Burt in 1986, then remember the 1985 Bears who went 15-1, add in TWO strike seasons & then watch Joe get hit playing the 1990 Giants in the NFC CG. The AFC teams got BLOWN OUT for over a decade. The real Super Bowl was the NFC CG in those years (1984-1996). Montana getting to & winning 4 SBs is amazing for the 1980s. I still have great respect for other QBs like Elway, Kelly, & Marino. They got hit just as hard. The Bills were 4 wins away from being the greatest team ever. Joe Cool just had a way about him that I always admired. He’s one of the greatest at getting it done when it mattered most.

    • @williamwarner9829
      @williamwarner9829 Рік тому +1

      @@r.williamcomm7693
      Nice response there. Too bad it doesn’t address my comment at all.
      The point I made was that people should stop trying to degrade players or teams because they played in a weak division or conference. They all had to play all the teams eventually over that span (as they do today) and literally none of them were or are safe from the hardest players out there.
      The great players and teams aren’t defined by the strength or weakness of the teams they play, they are defined by what they do on the field no matter who they are playing against.
      We all know how great Joe was. Especially those of us who were alive to watch him. Folks need to stop trying to falsely mystify the road he took there.

  • @benjohnson5363
    @benjohnson5363 Рік тому +9

    I can't believe people have to even ask that question today. The man is Legend, okay! 4 Super Bowl Rings with NO INT'S!! Nobody can match that or hope to, period!! 🏆🏆🏆🏆

    • @wingracer1614
      @wingracer1614 Рік тому +1

      And it's kinda surprising since Joe did throw a lot of interceptions over his career but never when it mattered most.

  • @mattprescott7458
    @mattprescott7458 Рік тому +19

    He is still the greatest of all time.

  • @snsdkbopper7819
    @snsdkbopper7819 Рік тому +19

    It could be a generational thing, But Joe Montana will likely always be my favorite quarterback of all time.

  • @candlestick1231
    @candlestick1231 5 місяців тому +1

    The thing is he had bad games, 0 TDs and 3 INTs type games, but he had some insanely impressive games, superman efficiency, and he's 4-0 with no turnovers in Super Bowls. Joe Montana was a special player. The only thing missing is more Super Bowl rings which he would have got if he stayed healthy and played longer.

  • @RobertMichael
    @RobertMichael Рік тому +16

    So basically the greatest

  • @scott6828
    @scott6828 Рік тому +8

    Montana played in a completely different NFL...hitting and tackling were a part of the game in those days.

  • @MarkKrauklis
    @MarkKrauklis 11 місяців тому +2

    I'm 72 years old and NOT a 49ers fan.🥰 Joe Montana is one of the top 3 quarterbacks that I have seen play in my lifetime! 🥰🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

  • @Dan-qz8do
    @Dan-qz8do Рік тому +7

    The reason i became a fan in the early 80's

  • @AxlKhan-v1f
    @AxlKhan-v1f 11 місяців тому +3

    If I want anybody to save my life to deliver a clutch play in any given time when the heat 🔥 is on. Its absolutely, positively the one and only Joe Cool. There is Simply no-one better. Its Montana and Daylights second.

  • @ASportsLife
    @ASportsLife 11 місяців тому +1

    Great video and good content just a FYI at the 7:28 mark it say he throws for 28 TDs and 10 TDs but I think you meant interception - keep up the good work

  • @richardandaya3932
    @richardandaya3932 Рік тому +12

    He was known as, “Cool Joe”. And there’s a landmark in Washington called the House White.

    • @ChrisH421
      @ChrisH421 Рік тому

      Glad I'm not the only one who heard that

  • @adamlee3892
    @adamlee3892 Рік тому +1

    It’s was Joe Cool. Great video man for someone so young.

  • @LamontYvon
    @LamontYvon 10 місяців тому +2

    I went shark diving with Joe and a film crew twice! Right after the SB. True story

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  8 місяців тому

      That's incredible. Talk about a memory!!!

  • @Sublette217
    @Sublette217 11 місяців тому +2

    Clemson hosted Notre Dame in 1977, pitting two future NFL QBs against each other - Steve Fuller and Joe Montana. I marched in Tiger Band and the stadium secretly engaged in a Quiet Out before the game because of coach Dan Devine writing the ACC that week griping about crowd noise - and the stadium went from dead quiet to EXPLOSION on the pedal note of Tiger Rag. Despite valiant Clemson efforts, Montana prevailed in the fourth quarter.
    My favorite college band memory.

  • @Capital_Ideas1
    @Capital_Ideas1 10 місяців тому +1

    Montana had an aura I've never seen another player have. It was supreme calm and assurance.

  • @josantonioalcantara
    @josantonioalcantara Рік тому +9

    For me, he is the GOAT. If I had to pick between him and Brady to win a game, I wouldn’t hesitate to choose Joe. I don’t question how good Brady was and I bear in mind this is a team sport, BUT nobody talks about Vinatieri when the GOAT discussions pop. Joe led his teams to comebacks or blowouts against two historic QBs. He’s the finisher by definition, pure Joe, no kicker needed

  • @gregjohnson7270
    @gregjohnson7270 11 місяців тому +1

    I've been a lifetime KC Chiefs fan but always enjoyed watching Joe Montana play with the 49ers, he always did amazing things on the field and is definitely one of the greatest QBs ever.

  • @darthvirgin7157
    @darthvirgin7157 Рік тому +3

    people today don’t realize that the FIRST two Superbowl wins by Joe were WITHOUT the great Jerry Rice.
    and it could be argued that Joe’s stats actually improved when Jerry Rice joined the team. but then Jerry also benefited from having two of the greatest 49er QBs ever.

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  Рік тому

      Excellent point!

    • @Duck_Dodgers
      @Duck_Dodgers Рік тому

      Young isn't even close to being one of the greatest! People forget about John Taylor and how good the 49ers defense actually was

  • @healey714
    @healey714 11 місяців тому +1

    I got the pleasure of watching most of his career, those 49er teams were so fun to watch. Joe will always be my QB GOAT.

  • @paparazziphotography6712
    @paparazziphotography6712 Рік тому +1

    Well done, & thanks for the "BIG TIME" memories! Mr. Hop..

  • @JS-ty3od
    @JS-ty3od 5 місяців тому +1

    The greatest! What a pleasure to watch play when I was growing up ❤️

  • @jamalmarsh2617
    @jamalmarsh2617 Рік тому +4

    Joe is the reason I love football to this day

  • @JesseAflleje
    @JesseAflleje Рік тому +4

    He is the reason I became a Chiefs Fan. Grew up in CA so I was a 49ers fan…but followed him to KC and have been a KC fan since. Loved watching him play

  • @TerrenceHowlett
    @TerrenceHowlett 11 місяців тому +7

    Greatest ever Quarterback in American football history

  • @timothyjohnson148
    @timothyjohnson148 5 місяців тому +2

    His elbow injury was during the 91 preseason; not related to the hit from 90 championship game

  • @juliojaquez6211
    @juliojaquez6211 Рік тому +27

    It’s not about how may Super Bowl rings you have…( Brady)….it’s about how you play those fabulous unforgettable beautiful games!!!!
    Forever Joe Montana fan …. Cool Joe
    The Greatest EVERRRRR
    I watched all his games… winning or losing were a fabulous games…
    I missed those NFL football games!!
    Not today’s craps!

    • @WALKINGPHONE
      @WALKINGPHONE Рік тому +4

      using the number of SBs won to say that one QB is better than another... that places Dilfer or Flacco or Dough Williams or Jeff Hostetler as better QBs than Dan Marino and that is blasphemy...
      Yes, Brady is the QB with the most SB rings, but Montana is a QB in a chemically pure state
      If Montana had played with the QB protection rules that protected Brady and if Joe had played 23 seasons because of it... his numbers would be monstrous

    • @marckellough529
      @marckellough529 Рік тому

      Did you honestly just say It's not about how many rings you have?? You got to be kidding?? You're just saying that because Brady has almost twice as many rings as Montana. I guarantee you if it was Montana with 7 rings and Brady with 4 you wouldn't be saying that. DON'T MAKE ME LAUGH OF COURSE IT'S ABOUT WHO HAS THE MOST RINGS!!!

    • @WALKINGPHONE
      @WALKINGPHONE Рік тому +2

      @@marckellough529 Based on your same argument, prove me that Eli Manning, by having two SB rings, is a better QB than Brett Favre or Steve Young who only have one, or prove to me that Trent Dilfer whit one ring is better than Dan Marino who does not have a single one, but I don't want a speech, I want a sports analysis

    • @juliojaquez6211
      @juliojaquez6211 Рік тому

      @@marckellough529 it’s about the quality of a game player…Montana never lost a superbowl or have an interception!!!

    • @marckellough529
      @marckellough529 Рік тому

      ​@@WALKINGPHONEThat has nothing to do with the fact that Brady has 7 which is more than any team in History. You can play around with the facts about one or even two rings but you can't explain away SEVEN!!! By the way Marino is overrated and he didn't play that great in the playoffs anyway

  • @HusamSimaan
    @HusamSimaan 11 місяців тому +2

    Once he joined KC and took them far, he shut down all speculation that he was a system QB. He WAS what made the system work.Just ask Jerry Rice and the other 49ers on offense.

  • @robbycatalina226
    @robbycatalina226 Рік тому +8

    I don’t think that there’s an argument about Rice being the best WR the NFL has ever seen.

    • @wingracer1614
      @wingracer1614 Рік тому

      The most talented I have ever seen was Moss but Rice was a true football player with nearly as much talent. Rice is the GOAT

  • @Au60schild
    @Au60schild Рік тому +3

    Joe Montana was so good that there wasn't anyone talented enough who could push him to the limits of his abilities.

  • @SmokinZen
    @SmokinZen Рік тому +1

    This is why I was a niner fan in the 80s once he left I became a cowboy fan after losing in the playoffs since 1996 I am going back to my old team

  • @davenone7312
    @davenone7312 Рік тому +5

    QB's today would never have lasted as long as they have if they played in Joe's time. Their position is extremely protected nowadays! In Joe's daze of playing, the QB was a regular player when it came to tackling and hitting. They took a sheer beating game after game!

  • @TALKINGtac0
    @TALKINGtac0 11 місяців тому +4

    Hate when people compare Brady and Montana to see who was better. Two different QBs from two completely different eras. Montana played at a time when you could hit QBs as hard as you wanted to. They were no more protected than a running back. He also didn't play as long as Brady. Not gonna knock on Brady's accomplishments, he did what he did because he's a good QB plain and simple. But he's not Montana, and Montana isn't Brady.

  • @tphillips37
    @tphillips37 5 місяців тому +2

    Montana is still the greatest of all time. He didn't play with the QB protective rules Brady did.

  • @rosedavila3547
    @rosedavila3547 Рік тому +8

    Cool Joe was the best in his era the game changed n it was a hard hitting game back then they called Ronnie Lott the hit man 4 a reason

  • @juliorodriguez4954
    @juliorodriguez4954 11 місяців тому +1

    There’s something you forgotten about Joe. Even at his worst games, improved and adapted his playing style. Something very rare in today’s game.

  • @jacktheripoff1888
    @jacktheripoff1888 Рік тому +6

    By 1986 some were starting to say his best days had passed. He had by then 2 SB rings and MVP's with them, so a damn good career to reflect on many thought. In '86 he had surgery on his back and some thought he'd never play again. He comes back mid-season, gets Frisco in the playoffs, and then just gets plastered on the Giants Stadium turf. Now Young is brought to Frisco because that may be it for Joe. But SB's in '88 and '89 and a great '90 season. But then comes more playoff pain courtesy of the Giants, Joe gets laid out again. He's out for almost 2 years, comes back, becomes a Cheif and 2 more postseason appearances with them. When he retired in '95 it was generally accepted that he was in fact the most prolific QB the NFL ever had.

    • @wingracer1614
      @wingracer1614 Рік тому

      His dismantling of Buddy Ryan's defense as a chief against the Oilers in the playoffs is one of the most impressive performances I have ever seen from a QB

  • @williamvalentine4858
    @williamvalentine4858 5 місяців тому +2

    If Montana was playing in today's game with today's rules and medical technology, Montana would have won 10 superbowls!

  • @aaronburtram3175
    @aaronburtram3175 11 місяців тому

    From the games I watched, he was a master at looking off defenders and going the other way. And it helped that he had receivers with excellent hands, and a decent running game to boot.

  • @richardc751
    @richardc751 11 місяців тому +1

    He will always be golden Joe he is a winner and an outstanding athlete he made you rude for the 49ers without him. They were just a team with him they were champions he is without a doubt one of the best quarterbacks ever played the game.

  • @realmackle
    @realmackle Рік тому +2

    I feel like with a superteam marino, montana, and brady all have a case for them. All incredible talents.

  • @Jayfromphilly
    @Jayfromphilly 7 місяців тому +1

    Although I’m die hard Eagles fan but this is amazing Joe Montana moment week 3 1989 season Eagles vs 49ers Eagles dominated for 3 quarters of that game Joe Montana led an epic comeback and defeated my birds 38-28

  • @thinkcivil1627
    @thinkcivil1627 9 місяців тому

    As a long-time Packers fan, having watched Bart Starr, and both Favre and Rodgers, Joe Montana will always be in my top 5 quarterbacks of all time.

  • @stephanvalkyser3186
    @stephanvalkyser3186 11 місяців тому +1

    They even named a state after him.
    That’s how good he was.

  • @michaelgarza8271
    @michaelgarza8271 11 місяців тому +2

    He's the greatest quarterback I ever saw.

  • @davidfeltz8697
    @davidfeltz8697 Рік тому +11

    One of the smartest players. Difficult tk quantify this guy. He just had some rare magicsl mystical talent. Soooo tough and soooo fun to watch.

  • @michaelh2791
    @michaelh2791 Рік тому +3

    Joe will always be my all time pick at QB!

  • @riikkaalanen3429
    @riikkaalanen3429 Рік тому +2

    Notre Dame were the NCAA Champions in Montana’s junior year !

  • @SXP3RN0VA
    @SXP3RN0VA Рік тому +9

    Better than anyone.

  • @albertmartinez3368
    @albertmartinez3368 Рік тому +1

    Joe Montana has always been my fooyball hero . . .

  • @ErrolDAllen
    @ErrolDAllen 6 місяців тому +1

    "Black 59 razor!! Montana called this audible in the Super Bowl against the Bengals when he saw the safeties up and outside the hashmarks, Rice ran a post and was wide open for a touchdown.

  • @beatnikbytes
    @beatnikbytes 11 місяців тому +3

    He is tied with Terry Bradshaw for 4-0 in the SB and Bradshaw did it before Joe did. Terry did it in an era that was even meaner than the one Joe was in and he did it in 6 years exactly like Joe would follow. So really Bradshaw is the OG GOAT who was followed by Joe and those 2 are tied at the same exact level while Brady is 7-10 in the SB and with a full 3 more SBs and not to mention 6 more appearances than the other 2 GOATS that defaults Brady to the one true GOAT. But don't forget Bradshaw, he did it before Joe or Brady and he did it exactly like Joe and Joe is tied with him but Terry is the OG. And there were less teams then which means that you had to play the same teams more often and it was a lot tougher to win due to that. That era was extremely brutal even more so than Joe's era.

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  11 місяців тому

      Really great take. No one gives Terry much respect on the goat level.

  • @shruggzdastr8-facedclown
    @shruggzdastr8-facedclown Рік тому +2

    If you haven't already made a video on arguably the NFL's greatest quarterback prior to Joe Montana, Johnny Unitas, please do so. Like Montana (as well as Jets' Super Bowl-winning QB, Joe Namath, and Dan Marino, amongst other NFL QB greats), he was born and raised in Western Pa.

    • @Duck_Dodgers
      @Duck_Dodgers Рік тому

      Namath had what 3 good good yrs

    • @shruggzdastr8-facedclown
      @shruggzdastr8-facedclown Рік тому

      @@Duck_Dodgers: I referenced him bc of his being from the same part of the country as Montana (and other NFL QB legends) -- not for addressing his longevity, or lack thereof

  • @Eddieavina123
    @Eddieavina123 Рік тому +1

    First, hi, love your video The Halftime Show and keep up the great work

  • @nickamalfitano3613
    @nickamalfitano3613 5 місяців тому +3

    The real GOAT

  • @MarkEnriquez1971
    @MarkEnriquez1971 11 місяців тому +1

    Joe Montana is the best all around QB of all time. He was 4-0 in the SB, zero interceptions, and on 3rd and 8 he’d run for the 1st down if no one was open. He had it all.

  • @ClarkBeattie14
    @ClarkBeattie14 9 місяців тому +1

    I appreciate "grace" in athletics. It's why I enjoyed watching Ted Williams and Will Clark's batting strokes, Klay Thompson's shooting stroke and Muhammed Ali in his prime. Joe was the epitome of grace at QB. Watch some of his videos. It's poetry in motion.

  • @rickyholmes-r6z
    @rickyholmes-r6z 5 місяців тому

    to me he will always be the best to take the field . No matter what the situation he's the quarterback I would want in my backfield. Take care Joe

  • @Bhill-jo2wg
    @Bhill-jo2wg Рік тому +3

    Montana played football when it was a contact Sport unlike most of Bradys career. Joe = GOAT

  • @penguinrea0088
    @penguinrea0088 Рік тому +3

    Keep up your fantastic videos, all of The Glory goes to King Jesus

  • @theRealtensigh
    @theRealtensigh 8 місяців тому

    My greatest Montana memory was a Monday night football game against the Rams. The 49ers blew it in the first quarter, and the Rams took an early and really big lead. Over the course of the game, the 49ers whittled them down. John Taylor had to 90+ yard touchdowns in that same game.

  • @AlanSenzaki
    @AlanSenzaki Рік тому +3

    Joe is the GOAT!!😮

  • @idatrails3925
    @idatrails3925 Рік тому

    Quarterbacks of yesteryear were a different breed. They played with very little protection from "roughing". These dudes would get lit up every single time.

  • @thud9797
    @thud9797 9 місяців тому +1

    In the famous 1981 Championship game against Dallas, Montana had thrown three interceptions before the famous "catch." But he still won it. 😀

    • @josedopwell9645
      @josedopwell9645 5 місяців тому

      The game that changed the fate of two franchises. Dallas lost 3 consecutive NFC title games and slowly deteriorated. The 49ers went on to win 4 Super Bowls in the 80s.

  • @Gio-ue8ps
    @Gio-ue8ps 11 місяців тому

    I’m glad many people in the comments understand how different the nfl is today from back in the day. It was much more physical. Hits today that are illegal were all legal & fair game. There was no targeting or other rules etc

  • @dondajulah4168
    @dondajulah4168 Рік тому +6

    “Steve McBerg” LMAO. You have a shot right there with his name on the back of his jersey and you manage to screw it up.

  • @moeball740
    @moeball740 Рік тому +2

    What isn't mentioned about the Notre Dame win over Houston - I believe the narrator says that Notre Dame came from behind to win 35-34, but that doesn't begin to tell the real story. I believe at one point Houston was ahead 34-12 but then Montana led Notre Dame on a 22-0 run to pull off a miracle win!

    • @MikeyD22
      @MikeyD22 11 місяців тому +1

      On top of that Montana was horribly sick the entire game.

    • @josephciccolini1590
      @josephciccolini1590 11 місяців тому

      People forget that he also had big fourth quarter comebacks against Pittsburgh (trailed 17-7, won 26-17) and Southern California (trailed 24-6, brought them to a 25-24 lead before losing on a last second field goal).
      He has established himself as a comeback QB long before the Cotton Bowl.

  • @ianwestc
    @ianwestc Рік тому +2

    For me, Joe Montana's SB success is like Madison Bumgarner's World Series success. Yeah, Bum lost a division series game, but when it came to the World Series, the point where it matters most, he was cool, dominant, and the best who ever played. Same attributes go to Joe Cool.

  • @ronnie_5150
    @ronnie_5150 9 місяців тому +1

    The Al Pacino character in "Scarface" Tony Montana was named after Joe, as screenplay writer Oliver Stone was a big Joe Montana fan.

  • @stuisaac249
    @stuisaac249 11 місяців тому

    Went to high school with Montana! A phenomenal athlete!

  • @Luke-pk9fe
    @Luke-pk9fe Рік тому +5

    Best team leader ever.

    • @devmag52
      @devmag52 Рік тому

      “Hey, isn’t that John Candy over there?”
      Classic Joe Cool.

    • @paysonfox88
      @paysonfox88 11 місяців тому

      Rodger Staubach has entered the chat 😮
      He led men in battle during live firefights in Vietnam, and then let men to several super bowls in the NFL.
      Talk to me when Joe Montana had bullets flying over his head in life combat. Then tell me he's a real leader of men.

  • @mashokaise6881
    @mashokaise6881 Рік тому +1

    As a Giants fan who grew up in the 80's, Montana (and Rice) were absolutely scary--he could surgically cut through your defense at any time, and he could really take a hit. After seeing the Leonard Marshall hit live, I never expected Joe to get up, or even move, but he did--one tough SOB! Joe is a titanium tumbler compared to the over-priced china QB's today.

  • @johnweber7960
    @johnweber7960 Рік тому +2

    I was in basic training in the army when I watched the 1st SB win... totally awesome

  • @dioniciotorres4290
    @dioniciotorres4290 Рік тому +2

    I was there for Clark's the catch, I thought Montana was throwing it away til Clark picked it out of the clouds...😮😮😮👍👍👍

    • @thehalftimeshow
      @thehalftimeshow  Рік тому +1

      Wow, talk about an experience. That must've been legendary and an incredibly fun day.

    • @dioniciotorres4290
      @dioniciotorres4290 Рік тому

      @@thehalftimeshow yeah some amazing memories at candlestick. Funny I've been to so many games at candlestick I lost count but I've never been to Levi's stadium. Definitely on my bucket list. Go Niners!!!!

  • @markthompson7093
    @markthompson7093 8 місяців тому

    Acouple things that need to be said, he was also a very elusive running QB, he could shred a defense with his feet. Also, he had an intangible team leader component that is hard to put in words. He had a genius coach in Bill Walsh as well.

  • @pita388
    @pita388 9 місяців тому +1

    Joe did this in a time when "protecting the QB rules" were a joke if they existed at all. Some of the greatest defensive hits/plays from back then would be ejections and finds today. He would have a lot more rings if he wasn't clobbered from the blindside in a hit that today would be illegal. If you had to win a game, life on the line, you choose Montana.

  • @danieljohnson5726
    @danieljohnson5726 11 місяців тому

    Joe Montana was the Steve McQueen of the NFL. He was Joe Cool! He was also a modest QB, who attributed his success to his receivers, ie Jerry Rice that helped him look good. Just after Desert Storm I sent Joe a patch I had worn, along with a card & self addressed envelope. About 6 months later I received the card in the mail, post marked San Francisico. It was signed in a blue ballpoint pin, but I didn’t care. I did get a chance to see the 49ers vs Saints at a Monday Night game, 1995 (?) in N.O. Joe didn’t play, but Steve Young put on a clinic. Joe is still one of the best QB’s ever.

  • @shruggzdastr8-facedclown
    @shruggzdastr8-facedclown Рік тому

    An important thing for people now too young to have witnessed Joe Montana playing the quarterback position in real-time and not in retrospect decades later now that a few generations of players have metriculated in and out of the League since when he retired, when assessing his G.O.A.T. status against Tom Brady (who, incidentally grew up in California and was a die-hard '49ers fan and idolized Montana), is that he accumulated his completion, yardage and touchdown stats all during an era when defenses were allowed to play a lot rougher against QBs and their receivers than they are these days.