Saylor in the previous years was arguably one of the best hitters in the league. I don’t know what happened but he just looked like a total different player
As a preds fan, Kracht is great obviously but I feel like overall Knorp is the best player in the MLW. It’s hard to justify picking ANYONE over Knorp. If you had a redraft of the MLW Knorp would 100% be the first overall pick. His impact in all 3 phases of the game make him so valuable.
Honestly it’s hard to disagree on that, the only thing is that Kracht pitching is slightly better and his hitting was a lot better this year. However, if your picking someone to lead a team, then 100% it’s Knorp
Man, I love this video. I love that you made it. It’s what we need. I’m going to give one criticism that’s also a compliment. You are great at baseball metrics… which is also a problem to me. Advanced metrics need a full baseball season to make sense. I love looking at stats, but with the number pitches and at bats you need waaaay more eye test. This is a clutch league. If you have 10 bad at bats to 1 walk off hit you are a .100 hitter but your WAR passes the eye test. Thanks for your effort.
Sorry to respond to myself but the point I was trying to make is that in such a short season A LOT of these stats come in games that are already over. Not a lot of impact on wins.
Thanks for your support! But one thing I look for a lot is consistency, and how consistent you can be at producing for your team. I’d love to take credit for the metrics, but that’s all Sean’s work. His links are in the description if you wanna check him out lol
amazing video, my second time watching it. ik it’s not much data but I’d love to see a follow up of big drops and improvements, as well as reviews of the new guys after slate 3 :)
Great video! I’m a Mallards fan so I really hope Kolm and Carlington especially get more time and develop. Davenport is unfortunately probably the odd man out at this point :(
I think your list is really really sound from an analytical standpoint! Like other ppl have mentioned, I am concerned about small sample size and volatility and how cold and hot stretches can essentially last an entire season, but I agree that consistency is what matters the most.
I do think Sawyer, Jonah Heath, and Blade are too low on your list (I keep my own list throughout the season and I had them in the teens) but other than that I was pretty spot on agreeing with everything. Awesome video!
Thanks! I definitely see where ur coming from with pitching. However, it depends on how you value like a tier 3-4 pitcher vs a tier 2 hitter which can be evaluated in many different ways.
For a list about the top players going into 2024 I really wish there was more appreciation on players trending upwards. Maybe you could do a video about where you think everyone will rank next year? Cool video with more people would make mlw vids
I try to do a little projecting, but I try to balance it out between 2023 and projecting for 2024. I could do a video about players that are looking to take the next step forward.
Crazy how the guy least known in the draft turns into the 3rd best, and became arguably the best hitter on his team. Pyszka gonna be a stud for years to come.
I need ur MLw playoff prediction before all star break I’ve got mallards and predators in the World Series and I think Robles might take it home what r ur opinions
As a preds fan, I’m happy to see Behen go out of conference. With that being said, I do actually think the gators are a threat again. I thought it was another bailout, but both Behen and Drew being on the pod makes me believe this was actually real. Jorgy really stepped it up last season, and I think Behen is going to bring some energy to that squad. I think literally everybody on that team is going to do way better than 2023 (I mean, it’s hard not do better.)
And the cobras traded for the 40th best player in exchange for the 23rd best player There must be something we don’t know because this is a horrible trade
Might be a bias magic fan, but I would put Aigner a little higher than 33. His average wasn't good, but the power is there, and he can definitely fit as a 3rd bat for the magic in my opinion. If he goes into 2024 with the same fixed swing, I think he'll do way better. I would also switch Chadwick and Carlington.
I’d like to see a bit more consistency from Aigner, but he definitely outperformed my expectations. I could see him higher if he continues. With Matt over Chaddy, honestly it’s more that I just see a higher upside with him and I like his OBP capabilities a bit more. I would love to see Chaddy return to form tho
@@eck.sports I do agree that Aigner wasn't too consistent, but Caden Irwin played in 6 games throughout the regular season, while Aigner played in 14, and I think Aigner should have been higher, just for showing up.
He can't pitch, he can't field, he can't run bases/get an extra base, he can't hit contact for a high average, and he can't draw a lot of walks. Decent power is literally the ONLY thing he has going for him out of like 6+ attributes you'd want in a wiffleball player. I think 30ish is plenty fair.
I also think 13 is wayyyyyy too high for Warda. I value people who are able to be passable on the mound more so Sawyer, Cheetam and others I have higher
Agree with Kracht being 1 … he’s pitching is elite. I get it. But Grant Miller is far and away the best player in the league. That team won the series because of him. And you got to put Walgate as 3. Those two carried the Magic.
Jimmy is the best player in the MLW. Been in the league for longer all the awards only team to win back to back championships. He wasn’t at his best hitting this year but was still a dominant pitcher crazy he isn’t 2 or 1 on the list. He’s like a one man show carrying that team. But Ryan is also very good only player in my mind even close to as good as jimmy
I definitely thought it was a W for the Gators, but Behen/Baran didn’t work together since they have very similar skill sets and clearly there’s an issue with Behen/Drew so idk. Also I think it’s good that Szerlag gets a change of scenery.
Calling Szerlag the worst manager is crazy. He has a WS ring, he may not have been the Gators best player, but he made the move to draft both Jorgy and Cheetam. He then had the self awareness to step away from managing (after this video was made) when he realized the Gators weren’t going anywhere right after he traded himself to the Cobras to play for the actual worst manager in Drew Davis, for Sawyer Behen so the Gators could have an ace.
@@eck.sports Bennett hasn’t done anything in his career and Ackerman literally just won World Series MVP also what has Jacob Pychka done to be that high
@@MatthewShapiro1006 Pyszka hit very well when he played, but i'd agrue Bennett is better at getting on base and providing for the team. We'll see how they do next year tho.
Solid, but I don’t see how RJ could be over Knorp/Grant/Robles considering that he was a rookie and only pitched. Grant only hit, but was miles better than everyone else while RJ was very comparable to Dallas and Kracht.
Any thoughts on the list?
quality list
Some small changes I would make but overall very well done!
I didn’t like the baranoski pick at 21 bringing up his 2022 stats and year is like going back in the past anyway good video 👍
Where was Jacob Pska
@@johnfawaz3498#16
Saylor in the previous years was arguably one of the best hitters in the league. I don’t know what happened but he just looked like a total different player
I’m really hoping he can bounce back this year considering he would’ve been a top 5 player the two years before
It’s his swing he changed it significantly
He was taking massive hacks the entire season he had flashes of his former self but it seemed like he was putting a lot of pressure on himself
I think I remember the boys on pipe it up saying that he’s done with baseball and that messed him up? I could be wrong. Saylor will be back I believe.
This last video where he played the D-Backs shows that he is definitely back
As a preds fan, Kracht is great obviously but I feel like overall Knorp is the best player in the MLW. It’s hard to justify picking ANYONE over Knorp. If you had a redraft of the MLW Knorp would 100% be the first overall pick. His impact in all 3 phases of the game make him so valuable.
Honestly it’s hard to disagree on that, the only thing is that Kracht pitching is slightly better and his hitting was a lot better this year. However, if your picking someone to lead a team, then 100% it’s Knorp
Knorp had a down year last year.
Kracht is still the best. Knorpp is #2, but Kracht is the best overall player.
Dude he just spent a bidei justifyingqhy kratch is 1
Kracht is way better at pitching
Man, I love this video. I love that you made it. It’s what we need.
I’m going to give one criticism that’s also a compliment. You are great at baseball metrics… which is also a problem to me.
Advanced metrics need a full baseball season to make sense. I love looking at stats, but with the number pitches and at bats you need waaaay more eye test.
This is a clutch league. If you have 10 bad at bats to 1 walk off hit you are a .100 hitter but your WAR passes the eye test.
Thanks for your effort.
Sorry to respond to myself but the point I was trying to make is that in such a short season A LOT of these stats come in games that are already over. Not a lot of impact on wins.
Thanks for your support! But one thing I look for a lot is consistency, and how consistent you can be at producing for your team. I’d love to take credit for the metrics, but that’s all Sean’s work. His links are in the description if you wanna check him out lol
amazing video, my second time watching it. ik it’s not much data but I’d love to see a follow up of big drops and improvements, as well as reviews of the new guys after slate 3 :)
Great video! I’m a Mallards fan so I really hope Kolm and Carlington especially get more time and develop. Davenport is unfortunately probably the odd man out at this point :(
Yeah that’s what I’m thinking as well
I think your list is really really sound from an analytical standpoint! Like other ppl have mentioned, I am concerned about small sample size and volatility and how cold and hot stretches can essentially last an entire season, but I agree that consistency is what matters the most.
Yeah honestly that is a good point, since the season isn't that long a bad stretch can really affect your season.
I do think Sawyer, Jonah Heath, and Blade are too low on your list (I keep my own list throughout the season and I had them in the teens) but other than that I was pretty spot on agreeing with everything. Awesome video!
Thanks! I definitely see where ur coming from with pitching. However, it depends on how you value like a tier 3-4 pitcher vs a tier 2 hitter which can be evaluated in many different ways.
5. Jimmy Knorp
4. Dallas Allen
3. Jordan Robles
2. Grant Miller
1. Ryan Kratch
Those 5 are very interchangeable fs
Now this is the perfect top 5.
Grant Miller is so overrated
The Knorpinator is too low imo
Knorpy is def the best overall player hands down
Great rankings and commentary!
Thanks!
For a list about the top players going into 2024 I really wish there was more appreciation on players trending upwards. Maybe you could do a video about where you think everyone will rank next year? Cool video with more people would make mlw vids
I try to do a little projecting, but I try to balance it out between 2023 and projecting for 2024. I could do a video about players that are looking to take the next step forward.
Wow very high on Jakob Pyszka! Let's see if he can keep the numbers up and make a run into the top 10!
Crazy how the guy least known in the draft turns into the 3rd best, and became arguably the best hitter on his team. Pyszka gonna be a stud for years to come.
Great vid!
I enjoyed this!
Awesome!
I need ur MLw playoff prediction before all star break I’ve got mallards and predators in the World Series and I think Robles might take it home what r ur opinions
@@impacted.2010 I should have some mid season predictions
Based on how his current season is going were do you think andy durand would go on this list?
He's probably around 10
Great vid ECK!
Thanks Jake!
As a preds fan, I’m happy to see Behen go out of conference. With that being said, I do actually think the gators are a threat again. I thought it was another bailout, but both Behen and Drew being on the pod makes me believe this was actually real. Jorgy really stepped it up last season, and I think Behen is going to bring some energy to that squad. I think literally everybody on that team is going to do way better than 2023 (I mean, it’s hard not do better.)
If Cheetam can go back to his elite ways, and Chaddy can at least be a solid contact guy then I could definitely see it.
And the cobras traded for the 40th best player in exchange for the 23rd best player
There must be something we don’t know because this is a horrible trade
It’s crazy
@@eck.sportsso know we know why…
Shoutout pipeituppodcast
Either They forced Drew to do this or the Cobras just didn’t like Sawyer as a person. Truly no other explanation.
Loved the video 🔥🔥
Might need a lil colab in the future👀
👀
Grant Miller stats are crazy......
Easily the best hitter in the league
great vid
Thanks!
Great Video Eck
Thanks!
Might be a bias magic fan, but I would put Aigner a little higher than 33. His average wasn't good, but the power is there, and he can definitely fit as a 3rd bat for the magic in my opinion. If he goes into 2024 with the same fixed swing, I think he'll do way better.
I would also switch Chadwick and Carlington.
I’d like to see a bit more consistency from Aigner, but he definitely outperformed my expectations. I could see him higher if he continues. With Matt over Chaddy, honestly it’s more that I just see a higher upside with him and I like his OBP capabilities a bit more. I would love to see Chaddy return to form tho
@@eck.sports I do agree that Aigner wasn't too consistent, but Caden Irwin played in 6 games throughout the regular season, while Aigner played in 14, and I think Aigner should have been higher, just for showing up.
He can't pitch, he can't field, he can't run bases/get an extra base, he can't hit contact for a high average, and he can't draw a lot of walks. Decent power is literally the ONLY thing he has going for him out of like 6+ attributes you'd want in a wiffleball player. I think 30ish is plenty fair.
W video like always
thanks!
Bonham statistically was pretty nutty although he didn’t pitch THAT much. I actually had him just outside top 10.
if it was just based on this year, he would prolly be top 10. I'd love to see him repeat this years success!
🔥 I’m bouta be top 10 on this list in the next few years
👀
Appreciate the love 🙌
Gonna be a great 2024 🔥
I don’t agree Jaxon so high but other than that this list is incredibly accurate and a lot of time was put in here
Thanks! Jaxen def has a lot to prove this szn tho
I also think 13 is wayyyyyy too high for Warda. I value people who are able to be passable on the mound more so Sawyer, Cheetam and others I have higher
I’ve also voted for Robles for MVP the last two years…he’s just like top 5 in all 3 aspects
Agree with Kracht being 1 … he’s pitching is elite. I get it. But Grant Miller is far and away the best player in the league. That team won the series because of him. And you got to put Walgate as 3. Those two carried the Magic.
This is kinda wild seeing szerlag after the trade.
Szerlags been great this year
Banger video
Thanks!
JIMMIE NORP IS #1
Hes not on MLW this season? Think i seen he switched to blitzball.. hope hes back
@@oksoonershe’s doing both
Jimmy is the best player in the MLW. Been in the league for longer all the awards only team to win back to back championships. He wasn’t at his best hitting this year but was still a dominant pitcher crazy he isn’t 2 or 1 on the list. He’s like a one man show carrying that team. But Ryan is also very good only player in my mind even close to as good as jimmy
What do you think about the behen trade?
I definitely thought it was a W for the Gators, but Behen/Baran didn’t work together since they have very similar skill sets and clearly there’s an issue with Behen/Drew so idk. Also I think it’s good that Szerlag gets a change of scenery.
Great video!! Always a banger with ECKSports!
Thanks Pat!
Calling Szerlag the worst manager is crazy. He has a WS ring, he may not have been the Gators best player, but he made the move to draft both Jorgy and Cheetam. He then had the self awareness to step away from managing (after this video was made) when he realized the Gators weren’t going anywhere right after he traded himself to the Cobras to play for the actual worst manager in Drew Davis, for Sawyer Behen so the Gators could have an ace.
No WOBA on the stat line? Come on now…
surprised youtube hasn't taken down the video yet 😂
I feel like Rudy isn’t overrated. I feel like we all know who he is. But that end of the regular season was very promising. I guess we’ll see.
Preston going crazy right now
why did there yt grt deleted
They’ve gotten hacked like 3 times
Only critique is that Landon might be a spot too high, I can definitely understand why you would think he is 10.
I flip flopped between jaxen and Landon a lot
I’m 100% taking Ackerman>Bennett and Heath
they are pretty close, but a lot of that is recency bias imo. I def see where ur coming from tho.
@@eck.sports Bennett hasn’t done anything in his career and Ackerman literally just won World Series MVP also what has Jacob Pychka done to be that high
@@MatthewShapiro1006 Pyszka hit very well when he played, but i'd agrue Bennett is better at getting on base and providing for the team. We'll see how they do next year tho.
Where’s Andy Durand
Didn’t know he’d be playing this year at the time of recording
Ryan Kacht is so great but he may need a trade. He needs to win a championship.
Preds might have a chance soon 👀
@@eck.sports We have been waiting for that team to do something.
Imagine kracht Dallas and Jimmy on the same team do they win world series or no.
Easily
Jimmy Knorp is the Beast and the Best”
Why ? Because Knorp wins every alley
Fight in MLW or every UFC fight at the Meadows 😂😂
😂
Heath at 26 is crazy
Do you think any rookies from 2024 will crack into the top 20-15.
I’m sure there will prolly be at least 2 that do
@@eck.sports do you have any idea who will be on draft boards this year?
@@ndftball_ I’ll have a mock draft on my Instagram soon
@@eck.sportssweet
this is sad, major league wiffleball?
Tommy is top 5 Forsure
Tommy being a one-way player makes it tough for him to be top 5
Cmon jimmy on ltop
Jimmy is #2
anyone who wears batting gloves for wiffle ball should be outside of the top 40.... just sayin...
good point 😂
Kyle over some of these guys is insane
still a very good two-way player imo
As a preds fan, I'm tired of watching rudy ramirez strike out in big moments. he should def be lower
No way in hell should Whalen be that high
No way Chris Cheetam over Dan that’s so dumb Dan is a great fielder and he had 4 homers in the 2nd half this year
Dan was bottom 3 in the main 3 metrics this year for fielding (it’s on Sean’s spreadsheets btw), but I really think Cheetam will bounce back
What were the metrics for fielding
@@maxsmlwchannel efficiency, success%, d-war and d-run value
Ok that’s cool hopefully Dan improves if u couldn’t tell he’s my favorite player Go Eagles 🦅 Hopefully the knuckle drop comes back
@@maxsmlwchannel it’s a better league when Dan is playing well fs
michael schema is retiring 😥
Tuff
Thanks Niko! Can’t wait for that recap 👀
@@eck.sports yessir, on that grind fr
Behen is a gator
1. Kracht
2. Dallas
3. RJ
4. Knorp
5. Grant
Yes, as a Mallard fan I didn’t put TC3 or Robles up there. But, one of them is definitely a Top 10 player
Solid, but I don’t see how RJ could be over Knorp/Grant/Robles considering that he was a rookie and only pitched. Grant only hit, but was miles better than everyone else while RJ was very comparable to Dallas and Kracht.
@@eck.sports As a Mallard fan Robles is way too high. #8 at best
Szerlag is too high
Aigner is incredibly low rated on here. He is a top 25 player or at least 30. Def better than some guys above him like Caden Irwin or nick sailor.
And Aigner is better than kolm, Chaddy, carlington, Ackerman, and Casey Bennett.
Casey and Ackerman had much better seasons statistically and Aigner is very inconsistent and strikes out way too much
Perez Robert Thomas Dorothy Young Edward
Heath is way above league average fielder
this year according to Sean's metrics, he was pretty above to slightly above average. In years past he's been elite tho.
Awesome vid ECK!
Thanks!