Leave A *LIKE* & *SUBSCRIBE* 👉 Button ua-cam.com/users/TheReelRejects - *Full Reaction* Watch Along & MORE For *SS* Rejects: www.patreon.com/thereelrejects - Follow Us On Socials: instagram.com/reelrejects/ www.tiktok.com/@thereelrejects?lang=en
@ReelRejects You guys have no idea what you're missing out! PLEASE watch HBO Max's The Sopranos! The main protagonist, Tony Soprano, the Boss of the New Jersey Mafia, is the G.O.A.T. gangster!
Director Helen Shaver needs to be given not only an Emmy but give her her choice of ANY future movie or tv show she wants to direct. It was such a brilliant move to have Sofia’s story start off in this bright and colorful charity event, then get darker and drained of color as they’re inside Arkham Asylum, and then have this gorgeous warm sunlight follow Sofia as she’s walking through the mansion past the bodies of all of her treacherous family.
@@shxtatstuffdid you not like the pacing of this episode? I really enjoyed it; the only scene that felt a little 🤏 difficult to read dramatically was the morning after when Sofia wakes up at Dr.Rush’s place
@@shxtatstuff go do better sweetie, i bet you definitely can't lol, why don't you sit down and shut it, it will be better for you, more useful than thinking you have anything meaningful to say, you don't
Agreed, and on top of that, make it believable. Not for a second I felt this went too fast. From being normal, to distressed and trapped, to accepting her fate, to planning the future, to becoming hangman. How the fuck did that even happen. Brilliant.
@@nealcaffrey541 between the mushrooms and the gas, she could be Poison Ivy? That's one thing about this show is waiting for the reveal of characters' "villain names".
FOR REAL. I thought it couldn't get any better after last episode but holy shit they did it. This episode was perfect. Idk how I'm going to feel about Penguin going forward tho.
this has been the weakest episode, because it has some issues: - I don't buy that carmine would offer her that position with she being so innocent at this point. - "if you were looking out for me you would've talked to me!" yeah he tried that and you told him to shut up, that he's just a driver... - The "you have a dick" comment falls a little flat when her father is talking about "breaking with tradition! and giving her the reigns. but i get it: they wanted to rush some of this because it is not the focus of the show; still a great villain origin story: though I thought by the end she would've embreaced the "hangman" name and hang some of the men in her familiy that have betrayed her
@@larrote6467 The "you have a dick" line is BEFORE her father even says that to her, if you want to talk about inconsistencies at least stay consistent within your own argument
The penguin is so damn good that at 9 I always stop watching the Sunday night nfl game no matter who plays or the score to just watch the penguin on time .
Just give Cristin Milioti the goddamn Emmy right now! She already had my vote for the first 3 episodes alone, but now I’m gonna root as fiercely for Cristin like I did for Anna Sawai for Shogun.
She gets pissed off at Oz for going to Carmine instead of talking to her even though he LITERALLY tries to talk to her about it in the car and she says he's just a driver, she doesn't want advice from a driver, no one wants anything from a driver.
What an episode ! Now we know why Sophia loves her brother so much, we know why Penguin didn't hesitate betraying Sophia, why that betrayal meant even more to Sophia. Next level writing and connecting the dots !
It looked to me like Oswald did not want to hurt Sofia but that was the direction he was going. He genuinely felt angry at her arrest but he adapts and backstabbing is his thing anyway.
Her brother wasn't a bad guy, he was even trying to stay clean. Don't forget penguin convinced him to drink which led to the drugs and then he killed him
Eh...he DEFINITELY was a BAD BAD dude...first off he didn't CARE that his father was a mobster that was also a serial killer...just that he framed his sister...he also was not only a bad addict but wanted to make everyone else the same plus he treated Oz like GARBAGE and got shot as a result.
Final shot of the series: Oz standing over either Sophia or Victor's grave at their funeral holding an umbrella in the rain, having now finally ascended to the boss.
Since Oz arguably gets unfairly blamed and subsequently awarded for “informing” on Sofia, I think Oz gets more invested in Vic and ends up giving him up to some criminal charges to shirk suspicions from himself
Would be such a waste to only have her in the series and not in the Batman upcoming movie 😮💨 horrible idea I just honestly rather have oz dyong a Vic taking over, would be far more unpredictable because everyone expecting him to survive
@@Insertmewtwoquote we already know oz wins and becomes the kingpin in the end ,some people already saw the whole season the question is will vic and sofia survive?
Man I’ve been locked up. I used to be quite wild with the substance abuse. When you go in, wherever it is, you officially become less than human. At one point I was fully convinced that animals in the clinic are treated better than life on the inside. Clean and sober now for 6 years and 3 months. Got out of prison in 2019. It’s something that changed me like forever. Forever. She nails it. Brutal.
This episode was another masterpiece in storytelling. I can’t remember the last time that I so wanted an actor to win an Emmy. Cristin Miloti is brilliant. Is it crazy that if she ends up killing his mom that I may not be mad about it?
Summer Gleason from Batman: The Animated Series and Sofia Falcone's arc with her going through what she went through in Arkham Asylum is just crazy. It had that Luke Cage feel to it with her trying to prove her innocence in front of Julian Rush and he realizes she is innocent and cares for her.
Also we got to see the same actor who portrayed Kinsey in The Batman return in this episode appearing in Sofia Falcone's flashback. Sticking to continuity so perfectly. Also the whole Club 44 below the Iceberg Lounge and how all the women died under the hands of Carmine Falcone being revisited during the events of The Batman is explained so well.
this episode shows how no matter how much bad things Oz do to these people they all deserve it, Sofia isn't any better than her family, and Alberto definitely had it coming
This episode also shows how Oz can never be trusted and will turn on ANYONE in order to serve his own interests. I was sympathetic to Oz until this episode. Now I want to see him fall and Sofia rise (wishful thinking)@@youssefheisenberg6410
Alberto deserved to DIE because he made Oz feel bad? What did Sofia do to “deserve” being locked away in Arkham for 10 years after being framed by her FATHER for crimes HE committed. Her father even murdered HER MOTHER.@@youssefheisenberg6410
Penguin also said earlier in the show one of the guys he drove for got caught talking to the feds and falcone killed him. Maybe he was trying to save her in his own way and it backfired massively.
Those final moments I was on the edge of my seat just trying to figure out how Sofia was gonna kill them…and was like “YES, GIRL…GET YOUR REVENGE!!!” (In that yellow dress at that..Sofia has arrived)😅🤭
I heard the name "Summer Gleeson," and I went "The reporter from Batman the Animated Series?! Nice." The majority of folks on twitter were saying "Just give Milioti the Emmy already," after watching *this* episode. Mark Strong did a good job in replacing John Turturro. Watching "The Batman" again, you understand *why* Riddler and Catwoman hate Carmine Falcone so much.
I’m surprised you guys didn’t catch on to falcone rather then it being Sofia. In the Batman he was strangling women he killed Selina’s mother and her friend. It’s been pretty obvious to me that it was always falcone who was the hangman haha.
Good grief just give Cristin Milioti the Emmy!!! I was shrieking in how disturbing this episode was. This is how you do a flashback episode. Not a waisted line of dialogue or frames. Ahhh it's just incredible!!!!
I mean its hyper stylized but also real ASF... they're constantly locking up sane people in asylums and jails and its EXTREMELY brutal how we treat criminals and crazies
Mark Strong was solid and definitely fits the classic comic book mobster role better, but I love the against the grain casting of Turturro in the movie, he felt so much slimier. Can't go wrong either way.
But did he really though? If he truly cared, he should have just kept his mouth shut and not said anything. But he didn’t. Penguin didn’t stay in his lane and he’s one of the reasons why she got locked away in the first place. Granted…. he may have not known what was gonna happen but again, it wouldn’t had been necessary if he didn’t snitch to Sophia’s father in the first place. Was Sophia a bit mean or harsh towards Oz? Oh yeah. I don’t deny that. But his actions isn’t an excuse. He was too ambitious for his own good.
I agree for the most part. He wanted to hurt her back after she called him just the driver. But I agree he never expected it to be taken so far, though he does not care about her.
@@rodgill9376Are you daft? He works for her father, who would kill him without hesitation if Oz kept this a secret. She literally told him he was worthless. Why would he confide with her? She just established that there was nothing between them.
@@blackmanwithcomputer she never said he was “worthless.” She said: “you’re just the driver.” Which that’s what he was. He told on her because he got his little feelings hurt and/or was too ambitious as I’ve already pointed out. Regardless of what was said, Oz is still a snitch. No different from his boss, whom do I need need to remind you was also a snitch as well? Takes a snitch to know a snitch, now doesn’t it?
@@rodgill9376 She said no one cares what he has to say. That he's only her driver. That's dehumanizing, and it severely clashed with her being nice to him earlier. To him, this was just her revealing how she actually sees him. Regardless, why should he protect her? He's just the driver, remember? She's not his friend. She made that very clear. If he kept this from Carmine, and Carmine found out, he's a dead man. Carmine was his boss, remember?
Was baffled not seeing John Turturro return as Falcone Sr, but holy shit was I equally joyful to quickly recognize Mark Strong. I’ve absolutely loved him in everything I’ve seen him in, as he is criminally underrated. To me both are amazing choices for the role, but it’s frustrating trying to be content with only one of them taking it now that there’s been a switch
The head of Arkham Dr. Ventriss later becomes Mirror man and I’m not sure but didn’t Magpie kill her mother in the comics before she became a villain? 🤔 so many great Easter eggs.
i'm not a big fan of the "insane asylum" cliches and it's a little tonally off for this show, but i thought this was hands down the best performance of the season so far for sure.
I love Alberto and Sofia’s sibling relationship; u can tell why Alberto’s death really really affected her; He had his problems, but he really cares for his sister; and the fact that he kept working with her for the new drug while she was still in Arkham; he didn’t take advantage of the situation, he loved her and wanted to cut her in; Just really nice writing 😢
That site seems like it’s always an outlier when it comes to reviews. Like, when it comes to a show or film that both critics and audiences collectively agree is amazing, they have to give it an average or below average rating.
My favorite episode yet and give her all the awards and I've never said about a actress or actor before in all of my 26 years of watching movies and tv.
I was wondering how they'd make Oz back into a villain after we've been following and rooting for him the entire series, but this gives us two/three paths forward. He'll kill one of either Vic or Sofia, or both.
I know this is a futile wish given The Penguin’s core position in Batman’s Rogue Gallery but in a perfect world, Sofia would exact ultimate and final vengeance on Oz for ratting her out to Carmine and killing Alberto. This episode made me do a complete 180 on Oz - especially seeing him turn on Sofia in front of the Maronis. Oz is the ultimate betrayer.
At the very least, he never expected the Arkham Asylum to happen. We’ve seen what happens when people hurt his ego, he hurts them back. He ratted her out though honestly I don’t think he ever knew how far it would be taken.
First he had no idea about the murders or what was going on in the family. He just knew about the reporter. Alberto insulted him, fair play. Oz being a backstabber shouldn't come as a shock. He is exactly that. That is what makes him such a unique protagonist. He is no Michael Corleone, he is Salvatore Tessio if Sal was wayy smarter.
Hes a survivalist...Whilst Sophia murdered a woman out of anger...the point is there are no good guys but Penguin is the lesser of these two but neither is a Saint and Oz did what lots of people would have done in that situation
Man those first 30+ minutes were rough. I get so sad watching people get abused emotionally and physically. But the PAYOFF! My lord this show is great!
Peguin is such a good series so far, especially with their characterizations. Like Penguin always does something dirty when someone disrespects him. The reason he betrayed Sophia is because she called him nothing but a driver and didn't care about his opinion. Those small details are so good to drive a series.
i think its also so good that we probably were all feining to see what happened with vic and Oz after last episode and they just throw this at us and we still love it
Definitely the best episode yet. By the 14 minute mark, I had a feeling she was going to get framed by her father and it happened. Once I saw the police while she was talking to Oz, I knew she was screwed. Sofia was innocent all along. Less blood on her hands than Oz. It’s similar to The Count of Monte Cristo where Dante gets framed for no reason and then a little bit of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in trying to make her go crazy in an asylum when she isn’t. I initially thought Magpie was Harley. I’m glad she got her payback against all her relatives who betrayed her. She wasted 10 years of life for nothing. Mark Strong did a good job but his Carmine Falcone felt a little too quiet and reserved compared to John Turturro’s version. Great ending song: “Strange Little Girl” by The Stranglers. Good show! Way better than Agatha All Along which I gave up on after Ep. 3. Cristin in that hot dress showing plenty of cleavage. She and Colin are the best parts to this show. 9/10 👍🏻
When Sophia sees Oz and says "what are you doing inside?" There's no vitriol or malice in her voice so I disagree entirely that she's talking to him,"like a dog." He's a driver, the drivers, in every mob or crime show/film ever made are always hanging out front by the cars. That's where they stay, by their cars. She was surprised that Oz was inside because it's entirely out of the ordinary and that obviously means something is amiss. That's all she's saying. Her momentary flash of anger at him when she's stressed about her dad didn't mark a change in her overall feelings for Oz, she was just pissed off about the reporter/her dad.
1000% agree. We have all had bad days, and lashed out to people we cared about. She treated Oz pretty well when everyone else was too busy making fun of him or calling him penguin. He was probably inside because he got a 'promotion' for being a rat. thats why the new jacket. When sofia said it looks good on you, and then walked into see her father, my gut flipped
this episode. this episode was just ... satisfying and suffocating at the same time. it was deliciously dark and i HONESTLY was so happy when she walked in with that gas mask on [and the choice of track was inspired]. i too hope she doesn't die. i'd love if [let's say the Maroni's are taken out], the city teeters constantly between Sophia's crew and Oswald's crew. and weirdly enough - just for giggles - i would NOT be mad if Dr. Julian Rush becomes this world's Scarecrow.
Protect Sofia at all costs. Blown away by Miloti since HIMYM and she transcends here. The empathy I feel for her on what she went through. I look at Penguin differently. Family got what they deserve. Falcone was down right monster and didn’t get enough suffering before and while he died from a single gun shot wound. Shame she needed Vito(sp?). Deserved it more than most.
THE PENGUIN🐧: Cristin Milioti is a masterful actress. An intense fourth episode in this journey of Oz in the decadent Gotham City of the Batverse🦇 by Matt Reeves. (DC/HBO/MAX)
Dude, is it just me or was it really obvious that she was framed. With her line to penguin last episode “I’m the hangman” and her reaction to the mom pulling her kid away from her. Ofc she was innocent. She did such a great job in conveying that
Penguin said to Vic not to believe everything he read in the papers about Sofia, so they'd been making it clear for a while that she wasn't her reputation.
Really obvious, but the nature of who blames whom for what that amounts to Sofia’s indictment/remanding to Arkham is the show, ESPECIALLY since her portrayal in the first (3) hours of the show, while disturbed, isn’t consistent with a serial perpetrator of lethal hangings regardless of what Gotham thinks We as the audience are shown a much more put together, psychologically composed character than the person carrying everyone’s projection of her
She and Oz had a literal conversation explaining that she was framed in the previous episode. I don't understand why it's being taken as a surprise at all.
I am vexed that Carmine never was held accountable for what he did to Sofia or to her mother or to all the women, for that matter. He got killed by someone who only cared about himself. Not that I am support murder. Just saying. Riddler took him out but was it really justice? I totally predicted that the trial will be cancelled. Why would they imprison her and traumatise her? Either that, or they were trying to make her crazy so that when the trial comes, she claims the blame herself. The fact that she endured the torture without giving in probably was the reason why the trial was cancelled.
Arkham Asylum needs to be condemned, and all the doctors (besides Rush) need to be locked up for life. I’ve seen Arkham Asylum in countless adaptations of movies, TV shows, video games and comics. But this is without question the darkest and most horrific version of Arkham ever made. It’s places like that that give countless people pause whenever they think of people who have been in mental hospitals or had mental health problems.
im not willing to give Rush a pass yet, dude seems like he has an agenda. be it romantic, or psychotic. We dont know if he got her out willingly. Might never find out.
How brilliant of Matt Reeves and the writers and producers to give the Penquin an antagonist that has more depth and character development than any other villian we've seen since Thanos.
Now, THIS is peak DC. Peak casting, peak directing, peak everything. And Cristin Milioti absolutely deserves all the awards, such a huge range. It's going to tear us apart the war between her and Penguin, I'm sure we're not ready. We're watching villains only the Batman universe could give us. I'm so happy we get to have that kind of show.
Amazing episode. I think e3 was the best episode so far imo but this is a close 2nd. Love the way this gave us context to so much from the first three eps.
I wanted to say props to how amazing Cristina millioti is in this role and also comment how much her storyline in this show reminds me of the warren white storyline in a serious house on a serious earth. Its one of the most intriguing gotham storys imo opinion and I'm thrilled that even if we're unlikely to ever get warren white himself in live action that the story of the "new fish" being driven insane is still a story that gets told in some form
Theres not many TV shows thats named after the signature character, that gives as much back story to a side character as they did in this one episode, its beautifully done, they didnt hold back either they made it feel raw. What a performance by all so far
I have a feeling, that her brother had to do something with those killings of all those woman. Maybe he did it. And I think, Penguin knows this. I think Sofia and the Pinguin will be friends again. ( I hope so )
Actually someone had to Rat her out before Oz went to Carmine. The reporter was strangled and Hung and it was done the same night Oz met with Carmine likely hours before.
Not saying he didn't go to Carmine and tell him but setting up another Hanging and getting Sophia framed would take more time than the minutes she spent talking to Carmine.@@Insertmewtwoquote
He likely went to tell Carmine but from the timeline things happened too fast. Summer died the police found her hung and Sophia was blamed only a half an hour later.@@Insertmewtwoquote
This is a universe I have fallen in love with. I hope DC capitalizes this and expands on this universe with the James Gunn. I doubt it'll happen but if it could...
Drivers wait with the car. Like Vic wouldn't be inside when Oz comes to the house. Sofia asking why he's inside is about her realizing he's not where he should be, followed by her seeing the new coat. She's realizing right then he's betrayed her.
I never expected this show to be as good as it is. I had hopes but really didnt believe it. Ive just watched this episode and it is LITERALLY one of the best episodes on TV ever
I just can't believe I am excitedly waiting for the next week after each episode. It has been so many years since the last time I was like this. Simply amazing.
Leave A *LIKE* & *SUBSCRIBE* 👉 Button ua-cam.com/users/TheReelRejects
- *Full Reaction* Watch Along & MORE For *SS* Rejects: www.patreon.com/thereelrejects
- Follow Us On Socials: instagram.com/reelrejects/
www.tiktok.com/@thereelrejects?lang=en
@ReelRejects
You guys have no idea what you're missing out! PLEASE watch HBO Max's The Sopranos! The main protagonist, Tony Soprano, the Boss of the New Jersey Mafia, is the G.O.A.T. gangster!
Sofia’s family gaslit her so she gassed them. It’s kind of poetic in way..
Yoooo - perfectly stated. Great callout!
Wow!! Awesome observation!!
They deserved it 😈💯
I read that in Sophia's voice
@LovelyJai23 you didn't watch it bro
We Riot If Cristin Milioti Doesn't Get An Emmy Nom!
ABSOFREAKINGLUTLY!!!
Agreeed
This show is top tiers....every Time im wondering how they Can keep the quality this time and they keep dropping peaks episodes After episodes
agreed
More 🐧 voice for the every clip 😆
Director Helen Shaver needs to be given not only an Emmy but give her her choice of ANY future movie or tv show she wants to direct. It was such a brilliant move to have Sofia’s story start off in this bright and colorful charity event, then get darker and drained of color as they’re inside Arkham Asylum, and then have this gorgeous warm sunlight follow Sofia as she’s walking through the mansion past the bodies of all of her treacherous family.
GREAT note! Really fantastic point re: Color
Massive shouts out!!
she can’t handle pacing to save her life
@@shxtatstuffdid you not like the pacing of this episode? I really enjoyed it; the only scene that felt a little 🤏 difficult to read dramatically was the morning after when Sofia wakes up at Dr.Rush’s place
@@shxtatstuff go do better sweetie, i bet you definitely can't lol, why don't you sit down and shut it, it will be better for you, more useful than thinking you have anything meaningful to say, you don't
I’ve never seen a character transform this much over multiple SEASONS of a series let alone a SINGLE HOUR!!
Agreed, and on top of that, make it believable. Not for a second I felt this went too fast. From being normal, to distressed and trapped, to accepting her fate, to planning the future, to becoming hangman. How the fuck did that even happen. Brilliant.
@@nealcaffrey541 between the mushrooms and the gas, she could be Poison Ivy? That's one thing about this show is waiting for the reveal of characters' "villain names".
watch game of thrones. but yess i agreee ! awesome character development. awesome tv show. awesome episode !
@@NicholasStuff Sofia changed more in this episode than Sansa changed in 8 seasons!
You know the shows good af when every week people say this is the best episode yet
TRUTH
FOR REAL. I thought it couldn't get any better after last episode but holy shit they did it. This episode was perfect. Idk how I'm going to feel about Penguin going forward tho.
@@aleppo5398 agreed. Cristin has absolutely stolen the show. If Cristin and Colin don’t win any awards for this show then that’s a crime
this has been the weakest episode, because it has some issues:
- I don't buy that carmine would offer her that position with she being so innocent at this point.
- "if you were looking out for me you would've talked to me!" yeah he tried that and you told him to shut up, that he's just a driver...
- The "you have a dick" comment falls a little flat when her father is talking about "breaking with tradition! and giving her the reigns.
but i get it: they wanted to rush some of this because it is not the focus of the show; still a great villain origin story: though I thought by the end she would've embreaced the "hangman" name and hang some of the men in her familiy that have betrayed her
@@larrote6467 The "you have a dick" line is BEFORE her father even says that to her, if you want to talk about inconsistencies at least stay consistent within your own argument
The penguin is so damn good that at 9 I always stop watching the Sunday night nfl game no matter who plays or the score to just watch the penguin on time .
@@robertoarsenal9044 terrible game tonight so it was an easy choice for me.
Those corrupted sports are trash and a waste of time and energy
Just give Cristin Milioti the goddamn Emmy right now! She already had my vote for the first 3 episodes alone, but now I’m gonna root as fiercely for Cristin like I did for Anna Sawai for Shogun.
FOR REAL!
Mariko sama 🧎🏻➡️
She gets pissed off at Oz for going to Carmine instead of talking to her even though he LITERALLY tries to talk to her about it in the car and she says he's just a driver, she doesn't want advice from a driver, no one wants anything from a driver.
Yep she is a spoiled entitled brat. Carmine sent her to Arkham Oz was genuinely trying to help her. If she talked she would have had to die.
Yeah I think that’s when he decided to sell her out to her dad. But I think he truly didn’t think Arkham would be where she would be sent to
That comment of "why arr you inside?" didn't help either
I mean he's always been rat to get whatever he feels he deserves, was she really wrong for not trusting a rat?
@@Insertmewtwoquoteand when was this "always"? As far as she knows he was just a driver.
Falcone also tries to strangle catwoman in “the Batman”
It’s staying consistent.
he also admitted to killing Catwomans MOM the same way.
Besides changing the actor
@@angelespinoza9917 yes that threw me for about a second and then I dealt with it.
Penguin was mad after Falcone joking about him, which made him pulled out his gun, just like ep1, the reason for the killing of Alberto.
He also strangled Selina’s roommate
"what are you doing inside?" was such a subtle yet strong line, shows that no matter how nice she is, she's still classist and Oz HATES that
Sofia looked so good in that yellow dress... sheesh!
Indeed
Right??? Even the rear view was exquisite 🤩
i know right?????
@@ForeverBrooklynNYCbum bum tssk
true that
I believe this entire series deserved to win an Emmy next year
What an episode ! Now we know why Sophia loves her brother so much, we know why Penguin didn't hesitate betraying Sophia, why that betrayal meant even more to Sophia. Next level writing and connecting the dots !
BRING BACK THE GCPD SHOW JAMES GUNNN !!
I think her brother had to do something with all those murders.
But we will see.
And if I am right, then she will hate her brother.
It looked to me like Oswald did not want to hurt Sofia but that was the direction he was going. He genuinely felt angry at her arrest but he adapts and backstabbing is his thing anyway.
Mark strong did a great job as carmie falcone
He really did - forgot it wasn't Turturro playing him.
Why the actor change though?
I preferred his performance to Turturro’s (also, he doesn’t do “TV”).
agreed
@@JoJoJokerthat’s wild
Her brother wasn't a bad guy, he was even trying to stay clean. Don't forget penguin convinced him to drink which led to the drugs and then he killed him
Yeah but he chose the wrong person and time to run his mouth 😂
For falcone standards he was pretty good.
Eh...he DEFINITELY was a BAD BAD dude...first off he didn't CARE that his father was a mobster that was also a serial killer...just that he framed his sister...he also was not only a bad addict but wanted to make everyone else the same plus he treated Oz like GARBAGE and got shot as a result.
@@jeux2322lol which means he was a bad dude
@ChrisSmith-tu9bu what did you expect him to if he stood up to his father he would've been killed or sent to Arkam his father had to much power.
Final shot of the series: Oz standing over either Sophia or Victor's grave at their funeral holding an umbrella in the rain, having now finally ascended to the boss.
nice call
Since Oz arguably gets unfairly blamed and subsequently awarded for “informing” on Sofia, I think Oz gets more invested in Vic and ends up giving him up to some criminal charges to shirk suspicions from himself
@@dinospumoni-l8t Sophia needs to be the one to kill Vic to get back at Ozzy boy.
Would be such a waste to only have her in the series and not in the Batman upcoming movie 😮💨 horrible idea I just honestly rather have oz dyong a Vic taking over, would be far more unpredictable because everyone expecting him to survive
@@Insertmewtwoquote we already know oz wins and becomes the kingpin in the end ,some people already saw the whole season the question is will vic and sofia survive?
Just give her and Ferrell the Emmy it’s over
Carmine was strangling catwoman the same way and got scratched by her too
He also killed Selina’s mother the same way, he tells her that as he’s trying to kill her
Man I’ve been locked up. I used to be quite wild with the substance abuse. When you go in, wherever it is, you officially become less than human. At one point I was fully convinced that animals in the clinic are treated better than life on the inside. Clean and sober now for 6 years and 3 months. Got out of prison in 2019. It’s something that changed me like forever. Forever. She nails it. Brutal.
When penguin told the kid "Don't believe everything" when the kid called her hangman I knew she was innocent from that moment
Plus, she did say she wasn't the Hangman in the last episode, and Oz didn't disagree.
What episode did he say that in? I forget
@@austincaucci the episode when she came by Ozz's apartment and vic invited his girlfriend over
This episode was another masterpiece in storytelling. I can’t remember the last time that I so wanted an actor to win an Emmy. Cristin Miloti is brilliant. Is it crazy that if she ends up killing his mom that I may not be mad about it?
Summer Gleason from Batman: The Animated Series and Sofia Falcone's arc with her going through what she went through in Arkham Asylum is just crazy. It had that Luke Cage feel to it with her trying to prove her innocence in front of Julian Rush and he realizes she is innocent and cares for her.
I love the way this episode re-contextualizes the previous ones, looking forward to where they take it from here!
1000%
Also we got to see the same actor who portrayed Kinsey in The Batman return in this episode appearing in Sofia Falcone's flashback. Sticking to continuity so perfectly. Also the whole Club 44 below the Iceberg Lounge and how all the women died under the hands of Carmine Falcone being revisited during the events of The Batman is explained so well.
Yup! Always enjoy your enthusiasm
Sofia Falcone has finally persuaded her hangman persona on another level
Fav Episode Of The Season?!
this episode shows how no matter how much bad things Oz do to these people they all deserve it, Sofia isn't any better than her family, and Alberto definitely had it coming
@@youssefheisenberg6410This episode was literally Sofia's villain origin story, and your reaction is that she deserved it?
This episode also shows how Oz can never be trusted and will turn on ANYONE in order to serve his own interests. I was sympathetic to Oz until this episode. Now I want to see him fall and Sofia rise (wishful thinking)@@youssefheisenberg6410
Alberto deserved to DIE because he made Oz feel bad? What did Sofia do to “deserve” being locked away in Arkham for 10 years after being framed by her FATHER for crimes HE committed. Her father even murdered HER MOTHER.@@youssefheisenberg6410
Flashback episode. Lame.
kenzie was the one with the broken nose in the movie
Penguin also said earlier in the show one of the guys he drove for got caught talking to the feds and falcone killed him. Maybe he was trying to save her in his own way and it backfired massively.
Yh and since it was his kid he was just expecting her to be sent out of the country at worst
@@codycharles6316 I think he was talking about Sofia and changing some details.
This show is PHENOMENAL!!! Give HBO all the acclaim and Awards
Mark Strong is a great choice because, he was a younger version of the Turturro Falcone as an older, more seasoned mob boss.
Those final moments I was on the edge of my seat just trying to figure out how Sofia was gonna kill them…and was like “YES, GIRL…GET YOUR REVENGE!!!” (In that yellow dress at that..Sofia has arrived)😅🤭
Just got through watching this episode. The way it’s show how she got crazy is so good.
I heard the name "Summer Gleeson," and I went "The reporter from Batman the Animated Series?! Nice."
The majority of folks on twitter were saying "Just give Milioti the Emmy already," after watching *this* episode.
Mark Strong did a good job in replacing John Turturro.
Watching "The Batman" again, you understand *why* Riddler and Catwoman hate Carmine Falcone so much.
Bro this show is so good. So good that I’m gonna draw all the characters! I’ve already drawn the penguin so far
Thats so cool! Are you gonna post it somewhere?
@@Villakeen thanks! My penguin drawing is on my UA-cam channel, it’s a short video
She acted hers and everyone elses ass off. So compelling to watch. Im in awe of her talent. Shes a badass. Favourite character for sure ❤
I’m surprised you guys didn’t catch on to falcone rather then it being Sofia. In the Batman he was strangling women he killed Selina’s mother and her friend. It’s been pretty obvious to me that it was always falcone who was the hangman haha.
Good grief just give Cristin Milioti the Emmy!!! I was shrieking in how disturbing this episode was. This is how you do a flashback episode. Not a waisted line of dialogue or frames. Ahhh it's just incredible!!!!
I mean its hyper stylized but also real ASF... they're constantly locking up sane people in asylums and jails and its EXTREMELY brutal how we treat criminals and crazies
A moment of silence for Summer Gleeson 😢
Mark Strong was solid and definitely fits the classic comic book mobster role better, but I love the against the grain casting of Turturro in the movie, he felt so much slimier. Can't go wrong either way.
Penguin did care about her he was genuinely surprised the police showed up. She started treating him badly as soon as he tried to warn her.
But did he really though? If he truly cared, he should have just kept his mouth shut and not said anything. But he didn’t. Penguin didn’t stay in his lane and he’s one of the reasons why she got locked away in the first place. Granted…. he may have not known what was gonna happen but again, it wouldn’t had been necessary if he didn’t snitch to Sophia’s father in the first place.
Was Sophia a bit mean or harsh towards Oz? Oh yeah. I don’t deny that. But his actions isn’t an excuse. He was too ambitious for his own good.
I agree for the most part. He wanted to hurt her back after she called him just the driver.
But I agree he never expected it to be taken so far, though he does not care about her.
@@rodgill9376Are you daft? He works for her father, who would kill him without hesitation if Oz kept this a secret. She literally told him he was worthless. Why would he confide with her? She just established that there was nothing between them.
@@blackmanwithcomputer she never said he was “worthless.” She said: “you’re just the driver.” Which that’s what he was. He told on her because he got his little feelings hurt and/or was too ambitious as I’ve already pointed out. Regardless of what was said, Oz is still a snitch. No different from his boss, whom do I need need to remind you was also a snitch as well? Takes a snitch to know a snitch, now doesn’t it?
@@rodgill9376 She said no one cares what he has to say. That he's only her driver. That's dehumanizing, and it severely clashed with her being nice to him earlier. To him, this was just her revealing how she actually sees him.
Regardless, why should he protect her? He's just the driver, remember? She's not his friend. She made that very clear. If he kept this from Carmine, and Carmine found out, he's a dead man. Carmine was his boss, remember?
After all that yet and the person we hate the most Johnny vititi is still alive
She needs an alibi and a servant. And access the cash and codes.
Was baffled not seeing John Turturro return as Falcone Sr, but holy shit was I equally joyful to quickly recognize Mark Strong. I’ve absolutely loved him in everything I’ve seen him in, as he is criminally underrated. To me both are amazing choices for the role, but it’s frustrating trying to be content with only one of them taking it now that there’s been a switch
Mark Strong has a stronger presence.
@@JoJoJokerfacts! Nothing against Turturro as he did a good job , but Strong just had THAT AURA that conveyed intimidation
@@JoJoJoker Agreed. Strong is simply “holy shit it’s Carmine Fucking Falcone,” as opposed to “it’s Carmine Falcone”
Strong as Archie in “Rock’N’Rolla”. Favorite role of his.
Don't recall anyone ever underrating Mark Strong.
The head of Arkham Dr. Ventriss later becomes Mirror man and I’m not sure but didn’t Magpie kill her mother in the comics before she became a villain? 🤔 so many great Easter eggs.
Is it Mirror Man or Mirror master?
This show truly gets better by the episode. I was amazed tonight. It’s elite cinema
i'm not a big fan of the "insane asylum" cliches and it's a little tonally off for this show, but i thought this was hands down the best performance of the season so far for sure.
she did say in the last episode that she never killed anyone, at a time when she would have no reason to lie / penguin sort of said it as well
What an episode! Take a bow Cristin!
I love Alberto and Sofia’s sibling relationship; u can tell why Alberto’s death really really affected her;
He had his problems, but he really cares for his sister; and the fact that he kept working with her for the new drug while she was still in Arkham; he didn’t take advantage of the situation, he loved her and wanted to cut her in;
Just really nice writing 😢
This show deserves all the Emmys. And not to shit on IGN. But, come on a 5. That was wild.
IGN lost all credit already, they are garbage journalists with no taste or variety. They are all braindead NPCs.
That site seems like it’s always an outlier when it comes to reviews. Like, when it comes to a show or film that both critics and audiences collectively agree is amazing, they have to give it an average or below average rating.
My favorite episode yet and give her all the awards and I've never said about a actress or actor before in all of my 26 years of watching movies and tv.
I knew from last week that carmine was the real Hagman killer after mentioning killing catwomen mom with his bare hands
and also trying to kill selina the same way
I was wondering how they'd make Oz back into a villain after we've been following and rooting for him the entire series, but this gives us two/three paths forward. He'll kill one of either Vic or Sofia, or both.
Killing Sofia was a forgone conclusion. Vic is going to be his right hand man. Like what Vitti was to Luca and now to Sofia.
It just gets better every week
I know this is a futile wish given The Penguin’s core position in Batman’s Rogue Gallery but in a perfect world, Sofia would exact ultimate and final vengeance on Oz for ratting her out to Carmine and killing Alberto.
This episode made me do a complete 180 on Oz - especially seeing him turn on Sofia in front of the Maronis. Oz is the ultimate betrayer.
Oh I was rooting for him. Now I want her to kill him.
At the very least, he never expected the Arkham Asylum to happen.
We’ve seen what happens when people hurt his ego, he hurts them back. He ratted her out though honestly I don’t think he ever knew how far it would be taken.
@@jrod1591I still gotta cheer for OZ but I hope she goes high fr
First he had no idea about the murders or what was going on in the family. He just knew about the reporter. Alberto insulted him, fair play.
Oz being a backstabber shouldn't come as a shock. He is exactly that. That is what makes him such a unique protagonist. He is no Michael Corleone, he is Salvatore Tessio if Sal was wayy smarter.
Hes a survivalist...Whilst Sophia murdered a woman out of anger...the point is there are no good guys but Penguin is the lesser of these two but neither is a Saint and Oz did what lots of people would have done in that situation
Man those first 30+ minutes were rough. I get so sad watching people get abused emotionally and physically. But the PAYOFF! My lord this show is great!
Summer Gleason is the Vickie Vale type of character on Batman the Animated Series 😂
I swear you can never trust any character Theo Rossi plays haha
"scealing stenes" 27:45
This the best one yet it felt like a long movie and not series. It shows how they turned her coo coo.
Peguin is such a good series so far, especially with their characterizations. Like Penguin always does something dirty when someone disrespects him. The reason he betrayed Sophia is because she called him nothing but a driver and didn't care about his opinion. Those small details are so good to drive a series.
i think its also so good that we probably were all feining to see what happened with vic and Oz after last episode and they just throw this at us and we still love it
Definitely the best episode yet. By the 14 minute mark, I had a feeling she was going to get framed by her father and it happened. Once I saw the police while she was talking to Oz, I knew she was screwed.
Sofia was innocent all along. Less blood on her hands than Oz. It’s similar to The Count of Monte Cristo where Dante gets framed for no reason and then a little bit of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in trying to make her go crazy in an asylum when she isn’t. I initially thought Magpie was Harley.
I’m glad she got her payback against all her relatives who betrayed her. She wasted 10 years of life for nothing. Mark Strong did a good job but his Carmine Falcone felt a little too quiet and reserved compared to John Turturro’s version.
Great ending song: “Strange Little Girl” by The Stranglers. Good show! Way better than Agatha All Along which I gave up on after Ep. 3. Cristin in that hot dress showing plenty of cleavage. She and Colin are the best parts to this show.
9/10 👍🏻
26:40 also had me in stitches 😭 her face said everything
I am 1000% rooting for Sophia for the rest of the series, even more than the Penguin and it’s his show
This episode is very messed up!
The ending... holy crap!!😮
When Sophia sees Oz and says "what are you doing inside?" There's no vitriol or malice in her voice so I disagree entirely that she's talking to him,"like a dog." He's a driver, the drivers, in every mob or crime show/film ever made are always hanging out front by the cars. That's where they stay, by their cars. She was surprised that Oz was inside because it's entirely out of the ordinary and that obviously means something is amiss. That's all she's saying.
Her momentary flash of anger at him when she's stressed about her dad didn't mark a change in her overall feelings for Oz, she was just pissed off about the reporter/her dad.
exactly
1000% agree. We have all had bad days, and lashed out to people we cared about. She treated Oz pretty well when everyone else was too busy making fun of him or calling him penguin. He was probably inside because he got a 'promotion' for being a rat. thats why the new jacket. When sofia said it looks good on you, and then walked into see her father, my gut flipped
this episode. this episode was just ... satisfying and suffocating at the same time. it was deliciously dark and i HONESTLY was so happy when she walked in with that gas mask on [and the choice of track was inspired]. i too hope she doesn't die. i'd love if [let's say the Maroni's are taken out], the city teeters constantly between Sophia's crew and Oswald's crew. and weirdly enough - just for giggles - i would NOT be mad if Dr. Julian Rush becomes this world's Scarecrow.
Protect Sofia at all costs. Blown away by Miloti since HIMYM and she transcends here. The empathy I feel for her on what she went through. I look at Penguin differently. Family got what they deserve. Falcone was down right monster and didn’t get enough suffering before and while he died from a single gun shot wound. Shame she needed Vito(sp?). Deserved it more than most.
I hope, if Oz ends up on top, I hope Sofia gets away somehow. Man she is a powerhouse.
@@kbrewers 🤞🏻 SAME. She just gives it up leaves before or her half sister Selina shows up back to help her escape 👀
THE PENGUIN🐧: Cristin Milioti is a masterful actress. An intense fourth episode in this journey of Oz in the decadent Gotham City of the Batverse🦇 by Matt Reeves. (DC/HBO/MAX)
Dude, is it just me or was it really obvious that she was framed. With her line to penguin last episode “I’m the hangman” and her reaction to the mom pulling her kid away from her. Ofc she was innocent. She did such a great job in conveying that
Penguin said to Vic not to believe everything he read in the papers about Sofia, so they'd been making it clear for a while that she wasn't her reputation.
Really obvious, but the nature of who blames whom for what that amounts to Sofia’s indictment/remanding to Arkham is the show, ESPECIALLY since her portrayal in the first (3) hours of the show, while disturbed, isn’t consistent with a serial perpetrator of lethal hangings regardless of what Gotham thinks
We as the audience are shown a much more put together, psychologically composed character than the person carrying everyone’s projection of her
They've been telling us that for 3 episodes tho
She and Oz had a literal conversation explaining that she was framed in the previous episode. I don't understand why it's being taken as a surprise at all.
@@bastien- plus her dad being known strangulation murderer from the Batman. How did everyone not know o was him not her? 🤣
I am vexed that Carmine never was held accountable for what he did to Sofia or to her mother or to all the women, for that matter. He got killed by someone who only cared about himself. Not that I am support murder. Just saying. Riddler took him out but was it really justice?
I totally predicted that the trial will be cancelled. Why would they imprison her and traumatise her? Either that, or they were trying to make her crazy so that when the trial comes, she claims the blame herself. The fact that she endured the torture without giving in probably was the reason why the trial was cancelled.
Arkham Asylum needs to be condemned, and all the doctors (besides Rush) need to be locked up for life. I’ve seen Arkham Asylum in countless adaptations of movies, TV shows, video games and comics. But this is without question the darkest and most horrific version of Arkham ever made.
It’s places like that that give countless people pause whenever they think of people who have been in mental hospitals or had mental health problems.
im not willing to give Rush a pass yet, dude seems like he has an agenda. be it romantic, or psychotic. We dont know if he got her out willingly. Might never find out.
Bro this is episode portrayed Arkham Asylum exactly the way I wanted. This was amazing!!!
Ventriss needs to go if he is not gone already
How brilliant of Matt Reeves and the writers and producers to give the Penquin an antagonist that has more depth and character development than any other villian we've seen since Thanos.
18:08 those eyes are terrifying💀💀
Just like last week, came out an hour ago and already edited it. I hail you and your editing magic! ^_^ lol
Now, THIS is peak DC. Peak casting, peak directing, peak everything. And Cristin Milioti absolutely deserves all the awards, such a huge range. It's going to tear us apart the war between her and Penguin, I'm sure we're not ready. We're watching villains only the Batman universe could give us. I'm so happy we get to have that kind of show.
So this is how The Magpie died 😂
Amazing episode. I think e3 was the best episode so far imo but this is a close 2nd. Love the way this gave us context to so much from the first three eps.
I wanted to say props to how amazing Cristina millioti is in this role and also comment how much her storyline in this show reminds me of the warren white storyline in a serious house on a serious earth.
Its one of the most intriguing gotham storys imo opinion and I'm thrilled that even if we're unlikely to ever get warren white himself in live action that the story of the "new fish" being driven insane is still a story that gets told in some form
This show will make us hate Sofia and oz. she’s gonna kill victor for revenge mark my words.
I think Sofia will kill Oz's mother
yeah vic is gonna die
wtf i JUST FINISHED watching the episode, you guys are so quick
(my favorite episode so far btw) love it love it
They got early screeners. It's the perks of being as successful a reaction channel as they are.
@@DarthTingleBinks makes sense lol
Loved it!
Theres not many TV shows thats named after the signature character, that gives as much back story to a side character as they did in this one episode, its beautifully done, they didnt hold back either they made it feel raw. What a performance by all so far
I have a feeling, that her brother had to do something with those killings of all those woman. Maybe he did it.
And I think, Penguin knows this.
I think Sofia and the Pinguin will be friends again. ( I hope so )
Actually someone had to Rat her out before Oz went to Carmine. The reporter was strangled and Hung and it was done the same night Oz met with Carmine likely hours before.
Penguin himself admitted he screwed her over
Didn't penguin said on the car that he is just doing his job to protect Sofia by telling Carmine?
Not saying he didn't go to Carmine and tell him but setting up another Hanging and getting Sophia framed would take more time than the minutes she spent talking to Carmine.@@Insertmewtwoquote
He likely went to tell Carmine but from the timeline things happened too fast. Summer died the police found her hung and Sophia was blamed only a half an hour later.@@Insertmewtwoquote
This is a universe I have fallen in love with. I hope DC capitalizes this and expands on this universe with the James Gunn. I doubt it'll happen but if it could...
This episode was so amazing! 👍
Fork scene took my all the way out. So unexpected and out of left field
This episode was so good! I cannot wait for the last 4
This episode makes you want to rewatch the Batman and ep 1-3 everything is in such a different light .
genuinely blown away by this episode
Drivers wait with the car. Like Vic wouldn't be inside when Oz comes to the house. Sofia asking why he's inside is about her realizing he's not where he should be, followed by her seeing the new coat. She's realizing right then he's betrayed her.
I never expected this show to be as good as it is. I had hopes but really didnt believe it. Ive just watched this episode and it is LITERALLY one of the best episodes on TV ever
Cant wait to get back to Oz next episode!
“ By the power of billionaires!!” LMAO
21:04 u say shock therapy or as harley would say a brain massage or as joker would say flossing your brain 🧠 😅
dawg this show is so good!!!
I just can't believe I am excitedly waiting for the next week after each episode. It has been so many years since the last time I was like this. Simply amazing.
Holy shit what an episode