Could someone please explain to me the meaning of the last line of the last poem in The House on the Marshlands, "The Apple Trees"--what is the meaning/significance of "women rooted to the river."? That seemed to me to have come out of nowhere.
The comments with the " ummm", etc., are related to the difficulty of relating to the language of poetry that one wants to perceive or put into words of understanding. To understand a language by means of speech is almost impossible. Poetry is very close to the world of the Magus, that is why any critic or commentator of any piece of art or language will find that difficulty to express to the public spirit ( and unquestionably to himself) the meaning . Thank u.
While I think you're on to something, notice that Louise also chose her words very carefully but without the 'ums' in between her words. She simply paused for a moment and continued speaking when the word came to her, whereas her interviewer seemed to be in a state of shock/reverence of Ms. Glück for the entire interview, which was exhausting to listen to and watch. Additionally, I don't understand what you mean by 'understanding language by speech is almost impossible.'
17:22 Once Ms Glüch was given free rein to actually begin speaking, the interview really picked up. It's unfortunate the previous minutes were so distracted by Mr. Streckfus's constant "um". (Although I guess we should give him a break. After all, he was "among greatness" and was likely a bit nervous.)
@@PK-re3lu Perhaps you would like to share with us what you have ever done that is so "great", since you seem to believe you are qualified to judge those who you deem unworthy. Perhaps you would like to tell us which Nobel prizes you have won.
@@DeutschlandGuy That is an astoundingly moronic comment. Regardless of what I have or have not achieved, it in no way impacts on the truth or falsity of my remark. They are two separate things. The anti-intellectualism implicit in your response is typical of the mindlessness of the age. Btw, anyone familiar with the history of literature would know exactly what I mean re a culture in which everything and anything is described as 'great'. Are there no adults on YT? The idea that a prize, any prize, confers 'greatness' on someone is nothing more than a sad reflection of our market-driven world.
@@irani544 Are you saying what she wrote isn't poetry? If you are, that is rather thick considering her Nobel Prize, term as the Poet Laureate of the United States of America, and numerous published works.
Delighted LG won the Nobel. That said, this effete style of discussing poetry drives me crazy. It really shows how the cancer of creative writing has turned poets into technicians (who invariably spend far too much time in universities-the worst possible place for them-surrounded by corporate mercenaries-very bad for the soul lol). Enjoy!
She just won the nobel prize thats what brought me here.
Samehere
Me three. I like what I hear.
I thought I would be envious; thought I would give students bad advice. Hahaha
Congratulations Louise Gluck
Congratulations!!!
Peter, the doctor of UM
Agreed! Right up there with like, you know, right, uh, and other fillers when you can’t think of anything to say.
Could someone please explain to me the meaning of the last line of the last poem in The House on the Marshlands, "The Apple Trees"--what is the meaning/significance of "women rooted to the river."? That seemed to me to have come out of nowhere.
Seems like a juxtaposition. River means changing but then also the word rooted is there. Rooted . Like change is the way to stay same kind of paradox.
The comments with the " ummm", etc., are related to the difficulty of relating to the language of poetry that one wants to perceive or put into words of understanding. To understand a language by means of speech is almost impossible. Poetry is very close to the world of the Magus, that is why any critic or commentator of any piece of art or language will find that difficulty to express to the public spirit ( and unquestionably to himself) the meaning . Thank u.
While I think you're on to something, notice that Louise also chose her words very carefully but without the 'ums' in between her words. She simply paused for a moment and continued speaking when the word came to her, whereas her interviewer seemed to be in a state of shock/reverence of Ms. Glück for the entire interview, which was exhausting to listen to and watch. Additionally, I don't understand what you mean by 'understanding language by speech is almost impossible.'
Um Namaha Shivaya?
17:22 Once Ms Glüch was given free rein to actually begin speaking, the interview really picked up. It's unfortunate the previous minutes were so distracted by Mr. Streckfus's constant "um". (Although I guess we should give him a break. After all, he was "among greatness" and was likely a bit nervous.)
With respect, the bar for 'greatness' seems to be steadily getting lower with each passing year ;)
@@PK-re3lu Perhaps you would like to share with us what you have ever done that is so "great", since you seem to believe you are qualified to judge those who you deem unworthy. Perhaps you would like to tell us which Nobel prizes you have won.
@@DeutschlandGuy That is an astoundingly moronic comment. Regardless of what I have or have not achieved, it in no way impacts on the truth or falsity of my remark. They are two separate things. The anti-intellectualism implicit in your response is typical of the mindlessness of the age. Btw, anyone familiar with the history of literature would know exactly what I mean re a culture in which everything and anything is described as 'great'. Are there no adults on YT? The idea that a prize, any prize, confers 'greatness' on someone is nothing more than a sad reflection of our market-driven world.
Um,
I'm sorry but the UMMMM was so distracting to the whole interview...
ummmmmm ummmmm
Umm very distracting
um, um, um like, um um how you say....um.......
um
Um um..um um and so um so um and so um. Take a shot every time he says um
PROZAC ... AZAP
Ummm, soo, ummm sooo, ammm, ummm, ummm soo 😑😑😑😑 he ruined the presentation 😢 how disrespectful.
The interviewer’s incoherence in English makes this unwatchable. What a shame.
My feelings exactly. Is it any wonder so many people are turned off poetry!? Thanks.
@@PK-re3lu The interviewer is a poet. Peter Streckfus.
Nobel prizs.... WOW
I read some of her works. How the hell is that even poetry?
What is your definition of poetry?
@@Lord_Heron I might not be able to say what a poem is but I can definitely say what a poem isn't.
it uses every words i think thats what appeals it to a broader, international market
@@irani544 Are you saying what she wrote isn't poetry? If you are, that is rather thick considering her Nobel Prize, term as the Poet Laureate of the United States of America, and numerous published works.
Delighted LG won the Nobel. That said, this effete style of discussing poetry drives me crazy. It really shows how the cancer of creative writing has turned poets into technicians (who invariably spend far too much time in universities-the worst possible place for them-surrounded by corporate mercenaries-very bad for the soul lol). Enjoy!