Chinese Coast Guard Blasts Philippine Boats With Water Cannons | WSJ News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 гру 2023
- Chinese coast-guard ships blasted water cannons at Philippine boats on Saturday in the South China Sea near Scarborough Shoal. The Philippines and the U.S. condemned China’s actions. Photo: Philippine Coast Guard/AFP/Getty Images
#wsj #southchinasea #philippines
The Phillipines need to build or acquire equal or more powerful coastguard ships to protect their sovereignty. This is the only respect China understands.
Diplomacy does not work with a communist regime!
I mean....yes. But, China is a nuclear power. The PI is still a protectorate of the US.
Haha, want to match industrial power with China? the No。1 in this blue globe for 13 years, roughly the sum of US + EU. Are you joking?
Philipines needs to rise up and use their sovereign power to defend their fishing industry and the rights Former Prez Dirty slowly took from the people and gave to CCP
You are right there. These authoritarian pricks dont respond to anything but might and power. If you don't boast the same capabilities as them they will kick you around and take advantage
Don't cheat Phil. You surrendered to the japanese and lost everything.
You want to play hard-ball? You are not yet in the league.
I like how China thinks they own the waters and everything else is there's.
No they dont think so they only enforce the law. If you know Chinese law enforcement they are a stickler for the rules.
@@amunra5330they're a stickler for making up their own arbitrary rules only when it suits them. Most of these incidents happen hundreds of kilometers away from Chinese territorial waters. You can't simply claim all the waters in an ocean and say dibs. That's not how the world works.
@@amunra5330Well it's hilarious that their laws conflict with how the rest of the world's laws under UNCLOS operates. You say China is a stickler for abiding by law, but you don't mention that they are BREAKING IT at the same time. 😂
@@ADAMADAM-cl1xk just because it’s called the South China Sea doesn’t mean it belongs to China. The Indian Ocean doesn’t belong to India. China doesn’t even border most of it, Southeast Asian countries do.
Very true. They have been violating Argentina’s sovereignty fishing on their waters for a while now
This reminds me of that one scene in the first Transformers movie where the autobot pees on Agent Simmons 😂
That’s just dirty…
China is rapidly escalating.
If the Philippines doesn't fight back, I think things will get worse.
Phillipine is a small kid 🐭
Any Countries or people that believe in China are often those that rely heavily on Chinese financial assistance, which may lead to a perceived need to curry favor with China. They know the truth but they are @ss-kissers.
upnext China will claim that solar system is part of 9 dash line and based on history😝
Actually what happen there, the black smaller ships that are attacked with water cannon are from the Philippine Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatics who are usually for fishermen support or science reasons. They were there because they were just doing their job of aid by giving some food and fuel supplies to the smaller Filipino fishermen in the area like what they always do. Before the attack the smaller Filipino fishing boats were parked beside those black ships refueling. Then China came along and started bombarding them with water cannon. In local news videos some of those smaller fishing boats were hit with the water. The Phil. BFAR ships sustained some damage to their radar and the ship because one of those Chinese ship hit them on the side. I believe China will now stupidly make a statement giving their reason on why they attacked those non Phil. Coast Guard/Navy ships who were not even delivering supplies to any military outpost that China always say they don't allow.
As screwed up as it is… I find it amusing when they have their water cannon battles.
因为你们国家想在11段线搞事，以前不揍你是爷实力不够忍着，现实刚好有揍你能力！
doing their job in cHINA SEA?
@@captainyeo4365 nice play on words. I think it's actually called the South China sea and it does not mean China owns it. This would be the same as South and Central America. Just because you have a name to a location does not mean you own it and all other countries that coast the South China sea have legitimate claims that span years. Some of these places are considered ancestral because they have been used for generations.
Thank you for reporting the facts that we surely won’t get from the news networks.
But lots of elites want their government to do business with them.. good slave labor is hard to find.
50% Unemployment for several years, all business leaving China.. they need to keep looking tough while they fall apart. Apperances. Profit.
yep, Nixon admin. is to thank!
Maybe. That's what we're told by the establishments we can't trust. So, maybe that's true, maybe it's not.
Adults behaving like kids in the backseat. “Mom! Timmy’s touching my side of the seat!”
What difference does it make?
The PUSA is asleep at the wheel.
Weak analogy
US says it stands with its ally...yeah, just standing! hahahahahaha
American is busy with their crushed jet in South Korea. Don’t have time for Philippines
bs...
Oh China, China. You think you owe everything.
Drones
Then the winner is the one who has cheaper ships to sink
In 1971, Chinese soldiers on Thitu Island moved to Taiping Island to escape the storm. However, after escaping the wind and waves, because it was time for rotation, this group of soldiers did not return to Thitu Island. Instead, they returned directly from Taiping Island to Taiwan. At this time, the rotation soldiers who set out from Taiwan, due to the wind and waves, We are still on the road and have not reached Thitu Island. Upon seeing this, the Philippine government immediately dispatched soldiers to Thitu Island, landed on the island, built fortifications, and waited for the rotating soldiers to depart from Taiwan.
Full of lies and propaganda from CCP
yes， and this China is ROC（the govement in taiwan）
And this is relevant how exactly? Don't be such a obvious Wumao.
@@nikushim6665 历史匮乏的菲律宾猴
The pinoys stole Thitu island from the Chinese. The Chinese have every right to bump the intruders off the island.
that's how they Flush the Crapper Storage👍🏼
Where is Robin Padilla , show now your courage…
Maybe there’s a hidden story between this and all we see is the visual
There is no hidden story. The Philippines has a legal exclusive economic zone, legal under UNCLOS (which China is a signatory of and violator of) that abides by laws recognized by all except for China.
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_VehicleI disagree with you here. There's always a hidden story.
@@LandoShmetzP. That's a blatant lie.
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicle any media coverage is biased. That makes any other story "hidden" by default.
Dont be mad when they fight back ☕️🐸
Democracies and friendly countries in the region. We are stronger together - we work together and the CCP will not prevail
good policy, maybe all players in the region might get more help from Japan, in one form or another...
No china 👎🏼
no black man
I love the “US and the Philippines condemned the Chinese!” Who’s hiding behind who?
Where is the US Navy?
@@user-qp4eq1oj5r Not in US waters?
Where is the U.S. on patrol now make it happen not just talk
What is the purpose 🤔
The island people will not stand for this
Free ship wash 😊
Where's the USA?
...standing...
Filipinos its time we fight back, i cant take this no more, too much bullying., let me know and ill take the first flight back home
If you are going to use distance to discuss the ownership of the islands, then please condemn the UK and Japan first, the Falklands are obviously closer to Argentina, yet all of the Philippines' so-called allies supported the UK after the Falklands war broke out. Similarly, Okinawa is obviously closer to Taiwan than Japan, so do you support Okinawa being part of Taiwan? Obviously you don't, and this is where your ridiculous double standards come into play.I know you will not be convinced, so let us talk about this issue from another angle. Historically speaking, Japan occupied the whole of Southeast Asia during the Second World War. On 1 December 1943, China, the United States and Britain issued the Cairo Declaration, demanding Japan to return the plundered territories and islands, including the so-called "Philippine Islands", which was once again made clear by the Potsdam Proclamation signed by Japan in 1945 after its defeat. To whom, then, does this area belong under international law? It is obvious. Interestingly, the Philippines, which was colonized by Japan in the Second World War, became a military colony of the United States immediately after the surrender of Japan. To cut to the chase, from the point of view of simple values, I can certainly understand the thinking of the Filipino people, but this is still a world of power, where the powerful countries wear the suit of international law and do vulgar things under a seemingly civilized exterior. Let me give you an example, Japan's Tsugaru Strait (you can Google mps for it) is located between Japan's Honshu Island and Hokkaido, and it's a high sea, but only China, the US, and Russia's warships in the world dare to pass through it. Why? I think you can understand it now.
从软实力角度来说，过早的对日本 南韩 菲律宾等周边国家展现出强硬姿态并不明智 在美国仍然没有完全退出东亚之前， 过早的展现出实力与野心并不利于博取周边国家内部亲华派的支持从而失去舆论优势， 仅仅使用冷兵器的中国海警就可以逮捕荷枪实弹的菲律宾海警已经说明了菲律宾意识到依靠自身实力无法与中国抗衡，一昧的强硬施压只会迫使其导向美国的怀抱，因此从现实主义的角度来说，中国应当伪装出一幅没有任何领土野心的和善老好人形象，在美国势力被迫全面退出东亚之前尽量尽可能减少对周边国家采取强硬措施，在民族主义十分强盛的现代社会，即使美国退出东亚，一昧的强硬姿态也有可能将菲律宾变成中国版本的古巴，不使用军事手段基本上无法施加任何影响力，非常不利于软实力的推销, 在软实力催眠最理想的状态下，所有周边国家，即使不是盟友，也会保持中立，而不是成为一块围堵中国的桥头堡, ，这与日本 南韩或者菲律宾实际上并没有任何关系，因为在这场关乎东亚真正主人的安全竞争中，中国唯一的对手，只有美国。
Kaylan pa tayo sa mga insikto na yan
Is this an act of war?
China would likely take it as an act of war if the U.S. did the same thing in their Exclusive Economic Zone.
Technically.
Nope. Just an act of Bullying..
China need a leader like PM Netanyahu
The two families have some conflicts inside, so their parents discuss together and make a game of playing water gun, all the family members pay attention to each other's family, after the game is over, their family becomes united and harmonious, which is a good strategy. Faced with huge contradictions such as unemployment, economic recession, gender divide and low fertility rate, China has no reason not to play this game
We have the oldest map! IT"S NOT YOURS~!
This was probably outside of the internationally accepted boundary of China's waters too.
It is 120 km away from the Philippines (in the Philippines exclusive economic zone), and 1200 km away from China.
Too much greed, China!
Black budget defense contractors are loving this
Me and my dad are making tons of money lately. Things are going exactly as planned.
Not good…
The spanish 18th century murillo velarde map shows that the bajo masinloc (scarborough shoal) and the rest of the island chain in the spratlys are recognized as belonging to the Philippines when it was still under Spanish rule.
Meanwhile, china’s historical narrative in the said sea only begun during the 1950s. Early chinese maps show that the southern most territory of China was Hainan. China’s imaginary and belatedly made up 9-dash line has no leg stand on even on their historical narrative.
If that’s true, it was Spanish territory not Philippine’s. Both the Chinese and the Filipinos were fishing and trading in South China Sea much earlier before the Spanish arrived.
@@quarelay2486 Is this comment intended to cause dementia? It's a non-sequitur to the OP's comment and it's also internally contradictory.
@@quarelay2486from Spanish era, this islands or reefs are still under philippine sovereignty
China is trying to break up the international law by defying it at every point it can. It is all about power and money. History isn't part of it. It is just a facade
@quarelay2486 thst spanish territory would have likely fallen under the jurisdiction with the Philippines. I'm not trying to sound mean, but that argument doesn't make sense. The colonial province would have included those islands, most likely.
PROTECT AND SAVE WEST PHILIPPINE SEA, PHL EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE AND BENHAM RISE EAST PHILIPPINE SEA, PHILIPPINES🙏
Its been Chinese territory before the country of Philippine ever existed, don’t pretend to be the victim
@@user-py1jw3kp4pChina is a part of Mongolia since ancient times so don't be play as a victim
@@panda-crux.165 well, you probably don’t know China has 56 ethnic groups, Mongolian is one of them, China has a province called Inner Mongolia. If you ever study Chinese history, you would know it, unfortunately from your ignorant comments, you did not. Regardless of how the Philippine government intends to act, it is futile in the face of China's maritime law enforcement ships, so enjoy the show
@@panda-crux.165and now part of mongol is chinese territory😂, ur point is out if the context
@@henrihns2659 my point is out of context??? Common liars can't accept fact😆
philippines 🇵🇭 need to boykot all of chainese products.and support our own products.lets do did this kahit lang nman d2 sa g boykot ng producks nila
Errr…what products did PH manufactured or produced other than maids, cheap service labours for export and bananas???
malabo yan.. market, tyange pa lng. ano makkita mo doon chinese product.. at yang kinabubuhay nila mga mamayan naten. how much mga stablishment na may employe na tao..
how bout lazada and shoppe...
maraming maapektuahn mapa rider economically we are reliant sa kanila.. we need them more than they need us..
Buy Indonesia made 110meter coastguard vessel atleast 20vessel and deployed all palawan dont worry Chinese made is fake..production
对对对！问题来谁能做谁卖你
Kung patuloy na i provoke ng Pilipinas ang China, tiyak na magiging katulad ito ng Ukraine
Where is the Alliance? Philippines is alone in faceing China! 😢
你们所谓的五眼联盟吗？除了美国，其他四眼，加起来都打不过中国诶。
聯盟有屁用、聯盟也打不過中國
@@zhongguotaiwans why don't you try defeating your population curve and real estate first
1950年我们就打过17国联盟，当时菲律宾也是联盟的一份子！
@@nou8953 现代战争靠科技不靠人口。菲律宾有什么技术，女佣的出口技术吗。😂
U know outside of America back in asia there is alot of asian on asian crime
Australia 🇦🇺 stands with the Phillippines. Stop the Chinese thieves
🇵🇭🇦🇺
Let them Asian b asians mind ya business
Australia？🤣🤣🤣
什么阿猫阿狗都来碰瓷了？
行，把你的税金统统拿给菲律宾，毕竟捍卫自由嘛
this will go on if ph will do nothing
Strategy of Tension operation continues World wide. 1 Samuel 2:1-10🎉
Why is China allowed to do this?
it's like asking why can you eat meat, you can when you can because you can so you can
Why is America allowed to engage war everywhere else in the world? Superpowers do whatever they please…
Because this are belongs to China! Go to search. And see why China also has this territory issue with Vietnam and Indonesian but are good partners. Only Philippine
@@friend5900it does not belong to China.
Why are you allowed to post here?
Pag ako nanjan baka pinasabugan ko sila dinamita haha
菲律宾为什么要纠结于这片海域，他们根本无法对那里进行开发。
China does NOT own or have sovereignty over the South China Sea. Its multi national waters. China is acting aggressively toward ships assisting fishing vessels. Why should Philippines need to elevate their Navy when they do nothing wrong.
The only reason China does this is because they know the US has a weak president. They would not be doing this under another US leader.
🎉😊
The Chinese forgot who's still rules the high sea. They better be careful or face the USN.
you can guess why this is only happening now instead of months ago when the confrontation just began, I mean let me tell you in case you really dont know, it means we are ready to face those ships.
你美国主子在中东挨打都不吱声，给它10个胆子都不敢来中国南海玩火
China: "Let's be friends. Give me all your stuff."
🇵🇭🇯🇵
Its begining to look alot like Christmas. Santas bringing global war
Meh, China has been chest thumping out in the south china sea forever. They wont go to war over it, they don't wanna risk their commerce infrastructure that and due to confucianism and recovery from the one child policy, massive troop losses would lead to a complete revolt against the party. There is a old Soviet saying "China's final warning", it means they will constantly give threats but will never back them up.
No he's not.
Di man lng lumaban ang philippine coastguard!!
This Chinese pple trouble Lord protect the Philippines Island from this evilness,
hsr subays dornse and autoamted cars.
Where is US navy? Chinese search US navy 👍🏻
@FA-Q20China doesn't dare do such provocations when the US Navy is around.
@@LunaticTheCatchina literally has the largest navy in the world. And the U.S. navy is not supposed to enter those waters where this is happening. Because those waters belong to china. Now entering international waters is different, because that is no man’s land.
WSJ, have you got any video clips from China side?
NO wsj NEVER SHOW BOTH SIDE PROOF,ALWAYS
POV video clips wouldn't make any difference on the legality of the situation that the PLA Coast Guard is in the wrong.
China clips wouldn't matter. China can just take these clips then say Philippine illegal vessels trespassing on chinese waters. We are so kind and benevolent that we only water canon their ships instead of sending rockets like US, UK or Israel would. But in reality the location was 100 miles away from Philippines. 500 miles away from China.
@@chrisnoctskie5869 Not to mention it's in the Filipino exclusive economic zone.
@@chrisnoctskie5869 distance is never an issue, which would be fully supported by US, Russia, Britain, France, Germany etc.
The Chinese only know how to use water and rocks 😂
don't know if that hypothesis should be tested to the max...
Comander coastguard is GAY im shy😅😅😅
hindi ko kaya ito. Yung tatay ko nag work sa ship :(
Its all fun and games until the picked on kids cry to the bigger kid, in this case, America and you know America is a paper tiger at this point
Paper tigers don't have nukes and more guns than the rest of the world combined 😂😂😂😂
Why does is say China Coast Guard in English? We don’t have US Coast guard in other languages on our boats
Because US runs the world.😏
@@chaoticstylez says it in English and Chinese because English is the most spoken language in the world. English didn't originate from the US but rather from UK
@@user10u7
*"English didn't originate from the US but rather from UK"*
Why did you add this irrelevancy to your comment?
The original poster did not imply that English originated from the U.S..
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicle because the comment i replied to said “because US runs the world” so I told him that the English language that you see on pretty much every boat isn’t because of the U.S.
@@user10u7
No, you are lying.
The comment says
"Why does is say China Coast Guard in English? We don't have US Coast guard in other languages on our boats"
It does not say "because the US runs the world".
Now thats a decent way to argue...water gun fight! Seawater only, no additives. Saltwater stings enough as it is! Incoming Jellyfish! 🍥 🐡 🦈
Wrong. Water cannons are meant to blast crewman into the sea. If they're hit while treading water, they will drown.
China must keep defending their scs against Philippines intrusion.
You don't know what you are talking
@@tatumarabaca4372 of course I know what I am talking. Go improve your knowledge before commenting here.
NO MORE WAR!
MAGA 2024
We all people can choose with our wallets. Its difficult buying goods which are not made in chine. But ine thing we can do easy. Now is the time China wants to sell their electric cars in EU and other coutrys. Refuse to buy their cars and mobile phones like Huawei, Honor, Oppo and Xaiomi products.
😂
parami rami kayo ng populasyon nyo tapos ngayon mang aagaw kayo ng boundary eh kita naman sa mapa na mas malapit sa pilipinas !!
interest of country syempre...
ang edge nila they can in force power and have military industry.
tayo wala nun.. kaya kundina lng magagawa naten at deplomasya..
kahit ally pa naten ang usa.
ala din naman tayo mabibili kasi we cannot afford it kahit Himars missle.. alangan inbigay ng usa yan syempre interest din nila yan to sell their equiptment..
Lumaban n tayo
Good luck.
Kaliit nga lng ng teretoryo ,,,palag din
china covid virus leader 😂
离我们远点无事，300公里以外无事
@JJ-qr5qz Easy white lung
Wuhan Virus
ZHONGGUO HAI JING
CHINA COAST GUARD
Is this in retaliation for US military’s adding four new military camps on the islands?
No, it's illegal enforcement of Chinese force after their military grew to the capability of forcing their belief of the "9-dash line" in the South China Sea which directly conflicts with the legal exclusive economic zone of the Philippines.
Kayawa nang mga intsika..
This is 120 km away from the Philippines (in the Philippines exclusive economic zone) and 1200 km away from China. Too much greed, China!
Territory is not defined by distance but who found and occupied first, don't be naive
@@hynoor7254 By your logic, Mongolia should've occupied the majority of Russia, Europe, and China. Then the UK should've retaken Malaysia, India, Canada, and many others. Yes?
@@hynoor7254 The Philippines has the Carta Hydrographica y Chorographica de las Islas Filipinas, dating back to 1734. It's a map portraying the Philippines' ownership of West Philippines Sea.
What does China have? The made-up 9-dash line, which began when? Yesterday?
@@hynoor7254 The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) and Hague Ruling already sided with the Philippines and other countries because, based on international law, there is an exclusive economic zone.
But China wants to claim the exclusive economic zones of other countries.
The Philippines was founded thousands of years after China owned this region
So where is the U.S. thought they were helping to protect against this kind of bullying😮
Unfortunately, we're stretched a bit thin. Tactical success is about opportunity. There are several "Art of War" versions. Give "Go Rin No Sho" by Musashi a try. It's an easy read and applies to much more than just war.
We're to busy trying to get rid of Biden and the facist left.😮
Better than using water and rocks😂
Small boats should not stay so closed to a bigger ship
Dont let any Chinese investors come to Philippines. My God let us be known with nothing but with dignity and not be known with everything but borrowed.
then your country would collapse
Yankee puppet
For those interested in history, Galle Trilingual Inscription is one piece of important historical artifact from Ming dynasty, as the result of Admiral Zhenghe's visit to Sri Lanka. He also helped Sri lanka people restored their own king from Indian invasion. Just remember that was centuries before Spain， Dutch and others explored South China Sea.
South China Sea and 10 dash line were set up by the founding fathers of modern China. Why? South China Sea claims are based on historical ground. When China developed silk trading route regions, hundreds of years early than Spain, most people in South East Asia were still aboriginal tribe people living like those in Amazon.
Another piece of history, Sri Lanka had to give their port to China due to Xis debt diplomacy and the insidious BRI
@@AF-cg2esthose claims are your exaggeration. It is a fix term lease arrangement to improve port operations, otherwise Sri Lanka could not turn out any profit
@@zhuangdavid5037 The 9 dash line was created by the ROC, with that said mainland China belongs to Taiwan.
@@hangten1904 don't be daft. It was the work of the same Chinese people as a whole. There is one China in the whole wide world.
Ano masasabi mo sen padellia
Mag te-treadmill nalang daw sya
Boat wash
Alam nyo ng hinaharas kau bat di kau nagpasama ng warship ntin... Kung ganunin kau at may warship ntin, birahin nyo pra malaman nila na tayong pilipino ay matapang at may pninindigan...
哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈😂😂😂
Fto!
Aha naman ang USA 😜😜😜
🤣🤣🤣
WWlll has started , Russia-Ukraine, Israel-Hamas, China-Asian countries
US IS involved in all of them 😂😂😂😂
Nah,Malaysia and singapore,north korea is side of China at least for now
Hanggang kaylan pO taU ngpp buli sA China,,,,,
If Commies rule China it's not China !
Tarantado talaga mga.chinese nato
Why us is everywhere
Why Pe Ya deflect
Water fight! He squirted me first! But he called me a name first!
I'm telling my Daddy!
Chinese hypocrisy 😂
"Let's make the U.S. bad for doing bad things, then do exactly what the U.S. did in the past that we criticize"
-🇨🇳
Free ship - wash
Hence the PH should NOT complain.
Water cannons are weapons just like any other intended to incapacitate a vessel -- crewman cannot operate atop their own decks because of the risk of being blasted into the sea. If a water cannon hits a man overboard, he will drown.
Philippines: "Hello big brother US, China splashed me again."
US: (Builds 2 new bases)
Water cannons are weapons, they're not "splashing water", they're trying to blast crewmen into the sea to drown.
If the Filipino didn’t let the U.S.A. leave the base in the first place these Chinese will not build bases and own the entire sea. Now they are trying to take over coz they have the military power.
Yep!
That's how it works.
Sadly how humanity works look at Japan they want to own everything like what china is doing now. Unfortunately a lot of people died and innocent civilians vaporized. Now they are pacifist nation.
菲律宾投降吧
China stop bullying and lying about what is legally yours and what is not.
Hypocrisy at its finest.
China is acting out exactly what China criticized the U.S. of doing.
中国停止欺凌和撒谎，不要再说什么是合法的，什么不是。
虚伪至极。
中国正在做的正是中国批评美国所做的事情。
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicle菲律宾为它美爹惹怒中国，就应该付出代价。我还觉得水炮不过瘾，应该直接开火把船轰沉。你应该庆幸中国的仁慈，如果是美国早就找个理由对菲律宾开战了😊
Free boat wash!😂
Looks like Russian intent, I'm bigger, "submit"!!!
菲律宾的船真是太脏了需要洗洗了，麻烦负一下洗船费好吗？