INTERVIEW | Parakala Prabhakar: ‘Cylinders to the poor, airports to a friend’
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 сер 2023
- The political economist believes that even if BJP were to lose in the 2024 Lok Sabha election, its brand of politics will not go away anytime soon.
Read the story here: frontline.thehindu.com/politi...
Credits:
R.K. Radhakrishnan
Shikha Kumari A.
Sambavi Parthasarathy
Abhinav Chakraborty
Saatvika Radhakrishna
Subscribe to Frontline: frontline.thehindu.com/online...
Follow us on:
Facebook - / frontlineindia
Twitter - / frontline_india
Instagram - / frontline.magazine
Institutions are dying , true, already died. CBI , ED , CAG ,Planning commission ,Election commission, CVC fall into this category.....
Dying or active!? In 60 years of Khangress rule how many ministers were raided!? Except PVNR and Jagan Mohan Reddy that too after they rebelled, any minister was raided, arrested and recoveries made!? Why!? Because all are khangis!? Until BJP became powerful enough to question any enquiries made by ED, CBI on curruption.. How many times 356 was imposed!? Is there meaning to it!? Now so many are caught but government is bad!?
Only institution which us working is ITALIAN BAR WAITRESS DYNASTY inside KHANGRESS
@@subbaraotanguturu9271true you came to power promising change yes or no.?
What you did is just opposite. You are just taking revenge no matter what happens to the country.
Name one such public interest project other than selling PSU’s. Who owns them?
Corruption is not visible? Talk any subject. We the people don’t want Congress or BJP or X, promise and forget.
Do you have the means to ask those promised? You with this blame and take revenge way’s feeling happy? Soon you will feel the opposite unless you are planning to send your children abroad.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271what you talking about 365 don't you feel you are betraying others? Don't you know how many Govts has been dislodged using money power which is worst then 356. How many institutions has been compromised? Are you the only educated person to find out everything going is all well? What about raids only nearing election of a state and that too only opposition? What about corruption of Adani why not investigate? Etc etc
@@ojoao5237 What non BJP governments which are ruling the states doing? How many corrupt in their governments, parties are raided? How many were raided for nearly 6 decades. Only PVNR and Jagan found. What about Momta, Stalin, Jagan so on. How many of their people raided!? Saw how worst WB is in corruption? Because of central agencies they are caught otherwise they are doing it continuously and enjoying the booty. How is it wrong!? No party dares to raid their own. It's a stark reality.
True. It may take a few years to wipe this out. We have gone back to stone ages almost.
Afghanistan may seem ideal for u guys.. isn't it
@@solicitor7793Yeah you can only compare it to Afghanistan.
Then you haven't read about stone age, please read ncert books. You are noob
Atleast NOW we have a chance to take a U-TURN....return to the road of Unity IN Diversity.... and make the country proud..
Better late, than n e v e r 😮😮😮
All is not lost there is hope still
Thanq sir
U opened up the hypocrisy of the present dispensation...
Really great!!
Idiot..airport dev bhikariko dega kya?..
India needs such daring and true Nationalists🎉
Patriots. We need more patriots than nationalists. Nationalism follows a blind path to defend one’s nation, while patriotism works on the flaws to make a better nation.
Like Modi ji ❤
Nationalist word is in itself not very clear. Simple. Better call an informed and wise person.
Why is he asking wife to work then
To tell the truth, one needs to have Moral Integrity transcending one’s religious and political convictions. Parakala Prabhakar and a few others possess it in plenty. God bless him and the others like him.
Blind hate to Modi actually.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271blind devotion to Modi isn’t good either
These are very serious points, which were earlier seen as just anti incumbency social media cries. Those days are gone by. Like Mr. Prabakar said, India as we know is dying a slow death.
A crucial challenge we now have, perhaps, is how are these thoughts going to be conveyed to the not so informed electorate of our country.
It is really alarming situation at present and very few people understand the the gravity of situation due to lack of real education.
I don't know much but people need to change their attitudes, look at the West, Europe etc we do need aesthetics, rights of the lower strata, workers rights, foe, dignity for jobs , indian attitudes do need to change
Rest assured that the electorate is fully informed and know that 75 years was not enough for previous dispensations to set social inequities right. In fact such people actively foment hatred just by sounding very superior to the common man and have ignored his problems. Very bombastic but nothing on the ground. What he says is true but not the whole truth.
Then how previously the uneducated people choose the right govts??
No use of any discussion No body wants this govt but unable to remove them from the power please think about the forward castes 'agony of not having any reservation quota for the last 76 years They have become downtrodden and now they became pauper by the hatred of this govt
After a long time Mr Prabhakar. I really miss your Wednesday episodes
Correct analysis of the present situation and things that happened during the last 9 years.
Shocking and disturbing to listen to such an enlightened interview. Thankyou.
The last point he made was the most horrifyingly pertinent... The seeds of hatred have indeed been sown so deep that it could take a couple of decades for sanity to return to India
Sad state of affairs but Andhbhakts think otherwise.
Hatred by who, when you have other religions persecuting hindus, yes thats hate.
Treat your self man..There is no hate...Hindus are still marginalised ..Our temples are ruled by Govt, but not a Mosque or church!!?
@@vikkumar9301 radical Hindus; as we have observed during the Modi regime are as uncouth & ghatiya as their radicalised Muslim counterparts. Too much religious discourse & narrative by any community will give rise to animosity among others & we've gone so overboard with Hindu khatre me hain, that ab Hindu logic khatre me padh Gaya hai
@@Bharathfirst-ou6os there's no hate ???😆😆😆 I am empathetic towards the blind, so I'll be sober with you
He is nirmala sitaraman husband..How mature are these guys .They both must be respecting the political differences of each other
Then why we are hearing about this great economist only now.Where was he tii now? We never saw his articles pertaining to economics in any of the newspapers or in main tV channels.The fact even after coming out of London school of Economics where was this economist.Suddenly appeared before some TV channels which are anti Modi.Anyway all the best for him.
He spoke long ago but we didn't pay a heed
Look he is giving an absolute toxic opinion of our economy, society, and politics. And I am sure that his marriage is definitely on the rocks!!He is not rational nor is he objective
Also he belongs to TRS!
@@nondescripthumanHe all know what happened to INDIA under SO CALLED GREAT ECONOMIST POPPAT SINGH😂😂😂
Mr Parakala Prabhakar articulates systematically and clearly what you and me are thinking about the future of our beloved country with fear and trembling: slow and planned destruction of every ideal we hold dear, namely, secularism, fraternity and harmony among people of all religions and ideologies, democratic values, institutions that safeguard human rights and all what our Constitution stands for. Congratulations Sir!
Secularism thrived as a ten percent ultra pacific minority were dispossessed and violently banished from Kashmir. When first the Marxists and now TMC employs jihadi violence to stay in power. When the Kerala LlA Speaker tells thousands of students that Ganapathy and other Hindu gods are myths: The same person extolled his own Islamic faith to high heaven at other fora. When Hindu religious processions are routinely attacked by the peaceful group and Hindus are invariably blamed for the ensuing violence. When pastors in Tamil Nadu openly exhort people to attack Brahmins and everyone laughs it off.
These observations and thoughts should reach the masses.English language has a very short reach in this country.
He himself is a millionaire. Did you know that? And if he wanted he could convince his wife Nirmala Sitharaman. But he doesn't.
You know why? Because he is making money from this interview, and he is only saying because BJP didn't give him a ticket.
Bjpand Modi govt in last nine years weakend democratic institutions such as parliament judiciary office of president and vice president office of speaker rbi election commission ed cbi it Universityies mediaetc.strength of democracy means safeguarding institutions freedom and their strength but I am worried.
@@rajx7120You mean all the stuff he said is lie ?
Listening to Parakalaji is always very enlightening.We would like to listen from him on regular basis.
Agree with you.👍🙏
He must continue his "Midweek Matters"
@@trivenisangamWhat is their to continue? Go back to Panditji’s socialism and the lower rung at the world stage. Socialism is no more the catchword except for Congress and the Commies!
Listening to him would make anyone sleep
Why are you here instead of watching arnabji @@sundaramkumar4041
The Real Indian with a spine.... ❤❤
He and his type has no spine. They would have given Kashmir to Pakistan on a plate.
@@vinodchauhan8304he is the husband of Nirmala Seetharaman 😅😅😅
@@kiranchand23😂 he perhaps is envious of his illustrious wife under who's watch and Modi's guidance Bharat has done way better than expected. 😂😂
Very very calculated statement of Sri parakar sir He is very appropriate on modi s governance nd I accept parakara s inner voice nd it is a hard truth I salute to Parakara sir 🙏🙏🙏
Very sharp analysis by an expert in economics and politics. Hope this helps at least learned people understand the gravity of our problems. Let’s see what happens in next election.
400+ for NDA
@@Zab10That time life was was smooth Up to some extent all. Were having peace of mind
@@HumbleSubmission dont vote for bjp be a human modis party create violence
@@Zab10 dont vote for bjp please save our country from these hitlers
Sir remove dp dont put dp till our country free from bjp in next election
One of the best and objective analysis of the whole situation in our country for past few years
Sir what a superb interview!!!!
Very good analysis by writer!
And these opinions are perfect!
Only thing is how people are going to understand this and vote accordingly!
People know what they want. Which is not necessarily what YOU think is good for them. This is the hubris of the over-educated underachievers. His wife has done more for the downtrodden than most people.
They do vote. But the EVMs and the EC are programmed by the BJP
@@krishnamurtichandrasekhara2187. With apologies, what has “his wife done for the downtrodden”? And who are “than most people” according to YOU?
@@joymascarenhas3491 nursed the deprived through covid stress and kept starvation at bay without inflationary doles. The others are congress party in particular.
Nursed the deprived?! Bodies floating in rivers, oxygen shortages, vaccine shortages, no planning only self praising.
The situation is indeed worrisome. And Dr.Prabhakar has voiced his concerns very well in his book "The Crooked Timber of New India".
What is indeed worrisome is that even some of the very well educated people I know have fallen for the wrong rhetoric and do not seem to understand what the country is facing today.
Do we have a future, a future of any consequence?!!
Bharat always has a future....it is so
..but whether it's in our life time or not is the question 😂
An in-depth review of the Indian politics in essense ...Great effort !
Ur so dumb to beleive him, without any data and also his fake articulation of data, if same application of procedure is followed than US and whole west is 3rd world. What a dumb way to do make up data.
Superb conversation n truly enlightening to know what is happening around us....
Don't vote for bjp modi party kill bilkinis bano pregnant in godra case
excellent mind opening conversation
V miss Dr. Prabhakar’s video. Sir v respect & love ur opinion & views. Very few knowledgeable educated ppl left to talk on issues . 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Excellent analysis and interpretation
Cautions regarding the future attack in our country by the fundamentalist forces , even their defeats in elections from the economist Dr. P. Prabhakaran should be noted.
Thankyou for this good and insightful discussion
Appreciation for Frontline & Just Big Big Thanks to Parakala Saab...
THANKS FOR PUTTING TRUTH POINT BLANK, SIR.
Wonderful conversation. ❤ honest statement thank you so much for enlightening people of india 🇮🇳 👏
Awesome discussion by Mr Prabhakar.
A very enlightening conversation..
It was very easy to follow and understand..
The real wages have come down drastically....but how many of the common men understands the term, real wage...
Also we are in the 128th position in terms of the per Capita income ..
I fully agree that the vertical split created by hateful vitriolics will not go away even if the bjp loses in 2024...
God save our beautiful country...🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I do agree Mr Parakala sir comments. Toxicity in the name of religion will never go from Indian society.
I totally disagree -- I have loads of evidence to prove otherwise -- The religion based discrimination is creation of COngress in 1950 and they nurtured like anything THINKING it is for eternal -- I have too many hard facts to support this .I personally have seen this
@@spg6651 Give just one example. Now days it has became habit to blame congress for everything launched by Modi.
@@syedmunir2259 Farmers bill = Which was itroduced by Congress -- It was one of best way Farmer income could have been increased BUt what happened .. one year protest on road -- Supported by Congress ?. Who is at loss now ?. It is the poor farmer .. The great economist former Finance minster has told in parliament house our village people can not use UPI / QR / Google pay etc.. Today Rural India simply love using UPI .. What happened sir ?.. Direct benefit transfer DBT is possible thrugh JAM trinity ..Central government mone gets direclt to poor's ;adies account In the past it use to be through State government machinery with 85% leakages as told by Congress PM in 1985. All poor Congress MLA/ MPs became super rich once they elected how ?. There is one party in UP which was in Power and many people use Charter flight oto travel within India and Abroad as well .. They are suppose to represent poor people of India through RAM MANOHAR LOHIA concepts .. there are plenty examples .. I have . In Karnataka state government introduced mindless program where in ladies can use state transport bus free of cost which is useless purposeless and mindless -- Total money lost is now touching 200 crores .. All developmental work has come to a halt in Bangalore .. This is congress . congress means coruption .. BJP is no good .. BUT PM MODI is really honest and works for the nation
As if toxicity of successful religion based politics and polity creation , is something new. Islam and its followers very conveniently hide there own past , beliefs and practice.
@@spg6651even this is my personal experience that amount of toxicity that BJP has given to the Indian society is very dangerous!! Stop taking name of Congress for everything
absolutely loved it, what an articulate man
Absolutely perfect truth of the ground reality.
Excellent analysis
Revealing the truth
Absolute delight to hear Mr. Parakala Prabhakar. He seems to have a great understanding about the pulse of politics and society.
He is a leftist. The fact that he can't find a single positive thing to say about the government is how such people discredit themselves.
He has a wonderful understanding but a crooked mind. A sold out intellect who us sold the tickets of prajarajyam and single handed my destroyed a political party of Chiranjeevi
@@vasumurthy47unfortunate that a sanghi is not able to think beyond
@@maryvarghese5718ONLY A RIZEBAG CAN THINK PROPERLY
@@maryvarghese5718 Undortunate that commie gas bags in tow with the chrislamic gas bags can always see beyond the stability of the country & break the country for the sake of lousy abrahamic agenda against the infidels also called as kafirs by the other abrahamic cousin.
Very concise and obvious discourse; excellent for the misinformed lot. We would appreciate a more in-depth analysis leading to what, when and how.
Beautiful narrative. Very aptly put, unfortunately the masses will miss this narative.
I hope Ma'am Nirmala Sitaraman ji watched this 😅
I am sure she is not watching this, now she is busy eating 🍎 apple
How can Mr Prabhakar have such a corrupt stupid arrogant irrational life partner like Nirmala.
Quite enlightening and though provoking interview. Thanks sir!
Excellent analysis!
Thank you Rao Saheb for mincing not word and upright and honest to the point. Such an honesty is such a rarity in India.
Brilliant & sharp conversation.
The irony is India has gone backwards..that is the main concern..😢😢
Excellent revelation. Thank you for this interview
I congratulate Economist Prabhakar for his forthright analysis of current political situation in India.I appreciate his boldness to call a spade a spade.Hats off to him.
Are you any economist or professor of economics!? That poor fellow is paid to speak to a script.
Ucc as wanted by founding father ambedkar is against equality for frontline.
Appreciation ...for discussing the hard fact...exposing the real India ....
Toxicity will never leave BJP because they are people with small minds. Eleanor Roosevelt said: " Small minds discuss people; average minds discuss events; great minds discuss ideas ". Opposition phobia is at the heart of BJP THINKING.
Rahul has great mind, well
@@ganeshnh😂
Thank you for your honest response. So straight forward and courageous.
Always a pleasure to listen to Mr. Prabhakar! He is both erudite and outspoken.
Thank you Frontline for this interview.
Honest, neutral appraisal of the state of the nation. Prabhakar Parakala is a courageous man who loves the Nation.
Modi and Amit shah perform their ministership as Hindu top priests instead of Prime minister and Home minister of the secular country, and Adani as their Apex bank.
Can't be truer 🎉 Salute Sir
What a succinct analysis of the present situation! I have been following Mr. Parakala Prabhakar for almost a year and a half. He puts forth his views with facts, no bombastic language. A very calm and clear voice. Thank you Frontline for such a great interview.
What facts has he presented
My God, I cannot believe that this person is an honest, and sincere Smt. Nirmala Sitaraman's husband purely from the contents in some of the points he has said. Eg. just on one aspect alone.....Mr. Modi never said every citizen will be given Rs.15 lakhs from the black monies. Every educated person who had listened to Mr. Modi's speech in Hindi knows only too well that what he said was the amount of black money if brought back would equal to every Indian citizen having Rs.15 lakhs in their bank accounts. I am mild in my comments only because I do not want to hurt Mrs. Nirmala Sitaraman's reputation in any way. She is too good a person.
Brilliant. Points cogently conveyed . Thank you.
Very refreshing to hear him say there is hope...
😊😊😊
Parakala has espoused the left liberal ‘woke’ paradigm. He wants to go back to the ‘Hindu rate of growth’ of Panditji’s socialism which had brought us to economic nadir. Is it a sign of ‘intolerance of partner’s’ rise in stature?
Prabakar is exactly true but the final heavy loss will be of the beginners....that is the historical truth "We India" ...how intelligent and true are Ambedhkar , Neharu and others....
Very scary situation seems to be in the making.
Lovely discussion. How I wish such individuals get into politics.
he was a BJP guy till few years back
Sir u are an honest man who talks about the reality of india in modis rule! Totally in sync with what u say but sir yr opinions are exact opposite of finance minister of india! Million dollar question to u is how do u manage that? What music do u hear back home?
Truly appreciate you sir we need more men like u in India! Don't change with pressure please!
The sly was putting secularism and socialism in the constitution which was thrown out by ambedkar.
And honest review by educated person is what we want. He is right in many ways saffron crooks government has put their men's in every institutions for their selfish political mileage.
His interview is a testament of how relationships and deep political differences can co exist !
His wife is in Delhi and he lives in Hyd. Although they may not have formally divorced, they're seldom seen together and even on their daughter's wedding, he was nowhere to be seen when FinMin was standing near her daugher and son-in-law. Deep differences between a couple in anything whether ideology, education, morality, financial status and even health condition, eventually erodes the relationship in the conventional sense of the word.
He had to stop his midweek matters incisive commentary abruptly. No prizes for guess where the pressure came from and whether he was happy about stopping midweek matters which was growing in viewership.
So true. BJP has done enough damage to the secular and economic fabric of the country and coming out of this is going to be so difficult which people fail to grasp.
Only a CHRISTIAN ITALIAN BAR WAITRESS DYNASTY can help India out of this HOLE
Simple, clear , concisely and correctly the situation of our country, it's people, government and about the future has been spoken by this gentleman. Looking forward to more such interviews and content. Thanks
Hatred for India and Hindus by the Hindu newspaper and frontline.
We need people like him
The toxicity is being nurtured since 1922
Husband of Finance Minister😂😂
looks like finance minister Nirmala Sitaraman seem to be not in talking terms with her hubby Parakala.... Pls talk madam...
Excellent commentary on the present state of affairs from a very perceptive thinker.
Thanks a ton.
The bigger tragedy than Modi-BJPee is to accept the fact that this man is married to Nirmala Sitharaman.😂😂
Now a days I keep on watching your discussions talks and debates. They are all acting as eye openers and giving a clear picture of today's India. Really worth watching. ❤
Leadership may be given by people like this author. Must be given .
Please god, make his wife think sensibly like him and work for the actual betterment of the ordinary citizen and also to stop lying to save her political boss.
Great interview and very interesting, informative talk by Parakala Sir.
Dr. P. Prabhakar has well analysed and exposed the current political scenarios, its implications on Indian Democracy under a fascist regime. Well done.
Many political families follow this strategy. One member part of ruling party other part of opposition. This is a safe bet in case of change of power. May be there is an understanding between Ms Nirmalaji & her husband.
I always expect a databased discussions from an expert. However, sorry to say, that is completely missing in this discussions. I found the discussions totally negative on the present situation, without being backed by any data ! Hence, to me , the discussion is totally meaningless !
Pls b the chief advisor for the new PM😊 you have so much of logic, good genuine strategy n briefing in ur talks..
He is a very intelligent human being.
Good old crap from Prabhakar! The economic development numbers and the growth of Bharat in the last 3-4 years speak the truth. Bharat is # 5 economy in the World today and he heading to #3. Why do we need such theoretical analysis which does not consider and cannot explain the current development of Bharat. The reality of Bharat is different and progressive, no matter what Prabhakar thinks and says.
Respect sir...
Perhaps Prabhakar does not read the rest of the world news and understand what’s happening around.
Democracy is dying slowly at the centre but it is in acoffin in state óf Kerala,w.bengal and Tamil Nadu etc
Excellent updates Sir, Hope People will Come up to the expection by 2024 & save the Nation
BEAUTIFUL INTERVIEW. A MUST WATCH.
Mr. Prabakar is trying convey as though all the problems of India have started from 2014 when in reality many problems date back to partition & misgovernance over the years. Some problems have been amplified over the last few years while some have subsided. Unless there is a nuanced view it will lack credibility.
He's nothing else but a Communist n Leftist minded person ! Only trying to misguide the common man against the BJP.... these people are not learned experts only good for nothing burden to the country 😅
5 th economy is bad for this guy
In Gujarat, Rajkot High court batch Judge delivered judgment quoting the Manusmriti section for supporting it. This is a mockery of the Constitution Thanks to both Gentlemen for Honest discussion on present condition.
For muslims you got Pakistan and Bangladesh, so please make a plan to settle there
Were the social fabrics of our country were not torn during partition?
During emergency also
Beavo gentleman..You have spoken for the silent majority..We are surely living in lala land..I salute both gentlemen..May God grant health,peace and God's protection upon you both.
How can he barried the toxic nirmala sitaraman?
Day by day....the democracy is vanishing its beauty bcz of Modi & his co team...
The Nation is in danger in all issues... It should be avoided at war foot basis... Jai Bhim 👍
A must watch
Parakala prabhakar intellectual /highly educated.... He has great credibility in southern states
The whole world is talking about India “This is exactly what I was telling my friends in India.”
They (Pee M + BJ Pee + RSS Hindutva) have sown the seeds of HATRED and this will take a long time to heal. When will the Healing take place?When all the people who have sowed the seeds of HATRED are Self-destroyed.
This gentleman is a husband of Nirmala Sitaraman. This guy is honest.
'The' would have been more appropriate than "a" husband😊