Yeah, but i believe they got it wrong in a way, I'm pretty sure the drawing was done after the murder, not before. Still creepy but it makes sense right? Since within the board game, the more letters you open, the more time passes within the game.
Fun fact: often when strangulation victims have scratch marks on their neck/chest, the scratches tend to come from the victim themselves accidentally injuring themselves while trying to free their neck from the hands of their attackers.
@@danielpleitez-martinez7638 they are using their hands against the attacker. In a state of panic, you're going to do whatever you can to get their hands off. That includes scratching and trying to pry their attackers hands away. Hang victims who try to resist also often have scratch marks on their neck from trying to free themselves from the noose.
@@danielpleitez-martinez7638 and if ya think about it, scratching your attacker is smart, because at least if you die, their DNA will be under your nails!
They're supposedly getting their own studio space in the next year -- so with a lot more room to themselves, this doesn't seem out of the realm of possibility.
The only thing I've noticed, though I haven't finished watching it yet, but they focused on the wrong time in the call logs. They focused on the morning phone call conversations. The 21:11 phone is what they should have focused on.
That sounds fun, but it would probably take away the “disturbing” factor of working with realistic evidence and disembodied voices and stuff. Find the killer irl tends to get goofy real quick
@@daphne-bai maybe they can record the final outcome IRL with the cast as different suspects that way we get the disturbing aspect but also the crew can show off their acting chops
the reading at the end was soooo gooodddd. like damnn the EMOTION!! i wish kids and also teachers in school would read like this. couse it just gets soooo boringggg
In some of my English classes back in high school, we would get to whenever we read something in play form so everyone could be assigned characters. Whoever was in the scene at the time got to stand up in front of the class too so that energy was there. It definitely was fun.
The voicemails on 29:11 are so crucial! The second voicemail could be Robyn spray painting Charlie’s car, the fourth one could be the murder itself and the fifth one could be Robyn carving a word into the tree!
Not them looking at the wrong time at 12:45 😭. Good thing they still had the correct intuition as Susan was on call for 33 minutes starting at 9:11 and ending at 9:44, clearing her
Fun. I think you guys can write down your staff's names and draw them to randomly replace the characters in the game. You guys can play it like they're in an alternate universe or something. Keep up the great content. I immensely enjoy your videos. Thank you for the hard work.
this part 2 is everything i could have ever asked for on this lovely sunday 🤪❤️ also our crime solving team is looking very very beautiful in this video 😘please please please do more - i’m obsessed with this series
Someone please give Kimmy and Sage an Emmy or an Oscar or some sort of award for that last interview scene - WOW. And wait...so they DID email Neeta first?! I gotta say, I was all in on Neeta after the affair reveal. Now I kinda want to see what the email response is for sending Neeta's name.
Wait though, when they read the phone log for the veterinary practice, they were looking at 9 in the morning hour, it's in military time. Wasn't the murder at night? Got me hot stressed.
Yeah because if they had read it correctly they would have been able to check that she called her lawyer for about 30 min and then Aura right after and Aura didn't pick up.
My Wife and I just finished watching both parts and man, what an ending!!! Kimmy takes the cake for that performance 🏆🏆🥇🥇 we really enjoy these kind of videos and hope the team will continue to do more of them.
Please please please do a couple more of these. You guys are so entertaining to watch and this whole murder mystery thing is such a great video concept.
‘Same old story, not much to say, hearts are broken every day.’ You Were Meant for Me, by Jewel! Did y’all not recognize that? It may’ve been an important song…
Great mystery, and damn Kimmy and Saige's cold reading of the confession was fantastic! Top notch acting. Also would love to watch more of this gang doing hunt a killer mysteries
Hi, first time commenting here so sorry for the awkwardness. I saw your comment about the Alice/Bob code and, being a cipher nerd myself, I can't help but want to contribute a bit to people who are interested. I'll try my best to explain since it's not really my strong suit 😁(and English is not my native language, either.) So, the Alice and Bob code is a form of public-key cryptography called Diffie-Hellman key exchange, where two people exchanges their keys and while the pother people can see the key, they don't have the full perspective to decipher the code themselves. The idea takes a prime number p (in this case, p = 17) and a primitive root modulo g (in this case, g = 3. I think there's a page on Wikipedia explaining better than me what a primitive root modulo is, so I won't delve deeper than that.) To generate a secret code, Alice and Bob will choose a random number between 1 and p-1 (we'll call this a for Alice and b for Bob. In the video, a = 7 and b= 15) and calculate A = (g^a mod p) and B = (g^b mod p), respectively (Normally, this will not be revealed to people in public like the video shows. The public will only know A and B). Then, Alice will calculate B^a mod p, and Bob will calculate A^b mod p. This will give them the same number, which is the shared key needed to solve the code. Let's try to do this: Alice: A = 3^7 mod 17 = 11 and sends 11 to Bob. Bob gets: 11^15 mod 17 = 14 Bob: B = 3^15 mod 17 = 6 and sends 6 to Alice. Alice gets: 6^7 mod 17 = 14. So the shared key is 14! Now onto the footnote: HvwgkwzzbchvoddsbouowbBwq (I think the cast got a few characters wrong in the video). Once you get 14, shift the footnote 14 letters back and you get: ThiswillnothappenagainNic or "This will not happen again, Nic." So, basically, it's a secret warning from the company to Nic, who is suspected of drug exchange (if I got that right from the video). Of course, it might be easier to just brute force the cipher. Nevertheless, thought I would share it here for people who are curious like me. Hope that helps! 😄
I have personally worked on Criminal Cases and this was a good watch. Timelines, witnesses , and twists lol. I thought this was gonna be like work but this was a satisfying watch.- brw
Please do more of these I can't find other channels that do these types of murder mystery boardgames that is interactive and has so many efforts and props put into it. Love this i hope it turns into a regular thing
You could say that Gavin was partially responsible for his death because he was so out of it with the drugs and alcohol, it left Charlie basically defenceless, and he might have been able to fight off the murderer if he had been sober!
I love that the clues were were so detailed; that the group worked well together and was genuinely committed to solving the game. 😊 This is how I'd the play, so it was fun to pretend we were playing together; plus this group vibe and bangin' background track were pretty calming to my anxiety (despite the sometimes suspenseful rhythm and their convo being about fake murder lol) Side note: those voicemails sent a bit of a chill down my spine- I'm with ya, Kimmy 😖 This is now one of my fave videos and I'd definitely love to see another mystery game episode. Well done.🤘🏾
Damn Kimmy's acting at the end was impeccable
exactly
[NO RESPONSE]
Yes! The climax of Robin's confession was great
I rewatched in 3 times. She did great
That kid's drawing is probably the scariest part about this. It's going to haunt me forever.
yeah, i'm deeply uncomfortable with that picture.
poor dad pie
Yeah, but i believe they got it wrong in a way, I'm pretty sure the drawing was done after the murder, not before. Still creepy but it makes sense right? Since within the board game, the more letters you open, the more time passes within the game.
I relate to Tommy when he said, "I'm giving a lot of signals that I won't be helpful today." 🤣
Fun fact: often when strangulation victims have scratch marks on their neck/chest, the scratches tend to come from the victim themselves accidentally injuring themselves while trying to free their neck from the hands of their attackers.
That’s more interesting than fun. But huh. The more you know
That really helps me understand more
Really, seems unlikely bc they’d be pushing or or defending themselves and using their hands or feet against the attacker
@@danielpleitez-martinez7638 they are using their hands against the attacker. In a state of panic, you're going to do whatever you can to get their hands off. That includes scratching and trying to pry their attackers hands away. Hang victims who try to resist also often have scratch marks on their neck from trying to free themselves from the noose.
@@danielpleitez-martinez7638 and if ya think about it, scratching your attacker is smart, because at least if you die, their DNA will be under your nails!
"There's not as much about Antonio"
Proceeds to list a bunch of evidence linking him to drug trafficking
@@darthvidar-spiller5343 wow
They were right though, that had nothing that gave reasonable evidence for him to have murdered Charlie, because he didn’t.
kimmy did such a great job reading at the end, got chills hearing her read out the confession
If this series continues,i think you should make a spy room set. Like police room for solving cases. That should be dope
Oooh or like, an interrogation room!
Ooh, with a corkboard and the red string. Yes please.
They're supposedly getting their own studio space in the next year -- so with a lot more room to themselves, this doesn't seem out of the realm of possibility.
This is where sage shines she leads games really well ⭐ would watch a series of theses 💯
The only thing I've noticed, though I haven't finished watching it yet, but they focused on the wrong time in the call logs. They focused on the morning phone call conversations. The 21:11 phone is what they should have focused on.
Oh man love it 😍 I would love to see more
Seriously! I *love* her hosting all this tabletop game content. She's a total natural.
All that dnd paying off
She leads well, she's also good at hosting and presenting. She does it so naturally and effortlessly
Y’all should do a IRL version of this with current and last members of smosh playing different characters
Past* not last
That sounds fun, but it would probably take away the “disturbing” factor of working with realistic evidence and disembodied voices and stuff. Find the killer irl tends to get goofy real quick
@@daphne-bai maybe they can record the final outcome IRL with the cast as different suspects that way we get the disturbing aspect but also the crew can show off their acting chops
I hope you guys continue playing Hunt A Killer, its so much fun to watch
the reading at the end was soooo gooodddd. like damnn the EMOTION!! i wish kids and also teachers in school would read like this. couse it just gets soooo boringggg
so tru!
readings like this could break the ice in discussions
In some of my English classes back in high school, we would get to whenever we read something in play form so everyone could be assigned characters. Whoever was in the scene at the time got to stand up in front of the class too so that energy was there. It definitely was fun.
@@cassandracarlton400 I once did a funny fainting during a line read like that and immediately smashed my head on the TV cart.
When I read Macbeth I read with a Scottish accent
The voicemails on 29:11 are so crucial! The second voicemail could be Robyn spray painting Charlie’s car, the fourth one could be the murder itself and the fifth one could be Robyn carving a word into the tree!
*Noah Killed This Detective Work, Good Job!* *Kimmie's Acting Was Amazing*
Someone give Kimmy an Oscar for that performance 😂
I sincerely hope that Kimmys boyfriend doesn’t break up with her. Her acting as Robyn was WAY too real
oh yeah, Kimmy is definitelly kill capable. There were signs way before this episode
good thing they got married, lets hope it stays that way
The real mystery is the Fanny pack!
Seriously... WTF
Did they even open it!? There definitely could have been something in there from back in the day.
@@johnchristensen9710 yes when tommy took it he opened it and looked inside!
Sometimes investigators get lot of things that are not relevant
When you are real time investigating ...Not everything you get is worth your time
I need this group to do this more often. I loved how they fed off each other.
Not them looking at the wrong time at 12:45 😭. Good thing they still had the correct intuition as Susan was on call for 33 minutes starting at 9:11 and ending at 9:44, clearing her
Thank you!!! Military time is a thing. 😂
I bet who ever does Noah’s hair (I am assuming he is getting it professionally done) gets very excited when they see him on their book for the day.
I kinda hope he just walks in everytime & when they ask what he wants this time, he always just shrugs and lets them do whatever. xD
Someone asked him on his Twitch stream once and he said his girlfriend does it
@@Lallyisaw3som3 That makes sense.
I always thought some practicing stylist/beautician was doing it
YOOOOO Kimmy at the end ABSOLUTELY KILLED IT
Fun. I think you guys can write down your staff's names and draw them to randomly replace the characters in the game. You guys can play it like they're in an alternate universe or something. Keep up the great content. I immensely enjoy your videos. Thank you for the hard work.
These comments have a shocking lack of Kimmy praise for that amazing cold read monologue.
The old love irregular polygon. One man, one crazy ex, one closet bi wife, and one gay old friend. Tale as old as time.
Unfortunately
It's always love.
I wanna know about the whole Neeta schtick. You emailed her name first? How did that turn out???
this part 2 is everything i could have ever asked for on this lovely sunday 🤪❤️ also our crime solving team is looking very very beautiful in this video 😘please please please do more - i’m obsessed with this series
Even though I know how this one ends because I solved it a while ago I love watching you guys go through this. Please do more!
I need to know: what did the footnote in the NDA mean??
(sorry, I might have missed them explaining it in the vid😅)
Yea and what’s with the Fanny Pack?
@@56848ful It says "this will not happen again Nic" !!
@@B__Optimistic absolutely no idea 😂
@@amytaylor686 Thank you!!
These 4 as a kooky crime solving team, id watch that TV Series ❤
There's so many great Hunt a Killer series and I'd love to see the Smosh team do some more. The quality of it is really good and I love the creators.
please do hunt a killer more. its so fun watching you all trying to solve a murder together.
been waiting for the second part!!! so excited :-) smosh is DELIVERING the content today
This game got my heart raising like it was an actual murder case.
We believe in Kimmy Jimenez supremacy! This waa such a good game. Hope you get to play another Hunt A Killer game again!
I legit thought Kimmy was crying at the end. Such a wonderful acting!! PLS DO MORE HUNT A KILLER YALL R SO ENTERTAINING TO WATCH
I really appreciate the subtle 'Who killed Markiplier?' nod with the lightning anytime someone said murder.
Someone please give Kimmy and Sage an Emmy or an Oscar or some sort of award for that last interview scene - WOW.
And wait...so they DID email Neeta first?! I gotta say, I was all in on Neeta after the affair reveal. Now I kinda want to see what the email response is for sending Neeta's name.
No. Before they emailed, they ruled out Neeta from the suspect list.
Same! I really want to know what the email reply said! I really thought it'd be her
Man Kimmy's acting at the end was intense. Way to go
I think my favorite part is noticing how they, as people who live in a big metro area cannot fathom it taking only taking 10 minutes to get somewhere.
Wait though, when they read the phone log for the veterinary practice, they were looking at 9 in the morning hour, it's in military time. Wasn't the murder at night? Got me hot stressed.
I got stressed by the voice mail with scraping noise. She was scraping the tombstone
That was the first thing that got me of the log as well.
Definitely Military time. They were reading the wrong thing but still reached the correct conclusion. Happens sometimes I guess..
Yeah because if they had read it correctly they would have been able to check that she called her lawyer for about 30 min and then Aura right after and Aura didn't pick up.
I was on the edge of my seat the last half of the episode, I couldn't stop figiting in anticipation as you all solved it!! SUCH a good video! :)
This was so exciting to watch! Kimmy's acting at the end was so good!
My Wife and I just finished watching both parts and man, what an ending!!!
Kimmy takes the cake for that performance 🏆🏆🥇🥇 we really enjoy these kind of videos and hope the team will continue to do more of them.
Please please please do a couple more of these. You guys are so entertaining to watch and this whole murder mystery thing is such a great video concept.
Smosh crew putting that grind in like for real putting out so many different videos and all of them been so great taking over the world
i totally got what noah was saying about robin not being the murderer but the desecrator. i mean, how sloppy of a murderer u gotta be to do that?
Sage and kimmy’s acting is some of the best work ever. Especially kimmys monologue
the video really be 50 minutes we love consistency
This was my favorite Hunt A Killer thus far. I still have the alien socks, and my husband still uses the beer coozy lol. Such a fun mystery!
Saige's squeaks at 32:30 are seriously the best thing ever OMG They were adorable but also showcased her child-like heart ❤️
‘Same old story, not much to say, hearts are broken every day.’
You Were Meant for Me, by Jewel!
Did y’all not recognize that? It may’ve been an important song…
out here watching everything smosh came out with for the past month or so, gotta watch'em all!!
Saige's makeup is always amazing!
Right! It’s so cute that she makes herself look like she’s 14 years old.
@@stephanie7142 😆
I’m so attracted to serious noah right now
4:19 Her thinking about it and then saying that is so funny
Even rewatching this Kimmy's monologue gave me chills
Great mystery, and damn Kimmy and Saige's cold reading of the confession was fantastic! Top notch acting. Also would love to watch more of this gang doing hunt a killer mysteries
Bro was getting cheated on and got liked by the ex he didn’t care about, talk about messy relationships like damn bro sheesh
some dude- you have 50 mins to live
me- *watches this video*
IM SO EXCITED I WATCHED THE FIRST ONE TODAY AND I COULDNT WAIT FOR PART TWO
Can these four PLEASE do more of these?!?!
Please make more of these! I loved following this story
I had to put in headphones cause Sage's occasional wistlenote laugh in this vid was freaking my dog out. Personally I find it super cute!
Another game uploaded in the morning = A lovely morning. :)
That was CRAZY GOOD!!!!!! Loved the ending, Kimmy and Saige’s was so good! I love these games!
The way they all lean in to listen to the voicemail with elbow on table and hand under chin. Adorable.
Loved this but was kinda hoping the Alice/Bob code thing would be explored more
Hi, first time commenting here so sorry for the awkwardness. I saw your comment about the Alice/Bob code and, being a cipher nerd myself, I can't help but want to contribute a bit to people who are interested. I'll try my best to explain since it's not really my strong suit 😁(and English is not my native language, either.)
So, the Alice and Bob code is a form of public-key cryptography called Diffie-Hellman key exchange, where two people exchanges their keys and while the pother people can see the key, they don't have the full perspective to decipher the code themselves. The idea takes a prime number p (in this case, p = 17) and a primitive root modulo g (in this case, g = 3. I think there's a page on Wikipedia explaining better than me what a primitive root modulo is, so I won't delve deeper than that.)
To generate a secret code, Alice and Bob will choose a random number between 1 and p-1 (we'll call this a for Alice and b for Bob. In the video, a = 7 and b= 15) and calculate A = (g^a mod p) and B = (g^b mod p), respectively (Normally, this will not be revealed to people in public like the video shows. The public will only know A and B). Then, Alice will calculate B^a mod p, and Bob will calculate A^b mod p. This will give them the same number, which is the shared key needed to solve the code. Let's try to do this:
Alice: A = 3^7 mod 17 = 11 and sends 11 to Bob. Bob gets: 11^15 mod 17 = 14
Bob: B = 3^15 mod 17 = 6 and sends 6 to Alice. Alice gets: 6^7 mod 17 = 14.
So the shared key is 14! Now onto the footnote: HvwgkwzzbchvoddsbouowbBwq (I think the cast got a few characters wrong in the video). Once you get 14, shift the footnote 14 letters back and you get: ThiswillnothappenagainNic or "This will not happen again, Nic." So, basically, it's a secret warning from the company to Nic, who is suspected of drug exchange (if I got that right from the video).
Of course, it might be easier to just brute force the cipher. Nevertheless, thought I would share it here for people who are curious like me. Hope that helps! 😄
@@quangvu6765 whoaaa it's very helpful!
These murder/whodunit games are awesome! I really hope you guys continue to do these on Board AF! Well done!
Really enjoyed the two episodes! You guys should do more hunt a killer
More of these please! This is ridiculously entertaining to watch!
I have personally worked on Criminal Cases and this was a good watch. Timelines, witnesses , and twists lol. I thought this was gonna be like work but this was a satisfying watch.- brw
I know that there's an upvoted comment about Kimmy's acting, just wanted to repeat it: she is so good!
Please do more of these I can't find other channels that do these types of murder mystery boardgames that is interactive and has so many efforts and props put into it. Love this i hope it turns into a regular thing
Kimmy's acting was on POINT.... That whole thing was INTENSE
I love these longer game videos! Pls keep making them!
I need more of this. I am vary invested and the music with this video, plus everyone just getting more invested into the lore. its great!
I love how into it they all got. So much fun!!
I love these hunt a killer videos, please keep making them
Yay the resolution! This was a really interesting case and it was fun watching you solve it! Lots of fun twists and turns.
Please do more of these! I was so invested the whole time
Yes please do this as a series and do it in an investigation room. I love this!!’
50 minutes?????????? Please more of this!!!! This is a w e s o m e !
Please continue this series! It is so good, immersive and interesting!
I need more videos like these!! So much fun and I love how everyone gets super into it!
You could say that Gavin was partially responsible for his death because he was so out of it with the drugs and alcohol, it left Charlie basically defenceless, and he might have been able to fight off the murderer if he had been sober!
Definitely want to see more of these! Sage and Kimmy must always be a part of these! They are awesome!!
I love that the clues were were so detailed; that the group worked well together and was genuinely committed to solving the game. 😊
This is how I'd the play, so it was fun to pretend we were playing together; plus this group vibe and bangin' background track were pretty calming to my anxiety (despite the sometimes suspenseful rhythm and their convo being about fake murder lol)
Side note: those voicemails sent a bit of a chill down my spine- I'm with ya, Kimmy 😖
This is now one of my fave videos and I'd definitely love to see another mystery game episode. Well done.🤘🏾
Someone get Saige and Kimmy their Oscars for that performance at the end. Amazing
YES I WAS HOPING YOU’D DO PT 2
i love this so much i feel like live streamed or just more vids with more people would be so epic!
would love to see more of these! It was so fun to play along and try to guess the killer
I lived this!!! I would totally watch more Hunt A Killer vids. You all worked together so well!
50 minutes of smosh?
Yes pleaseee💕
Someone give Kimmy a Oscar for that speech at the end. Like oh damn, full chills. 😮
That was PHENOMENAL! BRAVO TEAM! 👏👏👏
I’ve been waiting for this one. TURN IT UP
This was awesome, would love to see another of these!
I would love to watch so much more of you guys playing hunt a killer, it was so cool
Please do more of these, it's so fun seeing you solve mysteries! :)))
I'd love to see sage run more of these. This was so entertaining and well done.
I love when the group reunites to solve cases or just do a fun ttrpg
Please keep doing these! So fun!!