BAND-MAID 'Catharsis' Original + Acoustic | Musician Reaction + In-Depth Analysis
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- Multi-instrumentalist reacts and analyzes 'Catharsis' by BAND-MAID, original and acoustic.
SUBMIT REACTION REQUEST | wavepotter.squ...
or JOIN PATREON: / wavepotter
or JOIN YT CHANNEL MEMBERSHIP: / wavepotter
SHOP: wavepotter.mys...
One-Time Donation: paypal.me/vovw...
Mailing Address:
Wave Potter
PO Box 1434
Hudson, WI 54016
Song at the end: 'Just a Little More' | Wave Potter
• Just a Little More
Vinyl Art Behind Me: Kelsrart / kelsrart
STREAM MY EP ANYWHERE!
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Apple Music: / golden-handcuffs-ep
UA-cam: • Album - Golden Handcuf...
Soundcloud: / wavepotterofficial
SOCIAL MEDIA:
/ wavepotter
/ wavepotter
/ wavepotterofficial
Thank you to all my Patrons!
THANK YOU!
Rosie, my little wildflower
Byron Butterfield
Vladimir Chupin
Mark Zima
Matt Horstman
Steve Hoeltzel
Rahim Rahmat
Rabbi Rabbs
Glen Kelley
Ma3stro78
Michael Gehrman
John
Elf-Inflicted
Rene Gerstbauer
David Goren
Lord Vorador
Erik Christianson
Adam Pearlman
Grady
K C
Aaron Fritts
Jonas S
Glen Black
Glen Srigley
Dean F
Darren Taylor
Matt Heaffy
BadLlama
Karim El Nour
Lewis Smith
David Cook
Vero
Matt TW
Drogon R
Zachary McLaughlin
Mack Lundy
Ryan Mear
Robert Yule
Darrel Bina
William Brennan
Donald Kaake
Gizmotis
Jonas H
Eric Norton
Hiro Evrybear
Bob McSwigan
Ali Cameron
Ron E
Rizki Kamal
Tetsuya Matsuura
patron40silver
Dicodec
Sol Azoth
A Metalhead’s Perspective
Mogis2011
Tim Arnold
Daniel Morgan
Gregg Humphrey
Roy Russell
Lowell Scott
Frantisek Filipcik
Ingvar Tornberg
Jamie Stout
Philip Matin
Rebecca Haigh
Vahe
Andres
Franta F
KD
Cindy Clarkson
JM CM
Kekai Kotaki
BM 4-Life
Adam Lambert
ultragamer66
Robert Burns
ゆう
SefuArt
Bone Deep
聖諺 鄭
SillyVanilli
Carl G
kibs
Tiago Pinto
S0l1ta1re
ou812-5150
Min
Coffee
ELESIO BUCCAT
Leslie Knope
Watch the BAND-MAID Acoustic Okyuji and support them! bandmaid.tokyo/contents/477789
Original video: ua-cam.com/video/tx9h41gaNo0/v-deo.html
POUND LIKE and SUBSCRIBE if you enjoy this! :)
SUBMIT REACTION REQUEST | wavepotter.squarespace.com/
or JOIN PATREON: www.patreon.com/wavepotter
or JOIN YT CHANNEL MEMBERSHIP: ua-cam.com/users/WavePotter...
SHOP: wavepotter.myspreadshop.com
You can find a "plugged" live version of 'Catharsis' on their Live @ Line Cube Shibuya DVD as the 11th track (10th song)
Love is the most powerful force in existence. So at the foundation of this presentation is love. Love of music and performing. The Maids love for each other and for the fans. Love and passion for the setting, costuming and video graphs all present. I feel the love thru the hard work and commitment here. So thankful!
Well said Chris!
I never really realized how complex the drums were in the original song, not just in sheer speed or technique, but all the ghost notes and off beats, the weird rhythm and grooves. Akane said she had a really hard time (or the hardest time) with this song on Conqueror (but take that with a grain of salt, because she's very modest and likes to say things were difficult for her)
Chase Carneson sent me here and I'm glad he did. Truly love this breakdown. Now I've gotta go through all the rest of your BAND-MAID reactions. Especially digging the connections you draw to other forms of art, like the forced-perspective photography analogy. Every comment here is so valuable.
Thanks for taking the time to check it out! That was so kind of him.
This is the best reaction so far. Besides explaining the technical aspects, I appreciate your direct comparison between the 2 songs. You really demonstrated how they changed the vibe of the song and this could be a standalone. This was worth the wait... I've watched the Concert and the Commentary video every day. So sad I only have until March. Blu Ray pleeeease!!!
Thank you so much! I’m glad you appreciated it! And I’m sure there will be a DVD with how much everyone has loved it!
I love these breakdowns!
Thank you Yellow Clip!
Wave don't get to excited or you will wet yourself we know how awesome they are. lol!!😂 the whole thing was supercalafragalisticexpialadoshus, and so was your break down.👍
Why do you think Rosie is always late to the live streams? She's out getting Wave another box of Depends when he has BandMaid on the roster!
🤣Thank you Old Mr B!
That’s actually not a terrible idea... 😅
☕☕☕🤙🏼
You can find the live version on the Line Cube Shibuya Blu Ray. Miku plays those counter notes! I've been waiting for them to put it on their official video channel. It's sooo good. That riff is so catchy.
Love the song love it in acoustic better!
Excellent analysis! Loved the comparison to the original!
Kanami rejects opinions that acoustics have to be soft slow songs lol
I immediately feel in love with CONQUEROR my first listen. It's the BEST album by Band-Maid, so poppy and rock oriented. I get a huge smile on my face every time a song from this album comes on. It's like velvet audio or ear crack. I absolutely love how they integrated pop into these songs, so well done. Catharsis is widely considered a weaker track, but just listen to how much layering and changing is happening.
When the weaker track crushes most other band's songs!
That was a great video Wave 👌🏻
When you switched from the acoustic to the original song, I though you accidentally double the tempo of the song. It was so fast all of the sudden 😅
Oh, how great you are to react more deeply to this song once again. Doesn't it sound more tasty after you've known the original version?😋
You should definitely get the Shibuya DVD, this song is great live (as always) , can see what Kobato is playing😃. It may be a spoiler, but they dive right into another awesome extended intro to "Bubble"
Thank you for once again sharing your valuable insights. I'm glad that you promoted the band's archived stream, and mentioned that it's still available for sell. Good job! At 12:15 I think you're referring to the live video of "Take Me Higher" in which MISA and Kanami inserted a call and response leading up to the studio version's guitar solo
A lot of bands treat playing live as a job. BAND-MAID treat playing live as a passion :)
yes, if i add, as a faith to make the world better with music 💌
👏👏👏👏👏❣👍🤘✌
@@はるとも-d5y Hi HaT. Maidiacs provide the faith that make us all so much of a close-knit family :)
@@rindosolotouring Thank you Koke.🙏
Their passion to always perform at their best is why we love them 🤙🏼
Verse Two: The look on your face was priceless during the double time!!! LOL!!!!!!!
In their audio commentary on this song:
Saiki: This song has a lot of things happening at the same time.
Akane: Because Kanami stuff so much into songs.
Miku: Everybody is so busy.
Kanami: I wonder why I put these riffs into this song.
All except Kanami: You’re complaining now?
Kanami: This riff is difficult to maintain.
Miku: I’m struggling to play this.
Saiki: You’re not the only one, how about this melody in the 2nd half of the verse 2? How the hell did you come with this melody?
Yup, they’re awesome. XD
Thank you for sharing that! I love it 😂
😂 Never change Kanami
Misa: "Where is my whiskey?"
"A cup is only useful for the empty space." Band-Maid skirts the edges of simple and busy😄!
Band-Maid - [World Domination Tour [Shinka] At Line Cube Shibuya (Shibuya Kōkaidō) #13] Catharsis [Shibuya Public Hall 2020/02/14]
BAND-MAID - [Third ONLINE OKYU-JI #10] Catharsis
BAND-MAID - [ONLINE ACOUSTIC OKYUJI #12] CATHARSIS
Do you need these files?
I don't care what anybody says, that chorus is fire in BOTH versions.
Thanks, Wave. Outdid yourself on this one 👍🤘
As with all Band-Maid songs and performances, Catharsis is cathartic. Thx, Wave!
See this entire, incredible Acoustic Concert with archive tickets at their website.
🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
I remember when you used to be nervous about hitting the pause button. You've certainly gotten over that. LOL
MISA's bass glissandos are epic. She has now entered the saintly realm of Jaco Pastorius and Carol Kaye. Let's face it, these five women are jazz musicians.
Dude, you probably have the best breakdown for this song amongst all the reactors. Of course, that just my opinion. Incidentally, Champ of Medium did almost the same thing as you (react to the original, than to the acoustic). Difference is, he had heard the original before, but had not watch the concert (despite actually having the tickets!!). You, on the other hand, had heard the acoustic earlier, and are now reviewing the original. It's amazing how both your perspectives are quite different, possibly because of the order of hearing this song.
So, on a totally different note, if both of you are not already friends, you should really have a chat with him. I'll bet that you both are going to hit it off really quickly.
Thank you Rahim! That’s really cool to know. I’ll actually be meeting him on stream with Ryan Mear and Dicodec this coming Sunday!
@@WavePotter whoa, that IS cool!
All songs were rebuilded in this concert.
My man, an excellent analysis aka reaction - your best on Band-Maid - and of this particular piece outshines all other analysis of this song.
Almost un-noticed. No costumes. Very finely attired.
Misa, fine work on the bass - nice, nice lines by Kanami, as Misa walks it down. All of it sublime and most excellent.
Thank you Vincent! I’m trying to get over my fear of of pausing and just do my thing, but find a balance so I don’t wreck the flow of the song. I’m glad you appreciated it!
Original version of Catharsis is one of my favorite BM songs. Conqueror was a very divisive album in the BM fandom because they used a lot of styles/sounds instead of just hard/heavy rock. I love it for that very reason, but a lot of people who ONLY want one sound weren't big fans of it.
You might be late to react to this live video, but your reaction was so fun, and I enjoyed it till very end. Your part-to-part comparisons between the original and the acoustic version were really interesting.
Maids said that the live performance is the most important thing for them, and they spent twice more time to prepare for this acoustic live than the usual live show. So Maids will appreciate your detailed analytical comments on this video👍😉
You can find a "plugged" live version of 'Catharsis' on their Live @ Line Cube Shibuya DVD as the 11th track (10th song)
That was a superior breakdown, Wave. Catharsis was always one of my all time favorites, but not being much of a musician, I could never quite articulate how or why. So it was nice to have someone knowledgeable go through both versions in detail: it helps me appreciate the songwriting and arranging even more.
Elements of Zappa.
New drinking game during the live acoustic...down a shot every time Akane plays her chimes!
You're right about the location of the acoustic concert. I've been there many times, and even lived in and around that city for 11 years. It's in Yokohama's Minatomirai area (well, not exactly, it's on an artificial island with a big shopping mall, amusement park, and several other attractions), and is one of my favourite places in the world. I even know which building they're playing in.
You can hear the seeds of Unseen World in the album version of Catharsis. Kanami’s guitar work is really different for her… it reminds me of Steve Howe’s guitar work on the “Relayer” album by Yes. Fitting, as this song has the kinds of prog elements that become even more prevalent on Unseen World. Akane’s drum work also has a lot of prog sound to it as well. The acoustic version is so different! Yet it is a beautiful thing unto itself.
Wave, did you see Chase Carneson just shouted you out in his reaction to the acoustic version?
Wow Wave. Thanks for this. That was a great analysis and comparison of both versions. I call that masterclass of reaction. Great insights as usual. Catharsis is really an interesting song in every aspect. Love Kanamis Jazz borrowings in this and there are just never enough words - as always - to praise Akanes drum work. She’s such a creative and tasteful drummer. B-M is just masterclass - always, no matter in which direction they go with a song.
Thank you for the kind words! And well said! Every aspect of this band is so inspiring!
Let's face it...this is a jazz band that also plays rock.
Just go ahead and raise the bar for song comparisons why don't you! Wow!
😅 I just want to show how much I appreciate the effort they put into creating an almost completely new song for the acoustic show! I’m so glad they put this out to UA-cam!
First off, excellent review and analysis. Akane whipping out the Hot Rod Sticks for the live. This song reminds me a lot of their earlier, "Start Over."
MISA MISA MISA!
🥃🥃🥃
They way they transformed the songs into the acoustic versions we heard on Christmas was great. If Bandmaid were to do a bluegrass version of their music, it would probably be awesome.
Kanami and Akane: "I hope you Masters and Princesses really enjoy this because we're bored as S***. Wake us up when we get ready to play a really BA song!"
Kanami's performance on the bridge is Pat Metheny worthy...and remember, she wrote the song.
@@ShikataGaNai100 Kanami is awesome! She always does the right thing for the music, the band and the fans.
@@Glen.Black. ...and, to top off her talent and cuteness, she also has a bachelors degree in economics. I wonder if and when she sleeps? LOL
@@ShikataGaNai100 She probably doesn't. Music comes first.
I love your in depth analysis Wave. A great, great job with this one. Conqueror is their most experimental creation. An amazing LP.
Love how whoever edited the video made sure you didn't miss those chimes right before the drop
Wave... my man.... at least play 4 or 5 bars before pausing. You're pausing after every measure! LOL. You even paused while Kanami was "speaking". Ryan needs to slap you down for that.
Only on the second pass through!
I think maybe... but seriously, Kanami is always speaking during this song! 😂
As a percussionist, Akane's little flourish on the bar chimes was just chef's kiss perfection for me.
Right?! You could tell by the look on her face she knew it! :)
The acoustic version gives me mid 90s Alt Rock vibes. A la Barenaked Ladies, Big Head Todd and Indigo Girls....
Hey ,🙂 I would like to show for you a unique band.The band name is JAMBINAI They have a mv Time of extinction...I think you will enjoy 🙂 Anyway BAND-MAID FOREVER 😃
Don’t forget Miku’s great lyrics. “No worries, no night lasts forever” hits you right in the feels
This acoustic version fully shows how diverse their arranger skill are.
That’s a wedding space in Yokohama.
Line Cube Shibuya concert has this. Get it Blu-ray
Good music and your energy make me happy! 🎸 🤘😎🤘
26:20 Chimes!
MISA!!! MISA!!! MISA!!! 🥃🥃🥃
great reaction love it ! was giggling all the way
Great analysis as usual! And why were you so excited about those chimes?🤣
Because I could tell Akane was! But thank you! 😄
The part at 25:17 reminded me so much of YOYO's (not YOYOKA) acoustic cover of "Just Funky" that I just requested if for the next live stream.
Kanami is doing her Larry Carlton imitation on the acoustic.
Wave please check out Lovebites cover of Judas Priest song painkiller.
When I saw your Patrons reaction how may times did you mention the *Chimes* 😀
Sunday, October 9:
AFTERSHOCK------------------------------
Foo Fighters
Shinedown
Bring Me The Horizon
Architects
Action Bronson
The Pretty Reckless
The Interrupters
The Struts
Underoath
Jelly Roll
Dirty Honey
Zakk Sabbath
BaysideDead Sara
Royal & The Serpent
Carolesdaughter
The Warning
Maggie Lindemann
Band-Maid-------------------------------------------------------
The Mysterines
Eva Under Fire
You may wish to react to great British guitarist Sophie Lloyd. The link is to her version of Bon Jovi - You Give Love a Bad Name.
ua-cam.com/video/TP_ePW8UboA/v-deo.html
I'm probably going to get some flak for this, but I'm picking up some pregnancy vibes from Misa. I might be wrong I dunno. I know these ladies are all 30+ now and its not improbable. Miyako from Lovebites just had a baby last year.
Lol i think most of us are adults here so i dont think you would get flack for that. Not to mention Tamu from NEMO and Yuki from GS also had babies.
She wears a loose fitting outfit and this happens? Highly unlikely that she would be so with a tour in the works (although Nao Kawakita toured with MTH until right before giving birth to both of her kids). BTW, in Japanese culture, privacy is highly valued and that question would be seen as highly rude. Actually, I don't sense any malice in your question, but still...as the song says...MANNERS? One thing I have learned in dating a Japanese woman, also a J-Rock musician, for 10 years...let them bring up personal matters on their own. I have seen people saying, "Whoa, she drank a lot of water at the gig," so, you know..? Well, so did Saiki, who was sweating bullets, by her own admission.