Porcupine Tree - Bonnie the Cat [OFFICIAL VIDEO]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 435

  • @kunns123
    @kunns123 6 років тому +201

    Bonnie the cat had many a story to tell.
    But it was a rare occasion such as this that she did

    • @zoeyyohai4294
      @zoeyyohai4294 6 років тому +25

      Underrated comment

    • @TheWolfboy512
      @TheWolfboy512 6 років тому +21

      Tommy the Cat is my name...and I say unto Thee...(Beautiful & funny reference)

    • @DanielS10291
      @DanielS10291 6 років тому +10

      Say baby

    • @drury2d8
      @drury2d8 6 років тому +32

      Primus SUCKS.

    • @avisheksubba6445
      @avisheksubba6445 4 роки тому +1

      Isn't Bonnie the famous Robber? Bonnie and Clyde?

  • @ThatRoadrunner
    @ThatRoadrunner 13 років тому +75

    Porcupine Tree, the greatest band you've never heard of.

  • @spydermaker
    @spydermaker 10 років тому +89

    Awesome tune based around Gavin's brilliant drumming. LOVE IT!

  • @TempestDacine
    @TempestDacine 14 років тому +47

    I had only heard Time Flies before this, and wow...this song is just something else. I'm a Porcupine Tree fan now

  • @rizzorizzo2311
    @rizzorizzo2311 2 роки тому +43

    Man it must feel good to know you have one of the best drummers ever playing for your band. Like having the most reliable employee ever you never have to worry about.

  • @webshadow69
    @webshadow69 12 років тому +20

    Tool influenced video + Porcupine Tree Song = Eargasm

  • @o0LanternLight0o
    @o0LanternLight0o 13 років тому +15

    why does it seem like every time i get on youtube, i find a porcupine tree music video i had no idea even exsisted? they are my favorite band for crying out loud...

  • @moonfool4042
    @moonfool4042 7 років тому +15

    Best Drums you'll ever hear on any form of music!!!

  • @nobbyhobby2071
    @nobbyhobby2071 3 роки тому +9

    One of the best songs ever written.

  • @DJBalkenende70
    @DJBalkenende70 4 роки тому +14

    The most crazy rythm..........in 4/4!!

  • @mannymorganmorgan9063
    @mannymorganmorgan9063 6 років тому +5

    Gavin simply a gods special product, it's unbelievable stuff that no can't even imagine.

  • @SplendidFellow
    @SplendidFellow 12 років тому +4

    Still can't nail the time signature on this.

  • @shadowselfCA
    @shadowselfCA 8 років тому +52

    My brain gets all sweaty when I listen to the drums.

  • @chrisf8904
    @chrisf8904 4 роки тому +9

    I literally sent this to the drummer in the band I was in 20 years ago, that I haven't talked to for 12 years and have only caught up with a month ago cause this is fricken ridiculously tasty. I'm the bass player and OMFG I want to play this live!

    • @droptherapy2085
      @droptherapy2085 3 роки тому

      As a fellow bassist I definitely agree that the basslines sound really fun to play

    • @mrbungle3310
      @mrbungle3310 3 роки тому

      Guitarist here,i want to play Richards Synths here so bad... brought his inner Japan

    • @Absolutely_puck_fakestine
      @Absolutely_puck_fakestine 5 місяців тому

      Literally ?

  • @sidewayssky17
    @sidewayssky17 7 років тому +67

    The Grand Conjuration at 3:48.

    • @analogpark8059
      @analogpark8059 6 років тому

      yes!

    • @nicolemarieb.7044
      @nicolemarieb.7044 6 років тому +1

      Glad you said that. I know a little bit of Opeth, but i'm friends with an Opeth superfan. This song (The CG) came on, and i said "oh, that's like Bonnie the Cat" to myself. Later i tried to bring up that some Opeth and PT riff was very similar, and he didnt know what i was talking about.

    • @VictorDodon
      @VictorDodon 5 років тому

      @@nicolemarieb.7044 but didn't the Opeth TGC come out before Bonnie the cat?

    • @sergiovelasquez5138
      @sergiovelasquez5138 4 роки тому +4

      @@VictorDodon yes, TGC came out in 2005 and this was released in 2009. Besides, Mikael and Steven are kinda best friends so it's pretty obvious it's an Opeth reference.

    • @6yvonne
      @6yvonne 4 роки тому

      EXACTLY!!!

  • @profdimusica369
    @profdimusica369 5 років тому +6

    incredible track!

  • @saccccon
    @saccccon 14 років тому +3

    fantastic! The ideal of perfect band is here in front of your eyes

  • @joserobertorv4227
    @joserobertorv4227 7 років тому +3

    The best song of "The incident". Amazing vídeo!!..

  • @lucaskebi8678
    @lucaskebi8678 9 років тому +5

    amazing song and drums too

  • @reggaeraptor9143
    @reggaeraptor9143 4 роки тому +11

    When the drummer writes the song 😂 Gavin Harrison your the man!!

  • @olaqrtyna4327
    @olaqrtyna4327 8 років тому +4

    Excellent soundtrak , each instrument harmonizes with the rest. Pure harmony, perfekt cooperation - form a whole. As in the orchestra, there is no more important and the less important because every detail (musicians, instruments, vocals) form unified the final effect - you just have to know how to listen... I personally think that the albums, songs PT and S.W. They are excellent, inspiring, important, needed, just fucking cool...

  • @BWP-u3y
    @BWP-u3y 5 років тому +3

    Best Valentines Day song, ever! 😆

  • @markadams9999
    @markadams9999 8 років тому +19

    Song is great, and as usual Gavin's drumming is just fucking incredible ! Without a doubt the best drummer !

  • @locosychocrazy1
    @locosychocrazy1 12 років тому +4

    Great song! Those drums and the bass, man!

  • @JimmyAbbots
    @JimmyAbbots 13 років тому

    A little step away from classic Porcupine Tree songs. Well done.

  • @rmazali
    @rmazali 12 років тому +1

    Amazing video for an out-of-this-world song.

  • @noonelies4ever
    @noonelies4ever 13 років тому +1

    Nice video,been a fan four 2 years glad to listen them online.they deliver good music

  • @roopetiihonen6129
    @roopetiihonen6129 8 років тому +4

    just learned this drum beat. One of my favorite jams :D

  • @mikeg4972
    @mikeg4972 4 роки тому +2

    Great music, great video.

  • @erdemduman23
    @erdemduman23 8 років тому +43

    Roadrunner Records showed us why they were named like "roadrunner" by making this song faster.

    • @FACEL1FT
      @FACEL1FT 9 місяців тому +1

      Yeah this is trippin me up

  • @soundgardener4940
    @soundgardener4940 5 років тому +1

    01:00 That strip of metal over the eyes must come in handy with detail work.
    Nice one, Asimov.

  • @Fenrasulfr
    @Fenrasulfr 14 років тому +11

    The bass line of this song allways remember me of the Knight Rider theme song.

  • @MrDrumontherun19
    @MrDrumontherun19 11 років тому +6

    This song just makes you think about time...What if I told you it was entirely in 4/4? Hard to believe, right?

  • @Nosferatu_u
    @Nosferatu_u 3 роки тому +1

    This is amazing

  • @fafafak6
    @fafafak6 12 років тому

    my first Porcupine Tree song.
    that drum
    danm

  • @Dioliveson55
    @Dioliveson55 13 років тому +2

    3:07 love that bass riff!

  • @dawncroy
    @dawncroy 4 роки тому +7

    Reliving my love of Porcupine Tree and Gavin Harrison

  • @eeph4eva
    @eeph4eva 11 років тому +8

    Not really... I mean it sounds a bit odd in the beginning, but once you wrap your ears around it, it's actually quite easy to hear that it's in 4/4 time. Awesome song, anyway

  • @VJelectro
    @VJelectro 13 років тому +9

    It's not a bad thing that this video is similar to a Tool video. In fact, the world needs more videos like this. It's much more engrossing and you get enveloped in the vibe of the music.
    This song is totally badass, by the way. Amazing drum rhythm and the arabian scale bit is icing on the cake.

  • @TheProletarius
    @TheProletarius 9 років тому +36

    the video is also amazing ,reminds Tool !

  • @Anaximander29A
    @Anaximander29A 3 роки тому +5

    Legend has it that Gavin Harrison made a deal with the devil once. Nobody knows what Gavin got, but the devil got drumlessons.

    • @JustGrun
      @JustGrun 3 місяці тому

      That is the best drum comment ever))

  • @spaz480
    @spaz480 12 років тому

    equally awesome! band none the less, glad to see some Les fans in here too!

  • @timmarrier
    @timmarrier 7 років тому +2

    There's only one other band with these skills: Atomship, the album is called The Crash of '47. Pure art, just like these guys...

    • @Wedigar
      @Wedigar 6 років тому +3

      OSI is another band with skills. Gavin Harrison drums on two of their albums, and Steven Wilson sings in the song Shutdown.

  • @treumatic8420
    @treumatic8420 4 роки тому +4

    My heart aching, my brain melting...

  • @highartalert6927
    @highartalert6927 7 років тому +64

    Its quite obvious. WIlson's musical genius is best complemented by Gavin's beautiful drumming.

    • @mynameismud956
      @mynameismud956 4 роки тому +4

      Actually, Gavin's musical genius is complemented by wilson's beautiful singing

    • @AntiOrumcek
      @AntiOrumcek 3 роки тому

      I agree but do you have to mention all these? This is why we will never ever see it happening again. 🤣 SW can't and won't accept another name to be mentioned along his... That's the reason to see his solo line up evolving to less superior on each album.

    • @MrSonata12
      @MrSonata12 3 роки тому +2

      @@AntiOrumcek New PT album this year with Gavin and Richard 😉

    • @Ric653
      @Ric653 2 роки тому

      And by Richard Barbieri's keyboards

    • @jeanjacqueslundi3502
      @jeanjacqueslundi3502 Рік тому

      Nah, Gavin's great but Maitland is the best PT drummer for me.

  • @tnpbass22
    @tnpbass22 13 років тому

    total new era of music

    • @soundgardener4940
      @soundgardener4940 5 років тому

      Set down the crack pipe, Bono or Dave Grohl will be along shortly to gush utter nonsense about bands with you.

  • @thesolo
    @thesolo 13 років тому

    @Kapper2310 It is. It's slightly shifted & sped up.

  • @twiinkly
    @twiinkly 14 років тому

    @PTHead1 yeah.. totally agree. so was sleep together!

  • @Livielue96
    @Livielue96 4 роки тому

    Came to say this song still hits in 2020

  • @Psicokass
    @Psicokass 7 років тому +13

    Can't feel the pain that I expected
    I still place keys in the ignition
    I know what will be
    One thought is stopping me from sleeping
    I saw the future and it's breeding
    I know what will be
    Could be your last resort
    Like gold against your soul
    There are three things that I would die for
    But I am sure you're not one of them
    I know what will be
    Could be your last resort
    Like gold against your soul
    [Whispered:]
    You think you've got it all wrapped up now
    You stumble on so unsuspecting
    I know what will be)
    I hold your birth control to ransom
    The cells divide and grow inside you
    I know what will be
    I know what will be
    I know what will be

  • @PiousMoltar
    @PiousMoltar 3 роки тому +1

    I liked PT at this time but I don't remember them being THIS good. woah.

  • @chubby41
    @chubby41 13 років тому

    It's incredible!

  • @Linixion
    @Linixion 13 років тому

    @PennyDreadful1 Yeah I get what you're saying, and that's cool. Not everyone's brain resonates on the same level, or perceives the same thing in the music they listen to. Some songs I get tired of while I'm driving in a car, but if I chill out and listen in headphones I think it's amazing, there are many factors to listening to music.

  • @ReyCarmesi97
    @ReyCarmesi97 13 років тому

    i want this band on Argentina!!

  • @splendiferosity
    @splendiferosity 14 років тому

    I really like this song. And this vid was kinda kewwwl. I was hoping they'd post it after I saw it at Radio City.

  • @balaisaitama
    @balaisaitama 14 років тому

    @ortbitalreverb Completamente de acuerdo con usted sr , comenze a ver el video y pense en vicarious .

  • @odiumhumanigenerishorus9104
    @odiumhumanigenerishorus9104 2 роки тому

    👍muy buena música👍

  • @tribaltyn
    @tribaltyn 14 років тому +3

    saw this video during live performance, pretty intense that was.

  • @hanggeaanggi813
    @hanggeaanggi813 12 років тому

    exactly!

  • @stivgro
    @stivgro 12 років тому

    Cheers!

  • @6chhelipilot
    @6chhelipilot 8 років тому +174

    PT gets all TOOLed up.

    • @waldenbeaudet736
      @waldenbeaudet736 8 років тому +5

      Fuck yeah!

    • @akshaysinha9777
      @akshaysinha9777 7 років тому

      Piyush Stoicist I believe he is comparing Portnoy with Gavin, not the video. Which is spot on.

    • @headofvengarl8893
      @headofvengarl8893 7 років тому +25

      Akshay Sinha: You might have it a bit mixed up there; Mike Portnoy is Dream Theater's drummer, Danny Carey is Tool's drummer. But yeah, Gavin is incredible and so is Danny. And so are their respective bands of course.

    • @pyramidhead3109
      @pyramidhead3109 6 років тому +6

      @@piyusha1234 Clearly you haven't seen Tool's music videos at the time.

    • @soundgardener4940
      @soundgardener4940 5 років тому +1

      Sure, sure... 03:49 - 04:23 is total and utter genius, I was on the edge of my seat, what a BIT though!
      *_EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH! EUNGH!_*
      That's prog right there folks.

  • @AluryNinia
    @AluryNinia 14 років тому

    @TheAthesis No it was Lasse Hoile (an institution), check him out here in youtube

  • @TeslaNick2
    @TeslaNick2 12 років тому

    There's also a nice little polyrythm at 3:49 - 4:23 that's so much fun to play...

  • @organicate
    @organicate 13 років тому +3

    Here's a thought.. Porcupine Tree, Opeth and Dream Theater are all on Roadrunner at the moment. They need to put together a tour with those 3 bands. That would be progressive. Not to mention amazing.

    • @soundgardener4940
      @soundgardener4940 5 років тому

      Dream Theater sounds like Weaponized TurboMech Nerds practising scales, and don't even mention that fat ginger canuck with the fucked pipes, ARGH they're UTTER FUCKING DRECK.

  • @JohnTheRipper2
    @JohnTheRipper2 12 років тому

    dude, thanks for introducing me to primus. really, thanks!

  • @ian2120
    @ian2120 14 років тому

    I believe it is sped up because the video is really made to be a companion to their live shows, but I remember seeing this video else where, and it wasn't faster. And I don't remember the Radio City being at this tempo. In fact, I know it wasn't. It could be youtube

  • @imetzl9340
    @imetzl9340 7 років тому +120

    The best part part is it's all in 4/4

    • @drury2d8
      @drury2d8 6 років тому +8

      when I watched the tutorial my jaw fell off. British Sorcery

    • @soundgardener4940
      @soundgardener4940 5 років тому +4

      Why is that the best part?
      Oh, I get it: you're doing that gormless thing where you want to bring attention to something trivial, so you preface it with _"the best part is"_ despite it not being remotely the best in any way shape or form...okay look, just fuckin' forget it, okay _"Lee?"_ I've got bigger fish to...buy.
      Love, Mum
      PS: You killed your father. I mean my father. Both.
      Oh my God, Lee...how do we have the same....EWWWWWWWWW?! That's *_disgusting!_* Oh thank GOD you killed them! I mean him.

    • @CubeDrummer3
      @CubeDrummer3 5 років тому +22

      Sound Gardener no dumbass if you understood anything about music, you would realize that this beat and song sounds nothing like 4/4 time but somehow still is, that is why it’s awesome

    • @pankeaux
      @pankeaux 5 років тому

      i got that referece

    • @sillylieu
      @sillylieu 5 років тому +5

      No, it's 7/8 and 9/8 alternating. That's a big difference from straight up 4/4.

  • @PennyDreadful1
    @PennyDreadful1 13 років тому

    @Linixion I really get what you are saying there!

  • @Calabrone92
    @Calabrone92 13 років тому

    @bnanacheese2 ahaha is the first problem for everyone...but..the song is in 4\4...:) it's a rhythmic illusion of the accents on the time...:) try count the time ,starting from the first quarter...and you'll see that the song is in 4\4...strange 4\4...sorry if my english is not perfect :D

  • @minkk81
    @minkk81 14 років тому

    This video remind me some TOOL videos...stop-motion rulez! Great song and Great video!

  • @Marco-zt4xu
    @Marco-zt4xu 5 років тому +1

    It's incredible that it's a 4/4 (!)

  • @fuzzylogiceire
    @fuzzylogiceire 12 років тому +1

    Theres probably some other songs by them you'd like, a lot of their stuff is quite accessible.

  • @LiveOnQueen
    @LiveOnQueen 14 років тому

    @platinumdynamite yea i noticed that too....and it sounds sped up a little
    it doesnt make it as dark :/

  • @GiveSic
    @GiveSic 7 років тому +1

    If I ever made a movie or video game this song would be the music for the end credits.

  • @lorenwhit
    @lorenwhit 13 років тому +1

    @Calabrone92 yeah this guy is right. the time sig despite despite being in 4.4 is so complex, gavin harrison is a boss.

  • @evilpingouin
    @evilpingouin 13 років тому +1

    Anybody else noticed the similarity between the riff at 3:50 and the solo riff of Opeth's The Grand Conjuration?

  • @armydilo13
    @armydilo13 2 роки тому +1

    That's bass!!!

  • @westnile805
    @westnile805 14 років тому +1

    The progression of a great band. Unique.
    The Tool of Europe.
    Peace

  • @q0w1e2r3t4y5
    @q0w1e2r3t4y5 7 років тому +2

    I like this cause it resembles Karnivool somehow! My other fav is Circle of Manias cause it's so djenty :D And the joker is Time flies. That is so calming and nice.

  • @skeptikatheist
    @skeptikatheist 13 років тому

    @jammoose A hundred percent agreed.

  • @CrawfordDrummer
    @CrawfordDrummer 14 років тому

    3:50 is so awesome

  • @4look4rd
    @4look4rd 13 років тому

    @Jonnyjy Yes the music is good, but the video is really interesting and would look amazing in HD..

  • @waldenbeaudet736
    @waldenbeaudet736 8 років тому +26

    This band, I think, is a cross between Tool, Shpongle, and Pink Floyd. Tasty.

    • @flintwolf3951
      @flintwolf3951 8 років тому +6

      three bands that i all love so much, shpongle deserves more recognition

    • @waldenbeaudet736
      @waldenbeaudet736 8 років тому +2

      Yes, Shpongle is just so "tasty" to the ears

    • @Christestament
      @Christestament 8 років тому +5

      Never heard of Shpongle before. I should give it a try. Btw, Tool and Pink Floyd are finest!

    • @waldenbeaudet736
      @waldenbeaudet736 8 років тому +3

      Shpongle is some crazy shit, it'll REALLY make you spiral out, ha.

    • @ZoltanvamosOfficial
      @ZoltanvamosOfficial 7 років тому +1

      Walden Beaudet Fun Little Fact, Steven Never Really Liked Tool! he LOVED Pink Floyd, Beach Boys, Crosby Stills and Nash, Iron Maddin and Metallica. I know this stuff because I dug my face into researching this stuff

  • @revolutionarybaby
    @revolutionarybaby 13 років тому

    @smartj3 I agree.

  • @ADHDgrapher
    @ADHDgrapher 13 років тому +1

    Speed has been augmented.

  • @moinshariff5594
    @moinshariff5594 7 років тому

    There are 3 things i would die for, but I am sure you are not one among them !!!! OMFG.. extreme hatred in one line ! Long live Steven Wilson :D

  • @patrickniendorf4360
    @patrickniendorf4360 5 років тому +1

    Gavin Harrison is currently the best drummer on this planet..............Hands down

    • @Indianpsychonaut
      @Indianpsychonaut 3 роки тому

      Ever heard of Mario Duplantier or Thomas Hakee

  • @ADHDforTHEwin
    @ADHDforTHEwin 13 років тому +1

    i love how wierd wilson and crew are....it makes me smile.

  • @Lazzie_the_Psilocybe_Deity
    @Lazzie_the_Psilocybe_Deity 12 років тому +1

    Les Claypool and Steven Wilson aren't really comparable. They are both outstanding musicians. Their lyrics actually make sense. Other music of today isn't like that.
    Steven is more emotional than Les.
    Les is more political than Steven.
    They both do their own things in music, and they are on my top 5 favorite solo artists.

  • @djfrank203
    @djfrank203 14 років тому

    oh god guys check it out!"!! the pitch is different!!! they made it higher!!! O_O the album version is lower! youtube changed the pitch, see for yourself
    right now its in G but on the album its F#

  • @ultimate0death
    @ultimate0death 13 років тому

    @thierryman Wow, you're right! Listen to the album version, and then this version. This is like 1.3 times faster.

  • @NuMetalGoddess94
    @NuMetalGoddess94 13 років тому +2

    Love this video kind of reminds me of Tools videos XD

  • @theconstruKctionoflight
    @theconstruKctionoflight 12 років тому

    count to four over and over...it matches.

  • @jeanjacqueslundi3502
    @jeanjacqueslundi3502 3 роки тому

    One of the most Pluto songs I've ever come across.

  • @marcoau7u7
    @marcoau7u7 8 років тому +17

    Djeven Wils0n

  • @djfrank203
    @djfrank203 14 років тому

    @Stev0BabaGhanoush yea i noticed it, must be because they shortened the vid slightly for youtube!
    Now it's in G lol

  • @ortbitalreverb
    @ortbitalreverb 14 років тому +1

    Ah sí... Yo tambien vi la película y leí el libro "El Perfume" :D

  • @VadimHor
    @VadimHor 14 років тому

    @xSLAYER2x noticed the same. It's faster than in the album.

  • @JohnVullo
    @JohnVullo 13 років тому

    I dunno if anyone mentioned this, but it sounds like its about a half step, or even a quarter step sharp from the record. UA-cam encoding?

  • @AtomHeartMother
    @AtomHeartMother 13 років тому +3

    This sounds a lot faster than how it is on the album. The album version is much better!