How Civil Servants Built Modern India | Flashback with Palki Sharma

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @Firstpost
    @Firstpost  Рік тому +335

    Do you think the role of civil servants in independent India has been forgotten? Comment below and join the conversation.

    • @urbanistvlog
      @urbanistvlog Рік тому +2

      IITians are doing better than civil servants. nothing to be proud to be a civil servant.

    • @kedaryadav4118
      @kedaryadav4118 Рік тому +2

      We remeber civil servants more as a corrupt and illiterate babuies who have been fielded to over power the poor people by being CHATU OF politicians baaring few like brijesh mishra etc.

    • @Dream-mt7eb
      @Dream-mt7eb Рік тому +12

      No it is not forgettable.. but it is also know to wonder how you put all these informations in your mind I am preparing for the civil services examination . I forget the many things I need to revise again and again but when I see you guys I feel like what I missed how you revise all this informations I want to know this only from you? Please advise me how you collect the information and store in your mind

    • @subhambala6688
      @subhambala6688 Рік тому +2

      ​@@Dream-mt7eb jab shoot kodta ha uski pahala content Banta ha uski bad padta ha far shoot kodta ha

    • @everuttejon9886
      @everuttejon9886 Рік тому +1

      .......India was destroyed by distorted Indian history.... British slavery democracy and British slavery education system and corruption...So India will never be economic super power in the future.
      ...
      .

  • @koolmom9163
    @koolmom9163 Рік тому +1661

    My father retired as a top bureaucrat from Haryana in 1995…from the batch of unusual honest IAS officers!!!
    Soon after he passed away peacefully. Growing up I never saw him throwing his weight around or being arrogant. As kids we lived in huge government houses with security men and what not but he was very clear that none of that was permanent or ours. He didn’t have properties or tons of money that I heard other IAS officers had. We had one simple house when he retired. That was his earning of life. I remember once my brother got upset with him and hold him, “papa, you should have made tons of money..how come we are always working hard?” And his response was, “ I started from scratch and my goal was to retire with dignity and peace of mind. Money can be momentary but your conscious will always prick you for the wrong deeds.” Good lesson that I tell my kids today.
    I can’t thank you enough for reminding me how proud I am today to be daughter of an IAS officer who worked day and night to help people and to make a difference.

    • @sumankumarpk9300
      @sumankumarpk9300 Рік тому +70

      Tribute to your father and to our Great Country.

    • @SureshBabu-lv6bd
      @SureshBabu-lv6bd Рік тому +51

      Tribute, Salute & bow down to your father, he is very inspirational 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

    • @koolmom9163
      @koolmom9163 Рік тому +43

      Thank you so much! I feel I have honored him today 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

    • @dharmendraprakash7773
      @dharmendraprakash7773 Рік тому +41

      I am really humbled with narration..You are fortunate to have been born to such a great soul..
      My salute 🫡 to him for working for us and also to have been blessed with good children like you..

    • @priyalamba3600
      @priyalamba3600 Рік тому +24

      Tribute to your father.So inspirational

  • @courtlaw1
    @courtlaw1 Рік тому +734

    As an African American I will say I love that India got their country back from an imperial power and now is a world power and will likely dominate the later years of this century.

    • @everuttejon9886
      @everuttejon9886 Рік тому

      .....India was destroyed by distorted Indian history.... British slavery democracy and British slavery education system and corruption...So India will never be economic super power in the future.

    • @yourcat2971
      @yourcat2971 Рік тому +22

      There are too many challenges. Cheap politicians are by far the biggest

    • @tintunbirha
      @tintunbirha Рік тому +33

      No domination. Just contributer and soft influencer. I hope India never looses its generally gentle hindu ethos whatever others might do.

    • @eriol_h
      @eriol_h Рік тому +13

      Thank you for the generous wishes. Africa is a great nation with kind hearted people. I wish the best to Africa from India!

    • @gareeb_whatif8325
      @gareeb_whatif8325 Рік тому

      @@tintunbirha no we need to be ruthless like Americans and get all dirt from country and throw them out.

  • @pratibharajpoot1508
    @pratibharajpoot1508 Рік тому +367

    Civil servants are like the 4th lion of Ashokan emblem “Anonymous ,yet makes its presence felt at all times.”❤❤

    • @jacksmith-mu3ee
      @jacksmith-mu3ee Рік тому +2

      mIndia's Hunger index
      2013: 63rd rank
      2022: 107th rank
      mIndia's Happiness index.
      2013: 111th rank
      2022: 136th rank
      mIndia's press freedom rank
      2013:79th
      2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
      democracy is no more
      mIndia's unemployment rate
      2013:4.9%
      2023:7.5%
      Unemployment rate never increase in growing
      economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
      loan
      mIndia's Debt
      before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
      2023: ₹155 lakh crore
      mIndia's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
      $709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
      India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
      $2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
      double

    • @patraseduhelphand
      @patraseduhelphand Рік тому

      Neither Indian nor civil and not servants...Come to West Bengal see the conditions of IAS ..all hellish Corrupted vermins..these bastards are destroying the state...

    • @nileshsingh2669
      @nileshsingh2669 Рік тому +3

      Not always, only after PM Modi came to power they all started working like never before. Have you heard the culture of "babus"? They are the same people who keep rolling file from one table to different table and delayed projects for many years.

    • @jacksmith-mu3ee
      @jacksmith-mu3ee Рік тому

      @@nileshsingh2669 india beggar

    • @Raju-j4i7p
      @Raju-j4i7p 10 місяців тому

      ​@@jacksmith-mu3eewe rejected this fake western daya

  • @manils35
    @manils35 Рік тому +327

    Million thanks Ms Palki. I have performed many times election duty at various levels, including six in J&K (1996) and got appreciation letter from Government. You made a wonderful report honouring us. God bless you with success always!

  • @lakshmankumar3459
    @lakshmankumar3459 Рік тому +81

    My Shashtang namaskarams to you Palki. My father retired from the IAS and is 93 now. He belonged to that rare breed of honest officers who contributed to India selflessly. While I knew all the while that the Civil services was and is the steel frame work of India ...it is also true that it is loosing its sheen. The current breed are more keen on posting their own videos and blowing their own trumpet not understanding that it is their work they have to do. Being down to earth is missing...colluding with politicians for personal benefits is rampant...what I am saying is..they are diluting their own respect. Today I am proud of my dad and privileged to be son of an unsung hero...but the truth is he has always been my hero...admiring him silently..thanks Palki...May God bless you with eternal happiness. Jai hind. Jai Shri Ram.

    • @Vasudhaivakutum
      @Vasudhaivakutum Рік тому +4

      IAS and honest are antonyms

    • @lakshmankumar3459
      @lakshmankumar3459 Рік тому

      Well yours sounds like sour grapes..one of the failed aspirants I guess. More over you get what you deserve...so ho and get a life first Gaikwad...

    • @katta240
      @katta240 9 місяців тому

      It's the rusted pillar of India ,dear friend

    • @aemurkhapnichavisudhar
      @aemurkhapnichavisudhar 5 місяців тому

      Social media and coaching institutes have presented civil services as something which gives ultimate power(rutba, 2 no. Ka paisa, society me dabdba) but it should be a dieheart service for building our nation🙏

    • @AathvikaOrganic_Farm
      @AathvikaOrganic_Farm 5 днів тому

      Hats off to your father and his parents ❤.. love and respect from Tamilnadu, Bharat 🇮🇳

  • @upasanasahoo3305
    @upasanasahoo3305 Рік тому +147

    what a beautiful segment. as an IAS aspirant, this just recharged me. Palki ma'am is such a huge part of the reason i still trust media outlets.

  • @manjunathjeerla3687
    @manjunathjeerla3687 Рік тому +169

    This is called Real Journalism🙏

  • @seller2548
    @seller2548 Рік тому +52

    Look at our US civil servants.... mostly corrupt. I'd like to forget them. Your reporting of India's history of civil servants was eye-opening and should always be remembered....

    • @prasadchaturdesale5795
      @prasadchaturdesale5795 Рік тому

      Oh don't the Indian civil service a rotten pit This video is just remembering rare good watch Yes Minister it is so arrogant and so disgusting you haven't scratched the surface

    • @prasadchaturdesale5795
      @prasadchaturdesale5795 Рік тому +2

      Especially after 90s indian civil service are disgustingly aristocratic

  • @divyaloganathan1029
    @divyaloganathan1029 Рік тому +459

    This is a great tribute to our unsung bureaucrats. Let’ respect them

    • @nutan2278
      @nutan2278 Рік тому +9

      But don't you think corruption is also because of them Only

    • @Anvesh49
      @Anvesh49 Рік тому

      @rajputana_553 if they are following polticians they can do it without taking bride since they are taking means they are part of corruption

    • @surajm4547
      @surajm4547 Рік тому +2

      ​@@nutan2278Exactly.👍👍👍

    • @anonymous-fj1fd
      @anonymous-fj1fd Рік тому +10

      They are all chor. Real tribute should be given to entrepreneurs who despite all odds of corrupt politicians and civil servants build Indian economy.

    • @spg6651
      @spg6651 Рік тому +5

      Respect whom? IAS cadre - Not at all -- They are creator of the problem and giving legal tone to every problem -- Major contribution of IAS is to complicate the matter through quoting Obscure law points and stalling developmental work .. IAS is regressive -- Good political leaders are far far better than IAS - Biggest contribution if IAS is Gigantic corruption ( much higher than political leader as IAS stays irrespective of Government change )

  • @bangarisaiswaraj
    @bangarisaiswaraj Рік тому +83

    A huge thanks to Palki Sharma and team for narrating this flashback and bringing this to the forefront.
    I'm really glad to see journalists like Palki speak out their heart that throbs for the wellbeing of this nation.

    • @jacksmith-mu3ee
      @jacksmith-mu3ee Рік тому

      mIndia's Hunger index
      2013: 63rd rank
      2022: 107th rank
      mIndia's Happiness index.
      2013: 111th rank
      2022: 136th rank
      mIndia's press freedom rank
      2013:79th
      2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
      democracy is no more
      mIndia's unemployment rate
      2013:4.9%
      2023:7.5%
      Unemployment rate never increase in growing
      economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
      loan
      mIndia's Debt
      before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
      2023: ₹155 lakh crore
      mIndia's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
      $709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
      India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
      $2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
      double

  • @top_1_percent
    @top_1_percent Рік тому +64

    That’s the reason why we love Palki. While other media outlets are busy showing crap, you bring this amazing story that needs to be told.

  • @aayush_bibliophile
    @aayush_bibliophile Рік тому +171

    Thanku Palki Sharma for this tribute to our unsung bureaucrats ❤️These bureaucrats were truly like engines that run our country🇮🇳 Respect to all ur civil servants for their service❤️

    • @snehasahoo1718
      @snehasahoo1718 Рік тому

      True otherwise every today is only busy criticising the bureaucrats forgetting that if there are bad ones then there are good ones also. And I wish to be one of those unsung heroes who will contribute to the development of our country.

    • @91873delete
      @91873delete Рік тому +2

      Dude we don't need them today. They already lived more than their normal life. We needed them maybe for 30 years after independence but definitely not now. We need people of subject matter experts now. How does an anthropology graduate knows anything about chemical engineering or petroleum refining, but this nonsense system made a history graduate to be a head of the department or chief secretary of Panchayati raj ministry wtf man and he/she will be posted to some other dept within 6 months to another dept of there is a difference of opinion between the secretary and the minister. This is utter nonsense service which is not needed in today's india

    • @surajm4547
      @surajm4547 Рік тому +2

      Palki should have also mentioned the bad points. This is such a one-sided video.

    • @snehasahoo1718
      @snehasahoo1718 Рік тому

      @@surajm4547 Well the video itself talks about some good ias officers then what do u want her to tell you.

    • @surajm4547
      @surajm4547 Рік тому +2

      @@snehasahoo1718 This video only glorifys them... she should have balanced it with the other negative side such as their corruption,etc. BUT SADLY WE DON'T HAVE SUCH NEUTRAL JOURNALISM ANYMORE.

  • @gauravrana8379
    @gauravrana8379 Рік тому +62

    Thanqu for having this topic Palki mam.
    I myself is a UPSC Aspirant preparing to serve this honorable service & your show helps me a lot for my preparations, especially for the FOREIGN RELATIONS AND FOREIGN POLICY of India.❤

    • @ximin_sleepy
      @ximin_sleepy Рік тому

      "serve the nation" 🤡🤡 more like loot the nation and keep it from becoming developed

    • @oneshot_Chemistry
      @oneshot_Chemistry Рік тому

      Same here

  • @jangamreddyankireddy1571
    @jangamreddyankireddy1571 Рік тому +62

    True leaders behind the scenes. Excellent journalism. Nice tribute to our real heroes 👍

  • @chilikapradhan278
    @chilikapradhan278 Рік тому +34

    A heartful salutation for our legendaries who have given us Independent India.
    Bande mataram 🇮🇳

  • @rakeshchophla6017
    @rakeshchophla6017 Рік тому +4

    Palki is one of my favorite, her delivery crisp, absolutely clear, classy and spot on. She is one of the very few India has

  • @abhijitsen3143
    @abhijitsen3143 Рік тому +51

    Just wow what a topic to pick....hats off for honouring and remembering the silent backbone of our nation

  • @anoushkaghosh6526
    @anoushkaghosh6526 Рік тому +12

    Finally someone who appreciated the worth and hardwork of our executive officers. Yes we have some cunning minds among them, but nevertheless there are way more hardworking people. We must acknowledge and appreciate them. Thankyou Palki❤❤

  • @franklinbrown5625
    @franklinbrown5625 Рік тому +5

    I love how she explains things so average ppl can understand. Even ppl not familiar with India. Well done from Jamaica

  • @daretodream7204
    @daretodream7204 Рік тому +639

    And now we have 5 ex-bureaucrats as Ministers in Central govt.
    1)Dr. S. Jayashankar (ex-IFS)
    2) Ashwini Vaishnav ( ex-IAS)
    3) Piyush Goyal (ex- IAS)
    4) Hardeep Singh Puri (ex-IFS)
    5) R K Singh (ex -IAS )
    😊😊😊😊

    • @Sunny12-23
      @Sunny12-23 Рік тому +52

      ​@@aandy450Modiji's greatest talent is to make the best of everything- situation, opportunity or people around him. Nehru's greatest talent was to waste every opportunity and insult every accomplished person around him - be it Sardar Patel, Dr. Ambedkar, Acharya JB Kriplani, Gen Thimmaiah etc etc etc. He was so full of his own superiority as the only "Englishman" in the Congress. By the way for your information the bureaucracy was created by the British and not Nehru.

    • @abhijayp6000
      @abhijayp6000 Рік тому +32

      Piyush Goyal is not ex-IAS . However, RK Singh , Union power minister is a retired Bihar cadre IAS officer . Arjun Ram Meghwal is also a former IAS ( promoted from RAS) who took voluntary retirement .

    • @atharvzemse6599
      @atharvzemse6599 Рік тому +41

      @@Sunny12-23 The only failure of Nehru was he could not build false narratives like Modi. This is the basic when you learn Political science and that's why democracy doesn't work where a leader is being portrayed as godly person so no one can question him if anything goes wrong.

    • @daretodream7204
      @daretodream7204 Рік тому +1

      ​@@logical16he is a 1994 batch IAS officer

    • @Sunny12-23
      @Sunny12-23 Рік тому +29

      @@atharvzemse6599 Nehru's ONLY success was to become Edwina's pet poodle and preside over the partition of the country. His over weaning ambition would not let him take second place to Sardar patel or Jinnah both of whom were the choice of their respective parties. In fact he even refused to accept Gandhi's suggestion to let Jinnah, who was terminally ill, be PM and then succeed him later. If your mission is to to promote the Nehruvian narrative first get your facts straight.

  • @ravipeiris4388
    @ravipeiris4388 Рік тому +12

    I've learned more about Indian history in this 10 minute video than my entire time in high school where learning about european history was shoved down my throat without ever learning about African and Asian histories. But video series like these are helping to rectify that gross oversight.

    • @rajnikantchande2677
      @rajnikantchande2677 Рік тому

      @ravipeiris4388
      You must read " The Discovery of India." author: Jawaharlal Nehru ...you will, I assure you, learn huge amt about Indian history prior to & during British rule...Every Indian must read this book...and, if you have time, please also read Nehru's " Glimpses of World History "...Best wishes
      Jai Hind

  • @dilipmandava7447
    @dilipmandava7447 Рік тому +3

    This is how journalism should be.... all the other top journalists should work for India and not for any political parties...
    Palki is the Change we see and we expect more....

  • @vijayz9170
    @vijayz9170 Рік тому +8

    Thanks for bringing such an untold story and the other side of the bureaucracy to the public. There are still unsung heroes who are trying to bring positive change under all odds.

  • @bts_1999_jiminpark
    @bts_1999_jiminpark Рік тому +33

    8:12 "beating heart of india democracy "🔥 as an upsc aspirant this 9 mints filled my heart with pride.. civil servants are the foot soldiers of india!.

  • @ramaraocheepi7847
    @ramaraocheepi7847 Рік тому +17

    Indeed its huge effort to collect and collate the data of civil servants who remined and remain as foundation for sound admn.These civ servants matter a lot even today.Indeed its profound gesture in covering this most civil servants from pre indepence to the present contexts.

    • @91873delete
      @91873delete Рік тому

      No we don't need them now all of them became yes men to politicians, instead we need subject matter experts now

  • @anushkaachandra9792
    @anushkaachandra9792 Рік тому +10

    These episodes were needed . To know about our long lost history , how back then all things functioned and how we actually started after 1947 🎉

  • @ashishmandot4974
    @ashishmandot4974 Рік тому +20

    Brilliant presentation and topic to discuss.....Finally a long deserved recognition

  • @courtlaw1
    @courtlaw1 Рік тому +14

    Nice celebrating the people that actually make the world work. This is why I love this channel.

  • @spranavshanker
    @spranavshanker Рік тому +6

    Thanks for highlighting the importance of civil services of India. If not for them, politicians would have destroyed India.

  • @gadadallisatya8916
    @gadadallisatya8916 Рік тому +3

    Well deserved recognition to our Govt.Officers that held India together and match ahead as the largest democracy of the World.Pranams to All.

  • @vbeingworld3035
    @vbeingworld3035 Рік тому +2

    I literally felt this video .
    Real heroes.
    Army at borders and civil servants at home .

  • @rajats3
    @rajats3 Рік тому +6

    Much needed tribute....great work palki...🙌⭐️

  • @KalingaLions
    @KalingaLions Рік тому +2

    Excluding u no one is speaking about this
    Really appreciated journalism in right way ❤from an citizen of India u are the one who should democratic to keep india democratic ❤

  • @bharatirawte943
    @bharatirawte943 Рік тому +14

    A big salute to our unsung heroes.

  • @TinTin2014
    @TinTin2014 Рік тому +6

    Lovely episode. Thank you Palki Sharma. Hope you get to read this comment.
    Here is a nice story about the genesis of the great Green Revolution. The first decade after independence was disastrous with famine, starvation and poverty. It was three bureaucrats who hatched a plan. A government scientist, who had just been returned from the U.S. after working with Professor Norman Borlaug, along with Home Secretary Shivaramakrishnan and finance secretary Subramanyam convinced PM Shastry to lift the ban on agricultural seed imports. That scientist was Professor MS Swaminathan. He used the improved seeds from the US and Europe to develop high yielding crop varieties for the Indian farmers. India’s food production grew rapidly and triggered economic growth and prosperity. We call him the Father of Green Revolution and we will celebrate his 98th birthday tomorrow August 7.

  • @sunilmakheja7527
    @sunilmakheja7527 Рік тому +5

    Palkiji🌹, Bureaucrats are the Real Heroes, Who lay down the foundation for the development of country 🇮🇳.
    At the same time, Political will is so important 😊

  • @MangalBhobe
    @MangalBhobe 11 місяців тому +2

    Very true
    Many contributions & great work s
    Go unnoticed & unrecognized

  • @krishnammagaru
    @krishnammagaru Рік тому +15

    Palki ji , who ever gave you thought of this episode must be saluted . Needless to say your entire team and you for bringing a extremely nice piece of history. We thank all our Heros who built our nation . en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._R._Pillai and en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sukumar_Sen_(civil_servant) . en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satyendranath_Tagore . A lot more ....

  • @babulsy6460
    @babulsy6460 Рік тому +1

    They were ,are and shall always remain backbone of INDIA ... There is no doubt in it.
    They indeed are one of the best, top notch, second to none... and that's why today India is not in a state of Pakistan....

  • @mchauhan4
    @mchauhan4 Рік тому +47

    Man.. as a CSE aspirant this filled my heart with pride!

    • @patraseduhelphand
      @patraseduhelphand Рік тому +1

      Advance congratulations...Corrupted Criminal..like all IAS of West Bengal

    • @presekkk
      @presekkk Рік тому

      Me too mate!👍

  • @Socialbhanwar
    @Socialbhanwar Рік тому +1

    जय हिन्द, जय भारत।।
    वंदे मातरम्, भारत माता की जय।।
    जय हिन्द, जय हिन्द की सेना।।

  • @saumyajitbhaduri1083
    @saumyajitbhaduri1083 Рік тому +7

    It is thanks to a handful of bureaucrats that our country Bharat has come such a long way. It's true that a majority of bureaucrats are corrupt to the core...but it is those handful of such honest and upright officers that Bharat is where it is today. Yashsvi Bhava 🙏🏼

  • @gopinathnambiar9707
    @gopinathnambiar9707 10 місяців тому

    Very harsh, we treated . Belated honour, remebering them. Thank you Palki making us all realise, The Hardwork n Efforts put in to experience this largest Democracy.

  • @manoharkanade7383
    @manoharkanade7383 Рік тому +6

    👍.Palki is one of the very few respected anchors known for their sincerity, integrity, and to the point narrations 👍🙏

  • @ramjoshi3577
    @ramjoshi3577 Рік тому +9

    Salute to our all Beaurocrates ❤ Palki you always nails with topic you choose and at choosing tge topic

  • @rksahib8314
    @rksahib8314 Рік тому +3

    Excellent thought to remember the forgotten heros of freedom years. Deserve to be honoured for their dedication and thoughtfulness.

  • @jaganmohan7059
    @jaganmohan7059 Рік тому +1

    Goosebumps and nothing else .. Thanks to PS ..and the channel.... BHARAT MATA KI JAI ..

  • @TheSastrikal
    @TheSastrikal Рік тому +8

    On this independence day.... Let's honor those unsung heros... 🥳🥳🥳

  • @vijaykumarreddyt3287
    @vijaykumarreddyt3287 Рік тому +5

    Yes, diligant selfless visionary bureaucrats are indeed unsung heroes we should give them due credit

  • @DonJuanMarco1994
    @DonJuanMarco1994 Рік тому +3

    How I wish this kind of Program exist of Philippine News.
    People would learn history of our country even more.

    • @chandrukrishnan6445
      @chandrukrishnan6445 6 місяців тому +1

      Hi, yes I have always wondered why we don't hear about the Spanish colonisation of the Philippines, or even that much about the US involvement starting with the Spanish-American war. There are several books, movies and even TV shows about the British in India. But there is a block-out about the Philippines. It's hard to believe that this neglect is genuine. There is probably a motive behind it.

  • @seller2548
    @seller2548 Рік тому +2

    Look at our US civil servants....mostly corrupt. I'd like to forget them. Thank you for reporting India's civil servant history. It should always be remembered.

  • @Ank-Tiw
    @Ank-Tiw Рік тому +6

    Interesting series mam. We love it. We want to discover India 🇮🇳

  • @dhirajkadam4791
    @dhirajkadam4791 Рік тому +1

    Really as said by hon. Sardar patel that civil servants are the still frame of the nation. It holds true forever. They are the unsung architect of our nation. Today on the occassion of independence day.. let's salute them too !

  • @democraticthinker-Erk
    @democraticthinker-Erk Рік тому +7

    upsc aspirants assemble here....wishing all the best ...

  • @shivanijha3318
    @shivanijha3318 Рік тому

    Adorable Palki ! A righteous woman. Strong headed, clear in her thoughts and her words.

  • @sunnysshashidhar7682
    @sunnysshashidhar7682 Рік тому +7

    Appreciate the great detailing and helping us to remember our PAST - Thank you very much 🙂

  • @MangalBhobe
    @MangalBhobe 11 місяців тому +1

    True , many contributions & great work s go unrecognized

  • @gourijoshi7905
    @gourijoshi7905 Рік тому +3

    One of the most important episodes…. A positive side of bureaucracy 🎉

  • @harshyadav03._
    @harshyadav03._ Рік тому

    Heard so many journalists but Palkhi Mam you are someone that literally on top of all. So confidence, so energy, so dedication you put them to make the best analysis possible out there.

  • @sumankumarpk9300
    @sumankumarpk9300 Рік тому +4

    This job is great, Madom Palki, keep it up.

  • @kaminitayulladil2198
    @kaminitayulladil2198 Рік тому

    Thank you for this information & making us understand the importance of civil services officers ( Indian) in pre-independence India.True unsung heros🙏

  • @harshidshah1
    @harshidshah1 Рік тому +3

    it was truely said that ministers come and go but ministry [ civil servants ] always remains. they are heroes who in reality run the country

  • @nitintyagi2024
    @nitintyagi2024 6 місяців тому +2

    My father is in police and has to go to night duties at off hours at the age of 55 years. During elections or some protest, they have to be at location, sometimes 14 hours in scorching temps. Of 40-45 degree C.He is honest at his job, and sometimes even do overtime volunteeringly. And yet all over India, policemen are ridiculed by generalization. Feel sad to see this.

  • @bharatraj4134
    @bharatraj4134 Рік тому +3

    Million thanx to palki Sharma. A rare insight of how India built themselves, a smooth transition from British to भारत, from भारत तो democratic strong Bharat Desh. The paper put by you shows your in-depth knowledge, without which you would not touch any subject. Thnx.

  • @venkatakapardeemallajosyul3779

    Excellent post. Yes it is true that the Civil Service officers and the government officials who have built our modern India. It is also a fact that we would not have been united but for their contribution.

  • @manoranjansamal8032
    @manoranjansamal8032 Рік тому +8

    Great and honest story for those hardworking officers of INDIA 🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @jc3176
    @jc3176 Рік тому +1

    Wow Palki like always great report thank you so much for the recognition of all the past heroes !!!
    And today you’re certainly one love Your honesty & truthfulness way to go Palki

  • @yogirajdhake5967
    @yogirajdhake5967 Рік тому +8

    Great job you are doing through this series of news.

  • @tokiblah5388
    @tokiblah5388 Рік тому +1

    Excellent presentation. These flashbacks on modern Indian history by Palki Sharma are enlightening for most Indians for whom these finer details of Indian History were never taught nor discussed in school and collage curriculum. I Wish Palki Sharma would dwell more on such subjects. She has the disposition and demeanor for such presentations .

  • @anikalaghari1919
    @anikalaghari1919 Рік тому +4

    Always waiting for the Flashback every weekends. Thank you team for the hard work!

  • @servicetohumanity9256
    @servicetohumanity9256 Рік тому +2

    Great blessings to all civil servants and their children and grandchildren who work honestly and tirelessly to improve this nation and take it to higher level in all spheres. A great respect to all unsung heroes of ICS.

  • @ayodhyadawar2757
    @ayodhyadawar2757 Рік тому +53

    Corruption is more rampant in india ,modern day bureaucrats are corrupt to the greater extent of course plenty are honest too

    • @snehasahoo1718
      @snehasahoo1718 Рік тому +8

      There has to be a balance everywhere. there are indeed corrupt ones but there are loyal ones also. It has always been like that. Ultimately power and corruption go hand in hand but it depends on the person that whether he wants to use that corruption for ulterior motives or for the betterment

    • @jhansirani5281
      @jhansirani5281 Рік тому +1

      ​@@snehasahoo1718 Your last sentence..are you ok with corruption..

    • @snehasahoo1718
      @snehasahoo1718 Рік тому

      @@jhansirani5281 No. but it is true that till there is money and power in the world corruption cannot be omitted. But a middle way can be chosen. For example sone people do corruption to fill their own pockets and sometimes this also leads to difficulty for people and some business men like they are not able to set up their business and as a result we loose a lot of jobs. Now when an officer does this corruption thinking of good and then uses this corrupted money for the welfare of people like donating it in the NGO and all then it is a good corruption. We think that developed countries are free from corruption, that’s not true. In America there is a legal word for this lobbying which particularly means that the big businessmen will support the political leaders and in turn they have to make things east for them. The Chinese police officers are more corrupt than the Indian police officers

    • @ximin_sleepy
      @ximin_sleepy Рік тому

      @@snehasahoo1718 no we have a better solution abolish this colonial atrocity, replace it with a better accountable performance based system, private organizations are efficient for a reason, we don't need beurocrates who halt the development of the nation, under the name of service.

    • @snehasahoo1718
      @snehasahoo1718 Рік тому

      @@ximin_sleepy Some do not. There are many civil servants who did better work than the government in order to promote the growth of nation. And we can’t abolish everything as we will still need police officers to maintain law and order. And private organisations will also function for their own benefit. But what we can do is make the system more efficient and should keep checks on them also. Like proper training of police officers and making sure they are doing there duty. Also we should refrain the civil servants from entertaining the vip. For the vip security there can be private organisations providing bodyguards. In this way many people will get jobs also and the bureaucrats will focus on their jobs

  • @nehasplendid99
    @nehasplendid99 Рік тому

    Very correctly said Palki, good that you spoke on this. No Nation can be a success without a team of such intellectual Civil Servants. It is always the team that wins not and individual :)

  • @pankajmehta2928
    @pankajmehta2928 Рік тому +5

    Super topic for discussion. Great job.

  • @hassobhatia2885
    @hassobhatia2885 Рік тому +1

    Wonderful research, thanks palkiji. Had opportunity to serve Indian central government for six years..leaned so much about bureaucracy..

  • @pravinthombre7610
    @pravinthombre7610 Рік тому +5

    Only you can do justice to such topics ! Great art of story telling ❤

  • @Adykr1
    @Adykr1 Рік тому +2

    India needs more civil servants the gems of Indian democracy.

  • @udynes4457
    @udynes4457 Рік тому +26

    In my country Brazil the population is deeply divided. There is no chance of Brazil going anywhere but to disaster. Brazilians are reaching the point of hating each other.

    • @a.i2625
      @a.i2625 Рік тому +2

      Same in India also . People are fighting with each other on basis of religion and ethnicity. Government is playing communal politics and spreading more hatred among people. Just see what is happening in Manipur and Haryana .

    • @msdolly6101981
      @msdolly6101981 Рік тому +7

      ​@@a.i2625: 😅 this country was divided on communal lines 75 years ago. Religion based hatred started long ago not with haryana. Atleast now we don't have bomb blast everyday. Far better than the "Golden era" under the congress

    • @currentmatter4319
      @currentmatter4319 Рік тому

      ​@@a.i2625 it's Abrahamic faith peoples who see the other as Kafirs.
      Who hates the Indian civilization ideology.
      Now we can what happened in mewat

    • @punitadatta
      @punitadatta Рік тому

      ​@@a.i2625Especially the religion in self denial: Humanism.

  • @ashokgupta-jm2kc
    @ashokgupta-jm2kc Рік тому +1

    Thank you, this is an eye opener but since 2014 eyes are closed.

  • @sristi21
    @sristi21 Рік тому +9

    You are doing great di and your team too👍

  • @pinchutube
    @pinchutube Рік тому +1

    Really, chills running down my spine.

  • @Ssarah88466
    @Ssarah88466 Рік тому +29

    This is the 63rd day of eagerly waiting for Palki to finally grace us with her episode on Indian trains. It felt like a miracle, an interesting twist of fate that her previous video about Indian trains was released just one day before the grand triple train event in Odisha. I remembered how passionately she praise upon the advancements, sophistication, high quality and sheer brilliance of Indian trains during that segment! The anticipation is driving me wild; I can't wait to feast my eyes on this exquisite masterpiece of a video soon. I'm convinced it will be an extraordinary episode. I have been saving all popcorn for this very special occasion.

    • @daniel.92a3
      @daniel.92a3 Рік тому

      @@kakun63 what she meant is that she wants palki to the video on the odisha incident. Because the last episode about indian trains palki was saying how wrong the german cartoon was and how good indian railways are.

    • @Canyouseemeanna
      @Canyouseemeanna Рік тому +11

      ​@@daniel.92a3Dude it's not a she-its a Chinese bot. It has three channels targetting India and US. Someone already explained to this bot in previous comments that the accident was a case of sabotage and the accident report infact reinforced how technically sound Indian railways are but as the German video said why focus on truth when you can peddle propaganda.

    • @Canyouseemeanna
      @Canyouseemeanna Рік тому +4

      Dude it's not a she-its a Chinese bot. It has three channels targetting India and US. Someone already explained to this bot in previous comments that the accident was a case of sabotage and the accident report infact reinforced how technically sound Indian railways are but as the German video said why focus on truth when you can peddle propaganda.

    • @Canyouseemeanna
      @Canyouseemeanna Рік тому

      ​@@kakun63what are you saying? The case is being investigated by CBI for sabotage.

    • @Apache1970
      @Apache1970 Рік тому +1

      ​@@CanyouseemeannaYeah, but in my opinion the Railways need to get privatized to improve safety. The whole Indian government is a benefits system for the employees with little returns for the tax payers, much like the British East India company.

  • @cambalachandrakanth6742
    @cambalachandrakanth6742 Рік тому

    Palki Sharma, what a voice to hear and the topic choosen is really awesome and needs to be appreciated for the unsung heroes of India.

  • @UsmanAli-zt1fu
    @UsmanAli-zt1fu Рік тому +3

    I am a Tehsildar from Pakistan. This video proved really useful to me to understand how important the role of bureaucracy has been since beginning.

  • @prithwimanmitra4527
    @prithwimanmitra4527 Рік тому

    A very authentic report … thanks a lot for honouring those numerous nameless faces who runs the country.

  • @shubhaarunkumar1523
    @shubhaarunkumar1523 Рік тому +3

    Very well explained with interesting facts 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👌🏻👍🏻

  • @mahendramansingh7403
    @mahendramansingh7403 6 місяців тому

    Wonderful narrative! Ms Palki Sharma, Bravo!!!

  • @jethiya7990
    @jethiya7990 Рік тому +4

    Many people forget or ignore that if all Bureaucrats were like that then our country will be not running and at least not on the level it is standing today.

  • @osodowilberforce2321
    @osodowilberforce2321 Рік тому +2

    Wonderful nostalgic history,thank you Palki.

  • @ranjees3473
    @ranjees3473 Рік тому +3

    Thanks for picking this topic Palkii👌🏽

  • @ahmeddixit3999
    @ahmeddixit3999 Рік тому +2

    Thanks much for sharing this info.... May Allah bless and strengthen the honest good leaders of India

  • @tusharshukla9761
    @tusharshukla9761 Рік тому +9

    But we should also notice the cancer of corruption engineered by some extremely corrupt bureaucrats, those who charge their percent of share even in the slightest of administrative and executive procedures .

  • @ushathairani7940
    @ushathairani7940 Рік тому +1

    Very informative and nice programme. Thank you Palki Sharma

  • @paramagan
    @paramagan Рік тому +4

    First post needs to make clip on Indian justice system. Its rottinnto the core and millions of Indian are without justice. same on all these channels who really dont to talk about justice not delivered.😢

  • @Ranchhoddasji
    @Ranchhoddasji Рік тому

    Kudos for this story. Valuable. The positives far outweigh the unhealthy realities of India's steel frame".

  • @ubaidullah7772
    @ubaidullah7772 Рік тому +3

    Palki you are so beautiful. You are the cutest. I love you.

  • @sreenivasreddy5339
    @sreenivasreddy5339 Рік тому

    Great to watch your news. I love you Paliki dear. Your news really contribute for India's growth. Love you dear❤❤❤

  • @souptikmukhopadhyay6531
    @souptikmukhopadhyay6531 Рік тому +3

    We should also remember that civil servants are also quite prone to corruption and grossly misuse their power

    • @wiv2631
      @wiv2631 Рік тому

      I take it then that all were human beings, and it is easier to remember the very worst ones?

    • @souptikmukhopadhyay6531
      @souptikmukhopadhyay6531 Рік тому

      @@wiv2631 you can't defend them using this as the very heart of corruption of govt money lies in the hands of these civil servants ...

  • @drabhijitb
    @drabhijitb Рік тому

    Absolutely great Palki.
    These are really unsung heroes of Bharat about whom we rally do not know anything❤