The Problem with Reforming Religion: Hinduism Vs Christianity & Islam
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 тра 2021
- Religion is often forced to move with changing times. But what are the consequences to this? How does Hinduism fare compared to Christianity and Islam?
CORRECTION: Would like to make viewers aware of two errors in the referencing of quotes:
@6:51 the quote should have
One should renounce artha and kama if they conflict with dharma and even dharma if it results in future unhappiness or arouses people’s indignation. (Manu 4:176)
@7:12
The quote is taken from the Karna Parvan book 8 chapter 69
Note to viewer: The views on gender discrimination in Hinduism and the need for change are to be taken in a general sense. They are not in reference to specific cases such as the Sabarimala temple. The overall point is that Hindus in the 21st century are free to decide what rules are best for their traditions and temples.
man this channel is so underated... its not fair this guy should have atleast 1m or 500k subs
This tells you a lot about Hindus and their indifference to Sanatan Dharma.
@@devolishash3946 yeah
@@lovleenmehta5313 But those who worship for the love to the diety and not for the material desires gets the higest enlightnment and mukti . pls understand the script properly and then u explain it to me
@@lovleenmehta5313 shut up they were not given dalit status , from where are u getting this stupid information. ha first understand properly and then speak . koi bhi ata hai bolne ke liye
@@lovleenmehta5313 telling me about my dharma it seems .
So true. Sanatan Dharma has this flexibility which makes it eternal and ever-evolving ❤
Today's Hindus don't know anything about hinduism and they abuse their own religion. I am really happy to see this UA-cam channel which is teaching the real meaning of hinduism. I share all your videos
its normal .... when you are fond of baba who didnot teach u about Hinduism but co -called spritiually
islam says- become a muslim .
christianility says - become a christain
hinduism says- become a human
That would be nice!
@@shantinaturechild6385 India teaches become pseudosecular
Hinduism says - realize your true nature as the divine soul, a manifestation of Satchitananda / Eternal, Omniscient, Supremely Blissful Spirit
low cast human or high cast human?
@@Syed_12 . 🤣😂🤣 कूराnd का अर्थ 🤣😂🤣👇👇👇😂🤣🤣
कुरान का मतलब , कु = खराब , रान = टँगड़ी ! खराब टांग ? मोहाम्मद का एक टांग खराब था इसलिए उसने खराब टँगड़ी के नाम से निहायत घटिया एक सोच उछाला जिसे शैतानी शागिर्दो ने भलीभाती लपक लिया ।। उसके बाद की कहानी दुनियां जानती है , कैसे इन नामुरादो ने दहशतगर्दी मचा रखी है ?. पुरि दुनिया मै आतंक फैला रखा हे और खूद की मा बहनो को भी चोद देते हे थू इस आतंक के मजब पर thoo thoo ।🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂या उल्ल्ल्ल्लाही उल्लाह M0hmad रSoo ल मेरा गू खा 🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂
तभी तो फातिमा 💃की chuत👙 के पीछेM0hmad 🐷इतना उतावला था बेटी👩👧 को choद👙 के 200 👩👧👧बच्चे 👩👧👧बनाता है hL@ला👙 करने के बाद chuत👙 पवित्र हो जाती है। और बहन 💃choद👙 रही बात फतवे के तो बहन💃 choद👙 तेरा धर्म तुम चुडि या 💦गां*💦 मरवा के चला रहे हो आसमानी किताब📘 से।😭😭🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
कागज देख भो*_@सड़ी के......
🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂😂😂😂
अल्लाह🐷👙मादरचो* tt 👙 हैं, खाता सुअर🐖 का गोश्त है । 😬
मुहम्मद🐷 मेरा सा ला है, 💦लं *💦की तरह पाला है । 😬
आयशा 💃मेरी रखै
Only a hindu can think of following dharma rather than spreading it.(forcefully)
There is difference between the word *DHARM*and RELIGION.
Religion = ONE GOD
ONE SCRIPTURE
AND
COMMANDMENTS.
No one can go BEYOND that,I ;e
ULTIMATE TRUTH.
Idiots exist in every religion who always do bad things and thus makes people look upon them with a bad view. That doesn't mean the religion is inherently bad.
When scriptures say that they won't recognize existence of other religions/GOD'S
KAFIR.
CRUSADE
JIHAD.
NON BELIEVERS
ETC
Who R the IDIOTS?
This channel needs more views it explains Sanatana Dharma so well in English. Thank you 🙏🏼
Dharma speaks shld have 10 million subscriber or more because this is best among all youtube channels.
Every person who call himself hindu should watch this video. Namaskar 🙏
Another great video as always. I'd like to see you create a video on the topic of Vedanta. It would be nice to see someone explain the different schools of Vedanta in a comprehensible way. Sometimes it's hard for me to wrap my head around the concepts.
Already done ‘Hinduism why so many philosophies?’ Have a look on the channel 👍🏽
@@DharmaSpeaks Thanks brother
Can you make videos on the life and teachings of Various Hindu saints such as Sri Ramakrishna paramahamsa, Swami Vivekananda.
Outstanding description of the essence of Sanatan Dharma. Shruti is eternal while smriti is for the times we live in and should evolve with time.
Unfortunately , The Masses in India can't be farther from the Real Hinduism, It has been long forgotten, Only the Scholars and Intellectuals go to Understand the Real Meaning and Depth.
Hats Off to You .
You cant imagine the Ripple effect of your great Work for the generations to come.
Thank you
Thank god you are back
कृपया सभी सनातनी हिंदू भाई ही हमसे जुड़ें
हर हर महादेव🙏🏻🔱🙏🏻
Shiv bless you @Hindu sherni
Wow - can't miss this one!
I am happy and proud to be born in a dynamic and ever evolving faith called Hinduism which has no founding book or ultimate authority. Hinduism believes in Desh(country), Kaal(time) patra (individual) which means that morality is subjective to country, the current times we live in and upon the individual
You opened my eyes!! Thanks a lot
I'm hyped!
Namaste, so eloquently profound! 🙏🕉️
You are such an underrated channel, you should post more often
Change is the only constant. Something which is constant is something which is eternal. Sanatan Dharma will always remain open. Namaste and love from a Hindu from India!🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🚩
G = Generator ( Who is generated this universe) Lord Brahma
O = Operator ( Who operating this universe) Lord Vishnu
D = Destroyer ( Who end this universe) Lord Shiva
So God means Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva
Muhammad prophet : I am the messenger of God.
Jesus : I am the son of God.
Krishna : Oh Arjuna, I am the god. 🙏
@@TodayYearsOld114 so what's so Respectful.
@@saniatamanna7763 What do you mean "what's so respectful"? I respect my bhagwan and other's beliefs too, I didn't say anything wrong. Don't start something for no reason. 😐
SIR 😭YOU MADE ME FEEL CRY I LOVE YOU SIR , INDIANS WERE ALWAYS MADE TO FEEL SHAME ON THERE RELIGION BY OUT SIDERS BUT LOOKING AT YOU I JUST CANT CONTROL MYSELF EVEN OUR SO CALLED FAMOUS SCHOLER CANT EXPLAIN THIS THING THE WAY YOU EXPLAINED IT
The ones who forcefully convert someone to their religion is probably an egoistic idiot, and that doesn't mean their religion or your religion is itself bad.
Thank you Dharma Speaks 🙏
As always fantastic video on Dharma and it's concept in modern times.
The problem is also that many conservative views of Abrahamic religions are based in translations that are highly debatable too. But I really love how you differentiate between morality and revelation.
Thank you so much for your work on this. I've been struggling to find great sources to learn from, and your channel has been a gem. I know sometimes it can be easy to get caught up in view counts as a metric for impact, but just know that you have undoubtedly changed my life with your work.
Excellent video as always 🙏🏼🎉🙏🏼
Sanatan Dharma is not only religion but it is our Great Indian Culture also and every Indian should respect their Culture irrespective of their religion because first we are Indian and it's our first Duty and we have to respect our Great Indian Culture Love you all from India jai Shree Ram jai Shree Staya Sanatan Vedic Dharm Jai hind Jai bharat bharat mata ki jai vande matram jai Bhartiya Sanatan Sanskriti 🇮🇳🚩😇🙏✨
Very good description and opinion, I like your suggestions. God bless you.
Excellent Video! Thanks for your video and efforts in upholding the truth.
Thank God for this man
A video on the position of women in Hinduism would be highly appreciated!
Jai Sanathan Dharma 🇮🇳 🕉🚩
Not model of religion, but guiding principles rooted in Dharma. Many Thanks for the the important video.
🙏🙏🙏🪔🪔🪔🌀🌀🌀
Great insights! 😊
Thanks for another fantastic video. I love these videos, as the bring a unique light on the true Hindu perspective, which the mainstream media quite conveniently ignores. It is thanks to you, that I realized the truth about the Sanatan Dharma and came to appreciate its teachings.
Once again, thank you for bringing me back on this path! I hope, and would love to see, you reach great success. All the best
This is a very crucial video for present day Indians. Thank you!
wow, great explanation!
There is more than one lense through which we can and should view the world and beyond. This, as always, crystallises the dharmic choice superbly.
I wish you soon have at least 500K subscribers.
Excellent content 👍
Wonderfully explained.
The way u explain 🙏
Great job!
❤️
This channel needs at least 1 million subscribers.
Bro i found ur channel while i was searching some stuff about sanatan dharma and here i am you are doing a great work i will always support you if this is what you do
There are many types of yoga (paths) to achieve god in hinduism like
1 Bhakti(Devotion based ) yoga ,
2 Gyan (Knowledge based) yoga ,
3 Hath ( Body based) yoga ,
4 Raj (Inner control mind control based ) yoga ,
5 Kriya ( Performing certain action to achieve god ) ,
6 karma yoga ( Doing action with out pleasure desire of result and attachment )
And more , that is why hinduism is like religious democracy
This paths are related to each other and not absolute or isolate , The main goal of all this paths are to abandon material pleasure and achieve god by devotion and realise eaternal truth that is much more important , i agree with your saying that hinduism is evolving by its nature but keep intact core value of realising god....
There is no "Bhakti" yoga. We have just shradda (based on truth). In Bhagavad Gita, the word Shradda was replaced with Bhakti (blind devotion) by colonialists to promote blind bhakti movements which can mimic Abrahamic religions. Madhavacharya and Ramanuja were created out of thin air by colonialists to create duality between atman and brahman by distortion of original ADVAITHA AND DVAITHA.
Point is advaitha (non dual shiva) and dvaitha (dual shakhti) are incomplete without each other. This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience.
@@Dharmicaction oh brother do research see chapter 12 heading of bhagwad geeta it is bhakti yog , we already have bhakti we didnt get it from colonisation but we call it unconditional (nishwarth ) selfishless bhakti and not blind bhakti , sanyasi , sadhu baba leaving material pleasure doing is same
@@Dharmicaction i already know this god is both advait and dvait which guru ram krishna param hansh already proved it , he got ma kali in dvait form and brahm gyan from totapuri and got god in advait form , guru mentioned that both are same and lead to one , in hinduism we have freedom to choose any of this
to be clear.. I DO appreciate the honest point of view regarding the critique of both moderates and progressives.
जय श्री कृष्णा 💓🙏. May Lord Krishna bless you everyone 💓.
Hare Krishna
Wow!! Very nice video
Bg 5:18
Shree Krishna reveals in this verse how divine knowledge bestows a vision so different from physical sight. Endowed with knowledge, devotees see all living beings as souls who are fragments of God, and are therefore divine in nature. The examples given by Shree Krishna are of diametrically contrasting species and life forms. A Vedic Brahmin who conducts worship ceremonies is respected, while a dog-eater is usually looked down upon as an outcaste; a cow is milked for human consumption, but not a dog; an elephant is used for ceremonial parades, while neither the cow or the dog are. From the physical perspective, these species are sharp contrasts in the spectrum of life on our planet. However, a truly learned person endowed with spiritual knowledge sees them all as eternal souls, and hence views them with an equal eye
You explained it perfectly. By the way which Gita are you reading?
Well, we can't deal with a terrorist and sadhu in the same way, can we?. This contextual ethics is called Dharma.
Krishna asked Arjuna to kill his adharmic relatives and when Arjuna was worried about consequences, Krishna said (in chapter 18 verse 17) if the intention is to re-establish dharma without getting caught in opposites like pleasure/pain, pride/shame, sympathy/hostility (aka ego-less state) then one does NOT create karma or cause and effect.
Point is yoga pathway chosen depends on the context. When the motive is to get only Moksha faster, then sanyasa + dhyana yoga can be followed. While leading a worldly life and to escape from mind chatter and detachment form past actions one can follow Jnana yoga. To deal with adharma in the society Karma yoga can be followed.
Dharma, Karma, reincarnation and Moksha (based on the well validated Vedic metaphysics Sankhya) should be looked together. So, Jnana yoga (going beyond all identities) is not the only pathway to get enlightenment. Sarva dharma and sama bhava. All yoga pathway lead to the same destination.
If one fails to do their svadharma by pointing that everything is 'athma" - then it is nothing but escapism (unfortunately practiced by some hindus selectively)
@@sachisin1924 bhagwat gita as it is
@@YRSK6666 i meant description wise which Gita u r reading?
@@Dharmicaction but these contextual should be used to discriminate in terms of gender and birth. If a person is born into some caste due to his karmas then let nature decide his fate not us.
Jai Shree Ram 🚩🔥. U r awesome
well done.
Jaigurudev :)
I try to find good things in all...all sides..
Good video...
Hare Krishna 🙏
Its great that you mentioned this, because Manu Smriti is a clearly edited which also has a verse which contradicts the other, the original version is lost and some maniacal Brahmans used this to suit their own need, it's good that no one follows it now
Very informative video brother 😀. Keep going. Love from India 🙏🚩
"Only the change is constant"
A ship needs an a rock where it needs to anchor itself, if it anchors in an ever changing sand it will never withstand the stormy and ever moving sea. I have seen many people just drift, they usually end up ship wrecked.
This video specifically deals with reform. Have a look at ‘Where do Hindus get their morals from?’ on this channel. Discerning societal ideals is linked to our level of consciousness. Sanathana Dharma is ultimately a call for society to derive its values from its spiritual truths and practice.
The ship can hit the rock and get wrecked. If you are permanently tied to the rock, you can never leave the harbor for an adventure. You stay stuck and rust.
Greatest channel ever....talk about SANATHANA DHARMA@
HINDHUISM...
I love this chennel
Nice videos and vert clear views of Hinduism .
I request u to make a video for sankhya philosophy .even many Hindu's dont know any thing about sankhya school.
Please make a seprate video dedicated to sankhya philosophy .
Thank u
Hinduism is perfect Sanatan h
But why did Rama commit suicide at the end? Was samadhi normal then? Such a great king. Could hv died a normal death. Or did he face some shrap or karma from his previous ancestors? Because his next Avtara Krishna faced Ramas karma and died with an arrow
Bal Gangadhar tilak said Aryans initially were living near north pole..after ice age..they moved to europe and Asia...
@@lovleenmehta5313 Aryan invasion is fake bro, created by Germans in 1700
I would like to get in touch with you.you seem to be an enlightened soul your conception about spirituality is crystal clear. My guru says real spiritual knowledge comes only after kundalini Shakti which lies at muladhaar is awakened and not before that.
It also comes from listening and eternal learning and seeking for the truth and thinking with our own brains what makes sense.
@@shantinaturechild6385 Buddhi is the cutting instrument. Brain is just like a movie projector. It cannot create thoughts or memories. Yes, you are correct. Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built) can be validated not just by embodied experience but also by logic and double slit quantum experiment.
There are many extra orthodox hindus who want to follow every scripture no matter how morally wrong it's implementation is. A fluid can fit into all types of vessels without losing its properties but a rock cannot. Choice is yours. Stick to bad aspects and lose the entire religion slowly or progess and reform to establish relevance of religion in these times too. Times have changed and you can't bind people to religion by simply asking them to follow rules without questions. This kind of attitude of society led to the persistence of malice like untouchability, unjust behaviour with widows etc in the society for so long. Then there are aspects that are unscientific we should not cling on to them. Evolution is rule of nature. Everything is evolving from the universe to society to microbes. However reforms doesn't mean changing or letting go crucial aspects of this religion like revelations, many traditions etc.
Precisely
Namaste thank for making this very nice informative video bro love you from India jai hind 🇮🇳 🙏😇✨
You have reaffirmed my belief in Dharma. By your work and mere existence you're dispelling darkness, I shall do the same.
जय श्री राम 🙏🔱
Precisely.
excellent video once again. Are we seeing a Vivekananda reborn?
❤🙏
Every one regardless of religion can benefit from these talks.
May I just say
There are no proper Hindu texts that discriminate against race, sexuality, gender or caste
The ones which do say so are man made and can be traced back to specific person
There is no denying some part of religion is man made
But Hinduism is the only religion which allows followers to believe whatever as long as they are peaceful
So being sexist, homophobic or racist HURTS SOMEONE AND THIS CANT BE EQUATED WITH HINDUISM
Super super
Amazing🙏🙏🙏🙏😇🕉️
ଜୟ ଜଗନ୍ନାଥ 🙏🏻
Can you make a video on "Karma"?
What are the differences between "Justice" and "Karma"?
How "Karma" actually work?
already done, check out the channel
When people started to use religion and its moral compass to control people's own free will and leading them to a life of fear of Divine punishment, that's when it all started to go astray. Love of God was changed by Fear of God. Fear will never lead to a truly fulfilling spiritual life, because one can not love where there is fear.
Thats the problem w Abrahamic religion they say to fear God but also love God. No1 can love someone and fear them at the same time it'll get in the way of the relationship between God and human. God wouldn't even want to be feared anyways He loves us
@@shani2926 stop criticizing religion . Respect every religion be it dharmic, abrahamic or anything else
@@saniatamanna7763 bro that was ages ago when I was ignorant I ain't like that anymore 😂
नमस्ते, the manusamhita 12.105-106 is misquoted it seems because the reference when looked up says something else. ty
🙏🙏🇮🇳
In Hinduism the sky is the limit for the mankind. There is no ideology but enlightenment only.
Being a woman exploring spirituality kind of sucks. You have to go 4,000 years back to the first writings to find a time before woman was degraded and enslaved. This is now the best women have ever had it and we are progressing further with the help of the beautiful, kind, honest men seeking truth instead of power. Women will free men too, and we will be able to embrace and balance the masculine and feminine within each other and proceed towards enlightenment. Hating the opposite sex means you hate an important part of yourself too 💖
How do you choose your topics?
islam and christianity are history centric religions and sanatan dharma's is dynamic... history centric religions are based on events which happened once a upon time and cannot be repeated...they are very weak in nature.. dynamism of sanatan dharma survives with time while history centrism dies with time.(reason why history centered religions are predatory in nature)... love this channel
They're not even historic Amd everyone copies existing stories from the other.
Who knows who was there first and which one is true if at all!!!
They are just fantasy stories propagated as history. eg Virgin birth of Jesus to Prophet Muhammad meeting angel Gabriel sent by so called "God".
I have people wanting me to react to some of your videos. Do you allow it?
No one follows Manu Smirithi ...you will find only the Bhagavad Gita and Upanishads in person following Sanatana Dharma
8:30 exactly
Please enable Monetization....
You have very rightly said that Hindu dharma is always evolving with the changing times.for example we have done away with Sati dah pratha and also person of lower caste were not allowed in Temple and now all Hindus can go into any temple for diety Darshan. The very fabric of Dharma is to distinguish between the ever changing world which is Maya and cling on to the truth itself which is eternal .Here is where meditation and inner contemplation comes. What that is happening in this World is because of desire for satisfaction of ones senses .one should rise above these mundane things and concentrate on God alone.That has not changed my friend. One should realize that we are all stuck in this world of illusion and running after things which we will leave behind no matter how dear they are to us .try for liberation from this life and death cycle. That should be the ultimate goal of all human beings.
Sati was practiced by a few tribes in Rajasthan and Bengal but propagated as a pan-india practice by the British then and their commie henchmen now.
Only in the Kali Yuga.
Very agreeable video. Hinduism is a model for all religions
Can you do a video about the Aghori
We should all let love towards all animals including humans and Nature and the laws of Nature be our religion. Then there would be no war on earth!
Freedom and love and health to ALL that is!
Nature isn't all that peaceful and loving. Just look around, diseases, venomous snakes, nasty insects, etc. In nature, the unfit dies and only the fit will survive.
Why on earth is this channel has 60k the content is like a channel with several million subs
The 4 class of people is based on work not on birth. Today's age is the age of devotion. Keep chanting the maha mantra"HARE KRISHNA HARE KRISHNA KRISHNA KRISHNA HARE HARE ;HARE RAMA HARE RAMA RAMA HARE HARE "
So why are the Hare Krishnas advocating Brahmina initiation for everybody regardless of their occupation or position in society? Instead of giving the Gopal mantra which is the standard Vaishnava mantra, they are giving Gayatri as a second initiation. Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu repeatedly rejected the Varnashrama system as a means of achieving the highest goals in life. ISKCON is a conservative social reform movement aimed at establishing a Brahmina-led society. In Sri Caitanya lila, Ramananda Raya, Haridasa Thakur, Raghunath dasa and others were recognized as Mahatmas and leaders despite their lower birth caste. But Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu never tried to revise the system officially - HE JUST DISCARDED IT in favour of a higher platform of devotion. In the name of social reform, ISKCON has got themselves entangled in an outdated system that has traditionally perpetuated all kinds of abuses. The speaker of this video is correct. We should focus on higher goals and move on.
@@stillborn826 bhramanas were the people who were in the mode of goodness.(In today's age the case is not same.)When they say "be like a bhraman" they actually mean is to be in the mode of goodness first.This is for all people irrespective of their respective class(bhramin,kstriya,vasiya and sudra).
@@Me_bhi_jinda_hu With respect, it is not necessary to institutionalize the mode of goodness by giving Gayatri Mantra and sacred thread. This only causes confusion. ISKCON has already alienated foreigners from joining by failing to distinguish between social and cultural issues like Varnashrama Dharma, and what is essential to Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu.s teaching. Now ISKCON has practically become a form of Indian cultural nationalism with only a handful of foreign devotees (90% Indian and 10% foreign membership worldwide) This is not what Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu or even Srila Prabhupada intended. But like Prahalada Maharaja says, the effort to solve a problem often just creates a bigger problem. In this case the problem is that the imposition of an artificial caste system to reflect the mode of goodness is a huge distraction to the real business of Vaishnavism i.e. chanting the Holy Name.
@@stillborn826 Then what do you think the solution is?
@@Me_bhi_jinda_hu Put REAL faith in the Holy Name and recognize its priority over caste, religion, colour, gender etc.
All religions will loose their relevance if people are brought up as free thinkers. Curse internet, it will happen more and more.
No... Buddhism, Advaita Vedanta, many Hindu traditions etc will still survive very well. I am a free thinker. There is no idol worship or guru in my family. But we are very much Hindu in our demeaner, our idioms, our greetings, our festivals, our marriage, rice ceremony, death ceremony, in little kids organising Saraswati Puja and adults organising Durga Puja. Nobody worships Idols, they worship a concept, and when that's done the idols are immersed in water.
Will we ever get a face reveal?
EDIT: GOT IT. You misquoted 4:176 as 12:105-106
Original message:
but I don't understand the correction
@6:51 you are quoting a different quote in description. The one on screen is 12:105-106?
जय श्री कृष्ण
जय श्री राम