PM, Speaker clash during fiery Question Time
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Prime Minister Scott Morrison has clashed with Speaker Tony Smith during a tense exchange during Question Time on Thursday.
Mr Morrison was forced to withdraw comments he made about Labor leader Anthony Albanese in relation to the Somyurek scandal.
"This leader of the opposition, in the midst of a debacle and corruption scandal that he has overseen, corruption a word that..." Mr Morrison said.
"The prime minister will resume his seat. The prime minister will resume his seat. The manager of opposition business will resume his seat. The prime minister needs to withdraw that imputation," Mr Smith said.
"Mr Speaker, on the point of order ... No."
"Members on my left! Member for Kingston, the member for Kingston will cease interjecting. There’s going to be no debate. The prime minister needs to withdraw that imputation."
How much do we pay these fools to waste our time.
too bloody much. They do nothing but pocket our money for the little work they do.
Most backward polies you will find are cult members doing the bidding of evil for a doggy treat
They hate SCOMO because he joined the Trump train. You will find he is true blue and one of the best Prime Ministers we have had for a long time. However we need to boost One Nation to kelp SCOMOS associates in check
fast$$$$ parties ..In drongoberra
What dog act, blaming the recession on the government. He bloody well knows it's the world wide pandemic.
It's all labour have left is parliamentary games. It's other hobby is encouraging leftwing loon students and other trash to cause riots to wreck the country. Labour's attitude is if it's not in government, it will destroy the country. The labour party credits are pushing unions for high wage increases which has left heaps of people unemployed like in manufacturing. Single women having kids and living on welfare, wanting refugees and other no economic contributing migrants. And a complete destruction of moral standards in society. Well done labour , the party of scumbags and criminals.
Blame the deep state
Children playing whilst Australian businesses are dying. Pathetic.
Hang the lot of these clowns
Agreed. It’s all just a cock show. They hate SCOMO and are out to destroy him because he joined the trump train
boo hoo
Same in the UK, you should see our parliament.
well liberals are reluctant to do lockdowns while labor would see us shut forever if cases are more then 10 a day so go figure...
CORRUPTION IN AUSTRALIA IS THE MAJOR PROBLEM!
Bigger problems on the rise look what gates says
m.ua-cam.com/video/c4ojwQaGcyk/v-deo.html
It always has been and getting worse. Conspiracy’s are rife.
And our Prime Minister is trying to do what’s best for the nation
Lnp are nothing but corrupt dogs
@@KingZorLink21 complete bullshit
I love this Speaker!! 😅
He's doing a fair job, keeping to the rules. Far superior to Bronny.
He just needs to crack down on the Coalition's liberal (pardon the pun) use of "I move that the member no longer be heard" whenever they don't like the question a Labor MP is asking them, which isn't the reason the rule exists, and encourage debate in the house.
his name is Anthony Albanese. he's going up against Scott Morrison soon! by the way things are looking, he'll be the next Prime Minister of Australia.
As roudy as the British House of Commons is, the Australian parliament is frequently a disgrace.
What's the point of the bloke telling them to be quiet when they interject 5 seconds later anyway?
Shambles, embarrassing
Given we have a partisan speaker in Australia, I very much admire the Speaker’s independent and fair handling of this issue against his own party leader. Just as we saw, the Prime Minister’s fragile ego was shocked and affronted at being called out for his poor behaviour.
Morrison really lost it. He was like a toddler arguing with the Speaker. He hates getting called out and at the end of it, didn’t answer the question.
Do you ever expect him to ever answer the question?
That's what ScoMos like
That why he is no longer the pm ...
He obviously missed the fact that the entire world has been hit with COVID-19 and Australia happens to one of the best examples of handling the virus.
He knows fully well that it's the virus... He's just trying to use it to attack Scomo.
we were just lucky. if the primeminister did a job we would have no cases
You obviously missed Labor got us through the GFC caused by conservative ideology of DEREGULATION ... *without recession* And were pollard constantly by conservatives for going into debt.
@@off2dr4u keeping up? ive forgoten more then you will ever know
@@off2dr4u you make a statement but cant back it up haha. are you not all there or do you just like to insult people like a usual left tard
COVID is going to be blamed for many failures, even those of Politicians..... "accountability" 0 - COVID 6,000,000
Wish our politicians would stop pointing fingers at each other and remember who really caused this crisis. China and WHO.
119.941 dead and climbing thanks to Trump policy... not China policy.
Jasmine Love oh I’m watching the US very closely. It’s like a heads up on what’s coming next here.
These same fools that hate America are the same fools that import the worst of the USA.
#God bless the USA
#Aussies for Trump 🇦🇺❤️🇺🇸
@Axeholme Enjoy the Infection and death toll election.
dominic pelle
You’re clearly either disingenuous or a fool. Worst cases in the US, all in Democrat held cities.
Enrico Mammarella Dominic pelle is probably 50 cent army troll. Just ignore them.
What a weasel question from Albo to start this all off.
Maybe Albo is upset that his union chums haven't been given billions upon billions like they are in Victoria ? Ahh, Victoria- a place where the premier earns more than the prime minister, a place where borrowed money comes from the magic pudding that is china.
@@alexanderpowell1528 You really need to state facts, and if you don't know them, don't lie. PM pay is $550 thousand, Andrews is $440 Thousand. As for your quote of BILLIONS upon BILLIONS from Unions, that's a lie straight out of the Trump play book. You Probable should go online and see how much is donated to the Liberals in Victoria and to the Federal Government. Labor donations pale into insignificance compared to the Liberals.
@@MrsToodle47 oh dear, I've upset a pinheaded labor staffer who can see the writing on the wall for his beloved religion. Cheer up young rent boy- you've got your money from China now so you can get a job as an unskilled laborer with the cfmeu and earn $147K annually, or anally if you prefer.
I have seen better debates in kindergarten
Pathetic rabble, both parties... number 1 requisite to become a politician is to be a pathological liar
someone has to... good luck for you two if you ever decide to go into politics.
maybe stop arguing ..make stuff here ..australian people are not silly in the head ..one rail gauge sell nothing to ccp...
one love
They're a pack of clowns from both sides and people need to finally wake up and put both these dishonest and corrupt party's last
Seriously, parliament has no sense of respect for people who are speaking, 5 year Olds behave better than this lol
Oh my gosh he needs anger management
Please cut all politicians salary buy 10%-15% to help all Australians recover from this pandemic
who will cut them? you do realise their salaries are high because they dictate government policy. ie, they can choose how much they get paid
you are witnessing the swamp on both side of politics. Time to vote them all out.
Look at how weak ScoMao is as a debater.
As long as Tony Smith,as the Speaker ,puts Morrison in his place at every opportunity,because he tried to belittle the Speaker and that deserved dismissal from the chamber.
u sould blame ccp send covid_19. stuoidily
It is not ONLY China's doing ... most smart people do understand that... But china is now in the same position as germany was in the 1930's... needing to expand to keep her economy from faltering... All governments are owned by transnational interests ... The chinese government is now a successful transnational corporation... We should all remember that no matter where we are , a greater part of ALL our populations will suffer very badly, this is the next step in globalism according to the UN goals>>> depopulation
What an utterly disgraceful performance by our Prime Minister.
The recession was coming, COVID-19 or not, happens every ten years. Its how its handled that matters.
First recession in 30 years dude
Help out the single mum's. Help out the disabled. Help out the poor. Help the aged pensioners. Stop taking from the poor and giving to the rich. Tax cuts to the rich and payment cuts to the poor. Come on.
Liberal won't see that done, but Labor will.
@@beefykeith48 Labor just as bad they ALL corruption with an agenda
Scomo to the Time Out room .
That being the case, Mr Prime Minister, sue China for effects of the coronovirus.
, no, sue The w H 0, for causing this recession
He’d rather sell off our assets to China than sue them. As for who caused the recession Nick, that’s entirely down to the mismanagement of our economy by the current government. We were in a recession on a per capita basis as of March 2019.
What I want to know is, what is actually achieved at these government sling shots?
LMAO I love how the speaker dosen't even look the PM in the eye, he literally looks like he could care to do something else then deal with the room full of political todlers.
This is how many times he said "Mr Speaker"
👇
Twice
@@eliwhaley4804 lol
Tony Smith will be missed!
They gave themselves a pay rise
Anyone body else just feel like Tony Smith looks Corporate as fuck?😂🔥
yeah, but a whole lot better Speaker than Bronnycopter Bishop!
Nobody lost there jobs because of our choices.
Is he high?
Take responsibility for the choices you make.
The country did not need to be locked down, less than 1 percent of Australians where infected.
All the government is a joke, they ack like school children bickering back and forth .
What happened to maturity and civil discussion, these people make us Australians look weak to the rest of the world.
As someone that's only in there thirties, Grow up and do your jobs, because this is pathetic.
The current Gov did not give us the this problem. This is because of the CCP's mishandling for the wuhan virus and that's why we are suffering in this way!
Albo should be sorting his mate Comrade Dan out and the thieves and criminals within his own party......and they do nothing for the rest of the country. They should all be charged and thrown in with the rest of the criminals
but the Liberals do the very exact same thing
It's the Recession we had to have...
Priests are being paid. Universities and artists aren't. Lol.
Coalition priorities.
Why target one group of people? They are not being paid by the government but by the donations of people. In many cases, particularly in very small churches they have lost their income too.
The question "How many unemployed Australians don't have a job because the Prime Minister deliberately excluded them from Job keeper" was not answered. As usual the PM dodged the question and at the same time showed himself up as being out of control and had to be pulled into line by the speaker.
Not a word out of scunt Morrison is actually factual
he implied corruption & immediately tried to cover it up cause he knew they were onto him. What a goof
Like he can talk. His party is rife with it, whether it be sports rorts, car park rorts, protection rackets for MPs so they can hold onto their slim majority - you name it, the LNP are currently doing it.
The weakness of democracy, two parties system, is the argument they have to do, the speaker is the person who says please be quiet the PM is talking, the opposition won't listen, they still talk while the PM talks. Who is in charge of this country really?
"Who is in charge of this country?" - either the queen or Rupert Murdoch.
I think Labour have got him
Such a creep. Repeating Mr Speaker every second word doesn’t cop it.
They have to say it, it is the rule.
What a Kindergarten. An absolute joke.
Good on Tony Smith he is a fantastic speaker who doesn't hold back
He should've been named by the speaker
Ken oath you withdraw you absolute muppet. Should’ve been removed.
Excuse me Mr speaker, I just shit myself!
-scomo (probably)
The prime Minister is a JOKE.
It's a case of the pot calling kettle black they are a joke, they need to listen to the people they should be serving and be held accountable personally when corruption or lieing has taken place, not at the taxpayer experience, parliament needs to be cleaned up .
I wonder what the stroke/heart attack stats are for house speakers? Worst role in parliament!
Watching with interest from the UK. We in Britain look forward to having a great free trade deal with Australia and New Zealand. Our friends across the globe, we have a shared history and share the same head of state, the Queen. Lets move forward in cooperation :)
How about no. Stop moving to our country.
Make Australia a republic we don’t want to be associated with you guys anymore
I want a dollar for everytime the PM says Mr Speaker
It breaks my heart to know these are the people in charge of our nation and they get to make decisions the rest of us are forced to accept but also endure the lasting consequences. This just puts our nation to shame and if the women and men who fought in the two world wars and the wars that subsequently came after those two world wars could see this today I am sure they would be absolutely ashamed as well!! Perhaps it is time that every time a politician lies, is rude or disrespects their role of power and leadership they were fined $20,000 on the spot that comes out of their over abundant salaries and that money is put into a fund to support the micro and small businesses that are run from homes in Australia so those who actually made or can create real jobs for themselves get the financial support they need where the outcome is 'real' jobs!!
What happened?.
Albo is an Economist. He knows more about money than SM has had hot dins.
Are you seriously implying the Australian economy would be in better hands with a Labor government?
@@Chris-vp3fn Yes I am! These lieberal Lying Nutjobs have put us into so much debt with this Co-Vid it's just not funny. Thanks to their Princess they called Ruby.
@@alexajessop5590 oh yeah because Labor did so well when they were in charge. Bill Shortens budget was so ridiculous that it cost him the election. You’re blaming liberals for trying to keep people with income when unemployment went through the roof last year?
@@Chris-vp3fn yeah because a trillion dollars of debt is solid economic management! Liberal doubled labors debt even before COVID. And jobkeeper/jobseeker was a labor/unions idea that the liberals have taken all the credit for. So you have to thank the economy not completely tanking for a LABOR policy. Don't forget, Labor got us through the GFC with a triple A credit rating. We were one of the few first world economies to actually flourish in that period. But sure, keep sucking the Liberal party's right nut bahahaha.
@@Chris-vp3fn i dont think most of the voters read the budget, or knew anything at all abkut it, or really gave too much of a shit about it.
Dunce hats for the lot
This is why the Labor party is not in government. Each-Way-Albo's question was ridiculous, knowing full well the situation.
What a rediculas system. No wonder Govt never achieves anything resembling common sense or courteousy. We have an elected prime miister who is continously attacked by opposition & media. While State government do whatever they want. People are unemploye by stupid mandates created by Labour state Governments. God help us all
its like some mad jedi level of chess they are playing.
If, by Jedi Chess, you mean kindergarten Tonka tantrum slap down.
Your words mean nothing Scotty! Off you toddle!
Why can't the speaker look PM in the eye when he speaks to him?
Have you seen how Charlie Manson looks close up?
and your ruthless ideology mr adman
The poor are definitely not going to inherit the earth under your watch Mr Adman
and climate change buffoons don't realise they want to save the planet for the people making bank off the backs of what they are agitating for ( energy poverty)... next stage is depopulation according to the UN policies... how they have engineered this, ?....Lower co2 in developed countries with strict EPA rules and massively over regulating the population, increasing government worker force ( big government)... The UN lets china double emissions from 11 billion metric tons to 20 billion per annum before 2030... Oh the break from reality is astounding...and can only be achieved through heavy indoctrination ... we are very compromised through the UN agenda
Looks like Scomo is as sick of this crap as we are...
So what i gathered from all this was
Nothing about dealing with Ccp
There will be many more 100s of thousands after 17th December.
We're here because the governments in action. We were in a decline before covid. The jobe keeper was changed many times to actively exclude sectors. We have had mass economic shut downs because the federal government let states handle quarantine instead of managing it themselves and building appropriate quarantine centres.
This rabble, runs the country?????
How are things going for you now Albo ? You’re a flog
God I love Kingdom Politics ....... if you want a Republic .... you’ll get a boring Congress like America
America has better rallies than Australia, we don't attend rallies because we know they're clowns, this is just proof, but clowns are entertaining.
Actually … only major personalities like Bernie Sanders and Trump have large rallies. You should have a look at a Kamala or Biden rally. Snooze fest
@@a.hoctavius5848 still, bill shorten couldn’t pull a crowd
Australian politics is a blood sport
Albo really struck a nerve there huh LMAO
Tony Smith was one of the better speakers to grace our parliament. Morrison was very lucky not to be asked to leave under 94a
AND YOU CAN SIT DOWN....... Love it, go PM!
That guy with the red tie is mewing 🤫🧏
i say this guy did something wrong. response: not allowed to say that for some reason. they are arguing on how to talk and recycling arguments so no accountancy of the thing complained about is dealt with and then everyone forgets the mention of it.
Great speaker!
Good, real debate. This is the type of passion the BLUE-GREEN ALGAE faction of "Bossy Beyonce Berejiklian" is trying to ban in the New South Wales Parliament, or "The Bear Pit." This type of debate is great, I love it.
Mr Bill Hilly...first post I agree with👍
I could not share my 1.5 m distance with Albanese....
I'm picturing some big Spinifex grass vertical super farms for internal market development and as a material export.
As fair as this speaker was, there should definitely be a change in the process of electing the speaker. They shouldnt be part of the government.
He didn't actually withdraw though...
if only this was john bercow as speaker
This shit is the same as our leaders in London houses of parliament ...All out of touch
Tony Burke clearly does not know the rules.
Aust gone into recession because of lost of export market... period
The service sector was slowed by covid not agricultural production like wine fish and other products.
What the hell? Sky news is posting a video that makes the liberal party look bad????
I like ScoMo
Well you agreed to it Albanese. Now your placing blame.
Nice....
What a bunch of children for gods sake
🎀🕯️ The parasites are public they are everywhere and with covid 19 it's all worst.
☁️🕊️God bless
Why does sco mo remind me of an Aussie Will from the inbetweeners in 30 years
Unless all countries affected by this virus come to an agreement that China is 100% responsible, then this petty squabbling will never stop. China hasn't the balls or necessary means to counteract a rebuttal if we all come together and make them pay up financially..
china will be put in the same position as germany was before the second world war... These are very dangerous times geopolitically and we will all lose...
tell me does the government believe in individualism or conforming unity
it is a three ring circus
Finally, the bully shows his true colours!!
Mr Speaker Tony Smith should've kicked that thing pretending to be pm, out!
AND he owes Tony Burke an apology!
horrible actors