Vitamins and Supplements: Magic Pills - the fifth estate

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2015
  • As many as three out of four Canadians use natural health products. From herbal remedies to minerals, vitamins and other supplements, it’s a billion dollar industry that includes everyone from Big Pharma to Mom and Pop operations. They're products packed with promises, but what’s actually in the bottle? Could we be taking too much? And could they actually be harmful to your health?
    For more on the fifth estate : www.cbc.ca/fifth
    Follow us on Twitter : / cbcfifth
    Like us on Facebook : / thefifthestate

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @SuperTeeter
    @SuperTeeter 5 років тому +38

    Health Canada start doing your job!!!

  • @huiyingtanyayap
    @huiyingtanyayap 8 років тому +23

    14.30. she clearly didn't expect that kind of question, and just gave some BS answer.
    i went to see nutritionist, she prescribed me 5 to 6 different supplements from her company, i was like 'this is BS!'. that was clearly she was trying to sell her pills.
    i am healthy now without taking any of her pill.

  • @yelenaantipova3964
    @yelenaantipova3964 7 років тому +432

    33:00 so he is saying that he didn't do any study on the product's health effects but he knows it's effective because he wouldn't put it out there if it wasn't effective. I think you should go into comedy, buddy.

    • @adanacman666
      @adanacman666 6 років тому +13

      my buddy owns a health food store,sells every kinda potion,herb,vitamin,etc,u could think of,and he confides, what a joke it is, and he laughs, all the way to the bank,every single day,with armfuls of cash and a great big smirck on his face

    • @cicelyambrose435
      @cicelyambrose435 6 років тому

      Yelena Antippen mb

    • @dennismckeown5863
      @dennismckeown5863 6 років тому +6

      I guess you just lost you're only friend now.

    • @douglasnorthpole8542
      @douglasnorthpole8542 6 років тому +3

      That is how the nutraceutical industry works.

    • @Rayschall1
      @Rayschall1 6 років тому +3

      kwokshsee: I had to edit to write your name to make sure that I agree with you: Exactly, I thought the same so what choice do we have? Food? that, too, most of them poisoned. That means we shall starve.

  • @bobmarshall3700
    @bobmarshall3700 6 років тому +53

    Too much Vitamin D will cause hypercalcemia which will cause calcium blockages in the heart arteries and hence a heart attack. Vit D3 needs to be taken with Vit K2 to put calcium into the bones, not the bloodstream.

  • @jerramy
    @jerramy 5 років тому +229

    So ironic that we need to take vitamins to replace the vitamins taken out of food by the processing manufacturers.

    • @DaniAlchemilla
      @DaniAlchemilla 4 роки тому +17

      Yeah.... money money money.

    • @aminuaidara8601
      @aminuaidara8601 3 роки тому +10

      I don't even know why people need vitamins all u need is eat good food that's all

    • @TerenyiTamas
      @TerenyiTamas 3 роки тому +8

      Because here in wintertime there is no fresh fruits!

    • @soledadcruz6478
      @soledadcruz6478 2 роки тому +16

      @@aminuaidara8601 and where is the nutricional foods these days?

    • @phoebegraveyard7225
      @phoebegraveyard7225 2 роки тому +5

      Reject processed foods and predominately eat whole foods plant based. In the winter, eat frozen fruits and veg or Canadian brown root vegetables and brassicas like cabbage and kale when price or availability is an issue. Frozen also got me through the pandemic when I only went to the store once a month. That being said, in Canada if you don’t go outside, vitamin d still needs to be considered, just not in the mega amounts often offered.

  • @chrisp558
    @chrisp558 7 років тому +82

    give this lady a cookie... i love her stories

  • @kerryewen3624
    @kerryewen3624 Рік тому +3

    I’m so glad this came across my screen 📺.

  • @BlueHeron654
    @BlueHeron654 5 років тому +11

    Pregnant women need folic acid. Many people need calcium, iron, and vitamin D. Many people do not eat their veggies and need more. Vegan's need B12. Everyone is different. I have COPD and take carnitine and nac. It helps me

  • @jenholmes4033
    @jenholmes4033 4 роки тому +72

    I get my vitamins from fruit, vegetables, nuts & grains + a B12 supplement weekly & I am 92 & never been sick . No animal products for me.

    • @MG-hg1sq
      @MG-hg1sq 3 роки тому +5

      Saved by jesus christ ?

    • @snake1625b
      @snake1625b 3 роки тому +4

      Why B12 supplement?

    • @HappyMonkey11
      @HappyMonkey11 2 роки тому +3

      @@snake1625b B12 is made by the bacteria in the soil. We no longer consume this bacteria with our food and water due to sanitation so we need to supplement. Meat eaters get it recycled from the animals (who are ironically supplemented with it as well). Plant based eaters need to take a B12 supplement directly. :)

    • @HappyMonkey11
      @HappyMonkey11 2 роки тому +1

      Yes! Plant based whole foods for the win! 2 years pbhf and in the best health I've ever been 🌱💚

    • @paulmaxwell8851
      @paulmaxwell8851 2 роки тому +2

      @@snake1625b It's popularly believed that older adults can't absorb B12 properly. In fact, only about 20% (1 in 5) have this problem. Yet most doctors recommend all their older patients take a B12 supplement, without bothering to identify a problem first. Doses of 1000 mcg or more (400 times the recommended daily allowance) are usually suggested. My wife's doctor pulled this stunt and I hit the roof when I found out. It turned out she did NOT have a deficiency. That doctor was playing Russian roulette with her health.

  • @kimwilletts8476
    @kimwilletts8476 2 роки тому +18

    I remember my mother giving me cod liver oil, spoonfuls, when I was small, guess that was bad too? I'd rather take my chances with vitamins than some of the thousands of pharmaceutical products that are recalled each year. But people should choose careful what they are and how much they are ingesting into their bodies.

    • @helenkimayong369
      @helenkimayong369 Рік тому

      !

    • @nicp7826
      @nicp7826 Рік тому

      God forbid people taking some vitamin supplement and actually become healthier as that could cut into the profit share of big pharma. Who's gonna buy med if everyone is healthy??

    • @floand12345
      @floand12345 Рік тому +2

      These ARE unregulated pharmaceutical products 😂

    • @cincin4515
      @cincin4515 Рік тому

      No. The old cod liver stomped out ricketts which was a dreadful childhood deformity. Your mum did good. It's not needed now due to the abundance of food but some scandinavians still use it due to 6 month winter's devoid of sunlight. It was replaced with vitamin d in the west.

  • @EnergyCuddles
    @EnergyCuddles 4 роки тому +24

    Before taking supplements, thoroughly examine your diet and its nutritional content.
    That way, you can rule out what you absolutely do NOT need to ingest more of. My diet for example, is pretty low in magnesium.
    So I know that I need to compensate for that - either by adjusting my diet or taking (an appropriately proportioned) supplement.

  • @fredinatub
    @fredinatub 4 роки тому +255

    Does anyone else not wonder how come in 2019 we still don't have a clue what is good and bad for us or what the exact amount of vitamins we need.

    • @riyyahd8442
      @riyyahd8442 4 роки тому +2

      @cat Stapleton The BEST response I have heard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @restlessmind8921
      @restlessmind8921 4 роки тому +5

      @@riyyahd8442 lmao i hope you're being sarcastic

    • @Sadrul-Amin
      @Sadrul-Amin 3 роки тому +16

      Nowadays it’s very hard to believe anyone from the nutrition industry. Everyone saying different outcome with different food and supplements. However, I am over 40. I got positive out come with high power (7000 iu d3 +k2). If we get sunlight our skin creat 20,000 iu d. So lil bit high dose of d3 with k2 is not a problem. However, if you got cold and flue take high dose C . With in two days ..you will be clear. D, k2, zink, C and magnesium this safe me from Australian flue. It’s my personal experience.

    • @bunny.bunbob
      @bunny.bunbob 3 роки тому

      @Don Mega strawman

    • @user-ft9tw9zw5p
      @user-ft9tw9zw5p 3 роки тому +5

      Even in 2020🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

  • @CrazyforCruiser
    @CrazyforCruiser 6 років тому +171

    Chiropractor making vitamins is like a barber circumcising children.

    • @lizAscully
      @lizAscully 6 років тому +10

      Kamran Khan lmfao best comment here

    • @BeautygyaanBG
      @BeautygyaanBG 4 роки тому +11

      Dr. Eric berg is one of them on youtube

    • @restlessmind8921
      @restlessmind8921 4 роки тому +5

      ironically this used to be very common in my country tunisia lol

    • @E-Kat
      @E-Kat 4 роки тому

      So you mean we don't need chiropractors !

    • @WowWowzie
      @WowWowzie 4 роки тому +6

      Kamran Khan he was a chemist first! You have selective hearing!

  • @terryharnden5510
    @terryharnden5510 5 років тому +5

    With glyphosate all of our food has become toxic by omission > of all the vitamins and minerals necessary for the proper operation of our immune systems. Also when is Health Canada going to test all vaccines for safety and effectiveness and publish the results.

  • @DamienAshorTV
    @DamienAshorTV 4 роки тому +3

    Anyone from outside Canada also hooked on the Fifth Estate? Texas here

  • @Peekaboo-Kitty
    @Peekaboo-Kitty 2 роки тому +5

    If the food that is being produced wasn't vitamin and mineral deficient we wouldn't need these remedies!

  • @altheasmalling5826
    @altheasmalling5826 3 роки тому +18

    I love this channel and I am thankful for the exposure. Our people are being robbed of good health all in the name of a fancy, fast life. The world needs to know that the closer we stick to nature, the better it is for our health. Our heavenly Father loved us enough to give us what we need and the love of money is ruining that for us quite well. Our heavenly father cries for his people who are suffering from a lack of knowledge. A big thank you from the Caribbean!!!!!

  • @Captain_MonsterFart
    @Captain_MonsterFart 5 років тому +20

    Taking more than the recommended dose of vitamin D means I don't fall into a horrible depression every winter. It makes things more tolerable.
    THere's the other problem that agricultural soils are badly degraded and there is simple not as much nutrition in industrial food as there used to be.

    • @Captain_MonsterFart
      @Captain_MonsterFart 5 років тому +4

      This show also conflicts with what I was hearing and witnessing 10 years ago where many natural health products were being banned from Canada right and left, the reason seeming more to do with decreasing pharmaceutical competition than "preventing harm".

    • @awonderingsoul2445
      @awonderingsoul2445 Рік тому +3

      Tomatoes for example are not grown in soil, they are in a water solution under tarps. Same with other mass production of food. If people really knew what they are eating, they would be horrified. A lack of nutrients is just one of the problems.

    • @Nimyra
      @Nimyra Рік тому

      They don’t want you to take vitamin D so you can can their chemical medicines and stay mental fatigued

  • @alflurin
    @alflurin 7 років тому +271

    If you eat a balanced diet, you don't really need to self medicate with vitamins and stuff that your doctor didn't prescribed.

    • @lizzieAGAIN
      @lizzieAGAIN 6 років тому +6

      Exactly

    • @patricialloyd866
      @patricialloyd866 5 років тому +29

      Even Drs can't prove that the drugs they prescribe you is really good for you

    • @g.s.5868
      @g.s.5868 5 років тому +15

      as if your MD knew anything about HEALTHY EATING, you so funny

    • @Josh-ct6ue
      @Josh-ct6ue 5 років тому +4

      natureboy tom your so silly what makes you think that the supplement s are any safe ?, there’s nothing wrong with the soil eat real foods supplements are bad

    • @louistournas120
      @louistournas120 5 років тому +10

      +oyinbo peppe:
      "Vitamin levels in food these days are so low that it would take impossible amounts of food to eat every day to make up for the deficiency. "
      ==What is your source for that information?

  • @artcika
    @artcika 6 років тому +41

    I remember going to my GP for some stuff and just randomly asked if maybe there's something i could take to improve my immune system, since it was failing me a bit at that time. You know what she said to me? She was like "the best thing is, just have enough sleep and rest, eat properly and it will show the biggest difference". TBH i never really was big on all that BS, except when my mom would go for one or the other. But she wasn't huge on those either. I tried taking certain stuff for skin, hair and nails, but never really saw any difference.

    • @jumper4ever937
      @jumper4ever937 Рік тому +3

      because they don't work.

    • @cincin4515
      @cincin4515 Рік тому

      So your doc gave you excellent advice and you blew her/him off?

  • @victorpalamar8769
    @victorpalamar8769 4 роки тому +10

    I took vitamin D for years until I researched the internet and found that it causes Hypercalcemia which can cause the problems I am having with the urge to urinate when my bladder isn't full----getting up three times a night to pee
    about a tablespoon at a time!

    • @gitismita418
      @gitismita418 4 роки тому +3

      Did u take vitamin d with vitamin K2?

    • @victorpalamar8769
      @victorpalamar8769 4 роки тому

      @@gitismita418 no----with Glucosamine Sulphate and Vitamin B

  • @ursulaeissner9945
    @ursulaeissner9945 5 років тому +22

    The problem is , you ask 10 doctors , you get 10 different answers .

  • @havad3938
    @havad3938 Рік тому +3

    I have been so overwhelmed around my vitamins... Other than magnesium, a bit of d with K2 I am throwing the rest away. I will look into the potassium though.… CBC, thank you.!! So in depth, and not scared to be direct. I've not found anything else so informed.… The world needs to see this.…… Now, if you can press the FDA to share just exactly how they go through a process of approving these vitamins

  • @helenismail6241
    @helenismail6241 4 роки тому +10

    Depends how they make vitamins. It's not problem herbs, it's problem if they mix some chemicals drugs with herbs.

  • @Spiritueli
    @Spiritueli 2 роки тому +6

    Thank you for this. I would agree, moderation in everything, I think its the key ...

  • @kabo0m
    @kabo0m 6 років тому +10

    The problem with vitamins is people don't want them regulated for risk of increased cost as we know what happens with the cost of medication, but at the same time not regulated the vitamins don't always have what they are claimed to have. Who do we trust?? That is the key word ... TRUST. People do NOT have Trust in Health Canada or in the ones who profit from the selling of such products.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @GB-ql8vm
      @GB-ql8vm Рік тому

      @@sambawellnesshub no never heard of it can you please explain thank you

  • @rishaalsharma
    @rishaalsharma 5 років тому +28

    The law should not allow these to be sold in "pharmacies" unless they have been scientifically validated. Selling them in a pharmacy indicates to consumers that everything has been verified by a "trusted" pharmacist so it must be safe and effective.

    • @JohnDoe-in3ep
      @JohnDoe-in3ep 3 роки тому

      Lol, what about homeopathy

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому +1

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @domenicoberardi2739
      @domenicoberardi2739 Рік тому

      200%I agree

    • @D33Lux
      @D33Lux Рік тому +2

      "trusted" pharmacist so it must be safe and effective."
      LOL How many side effects do most if not all synthetic drugs prescribed by doctors and pharmacists. They are legally allowed to prescribed narcotics. Are those "safe and effective"?

    • @aprildec5518
      @aprildec5518 Рік тому

      The law is probably part of it

  • @leanneblake4248
    @leanneblake4248 6 років тому +2

    For goodness sake .Each a Balanced Diet . Meat , Dairy Fish , Fruit and Veg . Exercise go for a 30 minute walk everyday. Everything in moderation .Everything in Moderation try to be Happy. As a Aussie I am Grateful we have Healthcare .

  • @nauxsi
    @nauxsi 5 років тому +29

    I remember reading that 70% of supplements don't have / have very little of the ingredient on the label. Cowboys.

    • @sophiejones304
      @sophiejones304 3 роки тому

      Most of the vitamin supplements are not absorbed by the body

    • @denmark672
      @denmark672 2 роки тому +1

      @@sophiejones304 and you have scientific evidence backing up your claims?

  • @nathanandrewmeima
    @nathanandrewmeima 3 роки тому +4

    I was taught that consumption doesn't equal absorption. Nobody's body absorbs 100% of the nutrients you consume, especially if you're naturally thin. That is why they put up to 10x the daily recommended IU level of vitamins in supplements. If most of it is going to end up in the toilet then you would need to over consume to absorb the desired amount. I learned this in a nutrition class in a culinary school, would love to get someone's 2 cents on it as I have never been challenged on this opinion before. Am i right/wrong? Thanks.

    • @annoyedaussie3942
      @annoyedaussie3942 2 роки тому

      If you look at recommended intake in Australia they actually explain the studies they looked at to come to the recommendation. All recommendations are excessive to have a buffer and does take into account likely rate of absorption. If you look around the world the recommendations are slightly different but within 10% or so of each other.

  • @jeanetteferraro1484
    @jeanetteferraro1484 6 років тому +1

    Wow Mr. Dr. . Newmaster im from Guelph as well. Thank you for your research..

  • @superschnell5607
    @superschnell5607 3 роки тому +17

    So beautifully filmed and presented. Thankyou.

  • @smileandpresson
    @smileandpresson 6 років тому +34

    Really good documentary, make a sequel! Thanks again.

  • @amelie2626
    @amelie2626 3 роки тому +34

    'Everything in moderation' is a motto to live by.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty 2 роки тому +3

      Except for Sugar.

    • @sarahsnowe
      @sarahsnowe Рік тому +2

      @@Peekaboo-Kitty And tobacco and heroin and fentanyl and crystal meth etc. and maybe alcohol . . . .

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty Рік тому +1

      @@sarahsnowe
      LOL!

    • @jumper4ever937
      @jumper4ever937 Рік тому +1

      bad motto. Means that you don't know anything about food.

  • @charted8015
    @charted8015 3 роки тому +2

    Vitamin pills now contain much stringent vitamins. I just check mine. It says it have 8.8 mg E per pill lower than 15 mg what we need everyday. Since we have other sources of E, it is ok to eat one pill to ensure sufficient intake.

  • @shanellecanares
    @shanellecanares 3 роки тому +3

    I was obsessed in taking vitamin c , multivitamins, biotin and vitamin d before that caused my ferritin and iron saturation levels up. Now I’m doing venesecation to remove the iron from my system.

  • @debrawalker4642
    @debrawalker4642 5 років тому +23

    Like any food industry you need a Quality Control system.
    Someone who watches and controls the process of manufacturing and quantity of ingredients. Bacteria, mold and oxidation has to be picked up during the testing of these products. And the person who does the testing has to have the guts to document it and report it.

    • @timway6839
      @timway6839 2 роки тому +2

      Don't mention big tech back handers.
      Don't think they ran out of money paying the politicians.

    • @timway6839
      @timway6839 2 роки тому +1

      Don't mention big tech back handers.
      Don't think they ran out of money paying the politicians.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

  • @nanateali1038
    @nanateali1038 6 років тому +3

    what about the FDA approved pharmaceutical drugs ???? what about the quality and contaminations and others bad things they have, please we need a report on they products too.

  • @devingauthier2933
    @devingauthier2933 8 років тому +62

    I love this show, at its best.

    • @mhikl4484
      @mhikl4484 6 років тому +2

      Not a problem, Devin. But do not take anything for granted. All the answers are not on that programme; there is more to health than a 42m TV show can, well show and inform.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @arunainvent4926
      @arunainvent4926 Рік тому

      @@sambawellnesshub Meditation for a better life span yet no never infinite life

    • @ethimself5064
      @ethimself5064 Рік тому

      This vid has been debunked and CBC has actually apoliged for it. This as based on the fact that when they tested the products the tested Wrong. They tested for whole products and many are in a Standardised Extract form. Some caught were indeed correct. So far rhe CBC gas refused to take this vid down.

  • @glenncurley680
    @glenncurley680 3 роки тому +12

    I have always had my suspicions about vitamin companies!

  • @philipmcdonagh1094
    @philipmcdonagh1094 2 роки тому +6

    I've read loads of medical books, watched hours of medical documentaries, that sure don't qualify me to open someones heart up, of to make pills of any kind. Don' know what the law is in the US, but here in Ireland making pills of any kind without some sort of a license will end you up in a spot of bother.

  • @barend4285
    @barend4285 5 років тому +6

    The Ad I saw before this vid was for Vitamins!! :D

  • @jj-oo6oi
    @jj-oo6oi 2 роки тому +2

    This documentary is of a quality.

  • @wioi
    @wioi 2 роки тому +5

    *A doctor from a private and damn expensive clinic prescribed me vitamin D pills with 20. 000 iu per pill and he said I should take one twice a week. After 2 weeks I felt dizzy every time I stood up as soon as I stopped taking them the dizziness stopped. As soon as I started to take them again, the dizziness returned. So I knew that those vitamin D pills sure weren't good for me.*

  • @dillsimmons
    @dillsimmons 6 років тому +55

    Welcome to corruption lol

  • @marcosrissi
    @marcosrissi 2 роки тому +4

    This is very interesting. I had an idea of possible bad quality of supplements but not at all to the extent showed in this documentary. I am left with more questions than answers I think.

  • @boxersoho
    @boxersoho 7 років тому +22

    I have had multi-vitamin, omega-3, protein supplement and creatine mono-hydrate and felt better. Please also note that i had 10 hours of rigorous cardio and weight workout per week. If you are couch potato, i bet all these supplements will hurt you in short and long term as well. And btw, omega-3 does have inflammation effect, i have experienced it first hand in knee joints as i perform squats with weights in gym and wrists while performing bench press.

  • @bronsonstone725
    @bronsonstone725 Рік тому +2

    at about 21 minutes the lady interviewer states conclusions from various research articles indicating that the research demonstrated the products were of no value, the person she is interviewing responded by saying something to the effect of "the articles contain good supporting data, but not the conclusion", the interviewers response was "but conclusions are conclusions". This seems reasonable by the interviewer, however I have read thousands of research articles and have found many to be bogus, insofar as the research was done using ineffective quantities therefore resulting in conclusions of ineffectiveness.
    If research was to be genuine, it should be done using dosages utilized by real doctors, one as mentioned Linus Pauling, but also Robert Cathcart, Abram Hoffer, Jorge Fletchas, David Brownstein for starters

  • @theeditor592
    @theeditor592 5 років тому +6

    18:42+ they worry about oxidize oil/lipids that can do harm. What do you think of boiling pots of oil for your french fries??? Or any frying you do in your house???
    Find a good Nutritional Supplements you can trust. It only takes 3 months or 6 you should feel big improvements or even better... Got Better from your ailment.

  • @jo-annguthur7314
    @jo-annguthur7314 8 років тому +62

    Marketplace and fifth estate can you do a study on usdaOrganic and NONGMO labelling !

    • @myfirstaccountonutube6243
      @myfirstaccountonutube6243 6 років тому +1

      Jo-Ann Guthur hellz yeah

    • @susannahats6358
      @susannahats6358 6 років тому

      Jo-Ann Guthur I am sorry that my comment is so late lol but listen to Food Revolution Summit that starts tomorrow April 8 2018 they talk about a lot ,go to the website and register its world wide and free, it's every year and life changing.

  • @marcfavell
    @marcfavell 6 років тому +18

    My food is my medicine.......and Lil bit of weed!

  • @dennismckeown5863
    @dennismckeown5863 6 років тому +15

    Dr David Kessler needs to look at the Pharmaceutical company's.

  • @ebonypenguin2899
    @ebonypenguin2899 Рік тому +4

    When the health official stated that he had a harder time taking on the supplement industry than big tobacco 😳. I have wisened up significantly now, however, at one point I spent a small fortune on seeing naturopaths and taking bucket loads of highly expensive supplements for chronic ailments. Perhaps I was fortunate to only lose money and waste my time. Dr Harriet Hall has an excellent series on debunking the anti-scientific elements of the wellness industry.

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty Рік тому

      I take my Vitamins every day and they help me a lot. Without them I would no longer be able to function properly.

  • @dave11282
    @dave11282 7 років тому +55

    the power of knowledge, good video. I have made my health worse by taking too many supplements. Get your nutrients from mother nature, good nutritious food

  • @marissaspuza9892
    @marissaspuza9892 2 роки тому +35

    Wonderful studies, I have been asking this for a long time in my mind - how would you know whether what the vitamins are claiming are really true?

  • @prettypurple7175
    @prettypurple7175 Рік тому

    THANK YOU FOR MAKING IT SO CLEAR/////

  • @AnonymousPacifist
    @AnonymousPacifist 3 роки тому +7

    Noble documentary, some minerals and vitamins in a high amount are a no no🐽

  • @Lottieloves287
    @Lottieloves287 3 роки тому +3

    This is so sad. Our governments need to protect us from harmful chemicals on food, medication, technology,etc. May God protect us and bless us all. 🙏🏼

  • @Rickcpt
    @Rickcpt 6 років тому +2

    Thanks for that.. !!! What I do not understand at all is that currently your views are only on 210k.... everybody everywhere shoud watch this.. thanks again !!

    • @Rickcpt
      @Rickcpt 6 років тому

      should

    • @E-Kat
      @E-Kat 4 роки тому

      It's not about some mass murderer!

    • @E-Kat
      @E-Kat 4 роки тому

      Or popstar!

  • @tonymack6656
    @tonymack6656 Рік тому +1

    A wonderful expose of the vitamin supplement industry. Hope this will save a lot people a lot money.

  • @MasKistershi
    @MasKistershi 7 років тому +127

    People that take supplements need to instead concentrate on improving their diet with a balanced range of healthy foods. Then they won't need supplements.

    • @deniseg-hill1730
      @deniseg-hill1730 6 років тому +18

      MasKistershi
      You would have to make sure all your food was purely organic, not the chemicalised products that are around. Fruit, veg meat, milk etc full of chemicals all the crap fed to animals, intensive farming so cruel, spraying fruit and veg crops sprayed with chemicals.

    • @gerraddowns4909
      @gerraddowns4909 6 років тому +5

      Except that it's just big organic trying to get into your pockets as well. Notice when Amazon bought whole foods? they cut prices the next day

    • @robinlu4011
      @robinlu4011 6 років тому +11

      @Denise You literally cannot acquire food that has no chemicals in it.

    • @jeffdevine6387
      @jeffdevine6387 6 років тому +17

      not to mention that the soils are depleted and the vitamins and minerals that should be in the food are not there anymore.
      If we all grew a garden, there would be no food shortages

    • @eirikmurito
      @eirikmurito 6 років тому +4

      The supplements are useless anyway. The doses are so low you wont even notice any difference. If you eat healthy food you notice the difference instantly!

  • @AmandaGDumas
    @AmandaGDumas 3 роки тому +3

    Does anyone know any organization or third-party site of some sort that has information/research regarding the quality/composition of specific brands?

  • @reginalynnbush
    @reginalynnbush 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for sharing this.

  • @ecek123
    @ecek123 Рік тому +1

    But cantaloupe is not the most vitamin c intense fruit. He should have used kiwi. 1 person can easily eat 5 kiwis...which would make 350mg of vit.c, so maybe the pill could be divided into 2 or 3 for daily use (if the person is eating fast food all day). But when someone is sick, doctors recommend 1000mg per day. Excess vit.c is taken out of the body with urine anyway.

  • @TimTeatro
    @TimTeatro 4 роки тому +10

    4:05 - a chemist that went into Chiropractic. Oh, my, gosh! Why would you study real science and then go into quackery and anti-science? Was it a money thing?

  • @genim5913
    @genim5913 5 років тому +47

    I absolutely love how they show the equivalent in food source for the vitamins, like that's all that the source contains is the vitamin portion. Yes the cantaloupe only contains vitamin C! Sad part not a lot of people actually analyse what they are showing and how everything is presented.

    • @BettyJ155
      @BettyJ155 3 роки тому +16

      Something I've heard (or read) is that foods today don't have the same level of nutrients they had 60-70 years ago, because the soil is overused (for lack of a better word). So, that is why we would need to eat so much more vegetables or fruit to equal what one fruit gave us 60-70 years ago. Hence the need for vitamins to supplement our diet, since we cannot eat the quantities of food needed to get our daily requirements of vitamins and minerals.

    • @webdevdude1438
      @webdevdude1438 2 роки тому +5

      I think you misunderstand, what it is coming to is that we are overdosing on vitamins. He also said that we should listen to our stomachs and used the fruit to measure, it would be impossible to naturally consume the amount of vitamins that we take from the bottle.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому +2

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty 2 роки тому +5

      If the food that is being produced wasn't vitamin and mineral deficient we wouldn't need these remedies!

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty 2 роки тому +6

      @@BettyJ155
      I think the word you're looking for is "Soil Depletion." Plus all the fruits and veges you are getting is NOT fresh. It's kept in refrigeration for months before it hits the shelves. That's why we need the extra vitamins and minerals.

  • @tracyheaslip8754
    @tracyheaslip8754 3 роки тому +3

    Avoiding it's now 20 21 and vitamin D is helping stop covid-19

  • @SellYourHomeEZ
    @SellYourHomeEZ 6 років тому +3

    little is it known that vitamin c is in all kind of veggies.... for example - kohlrabi has more than lemons... people look and know your food, spend money on fresh vegetable and fruit, cook at home, eat a bit of everything even chocolate and live healthy

  • @NeilRoy
    @NeilRoy 6 років тому +49

    Wow! I am officially blown away. I never trusted vitamins in the first place as I questioned how replacing real food with a pill helps in any way, but I never expected this. Glad I don't take 'em.

    • @GeekBoy03
      @GeekBoy03 6 років тому +8

      Nobody is "replacing" food with vitamins. How do you know you are getting the needed nutrients which promote better health? Scurvy was a real problem, and still can be for lacking Vitamin C.

    • @NeilRoy
      @NeilRoy 5 років тому +9

      @@GeekBoy03: And yet, here I sit, 54 years old (in 45 mins) and the last time I got a flu was when I was 27. Never had a flu shot, don't take vitamins and rarely even eat oranges. I very rarely get a cold even and the last time I seen a doctor was 3-4 years ago. I used to be diabetic until I prayed about it and then went off all their medication and it went away. I obey GOD, I don't take pills, but I avoid the food HE tells me not to eat and do my best to obey the rest of His laws. How do you explain my good health? Hmmm...

    • @marionaroluwayin7190
      @marionaroluwayin7190 2 роки тому +5

      @@NeilRoy can I know the food God gave you to overcome your diabetes and how to go about it. Thanks

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @jumper4ever937
      @jumper4ever937 Рік тому

      @@GeekBoy03 scurvy is caused by lack of aminoacids, not vitamin c.

  • @es1653
    @es1653 Рік тому +14

    Excellent program! I had no idea that most health food products are only spinning a yarn for the fairy tale we want to believe of these products efficacy and if only we take them we will be 200% healthy and live to be at least a hundred years old!

    • @cincin4515
      @cincin4515 Рік тому

      Everything you know about everything is brought to you by ADVERTISING. The strategy to separate consumers from their money.
      Fear tactics through health concerns generate more than vanity product's.
      The first to reap the millions was the old Listerine ads of the 60's.
      "You probably suffer halitosis but nobody's going to tell you" campaign was the first to discover that frightening people with a made up disease makes millions.

  • @missalowe599
    @missalowe599 Рік тому +1

    Unless Dr Joanne Mansen study include them taking Vitamin K along with vitamin D her study is also skewed.

  • @PharmSistas
    @PharmSistas 2 роки тому +10

    You guys at CBC are just awesome. Thanks so much for this - so enlightening.

    • @sambawellnesshub
      @sambawellnesshub 2 роки тому +1

      Ever heard of Forever Living Products??

    • @ethimself5064
      @ethimself5064 Рік тому

      This vid has been debunked and CBC has actually apoliged for it. This as based on the fact that when they tested the products the tested Wrong. They tested for whole products and many are in a Standardised Extract form. Some caught were indeed correct. So far rhe CBC gas refused to take this vid down.

    • @Cassiee102
      @Cassiee102 Рік тому

      @Samba Global why are you replying to alot of comments with the same statement?

    • @ethimself5064
      @ethimself5064 Рік тому

      @@Cassiee102 Most of this vid is BS as CBC had the lab(s) do the wrong tests and lave deleted it from their real TV library, Plus did apologize later publicly

  • @magdalenaos8215
    @magdalenaos8215 5 років тому +19

    I don't think that we get enough vitamins with food - iron, magnesium, calcium and vit. d deficiency are quite common among people I know.

    • @andyjoseph4198
      @andyjoseph4198 4 роки тому +6

      If someone's level of any particular nutrient is low, it means that they're not consuming the food(s) which contain them, or they're not consuming enough of those foods; hence the reason our diet should be both balanced AND adequate.

    • @eisbeinGermany
      @eisbeinGermany 3 роки тому +2

      but thats people who only eat take away and pizzas and fast food who are sick,,

    • @magdalenaos8215
      @magdalenaos8215 3 роки тому +1

      @@eisbeinGermanyNope. IF I just drink 2 cups of coffee, instead of 1, then in two days I will be magnesium deficient, and my muscles will go wild. Also in northern hemisphere vit. D deficiency is very common because of lack of sun. When did you last time check your levels?

    • @JohnDoe-in3ep
      @JohnDoe-in3ep 3 роки тому +1

      @@eisbeinGermany You're wrong

    • @tommyharris5817
      @tommyharris5817 3 роки тому +1

      @@magdalenaos8215 I drink four cups of coffee a day and my magnesium was checked and was optimal. Vitamin D is the only supplement I take and again my levels are good, above 100 nmol/L.

  • @gudnikristinn
    @gudnikristinn 3 роки тому +3

    I take DHA omega 3 supplements made from algea, which is the same place the fish get it from.
    Going higher in the food chain only increases the risk of heavy metals and oxidation due to the way its manufactured.
    I also put wallnuts on my breakfast and crushed flaxseed in my smoothies etc.
    I don't eat fish but want to make sure i get enough omega 3s

  • @Succubusisis
    @Succubusisis 6 років тому +2

    It’s pretty ironic the industry is taking issue (38:40) with a method of testing for the chemical composition of their products that the Feds haven’t actively approved but wont apply that standard to themselves-the method hasn’t been disproven!

  • @TheHoofn
    @TheHoofn 5 років тому +2

    Very Informative.

  • @plokijuh5830
    @plokijuh5830 6 років тому +4

    Although it does happen, I highly doubt there would be enough anabolic steroids from this type of contamination (equipment wasn’t cleaned well enough) to cause clitoral enlargement (which occurs after long-term steroid use) and for there to be growth of male breasts when vitamin intake is stopped (due to the higher levels of estrogen produced naturally in response to an exogenous supply of testosterone). Anabolic steroids also do not necessarily make you aggressive, not to the point of causing you to get kicked out of school. Contamination is a big issue, especially for athletes who are subjected to tests, and people on anti-depressants and birth control. However this seems to be really exaggerated, which they’d have an interest in doing if they’re suing the manufacturer of the tainted pills.

    • @joanroberts8007
      @joanroberts8007 Рік тому

      Jr
      A very honest, enlightening and informative commentary for all who did not know. I am thankful that we can live healthy lives through foods that nature has provided for us.

  • @freespyrit
    @freespyrit 6 років тому +4

    Linus Pauling.. the worlds greatest quack! love it! Wake up people.. :)

  • @holashelah
    @holashelah Рік тому +1

    Science doesn't have back it, real life reviews for all those many years are what's needed.

  • @larrysullivan1137
    @larrysullivan1137 Рік тому +3

    This is such a hatchet job on nutrients. I take a full regiment of vitamins/nutrients and it has resolved all my health issues although I will say it is much better to take naturally concentrated vs synthetic vitamins they are not the same.

  • @krypticzisback
    @krypticzisback 5 років тому +4

    Best way to stay healthy is to juice and blend fruits an veggies

    • @bettamc
      @bettamc 2 роки тому

      I have very physical reactions to fresh fruits and raw vegetables. 😕

  • @mithzynelson1080
    @mithzynelson1080 3 роки тому +4

    I believe in the medicinal properties of plants. But i know that a lot of herbal companies are taking advantage of our trust and they cut costs by barely adding the medicinal properties needed to reap any benefit.

    • @helenaquin1797
      @helenaquin1797 Рік тому

      And/or just adding the cheap ones..
      Looked at some protein supplements' labels in the store. About 80% Pea protein. Then pea starch is listed next..
      Might as well just eat the peas! Lol..

  • @DrWil-km9zh
    @DrWil-km9zh 3 роки тому

    My favorite channel 👍

  • @jazznyc2781
    @jazznyc2781 Рік тому +2

    Has anyone seen the omega3 TikTok "??? SCARY!

  • @sandraphillips8307
    @sandraphillips8307 Рік тому +3

    You need to take vitamin K to avoid calcification and guide the vitamin D appropriately through the body.

  • @jordanturner5278
    @jordanturner5278 6 років тому +25

    How come since ive been taking vitamins ive gotten sick way less and when i do get sick the duration is alot shorter?

    • @sugarkats21
      @sugarkats21 6 років тому +16

      Jordan Turner Simple, the placebo effect.

    • @maleahlock
      @maleahlock 6 років тому +6

      Confirmation Bias

    • @stefanigreeneyes
      @stefanigreeneyes 6 років тому +9

      My little brother too and me also.. No it’s Not Placebo, my Vitamin D Level is from 10 to 100 now and them it’s like I‘m a New Person.

    • @LadyBeritanavatarius
      @LadyBeritanavatarius 5 років тому +2

      You found a good combination of supplements for your body?

    • @40pianos
      @40pianos 5 років тому +5

      Precisely. That is what the "placebo effect" explains. People believe they are taking something that is efficacious when in fact it is not, meaning the perception of efficacy is psychological, not physiological.

  • @kabo0m
    @kabo0m 6 років тому +1

    I have always heard that vitamins don't have as much in them as much as the actual food but in this video they say that the vitamin is as much as what is more than would fit in our stomach at one time??

  • @cellom.9227
    @cellom.9227 Рік тому +1

    Just get what you need from whole foods. Ditch the ultra-processed packages and eat veggies, fruit, protein. Maybe take a Vit D3 during winter months.

  • @magangordhan4796
    @magangordhan4796 Рік тому +3

    Excellent video about supplements. Best to eat variety of foods n nuts fresh fruit n vegetables. I also use lots different types herbs in my soup. Also garlick.ginger n turmeric

    • @Peekaboo-Kitty
      @Peekaboo-Kitty Рік тому

      All our fruits and vegetables are Nutrient Deficient because of Soil Depletion, so it doesn't matter how much you use, you will still be deficient.

  • @AndyLambg
    @AndyLambg Рік тому +3

    Is all about money to make and alot of greed plus lack of conscience here. Love this show, well documented. Kudos.

  • @joetodd7944
    @joetodd7944 3 роки тому +1

    I have taken supplements for 25years no side effects not like pharmaceutical drugs

  • @funkynate3954
    @funkynate3954 3 роки тому

    hell, do you have an investigation or study about VCO virgin coconut oil..how much tablespoon is the maximum in take in a day? thank you

  • @sparx180
    @sparx180 6 років тому +3

    I take a few supplements but after watching this show I wonder how much of a benefit they are. The politician who stood up and said "Government should not get involved." What a hypocrite he is. Didn't we vote him in to protect citizens and go after companies who are doing wrong by false advertising? Goes to show how a lot of these politicians will never go after the mega rich. You know they are padding their pockets with $'s based on lies and more lies.

    • @domenicoberardi2739
      @domenicoberardi2739 Рік тому

      Now day they will try to stop me ..just about thinking 🤔..(politica)…but can’t getting involved in health problems!?

  • @deniseg-hill1730
    @deniseg-hill1730 6 років тому +20

    The drug industry is no better, prescription drugs cause just as much if not more harm.

  • @safaahamed1246
    @safaahamed1246 6 років тому +1

    Is it safe if i dont take or consume any sort of suppliments or tablets

  • @franciscomontero9728
    @franciscomontero9728 5 років тому +1

    How is the international unit. Molares with the milligrams ? Or how much international units are for milligrams? Greetings from Mexico, very interesting. I take 1000 milligram vitamin c. How much International units are ?.

  • @redeyeboy1000
    @redeyeboy1000 8 років тому +55

    Good stuff,worth a watch,cheer's,

    • @adamj7613
      @adamj7613 7 років тому

      Joe Nelson But they are wrong when it comes to vitamin d. The 600 UI recomendation is based on false information. 600 units will keep you from some effects of defeciency, but its not an optimal dose.

    • @redeyeboy1000
      @redeyeboy1000 7 років тому +2

      Most of information we receive is false,it's every man for himself,vitamin's won't help if you jump of a high building,or hit by a bus.

    • @kabo0m
      @kabo0m 6 років тому

      What is the optimal dose for the average Canadian of Vitamin D and should it be combined with something else for optimal absorption and if so, what?

    • @anomarretsuk
      @anomarretsuk 6 років тому

      Vitamin D3 should only be taken toghether with Vitamin K2,..otherwise it can harm you,...research it yourself

  • @mksabourinable
    @mksabourinable 6 років тому +9

    Wait who takes omega-3 for their heart health?? I take them for my brain... because that's what omega-3 is for??? Like. I just don't eat fish very often, so I take some omega-3 supplements regularly to ensure that my brain has what it needs to function. Like if I've eaten fish that day (or even the day previous)? I skip the supplement. And I only really take it every other day as is.... Sheesh.

  • @carracing577
    @carracing577 7 років тому

    does requirements for vitamins changes with its doses, for fitness athletes

  • @miguelneet3438
    @miguelneet3438 3 роки тому +2

    To me if someone trying to sell you something inside a bottle " run for your life.😱😱😱