Billy Bragg - This Land Is Your Land (UK Version)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 117

  • @protestifications
    @protestifications 8 років тому +46

    Comrade Bragg does it again.

  • @Shorty5959
    @Shorty5959 9 років тому +4

    A friend of mine lives in Edinburgh, so this is nice to find and listen to.

  • @MoonatikYT
    @MoonatikYT 5 років тому +13

    As a Brit, this sounds wrong but right at the same time.

  • @gooders7366
    @gooders7366 4 роки тому +20

    This land is your land,
    This land is my land,
    From the coast of Cornwall,
    To the Scottish Highlands.
    From the sacred forests,
    To the holy islands,
    This land was made for you and me.
    As I walked out through
    The homeless counties,
    The traffic raging,
    Raging all around me.
    I closed my eyes and,
    Dreamed how it could be,
    This land was made for you and me.
    So I am going,
    No one can stop me,
    Where the wild flowers growing,
    Clean rivers flowing.
    Fresh winds are blowing,
    And the tall trees whispering,
    This land was made for you and me.
    I saw a sign there,
    When I was walking,
    And on the sign it,
    Said "No Trespassing".
    But on the other side,
    It didn't say nothing,
    This side was made for you and me.
    As the clouds went rolling,
    And the church bells ringing,
    I heard the songs that,
    The birds were singing.
    As night came falling,
    They went on calling,
    This land was made for you and me.
    From the teaming city,
    I made my escape,
    To find my place in,
    The mystic landscape.
    I'm not the first here,
    Nor am I the last here,
    This land was made for you and me.

  • @flaviomarangon2566
    @flaviomarangon2566 11 років тому +7

    great this uk reagge version wonderfoul bragg

  • @volkerhoff8599
    @volkerhoff8599 7 років тому +2

    reminds me of my wedding holidays in cornwall. Great landscape, great people

  • @narancauk
    @narancauk 2 роки тому +5

    God really blessed UK

    • @narancauk
      @narancauk Рік тому

      @@something1600 In short comunista

    • @quebeccityoliver4742
      @quebeccityoliver4742 Місяць тому

      @@narancauk No. But nice try. Words have meaning and your god ain't real.

    • @narancauk
      @narancauk Місяць тому

      @@quebeccityoliver4742 And your IS....I mean God .hahahahahahahahahaaa

  • @MarkTAllenby
    @MarkTAllenby 13 років тому +3

    @FENNYMAN Touche! Point taken. I agree with you. The world is my world, this world is your world.

  • @stevea2588
    @stevea2588 2 місяці тому

    Chorus:
    This land is your land
    This land is my land
    From the coast of Cornwall
    To the Scottish Highlands
    From the sacred forests
    To the holy islands
    This land was made for you and me
    As I walked out through
    The homeless counties
    The traffic raging
    Raging all around me
    I closed my eyes and
    Dreamed how it could be
    This land was made for you and me
    (Chorus)
    So I am going
    No one can stop me
    Where the wild flowers growing
    Clean rivers flowing
    Fresh winds are blowing
    And the tall trees whispering
    This land was made for you and me
    (Chorus)
    I saw a sign there
    When I was walking
    And on the sign it
    Said "No Trespassing"
    But on the other side
    It didn't say nothing
    This side was made for you and me
    (Chorus)
    As the clouds went rolling
    And the church bells ringing
    I heard the songs that
    The birds were singing
    As night came falling
    They went on calling
    This land was made for you and me
    (Chorus)
    From the teaming city
    I made my escape
    To find my place in
    The mystic landscape
    I'm not the first here
    Nor am I the last here
    This land was made for you and me
    (Chorus) X3 then fade

  • @TheRedflagflyer
    @TheRedflagflyer 14 років тому +3

    @dm1983 he is an english nationalist, but even with an independant scotland (which i support) its still the same 'land' and the same island

  • @PalashDave
    @PalashDave 10 років тому +2

    In response to a few commenters below:
    1. Thanks @TheLauraHowe for listing some of the "Heathens All" musicians who played on this track.
    2.@IndigoJo It's from both! This recording first appeared on www.discogs.com/Various-The-Disagreement-Of-The-People/release/2451757 (where The Heathens were also credited), and next on the 2006 UK, US & Aus re-releases (where it appears they shamefully and mysteriously weren't.)
    3. Discogs nevertheless recognises the Heathens as co-contributors in BOTH the 1995 and 2006 releases. Annoyingly these two mentions of the band don't properly resolve, as one refers to www.discogs.com/artist/698811-Heathens-All and the other to www.discogs.com/artist/1158888-Heathens-All (with an apostophe) Someone should (I might) alert discogs.
    4. Surely it's possible to have a number of different political/cultural identities (regardless of whether one is, in the UK case, a Unionist or a Welsh/Scottish/Cornish/English nationalist/separatist) that take in ethical universalism (and internationalism) at the same time as celebrating love of country region, culture, terroir, and so on? I admit it's a political tension - perhaps one of the defining tensions of the "anti-globalisation" movement - but need it be?

  • @Maximillian-Tiberius-Rex
    @Maximillian-Tiberius-Rex 13 років тому +7

    GREAT version of Woody's song

  • @ilanarhian
    @ilanarhian 12 років тому +3

    cool, I actually grew up with the Canadian version of this ;)

  • @StudioStruyf
    @StudioStruyf 6 років тому +2

    My land is your land, the world is ours.

  • @ChristopherCurtis1977
    @ChristopherCurtis1977 9 років тому +3

    Rest in Peace Aunt Shirley.

  • @imaplateoftoast
    @imaplateoftoast 8 років тому +62

    Can we make this our national anthem instead?

    • @MrIain73
      @MrIain73 6 років тому

      HK the Journalist no with that version no

    • @DaL33T5
      @DaL33T5 6 років тому +11

      I'm American, I want Woody Guthrie's original version to be *our* anthem, too!

    • @MrIain73
      @MrIain73 6 років тому

      DaL33T5 I know woody Guthrie be turning in his grave. I don’t mind the youngsters at school singing it tho

    • @sh-hg4eg
      @sh-hg4eg 3 роки тому

      No.

    • @Freya262
      @Freya262 2 роки тому

      @@DaL33T5 0.++ totally agree - I never understand why the US would want to keep Star Spangled Banner - a song based on a poem about war - as their national anthem when they have songs like this (original) celebrating the country. Warmongering vs pride in the land......

  • @communistpowerranger9629
    @communistpowerranger9629 6 років тому +4

    450th like in this video.Damn this is a good song.

  • @cinemarxism
    @cinemarxism 9 років тому +96

    People don't realise that this is a song about everyone being citizens of one world. Live in harmony everyone!

    • @guyfroml
      @guyfroml 5 років тому +6

      Figuratively speaking, but not literally. It's real intent, as stated by Woody Guthrie, is to appreciate all the beautiful things this world has to offer. It wasn't meant to be a political statement.

    • @drproctologist
      @drproctologist Рік тому

      globalism 🤮🤮🤮

    • @something1600
      @something1600 Рік тому +1

      @@guyfroml "Big high wall there, that tried to stop me.
      On it a sign was painted, said private property
      but on the back side, it didn't say nothing.
      This side was made for you and me."
      Yeah, totally not libertarian communist politics.

    • @something1600
      @something1600 Рік тому

      @@drproctologist Internationalism > Globalism.

    • @FinnZT
      @FinnZT 4 місяці тому

      @@something1600 this isn't the original version of the lyrics, he's talking about the original version of the lyrics

  • @rorybowskill
    @rorybowskill 13 років тому

    @TheLauraHowe Well done....Be proud to be a part of this great song's history

  • @Maximillian-Tiberius-Rex
    @Maximillian-Tiberius-Rex 12 років тому +2

    Great song

  • @contrarymary77
    @contrarymary77  16 років тому +1

    Thank you!!!

  • @InParticularNobody
    @InParticularNobody 13 років тому +1

    @MarkTAllenby ah yes. I'm rubbish at not reading the whole thread before I dive in.
    This galaxy is our galaxy. Amen.

  • @TJ413
    @TJ413 7 років тому +1

    This side was made for you and me.

  • @WannaBuff
    @WannaBuff 6 років тому +5

    One World One People / The Workers have no Nation / Citizen of The World !

  • @PHILRAWS
    @PHILRAWS 12 років тому +1

    ridiculous comments below....."these trolls are your trolls, these trolls are my trolls, and they NEVER say nothing, these trolls were made to piss off you and me"!!

  • @UNION_JACK_THE_RIPPER
    @UNION_JACK_THE_RIPPER 13 років тому +1

    @SpaceShipWarrior im a big fan of those lot they should all get together and do a song together

  • @narancauk
    @narancauk 2 роки тому +2

    What about instead ''from the sacred forests.....'' -----to be ..From the Stonehenge people to the St George's steeple-----------------Time dimension !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @maryamhalcrow4200
    @maryamhalcrow4200 9 років тому +4

    A bit different from when we sang it on St George's day by the dis-used airfield before the actions on St George's hill.... must be 20 years now..... YIP. YIP. YIP

  • @MarkTAllenby
    @MarkTAllenby 13 років тому

    @InParticularNobody Already dealt with and already lightened up. I refer the honourable member to my previous answer. ;-)

  • @bradjames1553
    @bradjames1553 9 років тому

    Is that David Amram playing the lute/recorder.

  • @TheGingersnaps11
    @TheGingersnaps11 6 років тому

    We'll win it back one day fellas

  • @TheLauraHowe
    @TheLauraHowe 13 років тому +1

    interestingly enough billy sought out out band to help him record this song..... Heathens all was our name 16 other musicians all went up to London to record....interestingly no credit to us .....Steve Poitier...Mandy freewoman, Carlo, Steve walker, Maya Preece, Jono O`leary, Tini Bridgman, Richard Whistance, Pock, Johny Aris, Laura Howe, Jim, Theo Simon and others forgive me......

    • @medes5597
      @medes5597 5 років тому

      They're all credited on the record.

  • @Transpooper
    @Transpooper 13 років тому +4

    why isnt this the british anthem?

    • @sh-hg4eg
      @sh-hg4eg 3 роки тому

      Because it's a pile of globalist shite.

  • @Transpooper
    @Transpooper 13 років тому

    @MrJackonRocks america?

  • @IndigoJo
    @IndigoJo 6 років тому +1

    I know where Holy Island is, but where are the "sacred forests"?

    • @SpringValleyCafe
      @SpringValleyCafe 6 років тому +1

      All over the World

    • @PeterBull1951
      @PeterBull1951 4 роки тому +2

      Possibly Druidic forests in Anglesey to Holy Island (Lindisfarne) - West to East, complementing Cornwall to Scotland - South to North?

  • @Nathpeggsy
    @Nathpeggsy 12 років тому +6

    who cares? all other countries have national anthems about place or its people, our national anthem is seriously outdated

  • @BrunaVidalgeekgirl
    @BrunaVidalgeekgirl 7 років тому

    Margo Roth Spilgman me trouxe aqui.

  • @InParticularNobody
    @InParticularNobody 13 років тому +1

    @MarkTAllenby oh lighten up mate. Otherwise as a born and bred Mercian, I cannot possibly accept a song that also includes the Kingdom of Wessex. C'mon. times change...

  • @Nathpeggsy
    @Nathpeggsy 12 років тому

    i meant like the whole population, rather than just one person who doesnt represent us accurately. its like the american national anthem just being about the president, its just not as good

  • @MrIain73
    @MrIain73 6 років тому

    Nope not do that version for the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 no way. I think some one will have to re write the uk 🇬🇧 version off this land is your land.

  • @rorybowskill
    @rorybowskill 13 років тому +1

    @TheRedflagflyer
    so why are people allowed to berWelsh nationalists, Scottkish Nationaliosts, Iriish nationalists, and Cornish nationalists.....but not English nationaliosts who want those countries to be free.....Is itr'cos England has welcomed Asians and Blacks? Oh dear look who is racist now

  • @3tangle3
    @3tangle3 13 років тому

    @TheRedflagflyer hes actually not that knowledgeable.............while most of us are 80-90% basque origin...saxon only 20% at best in NE england - norman a mere 2% I agree this island should LIKE the world be very cooperative...but there are cultural difference which the state tries to put down..........my welsh speaking family are like a different world to most southern eastern english

  • @3tangle3
    @3tangle3 13 років тому

    Lol yes its your land now the english state invaded everywhere

  • @Transpooper
    @Transpooper 13 років тому

    @MrJackonRocks yeah, so how does it prove america is great?

  • @Blueforlifefry
    @Blueforlifefry 9 років тому +7

    Kind of ironic that it has a Caribbean beat to it .... just saying

    • @williamwhitty7243
      @williamwhitty7243 7 років тому +10

      plenty of caribbeans were i gro up toxteth liverpool still british

    • @williamwhitty7243
      @williamwhitty7243 7 років тому +1

      just saying

    • @pierre-de-standing
      @pierre-de-standing 6 років тому +2

      It's just in 4/4 time, so you could sing it as a polka if you wanted.

  • @CareyGButler
    @CareyGButler 12 років тому

    (or see different cultures as a threat)

  • @MarchToFreedom
    @MarchToFreedom 12 років тому +4

    You thought Billy Bragg was a "nationalist"......

    • @colinmcdonald8521
      @colinmcdonald8521 7 років тому +4

      Quite possible to be both a nationalist and a socialist. Think of James Connolly - think of Fidel.

  • @MarkTAllenby
    @MarkTAllenby 13 років тому +3

    A good version, but I would prefer an English version. As an English man I realise that the Scottish Highlands are only mine by national conquest, not by rights. As a result I can't 'like' or share this version of the song.

    • @g1ngerrobot794
      @g1ngerrobot794 4 роки тому +4

      As it stands currently, the Highlands are not English or Scottish, but British.
      I'm Scottish but i was born in Bristol and I have an English parent and a Scottish parent. I see nothing wrong with this song and will not feel offended if you liked or shared it.

    • @gooders7366
      @gooders7366 4 роки тому

      I been studying Guthrie for the last few days, then I just stumbled upon this gem. Way I see it you gotta drill for the songwriter’s spirit of their meaning. Lots of folks going off on tangents of politics, Bragg surely knew this would happen and he so he walks a thin line with his lyrics.
      The lyrics strongly refence the original, but he rewrites it for his own style and for our modern ears (‘private property’ instead of ‘no trespassing’). He puts reference to ‘church bells’ in there, and in the last verse he uses the word ‘mystic’. This is a deliberate pointer for us all not to jump to an immediate political hearing of the song, but rather a mystical one. (There are as many and much more ‘church bells’ type mystics as the pagan flavour - think of the bishop of Lindisfarne, St Cuthbert, referenced right at the top of the song).
      Great, great song 🙏❤️

    • @solfennell8981
      @solfennell8981 2 роки тому

      'conquest'. Do you know how England and Scotland unified? Because it wasn't conquest.

    • @MarkTAllenby
      @MarkTAllenby 2 роки тому

      @@solfennell8981 And the Battle of Culloden was a friendly debate between equal partners? However, point taken, things are always more complex than any simple statement makes them sound.

    • @takakocaesar579
      @takakocaesar579 Рік тому

      Scottish hilands are ours because scotland joined england in a union

  • @iradan64
    @iradan64 14 років тому

    kinda killed a good irish mate?

  • @CareyGButler
    @CareyGButler 12 років тому

    We MUST keep our cultures. Don't let them be taken away from those who are blind to their value.

    • @leningradcowboy2953
      @leningradcowboy2953 6 років тому +10

      carey g. butler shoe this is not for nationalists go away we actually like other people and don’t discriminate based off of a social construct

    • @barrybenson4158
      @barrybenson4158 5 років тому +3

      bro you just posted cringe

    • @something1600
      @something1600 Рік тому

      Fascist reactionary.

  • @MrPielips
    @MrPielips 7 років тому

    not quite as good as Bruce Springsteen, sorry Billy