Formables that WILL NOT GET into RISE OF NATIONS ( and why )

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 104

  • @auditoriooo8078
    @auditoriooo8078 Місяць тому +40

    Some formables were removed every time for the same reasons, and we can apply them to suggested formables
    -fictional or near imposible
    -no direct descendent today
    -controversial
    -unnecesary / innacurate
    -not a formable (by this i mean the formable as nation didnt exist and it was based on a certain ethnic or claims)
    Those are plenty reasons why hyperant doesnt add need formables/releasables often, appart from being lazy

    • @PersonfromElSalvador
      @PersonfromElSalvador Місяць тому +8

      They should add back fictional formables like (USSA, Nile Empire, Saharan Kingdom) because that’s what made the game more fun for players playing countries that now have barely any formables

    • @auditoriooo8078
      @auditoriooo8078 Місяць тому +2

      @@PersonfromElSalvador oh yeah i agree, i want ruthenia back :(

    • @HermanosLuDi
      @HermanosLuDi Місяць тому

      @@PersonfromElSalvador We aren't adding that back.

    • @iGuessItsAzure
      @iGuessItsAzure Місяць тому +2

      so this applies to half the African formables that disappeared?

    • @auditoriooo8078
      @auditoriooo8078 Місяць тому +1

      @@iGuessItsAzure yea like empire of gabon for the first, upper volta for the fourth and koishan for the fifth reason

  • @alonxd3609
    @alonxd3609 Місяць тому +23

    I love how one of the reasons for not adding the Kingdom of France it’s because its a monarchy 😂

    • @touch540_
      @touch540_ 10 днів тому

      then probably have to delete Napoleonic Empire cuz Napoleonic Empire is also a monarchy

  • @cheeseGoblin101
    @cheeseGoblin101 Місяць тому +25

    they should add a formable that takes the entire world to form, and make it only formable with countries with 5 or less cities (Joke)

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому +6

      Glad its a joke
      Global formables are rejected, no reason specified

    • @Georgian_guy-1
      @Georgian_guy-1 28 днів тому +3

      we need a UN formable for Antarctica💀💀

    • @cheeseGoblin101
      @cheeseGoblin101 28 днів тому

      nah make some random formable need a random island like empire of japan needing like sardinia

  • @user-fi5vq8fo5e
    @user-fi5vq8fo5e Місяць тому +20

    A formable id like to see is the viceroyalty of new spain (mexican formable)

    • @carlosalbertopalaciosepulv3081
      @carlosalbertopalaciosepulv3081 Місяць тому +1

      won't be possible man cuz Mexico alr has a formable with the central america part which was also from the viceroyalty of spain and its quite difficult to make it so cuz spanish empire's formables doesn't use U.S part to form :/

    • @realawesomeos
      @realawesomeos Місяць тому +5

      In the words of the formable submission guidelines: "no country would conquer vast swathes of territory only to rename themselves to a colony"

    • @Helloer123
      @Helloer123 Місяць тому +1

      thats just patria grande but with more american land

    • @uru4123
      @uru4123 Місяць тому

      i want pepper coast and gold coast to be added back

    • @PluralOfSillyGoose
      @PluralOfSillyGoose Місяць тому

      @@carlosalbertopalaciosepulv3081new Spain would also include Florida, Cuba, Puerto Rico, Philippines, and (maybe) Louisiana

  • @HenceMan
    @HenceMan Місяць тому +6

    I’m just suspecting none of the devs want to put the effort to make said formables.

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      Hyperant is the only dev for rise of nations

    • @dr_frog01
      @dr_frog01 Місяць тому +2

      @@detektiv_mathz he's doing horrible decisions then.

    • @Georgian_guy-1
      @Georgian_guy-1 28 днів тому

      @@dr_frog01 yeah fr

  • @starleigh6680
    @starleigh6680 Місяць тому +3

    Making burgundy a releasable would be nice

  • @sawyak8850
    @sawyak8850 Місяць тому +2

    We need a celestial taiping kingdom formable

  • @dpterminusreal
    @dpterminusreal Місяць тому +2

    6:02
    the frankish empire, a monarchy: 🗿

    • @maxthetube8466
      @maxthetube8466 Місяць тому

      Fr in general, Russia would ( controversially) not want to form the Soviet Union or German the German empire, so that argumentation doesn’t work at all

  • @jakewilliamson2584
    @jakewilliamson2584 Місяць тому +4

    Then why does African and European, North American, and oceaninic exist and USA gets cut

    • @jakewilliamson2584
      @jakewilliamson2584 Місяць тому

      I meant ussa*

    • @NP-CB
      @NP-CB Місяць тому

      They removed the oceanic formable

    • @lagomite_is_stupid
      @lagomite_is_stupid Місяць тому

      @@jakewilliamson2584what is USSA

    • @GrilledCheesed
      @GrilledCheesed Місяць тому

      Pan Africanism and Pan Europeanism exist, and that's the base for those 2
      North America is technically real but with very low informations on the proposal
      Oceania and USSA died because not real

    • @PluralOfSillyGoose
      @PluralOfSillyGoose Місяць тому

      @@jakewilliamson2584you can edit comments

  • @r.ndomperson
    @r.ndomperson Місяць тому

    with the Caliphate of Cordoba, couldnt you just make Rif form it?

  • @user-oq1dr3te8v
    @user-oq1dr3te8v Місяць тому +1

    You know that the capital of Prussia was Danzig (or Gdansk)

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      Capital : Konigsberg and then Berlin

    • @dr_frog01
      @dr_frog01 28 днів тому

      Saying that hurted my baIIs
      that's psychological torture to any historians

  • @akaKuiper
    @akaKuiper Місяць тому

    United Arab Republic would be so cool as a formable imo

  • @dr_frog01
    @dr_frog01 28 днів тому

    In case of prussia, brandenburg could be an releasable ( from germany ) and since the duchy of prussia united with brandenburg leading to the kingdom of prussia in 1700s, it would make sence having an prussian formable by brandenburg
    But the only problem is that, lets take Bavaria and saxony for example, they have their own cultural values, but brandenburg is just an avarage region habitated by north-germans so so making it an releasable would be equal to releasing a second germany so brandenburg wouldnt be added and so prussia 😭😭😭
    And about the ancient prussian ( tribes ), they were extinct a long ago, and they werent even germans at all, they were baltic so again and since prussia is a german state ( came from the teutonics wich they were germanisators and they eradicated the prussian tribes there ), so again an prussian formable is ZERO 😭😭😭

    • @sejt23
      @sejt23 8 днів тому

      could kaliningrad form prussia? sounds stupid but what else have we got

  • @TatarWarrior
    @TatarWarrior Місяць тому +1

    i think kaliningrad should be able to form prussia

    • @SethACook
      @SethACook Місяць тому +1

      NO
      “In Honolulu,”
      “In the land of the Azores,”
      “and on Samoa,”
      “That Is Tradition.”
      I don’t need to say anything…

    • @Drew-lo8fu
      @Drew-lo8fu Місяць тому

      @@SethACookur not saying much of anything legible anyway

  • @lxrex.031
    @lxrex.031 23 дні тому

    if he aint french than idk

  • @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me
    @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me Місяць тому

    Where is the French Mapper thingy after your channel name? Like [FFM] or something

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      removed it to lower the influence of mapping on my channel, but it still is in my channel description

  • @kingam_thebest
    @kingam_thebest Місяць тому +1

    hey detektiv can u make a vid as egypt and form khedivate and africa? pls

    • @GrilledCheesed
      @GrilledCheesed Місяць тому

      he already did

    • @kingam_thebest
      @kingam_thebest Місяць тому

      @@GrilledCheesed oh really? sorry I didn't see that video but thanks for telling me

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      Grilled is correct, I did it already

    • @kingam_thebest
      @kingam_thebest Місяць тому

      @@detektiv_mathz ok thank you detektiv

  • @FraudulentBushwacker
    @FraudulentBushwacker Місяць тому +1

    why does finnic union exist then

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому +2

      proposed by estonia, its historical

    • @FraudulentBushwacker
      @FraudulentBushwacker Місяць тому +1

      @@detektiv_mathzyes but did it happen

    • @SethACook
      @SethACook Місяць тому +1

      @@FraudulentBushwackerno but yes !

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      @@FraudulentBushwacker it did not happen, but it was proposed to happen, which is why it exists

    • @FraudulentBushwacker
      @FraudulentBushwacker Місяць тому

      @@detektiv_mathz thanks

  • @lucasjohnsen1943
    @lucasjohnsen1943 Місяць тому +4

    Apparently the rise of nations dont want a good game and dont ant to give people what they want like a formable like german central Afrika would be awesome but they have to be difficult

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      They want a realistic game

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому +3

      Plus why would some countries want to recreate a german colonial project

    • @annishoxhaj4700
      @annishoxhaj4700 Місяць тому

      @@detektiv_mathzbecause it all depends on their leader, I mean there are plenty of leaders today that want to reform old countries that wouldn’t make sense for their current government.

    • @KazualBopthKatze
      @KazualBopthKatze Місяць тому +1

      @@detektiv_mathz why form the French Colonial Empire?
      Rise of Nations is just a side project based off of Hearts of Iron. Realism got thrown out the window when they allow some nations but relegate others to releasables.

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      You are mixing a Colonial Empire with a Colonial Project tho

  • @ikine
    @ikine 17 днів тому

    tu as oublié une partie de l'inde dans le royaume de France

  • @etruh
    @etruh Місяць тому

    nice

  • @N3O_4
    @N3O_4 Місяць тому +2

    How do you make the map empty like that

    • @WarLegend50
      @WarLegend50 Місяць тому +3

      He made a custom country with a black city and tile color in his private server using the console.

    • @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me
      @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me Місяць тому +1

      by using $$$ to buy a private server.

  • @Calebe575
    @Calebe575 Місяць тому

    1 more reason to don't play the rise of spams

  • @The_from_the_internet
    @The_from_the_internet Місяць тому

    3rd reich formable whit puppets included

  • @Viking-eu7ev
    @Viking-eu7ev Місяць тому

    Vichy France whit auxitania

    • @detektiv_mathz
      @detektiv_mathz  Місяць тому

      No, why the hell would vichy france even be a country

    • @Imsorrywat
      @Imsorrywat Місяць тому

      We have Occtainia that’s close enough for me

  • @partner-lt9pr
    @partner-lt9pr Місяць тому +1

    Hear me out nato and Warsaw pact formable

    • @dpterminusreal
      @dpterminusreal Місяць тому +1

      military alliances, no goal of unification

    • @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me
      @you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me Місяць тому

      But they should really enable every country to create a faction named Warsaw Pact, and also an option to create North Atlantic Treaty Organization instead of just cringe Atlantic Treaty(which prompts Brazil to join in many cases😂)

    • @dpterminusreal
      @dpterminusreal Місяць тому +1

      @@you_dare_to_gaze_upon_me we should have a bit more freedom with naming factions but unfortunately you know how people are

    • @qfk3
      @qfk3 Місяць тому

      @@dpterminusreal you can make gay community so

    • @NP-CB
      @NP-CB Місяць тому

      Warsaw Pact was a formable but got removed.