True, he was just going to let her die, thinking she was being treated. Isn't she a fighter pilot? That meant she needed to be treated. Galactica needs every fighter pilot or tech crewman they have.
@@drmayeda1930 Actually, I'm pretty sure he did give her the vaccine, because she was "One of the good ones" due to her being in the service unlike most Sagitarons (I butchered that poor colonys name)
As much as I love this scene, and I love Helo, the best part... Around the 3 minute mark, how many guys it takes to hold Helo back!! it's 4/5! :-) I know he's a big guy but that was just amusing.
Best show ever! Battlestar Galactica! By far my favorite TV show ever created. There is so much to learn from this from racism to sexism to spirituality, our freedom to choose, how to deal with our mistakes, our current anxieties and fears about technology and how it is shaping and changing our lives. This show speaks to just about every major issue confronting humanity and shows us how to have the dignity and strength and machurity to do the right thing to ensure growth and victory over our weaknesses and fears for all of us to emerge in the end as a united and whole organism victorious yay!
🍁Sometimes Helo's Boy Scout mentality got on my nerves, and sometimes I really appreciated his moral compass. This doctor was definitely a racist and a bigot.
Agreed. It was similar to Lee's boy scout ego in the first and second seasons of the show. Both have their hearts in the right place but Lee had perspective and Helo was doing the right thing simply because it was the right thing to do.
And a threat. Ethnic cleansing when the population of an entire species is already dangerously low? He's lucky they didn't just shoot him then and there.
@@MiguelLopez-is9te That's what blind hate/ignorance does to some folks. It throws reason out the window. Just out of curiosity, does anyone know what happened to that racist doctor after he got arrested?
I will never understand why he said who needs medicine more someone who won't raise a finger or a viper pilot But d is a bridge officer and probably one of the youngest people in the fleet with a commission she would have been the future of the fleet
The title is misleading. He knew who she was and that in his mind, she matters. He says it at the end. He didn't harm Dee. The civie Sagitarons are the ones who don't matter to him.
@@keitht24more so because they were not pulling their own weight during a time of war with limited resources and were actually a drain on those resources. If they weren’t going to contribute they should have just found them a habitable planet give them some resources to survive and just leave them there so they could live their Luddite lives. The cylons wouldn’t bother with them they were no threat.
After the way this pandemic has been handled, ESPECIALLY WITH THE SUPREME COURT RULING OF ALL THINGS!!! I now understand and ENTIRELY support Dr. Robert and his stance on why they shouldn't waste resources on people who refuse to believe in science. He is absolutely right and people should apologize for assuming he was wrong, ESPECIALLY in a triage type crisis.
Because they’re human beings who don’t deserve to die, no matter how stupid they are. Doctors don’t get to decide who lives or dies. Every patient should get the doctor’s best effort to save them.
He is absolutely wrong. Triage is a clinical evaluation of who CAN or CANNOT be saved due to the severity of someone’s condition. It is NOT a selection of who WILL or WILL NOT be cared for. On top of that, Dr. Robert did not just deny those people medical care, he deliberately poisoned them.
Agathon tossed that marine like a pillow 😂
I’ve always liked Agathon. He’s always been very supportive of his friends and commanding officers and he has a clean Conscience
Another great episode, the ending when Helo was proven right is great, the performances by all of the actors is 👍
Right I loved it when Saul was like "Shut the Frak up!" and then let Helo take the doc into custody.
Gotta love that subtle tap oh the shoulder when the sargent or a marine lets go Helo
Actually, that title is a bit misleading. He didn't attempt to kill Dualla. Helo just thought he did.
He wasn't wrong either, too bad he was a racist murderer.
True, he was just going to let her die, thinking she was being treated. Isn't she a fighter pilot? That meant she needed to be treated. Galactica needs every fighter pilot or tech crewman they have.
@@drmayeda1930 she isn't a fighter pilot she works in CIC.
@@drmayeda1930 Actually, I'm pretty sure he did give her the vaccine, because she was "One of the good ones" due to her being in the service unlike most Sagitarons (I butchered that poor colonys name)
Bitamusin*
RIP Donnelly Rhodes. Great scene.
As much as I love this scene, and I love Helo, the best part...
Around the 3 minute mark, how many guys it takes to hold Helo back!! it's 4/5! :-)
I know he's a big guy but that was just amusing.
Holding back someone that angry is a lot harder than you’d expect, two guys probably could’ve managed it, but when you got 5 ya use 5 lmao
Best show ever! Battlestar Galactica! By far my favorite TV show ever created. There is so much to learn from this from racism to sexism to spirituality, our freedom to choose, how to deal with our mistakes, our current anxieties and fears about technology and how it is shaping and changing our lives. This show speaks to just about every major issue confronting humanity and shows us how to have the dignity and strength and machurity to do the right thing to ensure growth and victory over our weaknesses and fears for all of us to emerge in the end as a united and whole organism victorious yay!
Tried to kill Dualla? Throw him out the airlock.
Helo always being good like a halo.
Could we get the “THIS PLANT’S OFFLINE! WE’RE ON STRIKE!” Scene?
I’m surprised this didn’t happen more often especially in the fourth season.
Helo is my fav 🥰
Goddamn I love this episode
“I want to sleep” can be equated to Spiritual Sleep
🍁Sometimes Helo's Boy Scout mentality got on my nerves, and sometimes I really appreciated his moral compass. This doctor was definitely a racist and a bigot.
Agreed. It was similar to Lee's boy scout ego in the first and second seasons of the show. Both have their hearts in the right place but Lee had perspective and Helo was doing the right thing simply because it was the right thing to do.
And a threat. Ethnic cleansing when the population of an entire species is already dangerously low? He's lucky they didn't just shoot him then and there.
@@BladeZero238 Oh, I know, right. To have that much hate... scary.
@@MiguelLopez-is9te That's what blind hate/ignorance does to some folks. It throws reason out the window.
Just out of curiosity, does anyone know what happened to that racist doctor after he got arrested?
@@dwnkaomwn3953 He was never mentioned again. I have the series on DVD and rewatched several times. His name was never mentioned.
Great Episode
I will never understand why he said who needs medicine more someone who won't raise a finger or a viper pilot
But d is a bridge officer and probably one of the youngest people in the fleet with a commission she would have been the future of the fleet
The title is misleading. He knew who she was and that in his mind, she matters. He says it at the end. He didn't harm Dee. The civie Sagitarons are the ones who don't matter to him.
This is an alternate version, no? I don't remember a lot of this.
Not an alternate. The actual episode.
I can’t stand Sagitterons either, but what’s wrong is wrong!
And the irony is Dualla then kills herself 🤦🏼♂️
I hated that. Absolutely hated it.
Totally unlike her. Another forced story line by the rushed script at the end.
This might not sound too good but after this past 1.5-2 years I've come to understand Dr. Robert a lot more which is a scary thought.
You're insane. He was literally murdering people because they were Sagittarian citizens.
@@keitht24more so because they were not pulling their own weight during a time of war with limited resources and were actually a drain on those resources. If they weren’t going to contribute they should have just found them a habitable planet give them some resources to survive and just leave them there so they could live their Luddite lives. The cylons wouldn’t bother with them they were no threat.
is his last name Fowci
After the way this pandemic has been handled, ESPECIALLY WITH THE SUPREME COURT RULING OF ALL THINGS!!! I now understand and ENTIRELY support Dr. Robert and his stance on why they shouldn't waste resources on people who refuse to believe in science. He is absolutely right and people should apologize for assuming he was wrong, ESPECIALLY in a triage type crisis.
I have to admit a lot what Dr. Robert said was true.
Because they’re human beings who don’t deserve to die, no matter how stupid they are. Doctors don’t get to decide who lives or dies. Every patient should get the doctor’s best effort to save them.
He is absolutely wrong. Triage is a clinical evaluation of who CAN or CANNOT be saved due to the severity of someone’s condition. It is NOT a selection of who WILL or WILL NOT be cared for. On top of that, Dr. Robert did not just deny those people medical care, he deliberately poisoned them.
I agree with him but a doctor does not have that option in his position. He is required by oath to treat anyone regardless of his feelings about them.