Meltzer 5 star matches tier list would be interesting to see. How well certain matches have aged and seeing the older matches from a modern perspective
You know Dave's ratings were often him going off of the clipped versions of matches that made their TV slot, right? There are cases (Misawa vs Kobashi 1/20/1997 comes to mind, which got 4.75) where I think matches that might have reached that rating weren't able to. So there's an extent to where I consider the distinction between 4.5 and 5 a bit arbitrary in some cases when it comes to that era.
@@KinchStalker I have seen a lot of AJPW footage and sure there is a lot of clipped stuff in there, but the big Triple Crown title matches are usually shown in full lenght. So while Dave arguably made some questionable ratings, his 5-stars for Triple Crown matches usually were given for good reason.
Its cus of the time, NJPW was not at the best state, also because of him loosing in the MMA fights he lost a bit of credibility and the faith of inoki, I do think he is one of the best champions but cus of inokism is but set him back from being top tire, he deffo is close and maybe should be there too
Pretty good list. I was worried going into the video since you guys don't talk about NJPW often, so I wasn't sure how informed the rankings would be. Couple of nitpicks here and there (Omega down 1, Makabe up 1, etc.), but overall really good rankings.
I was cautiously all ears until the Nagata section. It's marked highly enough but I was following very closely at the time of his major long reign; it was a brilliant array of matches and they talk almost the entire segment about the Cro Cop saga, when this could have been about the title reigns. Easily could have gone into some depth about the awesome Chono 60 minute defence, or truly intense bouts with Takayama and Sasaki. It feels thus (whilst still watchable) a little washy in covering title reigns, with token anecdotes of moments in their general careers rather than thorough reviews of the reigns. That's backed up by the fact it's mentioned that 'in the 90s' was a time when Japanese companies worked freely with one-another, unlike in the West; but AJPW and NJPW were complete enemies until October 2000 with the first event featuring any crossover after the NOAH split.
The problem is they don't do any research before these videos. I would say that would take hours upon hours so I know why they don't do it with other things to do. However I do agree and think with more research they would of seen that Nakamura and Inoki should of gone up (my only gripes about the list). Nakamura especially for being the "saviour" of NJPW for saving the belt and Inoki for having not just handed the championship to himself but going out of his way to legitimise his reign with a tournament win over one of the great Japanese wrestlers of the time Masa Saito (said to of allegedly invented the sharpshooter/scorpion deathlock) and the good matches he put on until the vacating of the belt.
I kinda want Taichi to eventually get this chance at hte top. He's always been the jobber to the stars, always involved in high profile feuds but never winning the big one.
Please more NJPW lists. The whole roster list would be incredible (maybe with an * by a couple people in light of current circumstances, Ospreay & Chase Owens spring to mind)
I know this is way too early to say, given that this reign started yesterday (as of 13/07/2020) - but, given time, were do you hope that the new 30th champion, EVIL, will rank in time after his first reign ends? Just what you hope despite it only just beginning.
Sam is 100% right. Ishii is the most underated wrestlers from this day. It's a shame that he never get his hands on the big title. He is one of the best worker in the world atm.
We need a tier list of every single Gary UA-cam. Personally I think it's down to Gary UA-cam and Gary UA-cam for who is the best Gary UA-cam, however, Gary UA-cam is also a contender for that title too.
Omegas match quality with the belt = high. Omega's reign in terms of opposition, story and the disgraceful way he left = poor. I'd have had him in bearable
"disgraceful way he left" its a business kid and his contract was up if they wanted him to stay they should start singing there talent to more then one year deals.
Yes, Fujinami beat Flair for the NWA belt at Starrcade in '91, in the Tokyo Dome, then dropped it back to him at the first Super Brawl, 2 months later in Florida.
How can you grade an IWGP title reign based on how seriously WCW treated it? I doubt their WCW runs are at all exemplary of anybody's actual abilities; certainly it is inconsequential based on their Japanese title legacy. (Thinking specifically about people like Chono and Norton.)
In Chono's case, his one run was really, really short. With Norton, he spent most of his time as champion in the States, while he was on the nWo's B-Team.
I'm a huge fan of Lucha Libre, any chance we could have a AAA mega champions tier list? Or CMLL? Also could we get some Lucha Underground lists, videos or tier lists please? I watch all this channels videos and you guys are amazing, easily my favourite channel on UA-cam. Best wishes to ALL of you for all your hard work, but big hugs to my favourite guy on here, Mr Ross Twedell, I've noticed he's been quiet again recently and hope he's OK. Regards KevtheRed
I still remember the very first New-Japan match I ever watched, the match responsible for introducing me to what has since become my favorite wrestling promotion in the world, was Tomohiro Ishii versus Katsuyori Shibata. That neither of those men ever won the big belt is, for lack of a better word, silly.
Brock wasn't paid what he was contracted and they never paid that back until he agreed to drop it to Kurt Angle a year later in the IGF, they could have easily gotten their title back if they didn't try and swipe it and not pay him what he was legally entitled to, say what you want about his heart not being in it, Brock did the right thing taking the belt hostage, and in the end it put Shinsuke over like crazy when he beat Angle.
Think it's a missed opportunity to not have a good tear in between lovely lovely lovely and alright I feel like Omega Naito Nakamura shouldn't be anywhere near the word alright
Them: "How much do you like Cultaholic's Tier Ranking videos?"
Me: "I've only seen 1 NJPW match and I'm watching this video."
That’s not a huge flex u rly need to watch njpw
@@carternelson7462 I think the point is how much he loves their content
That's probably one more than these two have watched.
@@carternelson7462 No I don't. I really need to breathe air and eat food. Everything else is optional.
Suzuki not being IWGP Champion is a bigger crime than Ishii
Nearly broke kayfabe at the start there Garry UA-cam
Nearly? Gary UA-cam dropped the ball there
Cornelius Driscoll lost interest in the video as soon as the ball was dropped, Gary & Gary (Ross & Tom)‘s commitments to Gary UA-cam is fantastic
The more I learn about Inoki, the more he becomes a Japanese Vince McMahon
oh man you're going down on the rabbit hole if you learn more about him
wanderlustwarrior why would you want to watch a young Vince die horribly?
Vince McMahon is an American Antonio Inoki.
You are really on point there with your comparison.
Matt lol exactly.
Meltzer 5 star matches tier list would be interesting to see. How well certain matches have aged and seeing the older matches from a modern perspective
GARY UA-cam HAS BEEN REPLACED BY GARY UA-cam?! IMPOSSIBLE
At least they're still Gary Youtubing
Today the role of Gary UA-cam will be played by Gary UA-cam.
They should be careful though, Gary UA-cam is lurking in the shadows waiting to steal his position
It's just like fake Diesel and/or fake Razor! D:
do tier list of all 5 star matches or AJPW triple crown title
5 star matches would be hard. How would they rank em? Match quality? They're 5 star for a reason.
@@Masterhighlight i would say match quality crowd reaction and the stakes involved like a title
5 star would be awesome!
You know Dave's ratings were often him going off of the clipped versions of matches that made their TV slot, right? There are cases (Misawa vs Kobashi 1/20/1997 comes to mind, which got 4.75) where I think matches that might have reached that rating weren't able to. So there's an extent to where I consider the distinction between 4.5 and 5 a bit arbitrary in some cases when it comes to that era.
@@KinchStalker I have seen a lot of AJPW footage and sure there is a lot of clipped stuff in there, but the big Triple Crown title matches are usually shown in full lenght. So while Dave arguably made some questionable ratings, his 5-stars for Triple Crown matches usually were given for good reason.
"Fujita can't do Epic matches"
Noah in 2020 would like to have a word with you.
Fujita vs shiozaki match of the decade
My personal highlight of that match was the thirty minute stare down
Ghc champion lol
Name a bigger feud then Jack vs Tanahashi's air guitar
Ibushi vs his own neck
Naito VS Osaka's crowd
Really like how you now added the names of who your talking about on the bottom. Keep up the good work lads!
Can you do a tier list of every Dave Meltzer 5* or more match
That's actually a really great, niche idea, would love to see that!!
"Get in the bin you 5 star match!"
kevinno then split it by century
Hal Jordan the tier system would have to change
YES!!! Book it!!!
Crazy to think that Ibushi is almost 40. Also, As much as I think it won't happen, I hope to see Goto to win the big one at least once.
Jack seemed like he wanted to fly through this 😂
Nagata: Holds the belt for the 3rd most defenses
Cultaholic: It’s only very very good
It’s not that deep
Nagata is probably their most underrated champion
Libe Jenkins agreed, he’s one of the GOATS of NJPW
Its cus of the time, NJPW was not at the best state, also because of him loosing in the MMA fights he lost a bit of credibility and the faith of inoki, I do think he is one of the best champions but cus of inokism is but set him back from being top tire, he deffo is close and maybe should be there too
Pretty good list. I was worried going into the video since you guys don't talk about NJPW often, so I wasn't sure how informed the rankings would be. Couple of nitpicks here and there (Omega down 1, Makabe up 1, etc.), but overall really good rankings.
Goto for IWGP Heavyweight champion
Could you do tier list of ROH or Impact world champions?
There would be more best tier Roh champs than tna champs
Ethan Da Omegaman X I hope you’re joking about Matt Taven being in the best
Would love to see both of those, along with AAA and CMLL
fuck, I was listening to this with my headphones on and when that intro for Inokism came on I got so unreasonably scared😂😂😂.
I’ve never even really watched new japan I’m still going to watch this lol
It's more than worth trying. Wrestle Kingdom 14 is free to watch right now on NJPW World (their version of the WWE Network)
Nick94956 I’ll give it a shot Im just too lazy invest more energy in learning about a whole new company and their wrestlers,Lore,etc lol
Don’t know too much about NJPW history but from what it sounded like, Fujinami and Choshu are the Japan equivalent to Bret and Shawn?
Inoki, Fujinami, Choshu = Hogan, Bret, Shawn
Tanahashi, Nakamura = Cena, Orton
Muto, Chono, Hashimoto = Rollins, Ambrose, Reigns
I freaking love Tanahashi, I wish I hadn't started watching New Japan so late.. I hope he never retires!
loved it! more japanese wrestling in the channel please
NJPW and ROH>any other wrestling promotions in 2021
36:21, They played that video when I went to G1 Special MSG, there were lots of boos for Lesnar.
Where’s the every IWGP champion ranked video?!?!
I was cautiously all ears until the Nagata section. It's marked highly enough but I was following very closely at the time of his major long reign; it was a brilliant array of matches and they talk almost the entire segment about the Cro Cop saga, when this could have been about the title reigns. Easily could have gone into some depth about the awesome Chono 60 minute defence, or truly intense bouts with Takayama and Sasaki. It feels thus (whilst still watchable) a little washy in covering title reigns, with token anecdotes of moments in their general careers rather than thorough reviews of the reigns.
That's backed up by the fact it's mentioned that 'in the 90s' was a time when Japanese companies worked freely with one-another, unlike in the West; but AJPW and NJPW were complete enemies until October 2000 with the first event featuring any crossover after the NOAH split.
The problem is they don't do any research before these videos. I would say that would take hours upon hours so I know why they don't do it with other things to do.
However I do agree and think with more research they would of seen that Nakamura and Inoki should of gone up (my only gripes about the list).
Nakamura especially for being the "saviour" of NJPW for saving the belt and Inoki for having not just handed the championship to himself but going out of his way to legitimise his reign with a tournament win over one of the great Japanese wrestlers of the time Masa Saito (said to of allegedly invented the sharpshooter/scorpion deathlock) and the good matches he put on until the vacating of the belt.
Jack and Sam are quality content love them together
Do an ECW Roster or ECW Champions tier list please! Appreciate the content Gary UA-cam!
Saw this and instantly wanted the list injected directly into my veins
I kinda want Taichi to eventually get this chance at hte top. He's always been the jobber to the stars, always involved in high profile feuds but never winning the big one.
I still hope that he'll be the one to replace Suzuki as the stable leader one day. Taichi-Gun, ichiban!
Maybe a tier list for the Jr heavyweight title? Great work guys!
Please more NJPW lists. The whole roster list would be incredible (maybe with an * by a couple people in light of current circumstances, Ospreay & Chase Owens spring to mind)
I'm sitting here watching on a big screen TV and I've been staring just at Jack and Sam's faces the whole time.
This looks like one of the most hardest tier lists Cultaholic had to compile together.
Tier list of intercontinental champions please!
I know this is way too early to say, given that this reign started yesterday (as of 13/07/2020) - but, given time, were do you hope that the new 30th champion, EVIL, will rank in time after his first reign ends? Just what you hope despite it only just beginning.
Sam is 100% right. Ishii is the most underated wrestlers from this day. It's a shame that he never get his hands on the big title. He is one of the best worker in the world atm.
Too bad they made after EVIL. Would’ve had a nice round number!
I’m so happy about Evil ♥️
Thank god somebody mentioned NJPW.
Unfortunately this company's gotten slept on because it's in the far east and western companies's taken over.
As much as I love AEW, I hate that it has caused people to forget about New Japan. Wrestle Kingdom 14 was better than anything AEW has run IMO
Also, the ongoing global bastard has made a lot of damage by not having any matches in four months.
I love AEW, but yeah, right now NJPW is the best company.
I'm not even an aew fan, so all the attention being drawn away from new Japan is really annoying to me
Do a tier list of the greatest matches of all time
If they're the greatest of all time, surely they'd all be in the best
@@iamdavejohnson The best matches rated by users of Cagematch??
Question, why isn’t the alright tier the Alreet tier?
We need a tier list of every single Gary UA-cam. Personally I think it's down to Gary UA-cam and Gary UA-cam for who is the best Gary UA-cam, however, Gary UA-cam is also a contender for that title too.
How about doing TV champions from NWA/WCW tier list?
I would have done a separate tier in this list called Inoki
Inoki Tier cannot be constrained by the feeble 2 dimensions that make up this tier list.
Omegas match quality with the belt = high. Omega's reign in terms of opposition, story and the disgraceful way he left = poor.
I'd have had him in bearable
"disgraceful way he left" its a business kid and his contract was up if they wanted him to stay they should start singing there talent to more then one year deals.
Do a tier list of impact world champions (both world title belts)
Smooth first 20 seconds there😂
Great list!
Takada beat Mutoh for the belt at January 4th Tokyo Dome show and loss the title to Hashimoto at the next Tokyo Dome show.
It might take like 2 hours, but every WWE champion tier list?
Yes, Fujinami beat Flair for the NWA belt at Starrcade in '91, in the Tokyo Dome, then dropped it back to him at the first Super Brawl, 2 months later in Florida.
Lads, we all want the 5 star wrestling roster tier ranking
Been waiting for something like this, nice job fellas.
This aged well with evil winning the belt recently 😂
How can you grade an IWGP title reign based on how seriously WCW treated it? I doubt their WCW runs are at all exemplary of anybody's actual abilities; certainly it is inconsequential based on their Japanese title legacy. (Thinking specifically about people like Chono and Norton.)
Norton is clearly the greatest IWGP champion of all time
In Chono's case, his one run was really, really short. With Norton, he spent most of his time as champion in the States, while he was on the nWo's B-Team.
Every Meltzer 5 star list would be fun, lads
Between Antonio Inoki and Vince McMahon I’m starting to think you have to be at least a little insane to run a wrestling promotion
Can you guys do this with WWF and WCW World titles !?
Bread club 4 lyfe, Kojima 4 best, baby.
Ross is obviously the GOAT Gary UA-cam but Jack and Sam are low-key hilarious in these
GOD: OKADA
KING: TANAHASHI
ELITE: KENNY
BEST: NAITO
GREAT: STYLES
Will ospreay and kota ibushi are the goats ,and great muta and jushin are diamond
I'm a huge fan of Lucha Libre, any chance we could have a AAA mega champions tier list? Or CMLL? Also could we get some Lucha Underground lists, videos or tier lists please?
I watch all this channels videos and you guys are amazing, easily my favourite channel on UA-cam. Best wishes to ALL of you for all your hard work, but big hugs to my favourite guy on here, Mr Ross Twedell, I've noticed he's been quiet again recently and hope he's OK. Regards KevtheRed
If we are talking about people who need the belt before they retire hirooki goto is the top of my list.
what happened to the original njpw iwgp champions ranked video
I still remember the very first New-Japan match I ever watched, the match responsible for introducing me to what has since become my favorite wrestling promotion in the world, was Tomohiro Ishii versus Katsuyori Shibata. That neither of those men ever won the big belt is, for lack of a better word, silly.
Think shibata Definitely would have if not for the injury
I would love a Sam Jack Tier List of the NJPW roster
Jack ALWAYS wears a hat...getting some Ask Ketchum vibes.
If you had done this list now, would there have been any changes and where would you put Evil and Ibushi?
I hope Inoki shows up at Jack's door.
Not to beat him up...lol.....just needs a cup of sugar?
Inoki did fuck shit up . But he at least still got to be in the lovely catagory
would love to see yous revisit this list
Am I crazy, or did their used to be a ranking of worst to best from Pacitti of IWJP Heavyweight champions??
Where's the original Gary?
Gary UA-cam is having a few days off, so Gary UA-cam and Gary UA-cam are filling in for him. Hope that clears it up.
@@reno_2200 Hope Gary UA-cam enjoys his break. Gary UA-cam and Gary UA-cam covered well for Gary UA-cam.
what happened to your worst to best list for IWGP champions?
yeah, recognition for vader, let's go.
Depends what you like, I enjoy some more realistic grapple based bouts. Should not be so biased CW.
NJPW IC Champs tier list?
thanks for the education.
BOB SAPP BOB SAPP BOB SAPP BOB SAPP
Kinda burnt out on these tier lists with Sam. More Adam and jack with ross
They should have used the picture of Lesnar eating all the hamburger with the belt on his shoulder.
Brock wasn't paid what he was contracted and they never paid that back until he agreed to drop it to Kurt Angle a year later in the IGF, they could have easily gotten their title back if they didn't try and swipe it and not pay him what he was legally entitled to, say what you want about his heart not being in it, Brock did the right thing taking the belt hostage, and in the end it put Shinsuke over like crazy when he beat Angle.
It is really weird for Inoki to not top, even though I get your reasons.
oooohhhhhhhhhh I've been waitin on this one
Chono's theme is top tier, though
I enjoy learning the crossover history between mma and pro wrestling also enjoy mirko cro cop kicking the shit outta a young alberto
Where’s the every video of this?
I appreciate the notes on Inoki but reading those and listening to Jack also talk about Inoki is not possible :b
Omega and Naito are greatest champions Right?
Nagata dreads NYE now
I've also laughed so many times because of Inoki-Ism
This is just wrong, fujita didn't have epics? The Cultaholic guys have reddit brain
What about evil where would he rank
W list, but I think Naito could be moved up
While they're the right duo for this, it doesn't feel right not having Garry UA-cam host this
So why were 2 of the only guys I've seen work left off the list?
Next one should be IWGP Intercontinental Champions
Think it's a missed opportunity to not have a good tear in between lovely lovely lovely and alright I feel like Omega Naito Nakamura shouldn't be anywhere near the word alright
... You're not Gary UA-cam. Thought you could fool me?
Just in case the previous video ranking from worst to best was too specific for you...