The REAL REASON Why We Don't Have a Khilafa
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2024
- Dr Shadee Elmasry explains the need for Khilafa and the barriers to it. Highlighting the significance of love and obedience in bringing about real change in society, and why having a heart devoted to Allah is crucial for success.
Read the full paper: ummatics.org/papers/maliki_au...
Explore more at www.safinasociety.org
Learn Islam online at Arkview: www.arkview.org
Subscribe and hit the 🔔 icon to receive the latest news & updates from Safina!
Hoist the sails & join the tales by following us on social media!
Instagram: / safinasociety
Facebook: / safinasociety
TikTok: / safina_society
Twitter: x.com/safinasociety
Telegram: t.me/mysafinasociety - Розваги
Watch full episode: ua-cam.com/video/_mU_p0nZ8iQ/v-deo.html
Read full paper: ummatics.org/papers/maliki_authorities_on_the_imamate
I've been saying this for years that we muslims need khilafah. I hope we get united soon
Ameen
Think global, act local
Nope. We need democracy!
On what???? Unite with what???
We will never unite without Dastur al-Madina
Assalamualaikum,
I'm from Indonesia, I'm recently beginning to contemplate about the Golden Age of Islam, and I kind of longing for us stand at the top again. With piety and unity.
It is so amazing that the Colonial powers like Britain and French had a better understanding of Islamic Khilafa then Muslims did. They used this knowledge to defeat Islamic Power.
We just had too many munafiqs within our ranks. We let our guard down and now we've lost everything within 100 years. What a shameful time we live in.
But the Ottoman empire at times had sold the Ummah out. Khilafah isn't a utopian reality. @@umeriqbal8269
Yeah it’s not difficult, if you follow the Islamic principles even as a non Muslim you still reap the benefits in this world.
💯 mashallah very good point
@@umeriqbal8269yes I agree, but what is our role now?.
Loving Allah swt has its fruits. Judge it by the sacrifices in the face of oppression.
Awesome reminder. جزاكم الله خيرا و رحم الله العلامة الشهيد محمد سعيد رمضان البوطي و أسكنه فسيح جناته ❤
May Allah reward you and your team abundantly Dr Shadee for your dedication and spreading of such vital knowledge. I am a student in South Africa that has recently finished Fiqh al Seerah and it was truly heartening to see you spreading this concept of love for Allah and His Messenger as the foundation of success. It’s amazing how such simple yet profound these principles are and I recommend anyone who wants to get a better understanding of this concept to read Fiqh al-Seerah by Shaykh Ramadan al-Bouti.
Ameen..
Brilliant and heartfelt, this is the way the ummah will be successful in this world and on judgement day
Bring back the khilafa 💪🏻🤲🤲🤲
Working to establish the Khilafah is a fard kifaya
💯💯💯
Honestly I think it's been years since I've watched such an interesting and important series such as this one. Congratulations to the Sheikh and the people behind it. You really are doing the Lord's work. JazakAllahu khairan. May Allah put barakah in your work and time.
No reason a caliphate couldn't be created on any continent. New caliphate could be as good, maybe even better than the Moghuls, Ottomans. Allahu'Alim.
I wouldn't consider either a caliphate tbh. I do think having both were great for the Muslims and I would support them if they were still around. Just in terms of their leadership I personally don't consider them caliphates.
The Arabs will be last on my list to revive any kind of Caliphate. Even the last conqueror of Jerusalem was not an Arab. Salahuddin was Kurd/Turk.
@@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378Well we have seen the consequences of no Caliphate since 1924. We are like an empty bottle being kicked around the rubbish can.
@@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378Frankly, it doesn't matter what you think. Historically the majority of Muslims accepted them as their leaders and they were. This is a historic matter not an intellectual one. You can say that they were sinful for having it be done as a kingship, but they were still valid nonetheless.
@@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378Well you are wrong and tiny minority think like you. The Ottomans fulfilled the conditions of Khilafah and we're successful for hundreds of years in protecting Islam. They failed due to backstabbing ot the hypocrites Young Turks and the hypocrites Arabs who aligned themselves with Kuffar Britain.
Salam shaykh. Great reminder. Although i have a comment to make. I understand that Loving Allah is prereq for seeing change. Once this is achieved however, it is not possible for everything to just fall in place by itself without any effort on the part of the Muslim. In other words, after Loving Allah, the Muslim still needs to make a conscious and deliberate effort to create change in society. This is really important to emphasize which you did not in this video. Nothing gets done without action and The proof for this is the Seerah of the Prophet (pbuh). Now what does this action look like? Well i would have to imagine the Seerah is best place to find that answer. My advice is to create an organization of Muslims who Love Allah, and then work together to create change based on the Prophetic method. JazakAllah khair
Dear sheikh, may Allah swt reward you with the best and bless you.
You are absolutely right with the point of the love for Allah swt. Then you talk about the „critics“ who always ask „how will you do this and that…“ as far as I know, the founder of Hizb ut Tahrir, Sheikh Taqiuddin Nabhani had all these things figured out and written in his books.
I read some of his books and I am absolutely amazed by the details he provides for the Islamic systems and the khilafah. He or any of the other shuyukh of the hizb even wrote a draft constitution of the khilafah state. I can highly recommend these literatures for everyone who loves Allah swt and thrives for the reimplementation of his swt. Ahkam on this Dunya. Barak allahu feekum
Another point is that Hizb ut Tahrir did not leave out any part of Islam. HT covered the political sphere, the intellectual sphere and also most importantly the spiritual sphere with the book Nafsiyah ( what Dr. Shadee is talking about )
And no doubt Imam Taqiddin Nabhani is a gem of the 21st century. He amazes me every single time i think about how one man can go in so much detail about every aspect off Islam in this day and age, he is truly a Mujadid of our times. The way he revived Islam and gave it to us in a plate prepared
Masha Allah ♥️
We will do it. It will happen in sha Allah.
Ustaad Allah reward you abundantly for this advice
jazakAllah shaykh May Allah bless you!!
Allahumma barik
thanks for sharing!
Great video keep it up you're doing amazing things 😁👍
Please more videos about this very important but so neglected subject of the Khilafa!!!
جزاك الله خير
Is this part of a longer lecture? Otherwise it leaves more questions than answers . What is meant by loving Allah? Is this love concentrated in a specific section of the Ummah or does it encompass the whole Ummah? How does this translate to authority? Where does political thinking and strategy fit into loving Allah - is it part of it or is there a dichotomy between them?
قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ غَفُورٌۭ رَّحِيمٌۭ ٣١
{Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “If you ˹sincerely˺ love Allah, then follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.”} 3:31
Yes. Prophet Muhammed (saw) and his armies conquered from Spain to Persia with a few horses and a few tribesmen in a few years. They ONLY had love for Allah teala. An influencial and determined man who can convince enough Arab states of change is what we need; and alhamdulillah we will have it, as foretold by hadith
Alhamdulillah!!!
Aamena May Allah SWT make us love him more than anything in this world Aamena yarrabi All success comes from our lord rabbil Aalameen inchaAllah as more of the Ummah star to turn towards this direction the khilafah will be established very soon whether the jalous and lost people like it or not it just an objective that you can't do but aim for bow that we all see what a Gogless world always lead to. May Allah SWT help and support us in this target. Aamenal rabbil Aalameen
Assalamualikum thank you for the video. Why do we love Allah? How to love Allah the correct way? How to really Love Allah with all my heart? How do I know I really love Allah? Please teach me step by step the key essentials to love Allah in easy times and hard times? Thank you.
قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ غَفُورٌۭ رَّحِيمٌۭ ٣١
{Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “If you ˹sincerely˺ love Allah, then follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.”} 3:31
5:34 - this principle applies to everything in life.
Interesting perspective. Jazakallah khair. Would you say all almost 2 billion Muslims need to have this precondition before speaking/working for reestablishment of khilafah?
Jazakallahu khayran for this video. I would like to know more what we can practically do to achieve this goal. Because yes our hearts have to be devoted to Allah and that's true. But does it mean in practical steps. And when we just pray and do dhikr it will not change a lot. We need to fulfill alla requirements but how?
Assalamualaikum ❤. We Must Need To Unite ❤️
for the algorithm
Turn the love for Muhammad sali alayi wa salam
Look in to the istihad of sheikh Taqiuddin an-Nabahani rahimouhou Allah
💯💯💯🤲🤲🤲
Even his detractors are glad his movement brought the revival of the Khilafah to the fore.
However, his movement is extremely close-minded, anti-Ulamah and has produced a bunch of parrots who hand out flyers, raise banners, regurgitate stuff and have produced nothing matching the academic rigour of even this Ummatics "platform".
Wondering how the Amish living successfully & wealthy. Peace be upon you'll out there and assalamualaiqum wmt
I'm amazed how commited the Amish are to their own religion that they have sacrificed everything this modern world has to offer. What have we muslims sacrificed for Islam in comparison? A can of coke?
@@umeriqbal8269 fr
I feel like this answer defers the heavy lifting of practical matters to a later date, hoping for the solutions to come. Meanwhile the threats to this proposed kilafa come from practical and rational networks that dont leave things up to chance.
The love for Allah is there in people. Enough love. We need the other things. Things that love can't buy. The ones that are immersed in love are content with that love, and ready to leave the dunya to be closer to the beloved. They wont care for the worldliness of building a kilafa.
This implies that what we need instead are good Muslims who love the dunya enough to build a kilafa.
Fundamentally we are all part of a big puzzle, in which we are the pieces.
Hearing out and listening to different perspectives will In Sha Allah result in a positive, and slowly result in the completion of the puzzle.
Pointing fingers won't, in my humble opinion.
how can we expect something as great and beautiful as a khilafa from Allah when we have muslims who casually innovate in his sharia and distort his names and attributes wal iyyadhu billah. and some even go as far as comitting shirk...
♥️♥️♥️
Could you please give Shaykh Al Bouti's book name
im not sure where his quoting from but i believe its in fiqh ul seerah by shiekh Ramadan al Bouti
Very good topic I was intrigued as I’ve never heard someone bring it up quiet like this
I imagine having an Islamic state as big as all the Muslim countries combined would greatly alarm other elite powers in the world
The umma is capable of doing it, I’d some obstacles include the Islamist bureaucracy like you mentioned and perhaps even Shia and Sunni. But besides that the love of Allah SWT and of the religion of Prophet Muhammad PBUH will guide us
Jazakullah
Assalamualaykum Shaikh, can you define what loving Allah (and his messenger ﷺ) means?
قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ غَفُورٌۭ رَّحِيمٌۭ ٣١
{Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “If you ˹sincerely˺ love Allah, then follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.”} 3:31
how do we know we have fulfilled the condition to have a khilafah? Do we withhold working for khilafah until we fulfil this condition? Or do we work with khilfah and at the same time ensure we are working on this pre-requisite?
Brother prayer, fasting, Hajj and Zakat ( according to the means ), taking care of family, seeking rizq, gaining knowledge, enjoining the good and forbidding the evil, establishment of Khilafah etc. all come under the category of Fard.
Now my question is can we pick and choose in matters of Fard ? Can we say that my prayer is not perfect therefore my iman is weak so I will not fast because I fear that I will commit a grave sin during the fast i.e the khushu of my prayer is not optimal so i will not start fasting until my khushu in prayer is optimal ?
The answer is No, we cannot pick and choose in the matters of Fard. Therefore we must manage all Faraiz ( obligations ) during our lifetime to the best of our ability, whatever our level of Iman or Taqwa may be. The road to paradise is not easy, Muslims have alot of responsibilities.
And my last point is that some Fard are done individually and some require a collective effort such as accounting the rulers, enjoining the good and forbidding the evil and the establishment of Khilafah. So for those Faraiz (obligations) that require a collective effort an individual is obliged to be part of a Islamic group/party. Just look at what our Prophet (pbuh) did, although he was the best Dawah carrier to be witnessed by humanity he still did not establiish the Deen alone rather he built a group/party of the Sahaba that struggled politically, intellectually and spiritually
@@mohammadsameer8247 barakallahu feek akhi, very well explained :)
Khilafa means successor, ruler or leader (check wiki). What i'm asking is, how do you propose the change in the system?
Without any bloodshed, a coup or any kind Of revolt
We are the product on the system we live under. It will be harder that we fix everyone to love Allah as Allah should be loved because there are many distractions in the duniya.
It's kinda crazy to conclude that those love Khilafah doesn't love Allah.
Why would some love the Sharia of Allah via Khilafah if they don't love Allah?
Loving Allah would mean we love everything Allah gave us and hate everything Allah hates.
Salam alaikum,
Alhamdulillah excellent video especially in this time.
I have 2 questions though
1. Is it wise for us to adopt terms (catagories) that are ascribed to Muslims by non-Muslims, such as islamist ?
Aren't they just Muslims from amongst the Ummah spending efforts on the path of an obligation ?
2. Isn't it strange to argue that Khilafah isn't realized do to the absense of piety in those who strive for it ? And the presence of some pious observer(s) amongst us in this Dunya, who noticed others lacking (or meeting standards), did not have any other result in that very same respect and time span ?
So either the pious neglected to join or advise or undertake by themselves or we don't have piety amongst us at all ? Because they failed to act upon that which they knew ?
Or is it that the analysis in it's entirety should be revisited ?
Khilafa can only be possible/successful through Wilayah (divine guardianship) and in absence of a singular Nabi or the Mahdi, a council of prominent Ulema (scholars) should be accessible to provide guidance through (Shura) consultation with various experts.
ISIS was a desperate attempt to establish a Khilafa without the consent of ahl hall wa aqd ,What a disaster that was ! These are times of Fitna. We must return to the Fundamentals of the Din , unite the Umma upon the Usul by following the Sunna and not following Taghut .The reality is that the modern nation states has become the new world order since WWI and WWII.
is1s was created by m0sad, in order to discredit any real Khilafa movement.
@@briancordero7674 no it was isreal creating an excuse to kill Muslims.
ISIS was created by CIA and Mossad to discredit Muslims
bruh ISIS Is USA Proxy/Assets 😑
Amazing how they all start talking around the subject and then totally go off course.
Dastur al-Madina will return soon!
Make duaa for the Khalifa to start in khurasan
Lol in khurasan who can't speak Arabic? Khilafa has been established by khuraishi arabs . And khilafa always will be under khuarishis not afgahnis
@@theahmedfahad Allah gave these men a victory the miserable Arab haven't achieved in 100 years. So stick to your filthy t3ssub until the hadith that reveals what will happen to the 3rab comes true before your eyes. At that time, remember this warning.
@@theahmedfahad Ottomans were turks
سبحان الله العظيم
We already have the caliph/ rahbar ayatollah ali khamenei who resident of Iran and supreme religious leader. All Sunnis and Shias accept him as your leader and you will be guided .. otherwise you will always be mislead..
I wage war against the enemy every day by writing my elected officials, and participating in public protests and acts of civil disobedience. I was born in Australia, and moved with my parents to the USA as a young child. My parents are from a Muslim majority nation. I am doing more for Muslim progress as a resident of a southern state, than I ever was as part of, and regular participant in, one of America's largest Muslim Centers in one of America's largest cities. Who wants to run a Caliphate for their own greed and evil objectives, sullying the image and practice of Islam? Anyone who thinks that (s)he is good enough to do it is ignorant or too prideful to every be worthy of such a position. In a hundred years, Islam will be the faith with the largest number of global adherents anyways. I pray that Allah guides us, and our descendants to bear the duties and obligations of such a condition well.
la ilaha illallah
why so many cuts
ASSALAMUALAIKUM, I THINK ITS VERY VALID FOR YOU TO ADDRESS YASIR QADHI ... PLEASE DO SO ... 😊
He doesn't need to and I hope he doesn't. Shaykh Shadee is a great person to listen to for knowledge. I don't want him bogged down with drama.
@@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378 I think scholars need to come out and state their positions... Especially when you have scholars giving statements that affect many Muslims... we are one body, one limb hurts it damages many in the ummah ... SCHOLARS ESPECIALLY SUNNI ONES need to start becoming a little stronger and state unapologetic opinions ... And I AM WRITING HERE BECAUSE I TOO LOVE AND ENJOY DR SHADEE, And these are legitimate questions ...
The wahabis were the biggest obstacles to re establishing a Khalifa...
More videos own the khilafa!!
Do you belong to the Maliki school or some other school?
Asalamualaikum!
و عليك السلام و رحمة الله و بركاته
@@YA-do8tz Inshallah we will eventually get a true Khilafah
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Even without watching this video the answer as why there is no khilafa is very simple - Saudis.
Cheap cop out
@@PoeticAmmunition. Nonsense.
@@PoeticAmmunition.saudis are anti-khilafa. A true khilafa would bring the monarch of saudi under the chopping board first.
@@Jasdf-jm8ie It is a cop-out It's not to say you're wrongIt is a cop-out It's not to say you're wrong
Why does he accuse people who work for khilafha of not loving the Creator?
If it was hard for us Afghans to unite all of our ethnicities (Pashtuns, Tajiks, Uzbeks, Turkmens, Hazara etc.) under one flag, which caused too much bloodshed, how on earth would you think it is to unite all "Muslim" nations under one flag, despite all the sects there are in the Muslim world?
Exactly which also highlights how people lack real understanding of Muslim history. There was not unified khalifah, especially after the end of the Khalfiah rashidun. During the ottoman time, there were other sultantates and khlaifah around the world. West african muslims were never under the ottomans, same goes for the southeast asian communities. This modern idea of some total one unified community just isnt real.
Taliban just did that for you, in 2021. Materially and Effectively they united the entire Afg under 1 banner.
@@AsifAlli There influence is only strong in Kabul. But they will collapse, if they keep banning our Afghan Women from education. There will be bloodshed. Also don’t forget the north alliance of afghanistan in the panshir province, whom the Taliban can’t properly defeat.
@@AsifAlliAfaik, theres persecution of Tajiks, Uzbeks and hazaras since the taliban took office. Unity in terms of race or ethnicity is massive undertaking for a Muslim ummah in 2024.
@@Random_Boy353Taliban has defeated the shias and all it's influence. Shiaism and northern alliance hasn't got anything to do with Islam. amrullah saleh is currently sitting with Islam's enemies in switzerland.
The khilafa was constrained to the Arab world mainly what about the other Muslim people in Africa and Asia how do they fit in that ?
The longest Khilafa was non-arab called the Ottomon Empire.
Khilafa is for all people regardless of faith who want to live opposite to what kind of governance we see today in all parts if the world. Khilafa is about people first.
Well, the problem like uniting countries becomes who becomes leader then it's a mess. It's why a country has set governance of many powers. A set view of collaboration is only probably applicable today, so many counteyes san unite in a united way in conditions but there will probably not be one leader. Too many clashing heads. Start snall with united programs. An islamic caliphate and governance, is already there in a sense. But lets not pretend like dynasties didn't fall either. If you look at history and look at the reaults of the whys youll see many issues reaulting in too much arrogance and control freaks, no checks and balances. United is possible if condirionsbare plausible, so youll get these factoons wanting a full caliphate to return, but im pretty they only want their leader, so other factions will disagree and they'll all fight each other. So its just a fools game in ego tripping versus starting small in actual uniting assistance, like infrastructure help, economic help, education and such, like conditions for conditions.
A very good video to reflect the yearnings of the Ummah, thank you for efforts Shaykh.
However, as per the Qa'idah...'that which is necessary to fulfill an obligation in itself becomes an obligation' what are the necessary actions beyond Qurba to Allah - which in itself is an ongoing effort regardless of time and age. What are the practical actions from Sunnah that lead to achieving political change? What are the neccessary actions that we must engage in to achieve the establishment of a singular unified political entity that is based on the Shari'ah?
I am very happy to see this discourse becoming more widespread in the Ummah. Now we must seek crystallization of the idea so that the people can see the practical outcome of the yearning that burns within us all - especially after seeing the apathetic response the 'muslim' states have had in relation to our Ummah in Gazza and beyond!!!
I think Syed Abul A'la Maududi from Pakistan did say this.
Maudidi was Abit delusional
So did Dr Israr and Alama Khadim.
About love?
Please don't refer to Rasul Allah (SAW) as the founder of Islam.
Islam started with Adam (AS) and got completed with Muhammad (SAW).
Maybe the Muslim countries are too authoritarian and fascistic because it seems if the font love Allah and deen like people do not fear loss, in the sense that they don’t learn lessons observing the disasters of people who are not religious? And think “ thank God for the deen I could be like that!!! I love it as it saves.” if everything is very strictly controlled maybe it becomes like a religion which is good but nobody realises it i.e. like a fridge in the background which nobody hears even though it’s on (it’s called habituation in psychology I think). Another analogy would be Buddha before he left his palace - if he didn’t know the suffering, why would he bother with a path?
People can’t follow one Madhab but they think they’re ready for a khalifa to govern them
Why do people have to follow one madhab?
even the Sahaba differed within themselves, its not a bad thing to have opinions. We all agree on the core ideas.
@@shahriar4706_ the madhahib are from the sahaba! Each Madhab goes back to a sahabi
madhabs are supposed to be different. people who talk about single madhab don't understand how scholarship works
@@b-sideplank people who think you can pick and choose don’t realise how a madhab works
These activists and "influencers" ahhaha. Nice ending
The ottomans have the best claim, and Allah knows best.
To Qurayshi lineage?
@@mohammeds3114 The Qureyshi lineage was there amongst many powerful ottoman officials and shuyookh, and Allah knows best
@@Khairuddin313I'm struggling to find any material in English or Arabic proving that the Ottomans met the condition of being Qurayshi. Someone mentioned Abd-al Ghani Al-Nablusi but never any references to his discussion on the topic.
@@mohammeds3114 Sayyid Nursi, risalat annoor
@@Khairuddin313 With all respect, I'm just after a book/reference wherein the lineage of the Ottomans being Qurayshi is discussed. No doubt, they had love for the Muslims beyond their borders and we're a bulwark against Zionism but were they legit Khulafah?
European Union….
Lmao. Making it up as you go along.
khilafa lies in heart of the soul (nafs) of believers
Khilafst has come, but Muslims do not wish to accept it because they have lost Khilafst for so long that they don't even know how Khilafst works or how it feels like
Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya Zindabad!
You created another false religion out of Islam lol. Your 'prophet' died in his own diahhrea lol.
ok lil bro 👍
😂😊
@@Nanonium We don't accept Khilafat from fake prophet dying in his own 💩.
@@Nanonium 😆😆😆😆
We had one recently but mainstream Muslims were too busy calling them dogs of hellfire... :(
No doubt.
We witnessed the black flag flying over lands that had implementation the complete set of shariah law and experienced an immediate effect it had on the ummah who had chosen to live in the newest caliphate.
From the re establishment of a marketplace buying and selling enslaved human beings to unconsented sex outside of the institution of marriage just to mention a few.
It was indeed a miracle judging by how fast it took for an average human being to begin acting in ways and manners that would make savage animals blush.
We saw the best of it from the front lines.
The savage predation of a poor, defenseless and helpless ethnic minority group whose women folk bore the brunt of bringing back the activities and trade of sexual slaves.
Al Bahgdadi was dropping bars when he said " who are they to deny me that which has been made lawful for me by my God ? "
Mainstream muslims werent too busy labelling those animals as dogs from hell.
They were
WORD OF THE DAY: Khilaf, meaning "disagreement/mistakes'
duh?
salaam
Perhaps you would rather run for political office? Perhaps Muslims the world over are already too well behaved, and need to take on more challenges, rather than completing the life-long challenge of working to fulfill the duties and manners of a good Muslim, in the home, in the public, with family, friends and strangers alike. We have 49 nations, and we cannot even get those nations to cooperate to stand united with our brothers and sisters in Palestine and China (the Uyghurs) to prevent them from suffering the worst atrocities since the Jews of World War 2! SHAME ON US ALL!
THE ONLY NEED IN ISLAM IS THE QURAN, and dedicated Muslims to keep the discussion alive about what the Qur'an means to each of us! We do not need a Khilafa, or a Caliphate. Anyone who speaks for the world of Believers is dead. The prophet Muhammad (SWT) was the "Seal of the Prophets," meaning THE LAST ONE! There are plenty of Muslim majority nations, and there are plenty of other nations that permit freedom of faith. When we, as Muslims, make the same mistake as our fellow creation of various faiths, Abrahamic and otherwise, we run the risk of contaminating the pure nature and condition of Islam, which, as presented in the Qur'an, IS PERFECT as it is! We do not need to contaminate the Perfect Word of the Qur'an with the dirty twisted world of politics, economics and other messes, which by their nature, and by the corrupt nature of people, IS CORRUPT AND TOTALLY IMPERFECT! So far, even during the time of the Prophet (SWT) the umma has proven too wide and disparate in every means, political, economic, and even in their various ideas on Islam, that trying to group them all together, under any one organizational form, other than the widespread umma as it is, would only serve to diminish the ideals and perfect nature of Islam as presented in the Holy Qur'an. Anyone who tries to pretend to be a Khalifa, or to create a Caliphate, is doing so for selfish and ulterior motives.
We Muslims need democracy, no Caliph. In your lovely Caliphate you will discriminate against Shias, and non-Muslims.
No we don't want jewish democracy
Inferiority complex, cowardice, adopting false beliefs
We should never bring Khilafa back. It sounds good but is a nightmare unless you accept the Wilayah of Ameerul Mumineen Imam Ali [S]. The Khilafas did nothing but bloodshed and the burning of the Grand Library of Alexandria. The Leader of the Muslims can only be assigned by Allah which makes logical sense. Karbala and the Battle of Jamal didn't happen in a vacuum.
It's only a nightmare for you shias.
Donkey Channel
Amazing how they all start talking around the subject and then totally go off course.
Dastur al-Madina will return soon!