Voting for this matchup ended on Saturday. Final count was: NMIXX 96 SNSD 90 The late surge for SNSD would've given them victory!! Make sure you're subscribed to cast your votes on time!!! 🙏🙏🙏
I vote for SNSD / Girls Generation. But these 2 groups are from different era. However, GG is a living legend and their 16years of career explained how talented, diverse & impactful they are.
Girls Generation is 2nd gen and NMIXX is 4th gen, you can't compared each other but Girls Generation is a legend one, they good at singing, dancing, and so many genres of music. Imagine they made the MV like this in 2014, so powerfull and energic. They choreo always be iconic ini every songs.
I agree with you... the song catch me if you can't from snsd was released in 2014 and the song party o'clock from nmixx was released in 2023. Of course it can't be compared, it doesn't make sense to compare these 2 groups. They should compare each kpop generation, like fellow 4th generation, not comparing generation 2 with generation 4.
Yeah, but they have the point for concept to Girls Gen anyway. Nmixx has the replayability and dance performance. That doesn't have anything to do with the MV production.
GG for the win. Just evaluating the songs, Catch Me If You Can defines the word "banger." I listen to that song regularly, and everyone who sees that MV reacts the way you did. So Girls' Generation has to win this round. Party O'Clock is a really good song, but it is not in the same category. Now that you've heard Party O'Clock, it is time to react to the It's Live performance!
NMIXX, also because you’ve seen Party O’Clock now. The Party O’Clock performance on It’s Live is legendary. They actually made it 10000x times better live!
I was looking forward to hearing Party O' Clock after reading the comments, but I'm really surprised I don't agree. I actually still prefer Catch Me If You Can ( despite it not being an SNSD title track). I do feel like leaving the vote to the comment section might give you a biased result, because NMIXX is a current 4th gen group. I just saw someone say they're voting for NMIXX cause they're their bias 😂
I'm a fan of nmixx. I really want they win. But winning with vote from audience is just dont feels right, for me at least. Bcs they're current gen idol, so im pretty sure 99% mostly SNSD fans is already busy with their own real life businesses and not watching this video. So there is a lot biased vote. I recommend you to rematch with I GOT A BOY by SNSD vs DICE or O.O by NMIXX. I suggest u these song simply bcs they have MIXPOP in the song. So this factor could be the X-factor (if u need a tie breaker again) . Which one is do u think moreeee smooth in terms of switching genre. Just my thoughts guys, u can decide
There is still no one that come close to Snsd in any category. SNSD to this day stands on top of Girl Groups and only one that can compete with the boys head on.
@@thelastsplash Of course, I watched it live. Bae and Mujin's vibes matched perfectly. It was even cooler 'cause my current fav was singing a song from my old fav.
NMIXX!! Between these songs it's NMIXX all the way. I'm not big in this Girl's Generation song. If it was a different Girl's generation song, I probably would've voted for that.
GIRLS’ GENERATION FOR SURE. Catch me if you can is just a bonus single with a very low budget compared to their other songs/music videos. But they still killed it. First time looking at the comparison, i was a bit skeptical because you picked Girls’ Generation crumb. I would recommend the ones with higher budget. But after watching your video, i never regret stanning Girls’ Generation for 15 years. I should’ve never doubted them. I’m a proud Sone. 😊
Greetings! I will be voting NMIXX on this one. I admit I don't know Girls' Generation, but nevertheless I was able to watch the music video that you reacted to. Maybe it's just a show of the times, but I still think NMIXX's "Party O'Clock" showed more vocal runs as well as vocal diversity, more complex choreos and less of a feel of a "Performance video". Also, "Catch Me If You Can" was a bit too "club music" throughout, so even though it was catchy because of it (it reminded me of how PSY's "Gangnam Style" is catchy because of it's similar synth music) I would give it to NMIXX overall. All in all, I'm just grateful TWICE isn't anywhere in this competition, as it would be hard for me to think of anyone else winning! :)
SNSD are the original Queens. Cannot compare 2nd gen with 4th gen. Maybe check out I Got A Boy from SNSD for vocals and transitions. Or, concert performance of SNSD for more vocals. Catch me if you Can was really about dance line.
Girls generation got my vote. If it was between CMIYC vs Roller Coaster then that would be difficult for me. But I love CMIYC and I'm not vibing with Party O'Clock.
GG4EVER. I absolutely vote Girls' Generation!!! This year is their 17th anniversary and still being one of the top Girl group even in this current generation tho. They are LEGEND!!!
I choose Nmixx, both songs where good. Yeah I love Jiwoo chipmunk cheeks. Maknae line get me all the time in there MV's If Nmixx win I choose Dice - ua-cam.com/video/p1bjnyDqI9k/v-deo.html IVE - I choose their Debut Eleven - ua-cam.com/video/--FmExEAsM8/v-deo.html With how nmixx like to do change up, can't think of a song the ive has that similiar to that lol. Hope there some what similiar lol
As someone already said, it would be great to do another round with GGs I got a boy and NMIXXs O.O/DICE for you to choose the winner yourself. But if it's not possible then my vote goes to Nmixx🐬
Voting for this matchup ended on Saturday. Final count was:
NMIXX 96
SNSD 90
The late surge for SNSD would've given them victory!! Make sure you're subscribed to cast your votes on time!!!
🙏🙏🙏
Voting is mostly girls' generation!!
it's not fair
Repeat the inventory again the days before Saturday
"Right now it's Girls' Generation, tomorrow it's Girls' Generation, forever it's Girls' Generation" 💗
I vote for SNSD / Girls Generation. But these 2 groups are from different era. However, GG is a living legend and their 16years of career explained how talented, diverse & impactful they are.
And how come you didn’t pick other Bangers from GG’s discography??
Girls Generation is 2nd gen and NMIXX is 4th gen, you can't compared each other but Girls Generation is a legend one, they good at singing, dancing, and so many genres of music. Imagine they made the MV like this in 2014, so powerfull and energic. They choreo always be iconic ini every songs.
I agree with you...
the song catch me if you can't from snsd was released in 2014 and the song party o'clock from nmixx was released in 2023.
Of course it can't be compared, it doesn't make sense to compare these 2 groups.
They should compare each kpop generation, like fellow 4th generation, not comparing generation 2 with generation 4.
Yeah, but they have the point for concept to Girls Gen anyway. Nmixx has the replayability and dance performance. That doesn't have anything to do with the MV production.
Girls generation for the win!
*Girls Generation ALL THE WAY!!!* 👑✨🔥
*You should have chosen PARTY vs PARTY oCLOCK*
Absolutely!
GIRLS GENERATION ALL THE WAY! ❤
Girl Generation for sure❤
Girls Generation is the best❤❤
GG for the win. Just evaluating the songs, Catch Me If You Can defines the word "banger." I listen to that song regularly, and everyone who sees that MV reacts the way you did. So Girls' Generation has to win this round. Party O'Clock is a really good song, but it is not in the same category.
Now that you've heard Party O'Clock, it is time to react to the It's Live performance!
No doubt Girls’ Generation are the best 💯
SNSD has been in the industry for almost 17years it's a no brainer
Their reactions when NMIXX starts singing you can tell they (Flip & Element) sure do like NMIXX.
NMIXX, also because you’ve seen Party O’Clock now. The Party O’Clock performance on It’s Live is legendary. They actually made it 10000x times better live!
Definitely nmixx such a bop
Voting for nmixx bc they deserve recognition and snsd is already a colossus ❤
No one can beat Girls’ Generation queens 👑
Girls generation ❤❤❤
I’m voting for Girls’ Generation for sure
I was looking forward to hearing Party O' Clock after reading the comments, but I'm really surprised I don't agree. I actually still prefer Catch Me If You Can ( despite it not being an SNSD title track).
I do feel like leaving the vote to the comment section might give you a biased result, because NMIXX is a current 4th gen group. I just saw someone say they're voting for NMIXX cause they're their bias 😂
Agree
May I suggest listening to the it’s live version. The studio ver pales compared to that version sadly.
Yesss my favorite girl generation song❤❤❤👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Girls' Generation's level is incomparable because they have stronger, stronger videos. It is not fair to compare them with others.
I think Im unsubscribing if my girls loses this match. I just cannot accept.
GG, all the way!!! 👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑
my vote goes to the LEGENDS, GIRLS GENERATION!!!
Final round for GG - PLEASE USE ‘YOU THINK’ MV
I swear no group can beat that MV 🔥🔥🔥
Yesssss pleasee
Absolutely AGREE!!! You Think is 🔥🔥🔥
Flip & Element's reaction when the beat drop from GG Catch Me If You Can, (Priceless)
I'm a fan of nmixx. I really want they win. But winning with vote from audience is just dont feels right, for me at least.
Bcs they're current gen idol, so im pretty sure 99% mostly SNSD fans is already busy with their own real life businesses and not watching this video. So there is a lot biased vote.
I recommend you to rematch with I GOT A BOY by SNSD vs DICE or O.O by NMIXX.
I suggest u these song simply bcs they have MIXPOP in the song. So this factor could be the X-factor (if u need a tie breaker again) . Which one is do u think moreeee smooth in terms of switching genre.
Just my thoughts guys, u can decide
Agree
Agreed, but the problem there is that in O.O the MV has a weird pause that kinda ruins the switch up in my opinion.
There is still no one that come close to Snsd in any category. SNSD to this day stands on top of Girl Groups and only one that can compete with the boys head on.
Let's go Girls' Generation!
Girls generationn for suree their vocal , dancee , rap , choreoo just amazinggg❤
Girls' Generation is something different, I love them ❤❤❤
I will choose nmixx❤❤
I vote for girls generation❤️
Girls Generation #GG4EVA ❤
Girls' Generation for the win!!
I chose nmixx because I like their music❤❤
SNSD FOR WIN
Girls' Generation all the way
I should highly recommend you to watch Party O’Clock its live! Maybe this will change your criteria
Yes, the It’s Live version is my favorite!!!
@@fromEPtoFW I love how they changed their adlibs in this song 😫😫
Thank you for the NMIXX & Girls Generation Banger vs Banger. I'm glad you are finding it hard to pick a winner.
My vote goes to girls generation for sure
Girls Generation for the win
Thank you, guys, for posting this funny series. I vote for my stan, NMIXX. It is good not to make my decision between NMIXX and 2ne1 :)
Did you hear Bae sing 2NE1 on Lee Mujin service?
@@thelastsplash Of course, I watched it live. Bae and Mujin's vibes matched perfectly. It was even cooler 'cause my current fav was singing a song from my old fav.
Please let's have a rematch between NMIXX's O.O or Dice and Girls' Generation's I Got A Boy!!!
I Got A Boy for the way all the way 😂
GIRLS' GENERATION👑
NO QUESTIONS SNSD KILLED IT, CONCEPT, MUSIC WISE, PERFORMANCE, VOCAL,
NMIXX for sure, their versatility is insane😭💗
They sure are. But versatility is a huge part of SNSD as well!
Ofc Girls' Generation 🎉🎉🎉
I got the boy should be there, a lot of change up. Thats song can compete with nmixx
Honestly both groups is in the top of my favorite GG tier list
2nd gen SNSD gp is always queens for me
Girls generation for me
I vote for Nmixx ❤
SNSD without a doubt 🔥🔥🔥
SNSD You Think Next Please if ever they get farther ❤❤
Please react to party o'clock its live version!!
Girls Generation for sure.
I vote Girl generation catch me if you can.
Girls Generation ofc💓🩷
NEXT GIRLS' GENERATION "YOU THINK" PLEASEEE
Definitely nmixx! Their talent are so unstoppable!
Yes they are!
I love Girls' Generation. But I will pick NMIXX.
SNSD All the way😘
Girls' Generation for me!
NMIXX!! Between these songs it's NMIXX all the way. I'm not big in this Girl's Generation song. If it was a different Girl's generation song, I probably would've voted for that.
I'm voting NMIXX but part of me wants them to go out so you can react to all their performances quicker 😅
I vote for NMIXX
My choice is nmixx
My vote is on NMIXX, I would like to see DICE in next video
GIRLS’ GENERATION FOR SURE. Catch me if you can is just a bonus single with a very low budget compared to their other songs/music videos. But they still killed it. First time looking at the comparison, i was a bit skeptical because you picked Girls’ Generation crumb. I would recommend the ones with higher budget. But after watching your video, i never regret stanning Girls’ Generation for 15 years. I should’ve never doubted them. I’m a proud Sone. 😊
I vote for my girls, Girls Generation.
It's actually lily who is the pitch corrector. She just can't withstand the incorrect pitch.
*FINAL BATTLE for GG please pick YOU THINK MV*
NMIXX ❤ No wonder they are my biases since their debut!
Greetings! I will be voting NMIXX on this one.
I admit I don't know Girls' Generation, but nevertheless I was able to watch the music video that you reacted to. Maybe it's just a show of the times, but I still think NMIXX's "Party O'Clock" showed more vocal runs as well as vocal diversity, more complex choreos and less of a feel of a "Performance video". Also, "Catch Me If You Can" was a bit too "club music" throughout, so even though it was catchy because of it (it reminded me of how PSY's "Gangnam Style" is catchy because of it's similar synth music) I would give it to NMIXX overall.
All in all, I'm just grateful TWICE isn't anywhere in this competition, as it would be hard for me to think of anyone else winning! :)
NMIXX for the win!!!❤
SNSD are the original Queens. Cannot compare 2nd gen with 4th gen. Maybe check out I Got A Boy from SNSD for vocals and transitions. Or, concert performance of SNSD for more vocals. Catch me if you Can was really about dance line.
Girls generation got my vote.
If it was between CMIYC vs Roller Coaster then that would be difficult for me. But I love CMIYC and I'm not vibing with Party O'Clock.
My fav 2nd gen group and 4th gen group but i have to choose nmixx... party o'clock is such a bop
GG4EVER. I absolutely vote Girls' Generation!!! This year is their 17th anniversary and still being one of the top Girl group even in this current generation tho. They are LEGEND!!!
girls generation!!!
Girls' generation they don't stop!! 🔥
Party O’ Clock is such an extraordinary music composition, NMIXX is not about trending and comercial but has a unique style
Nmixx❤ go check comeback title “dash”
girls' generation for sure!!
deffo SNSD catch me if you can
Nmixx... 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 The girl group that who can do anything... They eat every concept ....
Snsd❤
Girls gen my vote😊
GIRLS‘ GENERATION ❤❤❤
girls' generation's g stans for greatest of all time.
I pick NMIXX
It's Girls Generation
if nmixx wins yak should do dash nmixx vs i am or love dive if you haven’t done those i’ve ones!
I choose Nmixx, both songs where good. Yeah I love Jiwoo chipmunk cheeks. Maknae line get me all the time in there MV's
If Nmixx win I choose Dice - ua-cam.com/video/p1bjnyDqI9k/v-deo.html
IVE - I choose their Debut Eleven - ua-cam.com/video/--FmExEAsM8/v-deo.html
With how nmixx like to do change up, can't think of a song the ive has that similiar to that lol. Hope there some what similiar lol
I'm voting for SNSD🫶
Of course girls generation 😊❤
Girls generation is the best female group
As someone already said, it would be great to do another round with GGs I got a boy and NMIXXs O.O/DICE for you to choose the winner yourself.
But if it's not possible then my vote goes to Nmixx🐬
SNSD GIRL GENERATION ❤️❤️❤️ I LOVE THEIR CONCEPT
I see Girls generation 👑 auto click
Girls’ Generation~~~