there is still a chance slim but a chance, never count out the Buckeyes till the final rankings are out, I am a Buckeyes fan and being real here, there are ways I think if Oklahoma wins narrowly we have to win by a score of 100-0 to get in highly unlikely again a very good northwestern team, Northwestern is way better than their record shows and I think that will be a tough game, but as a Buckeye fan since I knew what football was I have to keep my fingers crossed for an Oklahoma loss and a Buckeye win, but if it don't happen Oklahoma wise i will settle for a Rose bowl appearance, nothing to cry about with missing the playoff we still get an elite bowl game barring a win by my Buckeyes
It's possible. I'm a buckeyes fan and I'm hoping for it. I think Texas is going to beat Oklahoma. I don't think Oklahoma will beat them twice this season. Actually if I part of the committee I would keep Notre dame out of the final four until they join an actual conference instead being handed a cupcake schedule every year
David Glass categorically incorrect...we would have more games that matter than we do now. And losses would matter just as much. You’d also be incentivizing tougher scheduling. This is the same dumb argument people made against a 4 team playoff...funny how those people evaporated.
33moneyball well i wasn’t on that train saying four was bad, and actually loses wouldn’t matter bc u could lose 2 and still have a chance at making it. also a tougher schedule wouldn’t matter bc there would be more spots so strength of schedule doesn’t matter therefore you have more teams playing the citadel
@@33moneyball the defense is catastrophic. If you say otherwise you're an idiot. And in that Texas game if Tom herman didn't go all conservative in the end they win by 20.
If Oklahoma recruited and coached up SEC level defensive players, you couldn’t touch them. Their only saving grace is that they play in the “ no defense” league. When you have to score 60 plus points to beat someone, a defense of any caliber can beat you.
34JROD34 exactly my thoughts. Oklahoma, Ohio state and Georgia all could argue are deserving of a chance to play for a championship. Not UCF, Michigan or 3-loss SEC teams
@@bradendavis5640 why doesn't UCF deserve a chance??? They have been undefeated for two years and last year beat the only team to beat alabama last year in their bowl game 🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
My problem is that a 1 loss team shouldn’t be left out. Because then no one can ever make a mistake. And most years there is a 1 loss team at 5 or 6 that should be included
No one will ever convince me that a slightly bigger playoff (yet still smaller by orders of magnitude than EVERY OTHER level of football)...is a bad thing.
Valen Sinclair it effects the athletes because it stretches the football season out and increases the chance of injury and the deadline to withdraw from the draft Is around January and they don’t wanna enter the draft it’s to much risk .... there’s a video where Joel explains it better on the herd
@ITHEREONETHATHASNT just pointing out that a nobody FCS school was competitive with you for a full half, and UCF is a far better team than The Citadel. I'll agree that Alabama is very good and probably would beat UCF, but to cast them aside in such an ignorant manner isn't wise. Upsets can happen.
I love Klatt, but he’s totally wrong about an 8 team playoff. I’d love to watch that, tons of people would... Or even a 6 team playoff with 1&2 seeds getting a bye.
The argument for 8 team playoffs is that most of these kids will NEVER play in the pros, so give them the experience of trying for a national title. Realistically, no #8 will win, but if one does, then they deserved it. March Madness never produces a true surprise, but if it did, it would be a blast & the process would legitimize the winner. Same thing. Let's do 8.
An 8-team playoffs would be amazing!! It would shut the mouths of analysts and let these teams resolve it on the field. Best time in sports? March Madness! Why not bring the playoffs to CFB?
But everyone loves March madness tournament which gives 64 teams a shot at the national title, 8 teams would not be a bad thing, would definitely make it more interesting than seeing the same 4-5 teams in the playoff every year
Yes! Thank you for listening to my request. But its crazy to think people are against an 8 team playoff format. Literally people keep debating about these teams. Let them play each other so the debates can be settled! But none of these good teams can play each other, because we have the not playoffs, and multiple undefeated teams have no chance at even playing good teams. If im wrong, maybe a 6 team playoff would be good
I don’t get why people get on ND , has anybody taken into consideration that in the last month alone, ND traveled almost 3,700 miles and still managed to win all those games? yes, I admit the USC game wasn’t pretty but when you’ve traveled so much.. can you blame them for not coming out 100% against a ready to play USC?
Why do people always skip a 6 team playoff and go straight to 8. It is fair because each power 5 champ gets in and there is a chance for an at large bid for a team like UCF! Every regular season game still matters which is what makes college football better then the NFL, and conf champs aren’t left out due to a stupid committees subjective opinions.
Guys I am a Michigan fan attend a Michigan high school and there are Michigan, OSU, Mich St, And Notre Dame fans there And all of the Michigan fans(including me) love Harbaugh at top 5-10 and the only people who think he is bad are the Michigan state Ohio st and ND fans
6 team playoff would be the beat. Usually the top 2 seeds separate themselves from everyone else and the other 4 spots would be competitive. Top 2 seeds get a bye
My only point is that Conference Championship games have to mean something. The only way is for those P5 conference champs to get automatic bids which would mean 8 team playoffs. You can the choose from 3 at large teams.
Off topic but that "Oculus Go" commercial is like nails on a chalkboard. I always have to turn the volume down before any youtube sports video. Already makes me miss the Peyton and Brad Nationwide commercials which were annoying as well ..
Florida and Texas aren’t an argument for an 8 team playoff though... it’s a very clear cut 8 teams right now, and if you’re telling me UCF at 8 is debated with the #9, 3 loss Florida team and the #15, 3 loss Texas team- I don’t buy it.
Purdue was 3-0 vs ranked teams. A catastrophe is Clemson losing to a team that only beat one other power 5 team last year, but getting an invite anyway as champ of the weakest of the power 5
8-team playoff is great. In NCAA basketball the 16 seeds could never win the championship, so all the teams that could win, are in. With 8 teams in football, the chance the 8 seed could win, is low. So at least all the teams that could win, have a chance.
I don't watch college football because barely any games mean anything once you lose, but I would watch a playoff 4sure no matter how many teams more the better.
The only way this gets fixed is if they do it the same way they do in college basketball or change it to an NFL style playoff system. I'm a firm believer in "any given Sunday" so I'd prefer the NFL style playoff system overall because it gives more teams a chance at a championship.
If we had an 8 team playoff it should look similar to this (with no upsets) #1 Alabama (SEC Champs) v. #8 Washington (Pac-12 Champs) #2 Clemson (ACC Champs) v. #7 UCF (Undefeated Group of 5) #3 Notre Dame (Undefeated) v. #6 Michigan/Georgia (At-Large bid) which would be the only one debatable #4 Oklahoma (Big 12 Champs) v. #5 Ohio State (Big 10 Champs) Seeding based on ranking with each conference champs in. Group of 5 would only get in if they go undefeated. I think this could really work. They were still arguing like the 8 team playoff would stay in the current system. With an 8 team playoff, the system would have to change in order for it to work.
Dabney Langhorne there just saying nobody wants to see UCF get in with that easy schedule and get demolished by Clemson ...when Clemson whole Dline is first round picks
@@tyreesetoomer13 every FBS school deserves a shot at a national title. It kind of hard to not be deserving of a chance when you go undefeated with a schedule you have no control over. They can't schedule big non conference games when the power 5 rather schedule cupcake teams. And of course there isn't much you can do about your own conference. You can't say that they will get crushed when they never had a chance to play them. Now if ucf gets thrown into the playoff and get crushed, that would end the debate about GO5 in playoffs. But the debate will continue until a team like them get in.
Dabney Langhorne I agree Some power 5s like Alabama wont play them because they would rather play teams like citadel but there some power 5 team that will Play decent out of conference games I just think that has to go both ways ...there in Florida they should at least try play one of the decent Florida teams at least once
@@tyreesetoomer13 I agree. I would love for them to do that but that may be Miami if any unless the SEC change the way they schedule games. I'm a Florida fan and Florida follows the typical SEC schedule. One tough non conference game and cupcake teams the other games. I'm not sure how the ACC does it but FSU had two or three tough conference per year but probably will not schedule ucf. Miami could squeeze them in. But then again, ucf is in a bad spot. They aren't considered a cupcake team but not big enough for the other teams to schedule them. They are in a black hole and I don't know the answer to solve this problem
Purdue is a lot better than their record. They beat Boston College! Also they were playing out of their minds on the big stage. They have some great young athletes that made plays. But most importantly, the game was much closer than the final score. Many of those TDs were garbage time because we were down in the 4th quarter and playing aggressively to try and get a turnover. The defense gives up big plays, but if they play more read and react (like against UM), OSU can hang with anyone. Oklahoma’s D is too bad to deserve a playoff run.
@@Codiggity369 For one, Maryland was 1 hilariously missed 2-pt conversion away from losing to Maryland. Second, no Purdue is not a lot better than their record. Yeah, they beat Boston College and destroyed Ohio State, but they also got ripped apart by Minnesota, made Wisconsin's passing game look semi-competent, and lost to effing Eastern Michigan.
FCS has had a playoff figured out for years without having bias coaches picking teams. Stop acting like you don’t know how to create a playoff just look one division over and do what they do.
@mr. Joseph, this ain't 2012! Think again! I GUARANTEE ND doesn't lose by 28pts to Bama! ND would probably still lose, but not by that much. Ur just bein a hater now
Even if teams may be flawed there are still a lot of good teams with 1-2 losses and not to mention conference champions that should get a chance to play for the national title. There aren't enough games in a college season to show who really deserves to be in a 4 team playoff, especially when 7-8 games are within the same conference. I still think it should be P5 champs make playoff with 3 at large spots. Undefeated G5 teams should always make those at large spots
The playoff needs to expand to at least give schools from smaller conferences a chance to get in. UCF is working on back to back undefeated seasons and can't even get a shot to compete for a national championship.
James Dishman exactly. It sucks and is clearly robbing them of a chance. People say their schedule well put them in and let’s see what they will do against a power 5 school. Last time they played one they beat Auburn sooo.
it sucks because those players have definitely earned it, but no team can do enough to prove they're one of the 4 best teams by playing a group of 5 schedule.
@@jaxsonlee10 If we had an expanded playoff format this wouldn't be a debate. Top teams get to play each other if you swap fluff games for competitive playoff games -> Who wants to watch top teams play rice, Tulsa, LA Tech, etc. It's better football.
Giving up a lot of points isn't a catastrophe if you're winning. That's basically saying "hey, I don't like the way they win". lol it's not golf, just getting more points is all that matters. Klatt is dead wrong
Will Ohio State make the playoffs this year?
The Herd with Colin Cowherd No I think Oklahoma will snag the fourth spot or Georgia makes it if they beat Alabama and Alabama gets the fourth spot
The Herd with Colin Cowherd Oklahoma sucks. Just watch their army game.
there is still a chance slim but a chance, never count out the Buckeyes till the final rankings are out, I am a Buckeyes fan and being real here, there are ways I think if Oklahoma wins narrowly we have to win by a score of 100-0 to get in highly unlikely again a very good northwestern team, Northwestern is way better than their record shows and I think that will be a tough game, but as a Buckeye fan since I knew what football was I have to keep my fingers crossed for an Oklahoma loss and a Buckeye win, but if it don't happen Oklahoma wise i will settle for a Rose bowl appearance, nothing to cry about with missing the playoff we still get an elite bowl game barring a win by my Buckeyes
It's possible. I'm a buckeyes fan and I'm hoping for it. I think Texas is going to beat Oklahoma. I don't think Oklahoma will beat them twice this season. Actually if I part of the committee I would keep Notre dame out of the final four until they join an actual conference instead being handed a cupcake schedule every year
Yes !!!
If these two had a show it would be the best thing on sports television.
Can’t be serious
it'll be close
Well, the bar is set very low so.... pretty easy to accomplish at the moment.
Yeah cause they actually talk about sports instead of yell at each other and talk about drama surrounding sports
Uhhhhhhhh no
Colin- I'm not about cool
Klatt- Clearly
Roasted
Typical Wednesday, Joel Klatt spitting straight facts
Facts like when he was gassing up Michigan last week
Except the idiotic narrative about an 8 team playoff ruining the season...
33moneyball except for the fact that it would
David Glass categorically incorrect...we would have more games that matter than we do now. And losses would matter just as much. You’d also be incentivizing tougher scheduling. This is the same dumb argument people made against a 4 team playoff...funny how those people evaporated.
33moneyball well i wasn’t on that train saying four was bad, and actually loses wouldn’t matter bc u could lose 2 and still have a chance at making it. also a tougher schedule wouldn’t matter bc there would be more spots so strength of schedule doesn’t matter therefore you have more teams playing the citadel
Wait, did Colin just say Oklahoma’s defense isn’t a catastrophe
Edit:Thanks for the 100 likes, that’s the most I’ve ever gotten
Good Boi Oklahoma’s defense isn’t a team...Oklahoma is. Yes the defense sucks....the team doesn’t get blown off the field. OSU does...end of story.
@@33moneyball the defense is catastrophic. If you say otherwise you're an idiot. And in that Texas game if Tom herman didn't go all conservative in the end they win by 20.
49-20 to Purdue is a catastrophe. OU losing by 3 to Texas is not a catastrophe.
@@trey4756 100% agree. Coming from an OU fan btw. Fans just can't be realistic when it comes to evaluating their team.
If Oklahoma recruited and coached up SEC level defensive players, you couldn’t touch them. Their only saving grace is that they play in the “ no defense” league. When you have to score 60 plus points to beat someone, a defense of any caliber can beat you.
Lmao that Principle analogy was out of left field.
Josh Got Juice sees like it’s from a past experience.... does Collin need to get something off his chest?
Josh Got Juice principal *
Worked tho. Lol
extrafreshhh listen grammar police, I was using text to speech :)
2:16 “ They lost by 29 to Purdont. “ LOL
Klatt looked straight into the camera to address us Michigan fans lol
It got real.
Make it a 64 team playoff
The playoffs would be on for months though.
300 team playoff
Yea, let everyone make it so it's fair
Christopher Alexander sarcasm isn’t your strong suit I take it
Alabama vs. Rutgers aw yeah
Wonder if Colin’s kids have to deal with all the memes that come from the show
His kids make the memes....lol.
16 Teams: NEVER!
Klatt has changed my friends
6 team playoff 3 plays 6
4 plays 5
Winners play 1 and 2
Than winners play
That’s my idea
That makes more sense
That’s a good idea
Dunk24 there is about 6 teams that can win it all. Twice a #4 seed one it. Bama Ohio State our of 4 times that’s 50% what does that say?
That’s the idea that CFP committee is putting into consideration.
Either that or a 5 team playoff
#1 gets a bye
2 plays 5
3 plays 4
Winner or 3 and 4 in the national championship
And # 1 plays winner of 1 and 5
What about a 6 team playoff just like NFL conferences? 1 and 2 get a bye, 3 plays 6, 4 plays 5 etc
34JROD34 exactly my thoughts. Oklahoma, Ohio state and Georgia all could argue are deserving of a chance to play for a championship. Not UCF, Michigan or 3-loss SEC teams
Naw no byes. Just add 2 more and let em all play to the title, or keep,it the same. It's currently working.
@@bradendavis5640 why doesn't UCF deserve a chance??? They have been undefeated for two years and last year beat the only team to beat alabama last year in their bowl game 🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
Six team playoff sounds more convincing to me
6 team playoffs, 1 and 2 get a bye week it's that easy. We always talk about top 6 teams, just put them in.
I enjoy how Klatt wins every debate against a guy who wrote a book.
It’s good to see that they’ve changed their opinion on the expanded playoff
Colin, are you still mourning the death of Kurt Cobain? It was 1994.
Layne Staley 2002, Mike Starr 2011 (2009?), Scott Weiland (2015), Cornell (2017)
He Is from the great city of Seattle
I don't get it? Did i miss something about Kurt in this video?
@@maxkuzela9745 He said in the video he holds old traditions and said specifically 1994. That was the only conection, just a joke.
@@bootitup6927 Ahhh gotcha. I mean he is kind of a Nirvana/Kurt fan so yeah.
My problem is that a 1 loss team shouldn’t be left out. Because then no one can ever make a mistake. And most years there is a 1 loss team at 5 or 6 that should be included
No there isn’t... every year there are 4 clear teams.. keep it at 4
I keep repeating myself, but man are these two so fun to watch
Yeah, because a four-team CFP is working out so well. No controversy at all.
Should do a six team playoff. Top two get a buy
Bye
What they buying?
Clemson really blasted ND by 4 touchdowns 😂😂😂
I love that they cut Joel talking about Mayfield at the end. Come on Colin, don't try to hide it.
You actually think Colin edits the videos?
6 or 8 team playoff would be FANTASTIC
No one will ever convince me that a slightly bigger playoff (yet still smaller by orders of magnitude than EVERY OTHER level of football)...is a bad thing.
Valen Sinclair it effects the athletes because it stretches the football season out and increases the chance of injury and the deadline to withdraw from the draft Is around January and they don’t wanna enter the draft it’s to much risk .... there’s a video where Joel explains it better on the herd
@@tyreesetoomer13 so remove conference championships, make it a 12 game season, and make it a 6-8 team tournament. for the natty.
i disco that’d just ruin the point of conferences then
@ITHEREONETHATHASNT you were tied at the half against the Citadel. Any given Saturday.
@ITHEREONETHATHASNT just pointing out that a nobody FCS school was competitive with you for a full half, and UCF is a far better team than The Citadel. I'll agree that Alabama is very good and probably would beat UCF, but to cast them aside in such an ignorant manner isn't wise. Upsets can happen.
6 team playoff with 1 & 2 getting a bye in the first round solves everything
8 team playoff allows for all power 5 conference champs, the best group of 5 team, and the next two best teams which sounds a lot better to me
I love Klatt, but he’s totally wrong about an 8 team playoff. I’d love to watch that, tons of people would... Or even a 6 team playoff with 1&2 seeds getting a bye.
The argument for 8 team playoffs is that most of these kids will NEVER play in the pros, so give them the experience of trying for a national title. Realistically, no #8 will win, but if one does, then they deserved it. March Madness never produces a true surprise, but if it did, it would be a blast & the process would legitimize the winner. Same thing. Let's do 8.
I'm not going to the NFL either, so does my team that plays at the park every Sunday get a shot?
Remember when they picked on Ohio state for loosing to VT at home???? Championship
I dont understand why an 8 team playoff would be a bad thing. Prove youre the champ lol.
“Kliff Kingsbury’s good looking” - Cowherd
“Yes he is, one of the few guys I blush in front of” - Klatt
An 8-team playoffs would be amazing!! It would shut the mouths of analysts and let these teams resolve it on the field. Best time in sports? March Madness! Why not bring the playoffs to CFB?
6 at the most. i want my regular season games to mean something. if it were 8 and lsu didnt lose to a&m, their game would've been meaningless
Who was Stanford Offensive Coordinator when Jim had Andrew Luck at Stanford?
But everyone loves March madness tournament which gives 64 teams a shot at the national title, 8 teams would not be a bad thing, would definitely make it more interesting than seeing the same 4-5 teams in the playoff every year
6 team playoff like NFL conferences, byes for 1&2.
"No a catastrophe is losing to Army" I laughed so hard at this 💀💀
BBALL Highlights isn’t Army in the Top 25?
Yes! Thank you for listening to my request. But its crazy to think people are against an 8 team playoff format. Literally people keep debating about these teams. Let them play each other so the debates can be settled! But none of these good teams can play each other, because we have the not playoffs, and multiple undefeated teams have no chance at even playing good teams. If im wrong, maybe a 6 team playoff would be good
4-20 team conferences with 10 team divisions that play a full round robin like the big 12 and then 4 conference champions that play in the playoff.
I don’t get why people get on ND , has anybody taken into consideration that in the last month alone, ND traveled almost 3,700 miles and still managed to win all those games? yes, I admit the USC game wasn’t pretty but when you’ve traveled so much.. can you blame them for not coming out 100% against a ready to play USC?
Colin:Michigan is a cold weather state
Me( I live in Michigan): Why is it so hot in November
189 in the last month if you haven’t heard😂😂😂😂
An 8 team playoff is the only way you are going to get a fair playoff system
I would be interested to hear their discussion about the current season.
I'm a huge Michigan fan and I love Harbough
Joel steady schoolin' Colin about CFB, LOVE IT! Nothing like seeing and hear Colin sayin' "Aww C'Mon!!" lol
I agree... I wonder what they think about michigan being ranked above michigan st. atm even tho michigan st. beat them..
Best team from each power 5, the best non-power 5, and 2 wildcards. That would be my favorite playoff format
Zachary T Alabama
Clemson
Notre Dame
Oklahoma
Ohio State
Georgia
WashU
UCF
We need 8 team playoff in college football
Why do people always skip a 6 team playoff and go straight to 8. It is fair because each power 5 champ gets in and there is a chance for an at large bid for a team like UCF! Every regular season game still matters which is what makes college football better then the NFL, and conf champs aren’t left out due to a stupid committees subjective opinions.
If Oklahoma, Georgia and Ohio State loose the 4 spot is for UCF
Great chemistry between these two.
It's all about money. I say Alabama, Clemson and ND get a bye and the one loss teams have a playoff (or Play-in) to see who gets to go to the dance.
If Oklahoma went to Purdue, they would've pushed 100 points vs OKLA
and oklahoma would put up 110
The gophers scored 41 on Purdue...
You think Purdues offense is better than WV???
Joe Odenwald there better than Kansas....
@@TheKalebWard barely better. Not by much if thry played it would be a coin toss who won.
Go go go go. Gotta keep running
what about 6 team college football playoff? First two seeds get a bye?
It should be a 6 team playoff
I would love to see 8 teams...conference champs. 3 wild card...something similar to NFL's playoff
Guys I am a Michigan fan attend a Michigan high school and there are Michigan, OSU, Mich St, And Notre Dame fans there And all of the Michigan fans(including me) love Harbaugh at top 5-10 and the only people who think he is bad are the Michigan state Ohio st and ND fans
Harbaugh didnt win a confrence title at Stanford?
Nope! 2010 they went 11-1 and lost to Oregon who was conference champs!
6 team playoff is the way to go, no one misses out and teams that don’t deserve to get in won’t get in.
6 team playoff would be the beat. Usually the top 2 seeds separate themselves from everyone else and the other 4 spots would be competitive. Top 2 seeds get a bye
I love Colin! Him and PTI are must watch! After them, then Skip and Shannon. But Colin? That's my dude!
Just make the playoffs like an nfl conference, six teams in with 1&2 getting a bye
My only point is that Conference Championship games have to mean something. The only way is for those P5 conference champs to get automatic bids which would mean 8 team playoffs. You can the choose from 3 at large teams.
I take a shot every time Klatt references the book lol
I just don't like the big gap from this Saturday to January 1st and then a few weeks is a championship game
“Okalahoma wouldn’t lose 29 to Purdue”. You’re right. Oklahoma would’ve lost by 49
“Maybe you need to make a change.”- klatt lol!!!!
Off topic but that "Oculus Go" commercial is like nails on a chalkboard. I always have to turn the volume down before any youtube sports video. Already makes me miss the Peyton and Brad Nationwide commercials which were annoying as well ..
Dude an 8 team playoff would be so good
Why not try a 6 team playoff ?
I honestly wouldn’t mind a play in game for #4
Make it a six team playoff
Florida and Texas aren’t an argument for an 8 team playoff though... it’s a very clear cut 8 teams right now, and if you’re telling me UCF at 8 is debated with the #9, 3 loss Florida team and the #15, 3 loss Texas team- I don’t buy it.
Purdue was 3-0 vs ranked teams. A catastrophe is Clemson losing to a team that only beat one other power 5 team last year, but getting an invite anyway as champ of the weakest of the power 5
8-team playoff is great. In NCAA basketball the 16 seeds could never win the championship, so all the teams that could win, are in. With 8 teams in football, the chance the 8 seed could win, is low. So at least all the teams that could win, have a chance.
Klatt vs Colin like OU vs Citadel......Close at half then Klatt stomps Colin out Tua style
I don't watch college football because barely any games mean anything once you lose, but I would watch a playoff 4sure no matter how many teams more the better.
The only way this gets fixed is if they do it the same way they do in college basketball or change it to an NFL style playoff system. I'm a firm believer in "any given Sunday" so I'd prefer the NFL style playoff system overall because it gives more teams a chance at a championship.
If we had an 8 team playoff it should look similar to this (with no upsets)
#1 Alabama (SEC Champs) v. #8 Washington (Pac-12 Champs)
#2 Clemson (ACC Champs) v. #7 UCF (Undefeated Group of 5)
#3 Notre Dame (Undefeated) v. #6 Michigan/Georgia (At-Large bid) which would be the only one debatable
#4 Oklahoma (Big 12 Champs) v. #5 Ohio State (Big 10 Champs)
Seeding based on ranking with each conference champs in. Group of 5 would only get in if they go undefeated.
I think this could really work. They were still arguing like the 8 team playoff would stay in the current system. With an 8 team playoff, the system would have to change in order for it to work.
Dabney Langhorne there just saying nobody wants to see UCF get in with that easy schedule and get demolished by Clemson ...when Clemson whole Dline is first round picks
@@tyreesetoomer13 every FBS school deserves a shot at a national title. It kind of hard to not be deserving of a chance when you go undefeated with a schedule you have no control over. They can't schedule big non conference games when the power 5 rather schedule cupcake teams. And of course there isn't much you can do about your own conference. You can't say that they will get crushed when they never had a chance to play them. Now if ucf gets thrown into the playoff and get crushed, that would end the debate about GO5 in playoffs. But the debate will continue until a team like them get in.
Dabney Langhorne I agree Some power 5s like Alabama wont play them because they would rather play teams like citadel but there some power 5 team that will Play decent out of conference games I just think that has to go both ways ...there in Florida they should at least try play one of the decent Florida teams at least once
Lol at Ala sec champs. Ala not all that they didnt play nobody but lSU the whole season. Ga can beat them. J.s.
@@tyreesetoomer13 I agree. I would love for them to do that but that may be Miami if any unless the SEC change the way they schedule games. I'm a Florida fan and Florida follows the typical SEC schedule. One tough non conference game and cupcake teams the other games. I'm not sure how the ACC does it but FSU had two or three tough conference per year but probably will not schedule ucf. Miami could squeeze them in. But then again, ucf is in a bad spot. They aren't considered a cupcake team but not big enough for the other teams to schedule them. They are in a black hole and I don't know the answer to solve this problem
They should make an 8 playoff team reason being if you win your conference you should have automatic bid to the college football playoff.
If you don’t expand Klatt how do you deal with flaws of the committee?
Purdue is a lot better than their record. They beat Boston College! Also they were playing out of their minds on the big stage. They have some great young athletes that made plays. But most importantly, the game was much closer than the final score. Many of those TDs were garbage time because we were down in the 4th quarter and playing aggressively to try and get a turnover. The defense gives up big plays, but if they play more read and react (like against UM), OSU can hang with anyone. Oklahoma’s D is too bad to deserve a playoff run.
Also Maryland beat Texas (2 years in a row) and Texas’s best Oklahoma. Texas is not that good and OK also almost lost to army.
@@Codiggity369 For one, Maryland was 1 hilariously missed 2-pt conversion away from losing to Maryland. Second, no Purdue is not a lot better than their record. Yeah, they beat Boston College and destroyed Ohio State, but they also got ripped apart by Minnesota, made Wisconsin's passing game look semi-competent, and lost to effing Eastern Michigan.
Maryland lost to Maryland?? Might wanna read that again bud and then take a hike @@SuperSparrow45
Collin needs to spend 20 minutes each with Klatt, Broussard, Parker, and a couple of his other FS1 guests. These segments are golden.
Klatt needs his own show. Speaking facts as always
FCS has had a playoff figured out for years without having bias coaches picking teams. Stop acting like you don’t know how to create a playoff just look one division over and do what they do.
Easily The best segment of the show when Klatt comes on .
With these two, I don't say this much, but Colin was 100% right in the first take about Oklahome v Ohio State lmao. Hi from 2021!!
Bold prediction ND beats clemson 31-27
If that were to happen then I'll go with the low hanging fruit: Alabama spanks ND 42-14 in the championship game.
@mr. Joseph, this ain't 2012! Think again! I GUARANTEE ND doesn't lose by 28pts to Bama! ND would probably still lose, but not by that much. Ur just bein a hater now
Even if teams may be flawed there are still a lot of good teams with 1-2 losses and not to mention conference champions that should get a chance to play for the national title. There aren't enough games in a college season to show who really deserves to be in a 4 team playoff, especially when 7-8 games are within the same conference. I still think it should be P5 champs make playoff with 3 at large spots. Undefeated G5 teams should always make those at large spots
Oklahoma lost to Texas who lost to Maryland. Also, Oklahoma gives up 40 points a game.
Div II and III organize an entire 32 team bracket there's no reason Div I can't do 8 or even 16
4:33, Those match ups actually look pretty good, and it would also hush up many complainers
I say a 6 team playoff and the 6 seed will be my GATORS!
I’ve noticed that there is normally 6 teams that can be in the playoff so why not make it six teams
Give each P5 conference champion a auto bid, give one G5 ranked in the Top 15 a autobid, and then 2 at large spots.
The playoff needs to expand to at least give schools from smaller conferences a chance to get in. UCF is working on back to back undefeated seasons and can't even get a shot to compete for a national championship.
James Dishman exactly. It sucks and is clearly robbing them of a chance. People say their schedule well put them in and let’s see what they will do against a power 5 school. Last time they played one they beat Auburn sooo.
Im Nxtion correction: last one they played is Pitt. An ACC division champion that almost beat Notre Dame. And they SMOKED Pitt
it sucks because those players have definitely earned it, but no team can do enough to prove they're one of the 4 best teams by playing a group of 5 schedule.
Because they're UCF. They wouldn't be undefeated if they played in a power 5., except maybe the big 12.
@@jaxsonlee10 If we had an expanded playoff format this wouldn't be a debate. Top teams get to play each other if you swap fluff games for competitive playoff games -> Who wants to watch top teams play rice, Tulsa, LA Tech, etc. It's better football.
Giving up a lot of points isn't a catastrophe if you're winning. That's basically saying "hey, I don't like the way they win". lol it's not golf, just getting more points is all that matters. Klatt is dead wrong