Session Horns Pro vs The Real Deal! HD

Me and my band are recording our song Keep The Fire once again for our new upcoming album with real horns this time! I like the new horns, but I find the session horns pro sounding really good! Thats is why I thought I could do a comparison. Anyway, the arrangement is slightly different and the tempo is 1 bpm different. Bare in mind that the new version with the real horns are not mixed ready at all! Just premixed for recording the horns in another studio. But what do you guys think?
The horns consists of a tenor sax, a trombone and a trumpet. The sax was recorded through a Neumann u87, the trumpet through a Sennheiser 441 and the Trombone through a sennheiser Md-416. They are dubbed once for fatness ;)