I was thinking it would be cool if they included the sisters in the song. Maybe have them harmonize or playing instruments instead of just having them sitting on turtles, especially since music seemed almost part of mermaid culture in the original. Plus it gives them something more to do, and it helps sell dolls since that’s all Disney really cares about
Man putting it side by side really shows you how far Disney has fallen. I’m glad my daughter is 2. When she’s old enough, I plan on just showing her the originals.
One thing I love about the original, is that Sebastian doesn’t notice Ariel’s gone because HE’S gotten carried away by the song, it’s THAT fun, that hectic, and most of all? It speaks to his character. He LOVES the sea, and everything in it, he genuinely cannot understand why Ariel would ever want to go to the surface. It’s not just the voice actor convincing you that this crab loves what he does, it’s so convincing you BELIEVE that Sebastian adores his surroundings and way of life. That’s acting.
The worst thing about this to me isn't having Ariel sing. That could have potentially worked if they had tweaked the scene a bit. The worst thing for me is having her sing and stick around for the last verse, then
Im no expert by ANY means but like. When my highschool did little mermaid and i played Sebastian, it was hammered into our heads OVER and OVER and OVER again just how important it was that this song be energetic and FUN and colorful. We would have whole days of rehearsal where we'd just do under the sea over and over again until every single person in the cast was breathing as much life into is as they could, until every move and line felt fresh and exciting and just. Putting all that work in and knowing what you need to make under the sea so good even in a highschool production and then turning around and seeing DISNEYS OFFICIAL REMAKE version be so devoid of color and excitement makes me so upset 😭
You know, having Ariel sing to it might have worked if it was shown somehow that she was trying to fool Sebastian into thinking that she was wavering, but there's nothing to indicate this, so it doesn't work. Her voice is lovely, but like you, I found it baffling.
Ariels voice in the remake honestly clashes with the reggae sound of the song. Its not just that its out of character, but it also doesnt blend with the song itself which is very offputting
I thought Daveed Diggs’ portrayal of Sebastian was flat altogether. I was really disappointed that they left out Sebastian being the kingdom’s grand musical conductor. Also, I agree Ariel singing along defeats the purpose of the song. I felt it was unnecessary
This song wasn’t just a fun little jingle to pad runtime. It was what made Ariel realize that no one was going to listen to her. Sebastian wasn’t trying to convince her. He doesn’t respect her like that. He was trying to scold her, invalidating her desire to leave.
Ariel enjoying the song DRIVES ME INSANE. She's irritated at the beginning and then leaves entirely, which also neuters the end of the song in the new version. Original crescendo and BAM Ariel's gone is a shocking reveal that is emphasized by the song.
I've always loved Disney and these golden movies, but I never even realized how genius they actually were. These little, subtle details, bold decisions and outstanding performances. A true inspiration, rest in peace, dear Disney company, thanks for making our childhood a brighther time.
Ariel singing along with Sebastian seems to be inspired by Kingdom Hearts II, where the same happens. The problem is that the KHII scene has a completely different context from the original movie: in the game, the song is meant to be part of a big concert which Ariel is supposed to take part in, so she's just singing her part, and she gets into it just because Sora, who's a big friend of hers in this universe, is there to cheer her up. The part towards the end, where Sora and Ariel dance together, is very wholesome.
Still don't get why Sebastian is a land-dwelling ghost crab with the swimming legs of a different crab family attached to his rear end, singing about being under the water where he cannot survive. The ghost crab is a obligate land crab which may help him in the land scenes, but he would not be a fan of the water
I was thinking it would be cool if they included the sisters in the song. Maybe have them harmonize or playing instruments instead of just having them sitting on turtles, especially since music seemed almost part of mermaid culture in the original. Plus it gives them something more to do, and it helps sell dolls since that’s all Disney really cares about
Man putting it side by side really shows you how far Disney has fallen. I’m glad my daughter is 2. When she’s old enough, I plan on just showing her the originals.
One thing I love about the original, is that Sebastian doesn’t notice Ariel’s gone because HE’S gotten carried away by the song, it’s THAT fun, that hectic, and most of all? It speaks to his character. He LOVES the sea, and everything in it, he genuinely cannot understand why Ariel would ever want to go to the surface. It’s not just the voice actor convincing you that this crab loves what he does, it’s so convincing you BELIEVE that Sebastian adores his surroundings and way of life. That’s acting.
The worst thing about this to me isn't having Ariel sing. That could have potentially worked if they had tweaked the scene a bit. The worst thing for me is having her sing and stick around for the last verse, then
Im no expert by ANY means but like. When my highschool did little mermaid and i played Sebastian, it was hammered into our heads OVER and OVER and OVER again just how important it was that this song be energetic and FUN and colorful. We would have whole days of rehearsal where we'd just do under the sea over and over again until every single person in the cast was breathing as much life into is as they could, until every move and line felt fresh and exciting and just. Putting all that work in and knowing what you need to make under the sea so good even in a highschool production and then turning around and seeing DISNEYS OFFICIAL REMAKE version be so devoid of color and excitement makes me so upset 😭
You know, having Ariel sing to it might have worked if it was shown somehow that she was trying to fool Sebastian into thinking that she was wavering, but there's nothing to indicate this, so it doesn't work. Her voice is lovely, but like you, I found it baffling.
Samuel E Wright absolutely SLAYED Under the Sea in the original film! Daveed Diggs just doesn't have the same energy.
Ariels voice in the remake honestly clashes with the reggae sound of the song. Its not just that its out of character, but it also doesnt blend with the song itself which is very offputting
I thought Daveed Diggs’ portrayal of Sebastian was flat altogether. I was really disappointed that they left out Sebastian being the kingdom’s grand musical conductor. Also, I agree Ariel singing along defeats the purpose of the song. I felt it was unnecessary
The original one gives me chills.. something about the animated movie is PURE MAGIC
This song wasn’t just a fun little jingle to pad runtime. It was what made Ariel realize that no one was going to listen to her. Sebastian wasn’t trying to convince her. He doesn’t respect her like that. He was trying to scold her, invalidating her desire to leave.
OG Ariel: Visibly pissed off and disappointed that nobody cared about anything she has to say.
fun fact: sabastian in the remake is a crab that'd die underwater
Ariel enjoying the song DRIVES ME INSANE. She's irritated at the beginning and then leaves entirely, which also neuters the end of the song in the new version. Original crescendo and BAM Ariel's gone is a shocking reveal that is emphasized by the song.
I've always loved Disney and these golden movies, but I never even realized how genius they actually were. These little, subtle details, bold decisions and outstanding performances. A true inspiration, rest in peace, dear Disney company, thanks for making our childhood a brighther time.
4:47
Ariel singing along with Sebastian seems to be inspired by Kingdom Hearts II, where the same happens. The problem is that the KHII scene has a completely different context from the original movie: in the game, the song is meant to be part of a big concert which Ariel is supposed to take part in, so she's just singing her part, and she gets into it just because Sora, who's a big friend of hers in this universe, is there to cheer her up. The part towards the end, where Sora and Ariel dance together, is very wholesome.
Still don't get why Sebastian is a land-dwelling ghost crab with the swimming legs of a different crab family attached to his rear end, singing about being under the water where he cannot survive. The ghost crab is a obligate land crab which may help him in the land scenes, but he would not be a fan of the water
This number was so awkward in theaters
2:46