Roy Keane: 'If they want a comedian they can get somebody else' | UCFB-LMA Insight Series
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лис 2019
- UCFB is a world first in sports education, offering university degrees in the football and sports industry. We provide an exceptional environment to live and learn in, with state-of-the-art facilities in two inspirational campuses in London and Manchester, which have the iconic Wembley and Etihad stadiums at their heart.
Find out more:
www.ucfb.ac.uk/
/ ucfb
/ ucfbuk
/ ucfb
The one dislike is from Keano himself for nearly smiling
Haha
Could be eamon dunphy.
Haha!
24 now, keano brought his family.
the other 39 are from Haarlands family.
I think keano is the funniest pundit in TV.
His dry wit and his own expectations of people are brilliant to watch.
His comedy timing is better than 90% of professional comedians.
In a world of snowflakes, Roy Keane is a bright ray of sunshine.
Chill ya shit with ya poetry Greg
That melts them all away.
He's the world leader the right wing needs.
Don't you think that Roy has bought into his own personality-cult a bit? Think about the tagline for this video - "If they want a comedian, then they can get somebody else....."
Oh, come on, Roy, you know perfectly well that people watch you because they find your acerbic comments AMUSING. People dig videos of Roy Keane because when he says something brutally critical, the brutality is amusing. Roy plays to the gallery with that stuff, and he knows it.... So he is very deliberately being a comedian sometimes, and he knows it, which means that in this video, he's bullshitting us and bullshitting himself.
People don't watch Roy Keane's punditry because it's more analytical than other pundits - it isn't. People watch Roy Keans's punditry because Roy lays his edgy personality on super-thick. It's a personality-cult. Truth be told, Roy's "football-analysis" is just about as detail-lite and banal as anybody else's. But he can pretend to be the great truth-teller by just exaggerating the "me and my edgy personality" thing.
As for his comment about "getting rid of all that player-power nonsense....."
Ahem,.....
Ah, does the place-name "Saipan" ring any bells, Roy?
I don't think that Roy is necessarily the best man to criticize "player-power."
To be honest, I strongly suspect that being a pundit has been pretty bad for Roy's mental health, because he doesn't even understand that he's playing a role. He reminds me of something which the anthropologist Tomas de Zengotita wrote in a book about media-culture. He wrote "Like everybody else, you've become so good at playing yourself that you've forgotten it's an act."
@@padraigmcgrath3876 Reading too much into it. Guy's a great pundit, he's the blunt old school fella and people enjoy him. It's his job, he leans into the character a bit sometimes and I'm pretty sure he's doing it on purpose.
The world needs more Roy Keanes...You'd follow him into battle wouldn't you.
jim lennon absolutely. Oh captain my captain!
There's a town called Battle in kent. Id follow him there if there was something in it for me . nothing more than that though.
jim lennon you would top footballer
@@johnsmith-wx5fb East sussex even
@@trainedobserver3972 your training has served you well
One of the best pundit ever.. an honest and honourable man
Honest? An honest pundit would actually talk about what's happening in the football-match he's been paid to watch, instead of just giving it loads of attitude and laying his edgy oersonality on thick.
I can't remember the last time Roy actually had anything concrete to say as a football-pundit, apart from "I'm so edgy, I'm so edgy, I'm so edgy....."
To be fair to him, a big part of it is the bullshit-culture surrounding football in England. Even guys with FA coaching-badges sometimes know surprisingly little about the technical nuts'n'bolts of the game of football. A guy with an FA coaching-badge once led me through how he would run half-time in a dressing-room. He said "Well, I'd isolate 2 or 3 players who needed to be pumped up or psychologically worked on, and I'd hand 2 of them over to the assistant-coaches, and work with one myself...."
So I asked him "But how many minutes do you set aside for tactical instructions?"
"None," he said.
"Let me get this straight," I said, "You've got an FA coaching-badge, but receiving that accreditation required you to know more about pop-psychology than about the technical nuts'n'bolts of the game of football....You'll spend ALL of half time playing the role of Mr.Motivator, getting players pumped, but WHERE'S THE FUCKING FOOTBALL? This would be like a company where the head of the finance department runs a team of accountants, but doesn't know anything about accounting himself - his only qualification for the job is knowing pop-psychology....Any company which ran its finance department like that would go bankrupt very fucking quickly....."
And if it's true of qualified coaches in England, then it's definitely true of pundits, including Roy Keane. They'll talk about players being "motivated." They'll talk about "problems in the camp." They'll talk about the temperamental frailties of "the modern player." Blah, blah, blah..... The whole discussion is polluted by pop-psychology. Nobody's actually talking about the game of football. And Roy is as guilty of that banal pop-psych bullshit as the rest of the pundits in England.
Roy, you are an amazing pundit. One of the best ever!
See shows what sort of man Keane is he’s fell out with fergie but yet he still tell the truth about how good of manager he was
From a Leeds fan 👏👍
@@peterkent1582 So what he should say nothing,and let old red nose talk Shit!
@@peterkent1582 would it have ended like it did if keane was 25 ?
@@peterkent1582 keanes contract was up wasnt it ? I think they didnt want to offer him the huge contract that as captain and for his service keane probably felt he deserved, i wonder how many other times keane did this on mutv ? Because to meit seems set up seeing the way keane speaks his mind as a pundit , fergie knew that keane would give him the ammunition
Keano. Legend. Give this man his own football show on tv.
1:40 If they want a Comedian?? Keane could have his own Stand Up comedy slot on Skyports roasting all the poor performers of the previous weekends games. Top man Roy Keane. Funny and serious 👍
Schmichael was overrated!! :D Sooooooooo funny!!
Best captain manchester united ever had , he was hard on him self and team mates,but thats what united dont have now.....
Along with bryan robson and cantona !!! Dont forget them 2 !
Him and Bryan Robson were the best captains Utd had
Keane was something else no comparison
RK wife "Darling your dinner is ready, have you had a nice day?
RK "Utter nonsense"
"Yeah but thats your job. Just keep it simple, stick to the basics".
Hahaha I'm his cousin but I know he would laugh at this
Class interview, there is something really endearing about Roy Keane's character. I think it's the fact you know he is going to say exactly what he thinks.
Love Roy Keane
Top bloke 👍
It’s a shame there’s no players like him these days
Roy "keep it simple" Keane.
What a legend how man utd treated him is shocking I think hes exactly the charachter united need as our manager now a true leader and inspirer of men
ssmmaacca hes failed at every club he’s tried to manage tho
@@cousinleigh1470 he got sunderland promoted and kept them up so you're wrong there
Cousin needs to learn to use google a bit.....
ssmmaacca
and he gets united relegated if he was manager Roy is better as if he was manager of cork fc first see if he is able to be top manager
cousin leigh he done well at Sunderland
As a Liverpool fan, I fuckin love Roy Keane he played the game as its meant to be played with passion aggression and non of this touchy Feely shaking hands in the tunnel bollocks. He tells it how is and if you don't like it? a genuine bloke and the kind of person I'm much more comfortable with as opposed to the social media loving fakery of most people these days.
Put simply Roy Keane was consistently the best performer that the PL has ever seen! No-one scored higher out of 10 per game over a 10 year plus period as Roy Keane. No-one.................
He's also the best Captain the PL has ever seen with the best record of success in terms of trophies.
There isn't a player alive or dead with the drive and determination of Roy Keane.
Please note I'm not saying he was the most talented player-although he was immense in that department to. Other players like Le Tissier, Scholes, Zola, Cantona etc were more talented but none of them scored as high out of 10 per game over 12 years of PL football as Keano!!!
Great analysis pal 👍
The greatest midfield player the Premier league has ever seen.
But he also made the rest of the team consistent because be wouldnt allow standards to drop
The greatest player of his generation. And a hero to all.
What a player. He was unbelievable. Just the best we've seen in this country. And we will never see his likes again.
He was a great player. Greatest of his generation? Hell no :D
Thug
Best midfield general of our generation..no doubt
As a united fan born in 89, I have had a deep love for this man as long as I can remember
Great interview. Haven't seen him that open in a while. Especially opening up on the book. Well done.
One of the few blokes who absolutely speaks his mind and doesn’t care who he offends.
Best pundit we've had in years by far.
love this man. such a breath of fresh air on tele
Love Keano football legend any young kid listening to Roy Keane can learn so much about attitude how to win how to dedicate yourself he's so right the things he says and is so professional love him amazing guy
thanks, good to see this side of Roy.
Still had my best away days under this fella at sunderland would love him back one day.
That was pretty good. G'wan Keano ya legend!
He is a natural comedian... intelligent man.
simply straight to the point no nonsense just pure honesty what you see with keano is what you get other pundits just tell you what you want to hear
Other pundits tell you what they think you want to hear. Roy tells it how it is whether you like it or not.
Top top player, probably the best captain ever in the premier league. Never has a captain been so influential.
Any player that played ok, is so happy to hear it, from roy Keane.
Most stand up guy in football! Love ya Keano!
It’s called a wry smile. Love Keano. Legend of the game.
Always been a fan of Roy Keane. That book was killer as well the second one with Roddy Doyle.
Being a fan from day one,that will never change legend
Seems to have evolved! Always an interesting man
Brilliant player outstanding man total respect for the man that always gave 100% so funny with that cork humour
LEGEND KEANO. THEY DON'T MAKE EM LIKE YOU ANYMORE. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU DID FOR OUR UNITED. 😈
Class act that bloke, I could listen to him for hours and not get bored.
Listen to his book on audible, THE SECOND HALF, brilliant
@@davidkavanagh8175 cheers pal, will do👍
Inspiring figure. We need such people who speak there mind - in all walks of life.
Keane is actually quality as part of the pundit team, he has an amazing sense of humour! I could watch him all day talking about football lol.
LEGEND
When I saw Keane get Sunderland promoted i thought he might be the manager at United one day. Winning promotion is a major achievement in my book. I expected him to become one of the best. Has not happened yet. Still time though. I also would like him to be director of football at MUFC. Signing big money flops has been a big part of the problems at United for the last few years. No bullsh!tters would get past an interview with Keane. There is a big Scots roadblock to Keane rejoining MUFC. Pity. I think he also would win elections in Ireland in a landslide. What's it called taoiseach?
Owner was clueless expecting to finish top 6 with a championship team he had enough and walked. I would love him back one day what a bloke
I would love to have him back at Sunderland
Taoiseach is like the Prime Minister
He's a bloody footballer, not a politician you crackhead!
I'd still vote for him tho
Christy Dolan your one of those type of Irish people I guess the type of Irish with that type of personality it gets no where and it’s the type that’s false. Can you tell me how many fights Roy Keane has had?? Can you tell me when he has had arguments a time when he had every right to say how he feels? People mistake passion for trouble and they want everyone to be sheep! Your that type of man the type of man who thinks everyone should toe the line and just live with whatever is going on. The type of man who his gf thinks is dependable as he has everything in order but she cheats on all the time for a bit of life and it’s all because your that type of man
Roy is always loved in my Family great player 100 everytime out
Legend
My names Roy Keane! He Goes by the name of Keano a class act!
Real footballer ..class ..Passionate as..Legend
Productive 11min.. Thanks keane :)
Kean 1 of the best people I like in football, widh you all the and hope see him manager of Manchester United 1 day..
He is sp complicaedly Irish.. love you roy.
Master class
Legend Roy
You have to love Roy Keane ❤ he's almost as big a Brian Clough fan as i am....almost!!!
legend
Legend roy
Liverpool supporter also,hes a top class man as he was a footballer.born winner. Good honest opinions and hes usually right
There will not be another Zidane for 770 years . Feel blessed for being alive the same time as the great man . A truly magnificent player . Arguably the best ever .
I’m a lfc fan...Roy Keane should be manu manager...he’s awesome
Know what could listen to Roy KEANE all day hes brilliant amazing person soooooo sad the way he was treated by Ferguson he gave him his Sir he won so many matches for him singlehandedly would never forgive Ferguson for that old saying eaten bread soon forgotten
The thing is Keane cracks me up more than any other pundit.
Surprisingly a nice side to Keane in this interview.
Cant help watching roy funny and engaging top man
Roy is destined to manage Manchester United one day....God willing. 🙏🏼
I would absolutely love that i
No he isn't.
@@iamnotyou1609 Remember, no spaces before the exclamation mark.
He has the passion but don’t think the world work his way anymore, unfortunately.
@C Klan nonsense
Never change Roy
Top man Roy KEANE👌👌👌👌
What a champion
All time favourite footballer
"particularly from bad players" haha
Keane is a Boss
Top man one of the best
Keane ... bleed man United, breathed man United,, intense but true, wish they were more, heart on his sleeve, needed desperately now at man United, try to bring back that passion
People like Roy keane should be celebrated in society
Never used to like him but can listen to him all day. Funny as well. 😉
Roy so true
He was one of our best and most professional players and we screwed that up so lesser men could feel good about themselves.
got nothing but respect for roy
What a legend 🇮🇪👊
The thing is Keane has a great sense of humour and is funny as well as serious at the right times
Une legende !!!
Keane's not even 50 yet - would still be a relatively young manager if he got a start somewhere next season.
I don't think there's a club in existence that'd give him another go. He's a shite manager and a very disruptive coach.
Joe Bish your talking bish! It’s not his fault his last team were no good
@@dondamon4669 Well, let's see if anyone gives him a chance and if someone does, let's see how successful he is.
@@joebish6629 I think he's just too old school and stubborn in his ways to morph into the kind of managers teams need now. As he said, players have too much power and I'd imagine if he insulted some of them, they wouldn't be too long kicking up a fuss.
Just like he said, PLAYERS get any, off too days, MANAGERS. SACKED 😮. Great interview 👍
Top man
he is a good man
He is so direct and brutally honest you believe every word he says
did he appreciate ppl being brutally honest with him?, no so with Alex .
@@dinogove lol he was certainly thin skinned but he didnt hide it or cowered.
I reckon he is quite simply the best pundit out there!!!!!!!!
Captain Keano
*Roy’s conscience: “I’m acting a bit serious”*
Roy to himself: “That’s my job”
Fresh
Keano !!!!!!!!!
I think Ole should appoint Keane as his assistant at Utd, if the players step out of line or are underperforming, Ole can send them to Roy.
That would only work if the players respected him and really cared about United and how Roy was an in important part in one of the most successful periods the club has been in.
It wouldn’t work as Keane is a MAN players today are pretty boy snowflakes so if Keane shouted at any of them the dummy would be spat out and they would sulk for weeks
As much as I like keano he isn't level headed enough for management.
He contradicts himself constantly and struggles to manage players.
Utd will never touch him, not until fergie is dead and buried anyway.
Ole won't do that as Roy is the alpha male of those 2
The Best thing Utd could do would be to give this lad his chance to manage them, what have to lose.
Like the music
I always found it's easier to get on with straight talking people. I think I'd like to be with Roy Kesne
Keano!
Keane passes to Owen....OH...AND OWEN MISSES! ...KEANE IS RAGING AT OWEN!
white dove haha fancy seeing you here
@@owens164 Keano said hed beat me up if i didnt watch this.
Would love to see Roy Keane manage united. The players would be afraid of him and afraid to let him down. Do you think the players are scared of ole? I very much doubt it.
lol pogba would not be afraid of keane. players know now adays if they are a star they have more power than the manager.look what pogba did the mourihno who is one of tge best managers ever.
Roy Keane carries everyone else. Roy start your own offering. You are prime to go independent!
A lot off players might not want to play for him possibly may be a bit intimidated of him but if you gave him 100% I think he would be a great manager Lee Hambleton from Sheffield
I think that ‘keeping out of trouble’ was a reference to his managerial career
That is not very nice. Roy Keane said he wants to go back to management.
Sunderland from bottom of the league to winning Championship in one season. Enough said.
Very level headed person