The Youtube Algorithm is BROKEN (here's why)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @User_not_found_403
    @User_not_found_403 Рік тому +13

    I've always been baffled by your sub count. Your content is better than most filmmaker channels. Almost, missed the great ending you had in this video. The cool scenes that you used to open with that originally attracted me to the channel! Don't back down guy, keep doing your thing. Eventually the others in the matrix will find you.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +2

      Always appreciate the support Garfy, people like yourself who've been around since the beginning give me hope!

  • @babyspine
    @babyspine 7 днів тому

    hit the nail on the head. this sucks for gaming channels like mine, it only wants me to do whatever got views and if I change games the views fall off a cliff, algorithm suppression is real. it seems you have to make a new channel for every idea that comes to mind and never change topics if you want to grow...what a shame.
    That Matrix skit at the end was awesome 😄😄

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  2 дні тому +1

      Thank you, checked out your channel - can see the algorithm in full effect! So limiting for UA-camrs :(

  • @FirstKickSeahawks
    @FirstKickSeahawks 2 дні тому

    This happened to me. I run a really small Football podcast, posted 1 short that was a review of my ebike because one of my subscribers asked about it
    Then my daily impressions literally went from thousands... To 9

  • @BrkDownMedia
    @BrkDownMedia Рік тому +1

    As someone who is a creative, why is this man not big??? The production-content value is phenomenal!

  • @steventrimble7350
    @steventrimble7350 Рік тому +1

    I think this is the problem with all social media now, make generic content that follows a precise model and it will get seen.
    Deviate and good luck. A buddy of mine and fellow UA-camr send me this, and I’m glad he did.
    The matrix but at the end was super well done. 🙌

  • @qar_ty7732
    @qar_ty7732 Рік тому +1

    funny how im seeing this video once im noticing youtube recommending the same channels alot more than im wanting(and it just keeps shoving the same videos at me(no matter if ive watched or not .. just a pain))
    it is nice to see a different channel

  • @SmartEnergyLab
    @SmartEnergyLab Рік тому +1

    I feel so much empathy for your predicament. I'm a small time UA-camr with only 8k subs but within my "real life" community I'm well known and respected for the content I make. My audience may be small but as EM Schmacher once wrote (actually its the title of his seminal book), "Small is Beautiful".

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Looks like you're doing some amazing and fantastically interesting stuff. It's a strange experience to be one thing to people in real life and something completely different here on UA-cam. Small is definitely beautiful!

    • @SmartEnergyLab
      @SmartEnergyLab Рік тому

      @@thesavagefilmmaker FYI, I get way more views on LinkedIn than UA-cam for the same content, though the 15 min max length can be a problem.

  • @patrik_x86
    @patrik_x86 Рік тому +1

    The parallels between Mr Beast's content and Fast food was fantastic. That sketch at the end was a lot of fun and good surprise too 😆

  • @Sn4fu
    @Sn4fu Рік тому +3

    Really enjoyed this video, the film education niche seems like such a bastard to break out in. So many talented people in it that know how to make good video!

  • @girafingo9280
    @girafingo9280 7 місяців тому

    From what I can see YT is an e-commerce platform - end of.

  • @DaDamuse
    @DaDamuse Рік тому

    Ironically, it was difficult to find an accurate video on this topic....Im so frustrated with UA-cams shit algorithm. Millions of videos, but can only show me 12 channels Ive watched before, if that. Yeah, genius. If you start asking youtube to stop recommending certain videos like i did, hoping it would widen youtube's scope, youtube just ran out of videos to recommend. homepage had literally 6 videos on it at one point. I had to resent my history.

  • @pixellegolas
    @pixellegolas Рік тому +2

    I was watching 2 dolphins creating NFTs....and....now I am here....weird algorithm :) Jokes aside, I recently bought a camera that can film raw and started to look for content on how to become a filmmaker. You have everything, knowledge, humor and great production. Keep at it! People will notice

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      Awesome to hear Patrik, hope my videos will continue to help you. Appreciate the comment and support.

  • @greenspiral2955
    @greenspiral2955 Рік тому +1

    well, this vid has got you a new sub! Not that into film making but this was 17min well spent. There are definitely some artists that refuse to play the game of constantly throwing new vids out there (the unex[ected gypsy is a 2 vid/month ish girl). Loved the creative ending :)

  • @leighhammondYT
    @leighhammondYT Рік тому

    Its been a while since your vids have been recommended.. I've switched on the notifications, hope that helps out! Top vid and so true.

  • @martinskristapsmickus
    @martinskristapsmickus 6 місяців тому

    OMG UA-cam algorithm is indeed not advertising this video 😂😶
    This should get a lot more views!
    I loved the Matrix part ❤️

  • @kevinbatts2804
    @kevinbatts2804 Рік тому +1

    Bro you have such great content. YT never shows me your content anymore. I have to search you out. It’s ridiculous. I will switch on alerts on. I have so many alerts it’s tough. They recommend so many folk who I’m not subbed to. I wish it would front load my subs first.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Thanks Kevin I appreciate that, I have a couple of favorite creators who never show in my Sub feed despite the fact I always watch their new stuff. It's very frustrating.

  • @TheRealHoloNet
    @TheRealHoloNet Рік тому

    I love this video. You've gained a subscriber who actually cares about your content and wants to see more from you. Stay strong, my friend!

  • @Bo_Hazem
    @Bo_Hazem Рік тому +1

    No fucks given about UA-cam's algorithm, as long as I get to subscribe to people like this fella.

  • @evilgeniusentertainment
    @evilgeniusentertainment Рік тому

    Hey, I'm one of those freaks who hit the notification bell for your channel! Love you content - your MATRIX parody better then the last 2 real films combined. YT's log is bizarre and hateful. My channel is an odd mix of full length horror movies and videos about 3/4 scale arcade machines. Some of my vids have millions of views, but other only a couple of thousand. Very wierd. Andrew Reid of EOSHD has made a video about this in the past, and all I can say is that I agree w/you - in the end, youtube does not reward creatives enough, and def encourages a rinse & repeat approach. Keep on swinging brother, and if you're ever in the Detroit area, first beer's on me.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Haha, thanks man, yes I'd love to see people be able to talk about multiple different topics and still get engagement. Sounds like you cover two of my favorite things. So I'm subbed!

    • @evilgeniusentertainment
      @evilgeniusentertainment Рік тому

      Well alright! I think that's how guys like us have to do it - one sub at a time.....

  • @andyevans6835
    @andyevans6835 Рік тому +3

    I’d give you a like, but I don’t want to feed the Algorithm. Thanks for keeping it real.

  • @DieterVanHolder
    @DieterVanHolder Рік тому

    Haha man I have to laugh at your everyday dad remarks. I once said the exact same thing in a comment on a video by a youtuber that isn't him. He somehow saw or someone told him and he confronted me by making a joke. I felt kind of bad, but I still feel like I was telling the truth. You're saying the exact same thing now. In general, a lot of the content we get isn't genuine at all. The same formula applied to the same content. I understand your feelings man. I can tell you put a lot of work in and then your videos don't get "fed". I occasionally make a video but my content is all over the place as well. I'm well aware I'm never going to take off so I'm trying to remind myself I make videos because I enjoy making them. Obviously it helps that I don't rely on video production as a source of income.

  • @brubels7905
    @brubels7905 9 місяців тому

    I have absolutely no idea what the algorithm is doing! Few years ago watching a walktrough of a game and after part 1 they logically were like hey you watched this all the way trough how about part 2? Or another video that's kinda on the same wave length.
    Nowaday i be watching some serie and instead of recommending the next part it shuffles between 3 or 4 video's i already seen and no matter what i watch how little it has to do with the content they will push those 3 video's down my troat every. single. time.
    Feels like i gotta dislike unsubscribe damm near block the channel out just to get something new recomended or at least something else cause idk about other people but unles it's music i don't watch the same 6 hour stream over and over again every day

  • @nathan_uncapped
    @nathan_uncapped Рік тому

    You are pure gold. Thank you for the refreshing content my guy. 👊
    Please. 🙏 Don't ever change. Haha

  • @NatureNorthwest
    @NatureNorthwest Рік тому

    thats what im running into i have wide variety's of things i like and try different things on my channel and it the more things i try the worse it seems to do on hits. its killed any hits and now im getting no views on older styles.

  • @lukekayart
    @lukekayart Рік тому

    I’ve watched all of your vids over the last couple of years, and your movie “Older” I found your channel through your bmpcc6kpro vids because I was considering buying one. It’s always been a bit discouraging not to see you doing much better, but good to see a couple new uploads recently👍… maybe limited recommendations based on geo location too.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Always appreciate your support and comments Luke, I'm trying to be a little more consistent but my Doc masterclass stuff took 6 months, so that was a bit time consuming. Hoping for more consistency in the second half of this year.

  • @billkujawa
    @billkujawa Рік тому

    Yeah it’s weird I posted a stupid 10 second short using my phone and got 16,000 views in less than a week lol

  • @Ansonandco
    @Ansonandco Рік тому +1

    I love every bit of this! im saying it, the algos are stupid hahaha

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +2

      Anson my man, I love your Sigma/Panasonic coverage and your visual style! Appreciate seeing you pop up in the comments.

    • @Ansonandco
      @Ansonandco Рік тому +1

      @@thesavagefilmmaker dude! Thanks so much. I’ve actually been following your channel for a while, so that means a lot❤️ glad you dig the content ✌🏻 keep up the good work

  • @kevinbatts2804
    @kevinbatts2804 Рік тому

    I used to watch every day dad as well. There’s only so much Apple reviews I need. Interesting observations.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      Haha we all get our fill of every type of thing eventually. That's why we should have the freedom to mix it up without knowing we'll likely get punished for it.

  • @sasqwatch35mm
    @sasqwatch35mm Рік тому

    Ha ha, absolutely love this Matrix parody, please don’t give up and keep it going! Brilliant work , man! Agree on all points thou

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      Thanks mate! Appreciate the support and I shall keep on keeping on.

  • @thegregdavieschannel
    @thegregdavieschannel Рік тому +1

    This is an awesome video. I have noticed that it's been harder to find quality videos in recent years.

  • @catfamloveee
    @catfamloveee 22 дні тому

    Love this. Great video & content 🤝

  • @100ThingsIDo
    @100ThingsIDo Рік тому

    Hopefully this video does extreemly well for you, I have a feeling it will. 6 years for me to get 6k subs! I feel your pain haha!

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      It's a looooooong road mate, I'm here every slow step of the way!

  • @JulesFredericNerestant
    @JulesFredericNerestant Рік тому

    I'm curious though, not being a subscriber of yours, how this video made it to my home page....

  • @dominicpclarke
    @dominicpclarke Рік тому +1

    Agreed

  • @peopleoflisbon
    @peopleoflisbon Рік тому

    Good vid. Watched till the end... and subscribed to you :-) Your production values are off the scale. But seriously... the UA-cam algorithm is complete nonsense. There no guarantee of anything with it. Even if you made content that is on the nose of what it wants... theres no guarantees with it. I've been making UA-cam content of different varieties since UA-cam began. In that time... a hand full of my videos have popped in terms of views. No particularly good reason. Those videos have got lots of likes / comments etc. Proving that the videos are good if presented to an audience... but if they don't... well they just don't. i have stopped thinking about it.... almost completely. Hence me watching this video :-)

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      It’s all getting a bit weird here on UA-cam. I hope they make some changes.

  • @RISE-327
    @RISE-327 Рік тому

    Rumble.

  • @5D_Films
    @5D_Films 10 місяців тому

    You and me are on the exact same page here lol, I’m at 2.2k subs and one of my most recent videos got literally 11 views

  • @ggdfggdfgdffgfddg34
    @ggdfggdfgdffgfddg34 Місяць тому +1

    Dude, only you Americans earn money, in other countries the income is 2 times less, if not even less. Then I have another question, what should be the algorithm promoting the video? Let's say there is a guy who uploaded a video, who should see it first of all?

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Місяць тому +1

      I'm not sure you watched this video properly. But firstly, I'm not american and I'm not based in america, I'm a New Zealander.... so not sure what the point was, but it's redundant. And who should see an uploaded video first of all? People who have subscribed to the channel of the uploader - that would be a good start. The algorithm doesn't work this way.

    • @ggdfggdfgdffgfddg34
      @ggdfggdfgdffgfddg34 Місяць тому +1

      @@thesavagefilmmaker it means whe need alternative of UA-cam

  • @waleeza
    @waleeza Рік тому +1

    😂 i agree with you 100% youtube‘s algorithm got crazy after covid…
    Censorship is making creators leave as well… 😢

    • @firstname405
      @firstname405 Рік тому

      Censorship of what? Because removing all that anti-science bunk and bigoted tripe was a great thing of the platform. Are innocent creators getting caught in the misfire from this bad content?

  • @RaymondParkerPhoto
    @RaymondParkerPhoto Рік тому +1

    I hear/see you. My channel is going nowhere and I know why -- I'm a perfect example of a creator with multiple ̶p̶e̶r̶s̶o̶n̶a̶l̶i̶t̶i̶e̶s̶ interests and, though I try to stay focussed, I have to wander at least a little to avoid boredom and burnout. While those wanderings produce my best content they also drag down "engagement." It doesn't matter if retention and other signals are positive; the algorithm suppresses them. I hope this comment doesn't attract the content police.😀

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +2

      Haha absolutely Raymond, I want to see people try different things we all need to wander down those new paths to stay energised with the content creation grind.

  • @SarumanHimself
    @SarumanHimself 4 місяці тому +1

    Video is informative, you are a charismatic gentleman and the content is substantive. Ergo 1000 total views is the correct push the algorithm should give you on this.
    I've recently had my most popular video get close to a millions views (SirBalz. Not this channel) multiple flaws with it as I've been growing in multiple areas.
    So naturally my new ones with far more investment and skill got 1k and a a recent whopping 4k! It's the best creator I just wanna give up formula they could come up with. Random astronomical success to regular non-explained total failure
    I do the promoting for the video as well, so as to give youtube a little hint. Getting posts with a link to the video in the comments to occasionally reach between 1k to 50k upvotes on reddit as well as 1k to 3k on facebook, some with articles on gaming magazines linking to the video itself. If I'm lucky all those factors in unison will bring in enough views to make it to 10k maybe 20k. All on my end, and that is the end though after 48 hours the video is just some relique to be found only by the most spelunky of users on the platform.
    Sorry for the rant 😂 Just got all this flowing in my head from a lot of what you mentioned here. And spectacular hollywood-esc sketch at the end. Makes me angry it was only viewed by me and three other people

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  4 місяці тому +1

      Appreciate the rant, it's all so very accurate. Thanks brother!

  • @craigklein5563
    @craigklein5563 17 днів тому

    Getting recommended videos that you've already thumbs down and left a comment on is solid proof that you're down votes don't do anything!

  • @Outlabyrinth
    @Outlabyrinth Рік тому

    So funny the matrix is real good !!!! And yet very sad that people with talent and passion with a real sharing experience a dedicated time makes no views no money compare to an everyday dad or random teenagers Tim tokers or a sexy babe filming her booty ….so sad 😢 that’s our realty in 2023
    Well thanks for your time and quality video even you deserve way more so far you help people and that’s something great that money can not buy 😊
    Cheers 🍻

  • @Bradum
    @Bradum Рік тому +1

    Sorry to be harsh, because I do like a lot of your stuff.... But you still have non-blackmagic videos that do well. Have you considered some of your content is just not compelling to your existing audience? You released a whole bunch of vlogs in a row, and while you may think they were really good it did tell me about them and I really had no interest in watching them.
    Looking through your channel and the views it doesn't look like all your BMCC videos did amazing, and then suddenly all your videos fell of the second you stopped making videos about BMCC. Your MacBook, Manual Focus, PP vs DR, iPhone, Red One, Dehancer, and other videos all did well. You likely just lost a lot of audience by releasing a bunch of videos in a row they didn't want to watch.
    It also seems you may not really understand your audience. Looking at the videos that do well, it seems the majority of your views come from people who are researching products, and some from more technical camera basics (how do I rig out a camera?, how do I manually focus?, etc.). Just because they're things related to filmmaking doesn't necessarily mean they want to watch a video about you winning a filmmaking award, or one about your creative process.
    With all that being said, you can still experiment with new types of videos, but maybe releasing 10 in a row without knowing if people will like that style is not the best way to go about it.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Totally valid point mate, and in fact I did have a whole other section dedicated to some of the other 'Niche's' my Videos have prospered in(which I trimmed out). What I can say is most of the Pocket videos did well, and there was consistent growth with most of them the same with Mac and Edit software vids, whenever I covered more diverse filmmaking topics it was very inconsistent and they never had the same algorithmic up-tick that those two topics did, not just talking about the Vlogs. But thats kind of my point, if my audience is not 'filmmakers' or those interested in 'filmmaking' and if the people who watch are not even a true audience who enjoy my style, but simply 'people who want product analysis', that's pretty stifling. And I think that's how channels get generic. But I would suggest judging by many of the other comments here on the vid, my analysis has merit. But I respect this take, it just doesn't fill me with a desire to try and make new product videos.

    • @Bradum
      @Bradum Рік тому +1

      @@thesavagefilmmaker You're absolutely right in saying that is how a lot of channels become generic; they're chasing the easy views. But I don't necessarily think that's the only way to grow a channel.
      The thing with that audience is that, while it's much easier initially to get views from someone searching "how to do this thing" or "Product X", it's not a very sticky audience; views on one video don't really translate to views on your next.
      What you really want to do is grow your core audience; people that will watch a video because YOU put it out, not just because it's a topic they're searching. This audience is much harder and slower to grow since you're relying on it actively being served up in their recommended videos rather than passively capturing people searching the topic (not a lot of people searching for "film festival in amsterdam vlog").
      Your core audience is likely still growing, but it can be hard to see that with such variance in view count on your videos. I know I said I wasn't really interested in your vlog series, but asides from that I watch most videos you put out because I know it's good quality content. Keep going with your content and I'm pretty confident you'll eventually start seeing the results you want.
      tl;dr don't let the non-sticky audience obfuscate the growth of your core adience.

  • @bonzology322
    @bonzology322 Рік тому

    This is true! I’m subbed to your channel and I rarely get ur vids presented to me and of course I never hit the notification bell on any subscription

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому

      They think you're not really interested, damnit. But of course we all avoid the notification bell at all costs!

  • @proteus1
    @proteus1 Рік тому

    Mans creativity destroyed by YT. Talk about Mr Beast and what he does on his videos within an upload of purposeful content and your social media presence and all other social media and that'e part of the key. Plus he may have afliates links that push his content too. Personally I thumb down his content as I'm not a follower of his, so just to let the algor I'm not intrested, so don't show again. Plus I'm human and like to change my thoughts because I hate compliance. Hence never going to school and leaving with no qulifications and and running my own business for 20 years. Personally, I couldn't give a Fly Truck If any one finds any content of mine, as it's siloed deep in some 286 pc burried deep within the earths core.I'm setting atrend of 20 billion Negative Subs.The more negativity I get the more attention I get.I clicked the like button twice for your cANNEL TO HELP YOU OUT. sUBED, THEN UN-SUBED. Trouble is your too big for them to handle, so they can't handle your great content as an Indi Film Maker. Here's something to cheer you up. ua-cam.com/video/qY6nHu1GdHQ/v-deo.html. I typed into search film makers nz and your face ins't there or your not in search.

    • @thesavagefilmmaker
      @thesavagefilmmaker  Рік тому +1

      Haha 'Mans Creativity destroyed by YT' should definitely have been my title. Damn not even in a NZ filmmakers search... maybe on page 5! Thanks for that lovely little Cooke interlude.

    • @proteus1
      @proteus1 Рік тому

      I could help you get on to page one as a film maker as I make lightweight websites and beat heavy content management ones. I think your wasting time on YT as your trying too many avenues and your skills are varied. Perhaps do the neich thing and website. Perhaps focus on being found with a website and earn more money as a film maker that way.

    • @proteus1
      @proteus1 Рік тому

      @@thesavagefilmmaker ua-cam.com/video/wLfZL9PZI9k/v-deo.html