Wow! Vicky sounds great! I never went out of my way to listen to her do Alissa’s songs because I really like Vicky, and I guess I was afraid I’d be disappointed. Now I’m glad I finally gave it a listen. I like Vicky more than ever now! : D
check their ears. Vicky has in ear monitors in here. Alissa just had ear plugs in every performance I saw with her. For a single singer comparison look up older motionless in white performances compared to now. a lot easier to not sing super flat when you can hear yourself. not to mention the rest of the band is waaaaaaay less sloppy with a click in their ears
@@longshucksgaming Yes, but Alissa was often off-key on the album recordings, too. Apart from the Swan Lake acapella, I’ve never been impressed with her cleans. Vicky can be a bit whiny at times, but she overall sounds like she’s had much more training.
I like Alissa's screams better. But, I like Vicky's clean vocals better. I think Alissa is better off in Arch Enemy and Vicky is better off in The Agonist
Alissa is better at managing her breathing but I think Vicky still does a great job, the unclean vocals in this song are very fast and not many people could come close to Alissa. At least if Vicky misses out one or two words each line then she can be consistent, instead of needing to miss out a whole line to catch her breath.
no voy a criticar a Vicky , tampoco voy a decir que es mejor que Alissa , obviamente Alissa tiene mas experiencia en glaturales Vicky de echo es muy buena también ... mejor dicho Alissa y Vicky son geniales , las dos.
EPIC...cant even get Alissa voice there any more,Vicky breaks all the dishes and fits perfectly,one day they should make a best of and put Vicky's voice in all them best songs ah!
weird l'angle de la Go Pro au dessu de Simon(drums), good job les boys. PS: Ya un des cameraman qui a maladoitement accroché une beer et elle a coulée le long de mon dos, j'avais les bobettes et les pants plein de beer. Le dude a meme pas bronché quand je lui ai dis que c'est pas cool, meme pas un "scuze dude". Pas gentil la, hehehe...
+angela González Quiroga Loli tiene razon vicky tiene que mejorar su tecnica yo he hecho un cover de eso y ni me he cansado y eso que tuve que usar un falsete porque no llegaba a la notas agudas puedes usar varias tecnicas cuando respiras al cantar si quieres escuchar mi cover avisame ;)
angela González Quiroga no tienes razon por que cuando la metieron de "cantante" ya sabía el estilo de The agonist y en ese momento practicar pero no solo intenta pero no puede y nunca va a poder compararse con alissa
@@itzelbarajas3074 eso no tiene absolutamente nada que ver, las tesituras son por el color y la amplitud en graves o agudos . las voces que suenan bien es porque trabajan en ellas no por su registro vocal
I've watched almost every The Agonist video and you are under all of them either praising Alissa or shitting all over Vicky. Get over it, Alissa is not in this band. You and everyone else needs to just forget Alissa was ever in this band and realize she is not coming back after all the shit she put The Agonist through. If you don't like Vicky, then fuck off because the ones who do like her (Me), don't want to hear it.
zada alex I don't think so, Alissa kept up with the same music tempo, it's just that Vicky shouldn't scream or growl, just keep the cleans... sorry if you like Vicky though 😕
They are doomed with Vicky, she can't get most of her screams, and most of the words were cut in half, sorry guys if you like Vicky, but listen carefully and you'll see it's true 😕
![Kalmah - For the Revolution/The Groan of Wind [Live in Montreal]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-x7e8kfIdzU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kalmah - For the Revolution/The Groan of Wind [Live in Montreal]](/img/tr.png)
![The Agonist - My Witness, Your Victim [Live in Montreal]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GcpzIPzI9eM/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow! Vicky sounds great! I never went out of my way to listen to her do Alissa’s songs because I really like Vicky, and I guess I was afraid I’d be disappointed. Now I’m glad I finally gave it a listen. I like Vicky more than ever now! : D
I miss Alissa, but, i like more vicky's style, she has a more agresive style and i love her clean voice too.
Fernando Saavedra more aggressive than Alissa? Really?
I think the same
@@sofiaaaaa.h Alissa aggressive, really? When? She's the most boring singer out there...
@@_MrTrick_alissa better all the way
WOW, she is waaaaay better now
This woman can only be from another world, awesome!
yeah, i think so
3:25 fucking epic scream
three words: oh my God O.O
Growling: Alissa for stamina
Singing: Vicky for actually being on key.
alissa didn't have stamina live. she's just hotter
Nah, Vicky is 100% better in everything.
@@_MrTrick_ clearly not seeing as the agonist broke up
that and the fact they couldn't do better than a tiny bar after being signed for 10+ years
check their ears. Vicky has in ear monitors in here. Alissa just had ear plugs in every performance I saw with her. For a single singer comparison look up older motionless in white performances compared to now. a lot easier to not sing super flat when you can hear yourself. not to mention the rest of the band is waaaaaaay less sloppy with a click in their ears
@@longshucksgaming Yes, but Alissa was often off-key on the album recordings, too. Apart from the Swan Lake acapella, I’ve never been impressed with her cleans. Vicky can be a bit whiny at times, but she overall sounds like she’s had much more training.
alissa fan boys everywhere...
for good reason lol. vicky missed or bullshitted half the song
lol, looser virgins are they. Alissa cannot sing her own songs live.
Well to be fair she missed a ton of words here because shes breathing at the wrong spots of the songs. At other pioints she was way to slow
Holy canoli come to Idaho Falls please!!!!!
🫠
She looks more organic in Agonist. Alyssa always sang with anguish. And Vicki everything clearly.
I like Alissa's screams better. But, I like Vicky's clean vocals better. I think Alissa is better off in Arch Enemy and Vicky is better off in The Agonist
+RainingBlood281 You took the words from my mouth
Totally agree. I actually can't decide who I like better anymore. Both are amazing at what they do now!
Same
I'm surprised more people aren't commenting about how good Chris looks with facial hair... 😍
Se cansa mucho en los guturales, pero tiene muy bien trabajada la voz lirica 👌👌
Nicest people I ever met!!
She needs more power
Temazo
why the is she missing words while growling?
Alissa has a different breathing technique
She is forcing her screams, probably just to stay with The Agonist for as long as possible... she can't really scream...
she doesnt have the skill to sing/scream them all....
Alissa is better at managing her breathing but I think Vicky still does a great job, the unclean vocals in this song are very fast and not many people could come close to Alissa. At least if Vicky misses out one or two words each line then she can be consistent, instead of needing to miss out a whole line to catch her breath.
@@wanderingmetalguy5825 vicky gotten alot better with her vocals
no voy a criticar a Vicky , tampoco voy a decir que es mejor que Alissa , obviamente Alissa tiene mas experiencia en glaturales Vicky de echo es muy buena también ... mejor dicho Alissa y Vicky son geniales , las dos.
Es el comentario más inteligente de todos estos imbéciles, excelente. Larga vida al metal.
Concuerdo!
EPIC...cant even get Alissa voice there any more,Vicky breaks all the dishes and fits perfectly,one day they should make a best of and put Vicky's voice in all them best songs ah!
Great song. Well done live too.
She sounds exhausted.
Oh man, it must be 'cause she's not human, right?
+Marco Agüero ahh man, you must have intentionally missed the point.
***** And the point is...?
she sounds like terrible man, growling is weak, clean vocals suck, she is no Alissa by far..
Marco, The point is that she can't sing live. She's just good in a studio.
extraño el poder vocal de Alissa, la forma de cantar sus ojos su estilo, fue lo mejor en the agonist
weird l'angle de la Go Pro au dessu de Simon(drums), good job les boys.
PS: Ya un des cameraman qui a maladoitement accroché une beer et elle a coulée le long de mon dos, j'avais les bobettes et les pants plein de beer. Le dude a meme pas bronché quand je lui ai dis que c'est pas cool, meme pas un "scuze dude". Pas gentil la, hehehe...
a very wise replacement for alissa this girl is awesome why am i just now seeing this lol
I like her clean vocals more.
HOW did she DARE
ella se queda sin aire, debe mejorar ese gutural
Loli Ploot Ponte a cantar asi y luego críticas XD aún así Vicky lo hace bien,no hay que mirarla en menos tampoco
+angela González Quiroga Loli tiene razon vicky tiene que mejorar su tecnica yo he hecho un cover de eso y ni me he cansado y eso que tuve que usar un falsete porque no llegaba a la notas agudas puedes usar varias tecnicas cuando respiras al cantar
si quieres escuchar mi cover avisame ;)
Si pero no era necesario criticar ,ya que ponte a pensar que esa técnica igual es súper difícil,no es llegar y hacerlo.
angela González Quiroga no tienes razon por que cuando la metieron de "cantante" ya sabía el estilo de The agonist y en ese momento practicar pero no solo intenta pero no puede y nunca va a poder compararse con alissa
Esta cancion es rapida
OF COURSE it is different "without Alissa" or "with Vicky". THEY ARE DIFFERENT PEOPLE. Learn how to enjoy each one's virtues.
Well yeah but that doesnt change the fact that she missed a lot of words because she nee dto breath or was way o slow a tother points of the song.
Vicky does okay but she will never be Alissa. With that said, she does do the old material justice :)
+MrFinntrollin and Alissa will never be Angela. So what's the point?
+Ariel Iconoclast and angela will never be johan hahah
+Ariana Montiel lol well this all escalated quickly
Thank God, she will never be untalented Bitchlissa.
Vicky never will be Alissa. You're right. She's much better now, than Alissa ever will be.
she isnt terrible but she needs to improve her breathing if she wants to play songs the put more stress on her lungs
When you think Vicky is worse than Alissa, remember of this video:
ua-cam.com/video/ukterJwsxeI/v-deo.html
Vicky i love you
Ngl Vicky is hot af
That hair though
i'm the 666 blue thumb !!!!!!!!!!!!
Esta chica esta para otra banda estilo death metal tiene un gutural muy bueno. Esta banda se fue al tacho sin Alissa
half the words aren't even pronounced.
the struggle is real
The agonist知ったの本当に最近だけど、私はやっぱり首にさせられちゃった青髪のボーカルさんの方が好きだな(◜௰◝)
Vicky n Alissa got same level... Just my 10cent opinion
Sorry but it' s not the same as with Alissa.
Honestly, Vicky doesn't do half bad. As long it is with the songs wrote while she was in the band.
Se queda sin aire... Que bajon me cago la banda mal Dx
El gutural se queda sin aire. . . eso es falta de práctica, pero en voz limpia, a mi parecer, canta mejor que Alissa en vivo
+Sayi Brink Vicky es Soprano y Alissa Mezzosoprano, es por ello que alcanza esas notas.
giuliana darrichon ponte a cantar tu entonces xd
Lo que pasa que alissa canta mas rapido
@@itzelbarajas3074 eso no tiene absolutamente nada que ver, las tesituras son por el color y la amplitud en graves o agudos . las voces que suenan bien es porque trabajan en ellas no por su registro vocal
🐮
essa mulher afundou o the agonist
this band is dead without allyssa
Arch Enemy now its better!
Unity Developer & Programmer yeah she made Arch Enemy better at least, but just so you know, she didn't leave The Agonist, they kicked her out
Not really. Have you heard their new stuff? They are pretty good unlike Arch Enemy lol.
nop
psicodélico
vicky cant growl voice ? more to scream
She got better at growling, listen to more recent live version of this song.
Alissa is ten fold better in any direction.
I've watched almost every The Agonist video and you are under all of them either praising Alissa or shitting all over Vicky. Get over it, Alissa is not in this band. You and everyone else needs to just forget Alissa was ever in this band and realize she is not coming back after all the shit she put The Agonist through. If you don't like Vicky, then fuck off because the ones who do like her (Me), don't want to hear it.
have fun with all that while the agonist continues to play basements
In no universe is shitlissa better than Vicky. 😂
@@_MrTrick_ Ugly Vicky and the worthless band abused Alissa, and lied about her. You're an idiot too!!!
after reading all comments ....what can I say I agree Alyssa much better...... what the he'll where they thinking
When was she better? 😂
alissa did better :
robert Gamechicken When exactly? 😂
No.
Alissa is better!
Sorry but this is very poor,destroyed a great song in my opinion ,
clean vocals are just ok..and i think she must work whit .stage present its a little boring
i think the tempo is faster than the original.maybe thats why she couldnt keep it up
zada alex I don't think so, Alissa kept up with the same music tempo, it's just that Vicky shouldn't scream or growl, just keep the cleans... sorry if you like Vicky though 😕
They are doomed with Vicky, she can't get most of her screams, and most of the words were cut in half, sorry guys if you like Vicky, but listen carefully and you'll see it's true 😕
This comment aged like milk.
Not the same without alyssa, sry guys
franchement je prefere Alissa je trouve quelle chante mieux et quel a plus de classe
Lmao she skipped all the lyrics
She can't do Alissa's songs well. She's clearly struggling
Alissa can't do her own songs well live, so what's the point?
@@metal8515 exactly
Vicky sings better than Alissa.
ahhahaahahhaha i'm laughing u are so funny
lol.
Dmitry Enikeev nice joke 😂😂😂
youve hear thank you pain right?
I totally agree, Alissa's cleans usually sound strained to me.
She doesn´t sing -_-
why did vicky did this to alissa's beautiful song huhuhu
WHAT A GAY CROWD !!!!
Alissa is better
thank you for ruining my favorite song.