Truly admire Ms. Mamata Banerjee of selecting the highly qualified persons to represent West Bengal n voice the grievances, suffering of the poor people of India. Whereas, it seems the bjp don't understand much English n they never debates in English. I enjoyed watching the TMC speakers speaks in the parliament...Keep it up TMC 👍👍...
@@globalcitien1984 bro west Bengal is not about only Kolkata. I live in west Bengal. I am not a bhakt and you have no idea about West Bengal’s current situation.
Yup , just like tajemul islam from tmc . Hes very educated . If you want to know more abd possibly aspire to be him , search up bengal flogging case .@@riderAB92
That’s because the state of WB amidst all the created negative publicity and propaganda still values education and makes tremendous efforts to ensure common men have access to the same at a relatively low cost
No taxation without representation, if this is understood by the people of the world than the elected representative will be only honest and just, and not looters favoring their friends and family. Awesome speech
Speaker is surely must be in awe over the way the united opposition is giving back to the government. And young and new MPs are directly catching the PM.
He speaks like a real leader, not much excited or angry and didn't get diverted from the topic. Seems like he has got proper education and a sensible human, Don't know much about him. Our parliament needs to teach our MPs how to debate or speak like him
People of Mumbai are grateful to this capable MP from West Bengal for raising the very important issue of overcrowding of local trains. Mamtaji's choice of MPs is great !
Sujit Nair always said that the Middle Class of India are always left out of the budget. The very rich enjoy the tax cuts. The poor get some benefit from schemes but the Middle Class get nothing only increase in taxes.
I'm a native of AP and I like the fact that we're 'finally' at a good position politically but what I do not understand is how every party says AP has got 'Too Much' importance just with a mention of 15K crore out of a budget of more than 10L crore, despite being neglected for the last 10 years when the centre has not respected the 'State Reorganisation Act' and denied us things that were actually promised in the parliament. Despite all my respect towards the Republic that we are, I feel AP government should blackmail the centre as much as possible to get everything my state deserves and had been deprived off, in the last decade.
Yes just make sure that when ur promises are not fulfilled u topple their seat … coz I m sure a lot of Bhakts still waiting on their 15 lacs of black money 😒 and all those promises etc
Modi 73 is one of the three vvip of our beloved country. These three vvip have more freedom of speech. They can talk whatever they like so long as people continue to keep them in power
The government's budget limits every avenue of investment as the returns are heavily taxed over the previous years. If there are no avenues for fruitful returns for one's savings, how does one survive and meet increasing inflation? The Government provides no dole or social security payments to tax payers post-retirement. How will they survive the next decade at this rate???
Very well articulated. Truth which some choose to ignore and many because of the rat race we are forced into can’t stop to even look at! And the loot of peoples taxes with improper representation continues without any accountability, conscience all at the integrity of the taxpayers!
The higher ups in the hierarchy seem to be conferred with the right to insult whomsoever they choose ! Spreading divisiveness and hatred is okay for SOME folks !😢😢
The whole of India is aware of the withheld budget for West Bengal over these past several years. It's also amazing to know that the Mamata govt is managing the state without central funds. Really shameful and childish of the Union govt. to fantasise a punishment. The FM is only good at talking smart when in fact she is really digging her own grave.
BJP government or can also be called taxation government. What about jobs for the youths? Wake up the people of India and see no jobs, no earning avenues and high inflation under PM Modiraj regime.
I'm not agreeing on the this, that she had given only 5 minutes, first thing is why she went when India alliance was boycotted.?? That means "दाल मे कूछ काला है"
High prices in Every commodities in the market is the outcome of high taxes that will kill the middle and low class civilians in the country. We never wants depopulation in the whole nation where civilians dies due to hunger, unemployment, sickness and so on so forth.
West Bengal big planned cities people already fr years talk all the advantages....they pay less to servents fr household work, house rent is very low, pay less electricity and avail all facilities like AC, TV, geyser, cooler, water purifier, hv to pay less in food as its cheep thus labourer come to Kerala and earn because kerela labour ask cost is high. What else facilities more west bangal want
Not Muslim...but bangladeshi muslims only....in west bengal they are the majority now....agar himmat he toh unko bahgake dikaho TMC (bangladeshi party)
BSF is controlled by the central government which rather works with TMC to export beef there... north bengal is flooded by Bangladeshis called and made to settle by bjpeee to increase their vote bank but ironically those people also rejected beti jalaao party in north bengal during bypolls😂😂😂
Non biological pawpaw should have explicitly mentioned Bangladeshi muslims then.....he made a very generic comment in his campaign speech...he won't coz that will upset his rapport with fellow dictator Sheikh Hasina....then beef baniya giri business with Bangladesh will be adversely affected
Waw !!! The finance minister is so incompetent that every opposition parties grilled her left, right, front n back...OMG..
Absolutely correct about Health insurance GST so painful
Another new generation bright statesman Mr Gokhel, thanks for voicing for the middle class.
SAket Gokhale has done an admirable job. Keep it up. We see few people showing mirror to the oppressor
Truly admire Ms. Mamata Banerjee of selecting the highly qualified persons to represent West Bengal n voice the grievances, suffering of the poor people of India. Whereas, it seems the bjp don't understand much English n they never debates in English. I enjoyed watching the TMC speakers speaks in the parliament...Keep it up TMC 👍👍...
This MPs are good for debate.
Otherwise they do no work for Bengal.
@@gourabroyyi was surprised by how kolkata has developed in last 10 years around new town etc even without funds from the centre. Dont be a bhakt.
@@globalcitien1984 bro west Bengal is not about only Kolkata.
I live in west Bengal.
I am not a bhakt and you have no idea about West Bengal’s current situation.
@@gourabroyy West Bengal is much much better than mp and up, so don’t fall into this propaganda of the bjp
@@Shakti-j9b bhai i live here i know the situation!
Excellent speech.
Yes, TMC. MPs really are brave and brilliant.
Saket Gokhsle an RTI activist brought up good points his speech and clarity the facts & the presentation was of high quality
I didnt know TMC have some brilliant Educated MP's ..
Ya.. Maximum MPs are educated.. Actually Mamata brings people from many sectors to Politics, Doctors, Actors, Teachers and other sectors.
Hence. Let us send our minions also go to RSS as well. BJP only cares about wealth. Not Money. Wealth.
Yup , just like tajemul islam from tmc . Hes very educated . If you want to know more abd possibly aspire to be him , search up bengal flogging case .@@riderAB92
That’s because the state of WB amidst all the created negative publicity and propaganda still values education and makes tremendous efforts to ensure common men have access to the same at a relatively low cost
TMC is have the highest woman representation in parliament. 38% of TMC's MP are Woman.
Remarkable speeech by leader, absolutely professional talk 👍
No taxation without representation, if this is understood by the people of the world than the elected representative will be only honest and just, and not looters favoring their friends and family.
Awesome speech
All the MPs from W Bengal are educated and cannot be taken for a ride by the corrupt politicians .👍
Really?
Then they should be ashamed about current situation of West Bengal.
@@gourabroyy You should ashamed for being a sanghi propagandist.
@@sayantanmazumdar3 not actually , ima bengali and I vouch for this guy . Tmc is far far worse than bjp
@@Viper-71 Not really☝🤓
@@Viper-71 I am Bengali too, BJP is the most Dangerous party for Bengali who want to divide Bengal in two parts.
Nirmala cannot be FM anymore for India. She can either go to Andhra or bihar.
Feeds the rich and starves the poor. Treacherous budget!?
Nirmala needs to go to jail. There are no onions in jail.
We have to learn from west Bengal they elected Educated and Qualified MP
Very good speaker.
Speaker is surely must be in awe over the way the united opposition is giving back to the government. And young and new MPs are directly catching the PM.
Remove GST first
You nailed it Sir! Excellent representation of the voiceless!
Unique mr Ghokele
Wrost FM
Send all of bjp to jail. That Kiran rijuju is also horrid. Send all to jail
He speaks like a real leader, not much excited or angry and didn't get diverted from the topic. Seems like he has got proper education and a sensible human, Don't know much about him. Our parliament needs to teach our MPs how to debate or speak like him
😂😂😂😂 awesome closing remarks 😅😅😊😅
Refers to Muslims ms as ghuspathiye is shameful BJP must retire
Very well spoken...
Super Presentation , Sir
Entire Cabinet is complicit. Hence Caeser must stay. But then Caeser....
a abhorrent colonial mindset.
People of Mumbai are grateful to this capable MP from West Bengal for raising the very important issue of overcrowding of local trains. Mamtaji's choice of MPs is great !
Sujit Nair always said that the Middle Class of India are always left out of the budget. The very rich enjoy the tax cuts. The poor get some benefit from schemes but the Middle Class get nothing only increase in taxes.
Illuminated❤
Treasury benches could nit even listen the well reasearched speech of this vibrant young MP and they're trying to shout him down.
The company tax’s are less than the income tax as a percent to the contribution to the central budget
Excellent representation on middle class problems, concerns and issues of Income tax, GST etc
Our Parliament needs MP's like Mr. Gokhale
I'm a native of AP and I like the fact that we're 'finally' at a good position politically but what I do not understand is how every party says AP has got 'Too Much' importance just with a mention of 15K crore out of a budget of more than 10L crore, despite being neglected for the last 10 years when the centre has not respected the 'State Reorganisation Act' and denied us things that were actually promised in the parliament. Despite all my respect towards the Republic that we are, I feel AP government should blackmail the centre as much as possible to get everything my state deserves and had been deprived off, in the last decade.
Yes just make sure that when ur promises are not fulfilled u topple their seat … coz I m sure a lot of Bhakts still waiting on their 15 lacs of black money 😒 and all those promises etc
Modi 73 is one of the three vvip of our beloved country. These three vvip have more freedom of speech. They can talk whatever they like so long as people continue to keep them in power
Swach bharath cess is for building toilet for modi
Colonial rule is unacceptable in democratic republic of India
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
The government's budget limits every avenue of investment as the returns are heavily taxed over the previous years. If there are no avenues for fruitful returns for one's savings, how does one survive and meet increasing inflation? The Government provides no dole or social security payments to tax payers post-retirement. How will they survive the next decade at this rate???
Democracy is back in our beloved country 😊
West Bengal voted for educated and dynamic representatives to the lok sabha and rajya sabha. Well done west bengal
Well said about Bengal analysis Budget,......& Deprived deliberately by MODI Govt
Yes. Come out from union & be individual
Taxes, without Representation of Muslims in Loksabha,... Shame.
👍
How many have to..die that..Ceasar remains..King?
I like the chair... Allows opposition to speak
Very well articulated. Truth which some choose to ignore and many because of the rat race we are forced into can’t stop to even look at! And the loot of peoples taxes with improper representation continues without any accountability, conscience all at the integrity of the taxpayers!
Before 1947 there was no such words gusbaitiya
Modi government fill Fall in September 🎉
The higher ups in the hierarchy seem to be conferred with the right to insult whomsoever they choose ! Spreading divisiveness and hatred is okay for SOME folks !😢😢
Modi is doing injustice to West Bengal Govt because Mamata Banerjee is the CM.
The whole of India is aware of the withheld budget for West Bengal over these past several years. It's also amazing to know that the Mamata govt is managing the state without central funds.
Really shameful and childish of the Union govt. to fantasise a punishment. The FM is only good at talking smart when in fact she is really digging her own grave.
BJP government or can also be called taxation government.
What about jobs for the youths? Wake up the people of India and see no jobs, no earning avenues and high inflation under PM Modiraj regime.
I'm not agreeing on the this, that she had given only 5 minutes, first thing is why she went when India alliance was boycotted.?? That means "दाल मे कूछ काला है"
High prices in Every commodities in the market is the outcome of high taxes that will kill the middle and low class civilians in the country. We never wants depopulation in the whole nation where civilians dies due to hunger, unemployment, sickness and so on so forth.
Who's in the chair
Chamcha of BJP, Modi.
A bundle of falsity
Kursi bachao budget for safety of bjp to survive in government
The finance minister is so very thick-skinned. As most of India hate her, she should resign
Nirmala looks like a failed student getting a 1st rank like the Neet exams rank holders by her govt.
West Bengal big planned cities people already fr years talk all the advantages....they pay less to servents fr household work, house rent is very low, pay less electricity and avail all facilities like AC, TV, geyser, cooler, water purifier, hv to pay less in food as its cheep thus labourer come to Kerala and earn because kerela labour ask cost is high. What else facilities more west bangal want
@@minimathew6748 let's fight for second independence from India...
Not Muslim...but bangladeshi muslims only....in west bengal they are the majority now....agar himmat he toh unko bahgake dikaho TMC (bangladeshi party)
BSF is controlled by the central government which rather works with TMC to export beef there... north bengal is flooded by Bangladeshis called and made to settle by bjpeee to increase their vote bank but ironically those people also rejected beti jalaao party in north bengal during bypolls😂😂😂
Non biological pawpaw should have explicitly mentioned Bangladeshi muslims then.....he made a very generic comment in his campaign speech...he won't coz that will upset his rapport with fellow dictator Sheikh Hasina....then beef baniya giri business with Bangladesh will be adversely affected
westbengal mps are always upto the mark.Bravo didi
തൃണമൂൽ കോൺഗ്രസ് സൂപ്പർ.. we need them in kerals