The American Tribe
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 сер 2024
- Why American Society Is Collapsing
Carl and Dan discuss why, from an outsider's perspective, American civilisation appears to be crumbling.
Watch the full premium video: www.lotuseater...
Exclusive video/written content for as little as £5 a month: www.lotuseater...
Subscribe to our other channel:
/ @lotuseatersdotcom
Follow us:
Parler - parler.com/pro...
Twitter - / lotuseaters_com
Gab - gab.com/lotuse...
Minds - www.minds.com/...
Facebook - / lotuseatersdotcom
VK - lotusea...
Sound Cloud - / lotuseaters_com
BitChute - www.bitchute.c...
Instagram - / lotuseaters_com
Rumble - rumble.com/c/c...
Ruqqus - ruqqus.com/+lo...
Reddit - / lotuseaters_com
Spotify - open.spotify.c...
DLive - dlive.tv/lotus...
Twitch - / lotuseaters_com
Google Podcasts - podcasts.googl...
Apple Podcast - podcasts.apple...
Ahh, the trolley test. Or the shopping cart test as we would call it. The only people who have a problem with that litmus test seem to never put their carts back.
The virgin 'Why should I? They pay people for that' vs the chad cart returner.
The Trolley Car hypothetical says a lot about people who believe in it. It's an argument for bloody authoritarianism. They're quite literally arguing that there's two options, we sacrifice others for the greater good or else.
I have never come closer to smacking another person's child than when he threw a candy wrapper on the floor of a mall and replied, 'they have people to clean up here' when I asked him to pick it up.
It's important to put the cart before the horse!
First thing we noticed when we moved to rural TN from Los Angeles. Everyone puts the shopping carts back. My husband and I were celebrating bc sometimes it felt like we were the only ppl returning carts in LA lol.
The issue is that the left thinks that rights can be redefined to suit the current political climate and the right disagrees
A constant redefinition - is by definition. Not a definition, but a Confine of a Conception.
They objectively can be, because rights were created by men and can be changed by men.
Rights are God given, not man made....
@@chadiverson3796 Rights are man held. Nothing else holds them. everything else is just a justification
@@rat_king- man held?
American society isn't collapsing so much as it's polarizing between cities and everyone else. You go into the hinterlands and you will have peace.
They’ll follow you there. They’ll never stop. The longer you hide the worse it gets.
Definitely collapsing, you have no industry, farming is struggling, everything corporatised and centralised, Christians are a minority it's going to be far worse than the great depression. When the handouts stop all those multiculturalists are coming to the countryside to take what you and your family have, better be ready.
TIS BUT A SCRATCH
@@barneyboyle6933 White flight is fleeing eventual genocide.
You can't anymore unless you're very wealthy. If you want a house that isn't falling apart and has a decent amount of land and doesn't need any work done, that'll be $500,000. Good luck paying property taxes with no income because it's in the middle of nowhere and your job prospects are negligible and farming doesn't pay.
“I wish it to be remembered that I was the last man of my tribe to surrender my rifle.”
“If we must die, we die defending our rights.”
- Sitting Bull
I had men and horses, arms and wealth. What wonder if I parted with them reluctantly? If you Romans choose to lord it over the world, does it follow that the world is to accept slavery.
Caratacus, British chieftain of the Catuvellauni tribe.
And that is no bull. My best friend is a Lakota spirit warrior.
Wounded Knee 😢
@@Madonnalitta1 Tell it to my ancestors massacred at Hatfield Mass in 1677.
@@williambranch4283 1677... would that be King Philip's War?
*_Never mind about' American civilisation crumbling'- Take a good look at our own, right here ..._*
Unfortunately, if the yanks fall apart, we're not far to follow. We do, on the other hand, get a head start on the problems when they arrive. That's why the weirdos invent names for us like "TERF Island" 😂
We're all part of Western civilization. One domino falls, the rest will probably follow. Any intermediate period will likely involve bloodshed, death, and widespread misery.
👆🏻😔
@@Gee-Con Their left's ideology is *why* our culture is falling apart. We didn't get a head start on this one because it was already here.
I have some thoughts on the subject. Returning my cart after I shop, holding the door for a stranger, helping the neighbor with their shopping, thanking folks who serve the public- I don't do these things because I'm a saint or to fulfill a social contract. I do them for myself. For my own wellbeing and peace of mind. I practice gratitude, and I make myself of service to others whenever I can because when I don't, I'm doing a disservice to myself. My actions and my thoughts are my own. It's not that I'm naive or that I'm blind to the state of decay. I do it _because_ shit is this way, not in spite of it. I don't consider myself above anyone, but I won't lower myself with cynicism and self-pity. And I won't allow an increasingly nihilistic culture to dictate how I choose to live my life. If this sounds self-righteous or self-aggrandizing, I want to reiterate that I'm not talking about healing the blind here or teaching orphans to read in Calcutta. It's just a little courtesy to help keep my head on straight and express my gratitude. And I know for certain there's plenty of folks out here just like me. Millions.
This is the way.
Yep. I am the same. I do it because it’s the right thing to do. Simple as.
I do it because I get a hit of dopamine or serotonin or whatever.
Those activities express a degree of trust in one's neighbours, i.e. social capital.
Diversity correlates negatively with social capital.
See: Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam.
@@patgray5402There really is more to life than accumulating dopamine hits. Easy dopamine hits are a big part of what is tearing down culture in the Anglosphere. Easy dopamine hits are also damaging a lot of human beings.
@@carolstoddard6280 If there's no short term or long term dopamine hits then I'm not going to do it.
No the community has been that violent for a while. There is a time article from the 50s which goes over the disproportionate amount of violence from that community. It has always been like this, we just don't want to notice uncomfortable patterns.
Yeah, but 2x as violent, not 11x as violent!
The movie Gangs of New York encapsulates this concept of American tribalism. Sadly, the constant mass importation of different peoples ensured we were doomed from the start.
Gangs of New York is a ridiculous work of fiction that tries to turn noteworthy but overall insignificant clashes between local gangs into a grand narrative of ethnic warfare.
It's Hollywood and none of it's real.
it was an idiotic masonic satanic ideal from the start, to completely destroy the empires and money of the world and create oligarch run "republics" to make everyone rootless deracialized economic tax slaves with no common God, ancestry or principles.
Black women kicked black men out the home to marry government and get free stuff. This is not men leaving.
That's the trouble with the social contract: Everyone who signed it are dead, therefore no one is beholden to it.
Social Contract theory is foolhardy to begin with
the problem is that all the white guys following it don't matter compared to all the new boat people who mock it openly
@@XtoDoubt25especially when it only obligates the citizens to the state, and the state feels no obligation to the citizens.
We're all not dead! People who went to school in the 60's and 70's were still pretty much taught to love our country and our Constitution. It's the people in my generation who became professors and left wing activists that brought us to where we are today.
You can see the 'sentimental' versus 'social contract' playing out on the UK train system at the moment, where the old paradigm where you would get on a train, speak to a (generally friendly) guard and buy a ticket there has been forcibly exchanged for mechanisation through being forced to buy tickets from machines at stations (if they work) and threats of fines if you even dare to set foot on a train without a ticket. The trains are still patrolled, but instead of guards willing to sell tickets it is now by 'fine enforcement officers' ready to hand out punishments for breaking the 'social contract' in its bluntest and most inhuman terms.
It was weird hearing you mention thanking the bus driver, I was thinking about this the other day. I always say cheers or thanks when I depart a bus, but I never see anyone else under 50 doing so
If youve ever been on a military base, especially a training base, ypull hear every last serviceman say “thank you sir!” When they get off the bus. It becomes a habit
I'm 25 and say it every time I get off the bus as I go to and from my Grandparents every weekend
It's common in the South.
Sargon is wrong here. The social contract in the United States does not grant the citizens rights. It recognizes those rights under natural law and the bill of rights as emanating from God. Not Granting them.
The Social Contract is more akin to: I vow to uphold this abstract notion of the contract, and in turn, I become part of the Society’s people. For example, I could become accepted as American within my lifetime. The same is not true if I wished to be an Englishmen, Japanese, or any other such society.
(editing)
@@Dr_Evil_Mc-Bad is this not similar to Ancient Rome, as a non Roman could acquire Roman citizenship by military service? Which is different from the early modern idea of the nation state.
@@thejustifier5566 what do you mean by the early modern idea of the nation state? nation states existed ever since antiquity. We have an extant example of an ancient nation state literally here and they're called the jews.
Ancient Rome was a sentimental society in its republican days since it only extended citizenship to the peoples of italy and only gave citizenship to foreign nationals who served the roman military for 25 years.
@@thejustifier5566 Not really. Citizenship in the ancient world (pre- Caracalla of course) was very different and worth a lot more due to it's exclusionary nature.
In the social contract, there is substantially less one needs to accomplish in order to become a full, accepted member of that society.
Additionally, it is not purely a legal concept we're talking about here, but moreso a philosophical one - an effort to describe the natures of various societies, rather than a legalistic description of citizenship and belonging.
Again, I would put forward the notion: How does the notion of becoming, and being accepted, as a traditional Englishmen seem compared to becoming a traditional American? One certainly seems much more difficult to accomplish than the other.
I think you guys took the term social contract too literally. I don’t think Carl meant it’s our laws or rights, more of it’s a “social” contract that you participate in to be a functioning member of society that benefits from the social games society offers.
Thomas Sowell has a great series of videos surrounding this subject
lol
@@judasescariot4626 the ✡ had a fascinating subject they were working on in science. Quite an explosive one actually. Seems a mouth breather and his cucks missed out on quite an opportunity because of their tribalist sentiments. LOL
He's wrong. There is no future in America with black people.
Things were better when Jazz was dominant in their culture. It was respectable, and musically its impressive. Now look at rap.
Jazz was also imposed from above by the elites on the masses.
@@thuglifebear5256If it was, but what did they do with music once Jazz was no longer imposed? You can call it a misallocation of freedom if you like.
@@thuglifebear5256 Lotta commies and drogas in jazz... 👀👀👀
2 days ago we were all Australians.
Today, after recent announcements we are tribes on an island.
Aboriginal, Convict, Immigrant and “mostly white” grifters.
The "American tribe" wasn't born until 1860, and didn't reach dominance until 1941. America wasn't meant to be one unified nation state, and forcing it to be one is unamerican.
Black Americans have different values, speak with a different accent, dress differently, name their children differently, have a different culinary tradition and even separate churches to whites. Saying tribes are not racial and an 'american tribe' is a thing is silly and stewpid.
Well... A hood rat is a hood rat. I knew plenty of white, Latino and Asian hoodrats growing up in Louisiana. There is a substantial overlap
Black American is an oxymoron in my opinion, because you can't be part of the American tribe if you chose to make yourself separate to the rest by emphasising your differences whether that be race religion gender or any number of things, it is our agreed upon commonalities that allow the tribe to exist.
@@stephenparker5241 - yah but they would never fit into Africa no matter how much they insist they are “African American.” They are uniquely their own culture in America.
And you can see that with the various regions in America. The SW is very different from the South. There’s even rivalry and differences between NorCal and SoCal. I’ve lived in both regions for many years and they are VERY different cultures.
In NorCal your weekends are not sacred. You are expected to work and the hustle is hardcore. In SoCal, weekends are sacred. People ask if you can work the weekends as a favor, not as a requirement like it is in NorCal. Totally different mindset. SoCal is much more shallow, flimsy, and plastic. NorCal is elitist, snobbish, and very much segregated by class and race. It’s just very very different and that’s all happening in ONE state.
Edit: spelling
they are closely related to it but not fatalistically tied to it. the republicans tried really hard to push the idea of a singular american tribe, the patriotic american filled with the necessary jingoism to overshadow close sentimental ethnic differences and conjoin these disparate tribes into one singular american identity.
Almost everyone else was willing to play into the game except for one tribe, blacks, and their enablers, the democrats.
I honestly believe that if blacks weren't part of the U.S, the Nation would be better even if it was filled with all manner of other tribes that are entirely different from each other, like the different european tribes, the different tribes of the arabian maghreb, the different asians tribes, and even the different subsaharan tribes, because you can clearly see that these groups are atleast willing to play into the game of assimilation to the greater american culture. They have no issue that the greater american culture, in its core, is born from protestant anglo saxon behaviors and ideals, the only group that does have a massive issue with this is the black american tribe.
I'm honestly not sure why that is, historical pains can be an explanation for it but they were still following the mantra in the early days of their emancipation by the republicans who wished to extend the social contract to the black american tribe, I guess the republicans didn't expect they would be betrayed by these people so eagerly.
@@kwazooplayingguardsman5615 They were given a country, a whole ass country, to go back home and settle, yet very few did. Historical pains are a bullshit excuse, especially today.
Sorry, but it does matter. History shows as much. Demographics=Destiny. Screeching at reality won't help you.
Why deny truth?
Sargon's misunderstanding of America stems from his projection of the parochial tribalism of England on to us. Also, what you see on the interwebs is not reflective of daily life for most of us. Shocking, I know.
He's also had a deep-seated urge to deconstruct the "white American" identity stemming from his humiliating encounters with the alt-right where his "what even is white" talking point was thoroughly mocked.
@@sneedchuckington Agreed. He has almost reasoned his way to understanding what Americans mean by 'white' a few times, but then returns to insisting it's a synonym for 'English'.
@@platoplombo15 It literally is. Germans other than Saxons weren't even considered white for years. The Irish weren't white for years. Italians still aren't white if you ask me.
@@giw_jones false. Naturalised citizenship in the early United States was restricted to whites and there is not a single example of an Irishman being denied citizenship based on their race, therefore by the legal standards of the time they were white. Same goes for Italians etc.
Even without getting into the fact that some of the founders were Irish.
@@sneedchuckington people cannot change, sadly
I'm kind to all the town NPCs in my simulation and believe that the parable of the returned shopping cart is a reasonable foundation for morality in the social contract.
The devs seem to be slow on fixing a few bugs that have sprung up the last few decades.🤔
@@sadwingsraging3044 that's actually a feature of the game, part of the main quest line. It's on the rest of us to unfuck the system we built for ourselves.
@@pfzht oh no you don't! I been firing off emails to the devs for three decades that the code had been corrupted and incomplete! Good thing I have a save point far enough away from where most of the glitches are occurring that I might weather the coming storm.🤠
@@sadwingsraging3044 I assure you that humans are currently playing the game incorrectly but thank you for submitting a ticket. Your commentary is important to us and will be addressed in the order received :P
@@pfzht all I wanted was an Exterminatus.Exe file! Is that too much to ask for?🥺
You can even make it a DLC!
Take my money!
Excellent work fellas.
I grew up in farm land US of A, the bread basket. Call me Iowan-American...even as I lived in Colorado and now in Kansas City Missouri. Good show blokes.
I love and am a Diehard member of the Metal-head Tribe
**whistling** Hair Metal _best_ Metal.🤘🏻😁🎸
Right on!
There was a famous paper? written by a guy who looked at US society as if it was a tribe that got pretty famous. It's called "Body Ritual among the Nacirema".
I'm from the south. My entire life, I've not seen myself as entirely "American" but Southern on top. Other parts of the country don't have that trait baked into them. They do often consolidate themselves into a mob that hates us often even northeastern rightwingers will pile on at times.
**Whistles Dixie** 😁👍🏻
I live and was born and raised in California. I don't identify with the majority of people in this state, so I'd describe myself as an American, not Californian.
Yeah, the South may be "conservative republicans," but we're not the same as rightwing Yankees, and we never will be. The Clairmont types will always look down their noses at us for our Spirit.
If one excludes the counties in the five metro areas with the worst homicide rates from the American statistics - St. Louis, D. C., Detroit, Chicago, Philadelphia - it used to be New Orleans but Philadelphia got worse - America is on average as safe as Spain or Italy. I would hazard a guess that were crime broken down by race within that skewed sample of American counties, black crime rates would not be anything near as disproportionately high.
That's interesting, and I'd have to look into that. I usually mention to the Euros looking down their nose at us that the white pop in America has the same murder rate as most of Europe.
A tribe, a tribe, a quest and a quest for knowledge. In this quest, I am seeking new experiences and exploring the reaches of my mind. As I progress along this journey, I will inevitably face challenges that may seem impossible. However, within each challenge lies an opportunity to learn more about myself and discover hidden talents and strengths that I never knew existed.
A tribe called quest
@@calstonjew correct.
the social contract is something ive recently learned about.. very interesting
More of these two together
E pluribus unum: out of many one.
E unus, pluribum... the new hotness.
Only when someone attacks us.
That was in reference to the 13 colonies that came together, not different people.
@@TheRyujinLP Not many E Asians there at that time ;-)
I don't think the US is too far gone. I'm biased because I live in the US, but day to day life is fairly normal. People manage to get along just fine. You just don't hear about it because that's the silent majority. The problem is the vocal minority, which is given voice by the mainstream. They're the ones trying to raise the racial consciousness of a population that, for the most part, just wants to grill.
I am of the Metalhead Tribe of West.
We are a crass, apathetic people. We look upon the evils of the world and sayeth, "Yeah? Well f-- you too."
🤘🏻😎🎸
Is Carl drinking on the job? I saw that flask. Churchill would be proud
If the US breaks down and balkanizes, my expectation will be that people will self-segregate into small monolithic Microstates (each about 2-3 dozen Counties or less in size) based on demographic commonality- be it race, religion, shared heritage, or sexual orientation (yes, I'm expecting the Leftists to set up at least one "Queer State" where being LGBTQ+ is literally a legal prerequisite for full citizenship). The endemic violence and turf wars between these Microstates is probably going to make the breakup of Yugoslavia look peaceful in comparison, and discredit Multiculturalism as an ideology.
@Possibly Layne Staley Are they? You really trust the tranny loving military?
It should be just a developmental phase that you look back on as an adult and either cringe or take some pride in but recognize that you have outgrown. In the case of a population that lives in a perpetual state of adolescence, stifled intellectually and up to their eyeballs in focusing on shallow externalities, you have a focus on loose tribal affiliations. Go, [insert sportball team name here]!!!
What’s this segment called on the website?
As we speak the American culture is coming back
Hello all
Hello, how is the weather?
@@voxsvoxs4261 Overcast and damp..
The link to your website isn’t working
My partner has no interest in politics, doesn’t watch the news, read or vote- yet makes snap ill informed judgements based on his leftist Facebook feed and left wing friends that Tories, conservatives and right wingers are generally evil. You have to actively hate Trump and Boris or there’s something wrong with you. Having even just a couple of nominally ‘right wing’ views is not an acceptable nuance. He just told me last night that ‘I’ve changed since we met’ and if he’d known what a ‘right wing bigot’ I was when we’d met we wouldn’t have got together. He bases this on the fact I
a. Occasionally watch GB News, b. voted Tory in 2019 (for the only time in my life)
c. defend Brexit even though I voted Remain.
He complains about ‘my’ Tory government and ‘my’ Brexit as if he knows what he’s talking about when he has ZERO knowledge, so certain is he that ‘right wing’ = ‘bad’ and Brexit = ‘bad’.
Yet he also doesn’t think illegal migrants should be allowed to stay in the country …. And he doesn’t think transwomen are women- so technically speaking isn’t he now just a horrid right wing bigot too?? I think our relationship may be coming to an end because I honestly am finding it harder to even have a conversation with him about anything. It’s very sad.
Absolutely spot on Carl, the Welfare State, and Biofemmes Empowerment Delenda Est
you can have welfare or open borders, never both
suffrage was legally universal and based on paying tax, so the tax thing would need to stop being taken
voting also required intelligence testing which was more important
@sea breeze females are half the population and biologically hardwired to have as imperatives seeking Protection and Provision. Thus, they vote for more and more welfare.
And that's before you take into account how they are Cognitive and Moralistic Children Adult only ever in body and they are shit at long term thinking, and considering the consequences of their actions.
The only thing that makes any females better than the rest cognitively is autism, but its no surefire thing because existence is a Spectrum of different Spectrums. It has to due with the autistic traits masculinizing their cognition, but even then those autistic females are still limited by their female nature
12 nations American nations.
Trump is going to be jailed. I can't wait for your tears!
"I've not really met anyone who was really on board with the Covid stuff"??! What a sheltered, insular life you must lead! I can't believe my ears!
Tribes aka culture is fine, but people need to stop basing their entire existence on a single identity. If you start breaking down identities, you ultimately just end up with individuals. Be part of a culture or multiple culture but maintain your individuality above all else. We need to build a better country together as individuals who defend our rights and the rights of those around us. There also needs to be at least some patriotism to hold people together.
The educational system now focuses so much on tribal identities and "uplifting" those tribal identities that any discussion of bringing everyone into one mainstream tribe (assimilation) gets you branded "colorblind" aka "racist".
See Victor Davis Hansen explain American citizens cannot be both tribal and American.
4:12 100%! oh boy was that disappointing
What the heck is the blinking red light at the bottom of the right half of the screen? Really distracting lol.
It's morse code for New world order. Illuminati confirmed. Sargon exposed.
I feel bad for those people who wanted to prevent another World War. They're forgetting how fucking bloody the first was, and that war was fought because of pure hubris. People like Chamberlain understood this fact, that's why they favored appeasment. Sargon has a hard time putting himself in the shoes of others or understanding historical context. I'm not saying appeasement was a good thing, I'm saying I understand the justifications for it. It's not because they hated Brittian or believed in the other side, they thought they were doing a good thing by preventing millions of deaths.
Disagreement with Carl when it comes to the English not caring about COVID policy.
My own family, my own parents turned against me for not getting the shot, to the point I had a mental breakdown by November 2021. The English (and Continental Europeans) are QUITE tribal.......
Americans on both sides of the aisle want to resegregate
They say they do, but urban lefties keep fleeing the hell-holes they created and invading conservative spaces. They haven’t learned their lesson, though - they insist on bringing their toxic ideas with them.
AY UP LOTUS EATERS
x
@@longriderxx Y
Metal tribe checking in🤘🏻😎🎸
@@sadwingsraging3044 HAIL BROTHER 🎸👍😎👌
@@2tone209 now you got me having to go listen to ManOwar.
_Hail! Hail! Hail and_ 😵
Talking about tribalism in any kind of positive context is pretty cringe, tbh. We are talking about far, far larger groups of people than the hundred or so souls that an individual's monkey sphere can handle; we need to be focused on the scale of societies and nations. Resurrecting tribalism only invites bloodshed.
A nation is the natural extrapolation of a tribe, even the UK acknowledged this "the united kingdoms" ~ plural ~ it means the multiple united tribes of the native inhabitants of britain (England, Cornish, Welsh, Scottish, Irish)
How exactly does your conception of tribes having customs and norms differ from the way Richard Spencer described whites as having a "way of being" different from other races? A position you got very mad about.
Exactly, this is just substituting the word tribe for race.
One is based on race and one is based on culture. Pretty self explanatory
because the idea that richard puts forth is a low resolution on WHY the different tribe/cultures do things and putting the onus on it being a differnc of race. thomas sowell wrote a book on it called 'white rednecks, black liberals'
Do you not understand the difference between race and culture?
@@GBNationalist Do you not understand that race and culture have strong correlations, despite them being definitionally different things?
Most nation states are in decline, not having enough kids. Especially in Europe. Nation states are also relatively new in the early modern era. If you go back to Antiquity as long as you had Roman citizenship and could speak Latin you were Roman.
I have colonial English, Scottish, Irish, Welsh, Swiss, French, German and Dutch ancestry before 1800. And Danish ancestors from the 19th century and some Cherokee snuck in there too ;-) The notion that I am American is superficial, I am from many tribes who found common cause in a New World. The post-WWII mirage is just that. America has died multiple times ... 1775 and 1861 for instance. We are a phoenix.
You miss the point, you can't claim to be English or Irish or any other flight of fancy that may have be detected in your family history. You were born in America. You will be distinctly American to any other foreigner who meets you. You are a product of your country and you couldn't be from anywhere else. The wide variety of peoples and cultures that made up the original pioneers to your country makes it unique to only America.
It is OK to be American.
@@stephenparker5241 - 100%. My parents were born and raised in S Korea but my mom came here when she was 20. I was raised to be very American. I barely speak Korean, I celebrate no Korean holidays. I grew up watching American cartoons and movies. If I go to Korea, they all know that I’m American. I look Korean but my tribe is America.
@@stephenparker5241 the only meaningful identity to claim would be White, but Sargon would have a problem with that.
@@stephenparker5241 called a category error
he belongs nowhere technically
@@umiluv American means nothing, a passport won't alter your DNA.
I really disagree with the idea that my country is in any way a "Social Contract" society, or that our nation doesn't have any sort of tribal or ethnic roots.
We fought because wanted our rights as ENGLISHMEN to be respected, we didn't just want to be a tool for our brothers in the British Isles to grow rich from through exploitation. This evolved into a war of independence. You will see that the ones most loyal to Britain, that would be New England, were the ones to put the most effort into the war; because we felt violated.
Upon independence our immigration was almost entirely from Northwestern Europe until the late 1800s when a bunch of Italians and undesirables fleeing the pogroms in the Russian Empire came. There exists a true and authentic American people; whose descent primarily comes through the British Isles.
I encourage you to read what our founding fathers said about immigration and American identity. I would encourage you to read "The Founders of the Republic on Immigration Naturalization and Aliens" by Madison Grant and Charles Stewart Davison.
I dunno, if there weren't figures like Thomas Jefferson in the founding fathers, I would have said you are right, but his preliminary works that is hailed as one of the cornerstone of the American Mythos give credence to the idea that your nation is a social contract nation. A nation that grew out of its sentimental origin which had to lean onto their social contract as it became more diverse and disparate from its parent culture. The republicans tried really hard to maintain that identity created by the social contract while maintaining certain imperative cultures (christianity) but they have failed spectacularly in the recent 7 decades.
@@kwazooplayingguardsman5615 you should read Jefferson's later work; particularly after leaving the White House. I think his own writing would push back against this idea.
Also, I would like to suggest that it is the Federalists such as Adams, Jay and Hamilton (and Washington; however much of an "independent" he might of claimed to be) who were the true strong foundation of this country, not really Jefferson or the Democratic-Republicans.
The Italians are some of the most Conservative and Patriotic people nowadays. This point is ridicuolous, most people assimilated.
This is why we have guns....
Carl "Amarica is falling apart and going to fall into civil war"
Me a Minnesota resident in a purple county
"...don't see it, but what do I know"
Hey fellow Gopher. I don't think Sargon 'gets' America and tends to project the parochialism and tribalism of England on to us.
I live in Arizona, a purple state, and the tensions are really bad here. People get their vehicles keyed for having Cali license plates.
@@Skeloperch Well Californians have ruined every state they've immigrated to. Even the "right leaning" ones are more permissive of leftie bs and will allow it to happen in their new states.
The big problem is we're sapping strength and unity constantly, at that point all you need is a crisis big enough to break the atrophied systems and then problems get very real very fast. Then it's less "defend your country " and more "defend your home, family and community, screw the rest."
@@Skeloperch That might have more to do with incoming Californians driving up the price of everything faster than Biden
It's genetic, please stop mystifying their behavior by chalking it up to, "I don't know, some other cultural differences". Knobs
it’s not genetic to punch a yew for being a yew
It’s not at all genetic.
@@joethewarthog blacks are violent everywhere they are regardless of the surrounding environment. Being an apologist for them now will do you no favor other than to make you a victim to them later
@@draconisthewyvern3664 no, that's usually because of something the yew did.
Member that time a yew raped and murdered a 13-year-old girl and tried to frame a black guy, and the uber-racists of early 1900s Georgia didn't buy it? They founded the ADL to try and spin that one.
@@joethewarthog MAO genes
It would be fascinating to see Oswald Mosley on Sargons show .
Isn't he dead? 🤔🤔🧐
@@MeanBeanComedy Yes
There is only one human race . . . but their are many breeds, due to historic geographic isolation effect on biology and mind. There are large wild wolves, tiny yappy lap dogs, agressive unpredictable pit bulls and somewhere in the mix, of canine breeds, the wonderful fur-shedding naturally mild tempered Labradors . . . that need much provoking before re-acting like their original ancestor when necessary
breed means the same as race aka sub-species
Can I get a QRD on what Boomer Truthers are?
Locus Eaters: Umpteenth video about "Demographics of England and/or [enter western country here] are becoming irreversible mate, this isn't good! Becoming minorities in our own countries, it's all over!"
Also Locus Eaters: Umpteenth display of cognitive dissonance with "Tribes are more important than race guys, like geez stop being so unoptical and just be a civ nat already. We're all one race and love is love man. Like, just accept the social contract and be around those that agree on a central governing framework."
How long time viewers may think that their views are genuine at this point is beyond me. Great grift, but also shameless.
I think you're not understanding what they are saying tribe is intrinsically linked to race, its race + culture, Social contract societies abstracts the culture away from the race but sentimental societies is congenial to both.
@@kwazooplayingguardsman5615 "One thing that I think is important...is now that we can get away from the concept of race. Because race is determined, right? You can leave and join a tribe." Literally in the first 30 seconds. If tribe is more important, and not race, then the videos pretending to care about demographic change are made dishonestly because the shared values of putting a shopping cart back in it's place is more valuable than the shared genetic makeup of the one that did it.
@@WAAAAAAGH It is linked to race but not fatalistic to it, Example, you can bring a small number of ghanians into the uk and disperse them into the general population and they will be forced to assimilate into the host culture given enough messaging, in that way, you will make ghanians who are english in mentality and culture but different in race IN THE OTHER SCENARIO, you bring a large enough number of ghanians, you concentrate them into one locale, and then give them a messaging that says to not assimilate, and they will not assimilate into the host culture instead they will practice and establish their OWN ethnic culture as unique tribe in the space that was once of the host tribe, they will then demand certain privileges and advancements BASED on their own seperate identity as a tribe.
As you can see, one enables the other thus is heavily linked with one another. The great republican experiment was to try and impose the social contract to EVERYONE including blacks, to make blacks adopt the abstraction of what it means to be an american citizen but obviously that experiment failed.
@@kwazooplayingguardsman5615 Yes, this is obvious. But theres still a contradiction in the messaging of the channel.
Is it the demographic change thats the issue or the lack of shared values/culture that is the issue? The (justifiable imo) demographic panic that is repeatedly put on this channel doesn't use the groupings of political values or traditions but that of obvious racial/ethnic makeup as the point of contention so I would say it's the former. Obviously the refusal to assimilate is the consequence of too much immigration, but the data, points, and charts that are brought up on this channel use the census results of native english/anglos to invaders, not british values to whatever the hell else.
There's no need to be a pedant about it, there's just a jarring and inconsistent left-right pull in the messaging of the ills facing the west (or the UK in relation to the example given above) on the channel, which makes me think that theres either a fear of leftist labeling which makes them cowards at best or a discovery of an easy monthly check from the fears of conservative westerners while not caring about the issues themselves through the cognitive dissonance on display in their own videos (like Tim Pool) making them dishonest grifters at worst.
@@WAAAAAAGH .... you're listening which is good but you're not thinking about it, your question is "Is it the demographic change thats the issue or the lack of shared values/culture that is the issue?" the answer is BOTH, both are the issues at play, and both interplay with one another very heavily thus both must be tackled simultaneously.
Finally some disambiguation about Scott Adam's nonsense; and all the race hustlers.
Too much focus on the tribal is what kills any Republic; All tribes need to coalesce around an agreement of participation or the stronger tribe will eradicate or blow out the centre as well as the fringes of their ideology.
Dictator Lincoln tried and failed. We are multiple republics.
Eminem?
Taylor swift?
Rebecca black?
Social contract lol Sargon is such a redcoat