Eddi Reader - Ae Fond Kiss

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лют 2009
  • Recorded at Celtic Connections, January 2009

КОМЕНТАРІ • 480

  • @Martyboy_Glasgow
    @Martyboy_Glasgow Місяць тому +6

    I may have commented previously.
    My brother suggested this song, this version, to escort my mother's coffin out of our church. My dad agreed. I have no recollection of that journey on the day but I know any challenge, personal or physical, I've had since , this song has always been to hand.
    Beautiful song.
    Beautifully sung.
    Thank you Eddi Reader!

  • @Miss-Placed.1
    @Miss-Placed.1 Рік тому +97

    My mum was Nancy, she died in 2013 and I miss her every day. I know the poem/song was written in a romantic context, but it's one of my favourites and always reminds of my dear wee mum. I've heard many people sing it but Eddi truly does it justice and breathes life into centuries old words ❤️

    • @franbreedlove9392
      @franbreedlove9392 Рік тому +4

      Truth! I have heard it sung by many people... No one comes close to her.

    • @user-ee7vr9nn8f
      @user-ee7vr9nn8f 5 місяців тому +1

      Your Mam was named Nancy but she is not Nancy only reminds you.

    • @davidgibson4840
      @davidgibson4840 5 місяців тому

      No Nancy is greater than the other... Leaving it there my friend .​@@user-ee7vr9nn8f

    • @louisaa.4614
      @louisaa.4614 4 місяці тому +2

      my mum who had dementia before she died always would whistle this song 😢

    • @gracekavanagh9198
      @gracekavanagh9198 4 місяці тому +2

      The Celtic woman also are amazing

  • @joyceharkin3641
    @joyceharkin3641 13 днів тому +1

    I had this played at my husband's funeral and the words were in his coffin. A beautiful song about love and loss.
    "Had we never loved so kindly
    Had we never loved so blindly
    Nor never met, nor never parted
    We would ne'er ha' been so broken-hearted" 💔💔

  • @ld3010
    @ld3010 Рік тому +12

    Every time I hear this song i think of my mother. She died coming up on 23 years ago. She loved all kind of Scottish folk songs. loved the Corries. But omg when i heard this by Eddie Reader I could have cried all day. So beautiful. She would have loved this.

  • @atiriareid3195
    @atiriareid3195 11 місяців тому +12

    Im a Māori from Aotearoa New Zealand with Scottish heritage through my father who was a Reid. This song & your singing makes something ring alive in my dna. My mothers Māoriside is real, passionate, intrinsic deep in my soul. This music sings to the other part of me LOVE IT XXXX

    • @alasdairwreid
      @alasdairwreid 3 місяці тому +3

      well . . .I'm an ancient Reid from the north of Scotland . . . with a pile of relatives in NZ (from the early 1840s . . .!!) , , , and this is a good auld Scottish song!!!

  • @davidanders2365
    @davidanders2365 13 днів тому +1

    This is 15 years old! Still at the top of my play list. I loved Fair Ground Attraction. Was lucky enough to see Eddie at The Basement in Sydney.

  • @paulmolloy6818
    @paulmolloy6818 7 місяців тому +5

    what a magic wee song and singer all the best from Australia PM

  • @johnmcglynn4164
    @johnmcglynn4164 11 місяців тому +7

    By far The Best version of this 👏👏👏💚🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @gracewilliams4802
    @gracewilliams4802 4 місяці тому +2

    This was one of my mum's favorite Burns poems. It was played as her coffin left the church.

  • @neilmaclean294
    @neilmaclean294 7 днів тому +1

    Beautiful Eddi, just beautiful.

  • @user-ln3gz1ib3f
    @user-ln3gz1ib3f 6 місяців тому +4

    I fell in Love with Eddie Reader back in the fairground attraction days I love her still today 💚☘️💚🙏

  • @mauriceogrady4447
    @mauriceogrady4447 24 дні тому +1

    A stunningly uplifting and deeply moving piece of music

  • @ainslieberrafella
    @ainslieberrafella 5 років тому +38

    This is real crying-intae-yer-pint-at-the-end-of-the-night stuff. Beautiful.

  • @annemilne100
    @annemilne100 10 місяців тому +6

    My mums favorite burns song mine is red red rose eddie does an excellent job on these I’ve saw her live several times she’s just perfect

  • @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY
    @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY 8 років тому +169

    Eddi's voice is the stuff of dreams. She is a musical enchantress. ❤️

    • @stewartnicol3028
      @stewartnicol3028 5 років тому +10

      Robert Loved Nancy in spite of her being wed tae anither. His spirit never got over his love for her. Here, in 2019, Burn's spirit still loves every single female that ever enticed him into her embrace. Love can only ever be one thing in spite of what society says. Love is Love.

    • @patsyballantyne9886
      @patsyballantyne9886 4 роки тому +3

      Yes

    • @derekjones2204
      @derekjones2204 2 роки тому +4

      I couldn't agree more

  • @lornarobinson1089
    @lornarobinson1089 Рік тому +8

    One of My mam's favourite songs. She died in 2018 and we played it at her funeral 😢. I thank you Mr Burns for the amazing words you wrote xx

  • @wm5113
    @wm5113 3 роки тому +13

    I never tire listening to this, choking back the tears. Makes me more proud to be Scottish. Thanks
    Eddie👍🏻😭🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY
    @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY 4 роки тому +23

    Burns still mourns the loss of his soulmate. Nancy. He loved his wife and children without reserve. However, Robert's heart burned for Nancy until they reunited in the afterlife. ♥️

  • @luciliacordeiro2626
    @luciliacordeiro2626 Рік тому +3

    Poor Nancy, ..... I am still in love with this song... Barry Mulcahy x

  • @louisebolton1773
    @louisebolton1773 2 місяці тому +3

    This was played at my Dad's funeral in 2020 and I couldn't be there because of covid travel restrictions..but I'm glad this, one his very favourite songs was played to help guide him home😢❤

    • @UniversalSoundAlchemy
      @UniversalSoundAlchemy Місяць тому

      I didn’t get to my dad’s funeral because of the travel restrictions either…I played and recorded all the music for the service…it still breaks my heart to have not been there…
      Best wishes to you 🙏🏼

    • @mauriceogrady4447
      @mauriceogrady4447 24 дні тому

      Your Dad would have maybe heard it from far away

  • @kanyewheast5695
    @kanyewheast5695 5 років тому +56

    this was played at my nana’s funeral today. It’s such a comforting song and is now the only thing I have left of her. Thank you so much for this beautiful song ❤️

    • @johnwilliams411
      @johnwilliams411 Рік тому

      Where are you from?

    • @sionyevans
      @sionyevans Рік тому +2

      no my friend...HER BLOOD RUNS IN YOUR VEINS, HER LAUGHTER IS IN YOUR EARS, HER FACE IN YOUR EYES..HER LOVE IN YOUR HEART...SHE WILL NEVER LEAVE YOU, SHE WILL ALWAYS BE NEAR YOU...GUIDING YOU..PROTECTING YOU...THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS, I KNOW THIS I FEEL IT...THEY DONT MISS US AS THEY VISIT ALL THE TIME...ASK HER FOR A SIGN...JUST IN YOUR MIND, JUST YOU AND HER...ITS EASY FOR THEM..BUT HARD FOR US TO SEE AND UNDERSTAND....BUT ITS AS NATURAL AS HER LOVE WAS FOR YOU...WOW IM GIVING MYSELF CHILLS, THATLL BE MY DAD, AGREEING WITH WHAT IM WRITING I HOPE THIS HELPS A LITTLE...❤

    • @franbreedlove9392
      @franbreedlove9392 Рік тому +1

      @@sionyevans I could not have said it better.💞 Emily Dickenson said " This world is not conclusion; a sequel stands beyond. Invisible as music, as positive as sound" They never leave, they just change form.

    • @catherinefairley2716
      @catherinefairley2716 Місяць тому

      Aye he did

  • @billsnooks6589
    @billsnooks6589 2 роки тому +10

    What a voice...if there are truely angels walking amongst us, then here she is!

  • @johnnyM809
    @johnnyM809 10 років тому +92

    The most beautiful love song ever in my opinion....Burns was a genius

  • @56Ronin56
    @56Ronin56 9 років тому +60

    For me , this is the definitive version of this song. Beautiful, heartfelt words, wrapped in a beautiful melody by an immaculate interpreter of Burns songs. I never tire of it.

  • @71gmf
    @71gmf 10 місяців тому +3

    I fell in love with Eddi, the first time I heard "Perfect" back in '88. Little that I know that "Perfect" was one of the least interesting songs of the Fairground attraction's debut album. Thanks to the internet I have heard her since on many live performances...
    I'm from Portugal, but I feel Eddi is as part of me as part of her scottish heritage.
    Thank you, my sweet Eddi!

  • @TheBSM100
    @TheBSM100 2 роки тому +13

    I’ve never once listened to this without weeping uncontrollably…..and I don’t really know why….it’s just THAT voice…x

  • @tartanteapot9387
    @tartanteapot9387 3 роки тому +41

    A cannae tell ye Eddi, how many times ave saw yer guid self in concert, but lemme just say, ye make me feel proud, no' only tae be born under oor great Saltire🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿, but tae be an amazin', fab n humble Glesga wummin'!❤ Nae maiter wherra am in the world, ma hairt aye comes hame tae 'Caledonia'. Thanks for all yer beautiful tunes ower the years, so many, the Burns Album, Galileo, Wings On My Heels, Kiteflyers Hill , they a' fill ma hairt wi' such joy, but at the same time hen, hiv me greetin' ma eyes oot like a big, daft lumpae a wean!😍😁😭. Oh the joys eh! Peace, health n happiness, ayeways!🎶🎙🎵

    • @wm5113
      @wm5113 3 роки тому +5

      What a fantastic comment, just readin it makes me proud to be Scottish 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿.. That sin brèagha / that's beautiful!

    • @tartanteapot9387
      @tartanteapot9387 3 роки тому +2

      @@wm5113 .... cheers fir that !👍 Greetings tae ye wherever ye are!🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @Northcountry1926
      @Northcountry1926 20 днів тому

      🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇨🇦

  • @56Ronin56
    @56Ronin56 11 років тому +14

    Well I'm English and I understand every word. A beautiful song beautifully sung. The definitive version!

  • @janesayers3000
    @janesayers3000 Рік тому +5

    What can you say - magnificent

  • @luciliacordeiro2626
    @luciliacordeiro2626 Рік тому +6

    Hauntingly beautifull.... one of the best songs I ever heard.. Barry Mulcahy

  • @stewartnicol3028
    @stewartnicol3028 7 років тому +28

    Eddi, Robert would have loved this! He would have also loved you.

  • @johannaweber9023
    @johannaweber9023 Рік тому +5

    My heart opens up on this song sung by Eddi Reader, all over my most favourite singer in my life.

  • @francesbreedlove3390
    @francesbreedlove3390 9 років тому +76

    I think this is the most beautiful song I have heard in years & it is because of this woman's voice... The emotions she puts into it.. I have not heard better for Ae Fond Kiss Thank you Eddi!

  • @johngibbs2
    @johngibbs2 Рік тому +5

    What feeling, This is one of the most beautiful songs I have ever listened to, if Burns imagined this !

  • @paull5708
    @paull5708 7 років тому +21

    Thanks Eddi... From an Irish fan, your Ae Fond Kiss will never be bettered! So beautiful!

  • @zeejimi4044
    @zeejimi4044 3 роки тому +11

    An absolutely FABULOUS rendition of a wonderful, wonderful song, by the incredibly talented Eddi Reader, who brings the true beauty of Robert Burns‘ work to the forefront. 100 points out of a possible 10 !!!

  • @KilgoreTraut
    @KilgoreTraut 6 років тому +53

    i'm no scot, but the first time i read this i was in tears by the end; this is a fittingly beautiful rendition of a incredibly tender poem, well done

  • @tiberiuskirk2111
    @tiberiuskirk2111 4 роки тому +56

    There's a thousand years of Scottish beauty in this wonderful artists voice. Eddi, now and forever

  • @JockLambert1972
    @JockLambert1972 3 роки тому +11

    I don’t think I’ve heard anything more beautiful in my life, I adore Eddi Reader 💖 & Burns wasn’t bad either was he 😁

  • @johnmerriam7844
    @johnmerriam7844 6 років тому +7

    This song is very deeply moving and brings me to tears every time i heard it

  • @lastbus
    @lastbus 5 років тому +7

    Eddi's coverage of Ae Fond Kiss brings tears to my eyes and being proud to have been to Rabbies graveside

  • @jimstirling7223
    @jimstirling7223 5 років тому +7

    A beautiful version of what I consider the best love song ever written

  • @calumroney7352
    @calumroney7352 7 років тому +19

    GOD BLESS YE MA FELLOW AYRSHIREMAN,yer the greatest poet that ever lived n yer words are timeless.

  • @TheBelroyal
    @TheBelroyal Рік тому +2

    I just keep coming back to this, wonderful

  • @TheBelroyal
    @TheBelroyal Рік тому +10

    Eddi is in my top 4 fave female vocalists, you can’t fake sincerity

    • @roderickcampbell2105
      @roderickcampbell2105 9 місяців тому

      @TheBel... "...you can’t fake sincerity" Yes, you can. Now, I am not knocking the singing nor the band nor the tune. But you can fake sincerity. I mean this sincerely.

  • @conachcraig
    @conachcraig 8 років тому +15

    One of the best times of my life was an evening spent listening to Eddi at Haddington Corn Exchange singing Burns songs. Ae Fond Kiss was so emotional and that memory will stay with me forever. It was also really great to get Eddi's autograph on our Burns cd ! A lovely lady.

  • @neilmclean4439
    @neilmclean4439 22 дні тому +2

    My Dad's funeral is on the 31st of May 24. We are going to play this version of the song at his service.
    Sleep tight Lachlan Cameron Hunter McLean ❤

    • @neilmclean4439
      @neilmclean4439 7 днів тому

      Ended up changing it to the Karen Matheson version. Sorry Eddi 😞

  • @footstompinleroyscott6892
    @footstompinleroyscott6892 5 років тому +7

    Fabulous.
    Nobody has done more for Burns songs in my time than Eddi Reader.
    Keep on.

  • @robertmiddlemiss6807
    @robertmiddlemiss6807 6 років тому +5

    My favourite singer of Burns' songs. Eddi is brilliant at totally focussing on the emotions in these songs and always gives a really mesmerising performance. I danced with her once at the Barrowlands ye know...

  • @nathandougal9361
    @nathandougal9361 7 місяців тому +1

    Song was played at my grandmothers funeral, means a lot to me

  • @kinnonkerr6532
    @kinnonkerr6532 8 місяців тому +1

    I fell in love with Eddi Reader a long time ago not just because of her beautiful voice she is a beautiful woman and I would love to see her live best wishes Kinnon.

  • @kimhall1431
    @kimhall1431 10 років тому +5

    Eddi Reader sings this version of Ae Fond Kiss beautiful. I love this song!!

  • @rieona3521
    @rieona3521 2 роки тому +2

    When my soul need to be healed, I visit this link. Truly beautiful.

  • @sionyevans
    @sionyevans Рік тому +2

    this is such a masterclass in feeling, and meadure, and I'm welsh wtf do I know...😆🙏
    but seriously iv let out some teats over last few weeks, and this just meets me, where I am emotionally...exquisite.. much love all that's what it's all about....

  • @lossiequine50
    @lossiequine50 3 роки тому +3

    The absolutely best rendition of Ae Fond Kiss, Eddi puts every ounce of passion into this..she is utterly glorious💙🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @dundee101
    @dundee101 Рік тому +1

    it have been said before ... but ...hen..... your voice.. your passion is a hymn to his memory

  • @shadyberero6809
    @shadyberero6809 3 роки тому +5

    A truly beautiful performance; such soulful, moving, emotional talent from Eddi Reader and what a perfect voice, brings Burn's words to life and brings me to tears whenever I watch it. Bravo Eddi

  • @gerardpoisson2042
    @gerardpoisson2042 4 роки тому +6

    wonderful! She sings with all her heart.....

  • @chunk828
    @chunk828 10 років тому +10

    It's all aboot the song and the beautiful sound of eddi's voice, braw...

  • @MrMusicguyma
    @MrMusicguyma 12 років тому +5

    One of my favorite songs, very evocative, sung very well by an emotive singer.

  • @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY
    @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY 10 років тому +25

    Nancy Maclehose - Robert never did get over her - I held her in my heart until my dying day - I never did forget her.

    • @johnwatson742
      @johnwatson742 4 роки тому +7

      My feelings for the love of my life my lassie Janice that I met during my army service in Edinborough I still love her after 60 years, some feelings never die

  • @yeechou9712
    @yeechou9712 10 років тому +7

    Loved this song instantly after I heard it at the Closing Ceremony last night

  • @steviesvideos319
    @steviesvideos319 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful!!!

  • @luciliacordeiro2626
    @luciliacordeiro2626 Рік тому +2

    "For to see her was to love her. I understand that sentiment well" Barry Mulcahy

  • @StubyStubyDoo
    @StubyStubyDoo 12 років тому +13

    I can honestly say that I have never heard a song more beautiful, or sung more beautifully, than this.
    I guess that this must be what perfection sounds like.

  • @hootie203
    @hootie203 8 років тому +8

    Eddi Reader.... Beautiful voice! 💖

  • @motomat2
    @motomat2 Рік тому +2

    Such a talented and beautiful pers.

  • @rhinely850
    @rhinely850 8 років тому +33

    I can listen to this over and over. Eddi's singing shows the emotions of a broken heart perfectly. As do the words of Burns, of course.

  • @fattwat1
    @fattwat1 5 років тому +4

    This woman should have been a world wide superstar

  • @clareomalley5644
    @clareomalley5644 8 місяців тому +1

    Eddie Reader is a gift to the World, When I feel sad her voice and spirit life me .

  • @shimnaman
    @shimnaman 3 роки тому +2

    Great song and singer... Never miss her concerts in Belfast. 👌

  • @marymamiekelly635
    @marymamiekelly635 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful singer !

  • @ivangilchrist1352
    @ivangilchrist1352 4 роки тому +1

    10 Years gone by and I have missed you Eddi...You heart breaker. Love you still

  • @jimstewart3239
    @jimstewart3239 Рік тому +2

    One word outstanding 👏

  • @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY
    @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY 6 років тому +9

    The song was written to be sung by one such as Eddi, a spirit who lived and loved with that of Burns. I love her in this life as in some past existence.

  • @KateNord
    @KateNord 7 місяців тому +1

    Wow that's so beautiful! ✨🎶🎶

  • @pilotactor777
    @pilotactor777 2 роки тому +1

    This is mae first tame. It's brilliant. Mae tears cannae stop flowin xxx

  • @sandrabotwright7632
    @sandrabotwright7632 4 роки тому +2

    Such a beautiful song. Thanks you Eddi

  • @lennon1005
    @lennon1005 4 роки тому +44

    This is the most beautiful song i have ever heard. and it reminds me of my ex who i will love to the day i draw my last breath and on my death bed i will be thinking of her😭❤️

  • @JohnBrown-dh5kn
    @JohnBrown-dh5kn Рік тому +1

    This is the best song ever

  • @lastbus
    @lastbus 5 років тому +14

    Having a wee burns supper down under in Whakatane to celebrate Burns life Think Ae fond kiss is one of his all time classics.Ae fond kiss and then we sever
    Ae fareweel, alas for ever
    Deep in heart-wrung tears I’ll pledge thee
    Warring sighs and groans I’ll wage thee
    Who shall say that fortune grieves him
    While the star of hope she leaves him
    Me, nae cheerful twinkle lights me
    Dark despair around benights me
    I’ll ne’er blame my partial fancy
    Nothing can resist my Nancy
    For to see her was to love her
    Love but her, and love for ever
    Had we never loved sae kindly
    Had we never loved sae blindly
    Nor never met, nor never parted
    We would never have been so broken-hearted
    Fare thee weel, my first and fairest
    Fare thee weel, my best and dearest
    Thine be like joy and treasure…
    Peace, enjoyment, love and pleasure
    Mmm, ae fond kiss, and then we sever
    Ae fareweel alas, for ever
    Deep in heart-wrung tears I’ll pledge thee
    Warring sighs and groans I’ll wage thee

  • @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY
    @StewartNicolasBILLYCONNOLLY 5 років тому +6

    Burns went to his grave with the memory of Nancy, Mrs MacLehose, the soulmate that he could never be with. Robert loved...he loved unconditionally - the women that Robert loved would have plead his case before the Kirk Session. He loved them and they loved Robert. Love is really all there is.....

  • @stewartnicol3028
    @stewartnicol3028 4 роки тому +12

    Oh my God, my dreams are haunted by Nancy. These days she is incarnated as Eddi Reader....

  • @robertmontgomery8209
    @robertmontgomery8209 3 роки тому +3

    An Amazing voice. She sings this from the Heart.

  • @hughtroy645
    @hughtroy645 8 років тому +5

    Great song wonderful rendition Hugh Troy

  • @Terence-gq8lh
    @Terence-gq8lh 2 місяці тому

    What a singer! And what a beautiful song!

  • @ThomasKelly669
    @ThomasKelly669 10 місяців тому +1

    It’s amazing Nancy Craig was my 5x grt grandfather’s Lord Judge William Craig’s Niece From his Brother Andrew, ❤️to the eternal memories ❤️

  • @user-tb2rv7sz2n
    @user-tb2rv7sz2n 4 місяці тому

    My lovely mum Nancy. died in 2012. Love to her always .

  • @emilegallin3506
    @emilegallin3506 7 років тому +1

    Just bought her double "The Best Of" album (2016), beautifully performed and very well recorded. Over 2 hours of happiness! STRONGLY RECOMMEND.

  • @DavyCooper-we2rz
    @DavyCooper-we2rz 3 місяці тому

    What a performance of the greatest love song ever from the greatest country in the world the Robert Burns will be proud of you Eddi you've taken a great song to another level you are a star

  • @lauramenzies9042
    @lauramenzies9042 6 років тому +2

    Absolutely fantastic.

  • @thestevenkirk
    @thestevenkirk 10 років тому +10

    gives me goosebumps, amazing lady!

  • @stewartnicol3028
    @stewartnicol3028 6 років тому +27

    If Nancy recorded in her diary "This day I will never forget, for this was the last day I saw Robert" - If this was how Nancy recorded her feelings, then how much more did Robert feel the loss of his relationship with Nancy? He wrote "AE FOND KISS"

    • @rogerdavies8586
      @rogerdavies8586 3 роки тому

      It's Robert' s reputation as a womaniser that makes the singer suspect he didn't take long to get over Nancy.
      Marianne using Roger's computer

    • @jsemplefelton5348
      @jsemplefelton5348 2 роки тому

      @@rogerdavies8586 - Robert may have loved the lassies but by the same token the lassies loved Robert. He wrote romantic poems to each what other 'womaniser' did that.

  • @Cani33ia
    @Cani33ia 2 роки тому +1

    This is just beyond wonderful. I wish I could have shared it with my Grandmother who loved Burns but I'm about 30 years too late

  • @avabloor3842
    @avabloor3842 6 років тому

    Nothing is better than a heartwarming Scottish song

  • @dmd9080
    @dmd9080 9 місяців тому +1

    The best version of this song, from an ardent Corries fan. Incredible.

  • @potdog1000
    @potdog1000 4 місяці тому

    beautiful, just beautiful

  • @jamesmarshall1650
    @jamesmarshall1650 3 роки тому

    I worked for an audio cassette magazine for blind and partially sighted and we interviewed Eddi when she was expecting her first child in 89/90 ( i think she was just forming THE PATRON SAINTS OF PERFECTION What a lovely girl and her happy heart driven talent has been a blessing in my life

  • @WeeJoePrice
    @WeeJoePrice 3 роки тому

    No words.....Just Brilliant, Every Time I Watch / Listen.......

  • @juliareadscottishpiperandh4861
    @juliareadscottishpiperandh4861 3 роки тому +1

    stunning. What a wonderful tone Eddi has to her voice