Our leaders do not work for us but for The World Economic Forum and other elite global organisations. Our leaders are mere puppets controlled and manipulated by an invisible evil hand behind the curtain. United we stand, divided we fall. The people of Gaza and Israel are not the problem--it is our leaders who are creating all these conflicts. Is it possible that this was a false flag operation? Have you considered the possibility that Hamas and the Israeli government are both owned and controlled by the same invisible evil hand hiding behind the curtain??? Are we watching a puppet show with a script based on fear and hate? Could it be that victims on both sides are real but that the events have been staged? There are truly evil people on this planet who firmly believe that the end justifies the means.
There is NO such thing as a moderate Left. What an absurd idea. The left is where Govt tyranny comes from, lol. The bigger Govt gets the Bigger YOUR problems get. The Socialist political spectrum is only a small FAR LEFT slice of the real political spectrum. Politics is "the administration of Govt." That is measured by SIZE AND SCOPE not the boots you wear. The problem with Europe is you have never tried anything outside of the Socialist political spectrum. You went from Monarchy's to Socialism in one nasty shite-filled step. Far right wing America under team George Washington (a real far right extremist) farts in Socialist Europe's general direction..... No right wing American in our entire History has ever advocated ANY flavor of European style Socialism. That would be the anti-American Democrats who are itching to lose another Civil War.
The left is incapable of doing so. It’s like they keep sticking a metal knife in an outlet and expecting a different outcome. It’s truly amazing, but in a bad way.
Government is to blame for creating the crisis but we wouldn't be in this mess if we stopped giving away our power to politicians. The people of Gaza and Israel are not the problem--it is our leaders who are creating all these conflicts. Is it possible that this was a false flag operation? Have you considered the possibility that Hamas and the Israeli government are both owned and controlled by the same invisible evil hand hiding behind the curtain??? Are we watching a puppet show with a script based on fear and hate? Could it be that victims on both sides are real but that the events have been staged? There are truly evil people on this planet who firmly believe that the end justifies the means.
The govt is too blame for all current homeland issues. Austerity and QE(filtering our money that didn’t trickle down) into their business buddies pockets. Never has there been a time when the British tax payer has been so fleeced. Even parasites in local councils on £750kpa!! For a public servant and councils don’t even want to talk too their paymasters anymore. Thieves of greed, lies and deceit.
I cannot see the two other comments here. Can you? Censorship is such a bad idea. I want to be offended by rude comments but YT is trying to protect my feelings - it seems.
We have democracy, we are a collective of idiots who vote for these governments. Lets blame ourselves, not exterior forces all the times like weak little pathetic victims.
😂😂😂 that's uncanny . Your post literally encapsulates why channels like this are popular: they tell you what you already believe and want to believe . They literally provide you with comfort and reassurance about a complex world. You do realise a few years ago some right wing mouthpiece spewing propaganda to camera would have seemed Orwellian.
This guest has spoken what I "feel" in my Country at the moment, the UK. My Lineage seems to be outnumbered within my ancestral home, the UK, by another group. The sheer scale of the protests is making me feel very, very Un cosmopolitan and I am feeling very frightened to the point of wanting to be with "My people" ... but who and where are they? These masses are not from my lineage but my lineage has gone so do I as a human simply join them?
You are not alone, the only hope is the rest of our people wake up sooner than later and stand together. That goes for Europe and North America. If we continue to sleep walk into this for much longer we will be too late.
Our leaders are importing an invading army that collapses wages, skyrockets crime, and destroys society - exactly what our worst enemy would do if given power.
I 'feel' it too. Our governments don't necessarily have our interests at heart. It's about time, everyone, pause for a moment and realise wherever you are in the world, we are only pawns in their murderous profitable game, played at the top by a handful of megalomaniac scientists and billionaires, gangsters and governments, they're having a laugh.
I've been listening to Bret for yrs now & he's so grounded in his understanding of the world, also listened to Neil for many years, so hearing them both speak about such terrible times is really interesting.
@@theGefilteFist A very significant portion of the world believes government ("democracy" if you like) is the *solution* to problems created by individuals in the private sector ("corporations" if you like)
It has always been like that. It will always be like that. All that we can hope for is for us, The People, to have enough power to be able to force the Governments to aquiesce to our needs and demands, and for us The People to have the moral values and wisdom to know what is good, what is bad, how to promote the good and limit the bad. Permanent Cold War between the heavily-armed, freedom-loving People, and a paranoid Government. This is sadly the best case scenario as I see it.
I've been saying this for years. I am not a PhD like Bret Weinstein, and I am not a connected politician. But I don't have to be any of those things to plainly see that diversity is not a strength. All I had to do was see things as they are, the bottom line. And spoiler alert, there are no solutions presented in this video.
The trouble is that most people WE vote in to make our rules and give them the ability to "control" the rest of us ACTUALLY only ever think of what "they" can get out of this "control" not "how do I make the society better" ?????
The sad fact is the vast majority of people want to be led. Whether it's to the land of milk and honey or over a cliff is irrelevant. Since there is no accountability in our system of governance it's inevitable we are on the road to the cliff.
We can’t let it happen we have to wake up. Someone commented on another video that she thinks she will be cancelled out. It’s sad and scary she should feel that way
Weinstein is mistaken that Western brilliance is based on abandoning ancestral identification in favour of metropolitan values. All of the great successes of the West came about during a time of European demographic dominance and quite a heavy dose of racial solidarity. Unfortunately Jews like Weinstein have used their disproportionate influence to undermine white racial solidarity. Jews had a big influence in undermining white immigration policies to America & Australia. The same is true in Britain to a lesser extent. Now that it is becoming clear that an alliance has formed amongst islamists, the left and "brown" identifying immigrants who view Jews as "white" and "priveleged" you will see them pivoting toward immigration control and civic nationalism. But if we are to survive as a coherant ethno-cultural group then European peoples need ethno-nationalism. We cannot compromise on that.
bollocks, we need to use our minds in the most advanced methods of analysis possible and avoid ethnic allegiance traps that will deviate our actions towards tribalism rather than cooperation and just sharing of resources
@@24haikus bollocks, you will be overtaken by other tribes if you maintain a civic minded liberalism like that. Race is real and we are evolved beings with an interest in propagating ourselves and our kin into future generations. Your desire to overcome basic evolutionary and historical conditioning will leave you unable to grapple with the nature of reality. The civilisations you attempt to build with your outlook on the world will simply be infiltrated and co-opted by patriarchally minded tribes with a higher sense of asabiyyah than you/
Perhaps, but maybe they are playing Christians against Muslims to achieve world dominance??? When the dog and cat are fighting, the rat runs away with the cheese!!! How else can a rat win when both the dog and cat are stronger and bigger? Imagine, however, if the cat and dog ignore the cheese and together focus on the rat!!!! Just because the rat wrote the script(ure) doesn't mean we have to follow it. United we stand, divided we fall. If we work together, we can all share and enjoy the cheese--but good luck getting the rat to agree when it believes God promised him the cheese!!!!
They wanted to a) give us a taste of what Israel is experiencing to get the West on side b) encourage their people to leave the West and move to Israel
The "lineage" ties always underlie everything - even in Cosmopolitan societies. Nobody in their right mind would let their own children starve, because someone halfway across the world is "needy," for whatever reason. Yet the U.S. govt is following exactly that insane scenario - us taxpayers pay for everything, while our leaders spend/waste infinite amounts of our taxes on OTHER nations, while refusing to spend any of our taxes in America.
A very simplistic analysis. Our aid abroad has lifted all boats ever higher. But it is true that newly developed nations are not the Great markets they once were and now increasingly directly compete.
The US (and all Western Govts) are not helping other countries. They use International Aid to fund foreign opposition parties and asset strip the nation state sending the money out of domestic realms and into the pockets of the International elite. Just look at the wealth theft from the US to the Investment Management class.
It's worse than that. They spend FAR MORE than our taxes, and the rest hits us in inflation, the invisible tax, which they lie about and manipulate the numbers to gaslighting us over, claiming it's far less than it is, while blaming "capitalism", which this is not.
@@MsDamosmum no hes using double speak. He seeks a multiracial society and believes lack of adoption of this idea is the reason for the problems with tribalism. His talk of resources is typical leftist bable
@goodlookinouthomie1757 This time, there will be no winners. The aim is to reduce the global population to a few 10s of millions. The true "great reset"
Japan is the country I admired the most....safe, clean and wealthy.....what's its secret?.....its homogeneous society...more than 90% pure ethnic Japanese.....they all share the same culture and values.....with cosmopolitan societies...you have different groups of people with different sets of culture and values....I think that's the root cause of the problem
@@m0ose0909 Not quite. They will likely achieve stability through use of tech/automation to replace young workers, and retain societal coherence precisely due to said homogeneity.
@@m0ose0909 I think this is exaggerated by the Western media...Japan's population right now is around 120 million...more than 100 million of that are pure ethnic Japanese...that's more than all the pure Danes, Swedes, Norwegians, Finns, Irish, French, and Spaniards combined....according to most projections..yes..Japan's population will decrease steadily and by the year 2050 will reach its lowest at 80 million (this is still more than all of today's pure English, Scots, Welsh, Irish, French combined) before gradually increasing again
So what you are saying is, Diversity is the "divide and conquer" agenda peoples strength? Who could have guessed it? Especially when always focused on divisive differences instead of commonalities and shared vision.
japan like most of the western wold sits at the end of the largest population boom in human history, where they like the rest of us pretty much quadrupled their population in just the last century, population collapse is really not the issue many try to make it out to be.@@m0ose0909
What happened to C○vid? Oh yes, Ukraine What happened to Ukraine? Oh yes, this Meanwhile what is happening about excess deaths and culpability? Oh wait...
This is my opinion. This whole war (and Ukraine to a lesser extent, I think that was a lucky coicidence for TPTB and also maybe a calculated distraction from post-covid woes on Putin's part) is a huge distraction from the avalanche of data/studies/enquiries etc. about the disastrous 'pandemic' response and the dangerous 'panacea' injectibles. Israel was Pfizer's 'laboratory'. What better population to also use as the primary distraction from Nuremberg 2.0. Screaming irony.
To quote John McEnroe, "you cannot be serious" if you actually believe that the most sophisticated military defense/intelligence system in the world, was breached by a bunch of guys on tractors and earofoils! Come on people!!
I am curious as to why it took them so long to respond to the incursions. Some reports say it was as long as 6 hours before there were boots on the ground to repel Hamas. Incompetence? Complacency? Treachery? Something else...?
@@dexine4723 The entire divisional command was wiped out by an attack on its HQ and the electronic border warning system was destroyed or failed. It was a dysfunctional system where technology replaced boots on the ground. They wont make the same mistake again.
It's becoming clearer that having Christianity as the moral framework for Western society was highly beneficial. The morality of the West has been steadily decreasing over the last 50 years.
Christian "morality" of tolerance is partly why Europe is in the mess it is in. I do not share any kinship with a black, Muslim or Jew. I only care what is good for me and the English people.
Christianity was humanity's Golden chance at brotherly love...the books of Acts shows how shocking and jaw dropping it was for Apostles and disciples and perhaps even more RIGHT NOW.
Let the actors on the stage perform in front of an empty room. Let's walk out of the theatre and let the puppet show go on without us. Nobody can force us to participate. They need our energy and attention because without it they are powerless!!!! The psychopaths behind the curtain need us but we don't them at all. We can write our own script based on love rather than fear and hate. The best way to deal with psychopaths is simply to walk away and refuse to play. It’s important, however, that we speak out and expose the truth to help break the cycle of Mass Formation. Don't be a star trapped with fear in a jar--your voice is the key so don't ever give it away! Star Outside the Jar by Frans Kuiper I’m singing a song, it belongs to me, Using my voice is what makes me feel free. Rising in frequency vibration sound, Words are for sharing and passing around. Everyone has their own key to the door, Give it away and you’ll always be poor. When you are creator YOU are the star, A driver in control of your OWN car. Never stop singing, drawing or writing, Believe in yourself, truth is worth sharing. The present is now for you to open, A gift to be sung or simply spoken.
The balance has been tipped for so long in lies, that the truth appears and that means an equalisation .. I have no doubt at all that this tyranny will stop .. The method of change? that is up to people knowing the truth .. In essence .. Truth wins.@@lizaroedewaller-bridge407
Instead the US is blowing up pipelines on the sly to keep purchasing from the Middle East. I think it’s a long term play. Wait until the Middle East eventually dries up, then who will be holding all the cards?
Bret Weinstein’s view of the Cosmopolitan West is interesting. The West is supposedly competing with the multi-polar world of BRICS. In the multi-polar world states cooperate according to their best interests. In the West, states are not homogenous and so, for example, a Palestinian minority in London can undermine the view of the UK to the point where the UK can make no meaningful contribution to the crisis. This is a separate problem from the fact that Western governments have simple been appallingly bad over a number of issues.
The last gentleman to speak pretty much hit the nail on the head with his commentary. The big question now is how do we as Americans react to reverse the mess we find our country in?
Who are the geniuses behind Holocaust denial and behind 'Christians' hoarding, leaving civilization, imagining themselves virtuous (Which Kenneth Clark said was the most wicked of traits.) and this Lazyboy hoping for The End? I spend my online time fighting both, as both a 1970s Catholic and a gentile classical musician of 76 with memories. Thanks, Bret and Neil...more, please.
Amongst all the horror, chaos and divisiveness it feels good to hear an overview that makes alot more sense to me. Yet, it still leaves a question in my mind, of how, as a species, do we re-address the balance?
Extinction is not on the table - but the demise of global industrial civilization will FEEL like extinction to a very large percentage of the population of the developed world.
Our professional, managerial and political classes spent their formative young adult years in a frivolous liberal bubble. The university system has a lot to answer for.
We should not expect the rules of war to be followed by people outside of Europe. The Treaty of Westphalia has been observed so long, we almost take it for granted. But others have never heard of it.
@@jaynetui8817 If your mind is pickled from birth into ethnic resentment and thousands of years old blood libel then yes, I guess you can see it from a different paradigm.
@jaynetui8817 I was being flippant meaning watching on TV far removed it appears nonsensical, rather different when confronted with it on your doorstep
@@JewrejHanuca her quote if she said it the quote has given her fame noterioty not sure about wealth she uttered those words to annoy white folks a favourite jewish pastime hobby 😂
No. It was going on strong at least 5 years before that, or Jordan Peterson either for that matter. But before that nobody was listening to canaries in the coal mine, like those from and around Elevatorgate or the gate of the gamers. Brett was so late to the party, and still talking some woke talking points himself when he first turned up, that his problems at Evergreen looked like the deserved consequences of his own ideology... that the creation had turned on it's creator, who was then running for help and changing his tune, but without ever acknowledging his own likely role in the build up of the situation. Don't get me wrong, I like the Weinsteins a good deal and listen to him and his Brother and wife often, but there was definitely stuff in the early conversations he had that was concerning.
@@TheJeremyKentBGross It was when they realised they could force Evergreen to do as they wished. Forcing White people off campus, having the staff grovel to them, whilst simultaneously the whole student thing and C16 bill was happening in Canada and they were getting Jordan pushed out, that they realised by joining forces they could create this ideology if they all got behind each others causes. So the feminists, the LGBTQ crowd, and later the BLM mob, and all lefty causes joined forces, and the woke movement was born. Sure it was all there before, but in order to create the "baby" the various factions had to "have Sex" with each other. This is where woke began, and like a malignant cancer it has spread uncontrollably and they won't rest until they have killed the patient, or are removed with some Chemotherapy also known as common sense.
No. He is saying that those who promote "rootless cosmopolitanism" for others but who themselves compete deploying in group preference are tearing at the social fabric. Marx, a Jew, said as much in his essay "On the Jewish Question." This problem has been ongoing in the West for one thousand years.
@@scottwatrous7649 Marx? The father of communism? A Jew? Just like Barbara Lerner Specter- a jew,a zionist and promoter of diversity in Europe. Jews are our greatest allies.
Bret aptly describes the evolutionary bases for co-operation (shared genes & reciprocity). The problem is that many civilized people refuse to allow themselves to consider that their altruism and co-operation have any instinctual genetic basis -- insisting instead that altruistic and cooperative behavior is driven by reason.
These pro-Hamas demonstrations this last fortnight have been a much-needed eye-opener for our pathologically optimistic liberal middle-class. So hopefully good will come of all this.
Not 'optimistic' Mate - Marxist. They aren't 'virtuous', that's just a smoke-screen. And they are not 'gullible' or 'incompetent' - we mustn't give them that excuse. They are COMPLICIT and TRAITOROUS. None of this is 'accidental' - it stretches credulity too far to imagine that EVERY politician in both parties can't see what every ordinary Joe can see. They CAN see - this is a DELIBERATE Neo-Marxist attack on Western values.
So who exactly is Bret referring to when he says a ‘group of people are extracting wealth’ (which most can see and could argue goes a lot further than just that), which is causing the undesired state of unrest in the “superior western” model of civilisation?... Why is it anti-semitic when we say it but objective truth when he says it?
The best way to deal with psychopaths is simply to walk away and refuse to play. It’s important, however, that we speak out and expose the truth to help break the cycle of Mass Formation. Don't be a star trapped with fear in a jar--your voice is the key so don't ever give it away! We are the true stars and we don't belong in jars!!! Star Outside the Jar by Frans Kuiper I’m singing a song, it belongs to me, Using my voice is what makes me feel free. Rising in frequency vibration sound, Words are for sharing and passing around. Everyone has their own key to the door, Give it away and you’ll always be poor. When you are creator YOU are the star, A driver in control of your OWN car. Never stop singing, drawing or writing, Believe in yourself, truth is worth sharing. The present is now for you to open, A gift to be sung or simply spoken.
But it's not necessarily about being "richer". And even in a wider sense being "richer" means being surrounded by our expanded "family". When a Labour Jewish MP complained about feeling like an outsider that's what she meant. You can have all the treasure that you like, but if you're surrounded by people that are different there will always be conflict of one kind or another, within or without.
if the fourth political theory can become a bit nicer and more sanitized in terms of high standards in due diligence, including local metrics on human rights, then it would be a much better solution, because it claims that those who absolutely WANT to be different, need a territory of their own to be that and have that. This is because at the same time it refutes "universalism" and grants local moral sovereignty, allowing the different religions to function and develop their societies in good ways.
When Brett talks about lineage he misses a crucial aspect of it. Parallel to that lineage runs culture and customs, common behaviours, values. This I believe is the biggest source of conflict when different lineages share or contest ownership. The cosmopolitan West has sought to ignore this in order to facilitate the global reciprocity Brett talks about but it is there. When an established culture finds that threatened by a significant outside group requiring the existing to change to accomodate there will be resentment. This is particularly relevant in the middle east since the establishment of Israel. I havent a clue how this will be resolved but it seems clear to me that offering Palestinians parcels of land where they have autonomy where once they had autonomy over the whole region is will not alleviate the resentment for many years yet. It is also relevant throughout Western Europe with increasing levels of immigration. Treating difficulties as purely about lineage prejudice and a need to be inclusive and tolerant misses the point. Until issues around the affect incoming cultures have on the existing are properly recognised and considered these problems are going to get bigger.
Cultural differences are secondary to material needs (or material desires ). As you note, the issue in the Middle East isn't primarily differences in lineage - it has more to do with land taking and displacement (and a many decades long history of attacks and counter attacks).
Love Neil Oliver. The most interesting journalist in the Country and good on GB News for giving him the platform to enlighten us. What a fascinating discussion.
From the point of view of anthropology and psychology, we are doomed. I think that in the future the only salvation (or end) will be artificial intelligence. The one based on quantum computing. Homo sapiens evolved to live in harmony and happiness in groups of up to 120 people. Above this number, other people exist only as statistics. Of course, we have a certain morality and let's call it a kind of enlightenment, there is also empathy, the ability to have a broader picture, but what percentage of people are we talking about here? And unfortunately these people never want to become politicians. This doesn't look good at all.
Although I don't like GBNews, and try to avoid it as much as possible, the expert here is completely correct. Tribalism is coming right back and especially so in times of crisis.
Islam is the key factor here and too many are dancing around it. Everyone is afraid of being called a racist while Muslims worship a god, that in writing demands everyone submit and face a rock in Mecca during prayer and kill anyone who refuses. The problem is a spiritual one. Without understanding the bible and the history of Israel one is without a clue as to the solution.
I think, according to Hazony, What Bret calls cosmopolitanism is really based on what Hazony calls the Liberal Construction Quote: ““In reducing political life to the individual’s pursuit of life and property, Locke did not merely offer an impoverished and unsuccessful account of human motivation and action. His political theory summoned into being a dream-world, a utopian vision, in which the political institutions of the Jewish and Christian world-the national state, community, family, and religious tradition-appear to have no reason to exist. All of these are institutions that result from and impart bonds of loyalty and common purpose to human collectives, creating borders and boundaries between one group and another, establishing ties to future and past generations, and offering a glimpse beyond the present to something higher. An individual who has no motives other than to preserve his life and expand his property, and who is under no obligations other than those to which he has consented, will have little need for any of these things. Without intending to, the dream-world offered by Locke’s Second Treatise rendered most of the Protestant order senseless and superfluous.” The cosmopolitan west is in severe danger because, by its liberal consent centric permissive nature, it doesn’t live within its means. See also Mary Eberstadt, her work re sexual revolution
The Tower of Babel, aka the world's first Utopia project, didn't work then and just cause were using steel and glass now doesnt make the idea any less dumb
Bret's opening remarks blaming Hamas for this atrocity are wildly ignorant and I am appalled to see him not acknowledging Israel's highly obvious abandonment of their own border security for an impossible 7 hrs or more. Israel is COMPLICIT in this development and could not plausibly have been blind to the build-up and planning to Hamas' incursion.
You have to 'break a few eggs' to grift $100B in unaccountable _baaksheesh._ The much anticipated House 'Renewable Energy' Bill has provision _to skim $34B right off the top for the Pentagon,_ which itself has never been audited by an outside Big 4 reviewer. Paneta's 'attempt to audit' was actually 'cleaning up the loose ends' from the 9/11 Coup. The Y2K backup of Congressional investigations into Pentagon malfeasance, was also destroyed on 9/11, when the NJ data warehouse hard drive was 'accidentally erased.'
I disagree with Bret's premise. I don't think "lineage vs. lineage displacement" is the threat or is even relevant right now. It's certain that the powerful are running roughshod over the powerless, and that governments are not acting in the interests of the people, but that doesn't have anything to do with lineage. "Reciprocity" just has a dark side, too. Like the kind of reciprocity that leads to "business arrangements" between politicians and weapons contractors. Like the kind of reciprocity that leads to entangling alliances and "strategic" violence in the hopes of maintaining global control over markets and resources. Lineage is but one of many ways to use the human instinct of tribalism to manufacture compliance for the agenda of the powerful. We "tribe up" in plenty of other ways besides lineage.
"Our leaders are not necessarily on our side." Never a truer word spoken.
Our leaders do not work for us but for The World Economic Forum and other elite global organisations. Our leaders are mere puppets controlled and manipulated by an invisible evil hand behind the curtain.
United we stand, divided we fall.
The people of Gaza and Israel are not the problem--it is our leaders who are creating all these conflicts.
Is it possible that this was a false flag operation? Have you considered the possibility that Hamas and the Israeli government are both owned and controlled by the same invisible evil hand hiding behind the curtain??? Are we watching a puppet show with a script based on fear and hate? Could it be that victims on both sides are real but that the events have been staged?
There are truly evil people on this planet who firmly believe that the end justifies the means.
But the Weinsteins are always on our side.
Our worst enemy are our own governments.
'Necessarily'? I wouldn't give them the benefit of a doubt at this juncture.
@@Sean70244 I never thought of it like that. 👍👍👍
If only all of the moderate left could be woken up to the realities. That would be a major step in helping to get us out of this crisis.
If only the right could stop thinking they are right.
There is NO such thing as a moderate Left. What an absurd idea. The left is where Govt tyranny comes from, lol. The bigger Govt gets the Bigger YOUR problems get. The Socialist political spectrum is only a small FAR LEFT slice of the real political spectrum. Politics is "the administration of Govt." That is measured by SIZE AND SCOPE not the boots you wear. The problem with Europe is you have never tried anything outside of the Socialist political spectrum. You went from Monarchy's to Socialism in one nasty shite-filled step. Far right wing America under team George Washington (a real far right extremist) farts in Socialist Europe's general direction..... No right wing American in our entire History has ever advocated ANY flavor of European style Socialism. That would be the anti-American Democrats who are itching to lose another Civil War.
The left is incapable of doing so. It’s like they keep sticking a metal knife in an outlet and expecting a different outcome. It’s truly amazing, but in a bad way.
They never will
@@noelpucarua2843As I thought, it’s not going to be easy.
The government is to blame for letting them all in
Government is to blame for creating the crisis but we wouldn't be in this mess if we stopped giving away our power to politicians.
The people of Gaza and Israel are not the problem--it is our leaders who are creating all these conflicts.
Is it possible that this was a false flag operation? Have you considered the possibility that Hamas and the Israeli government are both owned and controlled by the same invisible evil hand hiding behind the curtain??? Are we watching a puppet show with a script based on fear and hate? Could it be that victims on both sides are real but that the events have been staged?
There are truly evil people on this planet who firmly believe that the end justifies the means.
The govt is too blame for all current homeland issues. Austerity and QE(filtering our money that didn’t trickle down) into their business buddies pockets.
Never has there been a time when the British tax payer has been so fleeced.
Even parasites in local councils on £750kpa!! For a public servant and councils don’t even want to talk too their paymasters anymore.
Thieves of greed, lies and deceit.
I cannot see the two other comments here. Can you? Censorship is such a bad idea. I want to be offended by rude comments but YT is trying to protect my feelings - it seems.
@Dibley8899 It was way before then. Maybe Blair opened them wider but it started a long time ago.
@@CHX_37See "Rivers of Blood" speech to confirm your point. This issue is hardly new.
Good to hear of Dr. Weinstein again. He took me through the quarantine madness.
Jews are our gratest allies. They would never use holocaust to guilt trip us to celebrate diversity.
Me too?
And me lol
@@lucyfawcett40 That’s the other Weinstein. Not related
He’s useless. A Zionist.
“The goal is an endless war, not a successful war.”-Julian Assange
Two honorable intelligent men
Our so called Governments need to be held accountable for their treasonous actions against our country's and humanity.
We have democracy, we are a collective of idiots who vote for these governments. Lets blame ourselves, not exterior forces all the times like weak little pathetic victims.
By whom, and how. The ignorant plebs will, and recently have gone out and voted for them.
Don’t forget Charlie ( King)
@@marylou3995 And the so called King
@@marylou3995 he didn't let them in.
It is good to hear people talking about this on the basic level of human existence.
@nikosantikythera2422 What approach is preferable?
@nikosantikythera2422care to elaborate?
Shame he never said capitalism (which is what reciprocity is based on).
@@R3tr0v1ru5 Are you sure it isn't that capitalism is based on reciprocity?
@@R3tr0v1ru5crony corporate capitalism to be precise.
When you feel strangely reassured after watching something you know in your heart is true…
😂😂😂 that's uncanny . Your post literally encapsulates why channels like this are popular: they tell you what you already believe and want to believe . They literally provide you with comfort and reassurance about a complex world. You do realise a few years ago some right wing mouthpiece spewing propaganda to camera would have seemed Orwellian.
@@garethmorgan3665and the exact same thing happens to you when you watch your chosen channels
@@garethmorgan3665 it appears I should’ve begun that comment by writing ‘how sad, that…’
@garethmorgan3665 Well said. Don't expect any intelligent responses.
@@kmg474 where’s yours? 😂
This guest has spoken what I "feel" in my Country at the moment, the UK. My Lineage seems to be outnumbered within my ancestral home, the UK, by another group. The sheer scale of the protests is making me feel very, very Un cosmopolitan and I am feeling very frightened to the point of wanting to be with "My people" ... but who and where are they? These masses are not from my lineage but my lineage has gone so do I as a human simply join them?
You are not alone, the only hope is the rest of our people wake up sooner than later and stand together. That goes for Europe and North America. If we continue to sleep walk into this for much longer we will be too late.
Our leaders are importing an invading army that collapses wages, skyrockets crime, and destroys society - exactly what our worst enemy would do if given power.
Accept replacement.
You have been sold out..
what do you mean by your lineage?
I 'feel' it too. Our governments don't necessarily have our interests at heart. It's about time, everyone, pause for a moment and realise wherever you are in the world, we are only pawns in their murderous profitable game, played at the top by a handful of megalomaniac scientists and billionaires, gangsters and governments, they're having a laugh.
I've been listening to Bret for yrs now & he's so grounded in his understanding of the world, also listened to Neil for many years, so hearing them both speak about such terrible times is really interesting.
Integrity Crew Unite
I love them both. and just listened to the excellent podcast with Dr Chris Martenson, another brilliant man who was a voice of sanity during covid,
Pair of absolute liars😂.
"We are rapidly approaching an era where people vs government becomes a worldwide phenomenon." ~ John McAfee
All due respect to the antivirus, pro-paranoia pioneer but when has it ever been otherwise?
@@theGefilteFist A very significant portion of the world believes government ("democracy" if you like) is the *solution* to problems created by individuals in the private sector ("corporations" if you like)
Maybe we are already (hopefully) there.
It has always been like that. It will always be like that. All that we can hope for is for us, The People, to have enough power to be able to force the Governments to aquiesce to our needs and demands, and for us The People to have the moral values and wisdom to know what is good, what is bad, how to promote the good and limit the bad.
Permanent Cold War between the heavily-armed, freedom-loving People, and a paranoid Government. This is sadly the best case scenario as I see it.
Never expected this cross over, could listen to these two for hours.
Bret & Oliver have met on the record before. Some conversations are on YT.
I've been saying this for years. I am not a PhD like Bret Weinstein, and I am not a connected politician. But I don't have to be any of those things to plainly see that diversity is not a strength. All I had to do was see things as they are, the bottom line.
And spoiler alert, there are no solutions presented in this video.
Our future looks grim,it certainly feels like this in the UK😩😩
Please, keep in mind that the Jews are our greatest allies and would never side with minorities in host nations against europeans interest
@@JewrejHanuca The most sensible comment I've heard today
@@stephendalton1648 It's our sacred national duty to combat global antisemitism.
@@JewrejHanuca"Please, keep in (...) against europeans interest"
Wonderful sarcasm! Hats off.
Sad to say, same here in the US.
I have tremendous respect for Bret Weinstein
Yes I’ve listened to him and his wife talk on many subjects and he’s a a good man.
Yes, especially when he reads off a cue card.
💯
@nikosantikythera2422What?
A fine man. Opposite to a coward.
The trouble is that most people WE vote in to make our rules and give them the ability to "control" the rest of us ACTUALLY only ever think of what "they" can get out of this "control" not "how do I make the society better" ?????
The sad fact is the vast majority of people want to be led. Whether it's to the land of milk and honey or over a cliff is irrelevant. Since there is no accountability in our system of governance it's inevitable we are on the road to the cliff.
We can’t let it happen we have to wake up. Someone commented on another video that she thinks she will be cancelled out. It’s sad and scary she should feel that way
💯
What a treat , and a relief to hear an intelligent and reasonable discussion, from two eminently well qualified men.
😅
Weinstein is mistaken that Western brilliance is based on abandoning ancestral identification in favour of metropolitan values. All of the great successes of the West came about during a time of European demographic dominance and quite a heavy dose of racial solidarity. Unfortunately Jews like Weinstein have used their disproportionate influence to undermine white racial solidarity. Jews had a big influence in undermining white immigration policies to America & Australia. The same is true in Britain to a lesser extent. Now that it is becoming clear that an alliance has formed amongst islamists, the left and "brown" identifying immigrants who view Jews as "white" and "priveleged" you will see them pivoting toward immigration control and civic nationalism. But if we are to survive as a coherant ethno-cultural group then European peoples need ethno-nationalism. We cannot compromise on that.
agreed
Absolutely! Time to lift the veil that blinds...Ignore THE TRUTH at your won peril.
DEUS VULT!
bollocks, we need to use our minds in the most advanced methods of analysis possible and avoid ethnic allegiance traps that will deviate our actions towards tribalism rather than cooperation and just sharing of resources
@@24haikus bollocks, you will be overtaken by other tribes if you maintain a civic minded liberalism like that. Race is real and we are evolved beings with an interest in propagating ourselves and our kin into future generations. Your desire to overcome basic evolutionary and historical conditioning will leave you unable to grapple with the nature of reality. The civilisations you attempt to build with your outlook on the world will simply be infiltrated and co-opted by patriarchally minded tribes with a higher sense of asabiyyah than you/
For decades Jewish people have promoted cosmopolitanism but now they're starting to think it might backfire on them.
Bingo! Let the ass biting begin.
Perhaps, but maybe they are playing Christians against Muslims to achieve world dominance???
When the dog and cat are fighting, the rat runs away with the cheese!!! How else can a rat win when both the dog and cat are stronger and bigger? Imagine, however, if the cat and dog ignore the cheese and together focus on the rat!!!!
Just because the rat wrote the script(ure) doesn't mean we have to follow it.
United we stand, divided we fall. If we work together, we can all share and enjoy the cheese--but good luck getting the rat to agree when it believes God promised him the cheese!!!!
They wanted to
a) give us a taste of what Israel is experiencing to get the West on side
b) encourage their people to leave the West and move to Israel
Different Jewish people have different views on politics and society. They aren't a Blob.
@@tonybuck1225 There is a pretty solid record of a large blob of them promoting blobism to the determent of the non-blobists, however.
The "lineage" ties always underlie everything - even in Cosmopolitan societies. Nobody in their right mind would let their own children starve, because someone halfway across the world is "needy," for whatever reason. Yet the U.S. govt is following exactly that insane scenario - us taxpayers pay for everything, while our leaders spend/waste infinite amounts of our taxes on OTHER nations, while refusing to spend any of our taxes in America.
A very simplistic analysis. Our aid abroad has lifted all boats ever higher. But it is true that newly developed nations are not the Great markets they once were and now increasingly directly compete.
@@scottwatrous7649 Much foreign aid goes to corrupted governments. Just look at the $80 Billion gifted to the Taliban.
The US (and all Western Govts) are not helping other countries. They use International Aid to fund foreign opposition parties and asset strip the nation state sending the money out of domestic realms and into the pockets of the International elite.
Just look at the wealth theft from the US to the Investment Management class.
They are not doing that at all they are propping up the empires outposts and failing.
It's worse than that. They spend FAR MORE than our taxes, and the rest hits us in inflation, the invisible tax, which they lie about and manipulate the numbers to gaslighting us over, claiming it's far less than it is, while blaming "capitalism", which this is not.
The thing about the Middle East is that it never advanced beyond the "lineage vs lineage" mode.
Have you seen little England lately?😂
Agree, everything is run on tribal allegiances
The conflicts between the Abramaic religions don't help, and provide just another excuse to dehumanize the opposition.
@@trevaudiowhat’s wrong with the English people 🤔
@@trevaudio Yes, it's filled with _not_ English people.
Brett has incredible knowledge.. Thank you for interviewing him!
He said to put our genetic relationship aside for money. Cosmopolitan appeals won't stop islamic take over if they keep coming
@@tomowens1571Err, I think you must have misunderstood him
@@MsDamosmum no hes using double speak. He seeks a multiracial society and believes lack of adoption of this idea is the reason for the problems with tribalism. His talk of resources is typical leftist bable
Neil seems to be able speak Brett and interpret him for the rest of us, which is helpful.
@@mickadams1905 Neil is assuming the best possible interpretation instead of just more multicultural integration double speak
Anyone else feel like it may aswel be the 1930s again? So certain am I, that we are heading for global catastrophic consequences.
Hopefully the right side will win this time.
@goodlookinouthomie1757 This time, there will be no winners. The aim is to reduce the global population to a few 10s of millions. The true "great reset"
For sure. I’ve been feeling something big and bag coming for over a year now.
You would get that feeling alright, if you listen to Neil and Brett for long enough.
@@kmg474 ☺️it wasn’t the cheeriest conversation. The world is looking awful like the mouse utopia experiment lately though.😬
i love neil, he knows the peoples struggles all to well. great man with a good grip on the modern dilemma. great interview.
Japan is the country I admired the most....safe, clean and wealthy.....what's its secret?.....its homogeneous society...more than 90% pure ethnic Japanese.....they all share the same culture and values.....with cosmopolitan societies...you have different groups of people with different sets of culture and values....I think that's the root cause of the problem
Multiple cultures all living peacefully in one territory has only worked out in one place and one place only:
fiction books
@@m0ose0909 Not quite. They will likely achieve stability through use of tech/automation to replace young workers, and retain societal coherence precisely due to said homogeneity.
@@m0ose0909 I think this is exaggerated by the Western media...Japan's population right now is around 120 million...more than 100 million of that are pure ethnic Japanese...that's more than all the pure Danes, Swedes, Norwegians, Finns, Irish, French, and Spaniards combined....according to most projections..yes..Japan's population will decrease steadily and by the year 2050 will reach its lowest at 80 million (this is still more than all of today's pure English, Scots, Welsh, Irish, French combined) before gradually increasing again
So what you are saying is, Diversity is the "divide and conquer" agenda peoples strength? Who could have guessed it? Especially when always focused on divisive differences instead of commonalities and shared vision.
japan like most of the western wold sits at the end of the largest population boom in human history, where they like the rest of us pretty much quadrupled their population in just the last century, population collapse is really not the issue many try to make it out to be.@@m0ose0909
What happened to C○vid? Oh yes, Ukraine
What happened to Ukraine? Oh yes, this
Meanwhile what is happening about excess deaths and culpability? Oh wait...
🎯
This is my opinion. This whole war (and Ukraine to a lesser extent, I think that was a lucky coicidence for TPTB and also maybe a calculated distraction from post-covid woes on Putin's part) is a huge distraction from the avalanche of data/studies/enquiries etc. about the disastrous 'pandemic' response and the dangerous 'panacea' injectibles.
Israel was Pfizer's 'laboratory'.
What better population to also use as the primary distraction from Nuremberg 2.0. Screaming irony.
its this weeks psy-op to cover up last weeks psy-op
whatever happened to the crumbling concrete schools?
What happened to North Korean nukes? Nevermind that, something else came up
The Aliens are coming to sort it all out remember 😂
War does not determine who is right - only who is left. ~ Bertrand Russell
To quote John McEnroe, "you cannot be serious" if you actually believe that the most sophisticated military defense/intelligence system in the world, was breached by a bunch of guys on tractors and earofoils! Come on people!!
Yeah, because as we know the Israelis are machines that are incapable of making mistakes.
I am curious as to why it took them so long to respond to the incursions. Some reports say it was as long as 6 hours before there were boots on the ground to repel Hamas. Incompetence? Complacency? Treachery? Something else...?
9/11? It can happened look at history of war. It was so simple nobody was paying attention to it.
@dexine4723 Suddenly we're believing media reports?
@@dexine4723 The entire divisional command was wiped out by an attack on its HQ and the electronic border warning system was destroyed or failed. It was a dysfunctional system where technology replaced boots on the ground. They wont make the same mistake again.
It's becoming clearer that having Christianity as the moral framework for Western society was highly beneficial. The morality of the West has been steadily decreasing over the last 50 years.
Like forcing women to marry the man who raped them? Sure bro.
Christian "morality" of tolerance is partly why Europe is in the mess it is in. I do not share any kinship with a black, Muslim or Jew. I only care what is good for me and the English people.
Moral or not, the powerful can still harm you. Increasing poverty is the greatest danger. Debt, poverty and war are how you conquer any nation.
Christianity was humanity's Golden chance at brotherly love...the books of Acts shows how shocking and jaw dropping it was for Apostles and disciples and perhaps even more RIGHT NOW.
The media has a massive part in are demise !
A brilliant conversation. Huge thanks! The ‘lineage displacement’ problem described so articulately by Bret is immensely worrying
No it's not. Bret skipping over that the Imperialist West has a choice
You cannot stop it it has been planned years ago and they will carry it out and nobody can stop it.
You’re absolutely correct 👍
It will stop.
Let the actors on the stage perform in front of an empty room. Let's walk out of the theatre and let the puppet show go on without us. Nobody can force us to participate. They need our energy and attention because without it they are powerless!!!! The psychopaths behind the curtain need us but we don't them at all. We can write our own script based on love rather than fear and hate.
The best way to deal with psychopaths is simply to walk away and refuse to play. It’s important, however, that we speak out and expose the truth to help break the cycle of Mass Formation.
Don't be a star trapped with fear in a jar--your voice is the key so don't ever give it away!
Star Outside the Jar
by Frans Kuiper
I’m singing a song, it belongs to me,
Using my voice is what makes me feel free.
Rising in frequency vibration sound,
Words are for sharing and passing around.
Everyone has their own key to the door,
Give it away and you’ll always be poor.
When you are creator YOU are the star,
A driver in control of your OWN car.
Never stop singing, drawing or writing,
Believe in yourself, truth is worth sharing.
The present is now for you to open,
A gift to be sung or simply spoken.
@@minuteman747/ The problem is the price that leaders are willing to pay, until “the people” revolt against them.
The balance has been tipped for so long in lies, that the truth appears and that means an equalisation .. I have no doubt at all that this tyranny will stop .. The method of change? that is up to people knowing the truth .. In essence .. Truth wins.@@lizaroedewaller-bridge407
Thank you, Neil, for bringing us these fascinating insights from Bret Weinstein.
If the US was independent energy wise it would pull the rug under these Arab nations. Thanks Biden 🙄
The US actually have more oil than the Middle East. We’re just smart enough not to tap into it yet.
Not 'would' but 'could'.
You are. You could be again in a handful of years. But the current regime has deliberately made this not so.
The regime is not in DC. You know who wants us dependent on ME oil because we are then dependent on izrall.
Instead the US is blowing up pipelines on the sly to keep purchasing from the Middle East. I think it’s a long term play. Wait until the Middle East eventually dries up, then who will be holding all the cards?
They have complete ownership of the world's resources, to release at will and at the price they choose: They need to be relieved of this ability.
Mr Weinstein red pilled me with the disgusting Evergreen event. Always listen to those from the front line
My greatest red pill moment was when I found that Jews, indeed, are G-d's chosen people and it's our national duty to combat global antisemitism.
He has been in a few wars lately. I was grateful for his sense over covid.
A lot of tension would disappear over time if we got rid of all social media.
Bret Weinstein’s view of the Cosmopolitan West is interesting. The West is supposedly competing with the multi-polar world of BRICS. In the multi-polar world states cooperate according to their best interests. In the West, states are not homogenous and so, for example, a Palestinian minority in London can undermine the view of the UK to the point where the UK can make no meaningful contribution to the crisis. This is a separate problem from the fact that Western governments have simple been appallingly bad over a number of issues.
I never thought that this cosmopolitan system would work.
The last gentleman to speak pretty much hit the nail on the head with his commentary. The big question now is how do we as Americans react to reverse the mess we find our country in?
Who are the geniuses behind Holocaust denial and behind 'Christians' hoarding, leaving civilization, imagining themselves virtuous (Which Kenneth Clark said was the most wicked of traits.) and this Lazyboy hoping for The End? I spend my online time fighting both, as both a 1970s Catholic and a gentile classical musician of 76 with memories. Thanks, Bret and Neil...more, please.
Amongst all the horror, chaos and divisiveness it feels good to hear an overview that makes alot more sense to me. Yet, it still leaves a question in my mind, of how, as a species, do we re-address the balance?
Extinction is not on the table - but the demise of global industrial civilization will FEEL like extinction to a very large percentage of the population of the developed world.
Our professional, managerial and political classes spent their formative young adult years in a frivolous liberal bubble. The university system has a lot to answer for.
We should not expect the rules of war to be followed by people outside of Europe. The Treaty of Westphalia has been observed so long, we almost take it for granted. But others have never heard of it.
I used to watch the nonsense in the middle East and think bloody hell now it's here 😳
But was it nonsense? Or would it make sense when you saw it with a different paradigm?
@@jaynetui8817 If your mind is pickled from birth into ethnic resentment and thousands of years old blood libel then yes, I guess you can see it from a different paradigm.
@jaynetui8817 I was being flippant meaning watching on TV far removed it appears nonsensical, rather different when confronted with it on your doorstep
@goodlookinouthomie1757 I'd say they should just chill out and have a drink but the hypocritical lunatics do that anyway lol
@@jaynetui8817most things involving Islam are nonsense
“The marriage of Iron Age philosophy with 21st century technology IS A BAD ONE” -Sam Harris like 15 years ago
2 great minds of our modern times but, very interesting to hear from Brett as a Jewish man.
Please, ignore Barbara Lerner Specter infamous quote.
@@JewrejHanuca her quote if she said it the quote has given her fame noterioty not sure about wealth she uttered those words to annoy white folks a favourite jewish pastime hobby 😂
This man was a first hand witness at the Birth of Woke.
No. It was going on strong at least 5 years before that, or Jordan Peterson either for that matter. But before that nobody was listening to canaries in the coal mine, like those from and around Elevatorgate or the gate of the gamers.
Brett was so late to the party, and still talking some woke talking points himself when he first turned up, that his problems at Evergreen looked like the deserved consequences of his own ideology... that the creation had turned on it's creator, who was then running for help and changing his tune, but without ever acknowledging his own likely role in the build up of the situation.
Don't get me wrong, I like the Weinsteins a good deal and listen to him and his Brother and wife often, but there was definitely stuff in the early conversations he had that was concerning.
@@TheJeremyKentBGross It was when they realised they could force Evergreen to do as they wished. Forcing White people off campus, having the staff grovel to them, whilst simultaneously the whole student thing and C16 bill was happening in Canada and they were getting Jordan pushed out, that they realised by joining forces they could create this ideology if they all got behind each others causes.
So the feminists, the LGBTQ crowd, and later the BLM mob, and all lefty causes joined forces, and the woke movement was born.
Sure it was all there before, but in order to create the "baby" the various factions had to "have Sex" with each other.
This is where woke began, and like a malignant cancer it has spread uncontrollably and they won't rest until they have killed the patient, or are removed with some Chemotherapy also known as common sense.
Is he saying that "rootless cosmopolitans" are the problem?
It reminds me of 1930's
@@JewrejHanuca Hmmm. Props.
No. He is saying that those who promote "rootless cosmopolitanism" for others but who themselves compete deploying in group preference are tearing at the social fabric. Marx, a Jew, said as much in his essay "On the Jewish Question." This problem has been ongoing in the West for one thousand years.
@@scottwatrous7649 Marx? The father of communism? A Jew? Just like Barbara Lerner Specter- a jew,a zionist and promoter of diversity in Europe. Jews are our greatest allies.
@@scottwatrous7649karl marx wasnt jewish…
Europe has only been duped into giving up its genetical relative homogeneity recently.
Bret aptly describes the evolutionary bases for co-operation (shared genes & reciprocity). The problem is that many civilized people refuse to allow themselves to consider that their altruism and co-operation have any instinctual genetic basis -- insisting instead that altruistic and cooperative behavior is driven by reason.
and Reason was the result of Evolution.
Are the people that Hamas attacked completely innocent??? Really?
These pro-Hamas demonstrations this last fortnight have been a much-needed eye-opener for our pathologically optimistic liberal middle-class.
So hopefully good will come of all this.
Unfortunately, liberals only have 2 speeds:
slow suicide and fast suicide. They'll at best change from one to the other
Not 'optimistic' Mate - Marxist. They aren't 'virtuous', that's just a smoke-screen. And they are not 'gullible' or 'incompetent' - we mustn't give them that excuse. They are COMPLICIT and TRAITOROUS.
None of this is 'accidental' - it stretches credulity too far to imagine that EVERY politician in both parties can't see what every ordinary Joe can see. They CAN see - this is a DELIBERATE Neo-Marxist attack on Western values.
Stop living in fantasy
@@bar10ml44 what fantasy ?
It’s mankind or human. Humankind is redundant and PC.
Nice to see Brett on GB News
Thank you gb news for allowing the speakers speak
Just love Bret have been following him over the last 3 years
So who exactly is Bret referring to when he says a ‘group of people are extracting wealth’ (which most can see and could argue goes a lot further than just that), which is causing the undesired state of unrest in the “superior western” model of civilisation?... Why is it anti-semitic when we say it but objective truth when he says it?
Bret is so wise! I want to hear more of him on this and other topics
I regularly listen to the Darkhorse podcast he does with his wife, Heather Heying.
Their book was soo good I highly recommend
Thank you Neil ! Bret is an amazing mind and his wife they make the dynamic duo
You know things are bad when Bret is right
😂😂
He's been right for a few years now.
So things are good when he's wrong?
I've been watching him more and more post-covid,he showed rational and thoughtful analysis
@@steviecongo There hasn't been anything good for six years so we can't test your theory.
Thank you for having this wise man on your show. 🌟
Bret’s one of the smartest and most honest people on the planet.
If aliens turned up looking for a spokesman to explain humans, I’d nominate Brett.
Two of my Favourite Gentlemen ! Wise and Cautious .. 😇
Love Bret! He's awesome 👌
I think pop stars have all the answers and Greta don't you?
The best way to deal with psychopaths is simply to walk away and refuse to play. It’s important, however, that we speak out and expose the truth to help break the cycle of Mass Formation.
Don't be a star trapped with fear in a jar--your voice is the key so don't ever give it away! We are the true stars and we don't belong in jars!!!
Star Outside the Jar
by Frans Kuiper
I’m singing a song, it belongs to me,
Using my voice is what makes me feel free.
Rising in frequency vibration sound,
Words are for sharing and passing around.
Everyone has their own key to the door,
Give it away and you’ll always be poor.
When you are creator YOU are the star,
A driver in control of your OWN car.
Never stop singing, drawing or writing,
Believe in yourself, truth is worth sharing.
The present is now for you to open,
A gift to be sung or simply spoken.
LOVE Bret! I’m so glad he put himself out there more often!
We can do the only thing. Unite with similar to us. And stand against those who want to destroy our values.
Thanks all for showing us the way ! Now I can explain it to my kids and neighbours .... " cosmoploitan reciprocity....." . I`m truly enlightened !
Way too short a conversation for such an important topic.
This feels like the most important conversation being had on the planet right now. Thank you Neil and Brett and the man at the end.
But it's not necessarily about being "richer". And even in a wider sense being "richer" means being surrounded by our expanded "family".
When a Labour Jewish MP complained about feeling like an outsider that's what she meant. You can have all the treasure that you like, but if you're surrounded by people that are different there will always be conflict of one kind or another, within or without.
if the fourth political theory can become a bit nicer and more sanitized in terms of high standards in due diligence, including local metrics on human rights, then it would be a much better solution, because it claims that those who absolutely WANT to be different, need a territory of their own to be that and have that. This is because at the same time it refutes "universalism" and grants local moral sovereignty, allowing the different religions to function and develop their societies in good ways.
because one group insists it keeps lineage among its breeding subjects that stopped caring.
When Brett talks about lineage he misses a crucial aspect of it. Parallel to that lineage runs culture and customs, common behaviours, values. This I believe is the biggest source of conflict when different lineages share or contest ownership. The cosmopolitan West has sought to ignore this in order to facilitate the global reciprocity Brett talks about but it is there. When an established culture finds that threatened by a significant outside group requiring the existing to change to accomodate there will be resentment. This is particularly relevant in the middle east since the establishment of Israel. I havent a clue how this will be resolved but it seems clear to me that offering Palestinians parcels of land where they have autonomy where once they had autonomy over the whole region is will not alleviate the resentment for many years yet. It is also relevant throughout Western Europe with increasing levels of immigration. Treating difficulties as purely about lineage prejudice and a need to be inclusive and tolerant misses the point. Until issues around the affect incoming cultures have on the existing are properly recognised and considered these problems are going to get bigger.
Cultural differences are secondary to material needs (or material desires ). As you note, the issue in the Middle East isn't primarily differences in lineage - it has more to do with land taking and displacement (and a many decades long history of attacks and counter attacks).
Every country for themselves, tribalism is a good thing, cosmopolitanism reciprocity must end and the UN needs to be disbanded.
Great question…we can see what’s going on, but how do we stop those in power from constructing this crisis
Love Neil Oliver. The most interesting journalist in the Country and good on GB News for giving him the platform to enlighten us.
What a fascinating discussion.
Answer is easy : BORDERS
make em strong ones, while youre at it
From the point of view of anthropology and psychology, we are doomed. I think that in the future the only salvation (or end) will be artificial intelligence. The one based on quantum computing. Homo sapiens evolved to live in harmony and happiness in groups of up to 120 people. Above this number, other people exist only as statistics. Of course, we have a certain morality and let's call it a kind of enlightenment, there is also empathy, the ability to have a broader picture, but what percentage of people are we talking about here? And unfortunately these people never want to become politicians. This doesn't look good at all.
Thee problem is that technology has changed but people haven’t.
Although I don't like GBNews, and try to avoid it as much as possible, the expert here is completely correct. Tribalism is coming right back and especially so in times of crisis.
Such wisdom. Be educated and take note.
Islam is the key factor here and too many are dancing around it. Everyone is afraid of being called a racist while Muslims worship a god, that in writing demands everyone submit and face a rock in Mecca during prayer and kill anyone who refuses. The problem is a spiritual one. Without understanding the bible and the history of Israel one is without a clue as to the solution.
I think, according to Hazony, What Bret calls cosmopolitanism is really based on what Hazony calls the Liberal Construction
Quote:
““In reducing political life to the individual’s pursuit of life and property, Locke did not merely offer an impoverished and unsuccessful account of human motivation and action. His political theory summoned into being a dream-world, a utopian vision, in which the political institutions of the Jewish and Christian world-the national state, community, family, and religious tradition-appear to have no reason to exist. All of these are institutions that result from and impart bonds of loyalty and common purpose to human collectives, creating borders and boundaries between one group and another, establishing ties to future and past generations, and offering a glimpse beyond the present to something higher. An individual who has no motives other than to preserve his life and expand his property, and who is under no obligations other than those to which he has consented, will have little need for any of these things. Without intending to, the dream-world offered by Locke’s Second Treatise rendered most of the Protestant order senseless and superfluous.”
The cosmopolitan west is in severe danger because, by its liberal consent centric permissive nature, it doesn’t live within its means.
See also Mary Eberstadt, her work re sexual revolution
The Tower of Babel, aka the world's first Utopia project, didn't work then and just cause were using steel and glass now doesnt make the idea any less dumb
Bret's opening remarks blaming Hamas for this atrocity are wildly ignorant and I am appalled to see him not acknowledging Israel's highly obvious abandonment of their own border security for an impossible 7 hrs or more. Israel is COMPLICIT in this development and could not plausibly have been blind to the build-up and planning to Hamas' incursion.
You have to 'break a few eggs' to grift $100B in unaccountable _baaksheesh._ The much anticipated House 'Renewable Energy' Bill has provision _to skim $34B right off the top for the Pentagon,_ which itself has never been audited by an outside Big 4 reviewer. Paneta's 'attempt to audit' was actually 'cleaning up the loose ends' from the 9/11 Coup. The Y2K backup of Congressional investigations into Pentagon malfeasance, was also destroyed on 9/11, when the NJ data warehouse hard drive was 'accidentally erased.'
Bad times make hard people
Hard people make good times
Good times make soft people
Soft people make bad times
Losing confidence in politicians is a good thing, they have never deserved trust,
I prefer using their more accurate name, which instills an instant and correct feeling of distrust when you say it:
The Gentry
The sad thing is, we let small problems become big problems. Now we are going to have to be a lot less squeamish if we are going to solve them.
Two of my most respected intellectuals together!
Weinstein pronounced like Einstein.
Great couple of intelligent blokes. CHEERS!
So much to unpack in this discussion. Well worth watching more than once.
Bret's history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict goes as far back as breakfast.
I disagree with Bret's premise. I don't think "lineage vs. lineage displacement" is the threat or is even relevant right now. It's certain that the powerful are running roughshod over the powerless, and that governments are not acting in the interests of the people, but that doesn't have anything to do with lineage. "Reciprocity" just has a dark side, too. Like the kind of reciprocity that leads to "business arrangements" between politicians and weapons contractors. Like the kind of reciprocity that leads to entangling alliances and "strategic" violence in the hopes of maintaining global control over markets and resources. Lineage is but one of many ways to use the human instinct of tribalism to manufacture compliance for the agenda of the powerful. We "tribe up" in plenty of other ways besides lineage.
Beware the “philanthropist”
Bret brings clarity to almost every subject he opines about.
Bret and the dark horse podcast another of my regulars