Controversial Changes That Could Fix Minecraft

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @ludibri
    @ludibri  Рік тому +21

    What's your most controversial opinion about Minecraft?

    • @Hiriato
      @Hiriato Рік тому +4

      We should be able to sell sea shells on the sea shore.
      But the value of these shells will fall
      Due to the laws of supply and demand
      No one wants to buy shells 'cause there's loads on the sand

    • @Randommeisme
      @Randommeisme Рік тому +3

      I think it’s beautiful that I disagree and agree with some of your opinions, you have your opinion, and I have mine. It makes me feel more unique, ya’know?

    • @DewNotDisturb
      @DewNotDisturb Рік тому +3

      I agree that iron farms are fundamentally bad for the game

    • @powerscalingisdumb
      @powerscalingisdumb Рік тому +1

      overpowered afk farms are stupid.

    • @ABEE199
      @ABEE199 Рік тому +2

      I AGREE WITH Most of these. sorry for caps locks.

  • @faz_rock
    @faz_rock Рік тому +48

    I love making iron farms for only red dye and watching all the iron burn

    • @Ahle.haq0
      @Ahle.haq0 Рік тому +9

      You monster

    • @TheCreeperking01
      @TheCreeperking01 11 місяців тому +4

      Same, I got 200 double chests of flowers, and a iron waterfall to lava, just to make my sister mad

    • @alexmaja23
      @alexmaja23 9 місяців тому +1

      I want them to make golems because i usualy proclaim a village and they help me defend it

  • @DewNotDisturb
    @DewNotDisturb Рік тому +42

    A good balance of decent takes and god awful takes. Perfection.

  • @Jimyrt.
    @Jimyrt. 11 місяців тому +11

    A warden drop should only drop if the player kills it, not by suffocating it or by other means

  • @jaseb5120
    @jaseb5120 5 місяців тому +2

    some of these issues have actually been addressed recently, so, that's fun

  • @dvirovOfficial
    @dvirovOfficial 5 місяців тому +2

    Well, now the bad omen effect fixed
    Also we have more dog breads

  • @cuddlecakes7153
    @cuddlecakes7153 10 місяців тому +5

    6:33 The Elytra being as powerful as it is removes other creative ways of transport by completing invalidating them. I agree that they should be nerfed.

  • @PikkelP
    @PikkelP 10 місяців тому +2

    agreed. if survival becomes too easy with unlimited flight and auto farms, just play creative. i also think villagers should be nerfed right back to 1.13 standards or more. they currently make too many systems completely obsolete (like enchanting) and are tedious to work with (who enjoys breaking and placing the same lectern 200 times?). and generally, it will never be as satisfying to get your resources by clicking on a menu than by mining them in the actual game world.
    my suggestion would be making the only way of getting emeralds to actually mine emerald ore or finding them in chests. no selling items for emeralds. this would result in emeralds actually being valuable and villager trades would be a cool way to get some extra items after a mining trip, instead of completely overshadowing all other game systems

  • @kurumpa
    @kurumpa Рік тому +16

    Love your videos. Btw, you don't have to actually sleep through the night to get rid of [the blue mob that won the vote]. Just use the bed during the nighttime, it resets the counter. Otherwise, totally agree with everything being said.

    • @kurumpa
      @kurumpa Рік тому +3

      Oh, and you can also kill the raid captain with something like lava or flint and steel, but that one is meta and ruins the immersion, as many things do.

  • @larry-kapo-ya7326
    @larry-kapo-ya7326 9 місяців тому +2

    Elytras should be a glider. You have go up to the sky and then use them to travel, but fireworks dont work but you can have max speed lokking foward

  • @danelongden
    @danelongden Рік тому +8

    I love your style of content. Wish these were like 30 mins - 1hr long video essays

  • @PiercingSight
    @PiercingSight 6 місяців тому +1

    You right. Pretty much every single point fr.
    Hilariously, Mojang did some of these in some ways recently, which is fun~

  • @snaillord9927
    @snaillord9927 Рік тому +3

    i agree with everything but i think the elytra instead should just go back to being a glider without the rockets

  • @cuddlecakes7153
    @cuddlecakes7153 10 місяців тому +1

    5:13 "He's literally the hardest enemy to kill in the game, so why doesn't he drop anything?"
    When the Warden was first introduced, he wasn't ever meant to be killed. They only added that after people like you complained about him not being able to be killed. So you're missing the point when you say that he should drop something. He was never supposed to be killable in the first place, and honestly they shouldn't have listened to people who wanted that. It makes him far less intimidating, and farmable (which you also don't like, so Im not sure why you are acting like those little Minecraft kids that are obsessed with killing the Warden. Wouldn't you prefer the Warden to not be killable at all so he's not farmable?)

    • @cosmosisrbx
      @cosmosisrbx 6 місяців тому

      having the warden be able to 2 shot you with full god armor is insane, so avg players wont be able to kill it buttt people who want more of a challenge and want to fight the warden for fun i think is fine, especially if it drops something like a trophy. not needed whatsoever but is a cool accomplishment and would make the game have a higher skill ceiling in turn making the game last longer for most players

    • @cosmosisrbx
      @cosmosisrbx 6 місяців тому

      tbh if the warden couldnt be killed thats just taking out some of the challenge. with a trophy it doesnt rlly matter if you cheated since you didnt earn it

  • @Empyrean55
    @Empyrean55 Рік тому +5

    3:52 on this one, Id suggest a limited amount of spawns, like the zombie spawners have a 'durability' so 100 spawns or something

    • @Jett.o7
      @Jett.o7 Рік тому

      just swap the dungeon spawners with the new trial ruin spawners

  • @ruthlessasmr6662
    @ruthlessasmr6662 11 місяців тому +1

    YOU'RE NOT TAKING MY IRON FARM!!! I NEED IT FOR REDSTONE CONTRAPTIONS!!! SKREEEEEEEEEEEEE

  • @DarcyCook-z5x
    @DarcyCook-z5x Рік тому +3

    For elytra, make it harder to use by having it switch to cinematic camera every time you activate it. You know cinematic camera? When you press in your camera movement is smooth and hard to control, like an ice level on any video game ever. Make it harder to use.

  • @cuddlecakes7153
    @cuddlecakes7153 10 місяців тому +1

    Yes, remove iron farms, No don't remove fortune. Minning is sometimes monotonous and boring. Also yes destroy Crystal Pvp its dumb

  • @timurvoinov6415
    @timurvoinov6415 8 місяців тому +1

    I think we got that pillager raid thing in newest update, thats neat
    Especially if you are

  • @ChickenLORD-
    @ChickenLORD- 5 місяців тому +2

    well now they have bad omen potions so thats fixed

    • @ChickenLORD-
      @ChickenLORD- 5 місяців тому +1

      and different breeds of dogs

    • @ImNotAWall
      @ImNotAWall 5 місяців тому

      ​@@ChickenLORD- yeah I wasn't expecting theese changes

  • @Prim3ridian
    @Prim3ridian День тому

    I like how you casually predicted 2 things in recent updates

  • @gaspoweredpick
    @gaspoweredpick 4 місяці тому +1

    "Stop using fortune on iron that should not be possible!!!"
    Me: *Maniacally laughs while gaining 800 ores from a huge iron vein anyway.*

  • @W1LlzA
    @W1LlzA 5 місяців тому

    i like how a few of these suggestions actually made their way into the game

  • @codaman127
    @codaman127 Рік тому +1

    I hate that I agree with all of this, only because it's not controversial anymore.
    I've never even been to an end city. Some of the updates in vanilla MC and the mechanics that come from it are... I dunno, way too far out of the way, I don't care about it. Limiting myself to diamond organically by just ignoring the run around for Netherite (Which I fully support regardless) makes the underground cities and pockets of skulk genuinely hazardous. Yes, I know big boyo can still slap you dead quick in Netherite, but the game never added anything before him that really made Netherite necessary. It's just... Diamond, but 100% better, on top of already being strong enough to make nearly anything a cake walk with enough practice.
    Also I just avoid PVP, Crystal pvp is... gross, it's gross. I hate it, it's an unintended mechanic, albeit kinda novel. I don't see who PVP being a pair of suicide bombers showing how many more times they can explode over the other as Minecraft. I see it as some 2B2T edge case used by hacked clients against other hacked clients.

  • @GreenPoint_one
    @GreenPoint_one 7 місяців тому

    Afk farming iron is useful if someone like me want to build server wide rails, armor stands and iron bars. I never had an autofarm but I want one :3

  • @playcastlecraft
    @playcastlecraft 7 місяців тому

    "oh so we're listening to mojang now- yeah thanks for the sniffer. and fantoms..."
    Bars. 🗣

  • @thedog-random
    @thedog-random 2 місяці тому +1

    I don’t really think the elytra needs to be nerfed, that would probably make the game worse not being able to get to other biomes fast.
    The elytra needs to be harder to get (I’m not saying it’s easy to get already) if anything.

  • @ManofGeese600
    @ManofGeese600 Рік тому

    Wow, finally someone with actually controversial takes, not basic ones that appeal to the masses disguised as controversy.

  • @lifetheorist5146
    @lifetheorist5146 6 місяців тому

    I don't make iron farms because I make my home among the earth's veins, but I still wanna keep iron golem spawns. Mainly because I feel awful seeing villagers being so defenseless, and taking away their iron golem basically makes them worse off than me in any pvp games (which is to say, awful). That, and I find it cute how iron golems will give villagers flowers.

  • @antoforelle
    @antoforelle 11 місяців тому +1

    Bro the video, especially the intro, is so good
    ❤❤❤

  • @Mardx000
    @Mardx000 6 місяців тому

    5:26 6montsh tell today we have new dogs

  • @Empyrean55
    @Empyrean55 Рік тому +2

    On the iron golem farm one, my thought was that they should drop iron, that way you still get their defence but no farms :D

    • @Empyrean55
      @Empyrean55 Рік тому +1

      Iron and gold should be fortunable though wth?

  • @GreenPoint_one
    @GreenPoint_one 7 місяців тому

    I thought of passive phantoms too :3

  • @nett_the_tree
    @nett_the_tree 6 місяців тому

    How to fix the elytra: .....just remove it lol
    Jokes aside, the elytra needs to be nerfed, and horses, boats and minecarts need to be buffed.

  • @ben10in
    @ben10in 7 місяців тому

    i thought i was going crazy at first hearing the tf2 noises

  • @Lucid-_-Zues
    @Lucid-_-Zues 9 місяців тому

    I agree with the iron farms and any other afk farms/tnt dupe farms. But fortune and iron is an incentive to ACTUALLY mine. Some things need balancing

    • @dyllangames3592
      @dyllangames3592 9 місяців тому

      The problem is I used to spend HOURS upon HOURS mining… with fortune I only mine for like 5 minutes and I’m good. Like what’s the point?

  • @gradient95
    @gradient95 10 місяців тому

    Really, many things that makes the game less fun is our fault because of how we use it, like sprinting and the food bar.
    I tell my friend to dont sprint if its not necesary in our modded server because "we dont have food", and he NEVER enjoyed minecraft this way before

  • @F_I_S_H
    @F_I_S_H 7 місяців тому

    They need to bring back the original console versions instead of forcing bedrock on them. I miss the old mini games.

  • @zarathecatdemon1144
    @zarathecatdemon1144 Рік тому

    I always love playing hard on bedrock and pretending to do the "you die forever" challenge. Although I agree with more than half of the speel, other things like mending should have a limit on uses. What I mean is there's a timer so you can't endlessly get exp on it and still have your godly weapon. I think if you do it too much, it should break instantly.

  • @dysfunctionalqueer317
    @dysfunctionalqueer317 Рік тому

    Loved havin the privilege to be part of the editing of the first like.... 30 seconds. Awesome video my friend

  • @Dreadika97
    @Dreadika97 Рік тому

    I agree with all except Mending, I HATE mending it takes the work out of gear.

  • @corbinallen4562
    @corbinallen4562 6 місяців тому

    Easy solution dont make a iron golem farm. And dont judge others for playing the game the way they want. I hope this helps.

  • @latelyitsemily
    @latelyitsemily 11 місяців тому

    I NEED MORE VIDEOS. I love your style and humor!

  • @rando108
    @rando108 Рік тому

    man your hilarious. instantly subscribed, keep up the good work

  • @Timber-Hart
    @Timber-Hart Рік тому

    Your humour is drop dead funny. Love you commentary 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @makro477
    @makro477 8 місяців тому

    Wardens drop sculk catalysts im pretty sure

  • @EndyBro46
    @EndyBro46 6 місяців тому

    you probobaly real happy bout the bad omen potion being added

  • @_indii
    @_indii Рік тому

    I love your energy I am LIVING for it

  • @straymoore
    @straymoore Рік тому

    Ur passion for this game is inspiring I don’t think I’ve ever cared about something as much as you with Minecraft. Props

  • @pineapple_smoothie17
    @pineapple_smoothie17 Рік тому

    As someone who has gone to minecraft court over several murders committed by my pack of wolves, I can't stress how necessary the right-clicking people to stop your dogs committing hate crimes is.

  • @breadenjoyer5778
    @breadenjoyer5778 Рік тому

    Mending and elytra firework boosting should be removed

  • @Empyrean55
    @Empyrean55 Рік тому +1

    The elytra one, id just say, it only works in the end? That way you can do the exploring for loot but in the overworld theres no meed for it imo

  • @uShadowXD556
    @uShadowXD556 9 місяців тому

    and i didnt even know you could use fortune on iron and gold

    • @dyllangames3592
      @dyllangames3592 9 місяців тому +1

      Yep since they did caves and cliffs. Because now instead of dropping iron ore it drops raw iron

  • @Miles-unbuild91
    @Miles-unbuild91 6 місяців тому

    Actualy their new update in minecraft so new dog breads

  • @CosmoticVFX
    @CosmoticVFX 5 місяців тому

    W music choices

  • @nightmarenz8649
    @nightmarenz8649 6 місяців тому

    Bro, I've never agreed so much to this much game opinions in my life

  • @mr.rangatang3901
    @mr.rangatang3901 11 місяців тому

    Their was literally nothing to disagree about 🔥

  • @Remigrator
    @Remigrator 9 місяців тому +1

    Agree 100%

  • @BoredSloth3361
    @BoredSloth3361 9 місяців тому

    As a bedrock player I *have* to build unmodded

  • @pikalegosyt
    @pikalegosyt 11 місяців тому

    I totally agree with you

  • @dyllangames3592
    @dyllangames3592 9 місяців тому

    So… do you like the new dog breeds?

  • @cube22111
    @cube22111 10 місяців тому

    You had me at the phantoms, lost me at the iron golems. LOL

  • @kylemanweiler7806
    @kylemanweiler7806 Рік тому

    could literally watch this guy all day 😊

  • @pheo_a
    @pheo_a Рік тому

    Love your energy, keep up these silly goofy vids

  • @celeb-seventeen
    @celeb-seventeen 10 місяців тому +1

    It's okay to have opinions, even if they are wrong

  • @The-gg6lc
    @The-gg6lc Рік тому

    just remove phantoms and the game will be 73% better

  • @TopsMuffin
    @TopsMuffin 6 місяців тому

    different dog breeds baby🎉🎉

  • @zsplayroom
    @zsplayroom 4 місяці тому +1

    I hate crystel pvp!

  • @ImNotAWall
    @ImNotAWall 5 місяців тому

    i guess im a rare breed. I do use my elytra for building, i probsbly watched way too many 100 days videos.

  • @BonesInBroth
    @BonesInBroth Рік тому

    Maybe my view on a lot of this is different because I only really play Minecraft vanilla hardcore single player and you seem to enjoy multiplayer a lot more but having things like the Elytra, Mending and even AFK farms (In MASSIVE moderation, I absolutely agree that making EVERYTHING automated sucks so much fun out of the game and so can building them way too early into your world) really helps out a lot as I can more easily find important materials and plots of land for my builds.
    I'm actually currently working on a 10,000-block-long minecart tunnel that'll open up into a massive bridge to a Mooshroom Island so I can supe it up and build the perfect little town there since I love the athestetic of minecart systems (and tbh they're kinda low-key underrated? Being able to safely AFK ride to a spot while you go do something else for a sec is actually super useful plus the scenery can be very beautiful and I think that gets lost whenever anyone is talking about transportation in Minecraft. A minecart buff would be nice but if they did that I would want them to really revamp minecarts, like, speeding them up and revamping things like the furnace minecart. I'm even finding use for horses well into the end game as my main base gets bigger and bigger as they can work as a quick movement option to get place to place without wasting rockets) and without mending, the elytra and a single iron golem farm it likely would've been WAY out of my want/ability to actually work on as I would've had to spend even more time grinding out materials to replace my tools, mining to get all the iron and that's without taking into account the actual digging out part of the tunnel or having to find the island using base elytras.
    Speaking a little more about mending, I like not having to fully worry about my gear as much once I build the proper infrastructure and get everything set up. I remember when I first started playing the game when I was young, I'd never use diamond tools because "well what if they break??? :(" and that effect was made even more pronounced if it was enchanted. Mending allows me to fully enjoy diamond tools as I don't feel like I'm wasting a precious resource when mining or fighting with it since I can fix it without fear of the "too expensive!!!" tab showing up (awful design) so long as I am mindful of my use and build the infrastructure beforehand. Along with that, the addition of Netherite makes something like mending even more important due to how difficult/tedious it is to replace more than a few times.
    Most of these changes would force parts of the Minecraft grind I personally don't really like onto me and I think instead of tearing these systems down at players like me's expense Mojang should instead should prop up these other systems and mechanics instead. I can see how they can be super annoying in a multiplayer setting though and I think being able to "disable" things like the elytra or mending or firework boosts while propping up other systems as another way to do those things would help people be less hostile about the funny block game.
    I would love some more aethstetic changes for the game, if there was a mushroom that worked like pink petals/sea pickles or if they actually added fireflies as some kinda special replacement for "swamp flies" (recolored fire flies but just completely black so frogs can actually eat them) at night in swamps, only allowing frogs to eat the "swamp flies" instead I would be THRIVING. I also love the ideas for the Phantom! I've never been super bothered by them like most of the playerbase but having an enchantment to "disable"/passify them would likely make a lot of players happy without effectively taking away phantom membraines as a drop so it's a very good idea from a game design perspective. I agree with a lot of the other ideas as well. Like the bit about the dogs (my brother HATED the dogs when we used to play on Xbox because of the agro system lmao) and again, I'd LOVE more aethstetic changes for the game SO much. Prob. in my top 10 most wanted update topics.
    Sorry if this is a bit too much text but I'd love to hear these opinions you have more in-depth as I simply cannot wrap my head around what makes them such a massive issue within the Minecraft community other than mild imbalance in multiplayer worlds

    • @Ironicalyy
      @Ironicalyy Рік тому +1

      recap:
      "I prefer playing Minecraft in hardcore single player, focusing on the vanilla experience. Elytra, Mending, and even AFK farms, when used moderately, enhance my gameplay, helping me gather materials and find ideal locations for builds. Currently, I'm working on a 10,000-block-long minecart tunnel to a Mooshroom Island for a unique town. I appreciate minecarts for their underrated utility, and while a minecart buff would be nice, a complete revamp would be even better.
      Mending is a game-changer, relieving the worry about gear durability. In my early days, I hesitated to use diamond tools due to fear of breaking, especially when enchanted. Mending allows me to enjoy diamond tools without the fear of them becoming too expensive to repair. Netherite's introduction makes Mending even more crucial.
      Rather than dismantling these systems, Mojang should strengthen alternative mechanics. While these changes may be challenging in multiplayer, giving players the option to disable certain features could ease tensions.
      Aesthetically, I'd love more changes, like mushroom blocks or fireflies in swamps. Ideas like disabling Phantoms through enchantments show good game design without removing valuable drops. Additional changes, such as improvements to dogs and overall aesthetic updates, would greatly enhance the Minecraft experience for me."

    • @BonesInBroth
      @BonesInBroth Рік тому

      @@Ironicalyy Thank you for taking the time to do that! I have ADHD so I tend to ramble a lot especially with issues that seem to mostly come down to feelings rather than any really strong reasoning so having a tldr that can summarize what I said is super useful. Again, thank you!

    • @Ironicalyy
      @Ironicalyy Рік тому +1

      @@BonesInBroth you're welcome

  • @SkGoblin
    @SkGoblin Рік тому

    W takes all around

  • @Juan-gd7nd
    @Juan-gd7nd 5 місяців тому

    Kinda based actually

  • @sloppysilass3182
    @sloppysilass3182 Рік тому

    Big fan of this vid

  • @Marshall03GDYT
    @Marshall03GDYT Рік тому

    OMG YOURE SO FUNNY I SUBBED

  • @4MoonMoon4
    @4MoonMoon4 Рік тому

    🤌✨💫

  • @Jansenbaker
    @Jansenbaker Рік тому

    Are we sure it isn't April Fool's day?
    (But the "Small things" section I do agree with)

  • @f.g.2125
    @f.g.2125 Рік тому

    LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @corbinallen4562
    @corbinallen4562 6 місяців тому

    Im sorry but half of your opinions are you saying "no you have to play the game the way i want and if you dont your wrong" that goes against the purpose of the game.

  • @jas0330
    @jas0330 9 місяців тому

    Tbh i only use elytra to travel very long distances. Other than that i use my horse 🩵