@@TheMissiIeHodge couldn't carry Pendlebury's bag. Hodge is also an absolute "Derrick" of a bloke. He thinks he's the greatest and everyone should agree with his opinions. Just another Box Hill Dawk.💯%
@paulkyriakopoulos3444 Bucks is still the GOAT. Pendlebury doesn't come close. Try winning a norm smith against black,voss,heart,aker one of the best midfields and teams in general in the last 50 years. Pendlebury wouldnt get a touch if he played against that Brisbane side he isn't physical enough. Bucks is the GOAT and deep down he knows it. Bucks has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 games less! And a brownlow. Not even a discussion.
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 Also a gun coach. Pies win 2022 flag if he stays. They lost the qualifying final to Geelong and Prelim to Sydney. And if I remember correctly, Bucks beat Scott and Longmire more than they beat him....he always beat Longmire in Sydney mate. He still has a positive record over them even when Collingwood missed finals for 4 years while Geelong was making finals every season and Sydney making Grand final 2016 and competing those years. And talk about the injuries Bucks had to deal with his whole tenure, no Elliot or Moore for pretty much entire season including the GF. He pretty much made a GF with the VFL team, while massacring last years premiers in one of the most memorable days in Collingwood history 2018 Prelim. Had to bring Goldsack in after a knee for the big dance. Absolute gun coach.
Been saying it for the last couple years. Without injury it is only a matter of time until people start realising Pendlebury is the greatest Collingwood player of all time. It is now official, regardless of what happens from here on.
@@chriscoyne4827 no - he’s been trying to manage groin problems for over a month. The more work he does, the more it flares up. Put him forward more and he might get through the season easier.
@@shmick6079 no way Collingwood need him in the centre it's the only place his really good at. Let him rest and putting him back in after kings birthday clash
Well said, Bucks re: Nick Daicos. Gary had been criticising him throughout the entire game. Nothing positive to say. No surprise he had to bring up his nonsense in the show. Leave Nick alone!
@@stevelozevski8151 knew you would be the first reply before looking 😂. Forget champion data rating him one of the most effective before this week (one of the only vids you didn’t comment on BTW). You must be pumped that this week’s data actually supports your propaganda 😂
@@90srulz91 I don't need champion data to give me ratings. I can see with my own eyes that most of his kicks go to nobody. Finally on the weekend the commentators caught on and were calling him out. It's so obvious
Bucks is the GOAT. Would Pendlebury win a normy against heart, voss, aker, black one of the best midfields and sides in the last 50 years and in a losing GF? No disrespect to Pendles but those blokes would flatten him. Bucks is and always will be the GOAT. Bucks also has a brownlow and has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 less games.
Nathan Buckley is one of the few pundits of the afl world who knows what he is talking about. When he as a player himself is regarded as collingwoods best ever is saying this guy is better than me then you know its true
a lot of Nick Daicos's ineffective kicks on the weekend ended up working out well he kicked one inside 50 which initially went to Adelaide before a tackle dislodged the ball and led to a goal and an out of the full inside 50 from adelaides kick in went to collingwood
Yes Albert Collier, the most dominant player in the most dominant, most successful premiership winning team of all time. Jack Dyer was in awe of his skills and his toughness. No footage of him but his achievements are vast and his reputation from those who played with him, against him and those who saw him is of the supreme footballer
I always thought he was overrated, which sounds ridiculous because of his 350+ game, 2 flags and a Norm Smith career. I just think Buckley was a way better player.
Bulldust, always a present day player is the GOAT in this age of mass media. He wouldn't get a game in the great Collingwood teams of the 1920s. Just more forgetting the past greats.
What else does the bloke need to do? Broken almost every record, 2x flags 13 years apart, Norm Smith, 5 grand finals, most games for club, 6x AA, 5x B&F winner, longest serving captain, most Brownlow votes.
Bucks is the GOAT. Would Pendlebury win a normy against hart, voss, aker, lappin, black one of the best midfields and sides in the last 50 years and in a losing GF? No disrespect to Pendles but those blokes would flatten him. Bucks is and always will be the GOAT. Bucks also has a brownlow and has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 less games! There's no discussion.
He’s comfortably collingwood’s best player ever, but there’s not a lot of competition. Buckley was overrated, Peter Daicos has already been outshone by his son, there aren’t really any other standouts.
@@whitechrisbrown9283 , dopey? That's ... another one I guess? I was mainly talking about his skills. Turns it over his entire career. Keep up the add-ons though, I'm enjoying these replies.
Does anyone else love Bucks in his post-playing media career? Always has a brilliant analysis.
Cats supporter. Pendlebury is the best player/leader combo I've ever seen
He's next to Hodge. Those two are the far and away top 2 of this century
@@TheMissiIeHodge couldn't carry Pendlebury's bag. Hodge is also an absolute "Derrick" of a bloke. He thinks he's the greatest and everyone should agree with his opinions. Just another Box Hill Dawk.💯%
@@victorpeirce4753how much premierships Pendlebury won only 2 too Hodge's 4
@@Derek-gs5frYou really comparing one of the most stacked teams ever compared to Pendleburys flags 😂 Hodge had the most help in the last 50 years
@@victorpeirce4753 Haven't heard the term "derrick" in years. Love it.
He’s the greatest magpie of the modern era hands down.
All time, hands down
Love ya bucks 🖤🤍 always a Collingwood man!!
YEAH dude but the worst Collingwood coach in my lifetime
@paulkyriakopoulos3444 Bucks is still the GOAT. Pendlebury doesn't come close. Try winning a norm smith against black,voss,heart,aker one of the best midfields and teams in general in the last 50 years. Pendlebury wouldnt get a touch if he played against that Brisbane side he isn't physical enough. Bucks is the GOAT and deep down he knows it. Bucks has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 games less! And a brownlow. Not even a discussion.
@@Truthbomb101. agree dude. I stated coach . That's my opinion on bucks as coach
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 Also a gun coach. Pies win 2022 flag if he stays. They lost the qualifying final to Geelong and Prelim to Sydney. And if I remember correctly, Bucks beat Scott and Longmire more than they beat him....he always beat Longmire in Sydney mate. He still has a positive record over them even when Collingwood missed finals for 4 years while Geelong was making finals every season and Sydney making Grand final 2016 and competing those years. And talk about the injuries Bucks had to deal with his whole tenure, no Elliot or Moore for pretty much entire season including the GF. He pretty much made a GF with the VFL team, while massacring last years premiers in one of the most memorable days in Collingwood history 2018 Prelim. Had to bring Goldsack in after a knee for the big dance. Absolute gun coach.
@@Truthbomb101.pie's win in 2022 if he stays? Don't ever make comments that can never be backed up like it's a fact
Been saying it for the last couple years. Without injury it is only a matter of time until people start realising Pendlebury is the greatest Collingwood player of all time. It is now official, regardless of what happens from here on.
Leeter
But not the greatest AFL player of time 😂
@@Derek-gs5fr According to Jack Dyer Collier was a god that walked the earth, and he did it in the greatest team of all time winning 4 flags in a row
@@steve8510 what God
@@Derek-gs5fr You know, the invisible sky wizard
Mr Pendlebury. Absolute Champion.
66 years watching them, it would be hard to argue, go smooth...
De Goey forward is such a good move
He went forward cause his groin was flaring up. He will be out for 3 weeks now
Might be the only way he gets a game
@@shmick6079 are you drunk
@@chriscoyne4827 no - he’s been trying to manage groin problems for over a month. The more work he does, the more it flares up.
Put him forward more and he might get through the season easier.
@@shmick6079 no way Collingwood need him in the centre it's the only place his really good at. Let him rest and putting him back in after kings birthday clash
Nathan Buckley is arguably the Magpies greatest in terms of pure talent and he’s saying Pendles is that guy and I agree fully.
Well said, Bucks re: Nick Daicos. Gary had been criticising him throughout the entire game. Nothing positive to say. No surprise he had to bring up his nonsense in the show. Leave Nick alone!
Nonsense? Daicos's kicking has been horrible all year🤦.
@@stevelozevski8151 knew you would be the first reply before looking 😂. Forget champion data rating him one of the most effective before this week (one of the only vids you didn’t comment on BTW). You must be pumped that this week’s data actually supports your propaganda 😂
@@90srulz91 I don't need champion data to give me ratings. I can see with my own eyes that most of his kicks go to nobody. Finally on the weekend the commentators caught on and were calling him out. It's so obvious
@@stevelozevski8151 😂 😂 😂
@@90srulz91 great reply👍
I say this for every Collingwood supporter, we dread the day pendles retires, I feel like I’m losing a family member 😅
I call Pendlebury senior goat Nick Daicos young goat and Peter Daicos master goat
I'll let them know
@@iris5227 😂
Scott pendleberry fair dinkum unbelievable 😂😂❤😂😂❤😂😂😂❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Scott pendleberry is the g.o.a.t❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks Huddo, I feel so seen by your comment ‘poor old crows seem to be on the losing end every time’ 😂❤️
Acknowledging that I’m not across the history, for me Buckley and Pendlebury at the GOATs at least in terms of the last 25 years
Beat player of all time full stop.
If you take his leadership into account I agree he is up there
Ok buddy🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Bombers supporter. Pendles is definitely Pies GOAT and possibly just GOAT. Great footballer and pretty fair as well.
Nobody was better than Bucks
Good old Collingwood forever
Great piece Bucks but you are also well and truly in the greatest pies of all time; every Collingwood supporter knows that
Bucks is the GOAT. Would Pendlebury win a normy against heart, voss, aker, black one of the best midfields and sides in the last 50 years and in a losing GF? No disrespect to Pendles but those blokes would flatten him. Bucks is and always will be the GOAT. Bucks also has a brownlow and has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 less games.
Of cause his the goat no doubt about it his playing like a 21 year old watch him go and beat the game's record 💪
Learn how to spell dopey
Goat 🐐
Nathan Buckley is one of the few pundits of the afl world who knows what he is talking about. When he as a player himself is regarded as collingwoods best ever is saying this guy is better than me then you know its true
a lot of Nick Daicos's ineffective kicks on the weekend ended up working out well
he kicked one inside 50 which initially went to Adelaide before a tackle dislodged the ball and led to a goal and an out of the full inside 50 from adelaides kick in went to collingwood
Pendlebury is revered and popular in the Federer manner.
Lenny kravtitz/Billy idol pre game afl grand final entertainment 😂😂❤😂😂❤😂😂❤😂😂😂😂❤😂😂😂
lol why do you keep spamming this comment everywhere 😂
@@ComatosedpeanutO C D ITS hard for the young boy.
Gordon Coventry gets my vote.
🐐🍷
If he plays every game to his 400th it will be against the Cats. No way are they losing that one.
Collier
Yes Albert Collier, the most dominant player in the most dominant, most successful premiership winning team of all time. Jack Dyer was in awe of his skills and his toughness. No footage of him but his achievements are vast and his reputation from those who played with him, against him and those who saw him is of the supreme footballer
I always thought he was overrated, which sounds ridiculous because of his 350+ game, 2 flags and a Norm Smith career. I just think Buckley was a way better player.
Bulldust, always a present day player is the GOAT in this age of mass media. He wouldn't get a game in the great Collingwood teams of the 1920s. Just more forgetting the past greats.
What else does the bloke need to do? Broken almost every record, 2x flags 13 years apart, Norm Smith, 5 grand finals, most games for club, 6x AA, 5x B&F winner, longest serving captain, most Brownlow votes.
Bucks is the GOAT. Would Pendlebury win a normy against hart, voss, aker, lappin, black one of the best midfields and sides in the last 50 years and in a losing GF? No disrespect to Pendles but those blokes would flatten him. Bucks is and always will be the GOAT. Bucks also has a brownlow and has more goals than Pendlebury in 150 less games! There's no discussion.
Doesn't kick enough goals to be considered the GOAT of Collingwood.
are you fkin high lol
Shows you have no clue
@@billgabriel8042 He's not as good as Dick Lee,Syd and Gordon Coventry,Harry Collier,Des Fothergill,Bob Rose.
He doesn't play forward
He’s comfortably collingwood’s best player ever, but there’s not a lot of competition. Buckley was overrated, Peter Daicos has already been outshone by his son, there aren’t really any other standouts.
Never won a Brownlow shut up bucks
Neither did Leigh Matthews, so...
Brown is so annoying .
I'm first 😂😂❤❤😂❤😂😂😂❤😂
Your parents must be so proud
More like the most overrated player in the history of the AFL
You have no idea
Nearly 400 games, over 10k disposals, 2 x Premiership player, Norm Smith medal. Overrated? 🤣 Nice one.
He's a hack.
Fool
Typical Carlscum nuffy
@@RobKieranz , yes, that too. Thanks.
@@carletonclements4931no dopey he’s talking about you
@@whitechrisbrown9283 , dopey? That's ... another one I guess? I was mainly talking about his skills. Turns it over his entire career. Keep up the add-ons though, I'm enjoying these replies.