Raking vs. Shingling to Define Your Curls | Which Method Gives THE BEST Results?! (Detailed)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 347

  • @Diamond88keyz
    @Diamond88keyz 6 років тому +164

    awesome demonstration. I love the fact you got to the point without a long intro. Great video.

  • @erykahjackson8377
    @erykahjackson8377 7 років тому +141

    Raking is my Favorite because it’s quicker but both methods came out beautiful 💕

    • @tammi67able
      @tammi67able 5 років тому +3

      Erykah Jackson exactly

  • @Imet18
    @Imet18 3 роки тому +20

    Hands down the BEST tutorial on both methods I’ve come across! Thank you 🙏🏾 As a complete beginner I think I’ll brave it and go for the raking method 1st.

  • @lavernewebb7308
    @lavernewebb7308 5 років тому +57

    Another things I like about your videos is its not like so many others, where people go way overboard, with what I call, an I'm so pretty dance, attitude, and/ or dress. When watching those "overboard" videos I'm often reminded of being told that a person should be pretty and know but not pretty and show it. That is how you are, beautiful and confident and I like that.

    • @QueenofHearts02
      @QueenofHearts02 5 років тому +11

      Definitely agree...and the sticking out of the tongue and jester dancing, extra long music intro, please, get to the quality content already. Most of the time, I simply can't, but like you, I enjoyed her video.

    • @melencolley
      @melencolley 4 роки тому +6

      I agree... that face making and dancing annoys me for some reason

  • @KiaSynthesis
    @KiaSynthesis 5 років тому +22

    I love the shingling method for my 4 type hair. I do a combination of shingling and coiling. I do it so often to the point where it takes me 30mins to complete my entire head. It just looks better, imo.

  • @bbgirl800
    @bbgirl800 5 років тому +47

    I've only tried shingling once, the curls were beautiful but the shrinkage was insane

  • @kimrumph1547
    @kimrumph1547 7 років тому +70

    I love them both but I prefer the raking method! I have fine hair and I need volume and that little frizz to make it big! Gorgeous hair!

    • @AlishaWilliams
      @AlishaWilliams  7 років тому +3

      Thank you!!

    • @kapparhotau181
      @kapparhotau181 4 роки тому +2

      Yea me too I need as much volume as I can probably get

    • @dorissweatt6064
      @dorissweatt6064 10 місяців тому +1

      I agree and love all your positive comments as they voiced my thoughts while watching.
      Thank you

  • @carolinablue6987
    @carolinablue6987 6 років тому +361

    I love how some people can just rub conditioner on the surface of their hair and be like “ahhh, that’ll do.”

    • @MsIGetLotOfThat
      @MsIGetLotOfThat 6 років тому +30

      Carolina Blue seriously. You gotta get inside.

    • @tammi67able
      @tammi67able 5 років тому +7

      Carolina Blue exactly that’s me

    • @strwrs3m64
      @strwrs3m64 5 років тому +3

      That’s me 😬😂

    • @jazzy11213
      @jazzy11213 5 років тому +35

      Carolina Blue I wish I could do that lol my hair would laugh at me the next day full of frizz and dryness.

    • @kariw8473
      @kariw8473 5 років тому +1

      Frl😂😂

  • @FroLifeFroever
    @FroLifeFroever 6 років тому +55

    When you have a TWA, the shingling method is best for a more defined look. Once your hair grows out of the TWA stage, the taking method is better. That’s just what I’ve experienced in my hair journey.

    • @writteninstars
      @writteninstars 2 роки тому +3

      I don't know. I recently tried raking over shingling and my curls look way better. i wanted to wear my natural curl pattern, so raking was perfect while shingling created tighter, but more defined curls. I prefer the volume and natural definition that raking gives me.

    • @yourmom-fn5ij
      @yourmom-fn5ij 2 роки тому +8

      Whats twa

    • @babybubbles842
      @babybubbles842 Рік тому

      ​@@yourmom-fn5ij Teeny Weeny Afro

    • @briesangster7430
      @briesangster7430 8 місяців тому

      @@yourmom-fn5ijteeny weeny Afro

  • @adailydaughter6196
    @adailydaughter6196 4 роки тому +10

    Great vid. Thanks. My take away is that for tighter curls or less naturally defined, shingling would work best. For bigger or more naturally defined curls, raking 😀

  • @meka1002
    @meka1002 5 років тому +200

    I rake, shingle and finger coil my hair all at once lol

    • @jonigurl
      @jonigurl 4 роки тому +13

      GIRL DOES IT TAKE YOU 20 HOURS TO DO YOUR HAIR!??

    • @paulinedennis6393
      @paulinedennis6393 4 роки тому +3

      Please give me the names of the products that you use to the raking and shingling curls, thank you

    • @nothi_13
      @nothi_13 4 роки тому +4

      Same sis

    • @sarakebedomtsehaye4047
      @sarakebedomtsehaye4047 4 роки тому +1

      Same girl 😂

    • @AchAchoti347
      @AchAchoti347 4 роки тому

      Tameka Teasley WOW!!!

  • @Gamingandlipstck
    @Gamingandlipstck 3 роки тому +1

    When you came back with the dry hair…. The colorrrrrrrsssss are so pretty. Everything turned out beautiful!!

  • @erianjeffers4461
    @erianjeffers4461 7 років тому +104

    When my hair was shorter, I happily raked. But now my hair has grown considerably, shingling gives me the best results. It takes a little longer yes but my wash and go lasts a really loooooooong time!

    • @beaubeauknows3620
      @beaubeauknows3620 6 років тому +5

      Erian Jeffers yes!!!!!! Shingling makes my wash n goes last so long!!!

    • @raquelwatanasrimongkol3890
      @raquelwatanasrimongkol3890 6 років тому +2

      How long? Hours or Days?

    • @beaubeauknows3620
      @beaubeauknows3620 6 років тому +6

      Raquel Watanasrimongkol shingling? It takes me about an hr but it depends on how thick your hair is... finally.amber here on yt takes 30 min to do hers and hazel godesss (caaliyah) takes 2 hrs😂😂so it depends

    • @raquelwatanasrimongkol3890
      @raquelwatanasrimongkol3890 6 років тому +2

      beau knows88 I always lose patience and give up after 30 minutes. 😂 Mine is 4c so I’m gonna give my self 2hrs and try this again. Your hair is beautiful!!

    • @beaubeauknows3620
      @beaubeauknows3620 6 років тому +8

      Raquel Watanasrimongkol 🤗🤗🤗 and yea you have to find someone on here w/ your type of curl pattern and see the techniques they use. Wash n goes are about technique and realizing your curl pattern is yours. Sometimes ppl watch videos (im victim) and say oh my hair was a fail bc it didnt look like that and thats unrealistic.

  • @Candicedickinsonllc
    @Candicedickinsonllc 7 років тому +51

    Thanks for educating us on these techniques! Very helpful

  • @GigglesAttack91
    @GigglesAttack91 7 років тому +27

    Very informative!!! It's crazy to see the raking method has more volume, great video

  • @Prophetessgwb
    @Prophetessgwb 6 років тому +13

    I just tries the shingling method and for the first time my wash and go turned out great.😁 thank you

  • @shaniquabowden3638
    @shaniquabowden3638 5 років тому +8

    This was such a fun experiment to watch! I love the raking side. I also have very little time. Your hair looks like the bomb, Queen!

  • @annah.p4508
    @annah.p4508 5 років тому +3

    Wow will definitely try both ways. Love the curls and the earings too

  • @theyknittoo2360
    @theyknittoo2360 5 років тому +4

    THANK YOU for this explanation! I am wrestling with my comfort zone of straightening my hair out with heat and going natural. Your explanation helps me to feel confident trying these methods and understanding what to expect from them!
    Also - your hair is beautiful, as are you!

  • @daughterofyah6209
    @daughterofyah6209 6 років тому +43

    Wow I thought I was doing the shingling method 😂 smh I was raking the whole time. Well I guess I prefer the raking but I’ll try the shingling method 👌🏾👌🏾

  • @ellasamuels1416
    @ellasamuels1416 6 років тому +4

    I like both of them, now that you explained them, however, mostly do the Raking method, due to time and work and everything else, but considering the fact that the shilling method is tighter and it last longer, O think they both have their purpose so I will use both when necessary. Thanks a bunch girl, and your hair is the bomb.

  • @rutalaa
    @rutalaa 6 років тому +123

    Why when I do the shingling method or the raking method my hair shrinks to an Afro!!!!? There is no length! It just shribbles up like a raisin !

    • @malenyruiz6164
      @malenyruiz6164 6 років тому +6

      My to

    • @molierresignoga
      @molierresignoga 6 років тому +19

      Finger coil it

    • @islandgirl5382
      @islandgirl5382 5 років тому +4

      U have what U have!!!! Everyone doesn't have length! In 1 state it is longer, another; natural length!!

    • @donttouchmyhair9636
      @donttouchmyhair9636 5 років тому +5

      Who pic yo hair look *BONE STRAIGHT* 😑

    • @jungwonscactus9425
      @jungwonscactus9425 5 років тому +15

      @@donttouchmyhair9636 not everyone puts their face as their pic. She obviously knows the behaviour of natural hair and was just sharing her own. Bye🤣🤣🤣

  • @edric81
    @edric81 5 років тому +1

    Great video. Thanks for taking the time to make it for us, that were curious about the difference in methods.

  • @WillandRed2024
    @WillandRed2024 4 роки тому

    Thanks for the demo. I like the volume you achieved with the raking method.

  • @Ferney1c
    @Ferney1c 4 роки тому +3

    I really learned some things from this video. I didn’t know about shingling and taking. I think I lean more towards raking. When I do a fresh wash and go, on my very wet hair, I apply mixture of Mixed Chicks and Shea Moisture Caster Oil smoothie leave in conditioners. I don’t use any kind of butter (maybe I should). Then I section my hair and apply Camille Rose curl maker. After doing these things, I use a large tooth comb and my Denman brush to distribute the products through my hair. I also lean my head to the left, right and backwards using my Denman brush in a some what upward direction (I’m trying to encourage volume). Then I shake my hair from side to side, forward and backward. Curls form on their own. It takes a long time to dry but I like it.

  • @jenniferholliman6165
    @jenniferholliman6165 4 роки тому +1

    Very nice ! I’m washing and about to style my hair with these products! I used too much product last time and theirs is helpful. Thank you !

  • @suedamianos6466
    @suedamianos6466 6 років тому +1

    Thanks for giving examples of both methods. Most videos don’t explain the method being used.

  • @LELE16kj
    @LELE16kj 6 років тому +25

    Depends on how your curl pattern and texture of the hair

  • @marianb2530
    @marianb2530 5 років тому +1

    This was a thorough explanation of both methods. Thank you! Step by step.

  • @adriennejames5972
    @adriennejames5972 6 років тому +5

    This is my first time watching but I love the racking. I like that it gives volume and a little bit of frizz is fine... it is "natural"..

  • @veliciahumes3122
    @veliciahumes3122 4 роки тому

    Just began to transition to natural hair...thank you for explaining the difference between “raking” and “shingling!” THANK YOU! And...you and your hair, BEAUTIFUL!

  • @nikl250
    @nikl250 6 років тому +3

    Thank you for your straight to the point - very informative video. I appreciate it.

  • @neviustoney3518
    @neviustoney3518 6 років тому +3

    Any chance you could provide the list and order of the products you use and the type of hair you have...4a,b,c or 3a,b,c. Thank you and I loved both sides!!

  • @reremechelle
    @reremechelle 5 років тому +1

    I like both methods. Thanks for your very detailed explanations.

  • @carter394able
    @carter394able 4 роки тому +2

    I love this video exactly what I needed to guide me. Thank you Sis!

  • @DaniellLyfe
    @DaniellLyfe 5 років тому +18

    Raking looks better because more volume. Frizz doesn't bother me either, it just adds to the volume. Also love how quick raking is.

  • @Meelie30
    @Meelie30 6 років тому +2

    I like the raking method because it is quicker and I have no patience. The shingling looks great as well. This is a wonderful tutorial.

  • @gaylesjourneyofprojects
    @gaylesjourneyofprojects 4 місяці тому

    Both sides look beautiful. Shingling would be my way to go😊. Thanks for the demo. Very helpful.

  • @tinalandry3241
    @tinalandry3241 4 роки тому

    Great video!! I will try this tonight.

  • @tmac827
    @tmac827 2 роки тому +1

    Hello. I'm late to the video but I love the raking method and the idea of using my hand by finger combing my hair. I just recently did the coiling method as of 11/22. Thanks for sharing

  • @chocolatebutterfly9295
    @chocolatebutterfly9295 4 роки тому +1

    I absolutely love your hair and this video was the best I have seen whether on UA-cam or Instagram. Please, you got to tell me how would the same exact method work under a hair dryer. I was thinking of trying this but need advice first. Thanks.

  • @jeaninekolasa8113
    @jeaninekolasa8113 2 роки тому

    Great hairstyle! love it.

  • @Nceron
    @Nceron 5 років тому +2

    Excellent video! Very informative yet consise! Gorgeous hair!

  • @Bindi921
    @Bindi921 4 роки тому +1

    I'm so glad I found you! Your video is GREAT! I think I liked the shilling better. I'm going to try it this weekend. I'm struggling with finding the right products. My hair is always SUPER dry!!

    • @Bindi921
      @Bindi921 4 роки тому

      How do you care for your hair during the week to make it last?

  • @lavernewebb7308
    @lavernewebb7308 5 років тому

    I'm impressed with how fast the raking takes. Girl as soon as i'm able I'll be buying every product you mentioned I will, and i'm going to try both method. I'm so tired of wearing a "silverish" plain looking afro. Honestly I really don't know how to do my own hair. I would need you to do any makeup on me (smiles) because I don't wear nor know how to correctly apply makeup. Thank you so much for sharing and you explained it all so well.

  • @symlexbrn5396
    @symlexbrn5396 3 роки тому

    I just love these hair channels, so many pretty ladies Wow!

  • @annlouise7696
    @annlouise7696 2 роки тому

    Thanks for a great tutorial!

  • @Kiberawomensselfhelp
    @Kiberawomensselfhelp 11 місяців тому

    I love how the raking looks

  • @tarataylor1743
    @tarataylor1743 7 років тому +11

    Love your hair....I like the raking method😊

  • @flowerchild1835
    @flowerchild1835 6 років тому +14

    raking, for the fullness is what I like best

  • @audreyrobinson5238
    @audreyrobinson5238 4 роки тому

    As most of us Corona has given me no other choice but to do my hair (which I've never done). Kudos UA-cam! I've done raking, I like it (quick). Going to try shingling today. Thanks for sharing!

  • @happybabygirl4
    @happybabygirl4 6 років тому +5

    I love both! I’ve always used the raking method. How do you maintain at night?

  • @shesit318
    @shesit318 7 років тому +18

    I love both sides on you. I prefer the shingling method on my hair because of the definition then once it dries I do the banding method and it last me a full week.

    • @danigirl103
      @danigirl103 6 років тому +1

      Shes TheOne what’s the banding method? I’m still trying to navigate my TWA after my big chop and the shingles never last for me :(

    • @iamshesheisi70
      @iamshesheisi70 6 років тому +1

      daniamz Method of stretching the hair. They have videos on it

    • @danigirl103
      @danigirl103 6 років тому +2

      I AM SHE SHE IS I Thanks!

    • @Ms.Byrd68
      @Ms.Byrd68 6 років тому +1

      daniamz. You've probably found it already but here's an example: ua-cam.com/video/0ZeX5RmWxQg/v-deo.html

  • @lamekayoung8246
    @lamekayoung8246 5 років тому +1

    Raking for sure, Thank You for such good videos I just cut my hair two weeks ago and I’m in love with my hair

  • @justmyopinion9883
    @justmyopinion9883 5 років тому +1

    Your hair is beautiful. I prefer the raking method for my hair. Thank you for posting this video.

  • @p.2272
    @p.2272 10 місяців тому

    Great tutorial! Thx.

  • @osochelle15
    @osochelle15 7 років тому +6

    I prefer the raking method. Love your curl pattern and earrings..Where are they from?

  • @habyb.2850
    @habyb.2850 4 роки тому

    This video is PERFECT. Thanks.

  • @michellejackson423
    @michellejackson423 5 років тому +3

    Demo is great. Thank you. But, can you do a demo on your makeup application! Beautiful and flawless!

  • @wendimartin5168
    @wendimartin5168 5 років тому +1

    Shingling method showed more definition. This tutorial was very helpful. Your hair is beautiful in it's natural state!

  • @diamondloveru
    @diamondloveru 6 років тому

    Im so glad i found this video I never knew there was a difference i just thought girls were using different words to explain the same technique like ( fast & quick); i thought. ( shingling, raking, praying hands etc) were all the same thing never noticed a difference until you pointed one out. Thanks

  • @amberepperson1064
    @amberepperson1064 5 років тому

    Awesome video! Thank you so much! Trying both this weekend to see what works best for me.

  • @iamgratefula5313
    @iamgratefula5313 5 років тому

    love the shingling side, and your makeup is so lovely

  • @_zory
    @_zory 4 роки тому

    Is curling custard like gel?
    Love this video, very helpful. I want to but everything tomorrow and try this.

  • @jenw6545
    @jenw6545 6 років тому +11

    Your hair is beautiful! I find that when my hair is soaking, dripping wet I have the best results with any product that I use. I've tried shingling and raking with dripping wet hair both work better. I even add more water while adding products. I stand on a towel because its messy. But the results are phenomenal!

  • @nyreewright9808
    @nyreewright9808 5 років тому +1

    Great tutorial; one of the best on UA-cam...how do you maintain the shingle method of the wash & go daily? You said in your videos it lasts one week. How do you refresh it?

  • @butterlove0
    @butterlove0 4 роки тому

    Thank you for the demonstration great job. I like volume the raking is faster.

  • @christinawilliams008
    @christinawilliams008 7 років тому +8

    Hey Alisha...I first wanted to say I love both of your channels...You have a beautiful family as well☺..Ok when I do my wash and go's I like the ranking method the best for me...It takes days for my hair to dry when I shingle. I don't put heat on my hair so you know that's a pain..Also, my shrinkage is horrible when I shingle...So no shingles for me unless I am going for a shorter look...

    • @AlishaWilliams
      @AlishaWilliams  7 років тому +6

      I feel you girl! The shrinkage is TOO REAL when I shingle. Lol

  • @pennywarren2357
    @pennywarren2357 5 років тому

    Thank you for explaining the difference!

  • @cancelmycards
    @cancelmycards 6 років тому

    great job on both sides!

  • @pennywarren2357
    @pennywarren2357 5 років тому

    And your make up is on point Sis!

  • @Nadine48669
    @Nadine48669 4 роки тому

    I like both, I think the shingling side is best, I'm going to try this as I don't have time for a twist out today x

  • @debbiemcmichael6055
    @debbiemcmichael6055 7 років тому +4

    alisha,I like shingling because you can always work the curls your hair is so pretty

  • @christelransom2741
    @christelransom2741 6 років тому

    I do both, thanks for the great information.

  • @coralrose6506
    @coralrose6506 Рік тому +1

    Where is the makeup routine cause girlfriend your makeup looks so pretty and I love your makeup and your hair looks amazing and I love it. Thanks for sharing this method with us

  • @introvertinwonderland
    @introvertinwonderland 6 років тому +1

    Did the shingling method today took me forever. I also finger coiled. Cant wait to see how it looks when its dried though. I hope the style stays for a few days.

  • @aprilnelson221
    @aprilnelson221 2 роки тому

    Thank you, I've just learned something!

  • @Kay456Ms
    @Kay456Ms 5 років тому

    So Beautiful! Love both methods!

  • @kikoibuilds
    @kikoibuilds 5 років тому

    You're so pretty! your makeup is on point!!
    also thanks a lot for this tutorial!

  • @latashahorne870
    @latashahorne870 3 роки тому

    Looks nice, how do you manage at night, and what do you do in the mornings?

  • @deloisdelespin4666
    @deloisdelespin4666 5 років тому

    Thanks so much for your explaining so well

  • @georgiapeach2020
    @georgiapeach2020 6 років тому

    Your hair is GORGEOUS! I wish I had curls.

  • @dominiquemoise-johnson5918
    @dominiquemoise-johnson5918 5 років тому

    Very helpful. Thank you. What is the oil you use?

  • @njean6243
    @njean6243 5 років тому

    Love your videos!

  • @Jenarg712
    @Jenarg712 5 років тому

    I prefer raking because it's quick, but I want to try shingling so my style will last longer. You hair turned out nicely. Thanks.

  • @Adventures_of_Tiffany
    @Adventures_of_Tiffany 5 років тому

    Raking... and didn't realize that is what I was doing. Great video

  • @annaug1714
    @annaug1714 6 років тому

    Thanks I like both methods enjoyed watching!

  • @SW-rv9mf
    @SW-rv9mf 5 років тому

    You just saved my life!!!! Thank you.

  • @michellefrazier3288
    @michellefrazier3288 7 років тому +4

    I have never did a wash n go but I do rake products in my hair as oppose to shingling.

  • @KJInspires
    @KJInspires 3 роки тому

    Great video

  • @tommesharoberson2987
    @tommesharoberson2987 7 років тому +11

    I like both sides, but if I had to choose it would be the raking side ❤️

  • @TeethAndTendrils
    @TeethAndTendrils 6 років тому +2

    Our hair looks similar 😍 but girl raking is a no go for me. The only way I can get my hair to last at least a few days is by shingling... thanks for sharing! New subbie! ❤️

    • @Metroqt9
      @Metroqt9 6 років тому

      me too! i can get a week out of my hair if i shingle....

  • @moniquemercer9265
    @moniquemercer9265 6 років тому

    Definitely the raking..😍 love love love your videos

  • @Myaa1980
    @Myaa1980 7 років тому +32

    I have to stay away from shingling because my curls get super tight leaving no length what so ever.

    • @Cameyc3
      @Cameyc3 6 років тому +6

      myisha swearengin Me too! My shrinkage is insane! 😆

    • @beaubeauknows3620
      @beaubeauknows3620 6 років тому

      myisha swearengin true... my wash n goes have longevity and i just pineapple or band to stretch

    • @lorrainewilliams7896
      @lorrainewilliams7896 6 років тому +9

      This is so me. Yes, I get great curls, but the shrinkage is insane. And no matter how carefully I try to separate or stretch after, I get frizz.

    • @kapparhotau181
      @kapparhotau181 4 роки тому

      @@beaubeauknows3620 band method works better for me as the pineapple stretches out in some places but shrinks in other places causing my shape to look ridiculous

  • @213peachey
    @213peachey 5 років тому

    They both look good.

  • @osoprecious
    @osoprecious 6 років тому +1

    This is so informative! Love it

  • @lolah4218
    @lolah4218 6 років тому +5

    I love both styles. I really love the lip color!

  • @cheralewhite8253
    @cheralewhite8253 6 років тому

    Got to say that your curls came out looking awesome with both methods in my opinion. But the main thing I wanted to say was, thank you for this video. Because I've finally learned about another method for defining my curls other than the raking approach. Which I still kind of like. Just I think for right now with my hair type and still figuring things out since going natural. The raking method, just is not quite what I need. But I think with a better curl definer and more practice with the shingling approach(as well as a bit more time in doing it, lol), I may have found a way to get my coils back. Thanks again. :D

  • @FromAtoZVlogs
    @FromAtoZVlogs 7 років тому +70

    Your curl pattern is so beautiful. You’re so beautiful. ♥️😍

  • @katherinewesley3474
    @katherinewesley3474 5 років тому

    First, I love your videos, thank you!! Second, I love your hair, and make up. Last but not least, I am about to big chop my hair. I would like to know if you can offer a suggestion as starter products to curl my hair naturally. Thank you, and keep up the excellent work.