Are there Multiple Versions of QURAN ?? | Mulhideen & 7 Qirat ki Haqeeqat | By Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 чер 2020
- ▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
ملحدین کا قرآن کی سات قرآت پر اعتراض
کیا قرآن کے ایک سے زیادہ نسخے ہیں ؟؟
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ Visit our Websites & follow us on Social Media to get notifications of our latest Posts & live Programmes.
Websites:
www.ghamidi.tv
www.javedahmadghamidi.com
Facebook:
/ ghamidicil
/ javedahmadghamidishort...
Twitter:
/ javedghamidi
Instagram:
JavedGhamidi
WhatsApp
Join our WhatsApp Dawah group “Nawa-e-Ghamidi” to receive small audio video clips & quotes of Ustaz Javed Ahmad Ghamidi.
www.ghamidi.tv/whatsapp
‘Ghamidi’ App for Apple & Android users
Click below to download or update the app.
IOS link
www.javedahmadghamidi.com/send...
Android link
www.javedahmadghamidi.com/send...
Stay Blessed 💞
![[4/4] Existence of God Proved by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1qrXrKvCErA/mqdefault.jpg)
MashAllah..!! Allah Ta'ala Ki Ap Pr Rehmat ho..! Aur Akhirat Me Ajar Dey.. Ameen..!
Masha Allah.
Bahot hi achche tarike se samjhaya hai
Thanks lot 👌👍❤
Please translate it in English... after the viral video of Yasir Qadhi and Muhammad Hijab ....muslims in west have gone under immense pressure to answer these questions and many are confused .... please we need this to be translated and sent to Dawah community in UK .... !
Already refuted by Sc dawah channel & they have no answers. Watch on youtube
Yep this is a very comprehensive explanation of Ahruf wa quraat that the western young Muslim dai are arguing about these days.
@@jerrypeter7616 most scholars just leave this topic alone, I haven't seen this dealt with at this level until now. Well done Dr. Ghamdi..
its available in his book detailed paragraph his book name is mizan
@@zuberkhan84 Does he discuss the issue of manuscripts at all? I mean the old manuscripts that scholars are assessing?
Awesome
qiraath change honese meaning, person (first secand third) , singular plural.... bhi change hongena ?????
Masha Allah
mera msla hal kr diya
asal me ulma ko ye batain pehly hi se btani chahiye ta k nai talib ilmon k zehn sawal uthny se pehly hi jwabat se bhr jain
غامدی صاحب کو اللہ ہدایت دے...
Ghamidi sb ki fikar chorein. Apnay liye hidayat manga karein
Ye konsi video he???
Mushaf ki qiraath kounsi hai?????
Arz e aaqira 1 kounsa hai,
hafs ya warsh, ya .......
Hafs
@@amjadshekh4731 nahi jii
sir ek bat nhe smjh aii kajoor khana sunnat q nhe hai ? tou phr sunnat kia hai ?
Sunnat wo hai jo Nabi ﷺ ny deen k toor par jari farmae jesy Namaz Parhna.
@@fikr-e-farahi433 Sir yeh kese pata chalyga ke nabi ne deen ke toor par kia jari fermaya hai ? Jese bukhari main bohat jaga pe fermaya gya hai ke Nabi Pak SAW , yeh yeh kam karte the tou woh perh ke tou yahi lagta hai ke woh jo jo kam karte the us main kisi ko be apna lena sunnat hai ? Per agr Sunnat deen ke tor par jari rakhna ka ammal hai tou woh identify kese kar sakte hain ?
@@kking999 wo amal amli tawatur say jari kiya huwa hota hai ...naki bukhari mein likha huwa paya janay Kay Baad jari kiya gaya ho
@@kking999 dunia news ke channel pe ilm o hiqmat wali Playlist ma jao, wahan sunnat par ghamidi sahab ki 3 videos hongi, wo dekho.
assalmualekum
Walaikum Salam
English subtitles, please. Western Muslims are crying out for more knowledge on this topic!
The Quran may be in different accents but there is no change in the Quran, the same Quran is the same in the whole world which was revealed by Allah on Mohammad S.A., there may be a defference in qurat but there is no defference in meaning 🎉
@@TweemCT Not true. Read the book by Dr. Daniel Brubraker on Quran variant. It's not just qiraat, there are different VERSION of Quran with different words and different meanings.
@@dark_modeDifferent words/meanings which lead to the same thing. E.g. Surah Fatiha verse 4
مـٰلك يوم الدين
Owner of the Day of Judgement
And in 6 of the 10 Qiraat it is
ملك يوم الدين
King of the Day of Judgement
These are 2 different meanings but the don't contradict and they lead to the same thing. Because Allah ﷻ is the King of Judgement Day and He is also Owner of Judgement Day.
E.g 2
Surah Hujurat Verse 6
يـٰأيها الذين ءامنواْ إن جاءكم فاسق بنبإ فتبينواْ
O You who believe, if a wicked person comes to you with news, investigate it.
And Hamza, Kisai and Khalaf (The Qiraat Khalaf not the Riwayah) transmit the verse as,
يـٰأيها الذين ءامنواْ إن جاءكم فاسق بنبإ فتثيتواْ
O You who believe, if a wicked person comes to you with news, then examine it carefully.
As you can see the last word is different and the meaning of it is also different but these meanings compliment each other. Why because, If a wicked person comes to you with news then investigate and ascertain whether or not the news is true, and in Hamza, Kisai and Khalaf, If a wicked person comes to you with news then examine the news carefully meaning don't rush in your examination. Both meanings bring you to the same conclusion do they not.
The Quran was revealed in 7 ahruf, they don't contradict each other but sometimes have different meanings which compliment each other as I mentioned above.
I am saying only one line,
This is a Key kept it
Read and learn what Quraan saying ,before anything alse.
Mera sawal ye gai k hazor se nakal kis ne Kiya kyun wo qirat Jo or Hain wo to qariyun ki Hain to zahoor se kirat to kariyun ne hi nakal ki hashaba Mai Bhi wo qari Hain to matwatar Kiya rawayat hafas ya warsh ustad ap ne sir ghuma diya
Arbi ke style hote hain padhney ke start se kayi styles hain, naqall boht logo ne kiya, Lekinn Quraan asee tehqeeq aurr details me jane walo ko zada samajh nahi ataa, jo khud samajh karr padega Bilkul Neutral hokarr usko samajh ayegaa usey is tara ki behs be Matlab ki lagegi
What problem people are solving with the help of old or superseded qiraat. What wisdom exist in old qiraat which does not exist in Arz e aqeera
The other Qiraat are used in tafseer literally all the time
@@saadkhanzada6409 what help it provide in tafseer. It means it has something which is not Arze Aqeera. How?
@@tariqz5384 if you had even read deep tafseer books you would know that you asked a very stupid question.
@@saadkhanzada6409 Lack of knowledge, lack of contemplation, and lack of ethics always turn the matter into an attempt to win through emotions and baseless accusations. Whereas knowledge and ethics always prepare you to prove the point through reasoning while staying within ethical boundaries.
@@saadkhanzada6409Lack of knowledge, lack of contemplation, and lack of ethics always turn the matter into an attempt to win through emotions and baseless accusations. Whereas knowledge and ethics always prepare you to prove the point through reasoning while staying within ethical boundaries.
There are holes in the narrative 🕳️
You don't even know the standard narrative
@@subhanyusha
Don't worry muhammmedan, Yasir Qadhi knows the holes in the standard narrative.
Then why you people can't debate with those who say quran have different versions🤷🤷🤷even he also accepted their is some places which have different quran
Debate ka koii faydah nahi hai,
Jabh do Vakeel muqadma ladtey hain unka maqsad pehley se tayy hota hai, wo samney wale ki kabhii nahi manega ap apna maqsad tayy karein apka maqsad kyaa hai ?
یہ بات سمجھ نہیں آئ کہ جب اللہ کا حکم آگیا کہ قرآن کی ترتیب اور اس کو پڑھانا ان کی ذمہ داری ہے اور نبی پاک صلی اللہ وسلم نے بعینہ قرآن اسی طرح منتقل کیا تو پھر صحابہ کی طرف سے یہ اصرار کیوں ہوا کہ وہ اس طرح ہی پڑھیں گے جیسے نبی کو پہلے پپڑھتے سنا ہے۔
In details ko ek taraff rakh lo , ek side se Quraan khud samajh karr padhti raho agar tume khud samajh a gaya phir behs me nahi padogi.
There are more than 30 versions of Quran.
Azeezamm ,
If you stand by your definition of ijmaaah, then you should have known that muslim salaf ulemas have ijmaaa about the 7 Qiraats of quran.
Looks like you have changed your definition of ijmaaah.
Pls define why you always break your own principles time n time again ! 🙂🤷♂️
Ijma doesnt mean that all scholars agree on a matter from a specific time. But ijma/tawatur in usooli terms is those things or concepts theoretically(quran) and practically(Sunnat Not hadees) which has been sanctioned by Prophet Muhammad pbuh in his time and from then it became culture for all the coming muslim generations.
Ghamidi saahab uses ijma or tawaatur in its true essence. Not in traditional scholars narrative of a fatwa or khabar e waahid. Hope this answers your question.
Please don't be a fool. Don't call this word salfiyoon . If you call yourself by a name other than Muslim then you are a Mushrik according to Allah sw
Moulana Gamdi ho ya koi our ye jhoote chakkar baz hai 😮😢aap khud mutalaya karein ye taqiya Jhoot bolte hain
Sharem kro
@@zeeshanazeem3778 gumrahi se niklo,khud badimagi ko chodo.hosh me aao in chal baxaon se
Puri duniya me quran ek hai
@@shamaparveen1776Haan maghar logo ne jana khud nahi isliye waswaso me pade hain