Greetings from Quetta BALOCHISTAN.. Ashir sb they need a playground to practice, to earn money, to smuggle goods, to create uncertainty.. And BALOCHISTAN is the Favorite playground...
but some maven are saying something else... according to them current rise in insurgency of balochistan is due to the zero tolerance policy about smuggling of security departments in balochistan... as bread of powerfuls is on stak now...
Ashir sab what a great analysis.i totally agree with you.because i am also a Punjabi. My thoughts near to u. Pakistan needs person like you. Khush rahiain. GOD bless you. Rashid bhutto from Town ship Lahore
Is tarah kai banday zimadari se bhag jatay hai, aur bahir se lecture detey hai, banda wohi himat wala hota hai jo system me reh ker system ko tek kernay kai lia apna kirdar adda karay
@@AbdullahKhan-bf9ji lol 15 saal case larra Aashir bhai nae apnae ooper corruption k ilzam ka, family chali gayi lakin wo nahi gaye jab tak unka name clear nahi hoa istarah k jhootae comment gunah-e-Jairya mein aatae hein, agar aapko sach nahi pata tu buhtaan q laga rahae hein Yaad rakhein jab tak yea jhoot yahan likha rahae ga aap ko iska gunah milta rahae ga
Beta bhaga nhi hai apne ko punjabi establishment se clear kar k retirement le k phir bahir gya hai Punjabi establishment ne is gareeb Punjabi ko CIA ka agent keh kar nokri se fairg kiya tha phir ap k court ne clear kiya tha yeh hai history asal@@AbdullahKhan-bf9ji
Great show and truth in abundance ❤ Liked and subscribed Asher seems like a very intelligent and knowledgeable person with his heart in the right place
عاشر بھائی آپ کا تجزیہ لاجواب ہے۔آج جاوید ہاشمی نے ایک پروگرام میں کہا ہے کہ پاکستان بننے کے بعد پہلے مسنگ پرسن قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح تھے۔اور یہ سچ بھی ہے۔
Absolutely. Quaid could not vision and judge the people around him. Instead of hearing legends like Maulana Abul Kalam, who predicted exactly 14 points for the creation of Pakistan, Jinnah collected the Vaderas and Landlords from both sides from Sind, Punjab and Lucknow. The result is a Super Elite called Army Establishment, and an elite of landlords and sardars. The real people were ignored, and Pakistan became a Security State and the Army became a rentier army in search of dollars. The result, lakhs of muslim brothers killed and violated by the Pakistani Army from East Pakistan, to Balochistan, to Kashmir, to KP FATA to Afghanistan. What a shame.
@@JangBahadur-zn1ft hey hey hey stop here. Its not army. Its common people who gather on the voice of a street mullah to kill some non Muslim on blame of blasphemy. Its common people who used to cheer on shia killings and chanting slogans of shia kafir. It were common people who did not care when USA launched drone attacks on western border. Why do you blame army for everything? Its common people who consider Taliban better Muslims than army. You yourself/ we ourselves are duffers, fools and ideologically backward and not pak army. Forces are reflection of a society.
Very well done sir. this will continue and cover all the aspects. We are such grateful for your efforts. 🙏 doosri baat isbaar aap ka artistic sense of composing frame and background its really nice and refreshing 🌟.
assalam o allikum whatever u said made a lot of sense and the thing that appealed me the most was u talked about the solutions at the same time. there are lots and lots of people talking about the problems, they won't hesitate even adding fuel to the fire but this vlog was a v beautiful balance of identifying the problems, cause of the problems and then solutions. much needed way of approaching things JIZAKALLAH KHAIR
Great Ashir bhi, you are a heroics personality for millions of Pakistanis including myself who were in teen and young age during 90s because after extra ordinary performance Dhuwan. And I think you are again playing a similar role in educating our nation. I have just a comment that you haven't touched the role of china, Iran, India USA in Balochistan. How can we save ourselves in this tug og war ? And don't you think that balochis are also been used ? How could it's possible for them to through the weapons and stop demanding separate state, while having a great support from foreign agencies ?
Being a Punjabi, I second whatever Aashir Azeem said about Punjabis. Our racial relationship is based on Islam. Whether it’s Pashtuns, Balouchs, Bengalis or even Turkish, Arabs or any other Muslim race for that matter. I feel like Punjabis and Sindis are same in terms of speaking for their rights.
Sane voice, good analysis. Presently, people look for opportunities, development, rights, freedom from unnecessary force and influence and theft of resources. The reason that the present movement in Balochistan is different from the previous one; this time its both political and economic.
Ashir Sahib. I am and have been one of your biggest fans since “dhuan” era. I have also been following most of your videos on UA-cam and agree with almost all of your views. Unfortunately, this is the first time, I happen to disagree with your point of view on almost all your views (almost all, but not all). I wish I had the ways and means to give my counter argument to the points you have raised. Nonetheless, you will always be remembered as Pakistan’s most sincere son, in my humble opinion.
As always, each episode of your vlog offers a new perspective on positive thought. I fully agree with your analysis and the proposed solutions to these conflicts. I believe that over 80% of the population is already aware of these issues, but the leadership, including certain individuals in key military positions who lack personal stakes in Pakistan, remain disconnected from the gravity of the situation. They continue to exploit resources without regard for the long-term impact, ultimately abandoning the country. I remain hopeful for better times and believe that we must contribute to the nation's progress within our capacities.
Dear Ashir thank you for a very informative talk. I found it a very fascinating listen. I agree the Baloch, Pashtun and Bengali as well as being an ethnic group, they are also a nation but you didn’t mention the Sindhi or the Urdu speaking Muhajirs... Please discuss. Thank you
Sir totally agree the solutions you gave,we never want to go to root cause so problem never ends. However one point i coudnt understand that you have ignored the struggle of sindhis against Angrez bahadur,and sindhis never were the beneficiary of Angrez saltanat.
I am from punjab but I ❤all provisional people balochisitan is very good Ye sary baat hamary army smagh ly aor hamary sary pakistan ko bacha ly Hamary hr province ka bahut hi piara aor different taste h aor ye Allah ki tarf sy gift h Allah hamary sary province aor sary provisional people ko salamt rakhy Ameen
One can make out from your comment itself, how much you want to treat Baloch people. Why should the Baloch people be provisional? They are not provisional, but permanent people of Balochistan. I think it is Allah’s marzi that Bangladesh was created. Allah is the best planner, and I pray he frees the Baloch from the tyranny of the Pakistani Army Establishment. Inshallah.
Part 1. Dear Aashir Azeem Sahb! With reverence! i would say that in your vlog there are many confused and weaken things regarding the past history of Baloch & Pashtoons political legacy and struggle against British regime/era because British Empire had been completely won their war against Baloch & Pashtoon tribes that's why British Govt.constructed the railway system upto Quetta in the eastern side whereas upto Landi Kotal towards NWFP. Furthermore Amir Aman Ullah the Afghan Emperior became compelled to sign the peace accord with British, Govt. of India then the deurend live accord between afghan and British Govt. was came into existence which still prevails by legitimately and documented under International Laws, Geneva Convention mandate and UNO charter accepts its credible status by legally! before this Raja Ranjit Singh was being conquered the whole Punjab and defeated the Afghan and grabbed their large part of their soil which is now the integrated part of Pakistan and Insha-Allah will remain forever in next centuries. When British Govt. succeeded in Balochistan and Pashtoon areas then Viceroy fixed the annual grants/stipend to all chiefs/sardars and khawaneen to hold their control over their peoples and this type of system in which the annual stipend/grants were paying to all chiefs of all states/tribes in all over Pakistan specially in Balochistan and Pashtoon agencies until the P.M Zulifiqar Ali Bhutto Shaheed announced and stopped the stipends/grants and also Z.A Bhutto Sahb announced the termination of sardari nizam in 1973. those sardars and chiefs of tribes and Pashtoon khawaneen of NWFP agencies who were getting millions of rupees per anum, they became very angry and shown their enemity against Shaheed Z.A Bhutto while Gen.Zia deposed the Bhutto Govt.and took wrong and counter measures against Bhutto Sahb.again Zia Ul Haq restored their cancelled stipends/grants to get the favour of all Baloch Tribe Chiefs and khawaneen/mashra's of Pashtoon Belt agencies in NWFP. Dear Ashir Sahb! The all Baloch tribes are not similar as a one nation by their language, norms and customs and cultural wise they posses different heritage and behaviour! for example! many Baloch tribes speak different accent with different pronounciation, as such many tribes speak Balochi language dominant by Persian language, many Baloch tribes speak purely siraiki language, many Baloch tribes speak Sindhi Punjabi, Siraiki mixed language bases. for example! Jamali Baloch, Rind Baloch, Lasi Baloch, Langah Baloch, Mazari Baloch and others small groups further a large number of Brahvi/Brohi peoples/tribes also residing in Balochistan for since last centuries but they do not consider themselves as part of Baloch Nation. rather they become angry when anybody calls them Baloch in ignorance! When Mohattaram Quaid Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah Sahb, Mr.Mount Beton, Mr.Mohandas Gandhi and Mr. Jawaharlal Nehru became agreed upon the final draft of declaration of freedom in which an important article was contend that all states which were in prevailing then will join to their respective countries territory and if any state of their respective country will not comply the instructions of their respective countries then this type of act should be mounted as an attempt of rebellion so while India divided into two countries as Pakistan & Bharat then all states and provinces were merged & joint to their respective countries. e.g. Bahawalpur Province and all other states as such Khairpur, Sawat, Hunza, Lasbela, were merged in Pakistan. so how could it was possible that Qallat state refused to join Pakistan! rather it was deliberate attempt of molafied act of rebellion from the Govt of Pakistan & its territory. Cont: Dr.Shaikhu Larkana
I am from Balochistan city of Quetta ashier sab sir you are ware will guide for my nation but so sad 😭😭😭😭 my nation was not andarstand your advice so sad sir.god bless you .
Interesting thought, Ashir Bhai, but i have a few reservations. Sub nationalism essentially means that you are to stand for your own nation, not for the whole country. When sub nationalism is supplemented by populism, which is very easy to implement in Pakistan due to lack of literacy & critical thinking, it will ultimately always lead to anarchy & chaos type scenarios. This will still continue to happen regardless of whether they get their real leadership or the fake one. Populists will always blame Punjab regardless of what Punjab does. Your thought pattern is good because you are a good man, but you are judging it more like the Canadian people. I dont think it will be the case for the people here.
Ashir bhai Aap ki bat 100% right hn. Aap sy pakisatani bhht muhabt krty hn. Mgr Aap jesa inteligent Insan yey q nhi sochta k is dunya mn zulm aur zalim hi kamyab hn. Yahan achy log mushkilat ka shikar hn. To kia aik dusra jahan nhi hona chahiye jahan zalim ko saza mily aur mazlom aur achy logon ko prize aur respect. Warna to ye lazim aaiey ga k ye dunya ye zindagi bs aesy hi bana di aur is ka koi maqsad nhi. Jb koi aik insan koi bhi kaam bhager maqsad k nhi karta to phir ALLAH TAA'LA ye dunya bagher maqsad k k sy bana skty hn.
Ashir Sahb,i watch your videos and i find them informative... but why did you not mention Sindh, we also have our own identity, we speak Sindhi.. I was waiting to listen about Sindh from you but perhaps you forgot it...!
Baluchis consist of 3%, Pashtuns about 15%, and Punjabis over 50% of Pakistan thus their higher, but not disproportionate representation in Govt.. Punjabis in the Army are mainly from the arid Potohar region where the British recruited soldiers much before partition and its still a traditional there. You will agree that the Army ISSB test requires prowess and a mindset which is not for everyone, despite Bhutto’s “quota system” of 1971 where the qualifying height for Sind and Baluchistan was rolled back from 5’6” to 5’4” and a new Sind Regiment garrisoned in Hyderabad. Sadly the Sindhi recruitment is low despite ongoing efforts. Still, the Punjabi numbers in the Military is around 50%, likely less in the Officers grades and PAF/Navy. Ironically, almost all dictators our country got were non-Punjabi. Ayub, Yahya, Musharraf. Everyone except Zia. This flies in the face of your thesis of a “bad Punjabi army”. Ayub, Yahya, Bhutto (with Tikka Khan) and Musharraf (who murdered Nawab Bugti then came on national TV to brag about it) were directly responsible for the chaos in Baluchistan. In fact Gen. Zia provided amnesty to the Baluch and Pashtun and peace was restore. Facts cannot be changed. You should know better than most, that the COAS and his close generals are directly responsible for the Army’s follies. Punjab and Punjabis are just a favorite scapegoat which has outlived its usefulness. You talk about your memorable years in Baluchistan befriending sons of Sardars and glorifying their way of life, but have you ever lived in a Punjabi or Sindhi village where backbreaking toil and poverty is a common occurrence amongst other vile and violent incarcerations. You talk of the dark migration of 1947. Trekking over corpses to Pakistan; the old man’s heart would break today seeing his grand children still suffering. Agreed that the rich central plains of Punjab and Sind have been bereft with inequality, and the waderas and Chaudhries are cruel, but that is changing as land is getting fragmented. It may take longer in Sind given the size of holdings. But tell me what have the Sardars of Baluchistan and Malik’s of Pakhtunkwa done for their people despite getting regular levies and development funds from the Govt. I hear they discouraged schooling for decades and their people would come to Punjab and Sind to study. To strengthen your argument of “bad Punjabis” you conveniently removed the Sikhs from Punjab because they were the most formidable against the British, more so then the Baluch or Pashtuns who would ambush and then vanish into inhospitable terrain. Raja Ranjit Singh had many Muslim fighters in his army and scholars as his close aids because they shared a similar language and culture. Not only did they keep the British at bay but pushed the Pashtuns to the Kabul river. As regards your lists of HiFi values, maybe you would like to tell me why poor laborers passing through their territory are pulled out of buses and executed and innocent citizens are kidnapped and held in these areas for ransom? Punjab has a long and storied history of Saints, Sufis, Poets and folklore. All they preached was love, brotherhood and peace. If you don’t believe me read up on Baba Bulleh Shah, Waris Shah, Shah Inayat. Then make your own list for Punjab. We all know that the crux of the problem, as you do, is successive military juntas controlling and usurping all political and economic resources. You are just using the “Punjabi” card to play to the gallery and/or securing a safe passage for yourself to return home one day. I almost forgot, the three reasons for making Pakistan was not by the Punjabis. Only two of your reasons are valid. The first is that Mr. Jinnah espoused a two nation theory of Muslims and Hindus on which the creation of Pakistan was based. The second point was the language issue. Punjabis already had a rich language, In fact they sacrificed their own culture and heritage for the sake of Pakistan’s unity and embraced Urdu to the detriment of Punjabi. Close associates of the Quaid, mostly from Urdu speaking UP convinced Mr. Jinnah to have a unifying language as India had opted for Hindi. Obviously none of them were aware of the cultural and social implications. The point you shrugged off with a grin about the Khilafat Movement was a very significant moment in the Muslim Ummah’s memory and many lost their lives. Since you may be unaware of its importance I’ll let you have a “hall pass” on this one
Ashir Bhai, You're Real Hero Not Just In This Drama Also In Real Life... Big Fan Of You, By The Way My Name Is Too AZHAR... From Daska District Sialkot...
Just a little hateful tone for "Punjab" and "Punjabis"; not observed at the outset but can be observed while reading between the lines and observing your non-verbals. Seems like you do not like Punjabi culture, you might have had certain bad experiences. In your previous videos you mentioned a sentence the British had coined. "If you want to rule the Baloch, honour them. If Punjabis, just rule them". I do not know whether your diagnosis of the Punjabi inferiority is correct or false. I just know that it exists, very subtly, in your messages. Best of luck dear.
رابرٹ سنڈیمن ایک انگریز ریزیڈنٹ تھا صوبہ سرحد بلوچستان میں تعینات۔ بلوچ سرداروں کو اپنی عزت کا اتنا زیادہ پاس تھا کہ خاص مواقع پر اس کی بگھی کے گھوڑے کھول کے اسے خود اپنے ہاتھوں سے کھینچ کے لیجایا کرتے تھے۔ اتنی اوقات تھی ان سرداروں کے باپ دادا کی۔ اور انھیں اپنا آقا سمجھنے والے قبائیلی غلاموں کی سوچ کا اندازہ خود ہی لگا لیں
Sorry to say Ashir bhai but punjab resisted against British. Sikh empire had considerable muslims in its armies.The problem with Punjab was that we had an internal conflict between muslims and sikhs. Punjab was the last state major adversary that british waited to invade. It was not until Ranjit Singh died that british started to fight against punjab. The problem with punjab was internal conflict with sikhs. When sikhs started to subjugate muslims there were muslim revolts notable how punjab sided with Shah Wali Ullah. The chieftains of punjab sided with british to tackle the sikh-muslim problem.
With all the natural resources Balochisan people should be the most prosperous. It is the opposite. They have the right to be angry at Islamabad. Fix the problem and uplift the Baloch people.
بلکل درست فرما رہے ہیں آپ ، اس کا مطلب تو یہ ہوتا ہے ک پاکستان کے مسئلے کا صرف ایک ہی حل ہے اور وہ یہ کہ یورپی یونین کی طرح، Union of Independent states of Indus Valley.
سر پنجابیوں کے خیالات ، احساسات اور جذبات اب کچھ کچھ بلوچیوں اور پٹھانوں جیسے ہوتے جا رہے ہیں اور میرے مشاہدے کے مطابق اب پنجابیوں میں بھی گیم 50،۔ 50 ہو چکی ہوئی ہے
Excellent analysis once again about the Baloch issue, Sir. Just to add my few cents, you said that the Sikhs didn't collaborate with the British. Isn't it true the British Indian Army and Police forces had a notable Sikh and even Pushtoon presence? Both were considered 'Martial Races' as were many Muslim Punjabi clans.
very well elaborated....it is only development, improvement in the quality of life, a sense of real participation and respectful behaviour that can create harmony...apart from fishing and boat building, coastal tourism alone can earn billions of dollars. but the real problem in our country is 'badniyyati' in everything we do and the urge for taking undue credit.....with great remorse we have to admit that we are narrow minded and small hearted people.
Respectfully, Sindhi is also a nation with well documented history of before 712 AD and 7000 old civilization. I am surprised that in your whole discussion, you missed to discuss Sindh as a nation and its demand for right of self determination since 70's. Sindh was an independent country until British invaded, and Sindh was the last country in the region that British took control. Though, you have vey well described history of rest of the nations of Pakistan including Balich, Pakhtoon, Bengali (lucky to be separated), and Punjabi. regards
@@junaidshaikh9980 Point is so much clear, MI6 and western capitalist establishment created pakistan.... Only INDIA GOT INDEPENDENCE from great Britain, north western india I mean today's pakistan is until now a slave colony of colonial Power
@@junaidshaikh9980 why waste your time thinking about past mistakes. Secularism is not non religiosity or non godliness, it is about laws, to manage a modern complex nation state. 👍
The most tragic aspect of our history is that our rulers are still trying to rule us like British and unfortunately the stakes of those who matters are not in Pakistan
Greetings from Quetta BALOCHISTAN..
Ashir sb they need a playground to practice, to earn money, to smuggle goods, to create uncertainty..
And BALOCHISTAN is the Favorite playground...
THE BITTER TRUTH BROTHER 🔊.. QUESTION IS AS A CITIZEN AS A NATION OR AS AN INDIVIDUAL WHAT CAN I OR WE CAN DO OUR BALOCHISTAN OUR COUNTRY?
but some maven are saying something else... according to them current rise in insurgency of balochistan is due to the zero tolerance policy about smuggling of security departments in balochistan... as bread of powerfuls is on stak now...
Hopefully they get your message .you are a true Pakistani 👍🏻
Aashir bhaii you are 100% correct. those who live out of Punjab realise the actual situation on ground. Allah bless you and Pakistan.
Ashir sab what a great analysis.i totally agree with you.because i am also a Punjabi. My thoughts near to u. Pakistan needs person like you. Khush rahiain. GOD bless you. Rashid bhutto from Town ship Lahore
Balochistan Azad Hoga 😢😢
I think Pakistan govt should learn from this legend with open heart and also take advantage of this gem. Is tarah k bndy bht kam paida hoty hn
Is tarah kai banday zimadari se bhag jatay hai, aur bahir se lecture detey hai, banda wohi himat wala hota hai jo system me reh ker system ko tek kernay kai lia apna kirdar adda karay
@@AbdullahKhan-bf9jibaat karna asaan he jo ap kar rahay hain
@@AbdullahKhan-bf9ji lol 15 saal case larra Aashir bhai nae apnae ooper corruption k ilzam ka, family chali gayi lakin wo nahi gaye jab tak unka name clear nahi hoa
istarah k jhootae comment gunah-e-Jairya mein aatae hein, agar aapko sach nahi pata tu buhtaan q laga rahae hein
Yaad rakhein jab tak yea jhoot yahan likha rahae ga aap ko iska gunah milta rahae ga
Beta bhaga nhi hai apne ko punjabi establishment se clear kar k retirement le k phir bahir gya hai Punjabi establishment ne is gareeb Punjabi ko CIA ka agent keh kar nokri se fairg kiya tha phir ap k court ne clear kiya tha yeh hai history asal@@AbdullahKhan-bf9ji
pakistan ki govt ne kuch suna aur samjh na hota tu ajj yeh din daikhnay na parhtay!
Great show and truth in abundance ❤
Liked and subscribed
Asher seems like a very intelligent and knowledgeable person with his heart in the right place
عاشر بھائی آپ کا تجزیہ لاجواب ہے۔آج جاوید ہاشمی نے ایک پروگرام میں کہا ہے کہ پاکستان بننے کے بعد پہلے مسنگ پرسن قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح تھے۔اور یہ سچ بھی ہے۔
Right
Absolutely. Quaid could not vision and judge the people around him. Instead of hearing legends like Maulana Abul Kalam, who predicted exactly 14 points for the creation of Pakistan, Jinnah collected the Vaderas and Landlords from both sides from Sind, Punjab and Lucknow. The result is a Super Elite called Army Establishment, and an elite of landlords and sardars.
The real people were ignored, and Pakistan became a Security State and the Army became a rentier army in search of dollars.
The result, lakhs of muslim brothers killed and violated by the Pakistani Army from East Pakistan, to Balochistan, to Kashmir, to KP FATA to Afghanistan. What a shame.
@@JangBahadur-zn1ft hey hey hey stop here. Its not army. Its common people who gather on the voice of a street mullah to kill some non Muslim on blame of blasphemy. Its common people who used to cheer on shia killings and chanting slogans of shia kafir. It were common people who did not care when USA launched drone attacks on western border. Why do you blame army for everything? Its common people who consider Taliban better Muslims than army. You yourself/ we ourselves are duffers, fools and ideologically backward and not pak army. Forces are reflection of a society.
Very well done sir. this will continue and cover all the aspects. We are such grateful for your efforts. 🙏 doosri baat isbaar aap ka artistic sense of composing frame and background its really nice and refreshing 🌟.
assalam o allikum
whatever u said made a lot of sense and the thing that appealed me the most was u talked about the solutions at the same time. there are lots and lots of people talking about the problems, they won't hesitate even adding fuel to the fire but this vlog was a v beautiful balance of identifying the problems, cause of the problems and then solutions. much needed way of approaching things JIZAKALLAH KHAIR
Watan balochistan zindabad ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Great Ashir bhi, you are a heroics personality for millions of Pakistanis including myself who were in teen and young age during 90s because after extra ordinary performance Dhuwan. And I think you are again playing a similar role in educating our nation. I have just a comment that you haven't touched the role of china, Iran, India USA in Balochistan. How can we save ourselves in this tug og war ? And don't you think that balochis are also been used ? How could it's possible for them to through the weapons and stop demanding separate state, while having a great support from foreign agencies ?
I think you didn't understand the video. He Explained Everything without explaining.
Power of language is unbelieveably strong
Brilliantly said. This is amazing.
Very insightful and thought provoking.
We need police like you were in dhuwan drama Real bold and brave honest officer
As A Baloch From Quetta,Balochistan
I Love How He Tells The Truth Without Being Biased
We lost a gem of Pakistan and now that gem is in the crown of Canada shame on us . Ashir Azeem we wish you best of luck
Free Balochistan pak army 😢😢
Such a wise, talented & respectful man. 😊
I wish I also experience that kind of intellectuality.
Phenomenal Sir.. Really very impressive analysis
May Allah Almighty bless u
Love Balochistan zindabad ❤❤❤
Dear Sir,
I appreciate your broader concept of Nationalism, which is a guarantee of a united Pakistan. 💐
پاکستان کے قیام میں بنگالیوں کا بہت بڑا حصہ تھا بے شک یہ بہت ذہین اور بہادر لوگ ہیں ۔
Being a Punjabi, I second whatever Aashir Azeem said about Punjabis. Our racial relationship is based on Islam. Whether it’s Pashtuns, Balouchs, Bengalis or even Turkish, Arabs or any other Muslim race for that matter. I feel like Punjabis and Sindis are same in terms of speaking for their rights.
Great in-depth analysis. I really like your analysis Aashir Bhai.
Very very nice analysis, rather excellent.
Sane voice, good analysis. Presently, people look for opportunities, development, rights, freedom from unnecessary force and influence and theft of resources. The reason that the present movement in Balochistan is different from the previous one; this time its both political and economic.
یہ ہمارے رنگ ہیں
یہ ہمارا حصہ ہیں
کیا ہی خوبصورت انداز ہے سر آپکا
انتہائی دل کو چھونے والی بات
Sach an amazing analysis sir lot of love from Balochistan.❤
Allah PAK hmary mulk Aur Balochistan ka hami o Nasir ho.
Ameeen
Ashir Sahib. I am and have been one of your biggest fans since “dhuan” era. I have also been following most of your videos on UA-cam and agree with almost all of your views. Unfortunately, this is the first time, I happen to disagree with your point of view on almost all your views (almost all, but not all). I wish I had the ways and means to give my counter argument to the points you have raised. Nonetheless, you will always be remembered as Pakistan’s most sincere son, in my humble opinion.
As always, each episode of your vlog offers a new perspective on positive thought. I fully agree with your analysis and the proposed solutions to these conflicts. I believe that over 80% of the population is already aware of these issues, but the leadership, including certain individuals in key military positions who lack personal stakes in Pakistan, remain disconnected from the gravity of the situation. They continue to exploit resources without regard for the long-term impact, ultimately abandoning the country. I remain hopeful for better times and believe that we must contribute to the nation's progress within our capacities.
Sir Ashir : A true patriot
Long live free Baluchistan
Totally agreed. I wish i could make everyone listen to this masterpiece.
Ashir Sab,how can be one that practical and realistic 😮
I wish we would understand that diversity is something to be celebrated and not to be condemned.
Very well analyzed and said.
Great person and great analysis. 👍
Dear Ashir thank you for a very informative talk. I found it a very fascinating listen. I agree the Baloch, Pashtun and Bengali as well as being an ethnic group, they are also a nation but you didn’t mention the Sindhi or the Urdu speaking Muhajirs... Please discuss. Thank you
This started way back in 15th century when Gawadar was attacked by Portuguese( Vasco Da Gama ). The dust never settled since then
Sir very true and analysis on ground realities 👍🏻👌🏻👍🏻
Thank you so much for your brilliant ideas Sir. May God give our rulers some sense.
Respect for you n fully agreed with you 🎉....may THEY listen n act upon your suggestions AAMEEN
Common thing is UNJUSTICE, NOT NATIONALISM
Thank you sir for information big respect big love
I totally understand & agree with you Asher. God bless you
Sir totally agree the solutions you gave,we never want to go to root cause so problem never ends.
However one point i coudnt understand that you have ignored the struggle of sindhis against Angrez bahadur,and sindhis never were the beneficiary of Angrez saltanat.
I am from punjab but I ❤all provisional people balochisitan is very good
Ye sary baat hamary army smagh ly aor hamary sary pakistan ko bacha ly
Hamary hr province ka bahut hi piara aor different taste h aor ye Allah ki tarf sy gift h
Allah hamary sary province aor sary provisional people ko salamt rakhy
Ameen
One can make out from your comment itself, how much you want to treat Baloch people.
Why should the Baloch people be provisional? They are not provisional, but permanent people of Balochistan.
I think it is Allah’s marzi that Bangladesh was created. Allah is the best planner, and I pray he frees the Baloch from the tyranny of the Pakistani Army Establishment. Inshallah.
Baloch have been mistreated worse than the Bengalis. That is a cold fact,, no doubt.
People will now bash you in comment section, just beware that these are paid bots of India so dont get demoralised, Hatts off.
@@zarrarsaif9607 People using VPNs are common Zarar bhai. Indian servers are now getting as good.
@@JangBahadur-zn1ft exactly these all are proxies of enemies
Part 1. Dear Aashir Azeem Sahb! With reverence! i would say that in your vlog there are many confused and weaken things regarding the past history of Baloch & Pashtoons political legacy and struggle against British regime/era because British Empire had been completely won their war against Baloch & Pashtoon tribes that's why British Govt.constructed the railway system upto Quetta in the eastern side whereas upto Landi Kotal towards NWFP. Furthermore Amir Aman Ullah the Afghan Emperior became compelled to sign the peace accord with British, Govt. of India then the deurend live accord between afghan and British Govt. was came into existence which still prevails by legitimately and documented under International Laws, Geneva Convention mandate and UNO charter accepts its credible status by legally! before this Raja Ranjit Singh was being conquered the whole Punjab and defeated the Afghan and grabbed their large part of their soil which is now the integrated part of Pakistan and Insha-Allah will remain forever in next centuries.
When British Govt. succeeded in Balochistan and Pashtoon areas then Viceroy fixed the annual grants/stipend to all chiefs/sardars and khawaneen to hold their control over their peoples and this type of system in which the annual stipend/grants were paying to all chiefs of all states/tribes in all over Pakistan specially in Balochistan and Pashtoon agencies until the P.M Zulifiqar Ali Bhutto Shaheed announced and stopped the stipends/grants and also Z.A Bhutto Sahb announced the termination of sardari nizam in 1973. those sardars and chiefs of tribes and Pashtoon khawaneen of NWFP agencies who were getting millions of rupees per anum, they became very angry and shown their enemity against Shaheed Z.A Bhutto while Gen.Zia deposed the Bhutto Govt.and took wrong and counter measures against Bhutto Sahb.again Zia Ul Haq restored their cancelled stipends/grants to get the favour of all Baloch Tribe Chiefs and khawaneen/mashra's of Pashtoon Belt agencies in NWFP.
Dear Ashir Sahb! The all Baloch tribes are not similar as a one nation by their language, norms and customs and cultural wise they posses different heritage and behaviour! for example! many Baloch tribes speak different accent with different pronounciation, as such many tribes speak Balochi language dominant by Persian language, many Baloch tribes speak purely siraiki language, many Baloch tribes speak Sindhi Punjabi, Siraiki mixed language bases. for example! Jamali Baloch, Rind Baloch, Lasi Baloch, Langah Baloch, Mazari Baloch and others small groups further a large number of Brahvi/Brohi peoples/tribes also residing in Balochistan for since last centuries but they do not consider themselves as part of Baloch Nation. rather they become angry when anybody calls them Baloch in ignorance!
When Mohattaram Quaid Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah Sahb, Mr.Mount Beton, Mr.Mohandas Gandhi and Mr. Jawaharlal Nehru became agreed upon the final draft of declaration of freedom in which an important article was contend that all states which were in prevailing then will join to their respective countries territory and if any state of their respective country will not comply the instructions of their respective countries then this type of act should be mounted as an attempt of rebellion so while India divided into two countries as Pakistan & Bharat then all states and provinces were merged & joint to their respective countries. e.g. Bahawalpur Province and all other states as such Khairpur, Sawat, Hunza, Lasbela, were merged in Pakistan. so how could it was possible that Qallat state refused to join Pakistan! rather it was deliberate attempt of molafied act of rebellion from the Govt of Pakistan & its territory. Cont:
Dr.Shaikhu Larkana
Well Needed research and analysis ❤
I am from Balochistan city of Quetta ashier sab sir you are ware will guide for my nation but so sad 😭😭😭😭 my nation was not andarstand your advice so sad sir.god bless you .
How ugly English you have used. If you can't write in the correct English batter to write in Urdu
Interesting thought, Ashir Bhai, but i have a few reservations.
Sub nationalism essentially means that you are to stand for your own nation, not for the whole country. When sub nationalism is supplemented by populism, which is very easy to implement in Pakistan due to lack of literacy & critical thinking, it will ultimately always lead to anarchy & chaos type scenarios. This will still continue to happen regardless of whether they get their real leadership or the fake one. Populists will always blame Punjab regardless of what Punjab does.
Your thought pattern is good because you are a good man, but you are judging it more like the Canadian people. I dont think it will be the case for the people here.
Nice analysis sir ...
Kash GHQ mein bethe 12 jammat pass Rooh Afza/Jam e shirin k wapari Journelon ko yeh baat smjh aa jaye ..
Stay blessed my beautiful Balochistan...
Stay Blessed Pakistan ...
Ashir bhai
Aap ki bat 100% right hn. Aap sy pakisatani bhht muhabt krty hn.
Mgr Aap jesa inteligent Insan yey q nhi sochta k is dunya mn zulm aur zalim hi kamyab hn. Yahan achy log mushkilat ka shikar hn.
To kia aik dusra jahan nhi hona chahiye jahan zalim ko saza mily aur mazlom aur achy logon ko prize aur respect. Warna to ye lazim aaiey ga k ye dunya ye zindagi bs aesy hi bana di aur is ka koi maqsad nhi.
Jb koi aik insan koi bhi kaam bhager maqsad k nhi karta to phir ALLAH TAA'LA ye dunya bagher maqsad k k sy bana skty hn.
Never listen such a brief history of Baluchistan. Nice effort and simply describe for common people
Great son of Pakistan. Ashir Azeem.
Spot on Analysis!
ماشاءاللّہ سر جی
بہترین تجزیہ ❤❤❤
Ashir Sahb,i watch your videos and i find them informative... but why did you not mention Sindh, we also have our own identity, we speak Sindhi.. I was waiting to listen about Sindh from you but perhaps you forgot it...!
Great Explanation.❤
Baluchis consist of 3%, Pashtuns about 15%, and Punjabis over 50% of Pakistan thus their higher, but not disproportionate representation in Govt.. Punjabis in the Army are mainly from the arid Potohar region where the British recruited soldiers much before partition and its still a traditional there. You will agree that the Army ISSB test requires prowess and a mindset which is not for everyone, despite Bhutto’s “quota system” of 1971 where the qualifying height for Sind and Baluchistan was rolled back from 5’6” to 5’4” and a new Sind Regiment garrisoned in Hyderabad. Sadly the Sindhi recruitment is low despite ongoing efforts.
Still, the Punjabi numbers in the Military is around 50%, likely less in the Officers grades and PAF/Navy.
Ironically, almost all dictators our country got were non-Punjabi. Ayub, Yahya, Musharraf. Everyone except Zia. This flies in the face of your thesis of a “bad Punjabi army”. Ayub, Yahya, Bhutto (with Tikka Khan) and Musharraf (who murdered Nawab Bugti then came on national TV to brag about it) were directly responsible for the chaos in Baluchistan. In fact Gen. Zia provided amnesty to the Baluch and Pashtun and peace was restore. Facts cannot be changed. You should know better than most, that the COAS and his close generals are directly responsible for the Army’s follies.
Punjab and Punjabis are just a favorite scapegoat which has outlived its usefulness.
You talk about your memorable years in Baluchistan befriending sons of Sardars and glorifying their way of life, but have you ever lived in a Punjabi or Sindhi village where backbreaking toil and poverty is a common occurrence amongst other vile and violent incarcerations. You talk of the dark migration of 1947. Trekking over corpses to Pakistan; the old man’s heart would break today seeing his grand children still suffering. Agreed that the rich central plains of Punjab and Sind have been bereft with inequality, and the waderas and Chaudhries are cruel, but that is changing as land is getting fragmented. It may take longer in Sind given the size of holdings. But tell me what have the Sardars of Baluchistan and Malik’s of Pakhtunkwa done for their people despite getting regular levies and development funds from the Govt. I hear they discouraged schooling for decades and their people would come to Punjab and Sind to study.
To strengthen your argument of “bad Punjabis” you conveniently removed the Sikhs from Punjab because they were the most formidable against the British, more so then the Baluch or Pashtuns who would ambush and then vanish into inhospitable terrain. Raja Ranjit Singh had many Muslim fighters in his army and scholars as his close aids because they shared a similar language and culture. Not only did they keep the British at bay but pushed the Pashtuns to the Kabul river.
As regards your lists of HiFi values, maybe you would like to tell me why poor laborers passing through their territory are pulled out of buses and executed and innocent citizens are kidnapped and held in these areas for ransom?
Punjab has a long and storied history of Saints, Sufis, Poets and folklore. All they preached was love, brotherhood and peace. If you don’t believe me read up on Baba Bulleh Shah, Waris Shah, Shah Inayat. Then make your own list for Punjab.
We all know that the crux of the problem, as you do, is successive military juntas controlling and usurping all political and economic resources. You are just using the “Punjabi” card to play to the gallery and/or securing a safe passage for yourself to return home one day.
I almost forgot, the three reasons for making Pakistan was not by the Punjabis. Only two of your reasons are valid. The first is that Mr. Jinnah espoused a two nation theory of Muslims and Hindus on which the creation of Pakistan was based. The second point was the language issue. Punjabis already had a rich language, In fact they sacrificed their own culture and heritage for the sake of Pakistan’s unity and embraced Urdu to the detriment of Punjabi. Close associates of the Quaid, mostly from Urdu speaking UP convinced Mr. Jinnah to have a unifying language as India had opted for Hindi. Obviously none of them were aware of the cultural and social implications.
The point you shrugged off with a grin about the Khilafat Movement was a very significant moment in the Muslim Ummah’s memory and many lost their lives. Since you may be unaware of its importance I’ll let you have a “hall pass” on this one
Ashir Bhai,
You're Real Hero Not Just In This Drama Also In Real Life...
Big Fan Of You, By The Way My Name Is Too AZHAR...
From Daska District Sialkot...
One question. Why did you kept Sindh aside of all the points you discussed?
Just a little hateful tone for "Punjab" and "Punjabis"; not observed at the outset but can be observed while reading between the lines and observing your non-verbals. Seems like you do not like Punjabi culture, you might have had certain bad experiences. In your previous videos you mentioned a sentence the British had coined. "If you want to rule the Baloch, honour them. If Punjabis, just rule them". I do not know whether your diagnosis of the Punjabi inferiority is correct or false. I just know that it exists, very subtly, in your messages.
Best of luck dear.
رابرٹ سنڈیمن ایک انگریز ریزیڈنٹ تھا صوبہ سرحد بلوچستان میں تعینات۔
بلوچ سرداروں کو اپنی عزت کا اتنا زیادہ پاس تھا کہ خاص مواقع پر اس کی بگھی کے گھوڑے کھول کے اسے خود اپنے ہاتھوں سے
کھینچ کے لیجایا کرتے تھے۔
اتنی اوقات تھی ان سرداروں کے باپ دادا کی۔
اور انھیں اپنا آقا سمجھنے والے قبائیلی غلاموں کی سوچ کا اندازہ خود ہی لگا لیں
Ashir bhie U r Our Hero
U r in Our Heart ❤
Apny Pakistan man Change k lye Bht Efferts ki thi
Sorry to say Ashir bhai but punjab resisted against British. Sikh empire had considerable muslims in its armies.The problem with Punjab was that we had an internal conflict between muslims and sikhs. Punjab was the last state major adversary that british waited to invade. It was not until Ranjit Singh died that british started to fight against punjab. The problem with punjab was internal conflict with sikhs. When sikhs started to subjugate muslims there were muslim revolts notable how punjab sided with Shah Wali Ullah. The chieftains of punjab sided with british to tackle the sikh-muslim problem.
Lots of love and respect for u ashir bhie ❤❤
With all the natural resources Balochisan people should be the most prosperous. It is the opposite. They have the right to be angry at Islamabad. Fix the problem and uplift the Baloch people.
بلکل درست فرما رہے ہیں آپ ، اس کا مطلب تو یہ ہوتا ہے ک پاکستان کے مسئلے کا صرف ایک ہی حل ہے اور وہ یہ کہ یورپی یونین کی طرح،
Union of Independent states of Indus Valley.
very nice ashir bhai ❤❤ love you.
100% agreed.
سر پنجابیوں کے خیالات ، احساسات اور جذبات
اب کچھ کچھ بلوچیوں اور پٹھانوں جیسے ہوتے جا رہے ہیں
اور میرے مشاہدے کے مطابق اب پنجابیوں میں بھی گیم 50،۔ 50 ہو چکی ہوئی ہے
Excellent analysis once again about the Baloch issue, Sir.
Just to add my few cents, you said that the Sikhs didn't collaborate with the British.
Isn't it true the British Indian Army and Police forces had a notable Sikh and even Pushtoon presence? Both were considered 'Martial Races' as were many Muslim Punjabi clans.
Thanks your Explikation.
Great work sir. Appreciate it
I Respect you Sir. You are absolutely right
Sir i want Dhuwan Drama part 2 you are my role model since i watch your dhuwan drama and your acting was phenomenal ❤
Real analysis gill Sahab
Proud of u sir❤❤❤❤
Thank you Sir.
Excellent Analys and points
Ashir I tell you one thing Balochis hate the concept of Cantts and cantonments! They hate Army presence!
Which should be hated by all
@@umairmughal8410 Isn't that what I'm saying??
Respected Sir, What about Sindh Province and Sindhi.
Kindly assist
very well elaborated....it is only development, improvement in the quality of life, a sense of real participation and respectful behaviour that can create harmony...apart from fishing and boat building, coastal tourism alone can earn billions of dollars. but the real problem in our country is 'badniyyati' in everything we do and the urge for taking undue credit.....with great remorse we have to admit that we are narrow minded and small hearted people.
God bless you Sir. Many thanks for guiding me.
Kiya guide kiya hey ji aap ko ashir bhai nay zara explain kero?
@@wildlifenaturephotographyv4875 I am not supposed to explain you.
Dear Ashir Azeem Sahib 🎉 you did awesome research 👌 Well-Described 🎉🎉
Stay safe and healthy 👌
Brother kindly give references or suggest the names of books. You explained the whole history very well!
Aashir do you have any problem with Sindhis ?
I also noticed he never mentioned any details about SINDH !
very well defined and analyzed sir, your knowledge ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sir, you are our hero and ideal person since drama Duwaan . We proud over your thoughts.
All solutions r great but there is an Elite in the way of these fantastic solutions.
Fair analysis based on truth❤❤❤❤❤❤
Respectfully, Sindhi is also a nation with well documented history of before 712 AD and 7000 old civilization. I am surprised that in your whole discussion, you missed to discuss Sindh as a nation and its demand for right of self determination since 70's. Sindh was an independent country until British invaded, and Sindh was the last country in the region that British took control. Though, you have vey well described history of rest of the nations of Pakistan including Balich, Pakhtoon, Bengali (lucky to be separated), and Punjabi. regards
Pakistan will not move an inch without a secular constitution.
So what's point of making of Pakistan and separation of united India.
@@junaidshaikh9980
Point is so much clear,
MI6 and western capitalist establishment created pakistan....
Only INDIA GOT INDEPENDENCE from great Britain, north western india I mean today's pakistan is until now a slave colony of colonial Power
@@junaidshaikh9980 why waste your time thinking about past mistakes. Secularism is not non religiosity or non godliness, it is about laws, to manage a modern complex nation state. 👍
@@junaidshaikh9980bhai, your question will remain unanswered
You can not make people fool...we also hail from Balochistan
Excellent and well explaind
Aashir you are undoubtedly a true legend, got clearer understanding than dumb scholars and duffer generals.
🙏
Totally agreed
The most tragic aspect of our history is that our rulers are still trying to rule us like British and unfortunately the stakes of those who matters are not in Pakistan
In total agreement with you!