This is Bitterness truths disclosed, explained & discussion by TN Sudarshan sir ,Major Gen GD Bakshi sir, Sister Madhuji & our all Sangam Mentors. Thanks for Awareness to Indian...
RC guha is one of the most venerated scroundrels in the eco system media. Unworthy chap anyway. He found ways to earn his livelihood. That is his lifetime achievement which may fetch him some award by the way.
I.Ramamurthy Mr. Guha is self styled left liberandi and admirer of Nehru normally has to support Nehru-left social economic drum. He never analysed the real calibre of Subash Chandra Bose, Sardar Patel and gave a credit to these people. Unfortunately, he gave full credit to anti India, anti hindu bigot Nehru, Jinnah and barbarian EVR. Like Nehru, M.K. Gandhi, etc strong supporter of islamic fanatics. Gandhi and Nehru are the biggest betrayer of Hindus. Guha socalled eminent historian, his like other left historians have only copied the formula dictated by Max Muller and ignored the indian history till 1193 and accepted the indian history from barbarian invaded muslim period from 1193 and distorted the real indian history. Better ignore the left liberandi historians. Jai Hind Bharat Mata ki jai Vande Matharam Satyameva Jayate
Hearing Guha for sometime is enough to understand him as a left leaning political Activist using his historian status in furthering his Agenda. As rightly observed he uses facts to suit his own narrative. Fiberal distorian is the perfect discription of Guhahaha.
काश!ये विर्मश हिन्दी या भारतीय भाषा में होता तो मैं स्कूल जाते हुए छात्रों में सुना देता। विश्वास कीजिए , एक साल में भारत सरकार को गलत पढ़ाने के मजे आ जाते। मैं हमेशा इंगलिश व्याख्यान को पुरा सुनकर डिसलाइक बटन दबा देता हूं। आप में और उनमें भाषाई आधार पर कोई विभेद नही है।
प्रणाम संतोष जी। आपका कथन उचित है कि अंग्रेजी भाषा के कारण एक साधारण भारतीय जिसे अंग्रेजी का ज्ञान नहीं है, ऐसे ज्ञान से वंचित रह जाता है। क्या हम इस ज्ञान को सरल भाषा में अनुवाद करके, लिखकर या बोलकर, साधारण जन तक पहुंचा सकते हैं? मैं शीघ्र ही ऐसा करने का प्रयास करूंगा।
No one thought that Ramachandra Guha would join the liberals and dynasty Nehruvian Congress to oppose BJP. Probably he would be loyal to dynasty Congress for awarding awards. He should not distort our hindu culture and tradition. If he is very true to history, he should bring out all true facts of Nehru and Gandhi from their early life. We all know how hindus were treated badly by appeasing minorities, by these two persons. Ramachandra Guha's false narratives by other persons quotes to escape his responsibility. He should know Gandhi never wanted division of India but was made to agree for creation of Pakistan. We are seeing how terrorism was introduced in India and Guha should come out with how they are dangerous to India and world order. Guha thinks it is fashion to celebrate colonial British who squandered India's wealth and support opponents of hindutva. Guha has no authority to speak how brahmins should be or hindutva. Guha seems to be leaning towards communists. Better to neglect him and his works.
When someone says India should never become super power you very well know what does he want. He wants Indians to live in poverty and under subjugation of all kinds of enemies. So you know who and what he is. Clearly stating he is anti-India and therefore he is a traitor and must be tried under sedition laws.
He is reliable to be known as liar and biased. Pseudointellectual.. knowing this language in public discourse was one a overrated attribute but this privilege is gone. Rat holes have been flooded.
Mis representation of facts or distortion are the right words, but why such people are doing this , is it for money, fame or hatred towards Hindu's, it cannot be ideology.
The way Nehru Chamchas DEBASE , some Congress Leaders just because they arent loyal to Nehru Khandaa is shameful and exposed their inhuman slavish mindset
He may be an admirer of gandhi and nehru but he cannot discard their failures which are plaguing present india. If we observe the same line of division theory of caste is played by most of the authors. To worship lord rama and Krishna we need certificate from gandhi. That is the irony.
This Guha fellow cannot be called a historian by any stretch of imagination. He is basically a paid leftist who writes what his paying masters want him to write. Most of what he has written can be beautifully described in a Sanskrit adage उष्ट्रानां विवाहेषु गर्दभं गीत गायंति परस्परं प्रशंसंती अहो रूपं अहो ध्वनी.
Ramachandra Guha is known for his selective intellectualism, although his works are reliable, he holds a very biased view regarding Indian history. For instance, in his bestseller book, India After Gandhi, he doesn't even say a word about Jawaharlal Nehru's (whom Guha admires) role in curbing free speech through the draconian First Amendment Act. In his other bestseller book, Makers of Modern India, he has included Muhammad Ali Jinnah and E. V. Ramaswami (Periyar) as the Makers of Modern India and has excluded Subhas Chandra Bose and Sardar Patel, because they lacked what he calls “original ideas” and “both were out and out 'doers', whose writings were either insubstantial or merely humdrum”. Even worse is that Ram Guha in an article, he wrote for the Hindustan Times, has termed Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, a “regional figure” and “a lord in an age of feudalism who endorsed caste hierarchies”.
Very poor presentation. Manogna Shastry and Anurag's presentation on Irfan Habib and Romila Thapar were much better. Malhotra said that there should be no insulting, rhetoric, but a cold decimation of these leftists with facts. That was completely missing here as he was giving more rhetoric than facts.
Name calling......an old propaganda technique to discredit those whose political views contradict own beliefs & world view......these speakers need to critique the intellectual content created by Guha rather than attempting to discredit him through these childish talks.
I just request my friends to read Ram Guha to understand the nuances and intricacies of his writings so that we don’t go downward from the democracy to an authoritarian regime.
who is giving importance to this distorian? which political party gave him Padmavibhushan? He hasgiven selective nnarrow personal view of the Indian history. He should be neglected and ignored by all the Indians .early the better.
If only he'd shown some conciliatory noises towards RSS & BJP, this particular 'eco system' would celebrate him as dharmic, just as they accept savarkar's aethism as dharmic
Thanks for exposing such distorians like RC guha, romila and irfan habib etc
Two super words- Fiberals and Distorian 😂
Yes 😂
He is more a Cricket historian. An anarchist.
Mr Guha = Anarchic Fiberal Dystorian.
Sums up his personality !!!!
He is not a fibber but a Liar . Outright propagandist
Guha is a mere cricket historian. We don't take him seriously. He is no scholar.
This is Bitterness truths disclosed, explained & discussion by TN Sudarshan sir ,Major Gen GD Bakshi sir, Sister Madhuji & our all Sangam Mentors. Thanks for Awareness to Indian...
More power to all involved with Sangam talks
RC guha is one of the most venerated scroundrels in the eco system media. Unworthy chap anyway. He found ways to earn his livelihood. That is his lifetime achievement which may fetch him some award by the way.
Guha is gunman of SICKularism 😂😂😂😂😂
Hindus in India must understand what is gaher.
What is gaher? I could not find anything on google 🙄🙄
I.Ramamurthy
Mr. Guha is self styled left liberandi and admirer of Nehru normally has to support Nehru-left social economic drum. He never analysed the real calibre of Subash Chandra Bose, Sardar Patel and gave a credit to these people. Unfortunately, he gave full credit to anti India, anti hindu bigot Nehru, Jinnah and barbarian EVR.
Like Nehru, M.K. Gandhi, etc strong supporter of islamic fanatics. Gandhi and Nehru are the biggest betrayer of Hindus. Guha socalled eminent historian, his like other left historians have only copied the formula dictated by Max Muller and ignored the indian history till 1193 and accepted the indian history from barbarian invaded muslim period from 1193 and distorted the real indian history. Better ignore the left liberandi historians.
Jai Hind Bharat Mata ki jai Vande Matharam Satyameva Jayate
Cute
Very interesting but I wish he had presented actual quotes from Guha’s oeuvre.
Archaeologist with plenty of field experience have the right to be promoted as historian. Only theory will not do the needful justice.
Hearing Guha for sometime is enough to understand him as a left leaning political Activist using his historian status in furthering his Agenda. As rightly observed he uses facts to suit his own narrative. Fiberal distorian is the perfect discription of Guhahaha.
To me guha is just a English skilled fictious writer doing western interpretation of ancient Indian history without any original research.
Thought provoking
काश!ये विर्मश हिन्दी या भारतीय भाषा में होता तो मैं स्कूल जाते हुए छात्रों में सुना देता।
विश्वास कीजिए , एक साल में भारत सरकार को गलत पढ़ाने के मजे आ जाते।
मैं हमेशा इंगलिश व्याख्यान को पुरा सुनकर डिसलाइक बटन दबा देता हूं।
आप में और उनमें भाषाई आधार पर कोई विभेद नही है।
ऐसे भाषण हिंदी उप-शीर्षकोंके साथ प्रसृत करने चाहिये!
प्रणाम संतोष जी। आपका कथन उचित है कि अंग्रेजी भाषा के कारण एक साधारण भारतीय जिसे अंग्रेजी का ज्ञान नहीं है, ऐसे ज्ञान से वंचित रह जाता है।
क्या हम इस ज्ञान को सरल भाषा में अनुवाद करके, लिखकर या बोलकर, साधारण जन तक पहुंचा सकते हैं?
मैं शीघ्र ही ऐसा करने का प्रयास करूंगा।
@@VikasDhavaria नमस्ते श्री जब भी समय मिलता है यही करता हूं और जिसे बताता हुं उनका प्रतिक्रिया देखने लायक होता है।
@@ashokdeshpande8695 जी, आपका यह सुझाव अत्यंत उपयोगी है।
Guha’s books are published by foreign publishers but that doesn’t make him an intellectual I would put him in the category of pseudos
❤
No one thought that Ramachandra Guha would join the liberals and dynasty Nehruvian Congress to oppose BJP. Probably he would be loyal to dynasty Congress for awarding awards. He should not distort our hindu culture and tradition. If he is very true to history, he should bring out all true facts of Nehru and Gandhi from their early life. We all know how hindus were treated badly by appeasing minorities, by these two persons. Ramachandra Guha's false narratives by other persons quotes to escape his responsibility. He should know Gandhi never wanted division of India but was made to agree for creation of Pakistan. We are seeing how terrorism was introduced in India and Guha should come out with how they are dangerous to India and world order. Guha thinks it is fashion to celebrate colonial British who squandered India's wealth and support opponents of hindutva. Guha has no authority to speak how brahmins should be or hindutva. Guha seems to be leaning towards communists. Better to neglect him and his works.
No, he should be countered, not allowed to get away with lies. That is what sangam talks is doing. Sangam Talks is doing a fantastic job!
He is another false writer😮
When someone says India should never become super power you very well know what does he want. He wants Indians to live in poverty and under subjugation of all kinds of enemies. So you know who and what he is. Clearly stating he is anti-India and therefore he is a traitor and must be tried under sedition laws.
And to think he's such a good Cricket writer!
His History-writing, on the other hand, just isn't cricket!
Doesn't play it with a straight bat! 😀
Nehru is a Brahmin but Shastri isnt a Brahmin ??
Nehru actions was not brahmin but British Islamists
Now only lies of these Ravanas are being challenged
He is reliable to be known as liar and biased. Pseudointellectual.. knowing this language in public discourse was one a overrated attribute but this privilege is gone. Rat holes have been flooded.
Where can I get the book? Hard copy!
To become popular Leftist and anti Hindu smart intellectuals use Gandhi & Nehru.
Mis representation of facts or distortion are the right words, but why such people are doing this , is it for money, fame or hatred towards Hindu's, it cannot be ideology.
Fiberal Distorian - 20:100times the Narrative creator
👌🙏
RG is a cricket chronicler turned distorian
The way Nehru Chamchas DEBASE , some Congress Leaders just because they arent loyal to Nehru Khandaa is shameful and exposed their inhuman slavish mindset
once these Guha sort of guys start earning big money from foreign funds they forget their roots their ancestors they motherland
Guha has always been a Congress bhand akin to those other bhand who always sang paens of Congress and gandhi
He may be an admirer of gandhi and nehru but he cannot discard their failures which are plaguing present india. If we observe the same line of division theory of caste is played by most of the authors. To worship lord rama and Krishna we need certificate from gandhi. That is the irony.
Guha ko maaf kardo…… he is aged don’t waste time in countering Guha…
This Guha fellow cannot be called a historian by any stretch of imagination. He is basically a paid leftist who writes what his paying masters want him to write. Most of what he has written can be beautifully described in a Sanskrit adage
उष्ट्रानां विवाहेषु गर्दभं गीत गायंति
परस्परं प्रशंसंती अहो रूपं अहो ध्वनी.
Historians those who are motivated by some political party then all the history writen by them must corrected by honest and we'll for India.
बड़ी अजीब है भगवान राम का विरोध करने वाले राम जी के नाम से पूरा जीवन जीये जैसे
राम पुनिया
रामचंद्र गुहा
सीताराम येचुरी आदि😂😂😂
N ram also
what is the true motivation of people who spread lies and work hard at it ? is it money and power ?
No need to say who is a real distorian.
How right you are sir! these historians have polluted the minds of our intellectul with his views for long.
Jai modi jai shree krishna Jai shree ram
Ramachandra Guha is known for his selective intellectualism, although his works are reliable, he holds a very biased view regarding Indian history.
For instance, in his bestseller book, India After Gandhi, he doesn't even say a word about Jawaharlal Nehru's (whom Guha admires) role in curbing free speech through the draconian First Amendment Act.
In his other bestseller book, Makers of Modern India, he has included Muhammad Ali Jinnah and E. V. Ramaswami (Periyar) as the Makers of Modern India and has excluded Subhas Chandra Bose and Sardar Patel, because they lacked what he calls “original ideas” and “both were out and out 'doers', whose writings were either insubstantial or merely humdrum”.
Even worse is that Ram Guha in an article, he wrote for the Hindustan Times, has termed Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, a “regional figure” and “a lord in an age of feudalism who endorsed caste hierarchies”.
Bhai
RCG's history is contextual
Do not be an ignorant
He is a bloody anti hindu
0
He(R Guha)is another bogus intelectual! 😮 he is highly paid and hired writer!??! 😮his all works are not worth reading and to be thrown into dustbin😮!?
Very poor presentation. Manogna Shastry and Anurag's presentation on Irfan Habib and Romila Thapar were much better. Malhotra said that there should be no insulting, rhetoric, but a cold decimation of these leftists with facts. That was completely missing here as he was giving more rhetoric than facts.
N ram is also crook
Name calling......an old propaganda technique to discredit those whose political views contradict own beliefs & world view......these speakers need to critique the intellectual content created by Guha rather than attempting to discredit him through these childish talks.
I just request my friends to read Ram Guha to understand the nuances and intricacies of his writings so that we don’t go downward from the democracy to an authoritarian regime.
You can't really understand anything, this doesn't feel like properly researched expose. You guys can do better m
who is giving importance to this distorian? which political party gave him Padmavibhushan? He hasgiven selective nnarrow personal view of the Indian history. He should be neglected and ignored by all the Indians .early the better.
Yes ignore these useless fellows who r of no use to the country
Waste talking about Guha
You're accepting that he doesn't deploy Dharmic lens for contemporary India, but still go ahead and criticise his work thru that lens only 😂
Not a good orator,
Need to improve communication skills.
But still I would appreciate his interest, thats important.
Modi is a good orator , but whats the use.
@@Jai_Gauranga
Janab
Modi Sabh is god itself reincarnated for the resurrection of Jambu Dweepa.
Don't criticize him, heart aches.
@@robertbrowning41 people like you give him the confidence, though he has done 0 for hindus in 10 years.
Please speak content NOT REPEAT SORT OF MILLION TIMES. It irritates.
Thanksfor expressing your thrash opinion on TNSudarshan.
Guha is a true historian having no political interest.
Nice Joke😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
guha is like indian sepoy who gets order by general dyer kills those indians....
Lier
If only he'd shown some conciliatory noises towards RSS & BJP, this particular 'eco system' would celebrate him as dharmic, just as they accept savarkar's aethism as dharmic
Anti India n anti hindu bigot
Hinduism still survives not because of these "bhakts" but because of few honest guhas !
Good joke
Thuu rascal anti hindu liberandu