Sir Michael Marmot on 'grim reality' of poverty in Britain | LBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 січ 2024
- Professor Sir Michael Marmot joins Andrew Marr to discuss alarming data from the NHS, which suggests a signifiant increase in Victorian-era diseases, such as scurvy and rickets, during Rishi Sunak's premiership. Marmot attributes the return of these diseases to poverty and malnutrition and emphasises the 'grim' reality of Britain in 2024.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: l-bc.co/ListenNow
#AndrewMarr #NHS #LBC #RishiSunak #MichaelMarmot
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
A poor country with a few rich people. Well said sir.
The British Empire at it's best
Of course the UK is unequal. The country’s national anthem is about how a king or queen is prioritized over its people.
A country where the vast majority are either poor or very poor with a small minority of rich and super rich is almost by definition a third world country.
David Icke was always right then? 🤔
@@TheSuperPsychoKiller
Verse 6 is anti scottish
Never has the British public become so much poorer under one parliament than they have under this tory government
Hey, what's the problem? London has more millionaires now than it ever did before! They're going to trickle-down their riches to us any day now. Be patient. Work harder.
When capitalism succeeds in channeling wealth away from workers to the mega rich, fascism will rise. Beware.
It's because we give our taxes for people not to work or to work less. Riches come from working
@@Craig121000 yes it did you just never leave the house so don't know. Bet you complained about energy bills right?
@@davidcooks2379 more than half of people on benefits are in work. More people were on benefits in 2010 and not working. The exact opposite happened that you have claimed. Look up marginal propensity to consume and you'll realise instantly why this nation that funnels money to the rich is getting so much poorer.
The average person in Slovenia is living way better than the average UK resident. Almost every one in Slovenia has home property, which is unreachable for an increasing portion of UK society.
Lovely beautiful country that uk cannot match in most essential parameters .
I'm shocked to hear these things. I visited Britain some 20 years ago for study and when I hear such things it is shocking. Greetings from Tunisia.
So, why are people not flocking to Slovenia? 😂
If we were to judge a national standard of living by the percentage of households who own their homes, both Slovenia and Serbia would come far on top of Germany as most Germans rent, not own, their homes.
@@vaska1999 yes. Here in north africa the same. But honestly being in your own house and sometimes even on your own piece of land, and not having debt because you dont use credit gives you a certain security and freedom despite living a simple life.
Lived in UK since 2011 until 2022...since COVID it got me so broke that I ended up on the street after owning a company. Finally made the decision to move back to italy and when I think about how many poor people I left there I get so sad that they don't have another option like I did. My health is still not restored after all the challenges I put my body too just to get by and make debts in UK. Shocking
I hope your better soon. Be aware however that Italy is in just as much trouble, if it is not exactly showing yet, this is going to be world wide.
@@poetmaggie1we are definetly not on the level of having scurvy
And better climate.@@andreabianchi6156
@@borisnegrarosa9113 INDEED . .... never got it why you would want to " live" there , I moved to N. Germany to the coast : clean orderly attention to detail , food , price quality , crispy feeling. Chique houses. Perfectly built , modern triple glazed , renewables , fruit orchards , close to S Scandinavia and the picture perfect cities of N. Poland. Married here from Netherlands , brw also crispy clean , even creepily creaky😮
@@geertstroyif more of you move to Germany then order will be gone
Take a bow, everyone that voted Tory over the last 14 years. This is on YOU!
Blows my mind how they keep voting for the same dusty, worn-out politicians 🤯🤯
Go back a bit further. 1997
It's hard to bow when skiing
@@ClannCholmainNo, he's right. New Labour was just Thatcherism with a new hat.
Brexit has cost £140 Billion so far, imagine if we'd spent that on the country instead.
We haven't "become poor" we've been deliberately made poor.
When we are so poor that we live to work rather than work to live. Rich folks job is done. We effectively become slaves because we have no other options to better our lives. Rich sit in their penthouses and manor houses laughing at hiw they shafted us. Most of us won't even get a pension, so basically worked for nothing all our lives.
Yup, one of the results of capitalism
USA done by lies to rule eu and make down first Germany,started ukrean war the forced is uk usa, German fall on trap,so UK also fail on trap and will suffer lot with no help
Voted for Brexit more likely.
And you voted for it with Brexit. Having said that it is painful to witness this especially as nothing is being done to rectify it.
I am South Korean here. I pray for UK and British people to come back to Lord.
I am often deeply sad how so many British people say badly about their country.
Dear Heavenly Father, please lead them to come back to you so they don’t need to struggle with their false identities and finally see how much God’s grace was poured down on this special country.
It's not just Britain. It's everywhere.
Here's the worst part - people voted for this.
No they voted for the lies they were fed by almost all the tory mainstream media,
To be fair people voted for the cause not the effect. It's important not to just blame voters. They have to see why they shouldn't do it next time.
@@keech100 Scots haven't given the Tories a majority in 70 years so forget a next time!
Scotland never voted for englands disasterous brexit ...time for Scottish independence
To be fair, people were lied to. Leveling up was promised but broken.
As a visitor from Ireland, I have been astonished at the level of poverty in northern England. London is super rich but not representative. Germany imposed a solidarity tax after reunification that transferred wealth from west to east. That’s what England needs but of course the people keep voting for politicians who went to Eton and Oxford. It’s puzzling. What don’t I understand?
The voting system hinders proper representation.
Murdoch propaganda encourages focus on the wrong things
@@emmabrooker166 pointing the poor people at other poor people in rubber dinghy’s deflects from looking at a class of people that can afford €65k a year per child in Eton etc. clever
In America, it's been seen as the "Myth of Individualism"... A Society that works together and prospers together is seen as Flawed, it's those "Cowboys" who are Rough and Tumbled just looking out for themselves and their immediate family who will "Prevail" at the end!
No logic behind it besides the Reagan/Thatcher brainwashing over the last 40 so years!
The north voted Brexit and Tory. You couldn't make it up.
Vitamin C is also in cabbage and cabbage is cheaper than fruit!Fresh potatoes are nearly nutritionally complete too. Processed potatoes like chips, fries aren't nutritionally complete. Tins of beans are cheap and excellent for health. People lack nutrition knowledge, aren't cooking, and rely on processed food when they buy food. Sounds like they also need to offer free breakfast and free lunch at school for poor children.
Kids don't like cabbage
Of course they don't ifthey have a choice and brought up on pizza and chips.
@@sallypickard2227 Maybe they should learn to :)
@@sallypickard2227, They do if they’re hungry !
Cabbage has vitamin C only if eaten raw.
The food we have in the uk is honestly now only only one step above dog food.
Finally someone said it… the food quality has become shocking over the last few years
Yes! So noticeable! I moved back to Spain a month ago and the difference is unbelievable.
Agreed! I visited the U.K. twice recently and was appalled at what was on offer at the supermarkets. Nearly as bad as China. And that's saying something.
@@user-kl9vq9os4w I bought 500g of Tesco finest mince beef got it home and the bottom half was grey and rotten 😡
That's so sad really. If I went to one of the finer restaurants there would I not be served excellent fare?
We’ve turned the clock back to being the sick man of Europe all over again.
Scotland can do better much better...Time for scottish independence
Its what happens when you import the sick.
Look at NHS waiting list over the last 20years, a 700% increase of the sick.
@@britnatzaredemocracydenier5922Scotland 🏴 get out asap 🇪🇺
Even worse a lot of people voted for it.
Yeah because you never learn the lesson.....rich thieves lying and stealing and you are happy
I don’t get no sun light because I’m working 12 hour days 6 days a week to put food on the table and keep a roof over my head. The depressing thought about this is….I’m one of the “lucky ones”
This country needs a revolution!
Well said
So you DO get sun light?
@james Believe me you're not one of the lucky ones.😊😊
As d saying goes don't have time to get sick😂
Yes!
Poverty comes when cruelty, wickedness and hostilities against the other, is the order of the day. They are bedfellows!
Shocking and shameful 😮😢
Malnutrition and scurvy... Turns out Moog did manage to get the UK back to Elizabethan times 😂
Hey, that is Lord Jackob "I lied to the Queen" Mogg to you mister!
Mission accomplished for the "gentleman" from the 19th century.!🙄😬🤦
It's not necessarily the government more the food companies and billionaires pushing Ultra Processed Foods on us. Eat single ingredients and your'll be fine.
It's not funny, these are English children. The young, the future of our nation. You talk about it like it's a joke. Children in Ethiopia are malnutritioned. Now English people are talking like this is normal for the UK, not just the Horn of Africa. This subserviant mentality of the English working class is what has led to this. You never stand up to the upper class.
Neo-Liberal policies would prosper you they said....
The billionaires took all the money. Tax the rich. Get Boris to pay back every last cent wasted.
Johnson…
And stop the foreign aid, the HS2 white elephant and expensive hotels for adults who’ve got here illegally. What else does money get wasted on…? Legal fees, diversity training,…the list goes on . A fraction of it could have prevented this poverty.
🙄
Yes get Boris to empty his bank account and give that back at least
I wonder if mass unwanted immigration could be the cause of our problems
It's true, I am a single person working for local government on £36000 a year. But I have realised I struggle to heat, eat and pay rent. Why is Britain so hard to live in now?
I think it has something to do with the Sino-US trade war. In China, a person can survive very well with only 36,000 yuan.
It's crazy isn't it. I used to be a teacher, and earned 23k a year (not quite full time, but almost), and there is no way that I could have lived off that salary if I had to rent somewhere. I lived in a flat my mother owned for a couple of years, but ended up leaving teaching as it demands a lot and pays poorly.
@@Jalleur14325Called genteel poverty wages.
in other countries people live on $300 a month
I'm in a similar situation. I saved for 10 years and got a house, but I find I avoid having heating on at all. Maybe once a week if that. I eat fine, but heating has always been something you can control less in terms of cost so usually the first to go when budgeting. Rich folk probs don't even give heating a second thought and have a fancy hive thing.
These things are trivial to fix. That our government is incapable of this rather speaks to the general incompetence of our political class.
Oh, they know how to fix it. They're doing everything they can not to.
@@JerzyFeliksKlein which begs the question why. Their wealth is denominated in sterling. Taking out the rest of the country will take out them as well.
It's going perfectly to plan for the "Highwayman " (tory).
They've lined their pockets and now scuttling the ship. And still brits will vote for them...insanity.
Brits have voted Tor for 11+ years now, so that seems to be what a majority wants.
@@friedrichjunzt do you know how "first pass the post" works. For decades the tories have been in power by less than 50% of the actual ticked boxes, sometimes just over 1/3 of the votes. Educate yourself.
An artist once said, "They have money for war, but have no money for the poor"
We the people of the UK should be ashamed for allowing this to happen.
The faster you recognise you have been invaded with unconventional warfare (corruption and gaming the "humanitarian" "refugee" definition with a commandeered UN and EU) the quicker you will realise it is Global and beyond a "ashamed" thing.
They poor should never again go to war when the rich want them to. That day will come sooner or later. Let the rich lead the rich into the fight to protect their wealth. The truth is capitalist countries need people only to keep them in debt during peaceful times and to send them to war when one has started. Refuse to go to war, refuse to buy from abroad, refuse to buy new stuff, always buy second-hand, refuse to service your staff with networks, use local people. refuse to buy stuff local handyman or yourself can't service, refuse to insure, buy a bike, get rid of your car ... be as little a part of elite capitalism as possible. If many follow this, capitalist elite is dead. As it stands now, a lot o people in the UK still buy stuff they can't afford, like drug addict addicted to comfort a dose gives you, they want the comfort, but they have no money for it. Cut down on your market participation as described above and if that's not enough, leave the country. There is no point staying in the place you can't get a shelter, food, clean water, clean air, afford your car, your car insurance, your house mortgage. Pack you luggage and go elsewhere. The country will not change, and you will die waiting for a change that never comes.
Absolutely 💯
Still just as true today. For example our navy in the red sea has been firing off sea viper missiles which cost just north of £1 million shooting down drones that cost about £16,000. What makes it even more ironic is their missile was to protect red sea merchant vessels however the second you turn it into a warzone insurance companies refuse to insurance ships and tell them to take the Cape route instead. So now we are literally doing the Houthis job for them whilst paying for the privilliage. Those puppets who stand up and tell you about war either don't know what they are talking about or are lying about it.
You need to speak to dwp theres much help out there if you ask for it they should come out to your home .you need a ds5000 form from your specialist
The politicians that encouraged this need to be recognised for their work.
Like the French have done in the past?
@@Craig121000are you saying that the one has a direct causational link with the other?
You’d best be careful how you reach oversimplified conclusions in public like this.
In court
Yes, let’s thank our benevolent Victorian style government properly, by showing them the door at every available opportunity 😢
@@steveharrison76 No, that is what you said. I said what I said. Without threatening anyone. Take your "advice" and stick it.
Britain has the smallest average house size in Europe, 950 sq ft, in the US its 2200 sq ft--How big are the King's residences?
Glad I foresaw all this in 2017 and got out of the UK. No regrets whatsoever.
where are you
So where did you end up? As far as The West is concerned, there's not going to be much difference in the politics whether you're in the UK or EU, the principle is the same, the rich ruling class are gobbling up everything and leaving very little for anyone else. The ever changing regs and tax system are designed to make sure you'll never catch up with them.
I got out and unfortunately came back! and oh boy have I regrets
Very sad... I got out in 2001. Germany has its ups and downs but life here is so much better than I remember in the UK. It is a crime what the British political class has inflicted on the British people 😢
Rickets? Scurvy? In modern UK? A nightmare that cannot be believed.
Beyond desperation.
What if it's only a literal handful of cases of people who refused to go outside and get sunshine? Have you met anyone with these conditions which are curable with fruit juice 🧃
@@marcus.Hit isn't just a handful of people.
@@b62boom1 Well I missed the part where they said it was a lot of people. It could be that 5 people last year had it but 7 have it this year. That's a 40% increase. A massive increase, but 7 isn't really that much, even though it's a lot bigger than 5.
If loadsa people have rickets, why has no one told me? Why hasn't it been on the news?
How many people you met are literally unable to buy an apple? Or an orange? Is scurvy truly something that's widespread among the people you have met?
Sunshine fixes rickets. Last time I checked, sitting by a window to get some sun was available to everyone
@@marcus.H 30,000 cases of rickets and scurvy over the last four years.
@@marcus.H Well if 88 health authorities now have patients and in patients with these diseases, it is more than you suggest! You are deliberately belittling a huge new problem. Did you miss that in 2022 ONE MILLION children were in abject poverty, in destitution? Did you miss how destitution was defined as lacking 2 or more of the absolute essentials for life? And you think it is clever to belittle the numbers? How dare you. Have you also missed the report that children in UK have actually shrunk 5cm on average due to malnutrition? We only used to get such reports from famines in Africa. Now it is rife in the (still) sixth richest country in the world! Stop doubting the numbers and put the blame where it belongs, at the government of 14 years. At the government in power who could have avoided this.
I'm a palliative care patient living on social security in England. I eat one meal a day. I can confirm it really is grim and thank you for highlighting these issues.
My heart goes out to you 😢😢😢
You deserve so much more ❤
I'm so sorry your going through a difficult time i feel for you🌈
I'm sorry 😢 to hear this. Is there any support that has been offered to you? ❤ How about the citizens advice bureau?
really sorry to hear this
🙏
Interesting how the US and Britain are experiencing similar things at the same time.
Super, duper Interest-ing! But TRUST US they say!
Not quite. I live in California and despite our problems (all states have them) we don't have that kind of poverty and many cities are taking the homeless crises into their own hands while our state government in Sacramento deals with that and other issues.
In both countries, the last 45 years or so the same ideology has held sway. In both countries, we're saturated with right-wing media. In both countries the political class has been thoroughly corrupted by oligarchs & malign foreign influence.
US has a much higher standard of living than the UK, especially in average house size
The UK is waaaaaaaaay worse off than the US. Way, way worse off. Not even remotely similar. I know misery loves company, but this is not an American thing.
100% in agreement. The two things you cannot be in Britain in 2024. Skint or ill. The tories really have turned us into a backwater.
No NHS anymore?
@@rebjava
The NHS we have has been decimated, like pretty much everything else by the 13 years of conservative corruption.
Blair you mean. Things happen over longer timescales. Things went rotten ever since Labour got in. The current government just inherited a mess.
@danielclemence3689
Oh please.
@@Viewpoint91Oh please what?
a friend of mine come to visit from Dubai and spent travelling around UK, he said he never seen people anywhere so sad, poorly dressed and looking miserable like in the UK.
Karma, may be.
😂 it's not Pakistan give over!
OH please as if UAE is any better! It is not, I been there I have seen how people live there.
You think UAE is better than the UK? I don’t think so, I been working and live in UAE for a decades and more people poor than in the UK. Unless if you are in a business sector or to a wealthy royal family. 😂 all fake😂😂😂
@@Show_what_I_LoveMate, there are a lot of poorer countries than the UK. Travel more.
As thatcher said "there is no such thing as society" this IS the legacy she aspired to. She must be proud of the last 14yr's of "achievement" they have made.
Well the left think there is no such thing as society why else would they want open borders.
she's dead. how is she supposed to be proud of anything? geez.
Hypothetical my dear Watson, hypothetical. 😆😆😆........@@thehellyousay
She never actually said that, the quote was brushed up by the editor. This is not to defend her record, it's just a oft quoted error.
Margaret Thatcher said. "There is no such thing as society". This was during an interview with Womans Own in1978,@@siemprestruggle9272
I was fascinated by THE IDEA of the UK, so I moved there in 2016. It took me a year to admit my mistake and shortly after, I was gone. Never looked back.
You were GONE? Like... you disappeared into thin air and were never seen again?
@@melissachartres3219 haha - yeah - exactly
Where did you come from?
@@fezisheikh3044 Switzerland, Scandinavia and the US.
This is heartbreaking!
I really understand that someone might not want to vote for Labour or Lib Dems but to vote for a party that has never done a single thing for the average person but make life harder every time they're in government is beyond me.
Totally agree
Poor people pretending to be part of the rich by voting the rich man's party, happens in my country too.
They keep lying but people still vote Tory lemmings comes to mind 😮
This is how you define stupidity.
That's our republican party here in the US
Britain has become a third-world country, Nobody wants to take responsibility for the economy, It is sad when junk food is cheaper than decent meals. When I grew up, it was the other way around. My mother always managed to feed 5 kids a healthy meal.
The British Empire could never last
How much would that cost now, think about it. Food was getting cheaper but the last 3 or 4 years it’s got so expensive
@@hungbearlover when I was a child, 5lb potatoes was 2d (tuppence, old money). Two hot fresh pigs trotters from the butchers 1d. Bread from the bakers was 6d, and a cream doughnut a shilling - 12d. Butter and lamb from NZ was dirt cheap, ate it for breakfast, and dinner. Milk was cheap too. We really only stopped getting cheap healthy food when supermarkets started to shape our options and incomes grew in the 60s and 70s. Women were encouraged to go put to work, and often a second wage made a huge difference to family income, even with part time work. We cant keep on banging on about "my mam .. 20 kids ...fed on nothing.... healthy home cooked food". That doesnt exist anymore especially where people cant affird to turn on their cookers.
The third world is Britain's new population through continuous immigration from the time the Windrush docked to now. Numerous diseases have been brought into the country as no health checks undertaken with new arrivals.
That's over the top we're not third world, but we will be soon. Give I 50 years.
Having regularly lived/travelled through various European countries, I sometimes get the impression that poverty somehow hits UK families in a particularly hard way. Its not a pleasant experience anywhere but the subtle difference on how both the families elsewhere, their wider network of friends/relatives and authorities take it more seriously gets them somewhat more prepared. The guy interviewed mentions Slovenia but even countries in eastern Europe that seem poorer in monetary terms might actually have its poorest people living better than their UK counterparts.
*The government has really called things more difficult for its citizens, and we can't sit back and bear all the consequences of the bad governance.It's obvious we are headed for hyperinflation, it is always the poor who take the hit.*
*to be a successful in life required not only hard work but awareness and sometime opportunity at the moment, investment remains the best way to start.*
I agree with you. Investment is the key to sustaining your financial longevity. And not just any investment but an investment with guaranteed return.
*yeah investment is the key to sustaining your financial longevity but venturing into any legit investment or business without a proper guidance of an expert can lead to great loss too.*
*Obviously talking about been successful, I know I am blessed if not I wouldn't have met someone who is as spectacular as mrs ava Kimberly*
As someone almost 60 years old I am surprised anyone is surprised by this, every multi-term tory government ends the same way. The poorest are destitute, high streets are boarded up, roads go unrepaired but tories and their donors live in solid gold houses claiming there isn't enough money for social services, education, infrastructure etc and we all need to tighten our belts. The cycle repeats inevitably and no one ever learns.
Sadly reminiscent on Orwel's 1984! 😢
Yes it is like a sustained stealthy scoop from the public purse to the bank accounts of millionaires over the course of the terms. The tax brackets are out of date for a start. Freezing them with a future date in mind should be illegal
You have lived long enough to see a couple of these cycles, keep on sharing coz people should know.
Why did the people vote for that when they're all affected by it except a few.....there's something far wrong in the upper levels
How are the illegal immigrants faring?
The true legacy of 14 years of Tory government, a return to 18th Century. No wonder Rees-Mog looks so smug all the time.
@musicman An almost laughable comment.
@@Andrew-ti8hi whats almost funny about preventable diseases that this "government" has caused ?
That would be Ree-Smug.
It's thanks to Blairs New Labour from 1997 that England is in an absolute mess. They opened up the flood gates migration which has put a strain on all services, especially schools.
@@bert454 ooh dear haven't you seen the immigration figures under this tory regime , you're in for a big disappointing surprise
Poverty us in America as well. Not yet as bad as Britain. Bad fast food , soft drinks, snacks, processed foods.
We all need to grow a garden! Eat fresh foods.
I pray for my family and friends who live in the UK. I left a year ago and won’t work in the UK ; my life is at risk
My dad was an immigrant who came in the 60s. The councils had so much money, they didn't know where to spend it. Factories had employees to search and poach workers from other factories. You could get a job in any factory you walked into. Kids who left school could immediately get apprenticeship roles and employment. The council had enough money to fully refurbish your house (from bare brickwork) and even paid your rent when they moved you into temporary accommodation. This depletion of wealth and poor governance started 50/60 years ago.
Absolutely true
I am so confused living in Britain. It is a shell of what it used to be
TOGETHER WITH LABOUR GOVERNMENTS.
Sadly recent mass immigration hasn't helped infrastructure under pressure. A race to the bottom with wages. Manufacturing taken away. The country only produces financial services. My dad worked in the mills in Yorkshire that was a tough job he joined the Army to get out of the poverty they had to endure we've had family die in the poor house. This country really isn't Eldorado we can barely look after our own. Without offering a safety net to the world
@@maureenbarclay2127Always blaming mass immigration. The area with the most wealth is London which has a 40% migrant demographic. London creates most of the UKs wealth.
Got to turn those millionaires into billionaires. The rich never have enough. Same thing is happening world wide. No pensions from work anymore, terrible health care, raising the retirement age and government keeps hinting your state pension may go away in the future.
As we say in America, its expensive being poor!
I left the country 8 years ago and was very lucky as I came from a very poor background. I will never go back and now I have children i am so lucky they dont have to live in the UK. I speak to friends back there and I say if you can get out!
I haven't paid a penny to hospitality in the last 15 years. Not a coffee, a takeaway or a meal out nothing. I don't smoke, drink alcohol or socialize. Cheap fruit, veg and salad are roughly 60% of my food. Most people have more than enough to survive it is only the house and neighbourhood in which they live that impoverishes them.
Our lives sound very similar, and I'm in Denver, Colorado. I wish you well.
Back in 1992 I joined the Army coming from a very working class background. Ended up serving 25 years, retired and settled in Germany now living a very comfortable lifestyle. I'll never forget how Brexit voters told me that within a few years I'll be wanting to go back home to live in a prosperous United Kingdom.
The mind boggles
That's what you get for listening to Boris . he told a pack of lies solely and only to attain his personal ambition .
The German economy is doing far worse than the UK's. The standard of living that most Germans' are used to is coming to an end. I'm not happy about this, and had hoped that we would all weather this economic crisis, but a recession is inevitable. Young well educated Germans are leaving the country in droves. That does not bode well for the economy.
The EU once had an economy that was equal to the US. Now it has a fraction of that wealth. Hard times are coming.@@MookMineola
@@aion5837 Its only 1% less than the US in share of global trade....
Are you from the UK or Germany? It's no secret that Germany is not enjoying quite the same lifestyle it had twenty years ago but that's the same the world over. What I am talking about here is the comparison between the two nations. I travel back home twice a year so I sadly get to see the decay of my home country and it's very striking.
I am only talking here about my experience. @@aion5837
Rishi's response to the "destitute" sleeping rough is to fine them £500. If all fines were based on "ability to pay" then Rishi should have been fined £1Bn for breaching covid rules. The moral ethics of this man are mirrored by the effluent outlets of UK water companies.
Hang on, cut him some slack. He will lower taxes for some people and get rid of that pesky inheritance tax that clearly affects us all. 🙄
Inheritance tax is a tax on the dead and is shameful
Remember folks: “Punishable by fine” = “Legal for the rich.” 😂
We all remember Eat Out to Help Out, he was a wrong man at the wrong place, a court of law should look at this.
It's the UK government response to everything fine or sanction
Scurvy - it's why the Germans used to eat sauerkraut, it's also rich in vitamin C and very very cheap as it's just fermented white cabbage.
Remember when people thought brexit was a brilliant idea.....
The people in the UK are poorer because of 14 years of Tory Government. We need a government who cares about the people.
We won't be getting one any time soon
I am sorry to say that not much will change under Labour. It's the Establisment that rules, mostly faceless 'elites' that pull the strings. Both Parties serve the same master and vilification awaits all that challenge the status quo; as Corbyn well knew.
@@rayglenister9799The problems are structural. And paradoxical. By quitting the EU, people are now realising we need immigration to drive the economy and achieve growth. Without which we will all be poorer.
@@rayglenister9799 yet we were in a much better place when labour were running things. labour arent beholden to a handful of rich donors at least. with our press we stand zero chance of a decent left wing gov sadly.
Absolutely agree ..I've never voted Tory and never will .we've now had 14 years of wage stagnation..this is the result
But apparently all the problems will be solved when we 'stop the boats'. Shameful.
Don't forget whatever Frazer is on about. Dealing with bias on the BBC that exists exclusively in people's minds which is what makes it real?
@@cupguin So that's why BBC Scotland had to offer more corrections/apologies for falsities, than the entire BBC network combined?
Take your time now....
@@markwilkie3677 Congratulations on proving how idiotic her point is. Issuing corrections isn't proof of bias, it's proof the BBC issues corrections. It's even arguable proof the system is working as intended since corrections get put out as needed. Either way you look at it, issuing corrections doesn't show a need for added OFCOM powers.
And "there's a public perception of bias" cheers on demonstrating that. Let's say I work for the BBC. I make a mistake or learn something in the future, is that bias? More importantly, why are you so convinced you know that corrections were due to bias? Would I be wrong in assuming no matter what I saw you're convinced that there's a "left" bias that's reflected in those corrections?
And I'm going to give you a small hint why people are going after the BBC. If people can trust the BBC and it publishes a story about a sudden spike in childhood illnesses associated with lack of access to food it would reflect poorly on the government. That's not reporting bias, it's reporting reality. But if you're convinced there's a political bias at work you'll ignore that and think favourably about the government. So there's a direct political benefit in making people doubt factual reporting.
But sure, perception, correction and all being interchangeable when it comes to the BBC isn't serving Frazer's party at all and it's the BBC to blame somehow.
@@cupguinI agree wholeheartedly especially the third paragraph. Are these people who call BBC biased ok with bias in their direction (confirmation bias). I’m thinking specifically about the Panorama programme on supposed anti semitism in the Labour Party under Corbyn. It’s been proved to be lies and distortion but “hey that’s ok as it was our gang against your gang”.
Yes, net migration of 745,000 a year hardly helps the country. We are paying out millions every day for people who enter this country illegally.
I personally think people need an average salary now of between 50-60k a year, to have disposable income left over in their pay packets due to taxes and how much things cost in the UK.
Why is this happening ?
At long last someone says it how it is, thank you Professor. I have lived on both sides of the coin. When I was younger I went without meals in order to feed my children, I would eat their scraps if there were any and in my later years I paid the price with my health. Now a pensioner and 40 years on I cannot believe things are even worse but still Society and the Government engage in belittling and punishing the poor!
Thatcher came to power espousing "Victorian values".Implement Victorian style policies,get Victorian style results,it's not rocket science.
Spot.on.!!! But have the British as a people begun to recognize the connection from yesterday to the suffering of today?🤔
Of course they haven't but that's because 95% of the press and broadcast media don't tell the truth.@@staciasmith5162
@Anthony. It's certainly not rocket science but it's certainly twaddle!😊
What a nice man.. 🌼
Not only 🇬🇧 Britain has becomes a poor country, USA 🇺🇸 and 🇦🇺 Australia also. Many people in these countries are living in poverty with hundred of thousands homeless people living in tents ⛺️ on the streets.
I agree. I'm from Ireland and was visiting friends in Illinois this past September. I couldn't get over the cost of foodstuffs, all of it. for example meat cost on average twice or three times what I pay in Ireland for it. Mushrooms that would cost about 90cents in Ireland cost about $3.50 in the US. Everything just seemed to be far more expensive. I used to stock up on clothes when visiting there but not any more, it's much cheaper in Europe now.
Brexit Britain coupled with a widening of inequality in wealth distribution has set us back 150 years...Jacob Reece Smug must be absolutely loving this.
Neoliberals in 1980 - Give the proletariat just enough to be hungry and disciplined in the workplace
Rightwing libertarians in 2010 - Give them nothing! Starvation is the ultimate disciplinarian of the proletariat!
@@kinghenryxl1747the English ridicule the French as cowards in war but in reality it's the English who are the cowards.
14 years of Tory corruption on a scale never before seen and in full public view, systematic erosion of our rights, systematic destruction of our public service, destitution and poverty returning to pre war levels, a Tory PM suspends parliament to prevent scrutiny of a critical piece of legislation, the same PM openly breaks the law on multiple occasions and during a national emergency, Tory party changes PM and core policies multiple times without a GE, all this and more yet why isn't parliament surrounded by protesters demanding criminal investigations and an immediate GE.
If Macron had done just 10% of what the Tories have and continue doing the French would have dragged him out of the Elysée palace kicking and screaming all the way to court.
@dibdab You too.The perfect opportunity to be outraged yet again.😂
@@chatham43 glad to know you think it is acceptable.
Brexit ... but not the mass train wreck of lockdowns, half a trillion printed for furlough, sanctions war on Russian energy or green taxes. No... just Brexit 😂
This is truly shameful in one of the world's richest countries.
Yes and most if their wealth was by exploitation and plundering the unfortunate while they lived in their ivory towers
Britain is only rich for the richest in this country
I’m disgusted by what’s happening here
You honestly think the UK is wealthy country!?
You’ve been fed a lie for decades my friend! The uk has lived above and beyond its means for decades! Get used to it! It will get worse and worse. Wake up!
Not since brexit it isnt! Where have you been?!
UK is nothing now....UK was rich being in the EU....now it's just a hole for criminals
You can't possibly get enough VitD from sunshine over 30, and it gets worse with age. A supplement with a main meal is the only way.
"people just don't have the cooking skills and don't want to feed their kids proper food these days" Lee Anderson
There's enough money to go around. It's just in the wrong hands. And too few hands. Tax the rich.
800 billion + printed for covid and it's sitting in the bank accounts of all the Goverments big business mates earning them interest . Soon as interest comes down they will then buy houses and assets with it pushing prices up higher !! Goverment had a option to give everybody 16k over covid !! Instead gave it to there mates for trickle down effect that never happened
You can’t talk about poverty without mentioning the extreme levels of wealth concentrated at the top. The multimillionaires and billionaires have done very very well recently.
You ideas on how to fix this with potentially somebody like Trump as the leader of the ‘free’ world? Tax billionaires on their net worth? Can’t see him and those neo-con republicans even entertaining the idea……
Presumably you think that we are poor because they are rich?
The British should come to Brazil slums to see what poverty really looks like.
The same is happening in large cities here in Canada to both young people under the age of thirty and to the elderly. If that is happening in all nations which have been part of the Commonwealth or are continuing to be part of the commonwealth while their population is aging then what can we all do about it then besides working longer after retirement age; if we can; while offering charity to others too?
Cold snap last week , £90 for 1 weeks worth of gas and electric is a sick joke
At least wealthy pensioners got the cold weather payment, funded by you 👍🏼
@@jagman999Pensioners would have been in hospital with pneumonia without it.
Too true. I'm glad for this storm as the temperature at least went up a bit. 😔
Yes, my meter went crazy, what a madhouse.
On a so called Smart prepayment meter the costs are astronomical.
Absolutely crazy ricketts is back on streets in Britain 🇬🇧
Maybe exaggeration me thinks western countries have a plauge of obesity
Poverty is very saddening tourist 😮 but name for Briton in 20/21 centuries
Coming to Canada soon. Thanks Mr Turdo
I am a Portuguese citizen, living in Portugal, I love Great Britain and I´m heartbroken to hear this news 😢😢😢
Am sure you also loved Mozambique and angola😂😂😂😂
Yes brexit and taking back control apparently we'd all be better off post brexit ...well that's what they said as the sold it to the country .
Please don't believe it. Wages have been rising rapidly and prices have fallen
In Portugal the minimum wage is close to €5 per hour. In England, it's €13.37 per hour. These reports do not reflect the reality. I was shocked at how expensive Portugal was when I last went there. Shopping for food and fuel is cheaper in England
Brexit and taking back control so this is what it looks like ....
To clarify, I meant the 2024 minimum wage starting in April will be £11.44 per hour, which is over €13 per hour. This means the pay is more than double here. We also get paid holidays from work and fully matched pension contributions, meaning we make equivalent to about triple the rate in Portugal
Mogg must be ecstatic. Its like all his dreams have come true
Mogg lives in that phantom raspberry blower of old London town episode of the Two Ronnies 😅
He will deny it with complete, condescending conviction.
Absolutely! He's always wanted Victorian Britain for the present day and here he has is. Now all's he got to implement again are workhouses for the poor and the reintroduction of Chimney Sweeps.
Workhouses next
Shocking!
It's so sad to see what's happened to Britain! 👿
The solution to all this is very simple , never ever again with the Tories .
and reverse Brexit, it's cost £140 Billion so far, imagine if we'd spent that on the country instead of on the fantasies of a bunch of Eton schoolboys.
How is it the Tories fault? If people can't afford to feed their kids it's irresponsible to have them.
And what if you happened to have kids before the Tories took power? What if you had kids who are now 10 years old? You obviously can't spell your surname - too many "o"s.@@mikecook1537
How's it's the Tories fault 14 year's of austerity perhaps?
@@mikecook1537 then over time the low birth rates reduce the number of people in employment while also pushing the county's age demographic up. Elderly people are less economically productive, pay the least in tax yet consume the largest amount of public services. That, coupled with fewer young people in work paying tax, results in a massive decline.
You could of course bring in migrant labour but I'm guessing you're not particularly in favour of that either?
Despite what Thatcher said, there is such a thing as society and it's made up of a complex web of dependencies. If you change one thing you can guarantee it'll have far reaching consequences somewhere else.
The ultimate result of trickle down economics.
I never could understand how diarrhea could be described as a trickle
😂😂
So true. So sad. Shameless government.
The UK is not a poor country. Wealth is concentrated in a few hands. If ever there was a time for a top to bottom redistribution of wealth this is it.
It is a poor union
It's a poor country with a few very wealthy individuals in it.
it's a country of poor people leeched and rulled by the bunch of rich
@@jounikbritain is not a country Muppet
@@mmcc5846 "The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (UK) is an island country that sits north-west of mainland Europe." But what would the Commonwealth Secretariat know...
The government spent 40 billion on track and trace which disappeared and yet didn’t once think to share vitamins and organise fresh fruit deliveries for the vulnerable - no serious tech required and simple measures would do wonders for our country
You actually think that Karen and her six children on benefits wants to eat fresh fruit ? Really ! As for forty billion quids wasted : that's what UK government and councils are all about , spending other people's money and wasting it .
@@MookMineolathey do want to eat healthy food, but it's cheaper not to. That's the point.
£40 billion is a lot + £140B lost due to Brexit + all that lost to PPE scandals.
Dreadful
@@MookMineola people in Wales (40% poverty rate) cant afford to use their cookers to make hot food even when its given to them. Many on UC even in work have deductions from UC - one lady I know is having deductions against debts her husband ran up before he ran off, even though shes working part time and raising 2 children.
Money wasted on HS2 and Rwanda bill
@markbright Well it wouldn't do "wonders" for the country but it would have helped. Billions were wasted on Lockdown I do agree.
When u have to pay more for energy and rent, unemployment, how do u buy food
Wow, this is shocking. America has poverty also, but not rickets & scurvy. What happened?
You have oranges and sunshine.
Never in the history of British social inequality, has so much harm been inflicted on so many, by so few....
Yeah we will fight the corrupt rich on the beaches lol!😂
can't wait for GTA6, i must obey the system until then.@@jamiecurran3544
erm overpopulation? if the previous parent had less competitors for rent and property purchases they have more money for their children and vice versa. It's all about, overpopulation which drives up cost competition for investments. Also sometimes populations go through iq and creative thinking decreases. This further reduces the ability to bounce back. To be sure it is also in part fault of elites and lack of curtailment or regulation on what they can own and the fault of the banks.
but overpopulation and lack of cultural direction are the main drivers. Allied with, obviously the lack of action on restructure of national debt. However the national debt is also based on tax revenue based on many things, but overpopulation again being a big factor.
Come on, early medieval times were much worse
I want inform, that overpopulation is not always a deal breaker. But for a country that currently has no obvious industry strength, or natural resources (see japan and fish) and (bad timing) one of the worst artificial debts (created by the evil banks and allowed in by labour gordon brown) it is indeed a deal breaker. p.s. I am thinking of joining labour as a member, but havent voted for anyone in a long time.
So I have lived abroad for the past 15 years and have returned to UK for a long trip over some family issues. The amount of things that are broken or overpriced is pretty shocking.
Trains from Edinburgh to Liverpool costs £56 and was delayed for 50mins. Getting a a partial refund is nice but the fact that there is a system in place to handle these refunds kinda indicates this is quite a common thing to happen.
Waited for 36 hours in the A&E with my father.
Potholes EVERYWHERE! There are also road closures but it looked like very little work is being done.
Mobile reception is appalling. So many blind spots even in some central locations.
Even the AirBnB host had to ration heat because the cost of energy is so expensive.
The only thing that I noticed any improvement is when they want you to pay. Wireless card payment is wonderful but that’s about it.
Honestly, it’s really sad to see Britain like this.
Please let your friends and family know how bad things are in the UK. Avoid at all costs. Their people voted for clowns and now they are complaining. Next election, they will vote for the other clowns they voted out about 14 years ago. So the cycle of doom and destruction continues in the UK. Avoid even coming as a tourist.
Please let your family and friends know about the state of the UK.
Avoid at all costs, especially as a tourist. The people are to blame. They voted for clowns and now they are complaining, and in the next election they will once again vote for the other clowns that they voted out 14 years ago and so the cycle of destruction and decay continues.
There's a daily " Pay as you pollute the world airsupply" charge in the UK and a 32 km per hour speed limit in the UK, voted in by the public which means more taxes and even longer commuting times for the public to get to work and back.😂😂 All voted in. Which fool will want to settle in the UK?
How much did trains from Edinburgh to Liverpool cost in 2009'?
Conditions in the USA are just as bad.
Its not destitution ,it is poverty
My daughter invited a friend home after she felt weak and unable to walk all the way home from school just half a mile away. She hadn't had anything to eat for 5 days and was literally starving to death! This reality cannot continue for these kids with the 1% swallowing the entire wealth of those already at the bottom with nothing more, even food!
If you can't support your kids YOU are the problem! Don't have kids.
I am not British or UK person, but your whole country is going downhill basically and hearing this story of not eaten for 5 days, omg, such a poor child,
@@akhilsharma20 Not sure the whole country, the already wealthy elite are doing even better from the cost of living crisis, but we have had probably the most destructive conservative government since Thatcher and it's gonna take yet another Labour fight. Unfortunately I don't see it with Starmer, only the pure clarity of someone like Corbyn will ever help those at the very bottom like this poor kid is stuck in.
What about food banks ..are there not very many in each town..we have 2 in my town of 7,000 in Quebec, Canada..
@@zan4110 There is one, but many reasons why parents might not use them or children claim school meals. One solution would be to give all children school meals regardless of income perhaps.
“A poor country with a few rich people” perfectly summarises the current situation. I really don’t think it’s being felt fully yet because everyone is either racking up debt or reducing their standard of living; but eventually it’s gonna crash
Wow, that's a pretty scary thought.
Great Britain swirling around at the bottom of the loo
From April 2023 the benefit cap was increased to £25,323 in London and £22,020 outside London. Some people don't get this much from working.
Given the direction of travel and open contempt for the underclasses in the UK who could possibly be surprised by this? The Tories are looking to exacerbate deprivation.
Thatchers legacy... it's going great . Just as all the rational people said at the time she destroyed everything people fought over centuries, in a few decades. RIP UK
It's all about greed
“May I have sommore, please sir, I’m hungry.” :-|
didn’t have that on your bucket list five years ago did yah?
Time for Great Britain to eat their rich.
Just read his reports plus the one 10 yrs on. Its shocking. Life expectancy going backwards for the first time ever!
How can a health service run effectively with a -.75 % budget!??? Shameful. Prof. Marmot does whatever he can to raise awareness but on the current government it’s wasted.
Thank goodness we have Prof Marmot! ❤❤❤
As Marmot would also point out it’s not the health service funding that matters most either, it’s the cuts in funding to our social, environmental and public infrastructure that have taken the most toll on widening health inequalities.
We live in a heavily addicted society. That’s why the health service is on its knees
The Tories trashed the country and made the poor suffer and now they plan to persecute the disabled. This is stuff of real nightmares.
Welcome to our America, now, then and possibly the future! Talking about the poverty here and everywhere too!
The U.S. economy is doing great, far better than in England and Europe. I realize there are poor people in America, but as a country, we're doing great economically.
If you had your welcome to America moment, the people of Britain would be far wealthier and healthier. This is more like your welcome to India moment
All my friends *[ British ] in the United States are always saying it's bad here ?_ - but not as bad as Britain. And they mean it, every paragraph,sentence, word, and utterance. 🇬🇧 🦖 ☄️
High levels of inequality is destroying this country, the greed and selfishness by the billionaires is a disgrace. How many billions do they need? I couldn't comprehend having that much money and coutinue to want more while people in this country are living in such poverty.
The Billionaires don't have loyalty to any nation or people. They have loyalty to gold. If they can make more money in Singapore, they will go there. If taxes are lower in the US, they will go there. Billionaires have no vested interest in a nations stability or success. They just extract wealth and assets and then hide their billions in a vault in a Swiss mountain, or a Cayman Islands tax haven. Western Democracies are going to be destroyed not by Russia or China, but by the greed and avarice of Billionaires who have no loyalty to the West or Democracy, only gold.
there is no upper limit, if you feel insecure, you will always need more. Do not count for the reach to become less greedy. They do not feel they are rich and will never slow down. Stop paying for new stuff, use local services, buy national produce and products. That's the start.
Well importing millions of people who can barely sustain themselves and their families and take a lot of benefits doesn’t help, not that Marr would say that.
No body is allowed to say this u tube would ban you the media is far removed from reality illusions?
At last you have recognised the grim reality
Why so expensive to heat a home or apartment in Britian?
Hardly surprising people are destitute when UC barely covers rent for a HMO room these days, eating is now a luxury for many.
I don't understand how HMO landlords justify the rent
@@keech100they like money.
They can't but they don't need to, they hold the power
How much do you think UC should be?
UC is designed to encourage people claiming it to get a job instead. Cynically, you could argue it’s doing its job.