What's the most perplexing thing about this is that of all things to nerf, they nerf fire and blast protection. The two enchants I never use simply because why the hell would I ever use them over protection, which blocks everything? Yet Mojang seems to think it's a genius idea to nerf the one thing they have going for them...
Yeah it's strange to nerf things that are literally supposed to be effective against their specific niche, especially considering they're also very rarely used because of it
I'm pissed at the Blast Protection nerf as a Hardcore player. I keep it on one piece of my armor since it drastically reduces creeper damage (which is ridiculous otherwise) and only makes me a little less tanky against general damage. The fact that they're basically making the enchantment system even LESS interesting to experiment with than it was before (which was minimal) is damn annoying. I couldn't care less about the Fire Protection nerf though. Who even uses Fire Protection???
Of all protection enchants to nerf, they decided to nerf the ones with the most situational upsides over the one with universal protection. Game balance should be their specialty honestly.
genuinely boggles my mind that prot4 diamond plate gets to multiply your effective health by 10 against almost everything in the game, but fire protection isn't allowed to protect you from *one* thing
also the fact that there’s almost no reason to use blast or proj outside of very niche circumstances instead of more enemies actually dealing that type of damage
@@TehNoobinessDiamond chestplate has 8 defense, so it can provide at most 8*4 = 32% damage reduction, protection IV provides 4*4 = 16%, so in total we have 1 / ((1-0.32)*(1-0.16)) = 1.75 effective hp multiplier
@@griglog the math is MUCH less simple than that at least on java since armour toughness became a thing and now the damage reduction of armour depends on toughness and how hard the hit is
blast protection used to be useful as a one piece armor in hardcore difficulty, same for fire prot in nether tho now, we'll just go back to potions and shields only instead. at this point they may as well just remove these enchants, they've become completely useless.
@@T.U.P.Y.0I think it’s so you can reliably do MLG clutches. A lot of the time, you would place the water and then immediately pick it up before you hit the ground
I still hate Mojang for making two different versions of the same game and then a decade later retroactively deciding they actually only wanted one of them and deciding to kill the other one slowly and painfully
@@cannedsquasher5923 As a bedrock user, yes. I'm on Xbox and have to choose between the broken version and the discontinued version. I've recently died more to glitches than by legitimate reasons. Every time I go through a nether portal I have to drink a slow falling potion and fire resistance because like a third of the time I fall through the nether on my world. I died by using a riptide trident during the rain not knowing that you still die when you land softly. I was wearing feather falling IV and full protection IV when it happened. They supposedly patched it, so I tried it again. I died around 30 blocks in the air, and I wasn't even quickly falling or going too fast. I also had the same equipment on as last time. I've also had blocks vanish under me while bridging in the nether and I died. In the past week or two I softly landed with an elytra in a chunk that was seemingly unloaded on accident. I initially took no damage, but after around a second I lost around three hearts, then another three hearts, and then whatever I was standing on vanished, and the fall damage as well as the stray that shot me took me to half a heart. I also recently went to the end and fell through the platform, but didn't die only because the island extends under it. I wish I had a working version of Minecraft on Xbox
Bedrock sells more. Java was always meant to be the main version of Minecraft, but since Bedrock makes more money by being on more consoles and through the Marketplace, they're slowly ruining Java without giving any actual attention to try and make Bedrock a tolerable gameplay experience.
@@Thedarkknight902 did you even watch the video??? The enchants are stacking, yes, but now each piece with fire prot 4 decreases time by 15% instead of 60% So now you need full fire prot 4 armor to have the exact same effect as one piece in the past
I see it as them trying to make the version that doesn't have in game purchases (other then realms) less convenient, to get people to play the one that does.
@@Thedarkknight902 So you didn't watch the video, or are incapable of comprehending what was directly stated. Stacking means nothing when the effect of having all four pieces at level 4 has the same effect as one piece previously did. So yes, its a pretty severe nerf if no one cares about it stacking because they've ruined the numbers so much compared to how it was before without stacking.
@@jeremypanjaitan4039Tick tock Heavy like a Brinks truck Looking like I'm tip-top Shining like a wristwatch Time will grab your wrist Lock it down 'til the thing pop Can you stick around for a minute til' the ring stop? Please God
You said "no one uses Fire Prot anyways", but that's the problem. There's no reason to use the specialized protection enchantments, and all they do is lock you out of getting normal Prot. They passively frustrate players by existing and we have little to no use for them. And still, they get nerfed.
The 5 exclusive enchants (projectile, fire, blast, as well as smite and bane for weapons) still at least have a purpose, even if that purpose is like 1 very specific scenario for some of them. People forgot there are enchants that are not just useless, but lock you out of better enchants, frost walker and multishot. Multishot is just a worse version of piercing, even if piercing is at level 1. Its way harder to line up 3 mobs side by side than it is in a line. On java it could be considered better than piercing, since when a rocket is fired from a crossbow, it explodes on impact rather than always after a set time, and since enchanted bows are better than even a max crossbow, you’d likely only use rockets for them anyways, it still chews through durability and plus rockets are expensive and rarely have an actual use when attacking. I’d still consider piercing better since multishot is impossible to aim with unlike piercing, even with crossbows pretty much only helpful early on. Frost walker has literally no use. Level 1 you cant sprint jump on water bc it cant catch up, and level 2 can, but only sometimes. It gets to the point where a boat is going to be faster or giving it the enchantment that can’t be combined with it instead, depth strider. I have never used frost walker before, its not even worth using if you happen to stumble upon it with a lucky shipwreck spawn given how cheap boats are. I just don’t understand why you’d touch stuff that’s already fairly balanced when there’s “enchantments” that might as well just be labeled as curses at this point.
@@anoukk_ you're misinformed. The actual tip is that, if you really want to use specialized protection, like Projectile Protection, you should only wear one piece with it and have normal Prot on all three, as that adds up to the cap for projectiles and still protects from other damage. What you said is not possible because you can only reach the cap with a full set of Protection 5 (impossible). Until then, every protection counts. Except the weird ones
But projectile prot is worse than normal prot because you only get ressitance to projectile which you often dont have to face off against and with 3 protection and one fire protection max yoy have almost immunity before this prerelease to lave
Actually it seems that instead of fixing the bug to support the minor addition, they nerfed the existing feature to the ground so as to not need any patching. It's like destroying a house to make room for a shed.
In polish there is very funny speling error. While chosing difficulty, one sentence should say that "hunger can go down" Go down in polish is "spaść", but they wrote "spać" which means sleep. So, instead of "hunger can go down" we have "hunger can sleep" Version 1.20 I think
in italian they have translated lead as the metal rather than the leash, so in pocket edition one of the tips is saying that you can use metal on boats (and since is leads it's made into "piombi" which isn't an actual word but a weird plural)
@@GaryIsFoundDon't forget that the bow was forged from the bones of dragons, and that they infused themselves with lots of starlight from the constellation of Discidia.
(Former) Fire Protection user here. I play HC and UHC Survival. Fire Protection was amazing for us. My armour was always 2x Prot 1x Blast 1x Fire. This is pretty much the most armour diversity you'd ever see in Minecraft, since most of you will just be using 4x Prot but for my purposes, Fire and Blast were vital for keeping long running worlds alive. Now they've just nerfed it all so I guess I'm gonna be using the same as everyone else now, thanks Mojang. Actively making your least used enchantments less useful is a great decision, well done. (Might still take 1x Blast though to prevent instakills. Very useful for Hardcore).
I think your build 2x Prot 1x Blast 1x Fire should give 32% damage reduction from all sources except fire and explosions and 64% from fire and explosions. But 4x Prot should give you 64% reduction from ALL sources. So I think your enchantments were not so good, it also should give explosion knockback defense and fire time reduction, but I don’t think it was worth it even before nerf.
Mojang: vertical slabs inhibit creativity so we won't add them Also Mojang: we're changing how enchantments work to punish players who combine them creatively
The one thing Mojang needs to learn is: IF IT AINT BROKE DONT FIX IT. armour was FINE stacking enchants is a cool idea but cmon. You didn't need to fiddle with that
Seeing that happening everywhere unfortunately. Apparently what is fun and great for the players is broken and needs fixing by whoever is pushing for those to be "fixed."
PhoenixSC the fire ticks is decided by how long you stay in the lava not what version you’re in btw so most of you’re calculations are thrown off. Hope that helps
people dont use it because the benefit of having those specific enchantments is outweighed by having a general protection enchantment that protects from all other damage causes more. to make them a good enchantment, their benefit should be very powerful when the player heavily invests in it, like becoming immune to fire.
@@Nonname_From_The_Internets Yes, that kind of build should be carefully tuned to have more specific benefits the more specific enchantments you have. Something to keep in mind, though, is that having all the protection types should not be stronger than just having protection.
@@thechefwhodoesntcook8233 Yeah, don't complain, just consume product. Shut up and take it when companies change a game in ways that do nothing to improve it and can only make it worse. That always works out.
@@zkeletonz001 The problem is that people complain and then consume product. Actions speak louder than words. Do not consume product. Mod it back out then tell everybody you modded it back out. Upload the mod. Complaining is worthless if you don't actually do something about it.
I hope this reverts back. Was also really cool honestly trying to make the desicion- "hm, should I just do all protection? Or should one piece have fire protection, or should another have blast protection?" All while knowing the main protection would lower but the protection against something would buff. Made every enchant worth it
@@ethanrandall3005 I thought I heard stuff about that happening, glad it did. Now I can be one of the only people who happily use one of the protections ong
@@ethanrandall3005 I thought I heard stuff about that happening, glad it did. Now I can be one of the only people who happily use one of the protections ong
He was selling fire prot pretty well while explaining the old version. Like 5 ticks of damage if I fall into lava, 0 on bedrock?! Never knew how it worked and was ready to put it on something but then nooooo
Fire protection is honestly great, worth to have on at least 1 piece of armor if you have a specialized set for the Nether (like, a golden piece to avoid piglins or something)
@@capitaldcolonface Unless you're some ultra sweaty PVP nerd, then losing out on a single regular Protection 4 isn't a big deal for PVE purposes, it's just a major skill issue if you actually need that extra prot 4
@XAnderson27 as a bedrock player the wither isn't even really hard, it's the duration of the fight and how unbelievably overpowered the wither effect is on bedrock that makes it a pain
@@ilikethenumber7934plus the natural regeneration On Java, sustain makes up like, the entirety of the combat system- on Bedrock you really don't want long fights. And imo it's largely the screwy natural regen At least, that was the case when I was playing Bedrock a couple years ago. They might've changed it since then.
@justseffstuff3308 no lol, still a pain having long fights with small damage, your regen even with food is bad, plus the enchantments are bad too, or even the frickin armor doesnt protect like java, netherite java and bedrock are very inconsistent
Your info is out of date. What you guys are describing about the wither applies to it pre-1.19.2. They reworked a lot of the protection calculations and added a fix to the wither effect bypassing the protection enchant. Now, the bedrock wither is a way easier fight, as long as you have golden apples on you, you don’t really have much to worry about.
Not completely useless, just situational, but with the changes they made? yeah it's bad. You won't always have fire resistance potions, or any other items that grant complete immunity to fire damage, so having at least one armor peice with fire protection four can come in handy.
@@Feraligono That's not true... You have to enter the nether and find the ingredients. Considering the nether is full of lava, it is very useful to have Fire Protection before entering.
I see zero reasons why a full set of fire, blast or projectile prot 4 shouldn't just make you immune to those damage sources. Even then I doubt that would make people use them
I think the best way for each armor piece to work is: - Fire protection: Immune to lava -Blast protection: Immune to explosions and knockback -Projectile protection: Projectiles bounce off of you
@@btcbuster5556 it would make end crystal combat die which, is good cause end crystal combat is bs, especially since the people who do it has a hacked client to do it for them
Yeah, they’re so underutilized that they need to straight up be made really good if you only care about one damage source. Standard prot is so good generally, that if they want people to use the other ones without nerfing it, they need to be buffed to all hell.
This is a long line of changes that they've made recently that funnel players into one playstyle... I actually used full fire protection for the most part (one piece was always protection), and it feels like they don't want to give options.
what I hate about this is that before having one armour piece of fire prot for the nether actually made sense because the protection against fire and lava was higher with fire prot 4 than prot 4 combined with 3 pieces with prot 4 it was useful. Now it doesn't make sense to use it where before it actually did. Would have been better to delete the enchantment, then the people who used fire prot could at least enchant their armour with prot 4 instead.
My gold boots always get fire prot put on them. The overall reduction in protection really isn't that major of a difference, and having a 5 second burn time instead of 14 is a significant QoL improvement in the nether, where one tends to spend much time getting set on fire.
i mean, assuming your armor still decreases in durability upon taking fire damage (even when you take zero damage from it), they should really change it in java so a full set of fire prot IV gives 105% fire protection and reduces the burn time to zero. it'd be fun to have a lava scuba set instead of a bunch of fire prot potions
that's the part that baffles me, fire resistance potions already outclassed fire protection before this nerf, why not let the dedicated enchantment with a major downside at max level compete with the easiest potion to obtain(piglin bartering)
@@Pihsrosnec piglin bartering? you could probably stab a stupid bouncing lava thing with a looting sword and end up with a weeks supply of ingredients without even bothering with the piglin
Ok, these situational enchantments shouldn't be nerfed, they *_should_* be buffed! In most cases they suck even without the nerf. Ok with the misunderstanding cleared up I think they did good- Nevermind what they did is just made it only slightly more useless than before...
If you choose to use full fire protection armour, you _should_ be rewarded with fire immunity (or at least near-immunity)! Having interesting trade-offs would make the game more enjoyable. I might want to keep a spare set of armour around for when I'm expecting to be around a lot of fire or lava. That way I would trade some general damage protection for the extra inventory slots I gain from not having to lug around fire resistance potions.
you know, i got a great idea i think for this, likely not alot of people will see this but its okay, still worth mention. tldr; what if fire debuff time increased for each time fire was inflicted and fire proc kept reducing time and what if lava increased its damage the longer your in it with fire proc making the time to increase damage slower longer version: what if fire proc acted kinda like tf2's fire? Longer your on fire, or acted upon fire, or more fire is applied to you, the longer the fire will last. being in lava for only half a second could lead to a lower fire time, while being in fire for longer will increase the time. Fire proc would have a bit more meaning as it could take some of the hit of the increased fire time now lets add another what if. take some inspiration from starbound aswell. In starbound, the longer your in lava in the center of a world, the more damage you take. If you stood in lava for only a few seconds, normal half heart damage with armor. If you kept standing in it for as long as ibx did, it could increase to two, then three, etc, overtime, over lets say, 20 seconds. it still keeps the danger of Lava and staying in it for too long with base, while still making it strong even with armor and fireproc and stuff. Fire proc could again, reduce the damage taken by lava, or increase the time it takes to get to two heart damage, three heart, etc.
damn i actually wish java fire prot acted like it does in bedrock, thats really cool, also if i knew i could get max burn time reduction with just one piece of armor before i might have used it more often. mojang really choosing the worst option, fire is so annoying, "balance" does not equal fun
If they did this same exact thing, except made it so that full Fire Prot IV made you completely immune to Fire and Lava, and Blast Prot IV made you immune to explosions, they would have some utility and people would actually use them. I wish they would revamp the enchanting system. Make a bunch of set effects. Incentivize players to mix or match enchants.
If they want to buff the specialized prots they should: - Make them compatible with horse armor - Make them take no armor damage against the type of damage they are made for - Make the effect stackable but acting like levels in rpg where the higher you go, the minor the difference while still beign significative - Buff their uses overall (fire prot makes you resistant to fire projectiles and fire aspect weapons, projectile prot makes the effects of the projectiles weaker like the dragon's breath or the tipped arrows and blast prot gives slightly more knockback resistance in general besides the blast knockback resistance) EDIT: imma as well just put all the enchantments that need a buff xd, just because im mad at mojang not doing things that are so simple o could do with command blocks. Bane of anthropods: this enchantment could inflict poison to all mobs, like if it had insecticide for them, mantaining it's damage boost only on anthropods Smite: besides the undead damage boost, this enchantment could make crits do even more damage, nothing crazy, just make smite 5 do crits with 75%+ damage instead of 50%, this obviously for all mobs, just to spice up pvp and pve with some options. Thorns: just buff the damage the thorns do so the durability trade is fair. or buff the limit number of the enchantment, so we can have thorns 5 for example Knockback: just add y axis knockback, that alone will make players use knockback 2, shifting and attacking to throw the opponent to the air, maybe even buff the enchantment limit to level 3 Aqua affinity: just make it compatible with all breaking tools Impaling: make it work like in bedrock multishot: make it work lile a shotgun and make it compatible for bow but imcompatible with infinity piercing: make it compatible for bow and but incompatible with power power: same as piercing but for crossbow infinity: makr it compatible fot crossbows but incompatible with multishot Loyalty: give tridents a weaker multi hit function like arrows Sharpness: make it compatible for all tools (i just want a 4 damage hoe xd ) Sweeping edge: make it boost attack speed like haste does Frost walker: bedrock version is fine Soul speed: i just realized soul speed breaks your armor, for having a so specific use, i think it shouldn't, nerf the speed boost if you want but don't break the armor Mending: i don't want to buff this one, i want to nerf it, it's wau too good to the point you don't choose a path, you are forced to have it, so instead of every exp point repairing 1 point of armor i woulf nerf it to each 5 exp repairs 1 point, this is also to cut the long and boring netherite fights. it's too easy to heal armor
@@CarbonFang25 i think it's a good trade off, no armor damage and extra protection from one specific type of attack, any other type of attack will do normal damage and armor damage, that way you have an actual reason to use it or at least give fire prot to your horse
I have my world from 1.14 when there was that brief window that you could add all the protections to a single piece. So all of my pieces of armor have all the protections, but I never wear a chestplate lol
I hate Mojang's Pariaty features. They started off good but now they are just making both versions worse. They removed the ability to have a horse, donkey or mule on a boat which makes them actually worth taming & there reasons where stupid "too big" but in the same update they added to bedrock the ability to put turtles in boats & the turtle fits far less. I really hope the community can pressure mojang into changing their mind about these things. Like they aren't helping the game by nerfing stuff. We like it the way it is. Its not really for balance because the game is more fun when you can exploit it in certain ways.
Just to make sure I've got this right: Fire was already more dangerous in Java than in Bedrock? Fire Protection was already stronger in Bedrock than in Java? And despite this, Mojang nerfed Fire Protection in Java?
@@Budderman18Frost Walker is too good, except for legacy console where it lags for some odd reason. Considering that Mojang isn't bringing 4J back, I think Frost Walker is staying the same. They'd definitely nerf the crossbow enchantments though.
I think there's some confusion in the comments. The main effect of Fire Protection is reducing all fire damage taken (including lava damage) by 8 * combined level, up to a max of 32%. This remains unchanged. Reducing burning time is just an additional effect of the enchant, and that is the only thing that is being nerfed. You will still take less fire damage from having Fire Protection 4, and only need it on one piece to have the max amount of damage reduction. The only thing that changes is you will now burn for slightly longer compared to before. Blast Protection works in the same way, where the main effect is reducing explosion damage, but it also has the additional effect of reducing knockback. The nerfs will only affect the knockback reduction, not the damage reduction. This is why Projectile Protection is not being changed, as it has no side effect and only reduces projectile damage.
But regular Protection already gives similar defense against EVERYTHING. The reduction was what made these specialized enchants unique and now it may as well not exist.
Don’t forget that for blast protection to get the full kb reduction, you need it on all pieces now. This really effects crystal pvp as people can get out of combos easily due to the higher knockback as well as shields being overpowered once again because you can’t disable them easily anymore due to the kb increase increasing the gap between the player and the shielded
*Edit:* Change got reverted in RC1, yippee! I can see people using fire protection on a singular piece of armor, with other types of protection with their other armor pieces. It's an "all-rounder" armor set that, while i personally wouldn't use, i think is useful. It's a little unfortunate that fire prot is pretty much useless now, but I guess to another's eye it was already a useless enchant.
Why the hell do they nerf fire protection?!.... I felt like I was one of the only ones to put fire prot IV on my head (unless a modpack had limb damage - then it'd be on boots). Are you kidding me? They need to make it so you can stack fire prot on normal protection then. Make it so fire protection, blast protection, and projectile protection can simply stack onto normal protection (With some limit of 2 types of protection per armor maybe?). They've taken something that barely anybody uses and nerfed it harder than a DBD patch.
I never even knew of this whole immunity to fire thing; that seems like a really cool feature to me Because I know all the specific protections provide greater protection for their respective source than general protection but granting full immunity from them whilst stacking the enchants seems like a really cool feature that allows for "build" diversity in different situations, thus making them way more valuable than they normally are; stack fire protection in the nether, stack blast protection against ghasts, creepers, or the wither, etc. The fact that they're nerfing this seems really dumb and is only going to make them EVEN LESS useful than generalized protection
My main concern is how this will affect the crystal PvP community, as blast protection is actually quite important right now. With needed blast protection, crystals might deal even more damage then they already do, which is kind of a problem
@@dtm2741concidering how they have listened several times this update(notably how they reversed the piston sound change), the blast and fire protection nerf is most likely gonne be reversed soon when 1.21 releases
What’s with Mojang suddenly deciding to roll out all these unnecessary nerfs? It’s like they got tired of people asking for updates, and decided to make it so we’d hope they would never update anything again.
Mojang: "No one uses this terrible enchantment" also Mojang: "Nerf it!" Honestly, they should just fold Blast Protection and Fire Protection into a single enchantment, and do the same for Feather Falling and Projectile Protection...call them "Fulmination Protection" and "Kinetics Protection" respectively...with base protection renamed to "General Protection" or "Universal Protection".
I think most people aren't angry/annoyed because they use those enchantments, but because they were already so situational as to be almost useless and now they've been made actually useless. Might as well remove them from the game now so they aren't just bad rolls on the enchanting table.
@@EeveeRealSenpai oh yes ive seen those! Yeah I agree minecraft enchantments kinda suck imo, Ive actually come to realize that I end up having LESS fun after getting stacked with enchantments! I think its kinda like for me at least, becoming too op kinda kills the enjoyment, ive also come to realize that I have less fun after building farms too, I think many people (even myself back then) don’t notice how much being op and having too much drags down the game- it took me awhile to realize this but ever since ive challenged myself, refusing to engage with things that are way too op, ive actually had more fun on minecraft than ive ever had before! I think balancing in minecraft is very flawed, and drags down the gameplay tbh
Damn, I unironically ran a piece with fire protection instead of just maxing out protection on all my armor Guess Mojang didn't like the non-generalist enchantments actually getting used.
The spelling errors are intentional and an underhanded way to drive up engagement by baiting people to correct them in the comments. This tactic is very commonly found on TikTok and UA-cam Shorts
Literally everyone: buff fire and blast protection Mojang: Seriously though they should have just made fire exclusive to pants and blast exclusive to boots or something. It would have solved the issue of people thinking using multiple helps.
what they should’ve done is buff the effect of maxed out fire/blast protection, even if they nerfed the effect of only one piece. their intent is to give incentive to use full gear of these enchantments, and i think that’s a better way of doing that like, it stacking makes sense, objectively. there should be incentive to max it out. to make several different armor sets, like a set for the nether, etc.
Phoenix: So let's see how long it takes with one set of Fire Protection II **burns himself**
The rain: *Don't worry, child. I'm here to save you*
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495report for spam
Edit: I got shadow deleted by UA-cam
Phoenix: Can you not be yourself for FIVE MINUTES?!
Engineer gaming
yes
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495totally not a bot
What's the most perplexing thing about this is that of all things to nerf, they nerf fire and blast protection. The two enchants I never use simply because why the hell would I ever use them over protection, which blocks everything? Yet Mojang seems to think it's a genius idea to nerf the one thing they have going for them...
Yeah it's strange to nerf things that are literally supposed to be effective against their specific niche, especially considering they're also very rarely used because of it
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495 i think its the other way around
I'm pissed at the Blast Protection nerf as a Hardcore player. I keep it on one piece of my armor since it drastically reduces creeper damage (which is ridiculous otherwise) and only makes me a little less tanky against general damage. The fact that they're basically making the enchantment system even LESS interesting to experiment with than it was before (which was minimal) is damn annoying.
I couldn't care less about the Fire Protection nerf though. Who even uses Fire Protection???
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495you don't even make content you annoying little brat
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495Your action explained why your parents get away from you.
Of all protection enchants to nerf, they decided to nerf the ones with the most situational upsides over the one with universal protection. Game balance should be their specialty honestly.
I think stuff like this is why dungeons and legends died (besides the lack of support, that is.), they don't know game balance.
genuinely boggles my mind that prot4 diamond plate gets to multiply your effective health by 10 against almost everything in the game, but fire protection isn't allowed to protect you from *one* thing
also the fact that there’s almost no reason to use blast or proj outside of very niche circumstances instead of more enemies actually dealing that type of damage
@@TehNoobinessDiamond chestplate has 8 defense, so it can provide at most 8*4 = 32% damage reduction, protection IV provides 4*4 = 16%, so in total we have 1 / ((1-0.32)*(1-0.16)) = 1.75 effective hp multiplier
@@griglog the math is MUCH less simple than that
at least on java since armour toughness became a thing
and now the damage reduction of armour depends on toughness and how hard the hit is
"Most people don't use Fire Protection."
Mojang: So you're saying some people still use it? We'll fix that...
I tend to use fire protection as the chest piece, since the areas where I need fire protection at I will not be using an elytra and vice versa.
@@rheokalyke367smart
blast protection used to be useful as a one piece armor in hardcore difficulty, same for fire prot in nether tho now, we'll just go back to potions and shields only instead.
at this point they may as well just remove these enchants, they've become completely useless.
Hey guys, they fixed it! Release candidate 1 made it work like it does on bedrock.
@@rockrevenchy One Piece?
Other things Mojang will nerf;
1: Furnace minecarts
2; Riding pigs
3; Bane of arthropods
4; Gold tools
even tho this is mojang.. how could they possibly nerf gold tools 💀they'll literally last like 10 seconds of use before breaking
"We've decided that gold tools are too powerful, they will now have 8 durability, unenchantable, and be slower then just using your fist."
@@siriuslyepic308 make them mine with a speed between stone and iron
In bedrock the furnace minecart doesnt exist anymore btw
@@TNTsquid.But is it really needed?
The reason this change annoys so many people is that there's literally no reason for it. It's just dumb.
I still dont get it why they add coldown to a water bucket in bedrock knowing theres not even cooldown on tools
Reminds me of when they got rid of fireflies 💀
@@T.U.P.Y.0I think it’s so you can reliably do MLG clutches. A lot of the time, you would place the water and then immediately pick it up before you hit the ground
they reverted it in the release candidate (:
I mean they are obviously trying to rework it not just nerf it but idk why they started hear and did nothing else.
I still hate Mojang for making two different versions of the same game and then a decade later retroactively deciding they actually only wanted one of them and deciding to kill the other one slowly and painfully
It’s funny bc the one they’re supposedly putting all the effort into is still regarded as buggy and overall worse
No they take bedrock features too
@@Rob0_by who? Bedrock users?
@@cannedsquasher5923 As a bedrock user, yes. I'm on Xbox and have to choose between the broken version and the discontinued version. I've recently died more to glitches than by legitimate reasons. Every time I go through a nether portal I have to drink a slow falling potion and fire resistance because like a third of the time I fall through the nether on my world. I died by using a riptide trident during the rain not knowing that you still die when you land softly. I was wearing feather falling IV and full protection IV when it happened. They supposedly patched it, so I tried it again. I died around 30 blocks in the air, and I wasn't even quickly falling or going too fast. I also had the same equipment on as last time. I've also had blocks vanish under me while bridging in the nether and I died. In the past week or two I softly landed with an elytra in a chunk that was seemingly unloaded on accident. I initially took no damage, but after around a second I lost around three hearts, then another three hearts, and then whatever I was standing on vanished, and the fall damage as well as the stray that shot me took me to half a heart. I also recently went to the end and fell through the platform, but didn't die only because the island extends under it. I wish I had a working version of Minecraft on Xbox
Bedrock sells more. Java was always meant to be the main version of Minecraft, but since Bedrock makes more money by being on more consoles and through the Marketplace, they're slowly ruining Java without giving any actual attention to try and make Bedrock a tolerable gameplay experience.
They just gave a major nerf to fire and blast protection for basically no reason. Incredible.
If u call stacking a nerf
@@Thedarkknight902 did you even watch the video???
The enchants are stacking, yes, but now each piece with fire prot 4 decreases time by 15% instead of 60%
So now you need full fire prot 4 armor to have the exact same effect as one piece in the past
I see it as them trying to make the version that doesn't have in game purchases (other then realms) less convenient, to get people to play the one that does.
@@Thedarkknight902 So you didn't watch the video, or are incapable of comprehending what was directly stated. Stacking means nothing when the effect of having all four pieces at level 4 has the same effect as one piece previously did. So yes, its a pretty severe nerf if no one cares about it stacking because they've ruined the numbers so much compared to how it was before without stacking.
@@s47o26 how the fuck did you come to this conclusion. this doesnt change anything because no ones using it anyway lmao
they basically just removed the "Protection" in Fire Protection.
fire
FIRE IV
Well but then the tggggeehhe armor would just burn
@@jeremypanjaitan4039Tick tock
Heavy like a Brinks truck
Looking like I'm tip-top
Shining like a wristwatch
Time will grab your wrist
Lock it down 'til the thing pop
Can you stick around for a minute til' the ring stop? Please God
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
‼️ NOTE: Minecraft just reverted these changes in the 1.21-rc1 snapshot based on community feedback ‼️
Sarcasm... right?
@@suomingstar surprisingly not
@@suomingstar They're getting smarter... and better...
wow that's rare
Thank f$&&
At this point, the spelling errors have to be intentional.
There are spelling errors?
Are you talking about how he spells “armour”?
@@jamesisa7689trail chambers 💀
@@FinnjaymakesThats how you spell it in Australia and the UK
@SHOES-GEN.ALPHA2495 wow, your definitely a well adjusted person, and not a bot or inane insane child(this is sarcastic)(Duh)
You said "no one uses Fire Prot anyways", but that's the problem. There's no reason to use the specialized protection enchantments, and all they do is lock you out of getting normal Prot. They passively frustrate players by existing and we have little to no use for them.
And still, they get nerfed.
yeah additionally it's just completely outclassed by fire resistance potions lmao
The 5 exclusive enchants (projectile, fire, blast, as well as smite and bane for weapons) still at least have a purpose, even if that purpose is like 1 very specific scenario for some of them. People forgot there are enchants that are not just useless, but lock you out of better enchants, frost walker and multishot.
Multishot is just a worse version of piercing, even if piercing is at level 1. Its way harder to line up 3 mobs side by side than it is in a line. On java it could be considered better than piercing, since when a rocket is fired from a crossbow, it explodes on impact rather than always after a set time, and since enchanted bows are better than even a max crossbow, you’d likely only use rockets for them anyways, it still chews through durability and plus rockets are expensive and rarely have an actual use when attacking. I’d still consider piercing better since multishot is impossible to aim with unlike piercing, even with crossbows pretty much only helpful early on.
Frost walker has literally no use. Level 1 you cant sprint jump on water bc it cant catch up, and level 2 can, but only sometimes. It gets to the point where a boat is going to be faster or giving it the enchantment that can’t be combined with it instead, depth strider. I have never used frost walker before, its not even worth using if you happen to stumble upon it with a lucky shipwreck spawn given how cheap boats are.
I just don’t understand why you’d touch stuff that’s already fairly balanced when there’s “enchantments” that might as well just be labeled as curses at this point.
i mean it really is buffed on bedrock but not on java
@@anoukk_ Wrong. Full prot provides the most protection from general sources. You could look this up before spreading it everywhere.
@@anoukk_ you're misinformed. The actual tip is that, if you really want to use specialized protection, like Projectile Protection, you should only wear one piece with it and have normal Prot on all three, as that adds up to the cap for projectiles and still protects from other damage.
What you said is not possible because you can only reach the cap with a full set of Protection 5 (impossible). Until then, every protection counts. Except the weird ones
1:02 There are 2 hard things in computer science: cache invalidation, naming things, and off-by-one errors
This made me smile
*sigh*
Very true
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Tom Scott vooce: Remember, computers count from 0
Nerfing an enchantment while its already down in the gutter, bold move
Ikr
I'm convinced that person who made the firetick bug report is the kid who'd remind the teacher of the homework for that day.
No one on earth would report this. Mojang definetrly just watches livestreams or some shit and decided "hmm, his fire time is way too short."
This is why I use Projectile Protection.
So little people use it, even Mojang forget it exists in most of their blog posts.
so short people use it?
Same
Why not just use a shield? There are hardly any, if any applications for the enchantment
@@berhonkusbardledooLOL
But projectile prot is worse than normal prot because you only get ressitance to projectile which you often dont have to face off against and with 3 protection and one fire protection max yoy have almost immunity before this prerelease to lave
so you're telling me they patched a "bug" that technically helped out with java-bedrock parity.. cool!
anti-parity
Actually it seems that instead of fixing the bug to support the minor addition, they nerfed the existing feature to the ground so as to not need any patching. It's like destroying a house to make room for a shed.
Anti-parity, unless it actively makes one version of the game worse.
Yeah, just like barrel crafting recipe in bedrock@@RangerW3
Gotta wreck the java experience in order to force people to use closed source Bedrock Edition.
Mojang: "We want to create parity between versions of Minecraft"
Also Mojang:
parody
parody
Remove "also Mojan"= perfect comment
@@xz5901 It says "also Mojang:" what are you talking about?
@@G-Forces they're saying to remove that part dawg
In polish there is very funny speling error. While chosing difficulty, one sentence should say that "hunger can go down"
Go down in polish is "spaść", but they wrote "spać" which means sleep.
So, instead of "hunger can go down" we have "hunger can sleep"
Version 1.20 I think
🛏️😴😴
🍗
🛏️
ah yes, sleep: the ultimate struggle meal
in italian they have translated lead as the metal rather than the leash, so in pocket edition one of the tips is saying that you can use metal on boats (and since is leads it's made into "piombi" which isn't an actual word but a weird plural)
Wow. Such basic translation errors. Does nobody at Mojang check these things?
*Slams enchantment in car door.*
"Masterful gambit, Mojang"
It seems now mojang is shooting themselves in the foot, (more like shooting themselves in the foot with a power 5 bow and instant damage 2 arrows)
@@GaryIsFound erm axmtskturally if you deal 12 or more damage with your arrow, instant damage 2 does nothing due to how minecrafts s work
@@GaryIsFoundDon't forget that the bow was forged from the bones of dragons, and that they infused themselves with lots of starlight from the constellation of Discidia.
"I thlammed my enchantmenth in the car door"
@@marshaenderheart”you slammed your enchantments in the car door!”
*bang*
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHH
Fire protection went from a viable alternative to filling your inv with fire res for the sacrifice of some protection to being completely useless
(Former) Fire Protection user here.
I play HC and UHC Survival. Fire Protection was amazing for us. My armour was always 2x Prot 1x Blast 1x Fire. This is pretty much the most armour diversity you'd ever see in Minecraft, since most of you will just be using 4x Prot but for my purposes, Fire and Blast were vital for keeping long running worlds alive.
Now they've just nerfed it all so I guess I'm gonna be using the same as everyone else now, thanks Mojang. Actively making your least used enchantments less useful is a great decision, well done.
(Might still take 1x Blast though to prevent instakills. Very useful for Hardcore).
I'm not that much of a HC player, but I'm curious. what explosions are insta-kill in full prot 4 netherite besides intentionally maxing bed damage?
@@mr.phantom674End crystals, tnt dupers if you are using a terrarormer, creeper attack if you're at low hp, and, as stated, beds from debris mining
@@mr.phantom674charged creepers
I think your build 2x Prot 1x Blast 1x Fire should give 32% damage reduction from all sources except fire and explosions and 64% from fire and explosions. But 4x Prot should give you 64% reduction from ALL sources. So I think your enchantments were not so good, it also should give explosion knockback defense and fire time reduction, but I don’t think it was worth it even before nerf.
Mojang: vertical slabs inhibit creativity so we won't add them
Also Mojang: we're changing how enchantments work to punish players who combine them creatively
"I appear to have burst into flames"
- Spy
Judging by your PFP/comment I'm guessing spy is not having a good day. Poor spy
“Yo, we’re on fire!”
-Scout
"AAAGAHGH!! FIRE!!! IT BURNS!!"
Heavy
"I do believe im on fire"
"I am melting!"
- Medic
A Trail Chamber is a "Trail Ruins" and "Trial Chambers" that intersect with each other.
😂
you might say its a, *Trail Mix*
@@DBSilver2024Oh, you...
The one thing Mojang needs to learn is: IF IT AINT BROKE DONT FIX IT. armour was FINE stacking enchants is a cool idea but cmon. You didn't need to fiddle with that
Blame those pyromaniacs
Seeing that happening everywhere unfortunately. Apparently what is fun and great for the players is broken and needs fixing by whoever is pushing for those to be "fixed."
I kinda like it. it was broken because Minecraft after the first day ain't a survival game anymore
Fixing things that aren't broken is what mojang always do, Fire Protection, Netherite Armour, Copper Lamp delay and so on
@@bombie5549 minecraft is a sandbox game with survival aspects. if you want a pure survival game go play project zomboid or something.
2:53 it’s actually 3 ticks. you didn’t count the first tick which occurred shortly after you exited the lava
There are definitely half seconds here and there that have just been rounded for simplicity. 🙂
@@PhoenixSC makes sense, i assumed it had something to do with rounding
PhoenixSC the fire ticks is decided by how long you stay in the lava not what version you’re in btw so most of you’re calculations are thrown off. Hope that helps
@@Old-dec That’s just not true. It’s always been a set duration.
@@jeezuhskriste5759 1:17 he takes 7 ticks of fire damage after getting out because he got out quickly
And in the release candidate they just put out, they reverted the change, nice of them to listen to feedback like that
But why nerf it in the first place, this is just person x lit my house on fire but oh yea they put it out.
a single armor piece with fire protection has legitimately been my standard loadout for years
Same
Same. Because the difference from 3x prot-4 to 4x prot-4 is was actually negligible.
Just use a fire resistance potion
That's no good if you want to be prepared before going into the Nether. Also it means giving up at least one inventory slot for the bottle(s).
@@lagomoof ooo 1 slot out of 41 👻
people dont use it because the benefit of having those specific enchantments is outweighed by having a general protection enchantment that protects from all other damage causes more. to make them a good enchantment, their benefit should be very powerful when the player heavily invests in it, like becoming immune to fire.
Max fire prot on 4 armor pieces should make fire do negative damage, basically make fire convert your armor durability into healing.
Or they not conflict with protection, that makes second ultimate protection from one danger and protection for other sources
@@youtubeuniversity3638 Or maybe those damage sources don't harm durability
@@Nonname_From_The_Internets Yes, that kind of build should be carefully tuned to have more specific benefits the more specific enchantments you have. Something to keep in mind, though, is that having all the protection types should not be stronger than just having protection.
@@knightsofthedraftingtable1961 Maybe they replenish your durability?
8:40 "any second now I'm gonna drown to death" moment o7
fr
That clip lives rent free in my head o7
As the only person I know of who uses fire protection, I am outraged
I use it. Fire tick is annoying. I won't use it if they keep this though.
just use protection :sob:
@@thechefwhodoesntcook8233 Yeah, don't complain, just consume product. Shut up and take it when companies change a game in ways that do nothing to improve it and can only make it worse. That always works out.
@@zkeletonz001they are just saying to use regular protection since it reduces any damage.
@@zkeletonz001 The problem is that people complain and then consume product. Actions speak louder than words. Do not consume product. Mod it back out then tell everybody you modded it back out. Upload the mod.
Complaining is worthless if you don't actually do something about it.
8:30 technoblade:"wait let me take a break from drowning to drink a glass of water"
Terraria achievements be like
hold on i left the stove on at home 😂😂
I hope this reverts back. Was also really cool honestly trying to make the desicion- "hm, should I just do all protection? Or should one piece have fire protection, or should another have blast protection?" All while knowing the main protection would lower but the protection against something would buff. Made every enchant worth it
You're one of the only people to use frie and blast protection. Congrats.
It was reverted.
@@ethanrandall3005 I thought I heard stuff about that happening, glad it did. Now I can be one of the only people who happily use one of the protections ong
@@ethanrandall3005 I thought I heard stuff about that happening, glad it did. Now I can be one of the only people who happily use one of the protections ong
When I played in legacy edition I would do projectile prot for helmet, prot for chestplate, blast prot for leggings and fire prot for boots
He was selling fire prot pretty well while explaining the old version. Like 5 ticks of damage if I fall into lava, 0 on bedrock?! Never knew how it worked and was ready to put it on something but then nooooo
Fire protection is honestly great, worth to have on at least 1 piece of armor if you have a specialized set for the Nether (like, a golden piece to avoid piglins or something)
@@adaphion no, it is utterly useless, and always has been. Just use fire resistance
@@anakinlowground5515 Why are you getting so mad about a children's game?
@@adaphionyou said it was great, when its actively detrimental.
@@capitaldcolonface Unless you're some ultra sweaty PVP nerd, then losing out on a single regular Protection 4 isn't a big deal for PVE purposes, it's just a major skill issue if you actually need that extra prot 4
So much for making the game harder for java and making the one type of protection variant "more useless" and yet they haven't buff the wither in java
the game is way harder on the bedrock side, we just get some crumbs from time to time (like the fire protection shown lol)
@XAnderson27 as a bedrock player the wither isn't even really hard, it's the duration of the fight and how unbelievably overpowered the wither effect is on bedrock that makes it a pain
@@ilikethenumber7934plus the natural regeneration
On Java, sustain makes up like, the entirety of the combat system- on Bedrock you really don't want long fights. And imo it's largely the screwy natural regen
At least, that was the case when I was playing Bedrock a couple years ago. They might've changed it since then.
@justseffstuff3308 no lol, still a pain having long fights with small damage, your regen even with food is bad, plus the enchantments are bad too, or even the frickin armor doesnt protect like java, netherite java and bedrock are very inconsistent
Your info is out of date. What you guys are describing about the wither applies to it pre-1.19.2.
They reworked a lot of the protection calculations and added a fix to the wither effect bypassing the protection enchant.
Now, the bedrock wither is a way easier fight, as long as you have golden apples on you, you don’t really have much to worry about.
Why in the world would they nerf fire protection when it's already rendered completely useless by the potion of fire resistance?
Not completely useless, just situational, but with the changes they made? yeah it's bad. You won't always have fire resistance potions, or any other items that grant complete immunity to fire damage, so having at least one armor peice with fire protection four can come in handy.
It's useful before you get late game potions.
@@SPQR_14 what are "late game" potions? You can get potions of fire resist as soon as you can mine obsidian
@@Feraligono That's not true... You have to enter the nether and find the ingredients. Considering the nether is full of lava, it is very useful to have Fire Protection before entering.
@@SPQR_14 You don't even need to make fire resistance potions yourself, you can get them from piglins.
2:24 the timing for that was PERFECT
Finnaly a comment about this!!
I see zero reasons why a full set of fire, blast or projectile prot 4 shouldn't just make you immune to those damage sources. Even then I doubt that would make people use them
That’s fairly balanced for fire, less so for the others, but wouldn’t work well for pvp
I think the best way for each armor piece to work is:
- Fire protection: Immune to lava
-Blast protection: Immune to explosions and knockback
-Projectile protection: Projectiles bounce off of you
@@btcbuster5556 it would make end crystal combat die which, is good cause end crystal combat is bs, especially since the people who do it has a hacked client to do it for them
Tbh yeah this'd be awesome. Lava bucket gaming
Yeah, they’re so underutilized that they need to straight up be made really good if you only care about one damage source. Standard prot is so good generally, that if they want people to use the other ones without nerfing it, they need to be buffed to all hell.
This is a long line of changes that they've made recently that funnel players into one playstyle... I actually used full fire protection for the most part (one piece was always protection), and it feels like they don't want to give options.
When Mojang buffs something (the maces for instance), they will undoubtedly nerf something proportionally
Newton’s Third Law of Motion, “for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”
@@ThatOneDude-yx4mo That's the one and only one time physics laws apply to the world of Minecraft lmao
what I hate about this is that before having one armour piece of fire prot for the nether actually made sense because the protection against fire and lava was higher with fire prot 4 than prot 4 combined with 3 pieces with prot 4 it was useful. Now it doesn't make sense to use it where before it actually did. Would have been better to delete the enchantment, then the people who used fire prot could at least enchant their armour with prot 4 instead.
My gold boots always get fire prot put on them. The overall reduction in protection really isn't that major of a difference, and having a 5 second burn time instead of 14 is a significant QoL improvement in the nether, where one tends to spend much time getting set on fire.
Full fire protection IV should give you 0 fire damage
While there may be some inconsistencies in Java and Bedrock, Phoenix's upload time schedule is definitely the most inconsistent.
I haven’t seen you in forever Jiren
Idk what mojang is doing anymore they need to listen to the community
i mean, assuming your armor still decreases in durability upon taking fire damage (even when you take zero damage from it), they should really change it in java so a full set of fire prot IV gives 105% fire protection and reduces the burn time to zero. it'd be fun to have a lava scuba set instead of a bunch of fire prot potions
ikr, if the enchantment is called "Fire Protection", it should fully protect from fire on max set, or at least 95% of it
that's the part that baffles me, fire resistance potions already outclassed fire protection before this nerf, why not let the dedicated enchantment with a major downside at max level compete with the easiest potion to obtain(piglin bartering)
fun fact, the armor durability thing isnt a problem for netherite armor, as that doesnt ever take durability damage from fire or lava
@@Pihsrosnec
piglin bartering?
you could probably stab a stupid bouncing lava thing with a looting sword and end up with a weeks supply of ingredients without even bothering with the piglin
Ok, these situational enchantments shouldn't be nerfed, they *_should_* be buffed! In most cases they suck even without the nerf.
Ok with the misunderstanding cleared up I think they did good-
Nevermind what they did is just made it only slightly more useless than before...
Mojang has 2 modes:
-Great biomes, great mobs, great weapons, great mechanics
-LeT's dO rAndoM dUmbsHit anD chAngE thIngS thAt dIdnT neEd aN upDaTe
First the pistons, now the armour enchantments
They got rid of the annoying sound, no worries.
If you choose to use full fire protection armour, you _should_ be rewarded with fire immunity (or at least near-immunity)! Having interesting trade-offs would make the game more enjoyable. I might want to keep a spare set of armour around for when I'm expecting to be around a lot of fire or lava. That way I would trade some general damage protection for the extra inventory slots I gain from not having to lug around fire resistance potions.
you know, i got a great idea i think for this, likely not alot of people will see this but its okay, still worth mention.
tldr;
what if fire debuff time increased for each time fire was inflicted
and fire proc kept reducing time
and what if lava increased its damage the longer your in it
with fire proc making the time to increase damage slower
longer version:
what if fire proc acted kinda like tf2's fire?
Longer your on fire, or acted upon fire, or more fire is applied to you, the longer the fire will last.
being in lava for only half a second could lead to a lower fire time, while being in fire for longer will increase the time.
Fire proc would have a bit more meaning as it could take some of the hit of the increased fire time
now lets add another what if.
take some inspiration from starbound aswell.
In starbound, the longer your in lava in the center of a world, the more damage you take.
If you stood in lava for only a few seconds, normal half heart damage with armor.
If you kept standing in it for as long as ibx did, it could increase to two, then three, etc, overtime, over lets say, 20 seconds.
it still keeps the danger of Lava and staying in it for too long with base, while still making it strong even with armor and fireproc and stuff.
Fire proc could again, reduce the damage taken by lava, or increase the time it takes to get to two heart damage, three heart, etc.
damn i actually wish java fire prot acted like it does in bedrock, thats really cool, also if i knew i could get max burn time reduction with just one piece of armor before i might have used it more often.
mojang really choosing the worst option, fire is so annoying, "balance" does not equal fun
Agreed, the amount of time a player should burn in Java should be reduced in general
Its also _not_ balanced. It was already worse than protection, now its _significantly_ worse
6:00 I mean yeah if you’re going to use Fire prot, it might as well make you invulnerable
SOO TRUE
If they did this same exact thing, except made it so that full Fire Prot IV made you completely immune to Fire and Lava, and Blast Prot IV made you immune to explosions, they would have some utility and people would actually use them.
I wish they would revamp the enchanting system. Make a bunch of set effects. Incentivize players to mix or match enchants.
Llama Jumpscare Warning 😢
0:16
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
oh sorry that scared me why didn’t you warn me sooner
AAAAAAHHHH
Just had heart attack. Could've made warning more clear.
Thanks for the warning! I survived!
Wait I wasn't looking, do it again.
If they want to buff the specialized prots they should:
- Make them compatible with horse armor
- Make them take no armor damage against the type of damage they are made for
- Make the effect stackable but acting like levels in rpg where the higher you go, the minor the difference while still beign significative
- Buff their uses overall (fire prot makes you resistant to fire projectiles and fire aspect weapons, projectile prot makes the effects of the projectiles weaker like the dragon's breath or the tipped arrows and blast prot gives slightly more knockback resistance in general besides the blast knockback resistance)
EDIT: imma as well just put all the enchantments that need a buff xd, just because im mad at mojang not doing things that are so simple o could do with command blocks.
Bane of anthropods: this enchantment could inflict poison to all mobs, like if it had insecticide for them, mantaining it's damage boost only on anthropods
Smite: besides the undead damage boost, this enchantment could make crits do even more damage, nothing crazy, just make smite 5 do crits with 75%+ damage instead of 50%, this obviously for all mobs, just to spice up pvp and pve with some options.
Thorns: just buff the damage the thorns do so the durability trade is fair. or buff the limit number of the enchantment, so we can have thorns 5 for example
Knockback: just add y axis knockback, that alone will make players use knockback 2, shifting and attacking to throw the opponent to the air, maybe even buff the enchantment limit to level 3
Aqua affinity: just make it compatible with all breaking tools
Impaling: make it work like in bedrock
multishot: make it work lile a shotgun and make it compatible for bow but imcompatible with infinity
piercing: make it compatible for bow and but incompatible with power
power: same as piercing but for crossbow
infinity: makr it compatible fot crossbows but incompatible with multishot
Loyalty: give tridents a weaker multi hit function like arrows
Sharpness: make it compatible for all tools (i just want a 4 damage hoe xd )
Sweeping edge: make it boost attack speed like haste does
Frost walker: bedrock version is fine
Soul speed: i just realized soul speed breaks your armor, for having a so specific use, i think it shouldn't, nerf the speed boost if you want but don't break the armor
Mending: i don't want to buff this one, i want to nerf it, it's wau too good to the point you don't choose a path, you are forced to have it, so instead of every exp point repairing 1 point of armor i woulf nerf it to each 5 exp repairs 1 point, this is also to cut the long and boring netherite fights. it's too easy to heal armor
Protection armour about to last forever
@@CarbonFang25 i think it's a good trade off, no armor damage and extra protection from one specific type of attack, any other type of attack will do normal damage and armor damage, that way you have an actual reason to use it or at least give fire prot to your horse
@@InanamGames They are (probably) talking about the normal protection enchantment.
@@orangejuiceisagooddrink.5205 oh, xdddd i just realized, yeah, i was talking about only specified types of protection srry if i confused someone
I do like that suggestion for fire protection armor will never got burn by flame arrow and fire aspect weapon
Ah, I see they're taking the Blizzard approach to balancing.
Both are currently owned by Microsoft so...
@@xanthiusdrake2775 the amount of people who dont realize just how much of a criminal organization microsoft is is just crazy.
I have my world from 1.14 when there was that brief window that you could add all the protections to a single piece. So all of my pieces of armor have all the protections, but I never wear a chestplate lol
Same 😂 I had 4 set of Armor. I loose two of them :(
@@Seb_Semosyou can use duo glitches
@@omarbenjelloun2271 no, I don't dupe.
@@Seb_Semos
At that point you might as well change the versions and use creative mode and console commands
Whoa. So all of sudden trading for fire-res pot is more worth now
Wish there be a blast-res potion
I hate Mojang's Pariaty features. They started off good but now they are just making both versions worse. They removed the ability to have a horse, donkey or mule on a boat which makes them actually worth taming & there reasons where stupid "too big" but in the same update they added to bedrock the ability to put turtles in boats & the turtle fits far less. I really hope the community can pressure mojang into changing their mind about these things. Like they aren't helping the game by nerfing stuff. We like it the way it is. Its not really for balance because the game is more fun when you can exploit it in certain ways.
They should remove armor penetration, it doesn’t make the game more fun
@@weeblordgaming6062 pretty sure armour penetration is in both versions.
@@cillianennis9921 unfortunately
Just to make sure I've got this right:
Fire was already more dangerous in Java than in Bedrock?
Fire Protection was already stronger in Bedrock than in Java?
And despite this, Mojang nerfed Fire Protection in Java?
Sometimes I think minecraft has like 2 people actually coding and all the others are just there
And they have one person who decides all the changes like this one, who is a 5 year old
0:45 you miscounted, there was one fire tick immediately after leaving the lava.
Ironic that fire protection couldn't save itself from fire.
he could save others from death, but not himself...
They are going to nerf bane of athropods next.
They’ll find a way to nerf frost walker somehow
@@Budderman18Frost Walker is too good, except for legacy console where it lags for some odd reason. Considering that Mojang isn't bringing 4J back, I think Frost Walker is staying the same. They'd definitely nerf the crossbow enchantments though.
@@realPurpleOrb Forstwalker sucks, it ruins your builds and farms.
@@realPurpleOrbyou cant sprint jump just use depth riders with speed pot or a boat i you really want to go fast in water
@@jakepeng9962 you don't have to wear them in your builds and farms
This has apparently been reverted due to community feedback, so it should be back to normal.
I think there's some confusion in the comments. The main effect of Fire Protection is reducing all fire damage taken (including lava damage) by 8 * combined level, up to a max of 32%. This remains unchanged. Reducing burning time is just an additional effect of the enchant, and that is the only thing that is being nerfed. You will still take less fire damage from having Fire Protection 4, and only need it on one piece to have the max amount of damage reduction. The only thing that changes is you will now burn for slightly longer compared to before.
Blast Protection works in the same way, where the main effect is reducing explosion damage, but it also has the additional effect of reducing knockback. The nerfs will only affect the knockback reduction, not the damage reduction. This is why Projectile Protection is not being changed, as it has no side effect and only reduces projectile damage.
if this is true than thats actually so cool
But regular Protection already gives similar defense against EVERYTHING. The reduction was what made these specialized enchants unique and now it may as well not exist.
So... Prot 4 everything because they nerfed the only difference between the prot types? Kewl.
Basically, turn the other prots into regular prot. Well that does make them even more useless
The problem is that nobody is going to substitute out regular protection for fire protection now that they have made it *even less* effective.
unfortunate turn of events
Don’t forget that for blast protection to get the full kb reduction, you need it on all pieces now. This really effects crystal pvp as people can get out of combos easily due to the higher knockback as well as shields being overpowered once again because you can’t disable them easily anymore due to the kb increase increasing the gap between the player and the shielded
*Edit:* Change got reverted in RC1, yippee!
I can see people using fire protection on a singular piece of armor, with other types of protection with their other armor pieces. It's an "all-rounder" armor set that, while i personally wouldn't use, i think is useful. It's a little unfortunate that fire prot is pretty much useless now, but I guess to another's eye it was already a useless enchant.
0:01 Minecraft: Tricky Trails
fortnite ahh name
Aww I checked and they fixed it. They’re no fun 😂
Why the hell do they nerf fire protection?!.... I felt like I was one of the only ones to put fire prot IV on my head (unless a modpack had limb damage - then it'd be on boots). Are you kidding me? They need to make it so you can stack fire prot on normal protection then. Make it so fire protection, blast protection, and projectile protection can simply stack onto normal protection (With some limit of 2 types of protection per armor maybe?). They've taken something that barely anybody uses and nerfed it harder than a DBD patch.
they undid the nerf
Society if Mojang had a single person to revise over grammar in every addition:
1.20: Trials and Tails
1.21: Tricky Trails
I love fire protection because is the closest think we have to lava seas
2:45 average counting mistake. It's actually 3
what an idiot imagine making such a simple mistake couldn’t be me
2+2=3. Yep, that sounds about right 🙃
@@TheLonelyGamer_17 ok do you know the Minecraft enchantment system?
@@Crystal-bari Apparently not, but I do know math
I never even knew of this whole immunity to fire thing; that seems like a really cool feature to me
Because I know all the specific protections provide greater protection for their respective source than general protection
but granting full immunity from them whilst stacking the enchants seems like a really cool feature that allows for "build" diversity in different situations, thus making them way more valuable than they normally are; stack fire protection in the nether, stack blast protection against ghasts, creepers, or the wither, etc.
The fact that they're nerfing this seems really dumb and is only going to make them EVEN LESS useful than generalized protection
If you want to become immune to fire and have lava baths do not worry you can just use a fire resistance potion
im glad to have tuned in with "counting with pheonix"
My main concern is how this will affect the crystal PvP community, as blast protection is actually quite important right now. With needed blast protection, crystals might deal even more damage then they already do, which is kind of a problem
implying that mojang cares:
Instructions unclear, nerfed the Mace instead to assure that diversity will never occur
Damage isn't affected, just knockback (it's still terrible since we are basically back to old kb)
@@dtm2741concidering how they have listened several times this update(notably how they reversed the piston sound change), the blast and fire protection nerf is most likely gonne be reversed soon when 1.21 releases
I will be able to peak at HT3 now like I got lt3 in 2022
Fire prot was fine because I only needed room for a little bit of it, now I'm not even gonna use it at all...
man i love when mojang decides to nerf not only the good stuff, but also the stuff that really isnt used
Ah yes trail chambers
nuh uh, taril camherbs
Who else didn’t even know that this was how fire protection worked
i thought fire prot reduced the damage you took from lava,fire etc . lol
What’s with Mojang suddenly deciding to roll out all these unnecessary nerfs? It’s like they got tired of people asking for updates, and decided to make it so we’d hope they would never update anything again.
the nerf is gone, read the patch notes for the next snapshot/pre-release/release candidate after the one shown in the video
Wild update fr
Might as well remove the enchantment itself 🙄
Actually, Moyang won't do that because they want you to get trash enchantments from your table .-.
I’m just sitting back looking at how Minecraft is falling knowing it doesn’t affect me because I’m way too addicted to modded 1.12.2
Mojang: "No one uses this terrible enchantment" also Mojang: "Nerf it!" Honestly, they should just fold Blast Protection and Fire Protection into a single enchantment, and do the same for Feather Falling and Projectile Protection...call them "Fulmination Protection" and "Kinetics Protection" respectively...with base protection renamed to "General Protection" or "Universal Protection".
Oh no! Anyways
The only time i used fire prot on armor was when i used the 1.14.4 glitch to have all protections on 1 armor piece
if they were gonna nerf protection enchantments they should atleast let players stack protection enchantments
I think most people aren't angry/annoyed because they use those enchantments, but because they were already so situational as to be almost useless and now they've been made actually useless. Might as well remove them from the game now so they aren't just bad rolls on the enchanting table.
0:00 "Hey Minecroft"
Minecraft Enchantments are the reason why modded exists LMAO
What do you mean by this? Im a little confused
@@Ultra_Ocelot Minecraft enchantments are so flawed at times that it inspired people to make their own version of enchantments via mods.
@@EeveeRealSenpai oh yes ive seen those! Yeah I agree minecraft enchantments kinda suck imo, Ive actually come to realize that I end up having LESS fun after getting stacked with enchantments! I think its kinda like for me at least, becoming too op kinda kills the enjoyment, ive also come to realize that I have less fun after building farms too, I think many people (even myself back then) don’t notice how much being op and having too much drags down the game- it took me awhile to realize this but ever since ive challenged myself, refusing to engage with things that are way too op, ive actually had more fun on minecraft than ive ever had before! I think balancing in minecraft is very flawed, and drags down the gameplay tbh
@@Ultra_Ocelot Apotheosis mod is a good alternative to enchantments
Ever since the the first, "Why for I need arrow to have infinite ammo", I've been modded.
Damn, I unironically ran a piece with fire protection instead of just maxing out protection on all my armor
Guess Mojang didn't like the non-generalist enchantments actually getting used.
The spelling errors are intentional and an underhanded way to drive up engagement by baiting people to correct them in the comments. This tactic is very commonly found on TikTok and UA-cam Shorts
bump
Intresitng
Patch notes for 1.21.1: all trees removed, Replaced with birch, because all trees, (except for birch) are poisonous to Minceraft: Entity_Birch_Wood
Literally everyone: buff fire and blast protection
Mojang:
Seriously though they should have just made fire exclusive to pants and blast exclusive to boots or something. It would have solved the issue of people thinking using multiple helps.
8:11 Reminds me of Technoblade drowning
"I had to take a break from burning to death to set fire to my house"
-Technoblade....... probably
what they should’ve done is buff the effect of maxed out fire/blast protection, even if they nerfed the effect of only one piece. their intent is to give incentive to use full gear of these enchantments, and i think that’s a better way of doing that
like, it stacking makes sense, objectively. there should be incentive to max it out. to make several different armor sets, like a set for the nether, etc.
8:20 this is like that water trap that Techno was dramatically narrating from Dream SMP
_Fire Prot OP!!! REEEEEE!!!!!_
~Mojang, probably
no, I have always been into having 2 fire prot 4 armor pieces and i loved the almost invulnerableness to fire. that is ridiculous