The Tragic Case of the Tubercular Twins

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 288

  • @ForgottenLives
    @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +22

    👒🔍 Download June’s Journey for free now using my link: woo.ga/ggy7x0fj

    • @andycortes9617
      @andycortes9617 Рік тому +5

      Congrats on your sponsorship of today!! I love that game!!! I just started playing it thanks to you and it’s really fun!!

    • @ElKE-j9g
      @ElKE-j9g Рік тому +4

      This is a great Sponsor! Congratulations 👏 I downloaded June's journey about a year ago, with your recommendation, of course. Thank you FLives

    • @jessgunn6639
      @jessgunn6639 Рік тому

      there was an out break of malaria in cork in the early 1900`s back then in ireland and england you would get out breaks in very warm damp summers , the use of ddt is the main reason we don`t really get malaria mosquitos in ireland and britain anymore

  • @nanettejurgensen4451
    @nanettejurgensen4451 Рік тому +214

    Actually, tuberculosis is still pretty active around the world. Just in British Columbia last year there were 300 active cases. I haven't done researched anywhere else but was so surprised to find out how active it still was.

    • @NatureLover-62
      @NatureLover-62 Рік тому +35

      How surprising!! This video also highlights how tremendously important it is for immunizations and vaccinations as well!! We no longer suffer from polio or the measles but that tide has shifted in the last two years and measles is making a come back. They don’t recommend immunizations for fun but for the preservation of life.

    • @margaretkerr4591
      @margaretkerr4591 Рік тому

      It has been rumoured that T.B. and scarlet fever 🥵 are on the rise in the U.K.

    • @FUNKY_BUTTLOVIN
      @FUNKY_BUTTLOVIN Рік тому +23

      I was a Navy Corpsman and there are tons of Filipinos in the Navy, because of a Naval presence in their country, and a fast track to citizenship etc for Filipinos who enlist.
      Tons of Filipinos would have a reaction to that TB test, you know the test where a tiny bit of dead TB or whatever is injected in the forearm, then a day or two or whatever later they look at the site and measure the reaction, if any, in terms of how many millimeters it swells.
      But yeah, maybe half of the Filipinos would have an extreme reaction, because of prior exposure to tuberculosis, even if it didn't cause an actual infection. It's wild how much a positive reaction swells, 65mm etc, they often get a great big old goose egg from it

    • @robertzaborowski4656
      @robertzaborowski4656 Рік тому +12

      They are saying down at the southern border it's not uncommon among those from South America.....t.b. I mean

    • @monkeygraborange
      @monkeygraborange Рік тому

      America will soon rediscover the joys of communicable diseases we had once eradicated, thanks to this shaministration’s refusal to secure our borders.

  • @angierucinski5694
    @angierucinski5694 Рік тому +98

    Thank you for this beautiful broadcast. At the time of May's passing, TB was viewed as "A Poor Peoples'" disease and before the advent of antibiotics was a real killer of Rich and Poor. Even The Lovely Vivien Leigh passed with TB.

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +4

      Thanks for watching!

    • @heidibee501
      @heidibee501 Рік тому +7

      I did not know about Vivien Leigh. I know it was under control in the fifties when l had it. But maybe she had comorbidities.

    • @suzannehall5200
      @suzannehall5200 Рік тому

      Many famous people of the early to mid 20th century died from it including George Orwell, Maria Callas and Anna Pavlova.

    • @D38401
      @D38401 Рік тому +3

      ​@@heidibee501I read she got it from her travels. Also she didn't take care of herself. Other than being a alcoholic. We now know she was most likely bipolar.

    • @jennifers.3818
      @jennifers.3818 11 місяців тому +2

      My grandmother's mother passed away at 28yrs old of tuberculosis, when she was 5 and her little sister was only 8months old. She has a picture of her and her baby sis sitting on their mother, on her bed, when she was sick. She passed away about a week after the pic was taken. I was shocked when I found out she was actively sick w tuberculosis when the pic was taken, the babies sitting on her! She said she wasn't sure if they knew it was so contagious through air, which surprises me. This would've been about 1932

  • @jennifers.3818
    @jennifers.3818 11 місяців тому +4

    My grandmother's mother passed away at 28yrs old of tuberculosis, when she was 5 and her little sister was only 8months old. She has a picture of her and her baby sis sitting on their mother, on her bed, when she was sick. She passed away about a week after the pic was taken. I was shocked when I found out she was actively sick w tuberculosis when the pic was taken, the babies sitting on her! She said she wasn't sure if they knew it was so contagious through air, which surprises me. This would've been about 1932

  • @jinx17
    @jinx17 Рік тому +57

    my great grandma was a carrier for tuberculosis. she lived to 88 years old, but she did struggle with bronchitis every year. i grew up around her every day, and when i became a nurse i had to be tested for tuberculosis every so often (as did the rest of the staff). i think that's a rule in a lot of healthcare professions. i was always negative luckily because she was only a carrier

    • @GwendolynPorter-w6c
      @GwendolynPorter-w6c Рік тому +13

      If great grandma was a carrier u would have to inhale TB germ since it is airborne by coughing. Carriers of certain illnesses make other people sick not themselves. One reason u probably did not get sick was u were not around her when she was coughing. Here in NYC if u test positive for TB u take a chest x-ray and the medication INH for a year. Even with the treatment u have to take a PPD (TB test) every year. If u have been exposed ur PPD will have a positive result meaning eventhough u have been treated. U were just lucky u were not exposed

    • @jinx17
      @jinx17 Рік тому

      possibly, although it was always explained to me as since she didnt have active TB that's why it didnt spread, it was latent@@GwendolynPorter-w6c

    • @tonywhite2596
      @tonywhite2596 Рік тому +1

      My dad was also a carrier of TV but none of us ever got it

    • @sarahy1680
      @sarahy1680 Рік тому +1

      My nephew is entering a nursing program and one of the many tests and certifications he must have before starting is a current negative TB test.
      Get your vaccine shots, folks!

    • @kellyoneill-hinckley2955
      @kellyoneill-hinckley2955 Рік тому

      Teachers have tone tested often as well

  • @kathrynsmith3417
    @kathrynsmith3417 Рік тому +39

    Thank you for posting these historical explorations into forgotten lives. You have an excellent voice, good presence.

  • @patriciahayes2664
    @patriciahayes2664 Рік тому +9

    2:36 - What a beautiful sketch of those two girls!

  • @lindamorrison4285
    @lindamorrison4285 Рік тому +24

    How sad they were very beautiful. Thanks for this interesting but tragic story 🙏

  • @Mattostar-z2d
    @Mattostar-z2d Рік тому +23

    Thank you, Forgotten Lives for publishing another spectacular video. I was hoping for something interesting to watch as I chill out in my bedroom. Tuberculosis sounds like an awful disease to catch.

    • @LotusStitchandSketch
      @LotusStitchandSketch Рік тому +9

      Those poor girls! Tuberculosis really is a horrible way to go. It starts in the lungs gradually weakening the person's ability to breathe properly, and then eventually the other organs start shutting down because as it becomes harder and harder to breathe oxygen can't circulate in the blood. So as the blood cells gradually die off the major organs shut down since they can't get enough oxygen rich blood. This is what causes the "consumption" of the body. The worse it gets the more they waste away until they finally die. Was even blamed at different times throughout history for Vampires

    • @Mattostar-z2d
      @Mattostar-z2d Рік тому +4

      @@LotusStitchandSketch Goodness, this is a terrible disease to catch. Without proper treatment it's truly a death sentence. Sadly, from the comments on here it's still rather active today. ☹️

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +4

      Thanks for all the support !!

    • @Mattostar-z2d
      @Mattostar-z2d Рік тому +1

      @@ForgottenLives You're welcome Forgotten Lives. It wonderful to support you.

    • @LotusStitchandSketch
      @LotusStitchandSketch Рік тому

      @@Mattostar-z2d absolutely. People say the plague was an awful way to go but I'd still rather die from it than have TB. TB can sometimes take years to get to that point. At least the plague is a much quicker death, most people died within a few days to a week of becoming infected with it. Nowadays thank the Gods there is a test you can take to see if you have it and if you do have it there's medication for it. what's more annoying now is that you can sometimes have it but have it be dormant and not have the symptoms one day and then all of a sudden have it activate. It's recommended by the CDC that people are tested every 4 years.

  • @elvenkind6072
    @elvenkind6072 Рік тому +9

    7:35 It's shocking to imagine that people ridiculed this painting, "Syk Pike" ("Sick Girl") when the artist, Edward Munch, first had it exhibited in the period when Impressionism blossomed in France. The main focus was on the hand of the girl, that was termed to look like "fish pudding", a Norwegian dish I've never had any taste for, perhaps for being a fan of Munch in my early teens. Anyway: That they missed the whole atmosphere in the picture, the mother wasting away in sorrow, and the girl in illness.
    You got yourself a new subscriber by the way. Very good content, and you have such a pleasant voice to serve as a narrator of these stories, very good pronunciation of many European languages. I only noticed one small error in it all, pronouncing "scourge" (skörje) as "scrounge" (skranj), two very different things. 🙂
    Thank you, from Alv, Norway

    • @cw4608
      @cw4608 11 місяців тому

      I stayed at a bed and breakfast in Ireland and the first thing I saw was “The Scream” as I walked in the front door. It was a bit unsettling.

  • @sbalsamo410
    @sbalsamo410 Рік тому +16

    I just wanted to say that I’ve been listening for a while now and I really enjoy your channel (I listen). I appreciate the simplicity and dignity of your story telling and for me it’s a great combination of history and what I’d almost consider pop culture. Random - I live in the US. I was tested for TB in 1983 when I contracted a cough that wouldn’t go away. I was young and wasn’t living a very healthy lifestyle. (I had fun though.) I was sent for testing to a TB Sanitorium just outside Chicago. I didn’t have TB. Eventually, the cough just went away.
    Bonus: For anyone from Illinois, the sanitorium, which might be gone, was near the Leaning Tower of Niles.

    • @scholbe
      @scholbe 11 місяців тому +1

      I'm from Illinois and never heard of either. Crazy hidden histories we have in the states.

  • @Geoplanetjane
    @Geoplanetjane Рік тому +38

    Yes, TB is the leading cause of death is many poor counties. The biggest problem with TB is that there are strains of the bacteria that are nearly or completely resistent to antibiotics.

    • @AshleyMartin-f3x
      @AshleyMartin-f3x Рік тому +5

      Using and not finishing antibiotics can resistance

    • @aftersexhighfives
      @aftersexhighfives Рік тому +1

      Yeah I was confused about this too. It is not that the virus is better than the antibiotics that we have. It's that you have trained it. How to be better within your body. Because you never finish your rounds of antibiotics as prescribed. And for a long time, antibiotics were given for everything because it was thought that it wasn't dangerous and people don't really listen when you won't give them something for their virus. But viruses don't last as long, typically, So people rarely finish their antibiotics.
      As well as a culture of thinking that it didn't matter if you did sure didn't finish them once you start feeling better.
      These viruses are not anymore or less stronger. Your body you individually are more compromised because of your failure to complete your antibiotics full round over your lifetime.
      But the way the information is given. You would think that we're creating new viruses that can go from person to person.
      It is more that we systemically have had a problem with handing out antibiotics like candy and then not finishing them. I think it really affects those born before 2000.
      They have been doing a lot of marketing to get the word out about the dangers of not completing your antibiotic rounds now that I don't think Zoomers and Gen Alpha look at antibiotics as everybody before them did. They are well aware of the danger everybody else was not aware of until it became a common problem that therapies that should work, aren't for a lot of ppl. Antibiotics were handed out like candy, they thought it was the same as a sugar pill for those who didn't really need it.
      They were very wrong.

    • @StonedtotheBones13
      @StonedtotheBones13 6 місяців тому

      @@AshleyMartin-f3x no, having antibiotics inaccessible so ppl can't finish them causes resistance

  • @charlyshay1013
    @charlyshay1013 Рік тому +11

    Such beautiful pictures accompanying this story

  • @ojeda5577
    @ojeda5577 Рік тому +7

    I carry tuberculosis but itll never be active. I took meds for like 2 years and now im good. Its common around the world

  • @joanspragg9395
    @joanspragg9395 11 місяців тому +2

    Hi my Aunt had TB and had to spend 15yrs in a hospital only being visited once a month. It was awful for her. X

  • @debbralehrman5957
    @debbralehrman5957 Рік тому +6

    So sad😢 The immunization shots for Tuberculosis were one of the first ones I remember getting. Thanks for the video👍🏼

  • @patriciahayes2664
    @patriciahayes2664 Рік тому +11

    5:40 - These two young ladies were so beautiful. What a tragedy for them to die so young.

  • @juliapalmer2344
    @juliapalmer2344 Рік тому +8

    I saw this before getting ready for bed. I had to stay up to watch your marvelous video before going to sleep. I love your work. You are so talented ☮️💚 in Fleming , NJ Tiffany’s has stained glass windows on display at a glass museum there.

  • @thewitt55
    @thewitt55 Рік тому +76

    Your ability to correctly pronounce languages is remarkable and much appreciated. I frequently cringe while watching UA-cam channels where pronunciation is atrocious. And AI narration is often no better. Another wonderful history!

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +5

      Thank you for your kind words!

    • @nelliesfarm8473
      @nelliesfarm8473 Рік тому +5

      He didn't pronounce the word " heiress" correctly

    • @thefirm4606
      @thefirm4606 Рік тому +11

      @@nelliesfarm8473maybe that’s not the way it’s pronounced in the Bible Belt but over here in England it’s perfectly pronounced

    • @colorbugoriginals4457
      @colorbugoriginals4457 Рік тому +1

      @@nelliesfarm8473he did.

    • @morgainnejade
      @morgainnejade Рік тому +2

      Those kinds of channels you're speaking of boil down to being illiterate. Standards of literacy have been in a headlong free fall most drastically for about the last ten years, it seems to me. While I'd say Forgotten Lives presents as somewhat refreshingly literate, there's a bit of room for improvement. I noticed just a few words that were a little off (& one of them could have been "heiress" as mentioned in other replies here, I don't remember, but still nothing to get in a twist about, & likely due to differences between British & American English) but the only word I really noticed as being an egregious mis-pronunciation was FL saying "scrowge" instead of "scourge" while reading, closer to the end of the video. Not enough to really take anything away from the overall quality of the video, which was well presented & an interesting story, but like I said, there's room for improvement.

  • @deedragongirl
    @deedragongirl Рік тому +20

    Reminds me of the Siamese twins, Chang and Eng! Would love to see Forgotten Lives cover Chang and Eng one day!

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +4

      For sure!

    • @elizabethclaiborne6461
      @elizabethclaiborne6461 11 місяців тому

      Chang and Eng are not forgotten. There’s a ton of documentaries on them. They’re still at the edges of pop culture consciousness.

  • @annabelleb.8096
    @annabelleb.8096 Рік тому +6

    That stained glass window is so beautiful! How awful Consuelo also lost her best friend at such a sad time. I hope they reconciled later.

  • @EVEE_Rose-3
    @EVEE_Rose-3 Рік тому +7

    I love your voice. You sure know how to tell a story. Sad that today (01/10/24) is the 124th anniversary of Nell’s death. Tuberculosis or any illness doesn’t discriminate against wealth. Their actual names where Lady Jacqueline Mary “May” Alva Montague and Lady Alice Eleanor “Nell” Louise Montagu. This was a sad story. I still enjoyed learning about their lives during those times. I love the Victorian era. Thank you.

  • @blazefairchild465
    @blazefairchild465 Рік тому +18

    A few years ago TB and HepC were very prevalent in US prisons, we were warned about public transportation in cities like Philadelphia where TB was picking up as well. It’s just best to wear a mask if you are going to be in crowds now the Covid is going around again in my area I had it in Dec. it was mild, a week long sick but a few lingering problems. I had all my shots + boosters Thank goodness.

    • @nelliesfarm8473
      @nelliesfarm8473 Рік тому

      Those regular surgical masks do nothing...tests proved it. You need a better mask...the kind painters use

    • @marciaspiegel5280
      @marciaspiegel5280 Рік тому +1

      It was mild for you due to boosters.

    • @blazefairchild465
      @blazefairchild465 Рік тому +2

      @@marciaspiegel5280 yes indeed. I serious lung issues & was told I could die if I got any lung related infections so I have gotten all shots possible.

  • @dcnunez100
    @dcnunez100 Рік тому +5

    I absolutely love June's Journey! Started playing back when the pandemic hit. What a delight to see you mention the game in your video 🥰🥰🥰

  • @elisegauvin8262
    @elisegauvin8262 Рік тому +30

    I have a suggestion for you: Alys Robi. It's a tragic story just the way you like it: from rags to rich and famous to botched lobotomy!

  • @vladimiramiller3738
    @vladimiramiller3738 Рік тому +16

    Thank you for your work!❤

  • @michelepruitt3145
    @michelepruitt3145 Рік тому +14

    Love your Videos! ❤ Great work FL! 👻🐾🙏✌️

  • @neoandersonwick3263
    @neoandersonwick3263 Рік тому +6

    Amazing channel should have a series on 📺 as I would tune 🎶 in daily or weekly

  • @princ3ssangéli
    @princ3ssangéli Рік тому +22

    I live for this channel! Absolutely love your content! ❤❤

    • @mauricedavis2160
      @mauricedavis2160 Рік тому +3

      You and I both my friend, and for a reason, we get it!!!🙏😢

  • @TheWhore2culture
    @TheWhore2culture Рік тому +4

    Fascinating as always,the window is very beautiful & the only stained glass window by Tiffany in England. Though dreadfully short,their lifestyle was as near to "jet-set"/"celebrity" as it was possible in those days,the logistics of "coming out" in both NYC & London involving transatlantic travel,in great style. I have a scrapbook from a great aunt born around the same time,who lived a similar lifestyle, to see not just photos, but,menu's dance cards,dress designs etc really brings an extra dimension to stories like yours which are so well researched & illustrated. Thank you for the time & effort,it's much appreciated. Wishing you&yours the very best & a Very Happy New Year.

  • @newenglandcoast7121
    @newenglandcoast7121 8 місяців тому +1

    You do a wonderful job on your videos! You English is excellent, and your voice is pleasant; your accent is charming.

  • @margueritedilosa2944
    @margueritedilosa2944 Рік тому +7

    I viewed this on the 10th of January , its nice to think they have been remembered especially in Tiffany design in a stain-glass window but we are more than a “ pretty face” !

  • @Hava744
    @Hava744 Рік тому +3

    Beautiful girls , how sad . I am binge watching forgotten lives. It’s better than anything on television. In Uk .

  • @m.f.richardson1602
    @m.f.richardson1602 Рік тому +8

    Always interesting
    Thank you

  • @kristinmoreno9203
    @kristinmoreno9203 Рік тому +8

    Excellent Video, as Always! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

  • @ElKE-j9g
    @ElKE-j9g Рік тому +8

    Thank you for this very informative history of the past. Very sad though. You are really good with your knowledge and narration. Keep it up your great work. Ps: Sorry i was sleeping when you upload the video!

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +1

      Thanks again! Hope you are well!

    • @ElKE-j9g
      @ElKE-j9g Рік тому +1

      @@ForgottenLives
      You are welcome! I am trying to do my best, almost there. 🙏You!

  • @SportyOtterPop
    @SportyOtterPop Рік тому +6

    Subscribed! I have been enjoying the unique aspect of the stories you share, and the very mellow presentation style you have, for someone so young! Cheers, and here's to continued interesting topics, so strongly featuring women's history!

  • @sonyawoodrow9675
    @sonyawoodrow9675 Рік тому +4

    Wow, I live in Dunedin New Zealand the Otago daily times is our newspaper and today is 10 th January

  • @JustKrista50
    @JustKrista50 Рік тому +9

    The USA has TB still. If you work in a hospital, it's one of those diseases that you constantly worry about. Its not as deadly as it once was, but can still be for people that are immune compromised, like cancer, asthma, elderly and the young.

    • @JaRule6
      @JaRule6 8 місяців тому +2

      One of the many reasons that I still wear a face mask when I go into a hospital setting. 🤘

    • @Wmuthoni
      @Wmuthoni 4 місяці тому +1

      It was said that at one point T.B was about to be phased out similarly to small pox but that all changed due to antibiotic resistance strains that began to occur more often due to misuse of antibiotics over the years. Also the advent of HIV/AIDS led to a significant increase of cases as an opportunistic disease for the immunocompromised.

    • @drac2you816
      @drac2you816 14 днів тому

      ​@@WmuthoniDon't forget all the illegals who are coming to the country from places that do not require immunization. Sad.

  • @angelsinger4574
    @angelsinger4574 Рік тому +5

    I don’t know if y’all take suggestions, but I just watched this and then re-watched your excellent video on the Mitford Sisters. I was wondering if you might want to do another sister video? I have always been interested in the history of entertainment, and the Seven Sutherland Sisters of sideshow fame have always peaked my interest. Unfortunately, the few videos I have found on UA-cam thus far are short and not the sort of in-depth biographical videos you do on this channel. These ladies have truly become forgotten, and I think they deserve better.

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +1

      I always take suggestions! Thanks for watching and I have already covered them on the channel!

  • @karenfitzpatrick6256
    @karenfitzpatrick6256 Рік тому +27

    There are many communities in Africa where TB is still rampant. Often infecting whole families. With mutations spreading that are extremely resistant strains. Traditional antibiotics don't work at all and the medicines they must try have such debilitating side effects many sufferers can't tolerate them. The death toll is high. Many who die are very young.TB remains a scourage on humanity.

    • @georgiaamanatides4207
      @georgiaamanatides4207 Рік тому

      And coming to a town and city near by in the USA thanks to unvetted "migration".

    • @karenfitzpatrick6256
      @karenfitzpatrick6256 Рік тому

      @@georgiaamanatides4207 People from places with high communicable disease are carefully screened before getting on a plane. It would be akmost impossible for someone with active TB to get a passport. And would not be allowed on a plane.
      The only person I've heard of, years ago, who did fly with TB was not from Africa. He was identified as ill and the plane did not land in the US. All passengers and crew were checked and quarantined. No one got sick
      The people of the villages I mentioned live in extreme poverty and are very isolated. Far from the modern cites. They are too sick to work or to travel. All they have are their families. And their loved ones are there. They have no reason or means to come here. Relax.

    • @gnostic268
      @gnostic268 Рік тому

      ​@@georgiaamanatides4207That's bull. Tourism is equally responsible for spreading disease. It was early Europeans who brought diseases to Native Indigenous people around the world including North America. You're being an historical revisionist due to your obvious racism tho'

  • @lumia57
    @lumia57 Рік тому +4

    My Dad was actually born with TB.. His mother blame him for having it!... I was seven when Dad had a massive operation to remove his left lung.. I was screened for years myself unfortunately I had Covid and have been left with long Covid effects my lungs too ...

  • @ellaeadig263
    @ellaeadig263 Рік тому +2

    This is so sad. Consuelo's life was terrible enough, and on top of that she lost both of her daughters so young.

  • @heidibee501
    @heidibee501 Рік тому +7

    Tubercle bacilli are quite contagious. People with weak immune systems are more susceptible. I had it many years ago. I was thirteen years old but l looked seven. My mother came from a small German town in Romania where TB was still a death sentence. I was sent to a sanitarium. The doctor told me if l ate well (until then l was a very reluctant eater) l would be out in 2 years. I ate with great gusto and was out in 7 months. The other patients got 26 pills a day and a (weekly) streptomycin shot. I only got pills. That was over 70 years ago. I have a scarred lung, but l never had a relapse and l breezed through Cov..d, no injection required.

  • @cadillacdeville5828
    @cadillacdeville5828 Рік тому +9

    I truly enjoy your channel ❤

  • @meganalderton9273
    @meganalderton9273 Рік тому +3

    I thoroughly enjoy these educational and entertaining stories, especially before bed. They help me unwind. I work in a nursing home and a TB test is required before employees can start working!

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому

      Thanks and watching! And interesting to know!

    • @tabithamashburn8786
      @tabithamashburn8786 8 місяців тому

      My grandfather worked as a orderly at a state hospital on Long Island. Three men came on his ward, they had TB. Normally patients were screened for TB but these three went on Grandpa’s ward. Grandpa came down with a mild case of TB and stayed at home recuperating, up to a year.

  • @moondancer4660
    @moondancer4660 Рік тому +11

    Thanks for the video and for the work you had to put in it.😊

  • @triciamills309
    @triciamills309 9 місяців тому +1

    Your research and attention to detail really shine through in your videos. Plus you present each case with dignity and empathy. I will also be subscribing to your other channel asap. I was unaware of it thanks to YT and the dodgy algorithms.👍💯🤩🥇🎬📱💻📚✒🎤👑

  • @fatjackjack5416
    @fatjackjack5416 Рік тому +1

    Love your videos bud, they are great to relax to. Your voice could melt ice..

  • @richardw3470
    @richardw3470 Рік тому +3

    My gr-grandfather died of consumption contracted at the World Exposition in Chicago (I think it was) in the 1890s. A lot of people went home with it and caused it to be spread thruout their home areas. My aunt had it in the 1940s and was very concerned that it was having a resurgence in the early 2000s. So many of the women hospitalized with her did not survive it. I had to be tested when I went into a nursing home for a short stay. Very dangerous disease still. We've become blase about it.

  • @carolmanning8367
    @carolmanning8367 Рік тому +3

    Thank you, my mother 99 years young talks of family members who died of t.b. im australia & in the early 1960's we had eradicated t.b. through t.b. clinics.they were very pretty young girls.

  • @Kathryn-f1h
    @Kathryn-f1h 9 днів тому

    I am really enjoying your channel. I love the content, and I especially love your delivery and your accent.

  • @susanhayes4374
    @susanhayes4374 Рік тому +1

    What a wonderful story teller you are. I enjoy your tales very much.

  • @cherylbrooks7005
    @cherylbrooks7005 Рік тому +5

    Excellent as usual 😊

  • @giaatta9303
    @giaatta9303 Рік тому +2

    Interesting as always. Thank you

  • @WilloWindFarms
    @WilloWindFarms Рік тому +2

    Super interesting 😊

  • @Stopthismadnessnow-t4l
    @Stopthismadnessnow-t4l Рік тому +1

    I just love your work and choice of subjects. Thank you!!

  • @kimberlypatton205
    @kimberlypatton205 Рік тому +2

    My dear! Exceptional and wonderful as always! But equally as sad and tragic! I love your channel so much!
    If I may offer also , a small suggestion ( not at all criticism) as a small help to you in the future.. the word”scourge” is a strange one to say, but it rhymes with “George”…❤

  • @karenjames953
    @karenjames953 11 місяців тому +1

    So very sad.
    Those girls were so beautiful.
    A horrible shame.

  • @linneahite7493
    @linneahite7493 Рік тому +2

    So sad, they seemed to have it all. It always saddens me to see those so young pass before having a chance to live to experience so many of life's blessings. It also breaks my heart for the parents having to bury their children. It doesn't matter if it was more common back then, the pain was just as great to them I am sure.

  • @marygrummer9189
    @marygrummer9189 Рік тому +5

    How sad.

  • @latikireese1219
    @latikireese1219 Рік тому +4

    I was diagnosed with TB in 1994.

  • @jacqui.amelie
    @jacqui.amelie Рік тому +1

    Another great video FL

  • @laurac8659
    @laurac8659 Рік тому +4

    She was beautiful, so tragic 😢

  • @alexandria2243
    @alexandria2243 8 місяців тому +1

    My mom had TB and had to have a mass in her lung taken out. She's american, it's not common here or in the west anymore, but she works in healthcare, which is likely how she got it.

  • @debraturner4559
    @debraturner4559 Рік тому +3

    I wonder why only some members of a family and not others caught TB? Often a wife might die of it, but the husband didn't catch it. Or a sister but not their siblings. What kept other members of a family from catching the disease? Perhaps only a doctor who specializes in TB could explain it.

  • @Charlotte66666
    @Charlotte66666 Рік тому +5

    Wonderful content 😊

  • @tedenray20
    @tedenray20 Рік тому +1

    I enjoy your channel very much!

  • @LadyAnyaRose
    @LadyAnyaRose Рік тому +2

    I had tuberculosis when I was about 6 or 7. It sucked.

  • @ShastaTravels
    @ShastaTravels Рік тому +8

    I have never heard that about Alva. Alva even went on to name her own daughter Consuelo after her best friend. Consuelo Yznaga slept with Prince Edward not William Vanderbilt.

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +5

      Her daughter Consuelo was born in 1877 so a long time before they fell out!

    • @JaRule6
      @JaRule6 8 місяців тому

      There is a really good book out there about the relationship between Alva and her daughter Consuela written by Amanda Mackenzie Stuart

  • @bisibisbi
    @bisibisbi 11 місяців тому +2

    Poor girls. A friend of mine died from Corona only weeks before the vaccination was released.

    • @drac2you816
      @drac2you816 14 днів тому +1

      I'm sorry to hear. May your fond memories of your friend help you navigate you through your grief. My late husband died (not from covid) one week before the first USA requested self-quarantine in 3/2020.

  • @theoceandragonfly
    @theoceandragonfly Рік тому +2

    That really is tragic.

  • @janetlitster1046
    @janetlitster1046 11 місяців тому +2

    My great grandfather died of tuberculosis in 1914 😢

  • @jacquelinemiller6206
    @jacquelinemiller6206 Рік тому +1

    Thank you. ❤

  • @JPsMum
    @JPsMum 7 місяців тому +4

    Such very beautiful girls, who knows what effect they might have had on the British Aristocracy had they not died so tragically young.

  • @TheFinalBathAmber
    @TheFinalBathAmber Рік тому +1

    Very well done video

  • @thefirm4606
    @thefirm4606 Рік тому +1

    On form as usual sir! ❤

  • @megs4193
    @megs4193 5 місяців тому

    Sad but beautifully told as always 😊👍🐨🇦🇺.

  • @EmelyPhan
    @EmelyPhan Рік тому +1

    Smooth transition into the ad

  • @lovethejabberwocky2287
    @lovethejabberwocky2287 11 місяців тому

    Always a pleasure ❤

  • @nicholashodgkinson2822
    @nicholashodgkinson2822 Рік тому +1

    I was very surprised to come across this video these two girls are my x4 great aunts and the 8th duke is my great great great grandfather. I have pictures of their coffins as well the older daughter is in a rather elaborate coffin.

  • @jujubees5855
    @jujubees5855 11 місяців тому +1

    I had TB in 2017 and a scare last year. I live in the border state of Texas.

  • @debbie5876
    @debbie5876 Рік тому +14

    As an American, it's hard for me to understand why it seems the dukes didn't have jobs. It appears they were just playboys. No wonder they started losing their money and had to marry rich American daughters.

    • @Geoplanetjane
      @Geoplanetjane Рік тому +10

      Most of them did not have jobs, per se. Instead, their income was supposed to come from their estates, included were farms, forests, manual factories. Far too frequently, the tasks involved were simply beyond the abilities of the nobles involved. Plus, many were deeply in debt.

    • @nicolad8822
      @nicolad8822 Рік тому +5

      The gilded age American Princes and Princesses were no different. Living off Grandpa Railroad’s trust fund?

    • @susannechinn647
      @susannechinn647 Рік тому +1

      Dukes, did have jobs, as members of parliament in the House of Lords. But many wasted their income.

    • @JaRule6
      @JaRule6 8 місяців тому

      You probably also don't know that a lot of the descendants of Cornelius Vanderbilt didn't have jobs either. That's why the money dwindled. Most rich people don't like to work. Actually most people don't like to work but if you're rich you don't have to work 🤔

  • @zero_bs_tolerance8646
    @zero_bs_tolerance8646 Рік тому +1

    Thank you.

  • @littlemissliv100
    @littlemissliv100 Рік тому +1

    Your voice is so soothing and melodic. I can’t place your accent, where are you from originally?

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому

      Thanks! England! I have a video on ny mixed ancestry on my Ida wood video if you are interested!

  • @helennewell9932
    @helennewell9932 11 місяців тому +1

    TB is rampant in London around Hayes and Ealing. Its brought over from India

  • @thewitt55
    @thewitt55 Рік тому +11

    If the story of Artus Van Briggle hasn't already been suggested to you, you might want to take a look at this Art Nouveau ceramist (who also died of tuberculosis at a young age.)

  • @rodolfoayalajr.8589
    @rodolfoayalajr.8589 Рік тому +2

    Thank you for this educational video. May they both Rip Amen 🙏.🇺🇸🇵🇷🙏.

  • @carag2567
    @carag2567 Рік тому +12

    Was it intended that you posted this on the anniversary (eve, depending on where in the world one is watching) of Nell's death? Or is it entirely coincidental?

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому +2

      It was a actually a coincidence, I didn't realize until your comment!

  • @tb22k
    @tb22k Рік тому +1

    ❤thank you

  • @kippytx
    @kippytx Рік тому +1

    Very interesting

  • @sansnom508
    @sansnom508 Рік тому +2

    Tuberculosis rates have been on the rise for several years in Nunavut in northern Canada, particularly affecting the indigenous population. For decades indigenous children with tuberculosis were torn from their families and communities and sent hundreds of miles south for medical treatment. Many of those children never returned home and their families were told nothing, many died, some were adopted out to white families.

  • @shirleycoles3652
    @shirleycoles3652 Рік тому +2

    Tb is still rife in South Africa.😢😢

  • @hablin1
    @hablin1 Рік тому +3

    A fun fact the castle they lived in NIreland is home to Tayto Crisp factory where they make snacks and crisps I’ve been their once with my school as a girl it seemed very small for such a prestigious family used to wealth 🥰

    • @ForgottenLives
      @ForgottenLives  Рік тому

      Indeed!

    • @nelliesfarm8473
      @nelliesfarm8473 Рік тому +1

      Crisps lol sounds so silly. In america we call them chips

    • @nicolad8822
      @nicolad8822 Рік тому +2

      ⁠@@nelliesfarm8473Chips lol sounds so silly. In Britain and Ireland we call them crisps.

    • @binathere2574
      @binathere2574 Рік тому +1

      Many castles in Europe are small

  • @moomama217
    @moomama217 13 днів тому

    Sad but very interesting.

  • @carlamarlene2927
    @carlamarlene2927 11 місяців тому

    My twin boys were extremely ill(RSV) when they were not quite 6mos old. One was diagnosed with pneumonia while the other was not even tested. I bet the other had it for the fact I nursed them both and I did not sterilize my breasts between

  • @JaRule6
    @JaRule6 8 місяців тому

    It took me a minute but I realized that the Consuela in the story is the best friend of Alva Vanderbilt. I think it's kind of interesting that all those name was used as a middle name of one of Consuelo's daughters. Whereas Alva named her daughter Consuela 🤔

  • @blackwidowspider9852
    @blackwidowspider9852 Рік тому +1

    I had antibodies in my body against tuberculosis but the X-ray showed I had clean lungs I never got the disease although I was exposed to it and develop protective antibodies I lived in the Philippines as a child and I'm from New York I found out as a young adult by the test you get in your arm I reacted to it But the X-ray showed the lungs were clean further test proved I only had antibodiesI am Really blessed it's It's a deadly disease even now The medicines don't hardly work and they're so old

    • @drac2you816
      @drac2you816 14 днів тому

      Wow, hard to believe it's still so prevalent, how lucky that your immune system was able to protect you from this disease that consumes one from the inside out! Folks like you are what is needed to develop a vaccine! That makes you priceless 😌.

  • @genevabrantner365
    @genevabrantner365 11 місяців тому +1

    TB is still on the rise here in the US.

  • @dollinterests8661
    @dollinterests8661 4 місяці тому

    My brother died from TB a few months ago