One of the greatest Star Wars fanfics I ever read. Not only is Thrawn a Hero, he’s also even more brilliant and in my opinion Prefect story written in this. Saving Anakin, and seeing him as his first true friend was an amazing addition, also not viewing the Jedi like the rest of the galaxy, but hero’s and very important Allies and some as friends
in truth thrown has no friends , because his ]dependency on facts keeps him from making them, i wouldn't be surprised if he saw them as allies because of the fact that they were allies
I've watched this several times and I always love how Sun Tzu quotes were put in Thrawn's mouth. If anyone embodied Sun Tzu, it would be Thrawn. This should have been a long running series!
@@FantasyFolkloreI'd think it would be interesting to have both the Grysk and the Vong ( _simply known as just "Vong" instead of "Yuuzhan Vong"_ ) both in Canon as two separate - yet somewhat similar - species.
PART 1 RECAP Grand Admiral Thrawn, a blue-skinned Chiss from the Chiss Ascendancy, is sent to find allies against the threatening Grysk. He encounters Jedi Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi, leading to a meeting with Chancellor Palpatine in Coruscant. Thrawn offers his strategic prowess to help the Republic in the Clone Wars. After notable achievements in battle, especially alongside Anakin, Thrawn is promoted to Admiral. However, tension arises with Jedi General Pong Krell, culminating in the Umbara campaign. When Krell sabotages a mission by turning clones against each other, Thrawn strategically captures him. Krell reveals a foreseen rise of a new power post-Clone Wars. This revelation leads Thrawn to believe that an unseen force is driving the war. Determined to ensure the Republic's victory to prevent this predicted new order, Thrawn continues his strategic involvement, ever vigilant of the shadow force Krell hinted at. Thrawn, after carefully piecing together the puzzle, determines that Chancellor Palpatine is Darth Sidious, the Sith Lord behind the Clone Wars. Using evidence and logical deduction, he confronts Palpatine in front of several influential senators and Jedi. As Thrawn reveals the depth of Palpatine’s treachery, the Sith Lord tries to escape, resulting in a confrontation with the Jedi. The Sith Lord is eventually captured with the help of Jedi Masters, effectively ending the Clone War. Anakin Skywalker's secret marriage to Padmé Amidala is exposed during Thrawn's revelation, leading to a debate among the Jedi about his continued membership in the Order. However, Thrawn and Obi-Wan Kenobi vouch for Anakin, referencing his role in Sidious' capture and historical precedents like Revan, ensuring Anakin's place in the Jedi Order. Thrawn is heralded as a hero of the Republic, receiving a prestigious medal and an offer of a position in the new Chancellor Organa's bureaucratic council. Acknowledging the debt the galaxy owes him, Chancellor Organa assures Thrawn of any support he might need in the future. Seizing this opportunity, Thrawn seeks permission to return to his home in the Unknown Regions. Upon arrival, he finds the Chiss Ascendancy on the brink of war with the aggressive Grysk. Armed with the assurance of support from the Republic, Thrawn convinces the Chiss ruling families to form an alliance with the galactic superpower to fend off their common enemy and Saganu, one of the Aristrocra leaders of the Chiss goes with Thrawn to Coruscant.
Some of your best work! Part 2 was particularly awesome, well thought out, shows Thrawn's brilliance, drives up the stakes, pays off with the good feels. Thanks!
What if Thrawn lead the First Order? What if Hera Syndulla and Han Solo fell in Love? What if Aura Sing killed Padme? What if The Blue Shadow Virus was released? What if the Jedi and Sith Switched? (Sith are Jedi. Jedi are Sith)
I’m gonna put down the two what if’s I have on AO3: 1) what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era 2) what if Jyn Erso survived combined with what if she met and fell in love with Luke Skywalker The High Republic one is done and I’m working on the second one.
Yay a part two. Loved part one. Wish the real Thrawn would work with the New Republic to get rid of the Grysk rather than say FUCK THE CHISS, IMMA RULE LESSER SPACE!
@@InfernosReaperWhat if he had force sensitive allie or allies. I think, that the dark side extremes are rather negative, against his theater, manipulations, cold calculations and pure logic above feelings. I think, he was member of dark třída, probably a psychopat. With the dark side it would be bigger a struggle. But I think, he would be better with amoral, powerfull, wise and rich mentor. Plagueis made Palpatine into Palpatine, no matter the force. But otherwise he would be the same. Without some inspiration, he would be racing in speeders or something. Anyways Palpatine knew about the Sith and wanted to be a Sith already as a youngster, when was searching for Sith texts and similar stuff on the market - long before he met Plagueis. I don't think IT was the force, but that it was his brain searching for something close. He wouldn't be a good boy in any case.
@@WenceslasHolec What "force sensitive" allies could he have that would actually be under his control as just a regular guy with no powers, though? At best, he would just be a puppet in that setup
Ok, so I like it right up to the end. The Mith are already one of the 9 most powerful families in the Chiss Ascendancy. Thrawn was adopted into them by the leader of the family due to his abilities in combat. Read the new canonical books.
Ah shit I did know this but forgot 😭😭 instead, I think I’d have it that the current Mith aristocrac was killed by Plo/Anakin and they offer for Thrawn to take his place. Glad you like it tho thanks for watching!!!
What if, during the Clone Wars, Anakin Skywalker did something similar to Abeloth; he drank from the Font of Power and bathed in the Pool of Knowledge, but, unlike Abeloth, he also sat upon the Throne of Balance? This idea was inspired by the Disney+ series, "Ahsoka".
I think you left out this topic. The skywalkers of the chiss ascendancy. Force-sensitive Chiss navigators who helped the Chiss Ascendancy navigate the dangerous hyperspace conditions present in the Ascendancy's native Unknown Regions of the galaxy. I want to hear a talk about this topic and they losing their force sensitivity by adulthood by master Yoda and Mace Windu with Thrawn and Chiss leaders. EDIT:- I also want to see what would be the expression of Anakin when he knows that an entire section of force sensitives has been named after him
What about a possible part 3. Maybe with the ssi ruu??? Or perhaps a lost tribe of true sith could be the antagonists of the story with the strongest most elite force senstives using beskar with cortosis and sith alchemy to make and equip their own battle armour. Not to mention lightsaber hilts that cannot be cut in half or destroyed by blaster bolts. I really enjoyed this video. So please keep up the good work. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
What if Padme and Anakin were the same age? Perhaps 2 parts where there both 9 or 14 Obviously Padme can’t be a Queen at age 9 so maybe she’s a handmaiden for the queen or a student In learning. Maybe Padme sneaks out the ship and follows qui gon to the dealership where she meets Anakin. They become instantly friends and eventually they both developed a small crush before parting ways for 10 years The other one Anakin is 14 so maybe he’s still a slave but with lots of anger and darkness in him. Maybe he fix’s ships for a living or do small smuggling. Or maybe this time cleig Lars met Shmi when Anakin was 9 so he freed both of them and they live on the outskirts where Anakin and Owen are basically brothers. Padme either meets Anakin in the dealership where he worked on ships or Padme’s ship crashes on the Lars homestead. I would like to know how their story will develop if it’ll take them down the same path. They both still have the same personality, but the maturity it’s on the same level being the same age and all
Then it's probably likely that Luke and Leia are born and raised as Sith since Anakin would be the one giving birth, or likely they'd die due to a miscarriage after Anakin was burned on Mustafar. Very interesting what if
This is technically already canon as thrawn says to ahsoka that he knew her master though it’s unclear if he was referring to anakin during the clone wars or Vader.
Is this a remake of the original because if it is, they may maybe you should make what if qui gon jinn Freed , anakin, and his mother only this time Anakin at the end, survives for his mother, padme, and his children and also other remakes like what if Anakin stayed on mortis only this time the Jedi don’t die, but instead survive and move to mortis to help, Anakin maintain the balance along with other what if remakes
And also what if qui gon jinn became grandmaster what if dooku became supreme Chancellor and what if anakin became Jedi battle master will be the best what ifs you make? out of all of them but if I’m being honest these other what if scenarios that you know where these new ones will be the tip of the iceberg? What if anakin went with Yoda to the wellspring of life what if quinlan vos trained Anakin Skywalker what if the clone army was force sensitive? Or what if Anakin skywalker kill the son with the dagger of Mortis and kept at the end you decide man it’s up to you
of course the entire republic wouldn't have gone there would have still been pockets of rebellion in the outer rim like the empire had a while in canon
What if Maul was tought night magic by Talzin after he was healed? It is possible he is her reeal son..its in him...Im surprised no one never thought of this🤔🤔
Imagine After Thrawn Died in Star Wars Legends all the Chiss Females Intelligence Becomes Far Superior Than Thawn's was and The Imperial Remnant and The Chiss Females of The Empire of The Hand are Allies.
The new republic should have created treaties with independent worlds like Navarro. Nevarro could sell products from its mines to the republic and in turn have protection from pirates.
@@FantasyFolkloreDisney don’t listen to anyone not George, not the old EU writers and not even the fans. It’s a sad truth but atleast Dave is giving us some great Star Wars he’s the last hope.
BRAVO, BRAVO. I can very much applaud all those involved here. I am only about 6 minutes into the production and it is very well told. However, I have a few criticisms. For one, Thrawn sounds... robotic. The dialect is spot on, however the actor's inflections need some work: Occasionally. their voice goes down in pitch when it should go up, up when it should go down, and changes when it should stay neutral. The result is that Thrawn sounds... bored, for lack of a better term. And definitely robotic, as if performed by a speech generator, not a person. Other than that, spot on. So great voice acting, but it needs less robot. This is a fairly common issue for voice actors I hear on various channels though, so not too big of a criticism. The fellow definitely studied the Rebels series and how Thrawn spoke there, so major props to him or her for getting it very, VERY close. Your Palpatine on the other hand? Off. Off, off, WAY off. Literally by a few hundred light years, as Ray's using a voice that would be right at home coming from a Neimoidian like Nute Gunray. Coming from Palpatine, that sort of oily voice is way, WAY off the mark, at least from how he was before the events that rapidly aged him into the wrinkled old man he was during his issuing of Order 66 and the fall of the republic. After the fall though? Definitely go with the oily voice. Definitely agree with some of your other fans regarding getting a full animation team behind this. Perhaps some of the people at the House of Mouse would be able to take a crack at this; after all they did a VERY good job with Thrawn in the Rebels series. More criticisms and/or comments will likely be edited in as I continue to watch this. So far, it's a great film. EDIT: OK, who the actual living heck was portraying Yularen in this? He was nearly PERFECT for the role. Definite A-List voice acting there. However, emotions make the VA and that was a big flaw. When he's speaking to Anakin Yularen sounds bored, flat, emotionless. Not how Yularen would sound in a situation like that - he'd give a more impassioned, emotional plea for his General to turn back. Despite that, Yularen's voice is almost dead-on accurate to the Clone Wars television show, so a massive, massive cry of "Bravo!" to whoever played Yularen in this film, same as with the Thrawn voice. EDIT: Once again, bravo for the Anakin VA. Pretty darn close... at least early on. When Anakin says "that might actually work" around 11:03 his voice breaks into a more stereotypical Indian accent. Ouch. EDIT: Obi-Wan was also almost dead-on. He just needed to slow down a bit, as here he has a far more Scottish-sounding accent. On a related note, THIS is the voice you should have used for Palpatine earlier. I'm starting to notice a pattern here. Everyone except Palpatine does a pretty good job of VA-ing, they just need a bit of adjustment in some way. Thrawn needs his inflections adjusted, Yularen needs to put more passion in his voice, Obi-Wan needs to slow down, and Anakin needs to focus more. They're all very, very, VERY close. Some seriously good choices here, definite A-listers. OK, I'm now at 20:46 and Thrawn's actor has definitely improved. He's getting the hang of this voice, the inflections are improving. Practice is making perfect. I'm now at 40:26 and I must say: BRAVO, BRAVO ALL. The pattern I noticed continues, but it is improving. There have been a few cases where they've gone backwards, but it's been two steps forward and one step back the whole time. Definite improvements all around. I just finished the movie. A grand show, good narration and good story and worldbuilding, with the VAs for each character improving throughout. Practice really did make perfect for them. You have the makings of a professional author. A hundred thumbs way, WAY up!
honeslty the ending isnt the way i thought it would have ended. My thought is Thrawn would get married and bring his wife to the galaxy as the chiss embassdor to the republic and his decendants would be the embassdors for the next thousand years
Couldn't find Part 2 on its own so I watch this compilation and leave my thoughts here: Again, it was awesome to see what un-nerfed Thrawned could look like. It was great, for real. I'd like for more "What If?" channels to honor Thrawn, what he should be like. Cheers from France! 🍻 *Edit* For some reason I wasn't subscribed to your channel, I changed that while I'm at it.
What if anakin trained another Jedi after Ashoka left? What if obi wan and Ashoka trained luke and leia from birth? What if anakin and barris fell in love? What if savage oppress didn’t die in clone wars? What if maul and savage were Jedi? What if Ezra joined maul in rebels? What if kanan died in order 66? What if obi wan died instead of qui gon jinn? What if Ashoka found Galen Marrok instead of Darth Vader? What if Syfo Dias didn’t die? What if anakin had a twin sister? What if qui gonn jinn’s force ghost spoke to dooku Turning him back to the light side?
This was epic I was waiting for part 2 for ages what a sick conclusion. 1:03:54 part 3 some day???? Please like come on that literally is just teasing The Yuuzahn Vong you gotta do a part 3 with the Yuuzahn Vong invasion. Maybe later down the line where Luke and Leia are older and maybe have met Han and Mara all take part in the future war against the Vong as it would be an awesome way to connect both legends and canon together for one final epic conclusion. One can dream but either way amazing job 10/10 what if.
I think this is good but would have done better I feel had Thrawn and the Republic repurposed battle droids for it and it would have made it harder for the enemy as they can't be mind controlled and vibro weapons as well as magna guards weapons would have ended more enemy even with the Kortosis armor on.
On the next what if (1) What if Anakin skywalker can turn into the dragon (2) what if Darth maul trained Ahsoka before the Jedi found (3) what if Darth Revan trained Anakin Skywalker
The definitive Thrawn Story that deserves a full animation 👌
Five stars
Agreed
When I'm done with UA-cam in a few years and focusing on my career, I'll come back when I have good money and get some of these animated
@@FantasyFolklore sounds good to me
@@FantasyFolkloreplease don’t forget 😂
Dew it.
One of the greatest Star Wars fanfics I ever read. Not only is Thrawn a Hero, he’s also even more brilliant and in my opinion Prefect story written in this. Saving Anakin, and seeing him as his first true friend was an amazing addition, also not viewing the Jedi like the rest of the galaxy, but hero’s and very important Allies and some as friends
in truth thrown has no friends , because his ]dependency on facts keeps him from making them, i wouldn't be surprised if he saw them as allies because of the fact that they were allies
The only thing you should’ve factored into this video is that Thrawn would’ve been able to figure out Asoka‘s innocence. But well done.
He definitely would’ve but Anakin did have that case solved in a day. Having Thrawn around wouldn’t make things much faster
Plus with the way Thrawn kinda took over Episode 3 I’m not sure having Ashoka around would matter in a significant way
I've watched this several times and I always love how Sun Tzu quotes were put in Thrawn's mouth. If anyone embodied Sun Tzu, it would be Thrawn. This should have been a long running series!
"Elementary, my dear Skywalker..."
Day 16: What if General Grievous was secretly a Republic spy?
We need this
@@Adb475 On What if Mace Windu went on Mustafar with Obi-Wan, he said he'd do it on day 66
I’m sorry I’m lost right now?
@@Adb475 It was a couple weeks ago, but he did confirm
Oh I got you now
Atleast someone remembered the grisk. That was important, how everyone just forgot about then in cannon, including apparently thrawn
Underrated enemy. I wish there was more on them
@@FantasyFolkloreI'd think it would be interesting to have both the Grysk and the Vong ( _simply known as just "Vong" instead of "Yuuzhan Vong"_ ) both in Canon as two separate - yet somewhat similar - species.
Obi WAN’s voice actors totally nailed it. Thanks for the video.
PART 1 RECAP
Grand Admiral Thrawn, a blue-skinned Chiss from the Chiss Ascendancy, is sent to find allies against the threatening Grysk. He encounters Jedi Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi, leading to a meeting with Chancellor Palpatine in Coruscant. Thrawn offers his strategic prowess to help the Republic in the Clone Wars. After notable achievements in battle, especially alongside Anakin, Thrawn is promoted to Admiral. However, tension arises with Jedi General Pong Krell, culminating in the Umbara campaign. When Krell sabotages a mission by turning clones against each other, Thrawn strategically captures him. Krell reveals a foreseen rise of a new power post-Clone Wars. This revelation leads Thrawn to believe that an unseen force is driving the war. Determined to ensure the Republic's victory to prevent this predicted new order, Thrawn continues his strategic involvement, ever vigilant of the shadow force Krell hinted at.
Thrawn, after carefully piecing together the puzzle, determines that Chancellor Palpatine is Darth Sidious, the Sith Lord behind the Clone Wars. Using evidence and logical deduction, he confronts Palpatine in front of several influential senators and Jedi. As Thrawn reveals the depth of Palpatine’s treachery, the Sith Lord tries to escape, resulting in a confrontation with the Jedi. The Sith Lord is eventually captured with the help of Jedi Masters, effectively ending the Clone War.
Anakin Skywalker's secret marriage to Padmé Amidala is exposed during Thrawn's revelation, leading to a debate among the Jedi about his continued membership in the Order. However, Thrawn and Obi-Wan Kenobi vouch for Anakin, referencing his role in Sidious' capture and historical precedents like Revan, ensuring Anakin's place in the Jedi Order.
Thrawn is heralded as a hero of the Republic, receiving a prestigious medal and an offer of a position in the new Chancellor Organa's bureaucratic council. Acknowledging the debt the galaxy owes him, Chancellor Organa assures Thrawn of any support he might need in the future.
Seizing this opportunity, Thrawn seeks permission to return to his home in the Unknown Regions. Upon arrival, he finds the Chiss Ascendancy on the brink of war with the aggressive Grysk. Armed with the assurance of support from the Republic, Thrawn convinces the Chiss ruling families to form an alliance with the galactic superpower to fend off their common enemy and Saganu, one of the Aristrocra leaders of the Chiss goes with Thrawn to Coruscant.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU.
This was an excellent story. I enjoyed it all. Great job.
Thrawn is the True Heir to the Empire! you don't agree with me .... FIGHT ME!!!!!!!!
HEIR TO THE EMPIRE
Long live the empire!
Some of your best work! Part 2 was particularly awesome, well thought out, shows Thrawn's brilliance, drives up the stakes, pays off with the good feels. Thanks!
Thanks David!!!
What if Thrawn lead the First Order?
What if Hera Syndulla and Han Solo fell in Love?
What if Aura Sing killed Padme?
What if The Blue Shadow Virus was released?
What if the Jedi and Sith Switched? (Sith are Jedi. Jedi are Sith)
I have listened to a huge number of Star Wars "what ifs" and this was by far the most interesting and well written.
I think Thrawn is my favorite non clone or jedi character. Even the fanfictions writen about him hold my attention. This one especially was amazing!
a new threat began rising... the aeldar
I’m gonna put down the two what if’s I have on AO3:
1) what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era
2) what if Jyn Erso survived combined with what if she met and fell in love with Luke Skywalker
The High Republic one is done and I’m working on the second one.
What's the Erso/Luke Story called?
@@sebastianb.3978 A Change of Fate, and it’s not finished yet but I am approaching the ending.
@@reeceemms1643 thx
Star Trek has their Spock, and Star Wars has their version, Thrawn.
Yay a part two. Loved part one. Wish the real Thrawn would work with the New Republic to get rid of the Grysk rather than say FUCK THE CHISS, IMMA RULE LESSER SPACE!
Glad you enjoyed!
What if Palpatine was a normal Chancellor(Not Force Sensitive)
Interesting, he was very cunning but I wonder if his force sensitivity played a role in that, could be an interesting topic to explore
@@FantasyFolkloreI think it was more his experiences with the force (his training under plageus) that did that
He would not have been able to rise like he did without that power
@@InfernosReaperWhat if he had force sensitive allie or allies. I think, that the dark side extremes are rather negative, against his theater, manipulations, cold calculations and pure logic above feelings. I think, he was member of dark třída, probably a psychopat. With the dark side it would be bigger a struggle.
But I think, he would be better with amoral, powerfull, wise and rich mentor. Plagueis made Palpatine into Palpatine, no matter the force. But otherwise he would be the same.
Without some inspiration, he would be racing in speeders or something.
Anyways Palpatine knew about the Sith and wanted to be a Sith already as a youngster, when was searching for Sith texts and similar stuff on the market - long before he met Plagueis. I don't think IT was the force, but that it was his brain searching for something close. He wouldn't be a good boy in any case.
@@WenceslasHolec What "force sensitive" allies could he have that would actually be under his control as just a regular guy with no powers, though?
At best, he would just be a puppet in that setup
Ok, so I like it right up to the end. The Mith are already one of the 9 most powerful families in the Chiss Ascendancy. Thrawn was adopted into them by the leader of the family due to his abilities in combat. Read the new canonical books.
Ah shit I did know this but forgot 😭😭 instead, I think I’d have it that the current Mith aristocrac was killed by Plo/Anakin and they offer for Thrawn to take his place. Glad you like it tho thanks for watching!!!
The thrawn voice is freaking perfect
What if, during the Clone Wars, Anakin Skywalker did something similar to Abeloth; he drank from the Font of Power and bathed in the Pool of Knowledge, but, unlike Abeloth, he also sat upon the Throne of Balance? This idea was inspired by the Disney+ series, "Ahsoka".
Fuggin love it. I’m glad you had the voices. I love cartoon Thrawn walking with Anakin and Obi Wan.
I loved this Thank you for all the hard work everyone has done :D
What if Anakin agreed to stay on Ziegeria with the queen to free Ashoka and Obi-Wan?
Padme executes Order 66 on him? XD
Your voices are good!
The team is so good! Check them out in the description
I think you left out this topic. The skywalkers of the chiss ascendancy. Force-sensitive Chiss navigators who helped the Chiss Ascendancy navigate the dangerous hyperspace conditions present in the Ascendancy's native Unknown Regions of the galaxy. I want to hear a talk about this topic and they losing their force sensitivity by adulthood by master Yoda and Mace Windu with Thrawn and Chiss leaders.
EDIT:- I also want to see what would be the expression of Anakin when he knows that an entire section of force sensitives has been named after him
24:27 HA! I love the png of thrown moving next to them
The Grissk reminds me of The Dark Eldar of 40k Warhammer
Kinda aye
45:21 baby Ashoka, how cute picture
What if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter or what if Anakin was trained by Pong Krell
Thrawn is a detective cool and subtly Suave 😂 what a writ✍️
So slick aye
"What if" Meetra Surik didn't go to find Revan after defeating the Sith Triumvirate?
"What if" the love of Qui-Gon's life didn't die?
What about a possible part 3. Maybe with the ssi ruu??? Or perhaps a lost tribe of true sith could be the antagonists of the story with the strongest most elite force senstives using beskar with cortosis and sith alchemy to make and equip their own battle armour. Not to mention lightsaber hilts that cannot be cut in half or destroyed by blaster bolts. I really enjoyed this video. So please keep up the good work. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
Not a bad idea wud love to see a pt 3 or a full siries but then ik think the story shut change a bit to loeave more gaps open for new o
pertuneties
Thrawn in Ahsoka is an inactive idiot while here in a fan fiction he is an intelligent thorn in the side of many.
I think we're gonna see him level up in season 2/ the movie
Why does Thrawn look like the Scottish comedian Limmy here?
"Wits yer hing?"
LMAO
What if Padme and Anakin were the same age?
Perhaps 2 parts where there both 9 or 14
Obviously Padme can’t be a Queen at age 9 so maybe she’s a handmaiden for the queen or a student In learning. Maybe Padme sneaks out the ship and follows qui gon to the dealership where she meets Anakin. They become instantly friends and eventually they both developed a small crush before parting ways for 10 years
The other one Anakin is 14 so maybe he’s still a slave but with lots of anger and darkness in him. Maybe he fix’s ships for a living or do small smuggling.
Or maybe this time cleig Lars met Shmi when Anakin was 9 so he freed both of them and they live on the outskirts where Anakin and Owen are basically brothers. Padme either meets Anakin in the dealership where he worked on ships or Padme’s ship crashes on the Lars homestead.
I would like to know how their story will develop if it’ll take them down the same path. They both still have the same personality, but the maturity it’s on the same level being the same age and all
"What if" Sabine Wren discovered that she was Force-Sensitive at the same time Ezra did in the SW: Rebels series.
Def was worth the wait
Thanks mate I really appreciate it
What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy?
How would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?
Then it's probably likely that Luke and Leia are born and raised as Sith since Anakin would be the one giving birth, or likely they'd die due to a miscarriage after Anakin was burned on Mustafar. Very interesting what if
Another idea, what if star wars gender bent? males are female and females are male
Interesting, bit if a mind f aye haha
This is technically already canon as thrawn says to ahsoka that he knew her master though it’s unclear if he was referring to anakin during the clone wars or Vader.
Thrawn met Anakin. He was looking for allies wirhout the Chiss Ascendancy's knowledge and met Anakin while he was on a mission to save Padme.
Definitely one of my favorite fan fictions
Thanks Chris
Is this a remake of the original because if it is, they may maybe you should make what if qui gon jinn Freed , anakin, and his mother only this time Anakin at the end, survives for his mother, padme, and his children and also other remakes like what if Anakin stayed on mortis only this time the Jedi don’t die, but instead survive and move to mortis to help, Anakin maintain the balance along with other what if remakes
It's not a remake, just added part 2 at the end.
@@FantasyFolklore thank you for telling me
"What if" the Jedi discovered that the Sith Temple under their own was corrupting them?
WoW!! Awesome my unknown friend. Great story telling.. Im happy
Thanks Ricky!!!
Day 5: what if commander Cody went to obi wan after he left the empire?
I love Thrawn
And also what if qui gon jinn became grandmaster what if dooku became supreme Chancellor and what if anakin became Jedi battle master will be the best what ifs you make? out of all of them but if I’m being honest these other what if scenarios that you know where these new ones will be the tip of the iceberg? What if anakin went with Yoda to the wellspring of life what if quinlan vos trained Anakin Skywalker what if the clone army was force sensitive? Or what if Anakin skywalker kill the son with the dagger of Mortis and kept at the end you decide man it’s up to you
They're all on the list mate I'll get to them eventually
@@FantasyFolklore we love your what ifs always
Amazing story, great work this was brilliant.
Excellent, you should make more hour long videos, truly brilliant.
I would aye but it takes SO LONG
of course the entire republic wouldn't have gone there would have still been pockets of rebellion in the outer rim like the empire had a while in canon
What if Maul was tought night magic by Talzin after he was healed? It is possible he is her reeal son..its in him...Im surprised no one never thought of this🤔🤔
What was first just a dream has become a frightening reality for all those who may oppose us
Imagine After Thrawn Died in Star Wars Legends all the Chiss Females Intelligence Becomes Far Superior Than Thawn's was and The Imperial Remnant and The Chiss Females of The Empire of The Hand are Allies.
Would be crazyyyy
The new republic should have created treaties with independent worlds like Navarro. Nevarro could sell products from its mines to the republic and in turn have protection from pirates.
Day 2: what if Zahn wrote the sequel trilogy?
So just retelling of Heir to the Empire books? 😅
@@Hello-bi1pm no
I think he could’ve done something different but I wouldn’t have been upset with Heir
Oh god I still wonder why to this day they didn't get the legends writers on board. Personally, Luceno is my favourite but I'm bias!
@@FantasyFolklore Anderson, Stockpole…all of them
@@FantasyFolkloreDisney don’t listen to anyone not George, not the old EU writers and not even the fans.
It’s a sad truth but atleast Dave is giving us some great Star Wars he’s the last hope.
BRAVO, BRAVO. I can very much applaud all those involved here.
I am only about 6 minutes into the production and it is very well told. However, I have a few criticisms.
For one, Thrawn sounds... robotic. The dialect is spot on, however the actor's inflections need some work: Occasionally. their voice goes down in pitch when it should go up, up when it should go down, and changes when it should stay neutral. The result is that Thrawn sounds... bored, for lack of a better term. And definitely robotic, as if performed by a speech generator, not a person.
Other than that, spot on. So great voice acting, but it needs less robot. This is a fairly common issue for voice actors I hear on various channels though, so not too big of a criticism. The fellow definitely studied the Rebels series and how Thrawn spoke there, so major props to him or her for getting it very, VERY close.
Your Palpatine on the other hand? Off. Off, off, WAY off. Literally by a few hundred light years, as Ray's using a voice that would be right at home coming from a Neimoidian like Nute Gunray. Coming from Palpatine, that sort of oily voice is way, WAY off the mark, at least from how he was before the events that rapidly aged him into the wrinkled old man he was during his issuing of Order 66 and the fall of the republic.
After the fall though? Definitely go with the oily voice.
Definitely agree with some of your other fans regarding getting a full animation team behind this. Perhaps some of the people at the House of Mouse would be able to take a crack at this; after all they did a VERY good job with Thrawn in the Rebels series.
More criticisms and/or comments will likely be edited in as I continue to watch this. So far, it's a great film.
EDIT: OK, who the actual living heck was portraying Yularen in this? He was nearly PERFECT for the role. Definite A-List voice acting there. However, emotions make the VA and that was a big flaw. When he's speaking to Anakin Yularen sounds bored, flat, emotionless. Not how Yularen would sound in a situation like that - he'd give a more impassioned, emotional plea for his General to turn back. Despite that, Yularen's voice is almost dead-on accurate to the Clone Wars television show, so a massive, massive cry of "Bravo!" to whoever played Yularen in this film, same as with the Thrawn voice.
EDIT: Once again, bravo for the Anakin VA. Pretty darn close... at least early on. When Anakin says "that might actually work" around 11:03 his voice breaks into a more stereotypical Indian accent. Ouch.
EDIT: Obi-Wan was also almost dead-on. He just needed to slow down a bit, as here he has a far more Scottish-sounding accent. On a related note, THIS is the voice you should have used for Palpatine earlier.
I'm starting to notice a pattern here. Everyone except Palpatine does a pretty good job of VA-ing, they just need a bit of adjustment in some way. Thrawn needs his inflections adjusted, Yularen needs to put more passion in his voice, Obi-Wan needs to slow down, and Anakin needs to focus more. They're all very, very, VERY close. Some seriously good choices here, definite A-listers.
OK, I'm now at 20:46 and Thrawn's actor has definitely improved. He's getting the hang of this voice, the inflections are improving. Practice is making perfect.
I'm now at 40:26 and I must say: BRAVO, BRAVO ALL. The pattern I noticed continues, but it is improving. There have been a few cases where they've gone backwards, but it's been two steps forward and one step back the whole time. Definite improvements all around.
I just finished the movie. A grand show, good narration and good story and worldbuilding, with the VAs for each character improving throughout. Practice really did make perfect for them. You have the makings of a professional author. A hundred thumbs way, WAY up!
honeslty the ending isnt the way i thought it would have ended. My thought is Thrawn would get married and bring his wife to the galaxy as the chiss embassdor to the republic and his decendants would be the embassdors for the next thousand years
Great video Man!!!!
Thanks mate!!
Please next story:- What if Darth Nox returned during the Clone Wars
Thrawn is a better detective than poirot and batman combined.
Enterprise in star wars confirmed?!
A master of the water, trains the apprentice from a planet of sand.
What if Kit FIsto trained Anakin...
12:00 i finally hear quote that Sun Tzu actually said.
Grand Admiral Thrawn makes a great detective 🕵️♂️ .
Do I hear a Sabaton quote at 11:40. 😂❤
A true masterpiece
Goddamn thrawn is a savage
Couldn't find Part 2 on its own so I watch this compilation and leave my thoughts here:
Again, it was awesome to see what un-nerfed Thrawned could look like. It was great, for real.
I'd like for more "What If?" channels to honor Thrawn, what he should be like.
Cheers from France! 🍻
*Edit*
For some reason I wasn't subscribed to your channel, I changed that while I'm at it.
If this is a remake then can u please do what if palpatine trained anakin skywalker? Please I’m begging u fantasy folklore 🙏
I've kinda done this in other videos but I'm doing a specific video in the next month or so where this happens
"What if" Sidious, Vader, and Luke all died on the Second Death Star?
I love these thrawn fanfics
47:28 where is that fanart ship from? What is the ship servicing the other ships called?
contentor-class fleet replishment ship from Ansel Hsiao on ArtStation www.artstation.com/artwork/YzELV
This was a spectacular what if???. Very well done.
Cheers Mike!
@@FantasyFolklore could you do a what if of “What if the high council decided to remove itself from politics completely a few years before episode I?”
Enjoy that the voice actors aren't neccisarily trying to mimic the actors from the film. Gives a different take on the characters.
Give em total freedom!
What if anakin trained another Jedi after Ashoka left?
What if obi wan and Ashoka trained luke and leia from birth?
What if anakin and barris fell in love?
What if savage oppress didn’t die in clone wars?
What if maul and savage were Jedi?
What if Ezra joined maul in rebels?
What if kanan died in order 66?
What if obi wan died instead of qui gon jinn?
What if Ashoka found Galen Marrok instead of Darth Vader?
What if Syfo Dias didn’t die?
What if anakin had a twin sister?
What if qui gonn jinn’s force ghost spoke to dooku Turning him back to the light side?
Some great ideas thanks!
@@FantasyFolklore you’re welcome
The Mith were a ruling family of the 9 to begin with.
Yeah I messed that part up
Thrown should get a show about himself
47:11 What art is this?
1:02:14 He made sure to say it twice, just in case the dying guy didn't hear his taunt.
What if during episode 3 the Sacking of Coruscant happens instead of order 66
Part 3 palatine escape with the took the droid army and grist army left over and wage another war
Apparently someone just wrote the Thrawn Fanfic I've been craving for years.
What if Spider-Man 2099 was in Star Wars prequels
It's a canon event waiting to happen
Lmaoo
"What if" Hera was Force-Sensitive?
What if Palpatine had killed Yoda in their duel?
1:02:22, you had Thrawn repeat himself x_x
What if vader pull luke back up with the force after he jumped on bespin?
Thrawn sounds like paps palp😂, but a great story
what if anakin skywalker trained ezra bridger
I didn’t know the griss were eldar
This was fucking awesome.
I would so watch a movie like this, they should do a multiverse in Star Wars, that would be interesting
What if empire won the battle of endor
We need a part 3
This was epic I was waiting for part 2 for ages what a sick conclusion.
1:03:54 part 3 some day???? Please like come on that literally is just teasing The Yuuzahn Vong you gotta do a part 3 with the Yuuzahn Vong invasion.
Maybe later down the line where Luke and Leia are older and maybe have met Han and Mara all take part in the future war against the Vong as it would be an awesome way to connect both legends and canon together for one final epic conclusion.
One can dream but either way amazing job 10/10 what if.
I think this is good but would have done better I feel had Thrawn and the Republic repurposed battle droids for it and it would have made it harder for the enemy as they can't be mind controlled and vibro weapons as well as magna guards weapons would have ended more enemy even with the Kortosis armor on.
Impressive, most impressive...
Thanks mate
On the next what if (1) What if Anakin skywalker can turn into the dragon (2) what if Darth maul trained Ahsoka before the Jedi found (3) what if Darth Revan trained Anakin Skywalker