they know what made them special, effort. But why put in effort when the window licking, knuckle dragging masses will still gleefully shell out whatever price asked fo them, as long as they can chase that nostalgia high and pretend for a second they're little kinds again who have hopes and dreams, not sad adults busting their asses for fifty hours a week just so they can barely afford to live in squalor.
Realism is boring. In games, I can land a 900 on a skateboard. If I do it irl, I'll likely die or end up a vegetable. Not to mention a skateboard costs 120$+ while Tony Hawk Pro Skater can go for 30$ish.
And there was a talking dragon in the animated one and still people loved it. This isn't about realism. This is about the message. The message of being responsible and being there for your family.
Hats off for Disney. They introduced all of these changes in a movie loved by Western audiences to cater to the Chinese market and they managed to please neither.
Tommy Lei 雷 yeah I mean if it was a new movie it would be understandable bu since e original was made and brung into us it hurts us a little and you too
@Tommy Lei 雷 Gongli being punished for being a witch makes no sense. Anti-witch sentiment is a European Christian thing. The costumes were also kind of odd and the architectural settings seem out of place. The round buildings called 'tulou' in the movie were found in Southern China (Mulan takes place in Northern China) and tulous wasn't even a thing yet
They tried with the warrior dude, but they didn't say cow so.. whats the point..>? Can you imagine when Biden takes office how bad these movies pushing agendas will be?
She was chosen in the original animation. She was the awakened great stone dragon. It's imagery shown throughout the sequence of her cutting her hair & suiting up. That's why mushu couldn't wake it up. It was already awoken in mulan.
Kendall L. Buchanan she’s not the chosen one. She put herself in the ordeal, like the girl in the hunger game. The animation dragon stuff was released by the ancestors to protect her because of her courage. There is nothing chosen about her.
@@newp848 she might've been chosen one in some sense but all around she had to prove herself through hard work and her wits that she is equally capable of being a warrior and a hero. This new Mulan just uses the power of Chi to solve everything to the point that I think the Chi allows her to teleport considering how the movie was cut.
I haven't seen the new Mulan. I just meant to say she was chosen to be uplifted and protected in the animated one. I wasn't referring to any prophesy. Sorry
I always got the impression from the movie that every family in that world had a house dragon protector. It never came across as a chosen-one thing, but Disney's way to redo the success that was Robin Williams' genie from Aladin.
It wasn't about being realistic. It offended a lot of viewers in China and they've become a huge market so it was financially stupid to offend them again and risk losing out on millions of viewers. But as a Chinese American, this movie looks fucking stupid and definitely needed mushu and the songs
Disney seem to have forgotten the golden rule: story before everything else. Pixar learnt this in their very first film and completely changed it because they knew that the story wasn't working.
@@MeraHarch Toy Story was majorly reworked pretty far into its development because the stories and characters weren't endearing. I specifically remember hearing that Woody was kind of a huge dick in the original. So, they reworked a lot of the story to make it what it is today. Pretty sure that's what OP meant.
@@medhanshsankaran595 It's the fact that the message is trying to send is hypocritical. Abby who fulfills her every insatiable desire of revenge gets to get away with it while Ellie who stops is now in the worst spot on her life and has hit rock bottom that she could never bounce back from ever again.
The Junglebook one was alright when it came out, the problem is Disney is so creatively bankrupt that they have to remake their past successes for any chance of selling tickets. And usually, the past successes' 2D classical animation is far nicer to look at. On top of that, story goes overboard in typical hollywood style to be more surface level entertainment than having much substance. and so usually doesn't compete with the original anyway... Remakes are already a bad enough cash grab to do, but when the remake is worse and less enjoyable than the classics, it's just pointless. And yeah, maybe their purpose is to sell them to a new generation, but if I had kids I wouldn't be showing them the remakes.
Personally, I am becoming more and more artistically terrified for the alleged upcoming remake of “The Hunchback of Notre Dame” with David Henry Hwang as the supposed writer. Ever since I fell in love with the animated musical, read the original book, and saw how the Disneyfied stage plays like “Der Glöckner Von Notre Dame” could create a nice blending of both versions (even to the point of Esmeralda dying at the end), I always wanted a live-action remake to exist that tries something similar. The idea has been in my head, even before the live-action remakes became a Disney fad, and I even did my own fan projects of it on my UA-cam channel. But now, unless Disney both realizes that they cannot just coast on nostalgia with Hunchback and lets its writers make a dark and dramatic musical with passion, the remake that Disney releases is likely going to figuratively hurt me far more than any others have yet.
I don't exactly "hate" the movies, but I haven't watched any of them, and don't plan to, they stank heavily of "money grab" from the beggining. My time is better spend ... anywhere else really XD. and Holy Moly $30 on top of the suscription? REALLY? At that price tag I can just pre-order Cyberpunk 2077 and (most likely) be thoroughly entertained for tenths or maybe even hundreds of hours.
There was zero character growth for Mulan. As a child Mulan is this super powerful, ultra agile, supremely gifted mary sue. Goes off the war and has to pretend to be just another weak wimpy little man (yuck). Then decides she is a superhero, screw all this hiding. This is NOT character growth.
The character growth is shown by her deciding to show her true self. Being loyal brave and true is the thing they show the most and she realized she needed to be true to her heart. I liked that she chose to show herself instead of being found out. It shows the integrity and the braveness of mulan
@@margaretbakly7810 When a character starts off as an amazing prodigy then hides it then later shows what she was from the start it is not character growth. That is called a mary sue character. In the original she went from somebody that had no idea what she was doing to absorbing the training and dedicating herself to BECOMING better for herself, her fellow warriors, her family, and her nation. She worked her butt off for it. Not once was she shown as this spectacular specimen that just has all the talent. No, that would be boring. Instead she was shown as a great woman who overcame the prejudice of a nation that didn't think women should fight and she overcame the absolute terror so her dad wouldn't go out and die. Risk is what makes a hero. Showing everybody how fabulous she already was is not a heroic journey.
This is the 2020 feminist model for writing female characters. If they had given Mulan flaws or a need for character growth, they’d have been accused of being misogynistic pigs.
@@geraldm4728 just to build on your comment. The "hero's journey" is a classical depiction of what a story centered on a hero needs to captivate the audience and make it relatable. There's the "journey" which is usually the hero struggling a LOT to become stronger/better. Then they have a big "crisis/failure". And then they do a "comeback/rise up". This movie straight up jumps the journey and the failure. They just jump the journey. They change the crisis to "slight discomfort" and then they change the big comeback to "no discomfort". As a viewer you have no interest built up, from the start we know exactly everything that's going to happen, which is nothing special. Try to play an RPG where you from the start have all the best gear, the highest level and every skill. Then come tell me how fun of a game it was to walk to the end. The struggle is what people love, people love the "underdog" and they always will, cause the masses are petty.
I was looking forward to a “historically accurate” take on Mulan... obviously this was not it 😑 they took out the “magical” elements for.... more magical elements??? WTF DISNEY 🤦🏻♀️
the term "historically correct" got me excited as well. Thought we'd get a more realistic glimpse of chinese culture, lifestyle and traditions and what impact war can have. Instead we got a witch lady, barely a phoenix and jedi powers...
Just look at their 4 credited writers, all of them aren't even asian much less chinese. Which wouldn't matter, if they had did their homework but boy did they butcher up a classic. Some entitled western tweeters might tell their peers "this movie was not made for Western tastes" so don't judge. But anyone with any asian connection will tell you this is movie wasn't made for anyone's taste. My gf and sister never got along but this movie united them in hatred for destroying their childhood empowerment story.
Same I wanted a realistic and thoughtful tale, not this character super power garbage and witch villain. The original annimation is still a masterpiece.
Damn, I haven't heard Jeremy actually be pissed at a movie in a while. I've seen him rip a movie apart, I've seen him be disappointed and defeated, but actually being salty at a movie has been a while.
This film clearly was written and directed by people that literally have zero clue or understanding of Asian culture. Seriously, passing off Tai Chi as "the Force", were they frigging stoned when they thought that would be enough to explain Mulan's supernatural abilities to be amazing? X)
I think you misunderstood what they’re attempt was then. This is based on the real myth which has mystic elements. They didn’t want Mushu because his existence is just for jokes. Granted Mushu was actually good and the witch lady did nothing besides witch stuff.
akshay satish Bruh, it has a 46% on Rotten Tomatoes audience score chill tf out. Also, IMDb has a low score for it because MONTHS before the movie even released some kid made a hundred alts and gave it 1 star reviews with random BS in the review. In the end, so what about critic scores anyway? You’re free to have an opinion on a movie being good or not and fake scores shouldn’t define that
I remember seeing that! Don’t get why they needed this remake when the 2009 film is there and takeout mushu and Shang and the songs that everyone loved 😡
What disappointed me the most was that, in the cartoon she succeeds in gains the respect of the other people around her by using her insights to compensate for her lack of strength, she's smart and hard-working, and that is how she gets ahead, in the movie it just felt like oh, she has magic chi, so you know, I guess we believe her.
@@tar_a I am aware that it isn't, but I'm pretty sure there isn't a witch lady or use of magic chi in the original Chinese story. At least I've never come across it in other adaptations even ones that are hailed as being more true to the original.
Rebekah Rhodes in the original story she buys her own horse and sets off for war and she possessed the necessary fighting skills to hold her own amongst her comrades. Some adaptations make her more badass than this and all adaptations portray her as a warrior.
Totally agree with "dumb af" here. As an Asian woman, this movie try SO HARD to make us feel right, but honestly it just makes me feel yucky! It's fake feminism, like the animated version has so much more realism in terms of being a woman in Asian family & the kind of weight that comes with it. And don't get me started with Mulan's Jedi power. Like come onnn, the reason why people love Mulan is because she's just a normal girl who work harder & find more creative ways to solve problems. She doesn't have the body strength, but she's got the wit & much faster. She embrace her uniqueness instead of unleash her hidden force 🙄. I really wonder how Disney define "realism", because their animation are just so much more realistic (emotion & logic) than the live action.
Animated Mulan: The story of a woman trying to survive in a man's world, but through intense training and military discipline, she ultimately earns everyone's respect and is recognized as a hero for her bravery against impossible odds, quick thinking, and weapon skills she learned at boot camp. proving women can be just as good as men Live action Mulan: The story of a woman dominating in a man's world through the use of magic... because you know, women can't survive without handicaps. hard work is for men. women are born godly
Remember: CCP having literal death camps within view of the cast and crew - Gets heartfelt thanks from Disney Georgia having a pro-life stance - Lifelong ban on any filming and outraged condemnation from Disney.
The original Mulan showed her strength in her intelligence, not in her physical strength. She learned to fight in the army, sure, but that wasn't her main strength. Her fighting skills helped her defensively, not offensively. She took down Attila the Hun, sorry I mean Chenggis Khan... dang it I forget his name. Anyways, she doesn't fight the big baddie head on. She outwits him. The moment she got his sword from him and pinned down his tunic with it, it was Mushu who finished him off. Mulan was known for her planning, her strategy, just like when she took down 99.9% of the Hun army with an avalanche. THAT is the Mulan we love, because it shows that, in a world where the strongest people have power, Mulan doesn't have what it takes in strength alone, but can inspire people with strategy in order to fight back. That was her strong suit. The "girl power" thing doesn't work, especially not in Ancient China where everything is decided by the skill and strength of a man's sword.
@@thomassowellaudiobooks6441 , Chi is not magical powers. Everyone has Chi but not everyone can use Chi as they are not taught to harness Chi. Basically, in Chinese wuxia (fantasy martial arts) stories, Chi has always been a vital element where the hero/heroin outperforms other people. Anyway, if you follow the original story of Mulan, she was supposed to be an accomplished fighter even before she joins the army. If you're not a good fighter, you would not last 12 years in the army fighting the Rourans.
Guy Mor , they are making a Disney wuxia / Chinese fantasy martial arts movie. Chi in those stories are not superpowers or magic. You just need to find a sifu/sensei to teach you in those stories. Anyway, a lot of Chinese people believe in Chi but it does not work like movies. The best example is tai chi exercise you see a lot of Chinese people do. It is supposed to improve your breathing and indirectly improve your strength and health too
@@thomassowellaudiobooks6441 , Like I say, it is not magic. If you've watched wuxia stories since young, you'll understand what is Chi in those stories. It's not like a chosen one, force sensitive or even mutant powers. Everyone has Chi but people only become Chi expert if they are taught to harness it. It wuxia stories, Chi is linked to kungfu. It is part of kung fu where you need to learn and practise, then only you can use it. The movie made a big mistake. If they just insert a scene or two showing her father teaching her, it will make more sense.
I like how Disney wanted this movie to be realistic but they literally had a scene where the main bad guy catches an arrow right to his face while riding on a horse then the bad guy and his henchmen jump off horses and climb up walls using only their feet great job Disney for making it realistic! 🤦♂️
@@solinvictus2045 The funniest thing about this movie is that people holding different political views can find different reasons to hate this movie. Chinese nationalists: It's typical Hollywood propaganda. The Republican conservatives and Chinese dissidents: this is CCP propaganda. And the Democrats: This is misogynism propaganda. LOL
Disney: "The live-action Mulan won't have Mushu. We want to keep this movie realistic as possible, to respect Chinese culture" Fans: "Understandable, have a great day" also Disney: "So anyways, here's a shape-shifting witch with supernatural powers" *VISIBLE CONFUSION*
Just finished it now an not sure how I feel. No Mushu but you have a pointless Phoenix and a shapeshifter with questionable motive l lol. Should have just bought weed hahahaha
How I will remember the movie... a comedy, but slightly disappointed that Mulan didn’t go for the General’s daughter or become the Emporer’s next concubine.
So, I just watched the Mulan 2020 movie. This will have spoilers so be warned. Now, this is going to be an unbiased review, where I will ignore the fact that the main actress supports police brutality in Hong Kong. So what do I think of this movie? If I could describe one word to this movie, its that it is very Soulless. The only character that I genuinely liked was Donnie yen of course. Now, to get to the meat of this movie on why it felt soulless, let’s look at what the animated movie had. Mushu. The Exclusion of important characters. Mushu to Mulan was like what the Genie was to Aladdin. or Timon and Pumba was to Lion King Yeah, Aladdin and Simba were the main characters. But what made the movie went from “good” to near masterpiece was because of Genie, timon and Pumba. Their charming personalities and wacky content made the movies they were in from “good” to near masterpiece. If those characters werent in the movie, then the movies probably wouldnt be well-liked. Same with Mushu. Mushu brought the spark and energy that Mulan needed, which is why Mulan is genuinely a great film. Now, I understand that this movie is trying to be a movie about the real Mulan, and not the animated Mulan. But….. it has the same story elements as the animated Mulan. This movie is like a combination of the 2009 Chinese Mulan movie, and the Mulan cartoon. As a result it feels weird. Mushu, a great and likeable character, turns into…. a phoenix that acts as a map for Mulan. This movie also did not have Captain Li Shang from the animated movie. Li Shang was probably my favorite character. He was the perfect example of a male side character in a female led character done right. He was developed, had a likeable personality, and was very charismatic. Li Shang was split into two people, but those characters were kind of boring. The second problem with this movie is 2. The Lack of Music Now, i understand the director wanting to make it realistic, after all warriors dont just randomly sing out of nowhere. However, the problem with this is that the movie was boring. I am sorry, but like I said, this movie is trying very hard to be accurate to the real Mulan story, and seemingly copies the 2009 mulan movie in china. But this movie also tries to lighten the tone and just slap a Disney label on it. See, the 2009 Mulan movie is actually more accurate imo. But when I was watching this movie and seeing how this movie is trying to resemble like the original animated movie, I got bored and realized part of my boredom was that there were no songs. I think what made the live action movies remakes at least more bearable to watch were the songs because it could keep me interested. This movie doesnt have the Who I am song. But most importantly, it does not have the top 5 best Disney songs of all time “I’ll Make a man out of you.” Finally, the reason why this movie wasnt good 3. The villains The animated mulan movie had a villain name Shan Yu. The villain was not developed, but he was menacing. Seriously, the animated movie had darker themes than the live action. In the live action, heres the problem. There are two villains. What made Shan yu threatening and menacing was that he was the main villain. But in this movie, we get two villains, and as a result the villains dont feel developed or memorable. Seriously. this woman sides with Mulan in the end because she’s “a woman” or “Female empowerment.” or something. Like no offense, but if you’re going to betray your partner for the opponent simply because the opponent is a “woman”…. that’s not going to be satisfying. One more thing. 4. Mulan This is really personal. Because believe it or not, Mulan is my favorite Disney princess. No, its not because she’s Asian. Mulan was my favorite because she ws relatable. She was the underdog. Mulan was one of hte few characters who had flaws and lost battles. But she did whine and complain like a good girl? No, she sucked it up, overcame many challenges and became a worthy warrior. She proved that she didnt need to have masculine features to be a warrior, all it take was hard work and perserverance to achieve greatness. So what did this live action do? Well, it made Mulan the Chosen One. So what happened was they turned Mulan, a beloved Disney princess into a Mary Sue for their live action movies, like rey from star wars. Mulan in the live-action is nearly perfect, she succeeds almost all the time. She is the Chosen One, she is destined to defeat the bad guy. When you tell me it was her destiny to defeat an invading army, I am sorry but I lose interest in the character. In conclusion, this movie wasn’t memorable. It was boring. I am officially over the live action hype train. No, its not because its led by a female individual. Its because this movie felt boring or souless. It was way too long, didnt have heart in it. This movie didnt have any memorable characters, dialogue too long, and lack of developing villains. Review for this movie: 4 out of 10.
Why would I pay $30 to watch an inferior rehash of a 90s classic, when I can watch all the 1998-2005 Disney Shows + All The Classic Simpsons episodes + The Mandalorian + The original Star Wars trilogy (and Revenge Of The Sith) + every MCU film, etc. for just $10 bucks a month, such a rip off
Jeremy: Her father has no sons My brain, immediately: “My father has no sons so IM the one who has to social climb for one, cus I’m the oldest n the wittiest n the gossip in New York City is Insidious...
She apparently has a steel sword, even though steel did not exist at that time in China. Was first invented in India, apparently not done in China until 500 years after Mulan. "3rd century AD - China is commonly credited with being the first mass producers of high-quality steel."
@@warrenlauzon5315 Mulan is set after the third century in China. I am not aware of a version that sets Mulan before the Northern Wei Dynasty (386-534CE) during and in which territory the first version of Mulan in the ballad of Mulan was written. I think you are confusing the Han-Xiongnu war(141-87 BCE) for the setting of Mulan I can understand as the original Mulan is a confusing mess of Chinese and generally East Asian culture, history and setting. However from the uniforms, sets and general style Disney's 2020 Mulan seems to be set during the Tang Dynasty(618-907CE) when most of the most famous telling's of Mulan were written and set and that is well after the 3rd century.
We don't mind them making a live action of the anime but............... DO THE GOT DAMN THING RIGHT AND DON'T HAVE ASS IT AND NOT VIRTUE SIGNALING MESSAGES.
This is seriously a bad movie. Even as a movie, it fails at so many basic aspects required to make a film that it makes the filmmakers seem extremely incompetent.
I gave it a 2. It's not close to being good as the 1998 Mulan nor the live action Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Also the way it's presented is lacking that "movie feel". It felt like I was watching a long and boring tv series.
Because in society these days everyone wants to talk about not the substance of the story, but the woke messages in it. Unfortunately, some think that the more woke something is, the less you need to try for it to be considered good.
@@RedLeif1 A movie made for the CCP is woke o.0 That just doesn't sound right with the massive slaughter and detention of people, to the organ harvesting for wealthy westerners.
The mainstream movie studios just wanna sell stuff that's committee driven to sell as much as possible rather than making a work of art or something interesting. If you want actual good movies, just move away from Disney. Check out the smaller studios making good movies, check out the international film industry or even give animation a try since a lot of animated movies are better than most live action films these days.
It's this damn superficial push to make all stories pander to being "woke" and inclusive to all ideals and persons. Its superficial because its ALL ABOUT MARKETING. It's no longer about sending a message, it's all about that sweet $$$. I WANT MY FUCKING MUSHU!
Michelle Favre that’s the problem y’all are fine with ppl having an opinion on Chinese communism but when it’s Italian fascism everyone screams and tries to get you banned
I liked Aladdin live action to an extent as well, probably because of the soundtrack. And Beauty and the Beast but because of Lefou and Gaston mainly. And Jungle Book live action's tone is what exactly I'm looking for.
Pete's Dragon, Christopher Robin, 101 Dalmatians and Alice in Wonderland aka the good live action remake films for me. I'll stick with 1998 cartoon movie version whose I grew up with.
The thing is, in their attempt to make this movie more "woke" they ruined the positive female protagonist. In the original, Mulan was a normal girl who was being true to herself and by sheer determination and smarts, she prevails and saves China. In the remake, Mulan is not a normal girl, she was born with supernatural powers. So it wasn't what she chose to be, it was who she was born to me. This RUINS the positive message to children everywhere, but more especially the girls. The original: "Girls, you can be just as good as the boys if you try hard and use your head!" The Remake: "Girls, you can only be as good as the boys if you're magic!"
Mulan doesn’t have supernatural powers in the new film, she’s just gifted (albeit a little too much with cgi) but the whole message of the film is everyone is gifted in their own way and you shouldn’t hide from those gifts. In Mulans case her gift was her strategical sharpness that makes her a formidable foe to anyone .
Adam Moore exactly. If the message was “All girls could save China.” it would be disingenuous. The message of the remake was “Be true to who you really are.” Not everyone is gifted like Mulan, but do use your gifts to honor your family and help those you care about.
@@Adam-xb8xh strategical sharpness? I jist finished the movie and I don't think this phrase appeared in any point of the movie to describe Mulan. The phrase is “you have very good Chi” (smthg like that), which anyone else except the witch doesnt possess any in the movie. I am a Chinese and I read bunch of chinese kingfu and chi related novels, and none of them have this kind of setting where only some of them have chi or chi is forbidden. The whole movie is just an OP character doing whtever she want which occasionally encounter a little inconvenience...
@@micahwright5901 not all girl should save china, or should do anything, but if any girl want to do something like the boys did, they can do it without super power.
Still don't understand why people still trust Disney. They messed up Alladin, the Lion King, and now Mulan. Every remake they do is inferior with the heart and soul removed
they’ve done a lot right, but lots of misses just like every single other movie production studio the Last Jedi, Infinity War and Endgame are creative works of art, they will end up being the classic movies that define our era decades from now don’t like their movies then don’t go see them, until these remakes aren’t profitable they will keep making them.....also, Aladdin was great and something different from the animation , improved the story in many ways
I am not gonna pay 30 bucks for the movie. Sept 4 was supposed to be released but now dec 4th. I saw alot of reviews and said not worth my time and who has that money especially during this pandemic.
So they took everything that made the original great (music, mushu) and added gratuitous material that messed up the pacing, all with mediocre effects. So why did they make this movie again? Oh yeah money. This is kind of depressing.
Technically the original animation isn’t the ORIGINAL. Disney based it off a story and added singing and all that jazz. This is more in line with the actual story. But I understand why people are mad since everyone was expecting the cartoon version.
Mushu being funny: *YOU MISSED HOW COULD YOU MISS?! HE WAS RIGHT INFRONT OF YOU* Mushu being serious: *The truth is, we're both frauds. Your ancestors never sent me, they don't even like me. But you risked your life to help people you love. I risked your life to help myself. At least you had good intentions* This is what the live action movie missed.
I HOPE Disney loses a lot of money on this so they can finally stop with the live action remakes. I mean hell, you remember the 90s when we only had 3 remakes, both of which were really good? I mean hell, they were good because of how different they were, from the 94 Jungle Book that focuses on Mowglie's conflict between being human and animal (and was hella dark as hell) and 101 Dalmations that added a lot of humor to the film.
I personally don’t think it’s possible for Disney to come to that conclusion. They would probably think didn’t do well financially because of its release on Disney + for $30. Mulan 2020s financial success or failure has more control over if the same release strategy will be used for Black Widow.
I actually don’t mind the live action remakes I just haven’t liked the ones they released so far. Lion king , Aladdin and now Mulan are all horrible remakes and don’t follow the script and scenes 1:1 if any live action wants to be successful needs to be exactly like the original just with real people. That’s how I feel live action remakes will succeed
If it's a 1 to 1, scene for scene remake, then why make it in the first place? Why not save money and just re-release the one everyone already loves and just roll in the money?
I feel like people didnt get the memo that Disney said they werent going for the animated movie. They were doing a different tale of Mulan that hasnt been told.
@@Ravenbones even still, every single plot point is there. They followed the story board for the animation, but removed all of the elements that actually made it work and gave it charm, and added in an unnecessary witch subplot along with Disney's interpretation of Chi, which is basically Disney's version of "the force." No training necessary. You can do anything and everything you want for no inexplicable reason. Whether Disney wanted to do something different or not, they copied the storyboard of the original, and added in a bunch of unnecessary filler, as if trying to reach a "differentiation" quota, rather than trying to do things different out of actually wanting to tell a unique story (which is an even clearer indication that they added these elements for no other reason than to appeal to the Chinese government). And what's more, the original storyboard was made with music in mind, with music being the defining bond between scenes and events. You can't remove it and hope to have the same story. The entire thing had to be thrown out, and the movie had to be completely original. Instead, they went with the storyboard and whatever changes they made were so underdeveloped that the narrator had to literally step in halfway through the movie and tell us what should have been the payoff for a well-developed conflict. We got 2 scenes showing Mulan's shame in the lie, not helped by such wooden acting, and then the narrator to tell us she had had enough. The movie was just contrived garbage. It had none of the connecting techniques, none of the charm and flow that the original had (despite Disney wanting to copy it with some alterations), and whatever they did add was so underdeveloped that it stuck out of the rest of the story like a sore thumb, noticeably forcibly inserted, not interwoven
For one it makes her lighter so she can move around easier, for 2 she has amazing reflexes and the armor can very well and easily get in the way of that and be more of a hindrance than help.
I'm reading a reflection: a twisted tale where she goes to the underworld, nice use of 99 cents :) 2:00 no Mushu no peace. 4:25-4:30 feminism knows no boundaries lol hold my beer A-Force
i was waiting on your review to make sure i wasnt wasting my money. i knew i didnt want to spend that extra money, but you explained it so well!! thank you!!
Disney works with people who are technically incredible and competent but fails to hire competent writers. They are more about the look than the content.
OG Mulan: A beautiful girl that plunges herself into a very harsh training with an all male platoon, which eventually she conquers and gets recognition for her efforts. nu-Mulan: A beautiful girl that already has power, ability, and skills that makes her powerful but is forced to keep it in check due to plot. One is about progression, the other is about suppression. One is inclusion through merit-based recognition, the other is exclusion due to fear of sticking out.
That sounds awfully familiar to another Disney IP where the original had a hero who starts of inexperienced and throughout the trilogy grows to be a wise experienced fighter but the new one stars a hero who is good at everything from the start
Funnily enough, the original story of Mulan (called the "Ballad of Mulan") actually does have Mulan be trained in fighting, archery, and sword fighting by the time she enlists in the army. But this is in great contrast to her first depiction in the story, which is her in front of a loom (considered a feminine symbol). So basically, the original story still shows Mulan focusing on getting the job done and saving her father whilst contrasting traditional feminine roles (symbolized by the loom). A much more respectable premise than how they try to force the "girl power, fighting traditional feminine stereotypes" message down our throats in most movies nowadays, I'd say.
Mulan was always my favorite princess. She EARNED everything through HARD WORK, but this Mulan was already born with her albilities. Also, I think the music was really needed
“I expected nothing, and I’m still let down”. It’s clear that Disney doesn’t understand its own movies, but as long as they keep making money they keep butchering their movies.
Spoiler. But the part where there training and in remake they carry water up the hill, no one can do it but her which showed what? That a girl is stronger?? But In the Original they had to climb a pole and get the arrow. Her being a woman she sees a different strategy then the men, which was great. Her having another strength then the men at the time.
When I first heard about this live action remake I was kind of excited to see it. Especially when I heard it wasn’t going to be a musical. I hoped that it would be a compelling story more centered on the culture and the seriousness of war. Instead I got a bland movie where the main character had absolutely no growth and no personality.
You bet your ass. Before all this woke garbage infested pop culture, it was just a catchy song that the audience could sing along to. Nowadays some snowflake will get triggered and write an article slamming it as an endorsement of toxic masculinity or what have you.
You never not liked a movie once you got into it? dude, that's just saying you have no taste and you are a NPC eating down anything given to you. Learn to have you own opinion on stuff, its okay to not like a work of art. Also you cant just decide to like something, what you like is based on what you stand for.
This movie was truly inspiring. Its shows you that as long as you work hard and believe in yourself AND are born with incredible magical powers, you can do anything
I like the idea of having a villain that is a parallel to Mulan. We get a sense of who she could become if she decided to turn evil. It's like the parallel between Frodo and Gollum, because the audience gets a sense of an innocent protagonist becoming evil if they give in to the one ring. Mulan still chose to be a good person despite the fact that she was caught and outcasted.
It would have been a good idea but it doesn't fit here because Mulan wasn't supposed to be this amazingly perfect. Mulan isn't the best warrior but she's clever and hard working and earns the respect
I love his energy. He makes you energetic just watching him talk. And he’s always consistent with his presentation and videos, unlike some reviewers of movies and video games on UA-cam (I won’t mention who) that lost their energy and fun as they got older and more popular. He still keeps it fun and exciting. And we should all appreciate that.
I don’t hate women, but what I do hate, is paying 30 bucks just to have a crazy agenda shoved down my throat telling me men are bad, evil, stupid, untrustworthy etc, and telling me women are perfect, virtuous, good, compassionate, incapable of evil, good intentioned etc, maybe some simps like being told that, not me. We men and women are both humans and we both have good and bad, no need to virtue signal in a Disney movie
totalynotfunny guy Sorry, I should have added a /sarc to that post. Anyone who un ironically says this is someone who doesn’t argue in good faith and isn’t interested in a discussion. They just want to virtue signal.
OMG! I recognize the names of the actors, like Donnie Yen, Tzi Ma, Rosalind Chao (ST tng), Gong Li, Jet Li... Most of them do not really have dramatic acting chops, but are more into action-martial art roles. I noticed that someone mentioned that the character played by Rosalind Chao was likeable and not boring, which makes sense, because she is a dramatic actor, not a martial arts/action actress. Gong Li plays her generic role. From your review, I am going to wait for a cheaper viewing option to see this movie. It sounds like the actors were generally miscast... Great Review JJ! Saved me some time and money!
AlleluiaElizabeth it’s Disney man, they always find a way usually unnecessarily combining elements of different characters to make a new one that is somehow blander than a middle school lunch
Apparently Chinese test audiences heavily objected to a point of the movie where Mulan and the love interest kissed. Not sure if that was Shang, but yeah, blame Disney and China (I do). I’m not watching this movie.
Quotes from reddit comments: The actor who plays Mulan has in several instances voiced the support of the Chinese Communist Party. She also spoke out on the Hong Kong protestors condemning their actions. That’s the reason why, among many things, people are upset with the movie. It's even worse when you realise that she is also a naturalised American citizen. Saying that others are not allowed the same democratic rights and freedoms that she enjoys as a U.S citizen is massively hypocritical
Black Ninja exactly! Ironically Will was the only good thing about Aladdin, (after all the genie backlash). The other actors were so boring and the set design was horrible too, you could tell it was shot somewhere in the Disney backlot. So below average, they didn’t put any effort into anything!!
Mulan 1998: "I'll Make Man Out of You"
Mulan 2020: "I'll Make $30 Off of You"
EB081997 More like $40- near $50 when you add the service fee plus I assume tax.
$35 CAD So I'll have to pass.
¡¿ 🏴☠️ ?!
@@FullmoonPhantom-dn2sr plus the subscription to disney+ if you don't have one
And that's *all* they made, as this movie is bombing harder than Ghostbusters 2016.
Rotten tomatoes gives it 82% Ign gives it 8/10
Everyone I trust: “this movie sucks”
Disney scams everything, including the Oscars
Imdb has it at 4/10 so there's hope.
Disney bought them
@@Zombiesnyder13 yup except for those last Asoka episodes in Clone Wars and the new Mandalorian series. I thought those were really good
its been this way ever since 2017 bro
Disney is TRYING to use people’s nostalgia to get money but they don’t even understand what made the originals special!
who are you and how are you so wise in the ways of science?
they know what made them special, effort. But why put in effort when the window licking, knuckle dragging masses will still gleefully shell out whatever price asked fo them, as long as they can chase that nostalgia high and pretend for a second they're little kinds again who have hopes and dreams, not sad adults busting their asses for fifty hours a week just so they can barely afford to live in squalor.
@Winifred Eghrudje I don't know about you but I haven't seen anyone saying "Disney is doing well on Disney pulse."
Can you imagine when Biden takes office how bad these movies pushing agendas will be?
nor do they care
I take solace in the fact that Chinese audiences ALSO HATED THIS MOVIE.
The female actress who portrayed Mulan isn't even well liked by Chinese audiences to begin with.
@@dickmelsonlupot7697 Is it? I thought only the Hong Kong activists dislike her?
the actress is famous for her "acting" in china, that's why some Chinese hate her
@@theorosamadamba8095 Interesting....wonder what that is
bestwl her “outstanding acting performance” 🤣
I love how other reviewers point out "this is a more realistic take on Mulan" then show the hawk that turns into a lady.
Lol
Realism is boring. In games, I can land a 900 on a skateboard. If I do it irl, I'll likely die or end up a vegetable. Not to mention a skateboard costs 120$+ while Tony Hawk Pro Skater can go for 30$ish.
And there was a talking dragon in the animated one and still people loved it. This isn't about realism. This is about the message. The message of being responsible and being there for your family.
Imagine if Fast and Furious (4-8) is more realistic.
@@christmg4682 oh yeah that sounds a lot better than my silly comparison. Yeah man I agree. Question is, what does Mulan (2020) stand for?
Hats off for Disney. They introduced all of these changes in a movie loved by Western audiences to cater to the Chinese market and they managed to please neither.
Top 10 epic fails
If they want to "cater to the chinese markets", they should have hired someone who understand Chinese culture.
Tommy Lei 雷 yes but the movie mulan meant a lot to us and it broke our hearts they changed it like that but good for you guys
Tommy Lei 雷 yeah I mean if it was a new movie it would be understandable bu since e original was made and brung into us it hurts us a little and you too
@Tommy Lei 雷 Gongli being punished for being a witch makes no sense. Anti-witch sentiment is a European Christian thing. The costumes were also kind of odd and the architectural settings seem out of place. The round buildings called 'tulou' in the movie were found in Southern China (Mulan takes place in Northern China) and tulous wasn't even a thing yet
Mulan's sister was so unnecessary. They only needed her to scream when she saw the spider.
They added her to play off the sister relationship in Frozen. Disney! You can do better! Ugh 😩
This whole movie was so Unnecessary lol
When Mulan had a little brother in the original poem.
This entire movie was unnecessary.
@@yeilyn24 really?
The thought of “Dishonour on you, dishonour in your whole family, dishonour on your cow” not being in the movie makes me sad 😞
The line IS the movie.
They tried with the warrior dude, but they didn't say cow so.. whats the point..>? Can you imagine when Biden takes office how bad these movies pushing agendas will be?
@@MaesComedia scram. Noone wants to hear your political bs
🔴💗💘💗
One of the best lines in any Disney film! I wanted Eddie Murphy to come back
Making Mulan "the chosen one" just took away all the badassness in her.
She was chosen in the original animation. She was the awakened great stone dragon. It's imagery shown throughout the sequence of her cutting her hair & suiting up. That's why mushu couldn't wake it up. It was already awoken in mulan.
Kendall L. Buchanan she’s not the chosen one. She put herself in the ordeal, like the girl in the hunger game. The animation dragon stuff was released by the ancestors to protect her because of her courage. There is nothing chosen about her.
@@newp848 she might've been chosen one in some sense but all around she had to prove herself through hard work and her wits that she is equally capable of being a warrior and a hero.
This new Mulan just uses the power of Chi to solve everything to the point that I think the Chi allows her to teleport considering how the movie was cut.
I haven't seen the new Mulan. I just meant to say she was chosen to be uplifted and protected in the animated one. I wasn't referring to any prophesy. Sorry
I always got the impression from the movie that every family in that world had a house dragon protector. It never came across as a chosen-one thing, but Disney's way to redo the success that was Robin Williams' genie from Aladin.
Disney: We want this to be realistic, so no mushu.
Also Disney: yOu GuYs WaNt A mAgIc WiTcH lAdY
YESSSS!! Lol xD
Throw her in the brothel
Why Disney... Why have you done this
I like how Screen Rants Pitch Meeting described it at the end. Not exact quote.
That sounds like a fun movie. No it not.
It wasn't about being realistic. It offended a lot of viewers in China and they've become a huge market so it was financially stupid to offend them again and risk losing out on millions of viewers. But as a Chinese American, this movie looks fucking stupid and definitely needed mushu and the songs
“I Expect Nothing and I'm Still Let Down”
-Dewey Wilkerson
Joke's on you. You went to see it. Ooh la la mister igotmoneytoburn
@@slimcoolsmusings1152 Joke's on you. I pirated it
Slim Cool was invited to a party which ended up showing it.
@@slimcoolsmusings1152 congratulation, you wasted money
Id rather not have it than use it like that
Disney seem to have forgotten the golden rule: story before everything else. Pixar learnt this in their very first film and completely changed it because they knew that the story wasn't working.
Thats an interesting way to spell "virtue signaling"
I'm sorry, the story of Toy Story "wasn't working" ...? Dafuck ?
@@MeraHarch Toy Story was majorly reworked pretty far into its development because the stories and characters weren't endearing. I specifically remember hearing that Woody was kind of a huge dick in the original. So, they reworked a lot of the story to make it what it is today. Pretty sure that's what OP meant.
But I would say, that it has to be dynamic and hand to hand with its characters, otherwise it just falls apart (Last of Us 2).
@@medhanshsankaran595 It's the fact that the message is trying to send is hypocritical. Abby who fulfills her every insatiable desire of revenge gets to get away with it while Ellie who stops is now in the worst spot on her life and has hit rock bottom that she could never bounce back from ever again.
Jeremy: "I no longer look forward to disney live action remakes"
People who've been hating the remakes for years: *_ODIN IS WITH US_*
The Junglebook one was alright when it came out, the problem is Disney is so creatively bankrupt that they have to remake their past successes for any chance of selling tickets. And usually, the past successes' 2D classical animation is far nicer to look at. On top of that, story goes overboard in typical hollywood style to be more surface level entertainment than having much substance. and so usually doesn't compete with the original anyway...
Remakes are already a bad enough cash grab to do, but when the remake is worse and less enjoyable than the classics, it's just pointless. And yeah, maybe their purpose is to sell them to a new generation, but if I had kids I wouldn't be showing them the remakes.
I have not seen one live action remake in theaters and all the one that I have seen at home or on UA-cam suck
Personally, I am becoming more and more artistically terrified for the alleged upcoming remake of “The Hunchback of Notre Dame” with David Henry Hwang as the supposed writer.
Ever since I fell in love with the animated musical, read the original book, and saw how the Disneyfied stage plays like “Der Glöckner Von Notre Dame” could create a nice blending of both versions (even to the point of Esmeralda dying at the end), I always wanted a live-action remake to exist that tries something similar. The idea has been in my head, even before the live-action remakes became a Disney fad, and I even did my own fan projects of it on my UA-cam channel. But now, unless Disney both realizes that they cannot just coast on nostalgia with Hunchback and lets its writers make a dark and dramatic musical with passion, the remake that Disney releases is likely going to figuratively hurt me far more than any others have yet.
I don't exactly "hate" the movies, but I haven't watched any of them, and don't plan to, they stank heavily of "money grab" from the beggining. My time is better spend ... anywhere else really XD. and Holy Moly $30 on top of the suscription? REALLY? At that price tag I can just pre-order Cyberpunk 2077 and (most likely) be thoroughly entertained for tenths or maybe even hundreds of hours.
The only one I actually enjoyed was Beauty and the Beast..
Spoiler alert:
Mulan is force sensitive.
And a massive Mary Sue
I think she's the granddaughter of the tyrannical Emperor Qin Shi Huang.
She's about to fight all of the sith with her Jedi powers. No wait
Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Witch Lady the Hawk?
Oh dear Mulan.. try me baby, I'm all about it..
There was zero character growth for Mulan. As a child Mulan is this super powerful, ultra agile, supremely gifted mary sue. Goes off the war and has to pretend to be just another weak wimpy little man (yuck). Then decides she is a superhero, screw all this hiding.
This is NOT character growth.
The character growth is shown by her deciding to show her true self. Being loyal brave and true is the thing they show the most and she realized she needed to be true to her heart. I liked that she chose to show herself instead of being found out. It shows the integrity and the braveness of mulan
@@margaretbakly7810 When a character starts off as an amazing prodigy then hides it then later shows what she was from the start it is not character growth.
That is called a mary sue character.
In the original she went from somebody that had no idea what she was doing to absorbing the training and dedicating herself to BECOMING better for herself, her fellow warriors, her family, and her nation. She worked her butt off for it. Not once was she shown as this spectacular specimen that just has all the talent. No, that would be boring. Instead she was shown as a great woman who overcame the prejudice of a nation that didn't think women should fight and she overcame the absolute terror so her dad wouldn't go out and die. Risk is what makes a hero. Showing everybody how fabulous she already was is not a heroic journey.
@@margaretbakly7810 That literally makes zero sense .
This is the 2020 feminist model for writing female characters. If they had given Mulan flaws or a need for character growth, they’d have been accused of being misogynistic pigs.
@@geraldm4728 just to build on your comment. The "hero's journey" is a classical depiction of what a story centered on a hero needs to captivate the audience and make it relatable. There's the "journey" which is usually the hero struggling a LOT to become stronger/better. Then they have a big "crisis/failure". And then they do a "comeback/rise up". This movie straight up jumps the journey and the failure. They just jump the journey. They change the crisis to "slight discomfort" and then they change the big comeback to "no discomfort". As a viewer you have no interest built up, from the start we know exactly everything that's going to happen, which is nothing special.
Try to play an RPG where you from the start have all the best gear, the highest level and every skill. Then come tell me how fun of a game it was to walk to the end. The struggle is what people love, people love the "underdog" and they always will, cause the masses are petty.
I was looking forward to a “historically accurate” take on Mulan... obviously this was not it 😑 they took out the “magical” elements for.... more magical elements??? WTF DISNEY 🤦🏻♀️
I think ppl say the 2009 one is what you're looking for
the term "historically correct" got me excited as well. Thought we'd get a more realistic glimpse of chinese culture, lifestyle and traditions and what impact war can have.
Instead we got a witch lady, barely a phoenix and jedi powers...
Just look at their 4 credited writers, all of them aren't even asian much less chinese.
Which wouldn't matter, if they had did their homework but boy did they butcher up a classic.
Some entitled western tweeters might tell their peers "this movie was not made for Western tastes" so don't judge.
But anyone with any asian connection will tell you this is movie wasn't made for anyone's taste.
My gf and sister never got along but this movie united them in hatred for destroying their childhood empowerment story.
Look up "Mulan Rise of a Warrior." Its fantastic and realistic. This is the Mulan story you are looking for.
Same I wanted a realistic and thoughtful tale, not this character super power garbage and witch villain. The original annimation is still a masterpiece.
Damn, I haven't heard Jeremy actually be pissed at a movie in a while.
I've seen him rip a movie apart, I've seen him be disappointed and defeated, but actually being salty at a movie has been a while.
Well, you clearly haven't watched his rise of Skywalker review then...
Nah, that goes to Artemis Fowl. Also by Disney......
I was more excited for Jeremy’s rant than the movie itself lol
@@johngreen8921 no dip it was created by Disney
This film clearly was written and directed by people that literally have zero clue or understanding of Asian culture. Seriously, passing off Tai Chi as "the Force", were they frigging stoned when they thought that would be enough to explain Mulan's supernatural abilities to be amazing? X)
Wait a minute they said Mushu would ruin their realistic gritty movie about the actual Mulan. But a Hawk witch lady is totally cool. Smh
I think you misunderstood what they’re attempt was then. This is based on the real myth which has mystic elements. They didn’t want Mushu because his existence is just for jokes. Granted Mushu was actually good and the witch lady did nothing besides witch stuff.
They were trying to go into the Hong Kong fantasy period piece kind of vibe but didn't realize what Hong Kong does to make it work
Snyder sucks deep to the very core though...
@@aaronlevine6498 Why are you talking about Snyder lol no one brought him up
akshay satish Bruh, it has a 46% on Rotten Tomatoes audience score chill tf out. Also, IMDb has a low score for it because MONTHS before the movie even released some kid made a hundred alts and gave it 1 star reviews with random BS in the review. In the end, so what about critic scores anyway? You’re free to have an opinion on a movie being good or not and fake scores shouldn’t define that
Disney: We want to make the remake more realistic
also Disney: ChArActER dEvElopmEnt is NOT ReAlisTIC
Actors did well
The 2009 Chinese Mulan movie: the rise of a warrior is way better than this.
Can't think any previous version worse than this one.
@@KnightKao Mulan 2 is pretty bad too haha
I remember seeing that! Don’t get why they needed this remake when the 2009 film is there and takeout mushu and Shang and the songs that everyone loved 😡
@@singamummy8420 One reason, money.
Yes the 2009 was great, the 2020 matchless mulan wasn't that bad either
What disappointed me the most was that, in the cartoon she succeeds in gains the respect of the other people around her by using her insights to compensate for her lack of strength, she's smart and hard-working, and that is how she gets ahead, in the movie it just felt like oh, she has magic chi, so you know, I guess we believe her.
Rebekah Rhodes Film, not a cartoon
A lot of people are not aware that Mulan is not an original Disney story
@@tar_a I am aware that it isn't, but I'm pretty sure there isn't a witch lady or use of magic chi in the original Chinese story. At least I've never come across it in other adaptations even ones that are hailed as being more true to the original.
Rebekah Rhodes in the original story she buys her own horse and sets off for war and she possessed the necessary fighting skills to hold her own amongst her comrades. Some adaptations make her more badass than this and all adaptations portray her as a warrior.
@@MemeMan99 when the cartoon made more sense than the live action movie.
Totally agree with "dumb af" here. As an Asian woman, this movie try SO HARD to make us feel right, but honestly it just makes me feel yucky! It's fake feminism, like the animated version has so much more realism in terms of being a woman in Asian family & the kind of weight that comes with it. And don't get me started with Mulan's Jedi power. Like come onnn, the reason why people love Mulan is because she's just a normal girl who work harder & find more creative ways to solve problems. She doesn't have the body strength, but she's got the wit & much faster. She embrace her uniqueness instead of unleash her hidden force 🙄.
I really wonder how Disney define "realism", because their animation are just so much more realistic (emotion & logic) than the live action.
Because this movie is not to show feminism, just to appease the 'specific audience' if you know what I mean.
Missing some S's
This is what happen when boomers who doesn't know current trend try to understand the trend by employing feminist intern.
It's funny how Mulan's theme can be used for the pro-democratic Hong Kong protests
Animated Mulan: The story of a woman trying to survive in a man's world, but through intense training and military discipline, she ultimately earns everyone's respect and is recognized as a hero for her bravery against impossible odds, quick thinking, and weapon skills she learned at boot camp. proving women can be just as good as men
Live action Mulan: The story of a woman dominating in a man's world through the use of magic... because you know, women can't survive without handicaps. hard work is for men. women are born godly
And this isn't even to mention the CCP credits controversy. Yeesh, Disney.
China also release a mulan movie called matchless mulan that was good and mulan rise of a warrior was terrific 👏 from like 2009
Remember:
CCP having literal death camps within view of the cast and crew - Gets heartfelt thanks from Disney
Georgia having a pro-life stance - Lifelong ban on any filming and outraged condemnation from Disney.
@@Noplayster13 Pretty consistent: they're in support of killing people lol
The live action disney signify this era of disney, sucking the joy out of everything
And they're not done yet!
Slim Cool what movie is next?
Can you imagine when Biden takes office how bad these movies pushing agendas will be?
And ca$h
@@MaesComedia thankfully biden never going to be in office
The movie teaches people to be themselves, if they are hiding their grandiouse superpowers.
It’s her chi guys lol it’s her chi xD, chi is the answer to everything lol
Xi is the answer to everything
@@f0lkblues exactly, its fucking magic I tell you xD
Typical Walt Disney magic right there.
"Because when everyone is super no one is"
The original Mulan showed her strength in her intelligence, not in her physical strength. She learned to fight in the army, sure, but that wasn't her main strength. Her fighting skills helped her defensively, not offensively. She took down Attila the Hun, sorry I mean Chenggis Khan... dang it I forget his name. Anyways, she doesn't fight the big baddie head on. She outwits him. The moment she got his sword from him and pinned down his tunic with it, it was Mushu who finished him off. Mulan was known for her planning, her strategy, just like when she took down 99.9% of the Hun army with an avalanche. THAT is the Mulan we love, because it shows that, in a world where the strongest people have power, Mulan doesn't have what it takes in strength alone, but can inspire people with strategy in order to fight back. That was her strong suit. The "girl power" thing doesn't work, especially not in Ancient China where everything is decided by the skill and strength of a man's sword.
its not even her strengh but the magical chi!!!!
exactly what i wanted to say but put perfectly thank you
@@thomassowellaudiobooks6441 , Chi is not magical powers. Everyone has Chi but not everyone can use Chi as they are not taught to harness Chi. Basically, in Chinese wuxia (fantasy martial arts) stories, Chi has always been a vital element where the hero/heroin outperforms other people. Anyway, if you follow the original story of Mulan, she was supposed to be an accomplished fighter even before she joins the army. If you're not a good fighter, you would not last 12 years in the army fighting the Rourans.
Guy Mor , they are making a Disney wuxia / Chinese fantasy martial arts movie. Chi in those stories are not superpowers or magic. You just need to find a sifu/sensei to teach you in those stories. Anyway, a lot of Chinese people believe in Chi but it does not work like movies. The best example is tai chi exercise you see a lot of Chinese people do. It is supposed to improve your breathing and indirectly improve your strength and health too
@@thomassowellaudiobooks6441 , Like I say, it is not magic. If you've watched wuxia stories since young, you'll understand what is Chi in those stories. It's not like a chosen one, force sensitive or even mutant powers. Everyone has Chi but people only become Chi expert if they are taught to harness it. It wuxia stories, Chi is linked to kungfu. It is part of kung fu where you need to learn and practise, then only you can use it. The movie made a big mistake. If they just insert a scene or two showing her father teaching her, it will make more sense.
I like how Disney wanted this movie to be realistic but they literally had a scene where the main bad guy catches an arrow right to his face while riding on a horse then the bad guy and his henchmen jump off horses and climb up walls using only their feet great job Disney for making it realistic! 🤦♂️
The way they ran up the wall was retarded haha...
I mean catching an arrow right to his face is not unrealistic at all but running up walls is just nonsense.
This movie is a disaster.
Almost all Chinese agree that.
bruh,go away
@@juanlu3958 no u
@@solinvictus2045 The funniest thing about this movie is that people holding different political views can find different reasons to hate this movie.
Chinese nationalists: It's typical Hollywood propaganda.
The Republican conservatives and Chinese dissidents: this is CCP propaganda.
And the Democrats: This is misogynism propaganda.
LOL
@@lishiping84 this is true af lmao
Disney: "The live-action Mulan won't have Mushu. We want to keep this movie realistic as possible, to respect Chinese culture"
Fans: "Understandable, have a great day"
also Disney: "So anyways, here's a shape-shifting witch with supernatural powers"
*VISIBLE CONFUSION*
Just finished it now an not sure how I feel. No Mushu but you have a pointless Phoenix and a shapeshifter with questionable motive l lol. Should have just bought weed hahahaha
@@christophernazario2375 Could've bought a perfectly good eighth with that 30 lmao
@@qp7975 from your mouth to Gods ears forrel
@@qp7975 now I have to call my dealer an Explain why I'm suddenly buying in bulk lol
Christopher Nazario I rather spend it on a lap dance
[How I will remember the movie]
*Mulan Animation:* "I'll Make a Man out of You."
*Mulan Live-Action:* ...I lost $30.
How I will remember the movie... a comedy, but slightly disappointed that Mulan didn’t go for the General’s daughter or become the Emporer’s next concubine.
One of the best songs too
I lost $30
30 dollar is just not good for all the single person out there, living far far from the family.
You should’ve pirated it
My mom: I love this remake. It doesn’t make sense why everyone hates it.
Me: _You wouldn’t get it._
Melody snow And this was after they refused to film anything in Georgia because of “moral objections” to the state’s pro-life laws.
My mom saw what was wrong from the start and likes the animated more. Never felt proud before😂
Tell your mom to see the reviews from actual Chinese people.
It makes a lot of sense why people shit on this movie.
I liked it especially the fighting parts
So, I just watched the Mulan 2020 movie. This will have spoilers so be warned.
Now, this is going to be an unbiased review, where I will ignore the fact that the main actress supports police brutality in Hong Kong.
So what do I think of this movie?
If I could describe one word to this movie, its that it is very Soulless.
The only character that I genuinely liked was Donnie yen of course.
Now, to get to the meat of this movie on why it felt soulless, let’s look at what the animated movie had.
Mushu.
The Exclusion of important characters.
Mushu to Mulan was like what the Genie was to Aladdin.
or Timon and Pumba was to Lion King
Yeah, Aladdin and Simba were the main characters. But what made the movie went from “good” to near masterpiece was because of Genie, timon and Pumba. Their charming personalities and wacky content made the movies they were in from “good” to near masterpiece. If those characters werent in the movie, then the movies probably wouldnt be well-liked.
Same with Mushu. Mushu brought the spark and energy that Mulan needed, which is why Mulan is genuinely a great film.
Now, I understand that this movie is trying to be a movie about the real Mulan, and not the animated Mulan. But….. it has the same story elements as the animated Mulan. This movie is like a combination of the 2009 Chinese Mulan movie, and the Mulan cartoon. As a result it feels weird.
Mushu, a great and likeable character, turns into…. a phoenix that acts as a map for Mulan.
This movie also did not have Captain Li Shang from the animated movie.
Li Shang was probably my favorite character. He was the perfect example of a male side character in a female led character done right. He was developed, had a likeable personality, and was very charismatic.
Li Shang was split into two people, but those characters were kind of boring.
The second problem with this movie is
2. The Lack of Music
Now, i understand the director wanting to make it realistic, after all warriors dont just randomly sing out of nowhere.
However, the problem with this is that the movie was boring.
I am sorry, but like I said, this movie is trying very hard to be accurate to the real Mulan story, and seemingly copies the 2009 mulan movie in china.
But this movie also tries to lighten the tone and just slap a Disney label on it. See, the 2009 Mulan movie is actually more accurate imo.
But when I was watching this movie and seeing how this movie is trying to resemble like the original animated movie, I got bored and realized part of my boredom was that there were no songs.
I think what made the live action movies remakes at least more bearable to watch were the songs because it could keep me interested. This movie doesnt have the Who I am song.
But most importantly, it does not have the top 5 best Disney songs of all time “I’ll Make a man out of you.”
Finally, the reason why this movie wasnt good
3. The villains
The animated mulan movie had a villain name Shan Yu.
The villain was not developed, but he was menacing. Seriously, the animated movie had darker themes than the live action.
In the live action, heres the problem. There are two villains.
What made Shan yu threatening and menacing was that he was the main villain. But in this movie, we get two villains, and as a result the villains dont feel developed or memorable.
Seriously. this woman sides with Mulan in the end because she’s “a woman” or “Female empowerment.” or something.
Like no offense, but if you’re going to betray your partner for the opponent simply because the opponent is a “woman”…. that’s not going to be satisfying.
One more thing.
4. Mulan
This is really personal. Because believe it or not, Mulan is my favorite Disney princess. No, its not because she’s Asian.
Mulan was my favorite because she ws relatable. She was the underdog.
Mulan was one of hte few characters who had flaws and lost battles. But she did whine and complain like a good girl? No, she sucked it up, overcame many challenges and became a worthy warrior. She proved that she didnt need to have masculine features to be a warrior, all it take was hard work and perserverance to achieve greatness.
So what did this live action do? Well, it made Mulan the Chosen One.
So what happened was they turned Mulan, a beloved Disney princess into a Mary Sue for their live action movies, like rey from star wars.
Mulan in the live-action is nearly perfect, she succeeds almost all the time. She is the Chosen One, she is destined to defeat the bad guy. When you tell me it was her destiny to defeat an invading army, I am sorry but I lose interest in the character.
In conclusion, this movie wasn’t memorable. It was boring. I am officially over the live action hype train. No, its not because its led by a female individual.
Its because this movie felt boring or souless. It was way too long, didnt have heart in it. This movie didnt have any memorable characters, dialogue too long, and lack of developing villains.
Review for this movie: 4 out of 10.
Actually, soldiers sing all the time. It takes the edge off
Why would I pay $30 to watch an inferior rehash of a 90s classic, when I can watch all the 1998-2005 Disney Shows + All The Classic Simpsons episodes + The Mandalorian + The original Star Wars trilogy (and Revenge Of The Sith) + every MCU film, etc. for just $10 bucks a month, such a rip off
Yet you're paying the same company for all this who made this movie. Sucker
@@UNKNOWNANG3L I got it free for a year. I'll just watch the cartoon Mulan for free
I’ve seen you on the music review channels, the madden channels, and now movie reviews too.
And you can watch it for free (monthly subscription) on December 4
Agreed
According to IGN, this movie is GREAT with an 8 rating... Yeaa Jeremy's review seems more realistic
IGN reviews have always been garbage
same with rotten tomatoes it has 81 critic score
8/10 not too much water
Why? Because you don't want this movie to be good?
ur a hater jeremy a hater too
“I’m Rey”
“Rey who?”
“Rey Hua Mulan ”
lol
Rey Venge of the Sith
At least Rey had more emotion, personality & a fucking character arc compared to live-action Mulan.
@Neo's danger dude he just saying his own opinion why are you so mad over an opinion and I agreed Ray has more emotion than Mulan.
Jeremy:
Her father has no sons
My brain, immediately:
“My father has no sons so IM the one who has to social climb for one, cus I’m the oldest n the wittiest n the gossip in New York City is Insidious...
And now I’m penniless. Ha! Disney couldn’t care any less.
Lol what??
@@TheEntity0 Hamilton, lol
Hahahahaha
@@ghenesapaulma1963 ok, gotcha, thanks
Disney: we want it to be historically accurate so no music :(
Also Disney: *has her run on walls and magic*
She apparently has a steel sword, even though steel did not exist at that time in China. Was first invented in India, apparently not done in China until 500 years after Mulan. "3rd century AD - China is commonly credited with being the first mass producers of high-quality steel."
Yes. Historically accurate to the tales of Mulan. Key word is 'tales'.
@@warrenlauzon5315 Mulan is set after the third century in China. I am not aware of a version that sets Mulan before the Northern Wei Dynasty (386-534CE) during and in which territory the first version of Mulan in the ballad of Mulan was written. I think you are confusing the Han-Xiongnu war(141-87 BCE) for the setting of Mulan I can understand as the original Mulan is a confusing mess of Chinese and generally East Asian culture, history and setting. However from the uniforms, sets and general style Disney's 2020 Mulan seems to be set during the Tang Dynasty(618-907CE) when most of the most famous telling's of Mulan were written and set and that is well after the 3rd century.
@@gilesbarnes7456 wow
It was simply a movie for a chinese market. Nothing more.
Maybe we should stop making live action copies of animated films
Disney: Nah, it'll be fine.
They could have easily not have said it wasn't a remake but another adaption or retelling of the legend of Mulan
Do we watch the same drunk Scottsmen?
We don't mind them making a live action of the anime but............... DO THE GOT DAMN THING RIGHT AND DON'T HAVE ASS IT AND NOT VIRTUE SIGNALING MESSAGES.
@TheAnonymousGamer Pretty sure he is Scottish. Unless there actually is another.
"But you sexist fool I hear you say"
Guys do yourself a favor and watch the 2009 version 'Mulan: Rise of a Warrior'.
Nah
@@melviness4769 it's way better dude and it's on youtube
This is seriously a bad movie. Even as a movie, it fails at so many basic aspects required to make a film that it makes the filmmakers seem extremely incompetent.
It's not bad have u people are trolls half of u probably didnt even watch it stf with ur bs far from a bad movie
No heart.
No humor.
No reason.
No thank you.
That's what everyone should hear when they think about this movie.
Jack Healy “Without respect, we reject.”
These are great 😂
No Mushu, No Cricket, no granny, no ghost ancestors, no dramatically cutting her hair with a sword scene...
NO HONOR FOR THE EMPEROR
Well said
"The greatest gift and honour is having you for a daughter" how in God's name did they omit that powerful line?!
Man this line still makes me teary to *this* day!! That's how much Disney effed up!
Maybe it isn't that powerful?
He basically said it at the end of the movie 🤦♂️did you even watch it ?
@@justafidemyself impact of this line. U n I can qoute anything but it will never have the effect of the OG qoute of .0001%
It wasn’t omitted. That line is in the movie.
This movie was so boring. 5/10 and I'm being very kind
too kind, actuallly
I gave it a 2. It's not close to being good as the 1998 Mulan nor the live action Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
Also the way it's presented is lacking that "movie feel". It felt like I was watching a long and boring tv series.
I remember the villain in Disney's Mulan. Would Kill Children: Check.
He had some great lines!!
"The little girl needs her doll back."
@@toomuchpassion2361 Seriously tho he did
"Now all of China knows you're here"
"Perfect"
Took it like a champ
Why do so many films lack actual heart and depth nowadays and focus so much on realism and beauty?
Because in society these days everyone wants to talk about not the substance of the story, but the woke messages in it. Unfortunately, some think that the more woke something is, the less you need to try for it to be considered good.
@@RedLeif1 A movie made for the CCP is woke o.0 That just doesn't sound right with the massive slaughter and detention of people, to the organ harvesting for wealthy westerners.
The mainstream movie studios just wanna sell stuff that's committee driven to sell as much as possible rather than making a work of art or something interesting. If you want actual good movies, just move away from Disney. Check out the smaller studios making good movies, check out the international film industry or even give animation a try since a lot of animated movies are better than most live action films these days.
Because that's how most people in today's world are, as some of the other replies have stated.
It's this damn superficial push to make all stories pander to being "woke" and inclusive to all ideals and persons. Its superficial because its ALL ABOUT MARKETING. It's no longer about sending a message, it's all about that sweet $$$.
I WANT MY FUCKING MUSHU!
We should start a go fund me for Jeremy to give him back his $30
No
The actress that plays Mulan never stops supporting the Chinese Communist Party, boycott this movie
Dude she has the right to support whoever she wants...
Michelle Favre that’s the problem y’all are fine with ppl having an opinion on Chinese communism but when it’s Italian fascism everyone screams and tries to get you banned
Michelle Favre Would it be right to support Nazi Germany? Because that’s essentially what China is now.
Michelle Favre Agreed, but the CCP carries out atrocious human rights violations
This film also thanks several Chinese agencies directly responsible for the atrocities to the Uyghurs. Definitely boycott this film
I swear, the only good live action remake is The Jungle Book.
At least the director cared _a lot_ about the original film.
@@acrsclspdrcls1365 Too bad he didn't do the same for The Lion King.
I liked the remake of Cinderella. None of the other ones though.
I liked Aladdin live action to an extent as well, probably because of the soundtrack. And Beauty and the Beast but because of Lefou and Gaston mainly. And Jungle Book live action's tone is what exactly I'm looking for.
Pete's Dragon, Christopher Robin, 101 Dalmatians and Alice in Wonderland aka the good live action remake films for me. I'll stick with 1998 cartoon movie version whose I grew up with.
The thing is, in their attempt to make this movie more "woke" they ruined the positive female protagonist. In the original, Mulan was a normal girl who was being true to herself and by sheer determination and smarts, she prevails and saves China. In the remake, Mulan is not a normal girl, she was born with supernatural powers. So it wasn't what she chose to be, it was who she was born to me. This RUINS the positive message to children everywhere, but more especially the girls.
The original: "Girls, you can be just as good as the boys if you try hard and use your head!"
The Remake: "Girls, you can only be as good as the boys if you're magic!"
Mulan doesn’t have supernatural powers in the new film, she’s just gifted (albeit a little too much with cgi) but the whole message of the film is everyone is gifted in their own way and you shouldn’t hide from those gifts. In Mulans case her gift was her strategical sharpness that makes her a formidable foe to anyone .
Adam Moore exactly. If the message was “All girls could save China.” it would be disingenuous. The message of the remake was “Be true to who you really are.” Not everyone is gifted like Mulan, but do use your gifts to honor your family and help those you care about.
@@Adam-xb8xh strategical sharpness? I jist finished the movie and I don't think this phrase appeared in any point of the movie to describe Mulan. The phrase is “you have very good Chi” (smthg like that), which anyone else except the witch doesnt possess any in the movie.
I am a Chinese and I read bunch of chinese kingfu and chi related novels, and none of them have this kind of setting where only some of them have chi or chi is forbidden. The whole movie is just an OP character doing whtever she want which occasionally encounter a little inconvenience...
@@micahwright5901 not all girl should save china, or should do anything, but if any girl want to do something like the boys did, they can do it without super power.
@@331Dylan Let me guess, you're 1/128th Chinese? Lol.
Still don't understand why people still trust Disney. They messed up Alladin, the Lion King, and now Mulan. Every remake they do is inferior with the heart and soul removed
Not to mention what they did to Star Wars and Pirates of the Caribbean...
And Beauty & The Beast
Not to mention what it might to do to The Little Mermaid
Disney doesnt care about any of that. All they care about is the money. Theyre making billions off of these awful remakes
they’ve done a lot right, but lots of misses just like every single other movie production studio
the Last Jedi, Infinity War and Endgame are creative works of art, they will end up being the classic movies that define our era decades from now
don’t like their movies then don’t go see them, until these remakes aren’t profitable they will keep making them.....also, Aladdin was great and something different from the animation , improved the story in many ways
I refuse to watch any live action remakes at this point.
You are right they suck
This guy is brave, honest, and loyal for being honest about this film
I am not gonna pay 30 bucks for the movie. Sept 4 was supposed to be released but now dec 4th. I saw alot of reviews and said not worth my time and who has that money especially during this pandemic.
Jeremy is always honest, even if hes opinion goes against the majority
So they took everything that made the original great (music, mushu) and added gratuitous material that messed up the pacing, all with mediocre effects. So why did they make this movie again? Oh yeah money. This is kind of depressing.
They did it for a billion dollar box office.
So don't watch it please! Let's send Disney the message that we DO Not want these fucking remakes ever!
They took more of inspiration from the original story with inspiration from the animated with new things.
Technically the original animation isn’t the ORIGINAL. Disney based it off a story and added singing and all that jazz. This is more in line with the actual story. But I understand why people are mad since everyone was expecting the cartoon version.
KkRabbit45 agree 100%
Mushu being funny: *YOU MISSED HOW COULD YOU MISS?! HE WAS RIGHT INFRONT OF YOU*
Mushu being serious: *The truth is, we're both frauds. Your ancestors never sent me, they don't even like me. But you risked your life to help people you love. I risked your life to help myself. At least you had good intentions*
This is what the live action movie missed.
Takes Mushu out of the movie cause it's not "realistic"
*Has a shape-shifting witch*
People forget this .
Disney cynically has not heart anymore. The animation was from a time when people there still did. ($30? Really? **yikes**)
disney is a money grab they made billions off of marvel they couldn't have taken a hit on this one?
Thanks for taking the Mulan bullet for us. I was totally waiting to see a couple of reviews to confirm what pre-release news I'd heard.
I HOPE Disney loses a lot of money on this so they can finally stop with the live action remakes. I mean hell, you remember the 90s when we only had 3 remakes, both of which were really good? I mean hell, they were good because of how different they were, from the 94 Jungle Book that focuses on Mowglie's conflict between being human and animal (and was hella dark as hell) and 101 Dalmations that added a lot of humor to the film.
I personally don’t think it’s possible for Disney to come to that conclusion. They would probably think didn’t do well financially because of its release on Disney + for $30. Mulan 2020s financial success or failure has more control over if the same release strategy will be used for Black Widow.
they wont, cause a movie made for china will do well in china and china is more money then the rest of the world
I actually don’t mind the live action remakes I just haven’t liked the ones they released so far. Lion king , Aladdin and now Mulan are all horrible remakes and don’t follow the script and scenes 1:1 if any live action wants to be successful needs to be exactly like the original just with real people. That’s how I feel live action remakes will succeed
The only good cartoon to live action is 101 Dalmatians.
If it's a 1 to 1, scene for scene remake, then why make it in the first place? Why not save money and just re-release the one everyone already loves and just roll in the money?
They took out Shang, Crickee, Mushu, and I’ll Make A Man Out of You.
That was incentive enough for me to refuse to see this.
I feel like people didnt get the memo that Disney said they werent going for the animated movie. They were doing a different tale of Mulan that hasnt been told.
@@Ravenbones But can she manage to squeeze at least one more expression out of her face besides the blank too bored to be there face
twistedmetalplayer21 after doing shot for shot remakes for this long? No I don’t think people expected them to change course for this one.
@twistedmetalplayer21Obviously he got the memo that's why he is not watching it. If you like it so much go watch it 10 times then
@@Ravenbones even still, every single plot point is there. They followed the story board for the animation, but removed all of the elements that actually made it work and gave it charm, and added in an unnecessary witch subplot along with Disney's interpretation of Chi, which is basically Disney's version of "the force." No training necessary. You can do anything and everything you want for no inexplicable reason.
Whether Disney wanted to do something different or not, they copied the storyboard of the original, and added in a bunch of unnecessary filler, as if trying to reach a "differentiation" quota, rather than trying to do things different out of actually wanting to tell a unique story (which is an even clearer indication that they added these elements for no other reason than to appeal to the Chinese government).
And what's more, the original storyboard was made with music in mind, with music being the defining bond between scenes and events. You can't remove it and hope to have the same story. The entire thing had to be thrown out, and the movie had to be completely original. Instead, they went with the storyboard and whatever changes they made were so underdeveloped that the narrator had to literally step in halfway through the movie and tell us what should have been the payoff for a well-developed conflict. We got 2 scenes showing Mulan's shame in the lie, not helped by such wooden acting, and then the narrator to tell us she had had enough.
The movie was just contrived garbage. It had none of the connecting techniques, none of the charm and flow that the original had (despite Disney wanting to copy it with some alterations), and whatever they did add was so underdeveloped that it stuck out of the rest of the story like a sore thumb, noticeably forcibly inserted, not interwoven
There are some movies where when I leave the cinema I feel like a brand new person that wants to kickass.
*This is not one of them.*
The live movie script sounded like someone was trying to write a really long and formal letter...
I understand that Mulan chose to be herself, but why did she have to remove her armor before going into battle? That seems like a good way to die.
She does have armor....plot armor
For one it makes her lighter so she can move around easier, for 2 she has amazing reflexes and the armor can very well and easily get in the way of that and be more of a hindrance than help.
Why did she have to cut her hair in the animated cartoon?
Its a good thing she went into war with plot armor
You can’t move around at lightweight speeds when you have a sword in your chest...where armor should have been
The animated Mulan is dark. Not only are adults killed but so are children
I'm reading a reflection: a twisted tale where she goes to the underworld, nice use of 99 cents :)
2:00 no Mushu no peace.
4:25-4:30 feminism knows no boundaries lol hold my beer A-Force
Yeah, they are killed out of boredom
The children too? I didn't realise Anakin Skywalker was in Mulan?
@@HOTD108_ lol, the Huns are much darker than Anakin
Thanks for taking one for the team
i was waiting on your review to make sure i wasnt wasting my money. i knew i didnt want to spend that extra money, but you explained it so well!!
thank you!!
Even kingdom hearts mulan is better then this movie
I was waiting for this comment tbh
I wanted to like this comment, but since you're at 69 here's a comment
That level was fantastic.
Exactly what I was thinking. You know it's bad when a video game adaptation does it better.
Jeremy is cultivating his look to play Kurt Russell’s character in the Thing remake.
I'd watch that in a heart beat. I literally watched the original and prequel 3 days ago. Great films
We all are.
Or he's working toward being a Keanu Reeves double. Lol
@@alohacoach8002 technically the Howard hawkes version is the original and Carpenters is the remake.
@@PV1230 you right, you right....🤙
HOLY CRAP! Its been a few months since i’ve seen this guys vids His hair has become majestic!!
Disney works with people who are technically incredible and competent but fails to hire competent writers. They are more about the look than the content.
OG Mulan: A beautiful girl that plunges herself into a very harsh training with an all male platoon, which eventually she conquers and gets recognition for her efforts.
nu-Mulan: A beautiful girl that already has power, ability, and skills that makes her powerful but is forced to keep it in check due to plot.
One is about progression, the other is about suppression. One is inclusion through merit-based recognition, the other is exclusion due to fear of sticking out.
Expecting actual decent female characters from movies these days is futile.
And both has nothing to do with original mulan
What do you expect from the same people who think Alien/Aliens is sexist because Ripley has to "act like a man" to earn her keep?
That sounds awfully familiar to another Disney IP where the original had a hero who starts of inexperienced and throughout the trilogy grows to be a wise experienced fighter but the new one stars a hero who is good at everything from the start
Funnily enough, the original story of Mulan (called the "Ballad of Mulan") actually does have Mulan be trained in fighting, archery, and sword fighting by the time she enlists in the army. But this is in great contrast to her first depiction in the story, which is her in front of a loom (considered a feminine symbol). So basically, the original story still shows Mulan focusing on getting the job done and saving her father whilst contrasting traditional feminine roles (symbolized by the loom). A much more respectable premise than how they try to force the "girl power, fighting traditional feminine stereotypes" message down our throats in most movies nowadays, I'd say.
"This is coffee. Sometimes I need it when a movie bores me to sleep". Ouch 😅
That could've been the whole review vid lol
I thought, "So that's what we're leadin' with, huh? Lemme strap in..."
i really adore that you know how the review is going to go in the the first 10 seconds of the video
Mulan was always my favorite princess. She EARNED everything through HARD WORK, but this Mulan was already born with her albilities. Also, I think the music was really needed
“I expected nothing, and I’m still let down”. It’s clear that Disney doesn’t understand its own movies, but as long as they keep making money they keep butchering their movies.
And other franchises that doesnt belong to them as well too
Spoiler.
But the part where there training and in remake they carry water up the hill, no one can do it but her which showed what? That a girl is stronger??
But In the Original they had to climb a pole and get the arrow. Her being a woman she sees a different strategy then the men, which was great. Her having another strength then the men at the time.
Agreed. It’s like they made Mulan perfect and only she showed improvement
They dont have the arrow and pole scene!! 😯😯
If I can sum up this movie in one word, it's "Soulless."
When I first heard about this live action remake I was kind of excited to see it. Especially when I heard it wasn’t going to be a musical. I hoped that it would be a compelling story more centered on the culture and the seriousness of war. Instead I got a bland movie where the main character had absolutely no growth and no personality.
I’m guessing the song about being a man wasn’t in this version.
More like no music at all 😂
No songs. No humour at all.
Or a dragon 😔
You bet your ass. Before all this woke garbage infested pop culture, it was just a catchy song that the audience could sing along to. Nowadays some snowflake will get triggered and write an article slamming it as an endorsement of toxic masculinity or what have you.
This is just like removing that classic 'Be prepared' song from 'The Lion King' remake.
I really wanted to like this movie. Really did. I literally never not like a movie once I get into it but I seriously got bored SO FAST
You never not liked a movie once you got into it? dude, that's just saying you have no taste and you are a NPC eating down anything given to you.
Learn to have you own opinion on stuff, its okay to not like a work of art.
Also you cant just decide to like something, what you like is based on what you stand for.
@@MouseGoat agree!
@@MouseGoat disagree
@@MouseGoat well said man
Freedom Phoenix Goat chill out
Thanks for taking yet another one for the team
This movie was truly inspiring. Its shows you that as long as you work hard and believe in yourself AND are born with incredible magical powers, you can do anything
Y'all got me in the first half.
“Bores me to sleep”
Pretty much all you need to know about this movie
Or “Chris Bores me to sleep”, amirite?! XD
I wasn't bored at all 🤷♂️
Matt same. Loved it
"30 bucks to be bored out of my skull"
Lmfao
Pretty much
Should've just pirated it then
Geralt of Rivia Right, torrents exist for this very purpose. Don’t waste your bucks.
I like the idea of having a villain that is a parallel to Mulan. We get a sense of who she could become if she decided to turn evil. It's like the parallel between Frodo and Gollum, because the audience gets a sense of an innocent protagonist becoming evil if they give in to the one ring. Mulan still chose to be a good person despite the fact that she was caught and outcasted.
It would have been a good idea but it doesn't fit here because Mulan wasn't supposed to be this amazingly perfect. Mulan isn't the best warrior but she's clever and hard working and earns the respect
@L.N. I agree. that subplot in there just changed the entire movie for the worst
Hey watch out the new Mulan movie was shot in and actively supports the government officials of a city thats been genociding Muslims
This movie isn't even worth the damn sauce. - Rick Sanchez
😂😂😂
How dare you put words in my mouth.... but yes
*burp*
MORTY
😅😂🤣🤣😂😅
Szechuan sauce was sold at absurdly high prices. One man even gave his car in exchange of a dose of the sauce.
Mulan without "I'll make a man out of you" is a burger without the burger..
Great song for a cartoon.
you serious..... they took out the ONE song that is still played today. -_-;
And we didn't even get a side of limited-time szechuan sauce...
What made me cringe was the lack of diversity in there. No black person, white or latino. Like wtf?
Pretty sure they didn't have that song in the original Chinese story.
I love his energy. He makes you energetic just watching him talk. And he’s always consistent with his presentation and videos, unlike some reviewers of movies and video games on UA-cam (I won’t mention who) that lost their energy and fun as they got older and more popular. He still keeps it fun and exciting. And we should all appreciate that.
You are talking about Stuckmann, yeah that guy has always been a low energy boring ass and that shows in his reviews.
@@everythingisawesome2903 hello you
30 bucks to see a green screen Mary Sue? That’s a no from me dawg
Why do you hate women?
I don’t hate women, but what I do hate, is paying 30 bucks just to have a crazy agenda shoved down my throat telling me men are bad, evil, stupid, untrustworthy etc, and telling me women are perfect, virtuous, good, compassionate, incapable of evil, good intentioned etc, maybe some simps like being told that, not me. We men and women are both humans and we both have good and bad, no need to virtue signal in a Disney movie
totalynotfunny guy Sorry, I should have added a /sarc to that post.
Anyone who un ironically says this is someone who doesn’t argue in good faith and isn’t interested in a discussion. They just want to virtue signal.
Jared Price Yeah sorry bro I though you were serious 😂
“The visuals were great” is Hollywood’s equivalent of “She’s got a great personality”
Ironic that the lead actor does not have a great personality or acting talent for that matter
No, it's the equivalent of "she's hot".
I would take personality over look anytime, just as I would take story and acting over visuals.
Wouldn't it be vise versa? Great visuals would be "she looks hot, but nothing upstairs"
I feel it's more like... Well... At least she's pretty...
@@jaime_1660 that's stigmatized nowadays
this movie is pointless because the Disney animated exists and the 2009 (more closely based on the legend) exists, and no there is no witch hawk lady
Did you actually say "more closely based on the legend" ??? LMAO Wow.
@@Marvelhero24 Your point being? The legend is where the story comes from. It is the original source material that the film was adapted from.
Jack Louis Don’t you dare give a shit.
Really? Where is this movie?
@@Marvelhero24 idiotic zoomer detected
OMG! I recognize the names of the actors, like Donnie Yen, Tzi Ma, Rosalind Chao (ST tng), Gong Li, Jet Li... Most of them do not really have dramatic acting chops, but are more into action-martial art roles. I noticed that someone mentioned that the character played by Rosalind Chao was likeable and not boring, which makes sense, because she is a dramatic actor, not a martial arts/action actress. Gong Li plays her generic role. From your review, I am going to wait for a cheaper viewing option to see this movie. It sounds like the actors were generally miscast... Great Review JJ! Saved me some time and money!
It's nice to see that even a company that essentially prints money with whatever they produce is taken down a notch.
When they cut my boy Shang, I dipped out.
... Wait. They cut Shang? How do you cut Mulan's love interest???
AlleluiaElizabeth it’s Disney man, they always find a way usually unnecessarily combining elements of different characters to make a new one that is somehow blander than a middle school lunch
Same
@WindyQ they probably didn't do this so called "thinking" thing XD
Apparently Chinese test audiences heavily objected to a point of the movie where Mulan and the love interest kissed. Not sure if that was Shang, but yeah, blame Disney and China (I do). I’m not watching this movie.
Quotes from reddit comments: The actor who plays Mulan has in several instances voiced the support of the Chinese Communist Party. She also spoke out on the Hong Kong protestors condemning their actions. That’s the reason why, among many things, people are upset with the movie.
It's even worse when you realise that she is also a naturalised American citizen. Saying that others are not allowed the same democratic rights and freedoms that she enjoys as a U.S citizen is massively hypocritical
Well if its on reddit then it must be true. There's no bots on reddit. /s
@@jimduggan8962 I mean you can look up the facts for yourself, and form your own opinion.
Apparently she might have been forced to say that stuff by the Chinese government
Owen Conway you’re right, I read she was forced to say that.
@@rangelcarlos53 But nothing will force me to watch mulan
You can hear Jackie Chan's uncle screaming " Chi is not maaaaaagiiiccccc"
Haha ONE MORE THING!
Thank you and others for taking one for the team, Jeremy. No way I’m spending the $30.
The movie currently has a rating of 4.2/10 on IMDB, lol.
I mean, I trust Rotten Tomatoes far more than iMDB. And I don't trust Rotten Tomatoes.
@@MRauTObt rotten tomatoes sucks dav chappelle proved that.
That seems overly generous
It was 3.7 before the movie even came out so yeah
Imdb doesn't really count anybody can go on their and vote as many times as they like
This confirms it: I will never again raise my hopes for another Disney live-action remake.
A lot incoming......
You just learned that lesson? After how bland Aladdin was I stopped caring.
Millie007 Maybe it’s because I haven’t seen Mulan, so I didn’t have anything to gage against the trailers.
I stopped caring since the live-action Beauty and the Beast remake.
Black Ninja exactly! Ironically Will was the only good thing about Aladdin, (after all the genie backlash). The other actors were so boring and the set design was horrible too, you could tell it was shot somewhere in the Disney backlot. So below average, they didn’t put any effort into anything!!
Holy moly, I haven't watched anything from Jeremy this year and was pleasantly suprised with the hair! 😂😂😂
Wouldn't Mulan's father have been sent home right away, since he is unfit for battle?
Redshirt
Or he could be put in a non-combatant role.
Behind the Scenes Photos Put him on a horse and have him train and command troops. Problem solved.