Farmer Protest: Are the 3 Bills on MSP, contract farming & essential commodities pro or anti farmer?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 гру 2020
- PM Modi has had the guts to reform old and antiquated farm laws when previous attempts failed. But has he gone too far? Will MSP be done away with? Will APMCs go broke and will corporate house ruthlessly exploit farmers now?
#farmerprotest #msp #apmc
Sources
Times of India
Govt willing to amend some provisions of new farm laws; Vishwa Mohan & Neel Kamal; Dec 4, 2020
Don’t Kill 2nd Green Revolution; Rolling back farm reforms would privilege a small but vociferous group over the silent majority; Gurcharan Das; Dec 3, 2020
Here’s why farmers fear states may junk MSP system under new laws; Dec 2, 2020
Punjab passes 3 farm bills, 1st state to counter Central laws; Oct 21, 2020
Interview: Leena Nandan, secretary of the Centre’s department of consumer affairs; Oct 14, 2020
APMCs turnover 479% more than private markets in ’19-20; Priyanka Kakodkar; Oct 13, 2020
With new law, fate of 300 APMCs hangs in balance, by Praful Marpakwar, September 27, 2020
Agriculture’s Watershed Moment, by Amitabh Kant, September 22, 2020
With U-turn on farm bills in RS, BJD surprises many, by Ashok Pradhan, September 21, 2020
PDS grain demand high even during July unlock, by Priyanka Kakodkar, September 21, 2020
MSP to be higher, come early as govt allays fears, by Vishwa Mohan, September 21, 2020
Open agri trade, tighter Covid curbs cut APMC turnover 50%, by BB Nayak, September 19, 2020
And Punjab’s own commissioned committee explicitly recommended the same reforms, Sept 19, 2020
MSP for paddy up 2.4 fold, wheat’s 1.7x in 5 years: BJP, by Akhilesh Singh, September 18, 2020
The Economic Times
Passive-Aggressive Protests; Angry farmers want continued GoI support for a dysfunctional, wasteful system; Ashok V Desai; Dec 3, 2020
Agitating for Middlemen or Farmers? Jagadish Shettigar & Pooja Misra; Dec 2, 2020
Sow Farm Law Benefits More Carefully; MG Chandrakanth; Nov 30, 2020
Reduced Bargaining Power, MSP Worry Behind Farmers’ Stir in Punjab, Haryana, UP; Nidhi Sharma & Aman Sharma; Oct 3, 2020
Reforms for Refarming India, by Brijendra Singh, September 25, 2020
Opposing for Posing’s Sake, by Srivatsa Krishna, September 23, 2020
New Laws on Agri Trade and Contract Farming in the Works, by Rituraj Tiwari, May 23, 2020
Mumbai Mirror
Water cannons can’t douse their anger; Ajit Ranade, Nov 28, 2020
Why farmers are upset about reforms, by Ajit Ranade, September 21, 2020
Mint
Farmer protests are a reflection of this sector’s structural crisis; Himanshu; Dec 4, 2020
Selling to supermarkets is good for farmers; Shijith Kunhitty; Oct 21, 2020
An MSP guarantee won’t solve the problems of Indian farmers; Himanshu; Oct 9, 2020
IT’S BUSINESS AS USUAL AFTER THE FARM REFORMS; Sayantan Bera; Oct 2, 2020
India’s labour and farm reforms should be just a start; Rahul Jacob, Oct 1, 2020
Our new farm policy seen through Sharad Joshi’s lens, by Ajit Ranade, September 21, 2020
A revolt of the rich peasants of Punjab, Haryana, by Anil Padbhanaman, September 21, 2020
A REVOLT OF THE RICH PEASANTS OF PUNJAB, HARYANA; Anil Padmanabhan; Sept 21, 2020
Civilsdaily
Lessons from Bihar’s abolition of its APMC system for farmers, by Himanshu, September 25, 2020
Scroll.in
Why farm leader Sharad Joshi was a beacon of hope for India's liberals; Manuwant Choudhary Dec 21, 2015
I am Maharashtrian farmer's son and in Maharashtra farmers condition is getting worse day by day. I hope that due to this law something will change. The fact you told about onion price hike curbed by middleman is actually true. Even Mr. Shard Pawar wanted this reforms but now he is opposing this for his politics.
This guy has no idea what he’s talking about he’s not a farmer he has no right to talk about farmers go to the protest stayed a couple days then come back
@@lakhavirdi8498 How could you be so sure thay he is not what he claims? What's your source?
@@lakhavirdi8498 tell me how is onion planted in farm or how is sugarcane planted. Idiot do you even know basics of agriculture. If you are thinking that I am biased towards one party then you can see 'Mandi' a short film which is available on Kunal kamra's channel you will understand what is farmers problem in MH.
@@hrutikpisal6403 farmers problem in every state is different.....therefore state government should make their laws...why is central government soo eager to make uniform laws for everyone....let state decide their good n bad
@@hrutikpisal6403 so you are asking people to watch a biased propaganded video how fair? Everyone knows about him and no one is interested in his hatred.
This is the first non political account of the problem I have heard. Great work!
Thank you Raj.
Watch GyanJaraHatke video in farmers, he also explains is excellently with humour
LMAO you just need to search and know about the laws... there's bipartisanship on these laws.. only the communists and socialists are against it. Those whose opinions never matter.
@Aryan Thakur bh
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
Me watching whole video in 144p and ads are Playing in 720p😭
I hate ads playing in higher quality than the video
I think u r using Jio 😂
@@g8672 Well, I am using Airtel and everyone knows Airtel's speed. I have to wait like atleast 25 seconds for those high-quality ads to load
@@g8672 I am from j&K with Airtel internet ,it sucks sometimes Airtel's net shut downs for some time 😭
Vodafone 😂
Arthia give easy loan to farmers. And he is not middle man. And Bihar is not having APMC . Have u seen any farmer from Punjab and Haryana going to Bihar for work no because they in Bihar are not getting right price. Which farmers in Punjab and Haryana are getting. And essential commodities act will increase inflation. And it is not going to benefit farmers. And in contact farming what if quality of product is not good and company deny to buy at contract price. What farmers are not to do . As they can only to to sdm. Why they can't go to court. And how small farmers are going to negotiate contact with big company which are having big laws teams to make contact. These laws are not make for betterment of farmers these are make for big corporates. And income of farmers is high because of APMC in Punjab and Haryana. And government had said After demonetization they will be no black money. Is India black money free Country? Bjp in 2014 had said 15 lacks in account . Have u got ? . Government had said India will be Covid-19 free after 21 days in March. This government cannot be trust. And farmer had not block the border. Government had broken roads. Farmers had started journey from till delhi ramleela ground. Not till border of Delhi. And it because government they are at borders.
We like your comment Manharjot Singh ji
👍🏻
@Bisbo Whoa itna ehsan like kiya !!! Why doesn't you instead clear the doubts of this comment above which are genuine doubts also for so many of your followers !?! Are you biased or are you itself confused on these farm bills ??
And that's why thousands of farmers suicide when they are not able to return the loan with interest and since it is not a formal contract between them they can't get the help of judiciary
@@BisboWorld i think the point he made was concluded with political narrative ... So are u really being unbiased over here ? Punjab go to mumbai for bollywood doesnt mean it doesnt need any change becuase its giving employment. Labor from bihar even go to maharastra and up which are also supporting laws. Rubbish arguments .Additionally Punjab farmers have blocked the borders its for true .. May b u should experience it by yourself to have a better perspective.
I am farmer , when buying fuel why i should pay the middleman
I want to buy straight from govt at less price
And who'd pay for the storage, maintenance, distribution and others? Like seriously, what a dimwit would say that?
@@tusharsoni9043 you are a dumbwit. R u implying that storage and distribution would increase the cost by more than 100%??
@@chandrapm1578 bro tell me why r the fuel and gas prices rising albeit the global crude and gas prices r reducing....
@@SastaXed Gov needs money so they imply heavy tax on it , even non-bjp gov state impose it. Pretty simple.
@@SastaXed increase and decrease of fuel prices depend upon 2 factors.. 1) international crude oil prices and 2) the individual countries price distribution. It's any countries govt.s perogative to increase or decrease the gas prices. In this case it's the indian govts wish to increase or decrease the oil prices to it's consumers. If the indian govt. Doesn't want to pass the benefit of low international crude oil prices to it's consumers it's their wish. The real fun will begin when the crude oil price increases to 60 or 70$ per barrel. No nationalist feeling, no religion feeling will come to the front when it comes to putting food on the table for ur family. Worst days are ahead for indian consumers if Biden truely becomes the president .
Bisbo, you are doing a fine job. I am glad that I came across your channel because creating factual & unbiased content in this age of propaganda and social media is very difficult. More power to you buddy 🙌
Appreciated Aayush
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
@@pvsk6403 read my comment of counetring his comments . u will become andh bakth within 5 minutes
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
@@shoaibakhtar4389 loads of questions that Bisbo has not answered . Punjab farmers are not idiots
Farming must evolve like every other sector, its social darvinism
Totally agree Ajay
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
@@pvsk6403 No they are not 100 times more. Stop fear mongering.
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
Social Darwinism is Nazism.
This is such an enlightening unbiased on the ground report of why the Govt is pushing for new Farm laws. Thank you for breaking the confusion clutter! Great research and video.
Thank you Adithya
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
@@pvsk6403 ok BOOMER
This video is not factual
there are few issues with the current bill
1. contract farming -- how can the mediocre or small farmers be prevented from being exploited by the corporates ... as they have a very small holding
the example of pepsico shows only one side of the story .... there were cases ... for example ... when they refused to purchase potatoes saying the size is small and this was due to weather during that time , was not in hands of farmers
2. if pm says msp is there .... why can't he assure this by making a law rather than mere saying
3. by not keeping a limit on storage for corporates ..... this will make corporates control the market price
Bro suger cane are sailed by contract farming only from past 10 years they are living well now
Ans to your points....everything come to one place for me...FPO - farmer produce organisations (a kind of coorporation of farmers) ..a small farmer joins a fpo of 500-600 or 1000 farmers...that gives them the power to bargain.....what to grow what not to grow...whats the price...cause no other farmer in that area would be ready to accept their offer at lower rates....thats the solution.
2 i dont seriously understand msp....again fpo..if the farmers coorporation decide the price then what can companies do
Third point is valid...that demand should be their but...a rule also should be there to ensure that whenever there is unnecessary holding of anything(like the production is good but the commodity not coming to market) the govt or courts take suo moto investigation decision..that the third point
I am a son of UP based farmer, and I am confident that this will be very good for Uttar Pradesh Farmers
ok if u understand so much, tell me the main pros and cons of bill?
@@worldofscience5707 I though many have highlighted the pros and cons of the bills. So why keep asking
He is clearly asking if this guy is bjp bot
Farmers are real losers everywhere.. now they are being set to loose if this punjab middleman protests succeeds... Being a farmer's son..i see no good in agriculture if this apmc middleman system continues.. many of the farmers in our areas or side are moving towards cash crops rather than food crops.....Any monopoly in the markets hurts the market...BTW.. Good work bisbo...
Thank you Sudarshan.
You're Farmers Son and saying your Father Loser?
Idiot andhbhakt everywhere
@@vinayvashisth8083 truth is truth . You rahul and that bar dancer bhakt don't even know how much we will get benifit from that . My relatives r farmer and they r tremendously praising this bill . Oh god bcz of these dirty politics we will never be gonna get some good laws .
@@vinayvashisth8083 he's stating the truth
@@vinayvashisth8083 does who support this bill they r bhakts😂😂😂🤣🤣 wah
Swaminathan Committee had recommended the Government to build around 32,000 APMC to make sure that it is available to each and every farmer. Till now around 6870 APMC are functional which is way too short hence causing distress for farmers as they don't have the means to reach APMC nor they have any mean to reach the consumers directly.
This can easily be solved by using the PPP mode in all the states. Government and Private Companies should come forward and establish Mandis so that it becomes available to all the farmers. I feel around 22,000 APMC and 10,000 Private Mandis along with Cold Storage facilities managed by Private vendors and Government together and correct pricing method mechanism should be established to give the farmers best price for their produce.
The main problem here would be that Left and INC are too much against the Corporates and Capitalism. They love Socialism a little too much. Even China, the biggest communists use Capitalism to run their country. INC and Left put blame of every single mistake of the government indirectly on corporates. They want everything to be Nationalized. If Government would have had so much funds they would have alleviated many farmers till now by investing in agriculture. 70+ years was enough time, now atleast give slight leverage to the Private Sector to invest in agriculture. Atleast give them 10 years to show results. You have given 70 years to various governments without any success, who knows 10 years of Private Sector involvement might change the face of agriculture sector. Same happened with 1991 Industry reforms brought ironically by INC only. 45 years, industries were under the government and it was all in a big mess. 1991 reforms brought a big revolution whose effect was seen only by late 1990's and early 2000's. We need to take a chance. Ofcourse I am not saying fully privatize the sector as that too can be dangerous, Government should be involved but we need to give some freedom to the Private sector to invest in the Agricultural sector.
Though I am supporting the current Agri Bills but I want Central Government to make all the amendments that they have offered to the farmers. This will help empower the farmers as well provide them with additional security, specially when they are dealing with Big Private Firms.
Awesome!!!!
Well u hv a real and valid point which I must agree no denying for the most part of it,,,,china so called Communist country has failed in socialism under Mao and has shifted to capitalism that I must agree but the point is that they allow it under their own term to give you an example you can see the recent development of communist party of china with jack ma in other words government controls him as u can see jack ma is also communist party member but in India you can see major industrialists and giant business conglomerates dictating the government itself so when we talk of socialism and capitalism we should also talk about the nature of that country
Honestly speaking my opinion is that if u want to privatize any sector especially agriculture where above 70% of people depending on it initiate in step by step process with clear proper plan not with this half baked laws
@Chirag Sharma msp in india doesn't matter. Who even benefits from it anyway? Only 6% of farmers. Also, the govt procures way too much from Punjab as compared to other states. Hence, the protest might be about msp and the fuss around it, but it doesn't matter. Also, these laws...will only benefit farmers with sizeable land(avg land holding of an indian farmers is round 1.2 hec, that's very less to sell individually in a mandi anyway, so the whole msp and mandi reforms doesn't matter to these small poor farmers) Also, a lot of farmers who are benefited by monthly subsides don't even work. I have seen this is rajasthan, a lot of farmers take subsides, buy alcohol and food for the month, rice and wheat are from ration too so basically onka nikal jata hai mahina, I m sure a lot of ppl might have seen this too. So, this problem is way way deeper than we think and there are a lot of variables. Biggest is, indians are too much emotional when it comes to farmers and don't think logically. You go in Netherlands (2nd largest exporter of agri products) they know how to use their land. Hell, here the sector is so unorganised, everyone is producing the same thing and the govt is forced to buy it because 'emotions'. Then, there is no tech integration. There are about 450+ agri startups. And mind u, all are doing well, because agriculture in india is v v exploitable, so the existing machinery must have some sort of problems. Here, everyone is at blame. A collective problem, but the reforms put down...are ok, not the best but it's a change in right direction.
Valid point on private players building Mandis. This will be BSNL and Airtel case repeating again unless APMC and Private have same taxes and Rules.Thats one point this farmer protest is about
@@soloist7880 Agree with your point! Government before bringing a law for the benefit of people should talk with all the stakeholders. This autocratic way of doing things won't work in a country like India.
Government in this case should have atleast consulted Farmers, Unions and all State CMs. They didn't consult any of them and brought a law which despite being good is being opposed. I hope this incident proves to be a realization point for BJP that you can't pass bills at will just because you are in majority. I support the bills but it would have been better had they consulted the farmers and State CMs atleast before bringing out reforms. Also, though I don't like Left parties but the way this bill was passed in Rajya Sabha wasn't correct by BJP and they should have consulted the opposition as well. I hope Modi Government learns from this and keeps this in mind the next time they thing about bringing big reforms in any sector.
Your way of discussion in comments section is much appreciable.
No one other than bisbo does this kind of discussion such effectively. clearing most of the doubts of subscribers.
well done bisbo.
You deserve a gold play button..🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤️❤️❤️
Thanks a ton Vineeth. I try to answer if commentators raise a specific point and are not abusive or dismissive
@@BisboWorld it's appreciable really
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
Was waiting for this from Bisbo. Thank you
Most welcome Anand 😊
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
I appreciate this channel but its omitting a few points of concern so ill list them below. Please dont delete this comment bisbo, lets have a free discussion.
For better understanding let’s peak into the bills and their major points of contentions.
1. The Farmers (Empowerment & Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill: It draws a framework for contract farming agreement between farmers and buyer before sowing of a crop and for dispute settlement prescribes three level mechanisms - the conciliation board, sub-divisional magistrate and appellate authority. However, the points of contention are:
a) Under this law it’s not mandatory for a company to make a written contract with the farmer for any contract farming. So, even if the company violates the terms of the contract, the farmer cannot prove it.
b) It does not have any provision to penalize companies which do not register their contracts. For eg: Last year, Potato farmers from Gujarat witnessed a big issue where Pepsico attempted to penalize potato farmers for growing the same seed varieties. The farmer organizations finally had to knock on the doors of the court and agitate to get justice.
c) Bill does not prescribe or specify that contract price of the crop should be at least equivalent or above the MSP. It means the contractor/companies can pay whatever price they want to the farmer. India’s experience of the contract farming has been poor with farmers getting very low rates through contract farming as compared to selling it in government mandis on MSPs (Minimum Support Price).
2. The Essential Commodities Act (Amendment) Bill: It empowers the Central government to regulate food items in extraordinary circumstances or impose stock limits if there is a steep price rise. However, the points of contention are:
a) Till now only farmers, farmer cooperatives and Farmer Producer Organisations didn’t have any limit or restriction for stocking, producing or selling their crop. As a result, they take conscious decision of selling their crops only when the market or the buyer is offering good price for the crop. So, under this bill the farmers are not getting any new freedom. On the contrary the government is now removing all the foodstuffs from this category allowing companies and traders to store as much quantity of food as they want which amounts to promoting hoarding.
b) Through this Amendment the government is giving up its power to prevent hoarding and controlling price inflation. According to the law, government can intervene only if there is 50% price rise over previous year’s price in case of non-perishable goods and 100% price rise over previous year’s perishable goods.
3. Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill: It allows intra-state and inter-state trade of farmers produce beyond the physical premises of Agricultural Produce and Livestock Market Committee (APMC) markets. State will be now prohibited from levying any market fees or cess outside APMC areas.
a) The government says that now the farmers will have freedom to sell to anyone. Under the bill, the agri-business companies, corporate and traders will be allowed to open their own markets to purchase from farmers. However, the biggest fear coming from this is that it will destroy the level playing field between the APMC markets and other traders. Under the bill, the trade outside the APMC Mandis is virtually unregulated.
b) Farmers were demanding that in case the government is allowing, new set of farm markets to come up; the state and local government should be given power to oversee their functioning and also regulate them. However, the demand has been ignored.
c) Presently if the farmers feel the traders/corporate/agents working inside the APMC Mandis are involved in any unfair practices, they could complaint to the APMC Officers located in the yard itself. However, with the new Bill, in case of any disputes, farmers would be required to go to a sub-divisional magistrate court - which is beyond the capacity of small farmers to pursue given their financial constraints.
Hi, thanks for taking time to write all this. Firstly a lot of the issues raised are operational in nature; eg, no written contract necessary. Now if written then farmer will say he cannot read and write and taken for a ride.
If Pepsico or anyone tries to penalise farmers one season they will see other farmers dropping out next season and harm their own business. 98% of Pepsico's farmers continue their association. Surely this is an indication.
APMC fee is a scam which is deducted from farmers. In video we have said despite 100+ licenses given to pvt APMC is still 5 times larger.
MSP and free market forces will decide what is grown.
Also your claim that contract farming has exploited farmers is incorrect. ITC's e-chauopals have empowered them instead
The protests are simply a fear of what might happen. It's like jailing someone before a crime is committed.
@@BisboWorld you are cgeap to put have knowledge, Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
Although I'm not a big fan of the bjp government. I actually am finding more reasons to support these bills than to be against it. MSP is only available for essential commodities which would encourage the farmers to grow only that which is long term can be bad for the environment. MSP also leads to wastage of food resources. Ensuring msp for all is nearly an impossible task. Currently only 6% of indian farmers get MSP. These farm bills will provide an opportunity for those farmers who dont have access to MSP to sell the crop that they like to grow to any private buyer.
David, we completely agree
@@BisboWorld Wow didn't expect a response from you guys, keep posting such informative contents 👍.
What is the meaning of limirik
@@tanishqbansal4525 its a short funny poem having about 5 or 6 lines i think.
@@BisboWorld bro 👍 super maharashtra farmers also join in farmer pertost I meet with farmers in delhi protest thank for support
Bisbo, you have helped so many to truly understand what the truth is. Many a times what's placed at our nearest sight makes us lose sight of what's real and The Truth.
Everyone in the comments be like: I'm a son of a farmer I hate/love these bills
Well we all live in the same country so they are our brother and sisters😁
NGL I am great grandson of farmer. This bill will kill half of farmers and prosper other half.
@@shennaas6922 actually if you see what sadhguru did in South states you don't say this.. see once the main problem in india is ..you are a farmer I'm a farmer I grow tomatoes you grow potatoes now both of us own just 2 acres of land so a small famer with 2 acres of land is just using his lands to grow a small crop for this country ..the times have changed after globalization ..the solution for is growing the same grop in large hectors..for example we have 50 farmers in our village now the farmers needs to sign a agreement that all these farmers grow a same crop as suggested by the company ..farmer has just to grow rest of it will.be taken care by the company.. And next village will grow an different crop this is what the plan of these new bills..the problem with Punjabi farmers is they are braindead they are growing a useless food and dumping into Gov storages where the entire india doesn't need it..and forcing the gov to place MSP...if MSP is given farmers will grow same farms again and again thinking that they will get MSP ..no doubt sadar pagal bangaya..
@@drbh6331 what if the company doesn't take care after the APMC markets close down after many year. This will lead to exploitation.
@@drbh6331 No bill can be perfect. Let the states decide on what is good for them. Why does the center have to "Uniform" every day aspects of this diverse nation?
Bihar small farmers are doing work in punjab fields after apmc 2006 removal act
That cuz Bihar is poor state & have high population , farmland r small not big size like Punjab .
@@nishantshrivas7746 no...that's becoz punjab has mandis...and bihar don't have it...state government of bihar closed these mandis in 2006...if government brings that system back in bihar it will help farmers there
@@apj378 if current system is so good why farmers still in debt & die each year. Private investment need to come otherwise farmers will get RS 2 per kilo for tomato & u buy tomato ketup at rs60 per kg ........
@@nishantshrivas7746 i didn't say mandi system is totally fine...it has faults too..but problem is government is not ready to safeguard farmers from corporates...private investment is good but there should be some body to keep an eye on them...
@@apj378 even after 70yr of Independence we keep Targeting wealth generator like they r looting country. Country not gonna develop till we become free Market & support industry . Yes u r right we need regulator to oversee if corporate r exploiting or not . Farmers should form FPOs to collectively bargain . There is need to listen each other . We need these laws with some modifications but totally discarding will be a huge mistake .
It's not a farmer protest, it's middlemen protest!
Absolutely...and wealthy farmers also who stand to lose.
@@nadeemashraf1516 BJP is weak in communicating it's policies as said in the video!
@@nadeemashraf1516 I too have the same opinion. What kind of farmers demand Releasing poets who are behind the the bars?
@UCUiKFRkUoJtFrBOi8w0uGhw When did BJP used the Army? Avee he? It was Congress who asks for Proof? That's how it started and you people blame BJP for that? You listen to Kunal Kamra🤣
@UCUiKFRkUoJtFrBOi8w0uGhw Keep yourself Updated! If BJP gov had control over media then why didn't they banned Rndtv? Every party puts a lot of effort in Elections and campaigning, its not only limited to BJP! NIA and ED have started raids on Middlemen and Arathiyas soon they will be in Jail
This is THE BEST VIDEO on Farm Bills but sadly in India it's tough to pass reforms ,hope these farms laws will help our farmers
P.S Bisbo please keep doing your good work as your videos always provides good insite on a host of good work
Thanks Thirtharaj sir
It is not tough if you pass them
through ordinance and in a pandemic and which even having a division in Rajya Sabha.
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more......
These wealthy middlemen families have their children settled abroad in Canada, the US, and the UK. This is the reason behind the outrage in those countries. All coordinated to save middleman monopoly in Punjab and Haryana.
Haan... Modiji garibo k liye hi to hh....😂😂😭😭
@snap_potion no they needed them 10 years back
But now most of the farmers have bank accounts by the Jan dhan yojna scheme
They can apply personal loans for as low as 2 percent interest rate
Rather than taking them from middlemen at 15 to 20 percent
@SHIVAM VERMA
And they can also lower the price decided in the contract by making excuses like the shape or the size of the product is now exactly what they wanted.
Haryana and punjab farmers have the highest income in India.
If this system is that bad then why not other states farmers got richer and the ones from Haryana and punjab got poorer.
Nirav modi... Mallya.... All are wealthy farmers... Damn they took all our money and went there
Even after getting repeated assurances frm Govt regarding MSP, if someone protests against the farm bills, there is definitely an agenda at play...
Assurances are not acceptable, only bills that are passed will be.
@@jasmeetsidhu1872 Dats d real problem here, ignorance of d happenings....Govt has reiterated a set of over 8 changes to the bills but dat cn only b done if farmers accept...Dey r downright asking laws to b repealed, dats not how negotiations occur...Deres no goodwill of farmers in d minds of dose organising d protests....Personal ambitions at play like always or utter ignorance
@@abhishekmalik2333 LMAO, Dont you think that its funny how you are talking about discussions and all, but did you forget that the modi government passed these laws without discussion and how they framed these laws without even considering a single farmer XDD
@@parmeetsinghbanwait4645 there was no discussion bcoz opposition boycotted the parliament proceedings
@Aryan Thakur bro, if capitalism is the only answer then why countries like China with socialism are ahead of India.... Sometimes privatisation simply destroys the old monopoly and inturn creates a new monopoly.
I support farm laws. Anti-farm law protests are itself anti-farmer. Period.
@snap_potion I am extremely sorry for the late reply. I just saw your reply notification. I can enumerate different personalities, both economists and agricultural experts, who are in favour and support of these new farm laws. Arvind Panagariya, who is a famous Indian-American economist and a professor of economics at Columbia University, openly supported the new farm laws. Surjit Bhalla, who is an Indian economist and is currently the Executive Director for India at the International Monetary Fund, supported these new farm laws. Ashok Gulati, who is an Indian agricultural economist and a former chairman of the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices, the advisory body of the Government of India on food supplies and pricing policies, supported these new laws. Even the most celebrated author Chetan Bhagat supported the farm laws and the entry of foreign retailers in agri-marketing. Nobel laureate Abhijit Banerjee didn't make a single argument favouring the repeal/revoke of the new farm laws. Rather, he suggested the government to just postpone the implementation of these farm laws citing COVID reason. Therefore, one can understand, he favours the implementation of laws rather than its repeal/revoke. Ex-RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan, in one of his interviews with Barkha Dutt in Mojo story, opined that the NDA government doesn't intend to hurt the interest of farmers. He favoured the competition in agri-marketing through the entry of foreign and Indian corporates and retailers simultaneously ensuring the existence of mandis. This is what the new farm laws are also promising. And, the economist Kaushik Basu was the Chief Economic Adviser of the UPA government, which itself promised to abolish and reform APMCs and mandis and allow the entry of foreign corporates in the Indian agricultural sector in their election manifestos. Kaushik Basu himself supported the entry of foreign retailers in agri-marketing then. Now, he is against these new laws. The best example of hypocrisy.
@snap_potion And, regarding the MSP and entry of corporates. MSP decision is purely an executive decision and the MSP is guaranteed 100% irrespective of the enforcement of these new farm laws. MSP system and APMC Mandis will continue to work irrespective of these new farm laws. It is this same government which increased MSP in September 2020 after the passing of the new farm laws. This government paid more than double to farmers as MSP. Between 2009-2014, the UPA government paid just Rs. 3.74 lakh crore whereas, this govt paid Rs. 8 lakh crore between 2014-2019. This govt bought 74 times more pulses than UPA govt. Between 2009-2014, UPA govt just procured only 1.52 LMT pulses at MSP whereas, this govt procured 112.28 LMT pulses at MSP. Also, in 2013-2014, the MSP for Tur Dal was just Rs. 4300/quintal only whereas in 2020-2021, the MSP for Tur Dal has been substantially increased to Rs. 6000/quintal. Then, how can you turn your eye blind to these visible facts and figures??? Thus, the opposition arguments about MSP is totally baseless. You can verify these facts and figures through various agricultural websites as it is freely available in the public domain. Through these reforms, farmers will get the freedom of choice to sell in APMC mandi or choose any other seller. He/she will get multiple options to sell. He/she can be ensured of better prices through competition. He/she can sell directly to anyone and earn higher prices. Regarding, the court settlement of disputes, do you want to drag these honest, poor and innocent farmers to the web of lengthy, expensive, cumbersome legal procedures of Indian judicial system???. Nowadays, it is taking more time to get a dispute redressal in a reasonable manner. You must also note that most of SDM's are young IAS recruits who entered the system with the utmost vigour, competence and ardent devotion to doing good for the society. You should also note that the workload of a local judge is more than the same as an SDM. Of course, no system is perfect and blemishes-free. Even if a farmer is allowed the option to approach the court, there is no guarantee he/she will get a suitable redressal because of the widespread corruption in the Indian legal system. So, I suggest you approach the issue in a more open and unbiased manner. We cannot allow our emotions to rule over the visible facts, figures and realities. I know I am not that educated but I always try to approach an issue in an honest way without any prejudices.
@@sankarvenugopal2860 don't waste your precious time explain. It's not that they are going to accept it.
@@sargunangoppalan7809 Yes sir. You are absolutely correct.
@@sankarvenugopal2860 I really fee sd to see people with their passimistic thinking.
I will vote bjp for next election because they know what BLACLASH facing after reforming law but they take hard step that will benefit nation in future.... Aatmanirbhar mission is amazing Idea....
Yes for powerful develop india we should support modi vote for Modi
But Bisbo wont you say anything about the clause which restricts farmers from approaching courts and limits them to just DC/SDO?
Government has taken this into account and is ready to bring an amendment to allow farmers to go go courts.
@@apoorvmahalwar Where did you learn that exactly? I would like to know
Courts are already overburdened, cases last for tens of years, better to have it sorted at lower level
@@BisboWorld lower levels courts are corrupt, with contract farming they will always take the side of the corporations. X and Y reason I will buy your crop for 50 percent less now, mosh farmers are illiterate in India you think they will know what type of contracts they are getting into.
@@BisboWorld Fast track courts can be set up. You must live in Mumbai or Delhi buddy. Us small city people know how easily influenced a DC/SDO can be by big corporates, how unreachable they can be for the common man. Of course the DC/SDO can be the initial Arbiter of justice but to close off even the option to approach the courts is a death sentence on farmers.
(PS: I'm from Jamshedpur, the city of the Tatas, the corporate house claiming to be the most ethical in India, and trust me, I've seen this happening first hand, many times)
*I am quite sure those before me haven't seen the vedio completely but had already praised the vedio*
Yes, sometimes even I think so! 😃
Exactly
Video*
@@BisboWorld they are not here to gain knowledge ,, just to get some attention (likes)
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
Awesome,dont stop ever unleashing the real beast...(knowledge)
Thanks Hari
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
@@BisboWorld East India Company built roads, rails, courts, schools, police stations and even india gate but we still kicked them because they never listened to public. Stop being East India company, modi and ambani. Your profit is not bigger than people. Modi ambani ka nuksan nahi hone dega, chahe hazaro log mar jaaye. Hope you understand now.
@@pvsk6403
understandiong the historical stupidity of essential commofdities act here:
words-are-weariness.blogspot.com/2020/07/the-welcome-demise-of-essential.html
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
I request to BISBO to pls make a hindi and Punjabi or other languages dubbed version of this fantastic video on farm laws which they have made, this deserves to be telecasted in multiple platforms, to solve all this confusion going on in the country. Great work.
Thanks Sriram. Making in Hindi. I will be ready for the trolls!
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more....
I will vote for BJP if they do not bow down to pressure, I will consider them true reformers, idiotic politics are being played in this country keeping us poor.
Bro you will become more poor. These laws are bad for general public. If private companies start hoarding foods prices will increase drastically. Farmers are also right. BJP is also right they need to bring back MSP. Mandi is bad idea but if there is no MSP general public will get ripped.
@@raja_hustle4347 govt doesn't need to get involved in the business to keep the prices in check they can simply have a min max policy in place and that's it. When airlines went to private organizations it reduced ticket prices not increased. Problem occurs only when 1 or 2 players monopolize any market.
The Arhtiyas or as you refer them "middlemen" are actually service providers who store and dry the crop until it reaches the appropriate moisture levels or other qualifying grounds, load and unload it, clean it out, weigh it, pack it in bags and stitch them. They also finance the farmer all year long without collaterals. They have accountants, laborers and other staff. They have to pay for electric weighing and cleaning machines, they also have bills to clear. So i don't think it's appropriate to call them middlemen. THEY'RE SERVICE PROVIDERS
Yes, go back to the old Ambassador car.
That was great.You need innovation in collection storage , not rats eating your crop.Get a life.
Yes you are right. The video has got this point wrong.
Morever arhtiya gets his commission from the government not the farmer
Brokers in stock market are also service providers. Lol
@@TauroChuck Arthyas exploit farmers by high interest rates...which farmers cannot repay why do you think farmers commit suicide...
I get that 3 Bills are benifcial for farmer in some extend but you should also discuss the loop hole and other problem by bill and the way it was passed,simply praising the bill will not do much.
Yes, we have specifically mentioned that govt should have taken people along. Passing it hurriedly was suspicious
You are right bro... There are many loop hole in it
@@BisboWorld middleman is someone who is our countryman but corporate this video is one sided even farmers can't go to court when there is problem from corps and also corps won't allow anyone to grow naturalfood and corps will mainly buy GMO products
@@BisboWorld i get you have mentioned in description which we appreciate but most people now a days will just simply see the video of their favorite UA-cam and accept it as a fact which is why just at least give a small hint on the video about the problem with solution.
I really appreciate your informative video i always love to see your video and i get it is not an easy job but your video are always good to watch you are doing a great job,just tell information on both side if you can and thanks for all your hardwork you are one of my favorite UA-cam video to watch.
@@devanshtomar2449 true but it is also true on what is there on youtube video so we just need to see from both side of view and not take it as black and white.
Farmers are always in loss and our taxes are going to waive off their losses, and the cycle continues.
@@sashvatganesh People in this country seem to glorify poverty and hate the rich.
What about the NPAs and the loan waivers given to various so called business tycoons???
@@sashvatganesh thats what the 3rd farm bill is meant to do ..private investment in the agri sector
@@sashvatganesh Punjab farmers are protesting not all farmers, see the rally in Meerut in support of farm bills.
@@sashvatganesh because private investment must be brought in while the existing system remains. If APMC dies, these corporates will have the upper hand. And then the controversy about SDM courts and giving Collector the authority of a Civil Court and making him the final appeallate authority. SDMs and Collectors are executive officers, not judicial. The government has no right to say you can't go to a judicial court in case of disputes.
Great work dude u changed the perspective of farm bill
Thanks, we have to cut thru the bullshit 👍
Not expected the response but doing great work and ig best way to say abt something n want to thanks u for educating with the diff n valid facts abt every stuff
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
I don't understand why some people are saying that a farmer cannot sell outside his or her state. Can they point out any one law which restricts them from doing so. Ya I do agree that the local police do stop them from doing so but that is illegal.
Moreover there is no law which restricts the farmers from selling outside the APMC market.
Moreover Bihar has removed APMC act in 2006 and removed the middle man. But still farmers of Bihar are no less exploited.
Instead of this the government could strengthen the law so that the middle man cannot exploit the farmers.
Late Arun jaitley himself said in the rajya sabha that if we try to remove the middlemen the bigger middlemen, ie, the big cooperations will come into the game and exploited the farmers even more.
And giving example of Lays and amul to justify your point is wrong. This be because Cereal cannot be compared to dairy products and fruits and vegetables.
I have a doubt, did this government even consult any farmer or farm committee before enacting this law. Also if the farmers are unhappy with the gift you are giving them then take it back. Why do force the farmers to accept it.
You are a traitor. Everyone who shows mistakes of our supreme leader is a traitor. Go to Pakistan 😂😂😂
I had the same concern and i saw the new farm law against Indian farmer's but when i saw this podcast i was surprised and thought is this farm protest is even practical ua-cam.com/video/NS6KFlW3BSc/v-deo.html
Yes the government had implemented these reforms after discussing with the Standing Committee for Agriculture. Bhartiya Kisan Union itself wanted these farm laws to be introduced in its 2019 Kisan Manifesto. Now they are suddenly taking a U-turn on this. And yes, the protestors are mostly from Punjab and Haryana. Rest farmers from other states are coming up more and more in support of these laws. So there is no angle of forcing when the rest India wants it. These section of farm unions wanted it and then they suddenly reject it? Wtf lol...
@@sanketborkar92 just like CAA, famers from 10 states are doing rallies in support of this law...i am so confused
@@platokiro3353 I am still trying to find a counter-argument from these protest supporters on these things. I did thought their concerns might be genuine, but when they even rejected the amendments proposed by the govt by listening to all their concerns, this is when my mind started solidifying in support of farm laws. Their entire argument rests now on appeal to pity, appeal to authority(using celebs) and ad populum arguments. They even keep repeating ad nauseum that they are called anti-national and terrorists by putting words in Modi govt and media when they have clearly pointed out that only the Khalistanis who were trying to hijack their protests. They are introducing more and more facilities like gym, pizza, massage parlours in protests to encourage people to join for all this sensational stuff! 😂 Yet they cry foul when we point it out saying that if Ambani Adani could have it, then why cant the farmers? Lol...all appeal to pity! 😂
Beautifully represented the whole crux, this is what the media should actually be doing. Request you to present a second part of this as well, showing in-depth analysis of punjab's take and the motivation behind it.
Thanks Tanishq. I think we generally covered it here
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
And its not only punjab ,it is punjab haryana and up ,which almost more half producer of crops under msp,busbo is soldout, if laws passed these states farmer are most affected,
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
This video only shows the positive side which government indented..but there are black sides too ,for the rich people which government supports..its a fact that APMC mandi should be abolished, but not like this.. why didn't he pointed out the fact that farmers cant do arbitration above SDM level against any corporation, why can't a farmer go to court for the crops he grew.
How willl yu compensate the punjab government for the tax they get from apmc when u close them.
These things should be addressed, but Ambani just opened Jio mart, and asked to pass this bill.. so modi will try his best to get it done.. we all know their love
Modi should also remove kota system. One of my friend with both of his parents having govt jobs gets admission in govt mbbs college with really low marks while me didnot even got admission while i got more than 150 marks than him. Please make a video on this kota system
Wait for uniform civil code... One of the BJP's manifesto point. All caste and religion lines to be blurred. One nation one law!
Yes bro you are right I scored 98 percentiles in jee and my friend scored 67 percentile in jee but he gets better college than me because he is coming from st class and i am from open 🥺🥺🥺
🤓chak de fatte!
Your explanation always give me an exclaimation--WOW !!👏👏
May I hv ur email address. 🧐
Thank you Mandeep. Pls write to us at gobisbo@gmail.com
also, why farmers are restricted from approaching to court ???
Everyone have right to protest, when this protest just started a few people (near about 10-15) were protesting near my home in patiala. And police was beating them.
Beautiful visual representation. Someone like Prof Ashok gulati would love seeing this. So easily and chronologically explained.
He contradicts himself thrice in this video to argue in favor of these laws.
Bisbo should find a better monetary model. I agree money and time is needed to create quality content. But you cant cheat the hand which feeds you(Farmers). He should understand the laws and find the flaws which need to be revisited. Our judiciary is a joke currently.
He favours govt
@@aftabahmad199 have seen many of his videos where he was going against the current govt
Reality has a lot of contradictions, and Bisbo's statements do make sense.
Even India loose a case against a coorporate (Cair energy).
How do you expect farmers to win against coorporate.
Farmers will obviously be Scared.
Communist thinking spotted.....
Amazing video. I had read about the bills but this video really helps understanding more about the bills. Thank you bisbo
Glad it was helpful Kabir!
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more....
Not factual and he contradicts himself
I agree with the point raised by you in the video, Government should step forward and explain the the complete benefits of the bill and it should ensure the security of farmers as they are going to an agreement with big MNCs which might frighten them. Steps taken by modiji are appriciable as he is trying to explain farmers what actually the bill is. Although the bills are supportive to farmers the loop holes in the bills should get fixed then no one can stop these bills. Effort made by you is appreciable keep going ❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍......
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
Don't you know the PEPSICO fiasco in Punjab?
Happened once in 25 years
Sorry but you are not covering some of the major limitation in Thea's law
** Farmers are not getting right to file a case in court . They can only go to districts supritendent against big company's.
**It do not have any type of rules which may ensure that not a single company buy how much amount of crops. This would lead to situation how jio has done in telecom sector. First grap the market share than increase prices.
**In mandi system middle man provide intrest free short term loans to farmers . If mandi get shut than who would provide intrest free credit facility to farmers
**Many more........
Govt. has agreed for considerstion, if not all but to some of this issues.
But farmers be like
"We wont listen to anything, just take those f*king bills back"
@@physics19941994 bhai.... Farmers were asking for amendments and sitting for 2 months in Punjab and Haryana by stoping railway but government ignored them.... Now when they are asking for dissolution...... Why not a new bill can be formed with all merits of this bill plus with few more changes.... What could be the reason behind the rudeness that goverment is showing to wards farmers......
Lol who provides interest free loans bro. And courts already overburdened
@@BisboWorld bro I am a farmers son....
When it come to my sisters marriage we have taken loan from those middle man .... That yr. Our harvest was not too good... And we were going from hard time....🙏🙏🙏🙏
There are many things that only a farmer can understand...... 🙏🙏🙏
Also don't think that farmers can be fooled by any political party . Farming sector need changes but it's our request that changes should be according to us....
We are just asking for our rights that's all...,🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sorry but please see this perticular situation from a farmer's point of view......
@@BisboWorld you are saying that courts are overburdened ...... Is going to court for justice is not our right...... ????
What could be the reason that goverment is taking this right from us......????
Good that you explained in detail.Some people are supporting the protest in Delhi without knowing the intention of coming up with this bill.
Thank you Bisbo. I usually fear that people even educated people will be misguided by this protest being labelled as Farmer's protest. I was in Ambala for the last 3 months. And trust me not a single farmer behind my house (from nearly 100 farmers) went away. Only their land owners, buyers etc were gone away entirely as if a festival had started in Delhi. They are not sad.trust me. They have gone to disrupt and enjoy the vacation.
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
Somebody needs to break this news to punjab that Punjab's economy is screwed, and shit would not get better if they keep resenting change
Do you think a Sardar farmer will change.
A most bull headed species .
Yes you are right
This system have failed in US, Canada and Europe. It only look good on paper but in long term it will kill the farmers.
Remember jio and many other startups who initially will give huge discounts and later once you in the trap they will go deep into your pockets.
@@kushjindal2939 truth
@@SD-ko4jd US agriculture is highly controlled by the government. Everyone still uses jio at throwaway prices as compared to any other telecom. Curious, how is everything screwed? With time, better startups are coming in, which essentially give better prices to customer and the service provider.
Bisbo is genius in explaining the current affairs of the country , thank you Bisbo
Just leave this punjab and hariyana farmer with their old msp and athirtiya system .And rest of country must go with current new farm law and which help them to grow rich.
See the financial condition of Punjab farmers and Bihar's Farmer. Punjab farmer is eating dry fruits and Bihar's farmers are going to Punjab to work as labourers. A farmer got a profit of 1.5 lakh for 14 months of work. How is it better?
they was not real farmers
Punjab ground water 86% declined..1 kg of rice production water use 5000 liter.
punjab fermers 80% under debt.
Great work Bhai.. and it will be helpful to our local Indian farmers, if you make this content in Hindi language. Really explained very well about the previous and new farm laws pros and cons. However, I believe both farmers and corporates will become richer at the cost of consumers (as Indian middle class family will now have to pay high prices)
If modi doesn't bulge to protesters he will go down in history as one of the most reformist government, if backs down he will go down as one of the worst
Yes bro
Only a few middlemens vote doesnt decide pm kid
@@anmolsharma8949 Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
East India Company built roads, rails, courts, schools, police stations and even india gate but we still kicked them because they never listened to public. Stop being East India company, modi and ambani. Your profit is not bigger than people. Modi ambani ka nuksan nahi hone dega, chahe hazaro log mar jaaye. Hope you understand now.
@@green___apple bisbo really disappointed me with biased presentation, only showing pro of new and some are saying thsi is neutral what an hypocrisy.
I support farm laws but make sure corporates should buy from farmers at MSP minimum
U don't know corporates capitalists, first know the cons of bill on farmer and then debate
@Arun kumar give the power government and government officials would grow fat with corruption like they always did.
Learn some basic things about capitalism then debate... If communism or socialism seem attractive then look at North Korea and Venezuela
@snap_potion Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are much times more
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are much more....
Punjab farmers became prosperous with whatever system was in place so it was definitely going to be hard sell and they should have been taken into confidence but our 56" inch PM thought they are are just farmers so no consultation required. The Government took them for granted and now it is an issue of ego than anything else. Free market and privatisation will definitely make things efficient which is lacking in everything in India including agriculture.
Completely true
Completely true
Completely true
In bihar there is free market from a decade, and the situation got worse.
And the thing about free market, it always helps the traders not farmers, farmers income is seasonal, what if when they have their crops harvested and in free market the price of that crop is so low that it don't even cover the expenses, what would be the option for the farmers, to not sell the crop?
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more...
The major problem in india is unfair laws for farmers
Yes mostly benefited middlemen until now
Punjab farmers suck.
Not only farmers of Punjab they are farmers of India my friend . Please not make it to only one state problem. My humble request.
Farmers of UP,haryana,TN r also there
Why then other farmers aren't protesting you can't hold a state to ransom and i now i am hearing that you protestors are getting cooked food, foot massager what is this drama
That is the problem that those farmers that are protesting are not understanding. They maybe from anywhere but they are getting the MSP while in other states farmers are dying due to suicides and government have to look at farmers as equal citizens and take actions for their favour but nobody on the roads are going to understand that those bills are made for entire indian farmers and they are just a few percentage of them demanding to remove the bill for their MSP which us not even being removed and they are the ones threatning teh future of 49% indians that are linked to farming sector. People go on saying that take those farmers that are protesting as farmers of India but the fact is they are not listening at all they are blindly saying remove the bills. Meanwhile other states are in dire need of these bills.
Farmers protesting either don't understand the bill or are politically motivated. Please don't let politics blind you from what's right! These bills are necessary but the opposition is choking this country for their political benefit
After all I was waiting for this video 📹 thank you bisbo
Most welcome Sreeja😊
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more..
Bisbo you are doing a fabulous job. My sincere request is please make video on John Jones tragedy, Aron Ralston escape, these type of rescue operations....
You are excellent that's why I'm suggesting you.
Bisbo, this was amazing. What will be the next video and when will it come
Ishan next video on TRP (not focusing only on Arnab) but on the TV advertising market
@@BisboWorld but when
Like jio dominating telecom market n bsnl on loosing end .
Then this gone happen to
farmers.
APMC will suffer like bsnl... private player will give you higher price for crop for 2-3 years after that the APMC will be finished
Then they will give you what they want because there is no msp on crop in private mandi... And no way back because APMC till that will finished.
And why can't a farmer go to court for contract related why only sdm ?? please answer me that
And why should be there a msp if we can have a mrp on everything why not on crops ???
Answer me bisbo.???
BSNL still exist and you can get its subscription. BSNL was on loss before jio too. And BSNL now has got better than before (still in loss tho) , you will get disney+ Hotstar Premium with subscription! Haha, ok enough jokes.
Only 6% farmers get Apmc benefit (the figure goes up in Punjab, Haryana, West UP) . Apmc are still flawed before private comes. And the farmer will get written contract of guaranteed price. The private sector is not 1 company, there is competition among the private itself. Suppose reliance does what you say, but farmers don't like it, so they will go to Tata, which will give better price, seeing it Reliance will again give better.
Entire US and Europe runs on capitalism.
Google still provide best service because they know that if they don't, Yahoo will rise to takeover.
And the govt proposed amendments in the court part but Farm Unions rejected it. And Nirbhaya took around 10 years to get justice, that is Indian Court.
Only 6% farmers get MSP, rest 94% do not get MSP on their produce.
Govt (both centre and state) do not have enough money to buy on MSP. Still they manage sometimes just before elections.
But they do not know what to do with those produce and it eventually rots in godowns.
Govt cannot make policy that will benefit only very few people.
I have BSNL broadband connection
Thanks a ton for this bisbo. I wanted a clear and unbiased description on this topic and you provided it to me. I remember commenting on your last post asking you to post a video on this topic and u finally did. Thank you. Keep growing
This video is propaganda not unbiased read the negative comments for an unbiased view
@@danielabhishek3371 Yess indeed scrolled through the comment section for this video and most of the comments down here are positive only.
@@danielabhishek3371 Also if the video might not be unbiased but yess it is definitely not propaganda based. Farming sector needs to evolve like any other sector 😊
If FCI can't improve storage facility safe guard stocks from rats in these many years. How can you expect farmers to increase or upgrade his facilities.
govt will 1 lakh crores for storage and infrastructures
Ambani and Adani registered 53 agrecultural company in 2020
You have RoC data to prove this or only rumours?
@@BisboWorld www.timesnownews.com/india/article/adani-ambani-groups-registered-53-agro-based-companies-congress-mps-bid-to-link-farm-laws-to-businesses/694742
@@BisboWorld in.news.yahoo.com/adani-ambani-recently-registered-53-100041564.html?guccounter=1
Read ur links properly the MP claims.....52 companies are registered 🤣🤣. Bisbos u have done a wonderful job in explaining the 3 bills keep it up
What a brilliant way to describe the issues regarding the farm laws. Bisbo is the best.
No the report is not factual correct read any report not by gods media
@@danielabhishek3371 first of all Bisbo is the best!
Second of all bisbo always ensure that news is almost free from bias.!
So please :)
@@mohitkankani4421 read my comment or any give below against the video to see this video is actually a bj
@@mohitkankani4421 also check online most of the facts stated here have be disproved by experts
Hats off to your hard work
U make graphics which take a lot of time and hard work
Great video bisbo. Could you do a video on the situation of Indian cricket at the moment. It is very embarrasing especially after that 36 all out match against Australia. Please reply.
This video is not factual do not believe this propaganda
Its about all about a farm bills...but the trust that is not remain with goverment be it a demolition of notes or be it anyything done till now.. soo farmers how could they trust the goverment..and in contract farming not farmer has assurity that they will get a price of what he gets and something happens he could not go to the court..this is wrong
Am happy that i've found your channel
Very well explained, Bisbo Team!
It's totally a fault of government . When they know that they r going to touch indian politics so much high demanded topic just for rally purpose only that is so called "bharat ma ks kisan" then they should be careful . Before passing the bill they should have talked to different kisan agencies in all part of country .
Why? For the bills to be cancelled even before it is passed
@@Bufferedstart for bills to be better at all levels
Why do I feel especially this video on agriculture is influenced by some motive because I don't see ground reporting and also the video only explains from the government's point of view.
Can you try to explain the other side, if you are so much sceptical about ita
Sold out hogya bhai ye bhi
Coz you are Andhvirodi 🤓
this channel might b like that tho
6:30 “corporate houses are not the devils that they are made out to be”
Have you read the bills where it clearly states that the corporate houses can’t be sued by the farmers?
Or did you just read the biased script that you made/received?
Boss the corporates and farmers agreement is not binding to farmers and corporates can be sued in the authority of SDM
However, the authority should hv been passed down to an appellate tribunal setup particularly for agri issues which is one of the loophole
Anyway happy congress supporters
Yes there should be amendments, better ones than they have suggested.
Bisbo video is fully biased.
Check interview of a IIM professor on this bill who has already done something big for farmers.his view on this
ua-cam.com/video/u4odE3Kgc94/v-deo.html
His achievements
ua-cam.com/video/zO2oFmftMWM/v-deo.html
@@worldofscience5707 i hv seen his work, he is a very practical and innovative person
is this a company or a channel by one individual or a franchise of a company ??
Individual
He has shown pros and completely ignored cons bcoz if u discuss cons then u have no answer for the poor and weak farmers
Hey, bisbo how true/misplaced are the concerns of private players strong arming farmers in near future. And has it happened in anyother sector previously?
Edit :- this has been a recurring theme in many anti-farm bill comments and also i find many ppl say this.. would like to know abt this.
Is amul expoiling farmers mahindra exploiting farmers and you know what private plyers don't want to earn profit they would exploit their own workers
These laws looks good on paper.
Yeah and communism looks bad even on paper
@@abhimanyujha5550 so says the bakth ....hinduthva is definitely on those pages .Keep scratching
@Aryan Thakur 1)yes ,farmers receive subsidies in every country in the world ,otherwise it is a very Labour intensive /low profit job. No one will do it (it’s for the countries own food security)
2)yes ,Indian agriculture has a major stake in pollution ,may be diversifying crops is an idea , but it won’t Happen in a year it needs years
3) yes ,there is tax exemptions,but I don’t believe the smallscale farmers are benefited completely. But as there are big players who benefit.irrespective of state ,ideology or party.
4)yes ,they are defaulters,it’s because they don’t have the Money unlike some liquor baron ,that’s why they suicide (tax exemption is not helping them there nor do banks)
5)I agree to Landgrab,water usage etc.
6)but we are in grain surplus ,so I don’t know if we have imported grain. Govs.major complaint is grain and paddy is rotting in the FCI depos.
7)the storage /cold or dry is bad in gov .sector which they could improve with time ,that will give yearlong steady supply and price .
I was saying baby steps first before a leap could have been good.
@@Omarmalayail nah even hindutva is better cummunism
@@preetamsrinivasan7070 for an extremist islamophobic Bakth it definitely is
Bisbo narration is best suited for millennials and gen Z at least!!
Great way of representation. Amazing
Thanks Ritesh
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more...
@@BisboWorld This video is need to be shown to Dhruv rathee, Akash banerjee, soch, scoopwoop, but why etc. Why there are so many differences of opinions on this issue? We all want farmers conditions to be uplifted so why can't we all come together regardless of differences to discuss this issue and clear each others misunderstandings.
Superb video
Hats off to Bisbo👍👍
And
Please do a video about Religious Conversions and it's impact on National Security , Demographic change 🙏🙏🙏
Government should convince and Explain the detailed Analysis of Farm laws to the farmers they should spread the usage of farm laws by educating them. Only the Middlemen are benefitting from the previous laws like MSP. #### I support 3 farm laws 2020.
Finally... Someone talking sense and linking all related problems such as stubble burning, pollution to current system of agri purchase in Punjab. Even news channels are taking shit and praising Modi with putting facts. Keep up the good work!
Thank you.
We face this yearly but somehow Modi hate has blinded people
This video is not factual but propaganda
@@danielabhishek3371 Prove it
Very helpful video by bisbo as usual,was waiting for your response to the farm bill 👍
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more..
@Bisbo - if u think this farm law is too good and people protesting are middle man etc.. please create a new video giving answer to below questions...
1. if there is no scarcity of food then why was potatoes and tomato, onions sold at high price during lockdown. These are basic food items right... Do ur research and provide the explanation.
2. If u are saying about courts are busy etc but why is basic right to approach the court is taken away from farmer
3. Why was the farm laws passed as a ordinance then as a bill in hurry whereas other parties wanted it to be discussed thoroughly before implementing. Why was it passed during covid situation. If u say it important to take the action then, get a answer for me.. why there is no winter session in parliament (reason given for no session is due to covid).
4. If u think these laws are good then why is government ready to make the changes. Why is it not ready to take it back and re- implement with proper discussion.
We are staying in democracy. Everyone has its right to oppose/ take decision. No one should impose anything just to for his ego.
5. If PM feels these laws are good why didn't he visit the farmers at least once to discuss during the protest. Why is he hiding behind camera and giving his view.
I appreciate ur work u do ... I hope very soon I will see new video with answers for above questions.
1. That's a point.
But that's totally related to customer.
Not farmers.
2. Farmers has given the nearest courts, instead of big courts which far away from their reach.
& farmers don't have enough money to give to lawyers even.
That's why.
3. Ordinance is necessary because this laws is delayed from many decades.
All kisan neta, dr. Manmohan singh, Pranab Mukherjee, rahul gandhi every body wants this laws but they never did.
But Someone has to.
& there is 5 hours proper discussion in both houses.
& 10 days before this law passed, one copy of laws is already given to all MPs. They can read it. But they not. 😂
That's ruled.
Yes winter session is canceled.
& new session will start early in January. To make over winter seasons.
4. By this logic we have to canceled our own constitution first.
I can't imagine how many times our constitution gone through changes.
That's not make sense.
5. If u think PM not meet once farmers. Is totally yours thinking but its true or false that u can't give certification on that.
U can think what u want to.
Government has support of many farmers that's why they bring this laws.
If u r thinking government will destroy their votes by there own hands. 😂
They what to say. 😂
Generally no body does.
There is something on it.
Let BJP learn the lesson of the need of 'Effective communication' the Hard way. Next time they would take the consent and pass the bill more democratically.
Corporates only look into their shareholder and share value .. which means they will do anything for profitering
However a case of corporates exploiting farmers will lead to a drop in share price.....and secondly corporates are also people
Share price is not directly proportional to exploitation.
Share Prices directly related to stocking ability and power of manipulating and controlling market price. More Profit More Return to ShareHolder.
Secondly Corporates are Not Human Being.
A Human being is Mortal. It has life and dies after a certain age. Look at the age of FORD Mortors or Tata Group, Mc Donalds. It's a myth that we Run Corporates.
The truth is Corporates Run us, when it's employee base keeps changing its ownership keeps changing. It will keep thriving for profit at any cost.
It will set legal traps where people can get trapped. For example. The Debt trap created by Credit Cards. at 3.5% monthly interest and allowing easy use. It creates a trap which a person will only realise when it's too late.
Now think when smart people of the cities can get trapped in the circle of llife style loans.
What these Corporates will do once they get an oppertunity to interfere in a farmers farm land. So Much Land that can be acquired easily by making agreements that farmers cannot honor for long.
Why is govt. Not encouraging cottage industry..why this govt. Is so fixated with corporates.
@@pr33t007 good luck being a trader
@@pr33t007 ever heard of esg ratings?
@@ramquait21 I am not a Corporate Hater, but I think some industries are too sensitive to be given away so easily. In Punjab there is a Mandi every 4 kms. It functions well, it may need some modification to make it more efficient.
Nestle, Amul have good business models working with farmers for so long.
Wish this video was in hindi so that it could be spread to the farmers and more common people.
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
You can watch this video mate in Hindi and is unbiased ua-cam.com/video/Dj4rGHzc-3A/v-deo.html
@@1700robinwasu Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more
He will release it on bisbo hindi which has more subs man
@@1700robinwasu since when Dhruv rathee became unbiased? ua-cam.com/users/AnOpenLetter001 this channel exposed him.
Go on bisbo make such informative videos.
We will be happy to see atleast 1 video per week
Just love the way you narrate
Thank you Ananthu
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more...
@@pvsk6403 so you want to continue the same system which has been going on for years . I don't need to tell how bad the condition of farmers was . Finally when a bill comes which will help farmers not get exploited from middlemen dumb people like you are making them believe that it will be disadvantageous for them . Maybe you should educate yourself about the bill before protesting
@@ananthuironside8646 yes continue with same system as in punjab and haryana adapt it in all states ,kashmir punjab and haryana have best paid farmer ,bihar where APMC mandi was abolished only provate mandi has poorest farmer,
@@ananthuironside8646 go and chech list for any rich middlemen(artia)which only earning is from mandi,dont just belive media ,i am frim punjab and farmer,artia are have And how exactly removing APMC ARTIA middlemen help by i troducing ADANI AS ARTIA or middlemen in private mandi ,what a hypocrisy, atlest apmc artia vould be held in court or was licensed
Surprised to listen such ridiculous explanations! I mean do you honestly believe that the Essential Commodities Act ammendment won't lead to hoarding by private players??
Achha so why do china US and all countries except india allow private players to hoard hi and were nt hoarding allowed for items like fruits which did not come under msp gown many times did you find mangoes to be above 250 rs a kilo but onion does have 300 rs per kg moment
@@ramanujkumar7941 Firstly it would be foolish of us to compare our country to US,China etc since the economic conditions of farmers in India is already quite bad to start with, thanks to the combined efforts of Congress and the BJP. Our country, where 50% of the population is dependent on agriculture grows enormous amounts of wheat and rice and it is this surplus that is stored. Fruits and vegetables's storage life in granaries isn't a lot whereas wheat can be stored in silos for yrs.
I can't Agree with you
@@ramanujkumar7941 dude u have any idea that healthy eating is nightmare in the US for many people
@@nikhiltripathi3545 wheat can be stored in pantry for 6 months and 1 yr in freezer and fci godowns have pantry only except very few .hoarding will only lead to a more stable supply chains .
When the same reforms were carried out by china in 1980 their farmers condition were much much worse they have reached here by creative destruction .
The world's best country Netherland for agriculture combines amazing marketing techniques with scientific ones to have rich farmers .
If you want to be at lvl of China or America you have to reduce the no of farmers from140 million to 50 million like in China which feeds a much larger population with ajust 30 million Farmers and
Don't give the example of Bihar its industries didn't even progress after 1991 reforms cause it needed private investment but the investment climate was not suitable in bihar .the same thing happened with agri reforms there.by the way these apnc there were removed for much diffrent reasons
I Support these bills , because I feel for those 95% poor fatlemers of my motherland,and I will go against the rich monopolistic Farmers of India who account for less than 5% of Farmers, these bill will certainly help rise in income of all Farmers equally......WE INDIANS MUST SUPPORT THESE BILLS.LOVE FROM Assam to all .
Bisbo please try making some PDFs too which could be share on your telegram channel for referring.
Great video,great research
Working on it
Man one request will increase the consistency of the video...😀
I will try my best
@@BisboWorld btw ur videos are great.....❤️❤️it would be great if you would have some podcasts also....🔥🔥
@@BisboWorld Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more..
This was very detailed video! Untill now, I had just the negative views of Punjab's farmer. But now I can see the benefits of the law too. Thanks Bisbo ❤️
Great work bisbo
I wish ur endeavour gets recognised by every one
I cherish watching your page. It informative and explained very well
Farmers have issues with MSP not written in the law and dispute resolution authority. Arthiya is not middleman but a service provider in mandi who takes a commission. A parallel mandi will also need these Arthiyas ,so they'll never go.The way in which the laws were pushed without enough deliberation also is the reason why the farmers have taken the matter in their own hands.This video doesn't cover both view points holistically.
Hey there, the point of Msp not being in the bill is pointless as bills do not even concern MSP..but still you fall for such rhetorics by politically opined people..
@Odin-The War God Again rhetoric..Do you guarantee all farmers MSP or only some in punjab..Only some farmers in India(especially Punjab) enjoy MSP..Smarter farmers even sell high quality product to export and not on MSP..
@Odin-The War God Govt does not have the money or space to buy and store all produce on MSP..it buys only for ration shops and it will continue ..but if you include MSP in a law then govt becomes bound to procure every produce on MSP which it cannot do obviously..
@Odin-The War God Raising prices via MSP to help farmers is only 1 step of the solution..MSP is not the solution in itself..We obviously need better management of food produce to get more value out of it and only private companies can deliver the efficiency and govt cannot ..
@@lokeshmittal3071 sorry I don't understand. How is MSP not a concern in the Bill?
My uncle is farmer. He has been selling to companies illegally for so long for better prices.. almost every farmers in that area are doing same. Now he and other farmers can do it legally. He is very happy after these reforms. He Supports these reforms.
We support these reforms. Few farmers from punjab don't have right to deprive other millions n millions of farmers off of monetary benefits of these Pro-Farmer Reforms. Govt should not give special treatment to any specific state. All farmers from all states matters.
Never Ever Withdraw these reforms. Never surrender to Lies, misleading and anti-farmer commie agenda.
If govt will withdraw these reforms. You will see bigger and fierce protest against withdrawal in Gujarat and on MP border to bring back these reforms.
Much needed narrative ...thanku. Bisbo
Most welcome Manvendra
U showed both sides... Thank you bisbo!!! As expected you again rocked
Both sides? Ok,now tell me cons of these bills?
Read comment of summet singh also bisbo has only shiwn positive of bill only neither its negative nor better sides of earlier which are 100 times more...