Do not buy birds to then release them, all you are doing is feeding the local cats. If you get birds, let them fly around your house and have fun dont keep them in a small cage 24/7 AND do not isolate them, keep them in pairs and make sure they get along.
@@zulvanich._.4444 You maker it sound like bird poop is extremely bad and hard to clean which is false. It dries quickly and you can just wipe it off. Also, you let them out of the cage so you can see where your birds choose to hang out so that you can prepare those areas for them. My sister has done that and still to this day those birds hang out at the same spots and shit at the same spots.
Please put your fishes in spacious tanks that they will be comfortable in, not cramped, small tanks. And I'm so glad the sheikh mentioned children abusing the animals because some people don't take action when their kids torment pets either out of childish ignorance or for "fun".
I did ..disturbed parrots long tail outside of cage also n I couldn't control as I'm into taking chances of birds,animals, kids frm everywhere, ppl frm everywhere, same aged ppl to elder older junior whoever, .. parrots long tail I disturbed n it used to shout scream ..no pain I gave but disturbed.. same wth love birds,othrs along pigeons outside.. disturbed... but once I killed one pigeon..I'm responsible fully. Frst n last I gave pain mayb to something frm earth n killed a pigeon. Othr time just disturbed n my brother when he was little disturbed him tried best but could not continue successfully anymore. Othr time classmates, junior kids to teens, adult n elder older ppl.. just disturbed not pain .. I did like theives since little but not pain huge loss type..always not stolen type but labelling.. I'm sorry but I will disturb only human, nver animals birds but its so tough though till d end of my life but will try my best n won't disturb any birds, animals.. I loved them felt them but disturbed them bfre but cared them also but I'm worst n I won't ever wth them.
@@Fahhad007 my hands my fingers my mind my brain my feelings my emotion my body my life my exstance wish to squeeze, pull out, to tickle, to hug to kiss to bite to indulge into to eat to mix to b into etc whenever birds long tail , birds wth egos or birds wth innocence obedience, animals wth egos ignoring or animals wth innocence pet obedient , kids wth egos ignoring or kids wth pet obedience type, junior or senior wth egos ignoring or own ppl obedience loving type, seniors wth egos ignoring or own ppl obedience loving... pink color, colorful , green color, those foods, those drinks, things, materials, good outside nature, good insde home or othr places, etc.. make me out of control or excited hungry, etc...
@@Fahhad007 I wish I were psycho or dead one.. I was nver psycho nor ... so I'm ready to get pun ished by dea th sentence anytime..plz .. somebody help me..
Subhanallah, I had this doubt from long time, now I'm very much clear that we can keep birds and fish, Alhamdu lillah, Jazakumullahu ahsanan jazaa fidduniya Wal aakhira ya sheq, Aameen
The closing lines were awesome we can say we are feeding them and providing protection from predators which the birds will need to do it for themselves.
Protecting them by caging them and restraining them from their normal life, how is that logic ? Letting them in wild is just natural and the food chain is natural as well
Well that's just nature. Why are you starving predators from eating the birds too? That's unfair on the predators. Anyways sheikh said it's not haram. For haram you need proof from Quran & Hadith. But from an ethical point of view I wouldn't lock animals in a cage
@nooamystery2470 yes if not mentioned in the Qur'an but one thing Allah must have spoken of is animal abuse and torturing and that we have to be kind to animals.. so locking intelligent animals like birds is never received as a kind act by the bird. I only keep a bird I can train to roam freely around my house.
Alhamdulillah thank u for the clarification….. i have a conure, crow, 2 mynas n a kingfisher… except for the conure, all the rest are rescued. Almost everyday if weather permits i bring them out n let them fly around or do watever it is they want. By sunset all of em would come back to me n follow me back home. One of the myna will join the wild ones n come home by itself the next day or wait for me at our usual spot.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
@@banglacreatorblog2756 when in the hadis prophet Muhammad doesn't said it was not allowed then it's allowed. In the hadis about that little boy and the bird prophet Muhammad doesn't mention about that little boy wasn't allowed to have bird in the cage. Instead prophet Muhammad just mentioned about the sadness the little boy about lost his bird. That maen prophet Muhammad doesn't said that we aren't allowed to have bird in the cage. In the end Allah SWT and the prophet Muhammad peace upon Him knows best
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
I realized long ago that the reality of a 'God' was impossible, so I left my religion. The frailty of the human mind makes us want to believe that there is someone up there looking after us, and fear of death makes us want to believe that we will never die. After much deep thought I realized that we had been tricked by our ancestors who wanted us to behave in a better way for the benefit of society. My belief is so strong that I have an negative feeling towards the people who sustain and propagate religion, and happily take our Zakat (already invested to a value of 4 trillion dollars). Your belief may make you happy so stick with it, but 'God' IS a myth. You have all convinced yourselves that Allah exists because you want to believe it. The Scientific evidence that proves that 'God' did not create 'Man' or our Universe, has been denied by Islam because they don't want you to believe it. Believers are living in a false world, created by very clever people in the past.
@@Stiffytheenlightened our thoughts are actually human. To openly admit that God was created by humans. I do beleive in the same cause at the same time I wil not oppose that there r powers which as a normal being I'm unaware of.Anyways keep sharing your thoughts.
ALLAHU AKBAR SUBHANALLAH ❤ ALHAMDULILLAH❤🥹😭i literally feel sooo happyyy and light after watching this cause i had got two parrots before many days and my family was saying that they are in cage n it's a sin and all other things , i had been thinking of searching and seeing videos about what islamic scholars say about it but I couldn't and now my family had finally decided to return them n i was so sad , i had already started missing them so much but I agreed to return them cause I got convinced that it's a sin and nowww i just watched this videooo and first thing i'm gonna tell them in the morning is this insha'allah Allahumma Aameen ❤
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
I call u to Islam welcome. U don't need to be a christian, Jesus was not. Jesus is muslim. All God's prophets are muslims, since Adam to Mohammed may Allah's peace be upon them all. There is only one true religion through history, and that is Islam. All other religions are inovations by satan and people infuenced by their own desires.. so I call u to Islam, the religion of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Mohammed peace be upon them all ameen. Accept Islam and u will find peace.
Easy way to do away with being agnostic is looking at the different beautifully designed creatures. Evolution doesn't explain the designs of for example the colorful fish and birds. They didn't need to look that beautiful just to survive. A There has to be an amazing designer. Coming to which religion is true. The only preserved scripture is the Quran and the Sunnah. With all its miracles, prophecis and facts, no sane person would deny the truthfulness of the message. Embrace Islam brother/sister, thank us later.
@@animalsandnatureofbosnia5360 thanks for the dawah brother. I understand and you are completely correct. Unfortunately, I’m just not in a position to devote as much as true Muslims do. I believe in only one god. I live a pious, morally just life. I hope Allah accepts me as such
@WWITOTENKOPF I mean there isnt really much to it. You should try praying the way muslims do, and try fasting a few times with Muslims during the month of ramadan. See how it makes you feel. It might put you in an even better state than you are in now.
@@Supremeteamcaptain ur welcome. Noone can't be accepted without the only one way the way of Prophet Mohammed now. U can't be accepted with ur way how u think it needs to be, or by your desires. The only way to be accepted is to accept the whole way, enter Islam fully. All beside that is the way to eternal Hellfire. That is true. U must know. What u told me now that is not enough at all, I must to say to u directly and honestly. So enter Islam andnstart practice bc u never know when u gonna die.. maybe couple day from now. So accept Islam and find peace soon as possible.
I have a cat, and live in a citty almost no green only cars…in the summer the cat wil sit on the balkon togeter whit a ohter cat..in sha Allah i het a house whit a big garden…but the imam is right !!!! Always when i come home she is waiting in front of the door she hears my car from a mile away…and the i come inside and thinking (Subhana ALLAH look what Allah created) an animal thats waiting for you….and everytime she comes asks for food or want to play…i think about Allah and the creation of Allah so different but the “same”
As long as you're feeding them properly. Though it's much better if you set them free. If we have no plan on setting them free, we should build a big sanctuary cage amd put some small tree on it to mimic their natural habitat. If they breed, we can free some of them to multiply on the forest.
I still believe you should abstain because u r depriving them of their freedom..ask yourself the question: why do you cage them?? To satisfy your own desire??
It is a sin to keep them caged -- ignore the sheikh. His opinion is wrong and cruel. Allah SWT is merciful, a nd he has not made creatures to be confined. Lock the sheikh in a room, put a toilet in the corner, and shove food at him through a flap for the rest of his life.
@@rayahzoulou592there's nothing wrong with it. The Creation was created for us, for our sustenance and entertainment. We are give the authority on the earth over other creations. Abiding by shariah guidelines are the only conditions.
Allah has given each animal its own habitat and it’s own food sources. Who are we to keep them in a cage or a tank and feed them. If a cat is eating the birds that we freed that is because Allah made it that way. If you think about a human in place of it you would feel different. Imagine someone kept you in a 4bhk house with all kinds of food but you are not allowed to leave the house. How would you feel about that. Or think about the Covid times, the lockdown, the quarantine, not being able to go out to places we want, not being able to meet our friends and family. How did it feel? Animals too have their own community. Keeping animals in a cage IS WRONG. They don’t willingly come to live in a cage in our houses but rather people capture them. If you try to catch them they will fly, run or swim away from you. One of my neighbours kept a bird in cage for 19 years and in the end that bird died in a cage. How sad is that. And about the plants feeling bad. Do they try to run away no. Because Allah made it that way. If walking on grass was so bad he would have given us another alternative. This is really stupid.
Thank you! Perfectly said. Every animal has its own habitat and these birds are meant to fly free in it's natural habitat. Just feeding them is not enough. How ridiculous
if it was wrong, the Prophet ﷺ would have taught the little boy in the hadith that the skeikh mentioned that keeping birds in cages was bad. But obviously this didn't happen. And our beloved Prophet ﷺ's opinion matters more than any other humans
Please don't take me as an anti muslim. I am not an anti Shaikh as well. I am just saying that in the starting of the video Shaikh has given the full lecture on not to give our own conclusion/ judgement without basing them on quran and hadith. But at the end Shaikh himself has given the judgement at 5:53. Rest i really consider that this Shaikh has authentic knowledge of quran and sunnah. May Allah bless this Shaikh.
I dont think Sheikh passed a judgement nor gave his feeling on it. He was just stating his personal opinion which cannot be used as an official statement.
It's what we call 'hikmah'.. the explanation of any possible good effects of doing so or so.. not passing judgement or 'hukum' such as halal, haram, sunnah, etc.. this one need to be based solely on al-Quran & Sunnah..
In some cultures they love to catch birds and then keep them in a cage as a pet to look at. Please people, how would you feel to be caught and locked in a small room for the rest of your life?
@@tausiftaha12you are deriving nutrition from eating an animal. Food chain. What real benefit do you gain from improsoning a poor animal or bird and depriving it of its freedom? Any ecological benefit? What about nutritional benefits? Get a better hobby
So much informative for the pet lovers. And I have a question that can we do cross breed among birds and animals as nowadays the much more varieties of breeding coming into exist?
But the Quran says birds worship Allah by flying and spreading their wings, keeping them in cages is equivalent to preventing a creature from worshipping Allah for your personal satisfaction.
My brother in Islām, is the religion based upon what we feel? The Prophet of Allāh, the one who was the most merciful amongst mankind towards the creation of Allāh allowed this in the right manner. Then who are we to come and say that this is wrong? Absolutely wrong.
@@ahanimation6079this is the ecosystem of nature and nature is created by ALLAH. Someone’s death, someone’s life. Its not anyone’s concern that an animal will eat another animal. The event Sheikh mentioned was neither a usual practice nor Prophet صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم or other Companions did that. Bottom line is, only those animals and birds who benefit human are familiarly permissible to be kept as pets.
Bear in mind that invasive species from pet releasing is a thing. So I think we should be mindful on what are the impacts of the animals we release to the wild on the ecosystem. Preventing unwanted damage.
@@anthonydavix What do capturers do? They put animals in a cage, do you agree? What is the purpose of that? Is it only to fulfill the selfish desires of people?
@@Cimex090 What I meant is that you only mention the buyers. But the capturers still there. And yes, sometimes people will capture animals for selfish desire.
Mashaa Allah very good said of this Imam “If you have money for freeing birds give that money to poor muslims they will benefit it more” So glad yo hear it is aloud to have pets Because it is also good for children in the west to play and taking care of it instead of hanging on street and learning nothing
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
You think an 16 Year old Teenager stays at Home with an Bird instead of going out with Friends? Come on! Also many Animals arent good for Kids as the Pet is sleeping in the Day and the Kids are interrupting them. Just giving food and not beating the Animal wil not help. You need to give the Animal the life his Species deserve
@@susanneal6063 Well said brother... Just think that what kind of logic/argument is this? Children loves to that's why we can allow children to do anything that they loves to do? As like if you give a gun in any children’s hand then that child will love to fire peoples, then is it logical to give a gun to any children for the sake of their pleasure? Or if a child want to consume drugs to stay in home then can we allow them to consume drugs to stay/keep there in home? So matter of fact is we can't do or obey islam through or according logics, Islam is reality based on full of evidence.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
@@banglacreatorblog2756 and is there any hadits saying that we cannot take away animal's freedom? saying one thing is not permissible requires a strict indicator
@@SulthanMuhammad I can give you lots of hadis more like this that hurt or suffer any animal or if any animal suffer or hurt by you then you have to answer to Allah tayala. So I am saying that putting animals in cage matter of fact this is destroying animals freedom and animals are suffering so you don’t have righta to give suffer to any animal. Now give me hadis Against it.
I have given all the green plants to all the animals to eat. They will be food for every wild animal, every bird of the air and every small crawling animal.
Salam Alaikum wa Rabmatullah, To be honest to myself brother Hakeem is very knowledgeable because I always told myself if I free my birds this will definitely will be their end because by freeing my pet birds other birds or animals can eat them instead of doing the right thing I will be doing a wrong disaster thing to them.
Some people need to understand the difference. Sheikh said it is not haram. For haram you need evidence from Quran & Hadith. However, from a moral point of view I would also agree. I'd not keep any animal confined to a small space like a cage. It's against the animal's nature to just walk around a few centimetre and not fly
Assalamu alaikum.. Allah Az-zawajal didn't create birds to live in cages..if u do so u r depriving them of their freedom and natural instinct, that of flying..u can still observe the beauty of all creatures in their natural habitat and praise Allah Az-zawajal for that.
God is merciful and loving to all creatures and his creation and he doesnt like the oppressors or people who torture or harm. So its very simple, you should only get a pet if you can take care of them and make sure they are happy.
5:48 "Would I be rewarded if I buy birds and set them free? I personally think that you won't..." This guy gave a lengthy lecture about not giving personal opinions, then proceeds to give his own personal opinion...
He was talking about "sadistic" opinion when keeping animals in cage. As long as they keep their pets healthy it's not sadistic. Secondly he answered the question by adding "I personally think..." to make it clear that his answer is not from hadith or Quran. So you can take the answer, or leave it it's up to you.
I agree it is sadistic. I am by nature always saddened to see anything caged . It is life imprisonment for no reason whatsoever. ALLAH created everything to be free. It is a cruel practice.
Assalamualikum Sheikh! I am living now en non muslim country but i want to migrate en muslim country if i want to migrate to Saudi arabia , what can i do and can peole get citizenship in Saudi arabia? Plz anwer me 👏👏👏
Sheikh! Perhaps the meaning of the question that the brother asked was not clear. In fact, here in Pakistan, some people catch free sparrows by setting nets and then stand on the roadside and sell these sparrows, and people buy and free these sparrows for charity. So is doing this a reward as the sparrows were captured wrongly? And should not these sparrows be free??
Hi, I've rescued a sparrow bird today from my garage. It was trapped inside a cycle. So I bought it home & gave the bird some rice & water to eat. He is very small & can't fly yet & can't make any chirping sound. He also can't eat by himself. I handfeeded him with a syringe. I'm very scared of what to do to keep him alive. Also if it's Haram or halal to keep it? Please give me suggestions!
Having a pet is also a kind of training. It teaches children how to be a responsible parent in the future.They are not toys. And to my co-pet owners. Don't provide your pet a very small aquarium, cage etc... It should be big to make them thrive for so long.For example the betta fish. They were put on a small fish bowl which is not actually suitable for them. They should be raise like in the wild. Betta fighting should be stop.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
@@banglacreatorblog2756use some logic brother, if putting the birds in a cage or keeping them as pets aren’t permissible in islam then Prophet(صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) would have warned us and there would be atleast a quran verse stating the prohibition.
I got parrot and i take care him very well. New toy's every 6 or 8 months Every day, more than 7 or 8 times clean his pee And make sure i spend my time with him
I think keeping birds in cage should not be done, instead u can pet them as free creature like the pigeons. And also fish should not be kept in aquarium instead should be kept in Pond.
@@m.i.6841 Logics n arguments are not acceptable in islam. If you know about one single sahih hadis that says we fan pet animals in cage then show me. We can pet if we can give them freedom as they needed. Or for hunting that is another matter. So I want to know that for a personal desire, for self soul satisfaction can we put any animal in cage? Is there is any sahih hadis or any verse of Quran you know about this topic?
@@banglacreatorblog2756 what hadith says the use of logic in not permissable? maybe if u used the logic Allah swt gave u, u wouldn't be asking dumb questions on youtube
@@m.i.6841 I can give you lots of hadis more like this that hurt or suffer any animal or if any animal suffer or hurt by you then you have to answer to Allah tayala. So I am saying that putting animals in cage matter of fact this is destroying animals freedom and animals are suffering so you don’t have rights to give suffer to any animal. Now give me hadis Against it.
Each and every creature on this earth requires its own required space or territory to live within be it a Bird or animal on earth or inside the water according to its required habitual biome which many a times humans deprive to give them which is called privacy space of living
Can I disagree with the Shaikh without sounding rude please? In Islam we are allowed to eat meat without prolonging the pain and suffering of the animal. So the animal should live the most natural life and when the time to be slaughtered comes it should be treated with utmost mercy. What other reason would you cage a creature that was meant to live freely? I do agree its selfish and to some extent sadistic. Eating an animal is not the same as torturing it. No animal likes to be caged. Finally Nughaiŕ was not a caged bird and the owner of the bird was a child (Abu Umair).So adult Muslims are gonna be playing with birds now coz little Umair did it? Not a single sahaba kept caged birds as pets. How you treat a living being has an effect on your life baraka. Be merciful and keep a free pet like a cat etc not aquariums and cages. Wallahu a3lam
Is your disagreement based on the statements of the Salaf or the major credible scholars or is it your personal itjihad? You do realize that we understand the rulings of the Qur'an and Sunnah according to the understanding of the companions and the righteous predecessors right? And how scholars understand it? Sheikh said nothing on his own but what the scholars of Islam have understood through the hadith.
@@HATL201 Exactly bro. Neither the prophet nor the sahabas kept Allah's creation in restricted environments taking some of their rights. As I said the little Nughair was not a caged bird but more like a pet companion of little Umair. If you really want to be like the little boy then do what he did. Keep a pet companion and not pet prisoner. Have some mercy bro, its a Muslim requirement. I eat meat because the salaf did it. I dont cage animals because the salaf didnt. Lets not be like the Christians when they want to worship their desires they play with words and call Jesus God or son of God. Sacrifice your pleasures to gain Allah's pleasure. Wallahu a3lam
@@dublinbus4138 Again, you didn't really answer my question. You've come to the conclusion that it's impermissible to keep birds in cage based on your own ijtihad or you have statements of any major scholars who have said that? The laymen are not given the freedom to interpret the deen on their own. Check keeping the birds in cage fatwa on IslamQA. You said "Neither the prophet nor the sahabas kept Allah's creation in restricted environments taking some of their rights." What do you say about farming chickens, goats, cows etc. in farms where they are restricted in a closed environment? Do you see scholars giving fatwa against that? The answer is no. Because those animals serve a purpose for the humans. The same way, pet birds who are fed properly, looked after and well kept are a source of entertainment for adults and children, they give us joy and cheer us up. The scholars see that to be perfectly permissible. Again, see IslamQA's fatwa on that.
@@HATL201 The farm animals should not be caged unnecessarily either unless there is absolutely no otherwise. Just because Muslims today do something because it's convenient for them it doesn't make it halal. You know that for sure. Animal abuse is animal abuse whether we like it or not. An animal doesn't need food and water only. The conditions of the environment should be as natural as it's supposed to be. A bird was meant to stretch its wings and fly in vast environments. Chickens don't fly so a chicken doesn't need as much space as a wild bird. But in the end you do what you desire. We will all face the consequences of our actions. Salam bro
@@dublinbus4138 Understand Islam through those who have studied deen their whole lives, speak Arabic and are credible Muftis. Do not use your aqal and mantiq to come to conclusions, it's a dangerous road. Wa Aleikum Assalam.
Sheikh, every living creatures have their destiny, one should live as Allah swt created them, regarding hunted down is also destiny, but putting them in cages or aquarium is putting one in bondage, that's my believes.
Assalamualaykum shiekh 1 of your videos you described the face of Allah with 2 hands can you tell me more about it? Is there true? Allah has face and 2 hands
The mentioned narration doesn’t argument that any bird or animal is permissible to kept as a pet. As that was not practised by Prophet صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم or by Companions رضوان اللّٰہ علیہ اجمعین. Only those animals and birds are familiarly permissible to be kept who benefit human. It has become a fun and source of show off by keeping expensive animals and birds of no use.
@Jason Manson thats called nature...... if something happens to them in the wild thats natural, why did the bird have wings in the first place if it was meant to be kept in a cage????? It was given this blessing to survive in the wild and the thing knows how to best use it.
He said it is not haram. For haram you need evidence from Quran & Hadith. However, from a moral point of view I would also agree. I'd not keep any animal confined to a small space.
@@maazmustafa2322 The evidence is that the hadith says show animals "kindness". I don't agree with this scholar's interpretation of the hadith he refers to and to be honest he spent the first 4 minutes attack the questioner's expression of feeling which I think was to some degree unprofessional and came across as more of a personal emotional reaction. Allah Knows best.
Sheikh, respectfully, I do not agree. I believe your argument is wrong on this point. The hadith quoted does not imply that the boy's bird was in cage. It only mentions 'pet bird'. Now you will say that how can you keep a bird without a cage. Pet birds can be without a cage as well. I have seen, and you can research yourself as well. People have birds who are not in cages. It is the level of trust and bonding between thr animal and human that makes it possible. If you keep a bird which is caged that would mean that you do not have a bond with the animal and it would fly away if you leave it open. Meaning it is not tamed and not your pet and is being kept against it's own will. Do birds need big area by nature, to fly? Yes. Can birds be kept without cages? Yes. Which birds would die if you take them out of a cage? None. There is only a risk that the ones which you would have captured from another place/climate and all of a sudden you leave them out, then out of fear or out of confusion or because the environment is not suitable to them, etc, they could meet bad fate. Whereas if we leave the birds where they naturally are, then they will remain safe. So since there is no hadith or ayat indicating about keeping caged animals (afaik), i strongly believe that keeping animals in cages is cruelty and should not be done.
some people are just thirsty of philosophical knowledge thus were attracted to philosophical presentation. but philosophically one must also asked why was he here? what he is meant for? who controls the univ erse and who was the ultimate creator and designer? philosophical questions will also lead one to a supreme being... unless ALLAH subhanahu wa taala refused to guide him....
Sheikh i have one doubt plz answer me Que is that in my house there a cat come to my house always and we used to feed him but day by day he used to toilet in our bedroom so i decided to not let the cat enter in house Is it sin in doing so?
s.a i don't agree with placing a bird in a cage where it can't use its wings to fly. sorry...but that's my opinion. I also don't agree with the Sheikh telling him not to say that it's sadistic. it's just his opinion and he is entitled to it. he's still asking the question to make sure or he'll stand corrected. anyways, may Allah guide us all.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom. And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
The birds die very fast in the wild. Typically these birds aren't even native to their environment. Even if they are, they don't know where the food or water is, they don't understand how to take proper shelter, head to a warmer area when they're cold. They'll interact with other animals assuming they're friendly. They are blessed if they can survive a day
I used to have 15 to 16 birds and I only bought 5 but later they grew up to the rest and I had a cage as big as a large sofa ..but my mother always says that free them. birds curse their owner for keeping them in cage 😅 ...but now I know that they never did curse me atleast for keeping them in cage
Do not buy birds to then release them, all you are doing is feeding the local cats. If you get birds, let them fly around your house and have fun dont keep them in a small cage 24/7 AND do not isolate them, keep them in pairs and make sure they get along.
They make the house dirty
If its not a pegion then I don't think setting it free in the house is a good idea
Lets just not buy birds so that people do not capture them and then sell them for profits
@@zulvanich._.4444 Easy tame them i tamed my birds and they were free to do as they please
@@zulvanich._.4444 You maker it sound like bird poop is extremely bad and hard to clean which is false. It dries quickly and you can just wipe it off. Also, you let them out of the cage so you can see where your birds choose to hang out so that you can prepare those areas for them. My sister has done that and still to this day those birds hang out at the same spots and shit at the same spots.
@@zulvanich._.4444 They poop everywhere ohmgg
Please put your fishes in spacious tanks that they will be comfortable in, not cramped, small tanks. And I'm so glad the sheikh mentioned children abusing the animals because some people don't take action when their kids torment pets either out of childish ignorance or for "fun".
I did ..disturbed parrots long tail outside of cage also n I couldn't control as I'm into taking chances of birds,animals, kids frm everywhere, ppl frm everywhere, same aged ppl to elder older junior whoever, .. parrots long tail I disturbed n it used to shout scream ..no pain I gave but disturbed.. same wth love birds,othrs along pigeons outside.. disturbed... but once I killed one pigeon..I'm responsible fully. Frst n last I gave pain mayb to something frm earth n killed a pigeon. Othr time just disturbed n my brother when he was little disturbed him tried best but could not continue successfully anymore. Othr time classmates, junior kids to teens, adult n elder older ppl.. just disturbed not pain .. I did like theives since little but not pain huge loss type..always not stolen type but labelling.. I'm sorry but I will disturb only human, nver animals birds but its so tough though till d end of my life but will try my best n won't disturb any birds, animals.. I loved them felt them but disturbed them bfre but cared them also but I'm worst n I won't ever wth them.
Aquarium fishes or any fishes or water r scary..
Kid tormenting animals is huge sign of psychopathy
@@Fahhad007 my hands my fingers my mind my brain my feelings my emotion my body my life my exstance wish to squeeze, pull out, to tickle, to hug to kiss to bite to indulge into to eat to mix to b into etc whenever birds long tail , birds wth egos or birds wth innocence obedience, animals wth egos ignoring or animals wth innocence pet obedient , kids wth egos ignoring or kids wth pet obedience type, junior or senior wth egos ignoring or own ppl obedience loving type, seniors wth egos ignoring or own ppl obedience loving... pink color, colorful , green color, those foods, those drinks, things, materials, good outside nature, good insde home or othr places, etc.. make me out of control or excited hungry, etc...
@@Fahhad007 I wish I were psycho or dead one.. I was nver psycho nor ... so I'm ready to get pun ished by dea th sentence anytime..plz .. somebody help me..
Subhanallah, I had this doubt from long time, now I'm very much clear that we can keep birds and fish, Alhamdu lillah, Jazakumullahu ahsanan jazaa fidduniya Wal aakhira ya sheq, Aameen
Birdie birdie in the sky... Dropped a poopie in my eye.. me no scream, me no cry.. me thank the Lord that cows dont fly.. Thank you Sheikh 😊
😅
😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
🫡🫡🫡
I love Sheikh Assim Al Hakim so much
What love he is misleading
@@emotionpictures19 what thing he mislead? Dont do baseless accusation.
The closing lines were awesome we can say we are feeding them and providing protection from predators which the birds will need to do it for themselves.
Protecting them by caging them and restraining them from their normal life, how is that logic ? Letting them in wild is just natural and the food chain is natural as well
Well that's just nature. Why are you starving predators from eating the birds too? That's unfair on the predators. Anyways sheikh said it's not haram. For haram you need proof from Quran & Hadith. But from an ethical point of view I wouldn't lock animals in a cage
@@maazmustafa2322 From where do you get the ethical point of view if not from the Quran and Sunnah? This is just your subjective viewpoint.
@@nooamystery2470 still free the birds
@nooamystery2470 yes if not mentioned in the Qur'an but one thing Allah must have spoken of is animal abuse and torturing and that we have to be kind to animals.. so locking intelligent animals like birds is never received as a kind act by the bird. I only keep a bird I can train to roam freely around my house.
Keeping cat is the best way of pet 🐱 cat can roam freely inside the home and outside for search for food
If you are keeping cat feed it too..don't depend on your neighbour
@@stopover1238u know him? How u know he never does that?
Well replied. May Allah give you a long happy life and keep guiding us. Jazakallah khairan
What reply, he is totally misleading
@@emotionpictures19 How? Because he follows the way of the salaf?
@@emotionpictures19 how
Keeping animals, birds, fish and insects trapped in cages is A MAJOR SIN. Anything you do to the creations of God will be done to you.
May Allah Save us from sins AMEEN and forgive us our sins
Ameen ya rabbil alamin
Aameen....
Aameen
AMIIN ALLAHUMA AMIIN
Ameen
Alhamdulillah thank u for the clarification….. i have a conure, crow, 2 mynas n a kingfisher… except for the conure, all the rest are rescued. Almost everyday if weather permits i bring them out n let them fly around or do watever it is they want. By sunset all of em would come back to me n follow me back home. One of the myna will join the wild ones n come home by itself the next day or wait for me at our usual spot.
I'd love to see your birds 😍
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
Subhanallah Subhanallah
How sweet it looks...
They come back to u....
You are not destroying any freedom of them and its so nice💜 many peoples are petting animals like this
@@banglacreatorblog2756 when in the hadis prophet Muhammad doesn't said it was not allowed then it's allowed. In the hadis about that little boy and the bird prophet Muhammad doesn't mention about that little boy wasn't allowed to have bird in the cage. Instead prophet Muhammad just mentioned about the sadness the little boy about lost his bird. That maen prophet Muhammad doesn't said that we aren't allowed to have bird in the cage. In the end Allah SWT and the prophet Muhammad peace upon Him knows best
Masha allah. Very good explain.jazakallahu hairah.
Beautiful answer MashaAllah.
Ma sha Allah. Barak Allah feek.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
"They're walking on grass & hurting the feelings of grass"🙄😂😂
JazakAllah sheikh, well explained.
I realized long ago that the reality of a 'God' was impossible, so I left my religion. The frailty of the human mind makes us want to believe that there is someone up there looking after us, and fear of death makes us want to believe that we will never die. After much deep thought I realized that we had been tricked by our ancestors who wanted us to behave in a better way for the benefit of society. My belief is so strong that I have an negative feeling towards the people who sustain and propagate religion, and happily take our Zakat (already invested to a value of 4 trillion dollars). Your belief may make you happy so stick with it, but 'God' IS a myth. You have all convinced yourselves that Allah exists because you want to believe it. The Scientific evidence that proves that 'God' did not create 'Man' or our Universe, has been denied by Islam because they don't want you to believe it. Believers are living in a false world, created by very clever people in the past.
If my wife leaves the house without my permission, can I Beat her with a baseball bat???
@@Stiffytheenlightened do you have a channel or blog's
@@stoneworshipper2599 Why?
@@Stiffytheenlightened our thoughts are actually human. To openly admit that God was created by humans. I do beleive in the same cause at the same time I wil not oppose that there r powers which as a normal being I'm unaware of.Anyways keep sharing your thoughts.
Jazāka Allāhu khayran Sheikh. I love cats and my mind is at rest after listening to your speech.
shaikh I love for the sake of Allah. May Allah SWT reward you abundantly
Masha Allah great islamic scholar.
I love this answer..... Syukran
May Allah subhanahu wa taala guides us more.... Jazak Allah khayr.....❤❤❤
حسبنا الله و نعم الوکیل ❤
لا اله الا انت سبحانک انی کنت من الظالمین ❤
اللهم صلی علی سیدنا محمد و علی آل سیدنا محمد صلی الله علیه وآله وسلم ❤
ALLAHU AKBAR SUBHANALLAH ❤ ALHAMDULILLAH❤🥹😭i literally feel sooo happyyy and light after watching this cause i had got two parrots before many days and my family was saying that they are in cage n it's a sin and all other things , i had been thinking of searching and seeing videos about what islamic scholars say about it but I couldn't and now my family had finally decided to return them n i was so sad , i had already started missing them so much but I agreed to return them cause I got convinced that it's a sin and nowww i just watched this videooo and first thing i'm gonna tell them in the morning is this insha'allah Allahumma Aameen ❤
You are amazing and I am learning a lot from you. May Allah bless you.
Masha allah thanks shieak for clearing my doubt.
Beautiful🕊️
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
Y’a allah Grant us Al firdaws to all Muslims of SAW❤
Thank you for this clarification, may Allah cc reward
I’m a Christian, (I believe Jesus was not god however, so I’m more gnostic in belief) but I LOVE Assim!
I call u to Islam welcome. U don't need to be a christian, Jesus was not. Jesus is muslim. All God's prophets are muslims, since Adam to Mohammed may Allah's peace be upon them all. There is only one true religion through history, and that is Islam. All other religions are inovations by satan and people infuenced by their own desires.. so I call u to Islam, the religion of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Mohammed peace be upon them all ameen. Accept Islam and u will find peace.
Easy way to do away with being agnostic is looking at the different beautifully designed creatures. Evolution doesn't explain the designs of for example the colorful fish and birds. They didn't need to look that beautiful just to survive. A
There has to be an amazing designer.
Coming to which religion is true. The only preserved scripture is the Quran and the Sunnah. With all its miracles, prophecis and facts, no sane person would deny the truthfulness of the message.
Embrace Islam brother/sister, thank us later.
@@animalsandnatureofbosnia5360 thanks for the dawah brother. I understand and you are completely correct. Unfortunately, I’m just not in a position to devote as much as true Muslims do. I believe in only one god. I live a pious, morally just life. I hope Allah accepts me as such
@WWITOTENKOPF I mean there isnt really much to it. You should try praying the way muslims do, and try fasting a few times with Muslims during the month of ramadan. See how it makes you feel. It might put you in an even better state than you are in now.
@@Supremeteamcaptain ur welcome. Noone can't be accepted without the only one way the way of Prophet Mohammed now. U can't be accepted with ur way how u think it needs to be, or by your desires. The only way to be accepted is to accept the whole way, enter Islam fully. All beside that is the way to eternal Hellfire. That is true. U must know. What u told me now that is not enough at all, I must to say to u directly and honestly. So enter Islam andnstart practice bc u never know when u gonna die.. maybe couple day from now. So accept Islam and find peace soon as possible.
imagine getting consoled by My love, Prophet Muhammad PBUH
SallAllahu Alayhi wa Alihi Wassallam ☝🏻❤🤲🏻🇵🇸🏳
I have a cat, and live in a citty almost no green only cars…in the summer the cat wil sit on the balkon togeter whit a ohter cat..in sha Allah i het a house whit a big garden…but the imam is right !!!! Always when i come home she is waiting in front of the door she hears my car from a mile away…and the i come inside and thinking (Subhana ALLAH look what Allah created) an animal thats waiting for you….and everytime she comes asks for food or want to play…i think about Allah and the creation of Allah so different but the “same”
I had a misconception about keeping birds caged was sin
Jazakallah 🤲
From India 🇮🇳
As long as you're feeding them properly. Though it's much better if you set them free. If we have no plan on setting them free, we should build a big sanctuary cage amd put some small tree on it to mimic their natural habitat. If they breed, we can free some of them to multiply on the forest.
I still believe you should abstain because u r depriving them of their freedom..ask yourself the question: why do you cage them?? To satisfy your own desire??
It is a sin if you neglect it.
It is a sin to keep them caged -- ignore the sheikh. His opinion is wrong and cruel. Allah SWT is merciful, a nd he has not made creatures to be confined. Lock the sheikh in a room, put a toilet in the corner, and shove food at him through a flap for the rest of his life.
@@rayahzoulou592there's nothing wrong with it. The Creation was created for us, for our sustenance and entertainment. We are give the authority on the earth over other creations. Abiding by shariah guidelines are the only conditions.
Assalamualaikum jazak ALLAH for explaining even I was confused to keeping birds at home
Mashallah, insightful as always.
Allah has given each animal its own habitat and it’s own food sources. Who are we to keep them in a cage or a tank and feed them. If a cat is eating the birds that we freed that is because Allah made it that way. If you think about a human in place of it you would feel different. Imagine someone kept you in a 4bhk house with all kinds of food but you are not allowed to leave the house. How would you feel about that. Or think about the Covid times, the lockdown, the quarantine, not being able to go out to places we want, not being able to meet our friends and family. How did it feel? Animals too have their own community. Keeping animals in a cage IS WRONG. They don’t willingly come to live in a cage in our houses but rather people capture them. If you try to catch them they will fly, run or swim away from you. One of my neighbours kept a bird in cage for 19 years and in the end that bird died in a cage. How sad is that. And about the plants feeling bad. Do they try to run away no. Because Allah made it that way. If walking on grass was so bad he would have given us another alternative. This is really stupid.
Thank you! Perfectly said. Every animal has its own habitat and these birds are meant to fly free in it's natural habitat. Just feeding them is not enough. How ridiculous
if it was wrong, the Prophet ﷺ would have taught the little boy in the hadith that the skeikh mentioned that keeping birds in cages was bad. But obviously this didn't happen. And our beloved Prophet ﷺ's opinion matters more than any other humans
do not compare a human with an animal, give us some respect
Allhumdulillah I see this video I want to know too
Assalamualikum ma shaa allha we'll expained shaik may allha reward you in duniya and akhira
جزاك الله
Please don't take me as an anti muslim. I am not an anti Shaikh as well. I am just saying that in the starting of the video Shaikh has given the full lecture on not to give our own conclusion/ judgement without basing them on quran and hadith. But at the end Shaikh himself has given the judgement at 5:53.
Rest i really consider that this Shaikh has authentic knowledge of quran and sunnah.
May Allah bless this Shaikh.
I dont think Sheikh passed a judgement nor gave his feeling on it. He was just stating his personal opinion which cannot be used as an official statement.
@@abdulhalim-jk9lz before giving his personal opinion, that he gave a lengthy lecture about not giving personal opinion...
It's what we call 'hikmah'.. the explanation of any possible good effects of doing so or so.. not passing judgement or 'hukum' such as halal, haram, sunnah, etc.. this one need to be based solely on al-Quran & Sunnah..
In some cultures they love to catch birds and then keep them in a cage as a pet to look at. Please people, how would you feel to be caught and locked in a small room for the rest of your life?
I mean, how would you feel if you were domesticated and slaughtered and eaten?
If it's not haram, don't bring questionable morality into it.
@@tausiftaha12 your comment doesn't make sense and is utterly ignorent
@@tausiftaha12you are deriving nutrition from eating an animal. Food chain. What real benefit do you gain from improsoning a poor animal or bird and depriving it of its freedom? Any ecological benefit? What about nutritional benefits? Get a better hobby
So much informative for the pet lovers. And I have a question that can we do cross breed among birds and animals as nowadays the much more varieties of breeding coming into exist?
But the Quran says birds worship Allah by flying and spreading their wings, keeping them in cages is equivalent to preventing a creature from worshipping Allah for your personal satisfaction.
To provide a bird good treatment, food water and medication is way better than freeing it out to feed other big birds cats snakes etc.
Who said they need to be in a state of flight for the worship of Allah?
@@mustafasadmansakib exactly 💯
My brother in Islām, is the religion based upon what we feel?
The Prophet of Allāh, the one who was the most merciful amongst mankind towards the creation of Allāh allowed this in the right manner.
Then who are we to come and say that this is wrong? Absolutely wrong.
@@ahanimation6079this is the ecosystem of nature and nature is created by ALLAH. Someone’s death, someone’s life. Its not anyone’s concern that an animal will eat another animal. The event Sheikh mentioned was neither a usual practice nor Prophet صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم or other Companions did that.
Bottom line is, only those animals and birds who benefit human are familiarly permissible to be kept as pets.
جزاک الله خیر شيخ
JazakAllah khair
Bear in mind that invasive species from pet releasing is a thing.
So I think we should be mindful on what are the impacts of the animals we release to the wild on the ecosystem.
Preventing unwanted damage.
Yes.
Or maybe people should just stop buying pets so that way they can live in their natural habitat
@@Cimex090 You do know that there are still the capturers, right?
@@anthonydavix What do capturers do? They put animals in a cage, do you agree? What is the purpose of that? Is it only to fulfill the selfish desires of people?
@@Cimex090 What I meant is that you only mention the buyers. But the capturers still there.
And yes, sometimes people will capture animals for selfish desire.
Subhan Allah
Masha'Allah
Thank you 🎉❤🎉
Mashaa Allah very good said of this Imam
“If you have money for freeing birds give that money to poor muslims they will benefit it more”
So glad yo hear it is aloud to have pets
Because it is also good for children in the west to play and taking care of it instead of hanging on street and learning nothing
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
You think an 16 Year old Teenager stays at Home with an Bird instead of going out with Friends? Come on! Also many Animals arent good for Kids as the Pet is sleeping in the Day and the Kids are interrupting them. Just giving food and not beating the Animal wil not help. You need to give the Animal the life his Species deserve
@@susanneal6063 Well said brother... Just think that what kind of logic/argument is this? Children loves to that's why we can allow children to do anything that they loves to do? As like if you give a gun in any children’s hand then that child will love to fire peoples, then is it logical to give a gun to any children for the sake of their pleasure? Or if a child want to consume drugs to stay in home then can we allow them to consume drugs to stay/keep there in home?
So matter of fact is we can't do or obey islam through or according logics, Islam is reality based on full of evidence.
Barakallahu feek
The actual answer starts from @3:35 You are welcome
Haqq Subhaan Allaah...
It has to be based upon Qur'aan and Sunnah Period.. it's over.
Assalamu alaikum jazak allah all questions I had when I bought som birds after listening u i got my answers
Thank you for clarifying my doubt i had from long time
Having pets are a responsibility. If you want to go out, you have to give to someone else to look after and that person might not like it.
wise word brother. pets much more like our kid.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
@@banglacreatorblog2756 and is there any hadits saying that we cannot take away animal's freedom? saying one thing is not permissible requires a strict indicator
@@SulthanMuhammad I can give you lots of hadis more like this that hurt or suffer any animal or if any animal suffer or hurt by you then you have to answer to Allah tayala. So I am saying that putting animals in cage matter of fact this is destroying animals freedom and animals are suffering so you don’t have righta to give suffer to any animal. Now give me hadis Against it.
@@banglacreatorblog2756 and why do you think that birds in cages are suffering? brother they are happy and singing.
I have given all the green plants to all the animals to eat. They will be food for every wild animal, every bird of the air and every small crawling animal.
Salam Alaikum wa Rabmatullah, To be honest to myself brother Hakeem is very knowledgeable because I always told myself if I free my birds this will definitely will be their end because by freeing my pet birds other birds or animals can eat them instead of doing the right thing I will be doing a wrong disaster thing to them.
Alla💥 Created Every living 🌞with Freedom, Nobody's 😅can make them 😢under Control' 😮
Some people need to understand the difference. Sheikh said it is not haram. For haram you need evidence from Quran & Hadith. However, from a moral point of view I would also agree. I'd not keep any animal confined to a small space like a cage. It's against the animal's nature to just walk around a few centimetre and not fly
Assalamu alaikum.. Allah Az-zawajal didn't create birds to live in cages..if u do so u r depriving them of their freedom and natural instinct, that of flying..u can still observe the beauty of all creatures in their natural habitat and praise Allah Az-zawajal for that.
God is merciful and loving to all creatures and his creation and he doesnt like the oppressors or people who torture or harm. So its very simple, you should only get a pet if you can take care of them and make sure they are happy.
Amin🤲❤
5:48 "Would I be rewarded if I buy birds and set them free? I personally think that you won't..."
This guy gave a lengthy lecture about not giving personal opinions, then proceeds to give his own personal opinion...
He was talking about "sadistic" opinion when keeping animals in cage. As long as they keep their pets healthy it's not sadistic. Secondly he answered the question by adding "I personally think..." to make it clear that his answer is not from hadith or Quran. So you can take the answer, or leave it it's up to you.
Good to precise that keeping them in a cage where they can move freely not in a cage too small.
I agree it is sadistic. I am by nature always saddened to see anything caged . It is life imprisonment for no reason whatsoever. ALLAH created everything to be free. It is a cruel practice.
I agree. How about if we start locking people in a room for life. As long as we're feeding them. Right ?
@@catherinelynn5073, even in jail they feed.
Beautiful Explanation❤!!! Alhamdulillah !!!!
I love ❤️ pets especially fishes & birds ;
Jazakh Allahu khairan kaseera 💐💐💐😅
SubhanAllah …..
God bless you
If everyone on earth stops buying ornamental birds and fishes then there won't be rearing of such species who are destined to live in cage forever
The birds and fish will live in their designated environments and this will not be an issue.
@ssjlkrillin who will decide what are their designated environments?
When he said it’s sadistic he probably didn’t know that if they are freed the won’t be able to survive in the environment outside cage
Assalamualikum Sheikh! I am living now en non muslim country but i want to migrate en muslim country if i want to migrate to Saudi arabia , what can i do and can peole get citizenship in Saudi arabia?
Plz anwer me
👏👏👏
Sheikh! Perhaps the meaning of the question that the brother asked was not clear. In fact, here in Pakistan, some people catch free sparrows by setting nets and then stand on the roadside and sell these sparrows, and people buy and free these sparrows for charity. So is doing this a reward as the sparrows were captured wrongly? And should not these sparrows be free??
JazakAllah
Hi, I've rescued a sparrow bird today from my garage. It was trapped inside a cycle. So I bought it home & gave the bird some rice & water to eat. He is very small & can't fly yet & can't make any chirping sound. He also can't eat by himself. I handfeeded him with a syringe. I'm very scared of what to do to keep him alive. Also if it's Haram or halal to keep it? Please give me suggestions!
Keep it and take care of it man..
Ya seikh we ask because we don't know ad we care its just our feelings.
Assalamaliku As my ? Is in kabarstan can we sallam to moutha
Like as salaam ha ala kabur. What is have sahi hadis pl reply me
Having a pet is also a kind of training. It teaches children how to be a responsible parent in the future.They are not toys. And to my co-pet owners. Don't provide your pet a very small aquarium, cage etc... It should be big to make them thrive for so long.For example the betta fish. They were put on a small fish bowl which is not actually suitable for them. They should be raise like in the wild. Betta fighting should be stop.
Subhanallah Subhanallah Allahuakbar
Alhamdulillah.....my kid he love birds too much...he is 9 years old 🧓
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
@@banglacreatorblog2756use some logic brother, if putting the birds in a cage or keeping them as pets aren’t permissible in islam then Prophet(صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) would have warned us and there would be atleast a quran verse stating the prohibition.
You are really right, We can't do anything that can suffer animals..
Thanks you so much for helping me
Must the cage b big or any size is ok brother?Shud they b in pairs male n female?
Sheikh, the hadith of anas didn't mention the bird was caged.
I got parrot and i take care him very well.
New toy's every 6 or 8 months
Every day, more than 7 or 8 times clean his pee
And make sure i spend my time with him
5:24 BRO PROPHET IS WILD FOR MAKING FUN OF A CHILD WHO'S CRYING OVER A BIRD'S DEATH 🤣😂🤣😂😂
I think keeping birds in cage should not be done, instead u can pet them as free creature like the pigeons. And also fish should not be kept in aquarium instead should be kept in Pond.
"I think" "i feel." your feelings dont matter, tell us what you know.
how do you keep a pond inside your house?
@@m.i.6841 Logics n arguments are not acceptable in islam. If you know about one single sahih hadis that says we fan pet animals in cage then show me. We can pet if we can give them freedom as they needed. Or for hunting that is another matter. So I want to know that for a personal desire, for self soul satisfaction can we put any animal in cage? Is there is any sahih hadis or any verse of Quran you know about this topic?
@@banglacreatorblog2756 what hadith says the use of logic in not permissable? maybe if u used the logic Allah swt gave u, u wouldn't be asking dumb questions on youtube
@@m.i.6841 I can give you lots of hadis more like this that hurt or suffer any animal or if any animal suffer or hurt by you then you have to answer to Allah tayala. So I am saying that putting animals in cage matter of fact this is destroying animals freedom and animals are suffering so you don’t have rights to give suffer to any animal. Now give me hadis Against it.
Each and every creature on this earth requires its own required space or territory to live within be it a Bird or animal on earth or inside the water according to its required habitual biome which many a times humans deprive to give them which is called privacy space of living
Can I disagree with the Shaikh without sounding rude please?
In Islam we are allowed to eat meat without prolonging the pain and suffering of the animal. So the animal should live the most natural life and when the time to be slaughtered comes it should be treated with utmost mercy.
What other reason would you cage a creature that was meant to live freely? I do agree its selfish and to some extent sadistic. Eating an animal is not the same as torturing it. No animal likes to be caged.
Finally Nughaiŕ was not a caged bird and the owner of the bird was a child (Abu Umair).So adult Muslims are gonna be playing with birds now coz little Umair did it? Not a single sahaba kept caged birds as pets.
How you treat a living being has an effect on your life baraka. Be merciful and keep a free pet like a cat etc not aquariums and cages.
Wallahu a3lam
Is your disagreement based on the statements of the Salaf or the major credible scholars or is it your personal itjihad?
You do realize that we understand the rulings of the Qur'an and Sunnah according to the understanding of the companions and the righteous predecessors right? And how scholars understand it?
Sheikh said nothing on his own but what the scholars of Islam have understood through the hadith.
@@HATL201 Exactly bro.
Neither the prophet nor the sahabas kept Allah's creation in restricted environments taking some of their rights.
As I said the little Nughair was not a caged bird but more like a pet companion of little Umair. If you really want to be like the little boy then do what he did. Keep a pet companion and not pet prisoner. Have some mercy bro, its a Muslim requirement.
I eat meat because the salaf did it. I dont cage animals because the salaf didnt.
Lets not be like the Christians when they want to worship their desires they play with words and call Jesus God or son of God.
Sacrifice your pleasures to gain Allah's pleasure.
Wallahu a3lam
@@dublinbus4138 Again, you didn't really answer my question. You've come to the conclusion that it's impermissible to keep birds in cage based on your own ijtihad or you have statements of any major scholars who have said that?
The laymen are not given the freedom to interpret the deen on their own.
Check keeping the birds in cage fatwa on IslamQA.
You said "Neither the prophet nor the sahabas kept Allah's creation in restricted environments taking some of their rights."
What do you say about farming chickens, goats, cows etc. in farms where they are restricted in a closed environment?
Do you see scholars giving fatwa against that? The answer is no. Because those animals serve a purpose for the humans.
The same way, pet birds who are fed properly, looked after and well kept are a source of entertainment for adults and children, they give us joy and cheer us up.
The scholars see that to be perfectly permissible. Again, see IslamQA's fatwa on that.
@@HATL201 The farm animals should not be caged unnecessarily either unless there is absolutely no otherwise.
Just because Muslims today do something because it's convenient for them it doesn't make it halal. You know that for sure.
Animal abuse is animal abuse whether we like it or not.
An animal doesn't need food and water only. The conditions of the environment should be as natural as it's supposed to be. A bird was meant to stretch its wings and fly in vast environments. Chickens don't fly so a chicken doesn't need as much space as a wild bird.
But in the end you do what you desire. We will all face the consequences of our actions.
Salam bro
@@dublinbus4138 Understand Islam through those who have studied deen their whole lives, speak Arabic and are credible Muftis.
Do not use your aqal and mantiq to come to conclusions, it's a dangerous road.
Wa Aleikum Assalam.
Mashalllah
Sheikh, every living creatures have their destiny, one should live as Allah swt created them, regarding hunted down is also destiny, but putting them in cages or aquarium is putting one in bondage, that's my believes.
Signs of kiyamat
What is it can you explain?
Assalamualaykum shiekh 1 of your videos you described the face of Allah with 2 hands can you tell me more about it? Is there true? Allah has face and 2 hands
The mentioned narration doesn’t argument that any bird or animal is permissible to kept as a pet. As that was not practised by Prophet صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم or by Companions رضوان اللّٰہ علیہ اجمعین.
Only those animals and birds are familiarly permissible to be kept who benefit human.
It has become a fun and source of show off by keeping expensive animals and birds of no use.
I still think its unfair to keep birds locked in cages. Allah knows best
@Jason Manson thats called nature...... if something happens to them in the wild thats natural, why did the bird have wings in the first place if it was meant to be kept in a cage?????
It was given this blessing to survive in the wild and the thing knows how to best use it.
He said it is not haram. For haram you need evidence from Quran & Hadith. However, from a moral point of view I would also agree. I'd not keep any animal confined to a small space.
@@maazmustafa2322 The evidence is that the hadith says show animals "kindness". I don't agree with this scholar's interpretation of the hadith he refers to and to be honest he spent the first 4 minutes attack the questioner's expression of feeling which I think was to some degree unprofessional and came across as more of a personal emotional reaction. Allah Knows best.
Sheikh, respectfully, I do not agree.
I believe your argument is wrong on this point.
The hadith quoted does not imply that the boy's bird was in cage. It only mentions 'pet bird'.
Now you will say that how can you keep a bird without a cage.
Pet birds can be without a cage as well. I have seen, and you can research yourself as well.
People have birds who are not in cages. It is the level of trust and bonding between thr animal and human that makes it possible.
If you keep a bird which is caged that would mean that you do not have a bond with the animal and it would fly away if you leave it open. Meaning it is not tamed and not your pet and is being kept against it's own will.
Do birds need big area by nature, to fly?
Yes.
Can birds be kept without cages?
Yes.
Which birds would die if you take them out of a cage?
None.
There is only a risk that the ones which you would have captured from another place/climate and all of a sudden you leave them out, then out of fear or out of confusion or because the environment is not suitable to them, etc, they could meet bad fate.
Whereas if we leave the birds where they naturally are, then they will remain safe.
So since there is no hadith or ayat indicating about keeping caged animals (afaik), i strongly believe that keeping animals in cages is cruelty and should not be done.
some people are just thirsty of philosophical knowledge thus were attracted to philosophical presentation. but philosophically one must also asked why was he here? what he is meant for? who controls the univ erse and who was the ultimate creator and designer?
philosophical questions will also lead one to a supreme being... unless ALLAH subhanahu wa taala refused to guide him....
Sheikh i have one doubt plz answer me
Que is that in my house there a cat come to my house always and we used to feed him but day by day he used to toilet in our bedroom so i decided to not let the cat enter in house
Is it sin in doing so?
s.a i don't agree with placing a bird in a cage where it can't use its wings to fly. sorry...but that's my opinion. I also don't agree with the Sheikh telling him not to say that it's sadistic. it's just his opinion and he is entitled to it. he's still asking the question to make sure or he'll stand corrected. anyways, may Allah guide us all.
❌ Puting/keeping a bird or any animal in a cage is one situation and eating animals an another situation. By putting independent animal it is destroying animal's freedom.
And does Allah tayala, or Prophet muhammad (ﷺ) said that grasses and trees has life, they can feel? By command/order of Allah tayala even an Rock starts moving(As we can see in some hadiths), so does it means we can say now rock has life? If grases and trees had life/were alive then we can't draw them right? But in islam we can draw them it is permissible. So this argument is not acceptable and I don’t know is there is any sahih hadis available that says we can put any animal in cages for the sake of our self desire. And shayekh said one hadis in that hadis I didn’t saw any word like cage I am providing that hadis in my comment section please check.
Sheikh, can you please discuss whether the dog being a pet is haram or permissible in different ways.
I have heard people removig the utres of the pet. What is ruling in auch case
Is it haram to breathe.
What birds can you keep?
I miss thos sound effects after sheikh speak facts.
The birds die very fast in the wild. Typically these birds aren't even native to their environment. Even if they are, they don't know where the food or water is, they don't understand how to take proper shelter, head to a warmer area when they're cold. They'll interact with other animals assuming they're friendly. They are blessed if they can survive a day
I used to have 15 to 16 birds and I only bought 5 but later they grew up to the rest and I had a cage as big as a large sofa ..but my mother always says that free them. birds curse their owner for keeping them in cage 😅 ...but now I know that they never did curse me atleast for keeping them in cage