Ship Theory's 3: What If Britannic Beached On The Island Of Kea in 1916
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- Just a small theory on what could have happened if Britannic beached on the island of Kea 100 years ago.
Link to website bluestarline201...
Link to Facebook / blue-star-line-1653089...
Link to official Facebook group / 1154079661276954
Link to official Discord / discord
Link to my Steam profile (If you wish to add me) steamcommunity....
We would love to hear from you people out there, here is our Email bluestarline2015@gmail.com
Would you like to join the blue star line community?
If so then please Email us at bluestarline2015@gmail.com
Don't forget to like, comment and subscribe!
The Britannic flooded very quickly due to the open portholes on her starboard side (like the Empress of Ireland) but if all the portholes were closed, water wouldn't pour into the ship that much and she could've been afloat long enough for her to reach Kea.
Then Olympic wouldn't have been alone post-war.
Ikr!
@Rylan DeWitt no, if britannic watertight doors were not jammed the ship will not sinked
@@giovax1717 The Portholes is the one that's pressuring britannic! Britannic already had 6 compartments flooded (6 she can withstand; still be afloat) but the portholes were open making it flood to B Deck and make the ship sink.
Also the nurses opened the portholes a day before the explosion happened for fresh air to their patients.
She was not alone they were given 2 ships homeric (forgot og name) and bismark now called majestic
No when the brititanic hit the mine it knocked out the stairing. Controls
The captian had to try to beach her saving the people onboard by taking the risk to higher rates of flooding He was a hero
leonard vilander what if the damage was similar to TITANIC but, without the double skin addad to the Britannic.
Juan Longoria
Well then she would have been driving to her own death
I did honestly not think anyone would see this
If he order to turn off the. Pollors. In the sinking. No boy. Can die.
True
I love how the people of the island see the britanic sinking and come out to help
That really happened, thanks to help of the island inhabitants, more people were saved.
Zach baird Gaming agreed
More like come out to watch
Zach Baird would have realy happened if they keeper the doors closed
@John Arat No he won't
He died on Titanic
I don't know why i'm laughing but, at 4:15.
That tree is much taller than that Steam boat/ship.
Edit: and great video tho! :3
Hi michael UwU
@@Hi_UA-cam222 hello
@RMS Empress Seahawkic Seahawks Star772 wdym
It’s sad when you think she never got to be a ocean liner in her life :(
I know, she was an improvement over her own sisters. Imaging that Organ now, I feel like you may have been able to hear it from ashore! It would’ve been incredible for her to sail. She’s my favourite and it’s a shame White Star lost two wonderful ships, while Cunard still had at least Mauretania and Aquitania(despite Lusitania’s loss.)
@@oscillation9814 Aquitania was probably brought too early to be involved in the war if I were Aquitania I would be pressured of being in service for a few months before entering war service
Oscillation Also The Nomadic Is Still Therr
@@stefaniellanos9348, the Nomadic was a tender, small ship, not a Transatlantic liner.
she did once
I personally think Britannic (along with Aquitania) would survive just long enough to be used in WW2 and if she survived that, at that point most of white stars ships were gone, but I'm sure at this point someone would buy her, then she would be shuffelled between owners for around 30-40 years before being bought by either a charity to restore her or the British government helping out with the funding, then she finds a perminent home in Southampton or Cherbourg were she sits Today as either a Museum or Hotel
I agree.. or Britannic might end up like the SS United States... that would be sad.
@@northrepublicline1881 also a high but sad possibity
Or return home to belfast with nomadic
I totally agree with you about the fact that she would’ve made it to World War II
you know damn well it would be scrapped after the 1940's
Somewhere in an alternate universe:
What if britannic didnt make it to kea
Hi titanic's sister
well she sank but your scrapped mrs olympic XDDDDDDDDDDD
@@m.o.g.o.r.a.f.6.6.67 karma
@@Boypogikami132 bruh
that was what happend but this is saying what if she did beach
The Britannic looks so beautiful painted as a passenger liner
Agreed... it just goes to show that no matter what happens, or how, or even when... The Olympic class will always be... The most beautiful class ever known to exist... None can rival that...
Amazing work truly spectacular. This was well thought out and executed perfectly many thanks
I can’t imagine being a resident and then seeing the biggest ship in the world (at that time) come and beach it’s self.
The residents and the fishermen might be confused
Amazing how elegant she still looked in her hospital ship livery and those huge lifeboat davits.
and yes, they do look fairly good if i'm honest.
This video made me teary eyed. Not just because she survives the sinking but because this would put an amazing reputation for the Olympic class and maybe we would still have them today.
Beautiful! Love this! In a perfect world she and her sister ship, Titanic, wouldn't have met their doom and be on duty many years after their maiden voyage
Britannic (Wreck): Who are you?
Britannic (AU): I'm you. But, from an alternate timeline.
Britannic (AU): Where Healthcare is free, gun violence is a lot less, and there paid family support in America in the Alternate Universe I’m from.
Scott the Boeing 747-9 prototype: Also, in that same universe, Boeing is still making 747 and 757 and has stopped 737 production in 2016. Boeing in the universe we come from is still strong. Your Boeing is becoming sh*t.
@zacharykim436 Aurora the 787-10ER prototype: I hate raven so much!! Her father caused this britannic to sink. I always knew it wasn't a mine or torpedo! Our universe isn't under his influence. Scott, Britannic and I tried my best to stop the mark of Skath from infecting our universe.
It would have been unlikely for Britannic getting scrapped in 1935, since her career was passenger liner began 1919 and war interrupted her career. She would have been serving World War 2 then scrapped or bought in 1950.
That is what happened to Aquitania, but it would somewhat come out differently for Britannic if she didn't sink.
This is only my opinion, I just think 1935 is way too early for a ship who started passenger service in 1919.
it's true a ship career is 25 years so i think she was gonna be scrapped in 1939 but ww2 started so she and aquitania would serve as warships in ww2 and probably scrapped in 1950
Strangely morbidly ironic how her sinking kept her still with us when she would have been scrapped at a later date.
If memory serves, the captain of Brittanic did try to beach her in an effort to save the ship, but all the portholes were opened by the nurses. That started a pattern of flooding that made it impossible to beach her, let alone save her. Had he been able to, Brittanic would have needed extensive repairs because the mine bent her keel and did a lot of other structural damage as well in addition to the huge hole it blasted through her shell plating. I suspect she would have been repaired and quite possibly served out at least a twenty year lifespan, like Olympic. Were it not for war and a collision with an iceberg. Olympic and her sisters Titanic and Britannic would have been the "Old Reliables" of the North Atlantic, providing regular passenger service between America and Europe.
Germany would be in trouble because Captain Bartlett believed Britannic was hit by a torpedo but it was a mine.
Germany: Dude, chill, we didn't torpedo you, you just hit a sea mine...
Bartlett: You expect me to believe that, after what you did to the LUSITANIA?!
Germany: *hides behind a cluster of U-boats" Stay away from me man!
Bartlett's mind: wimps...
@@aninkytheorist1133
Britannic (Ghost): Tell me about it.
Titanic (Ghost): Is this what I missed?
lol Germany already got America on their asses after they murdered Lusistania
@@FriskDreemurrOfBiggCityPort
Olympic: Tf just happened Here
@@chrisdeeyt4392Germany: yall just gonna stand there and look like idiots or is someone going to get this crazy captain away from us?
Yes you made my request next maybe um what if rms aquitania not been scrapped
I can only imagine a massive rebuild would have been necessary. She was already literally falling apart.
and rms olympic too :D
And Olympic
If Aquitania didn’t get scrapped she would sink or capsize.
shuichiboy reparations were possible but far too expensive
1:44 the meme effects kinda killed it
5:12 i thought it was the island of lemons xD
lol
*W E O N L Y S E L L L E M O N A D E*
Request what if the all the worlds greatest ships in the past didn’t sink
I like your videos Blue Star line
If RMS Olympic didnt get scrapped
It would be turned in to a hotel or a titanic look a like
Britannic mustn’t drop the lifeboats so they can keep going
I don’t think she would’ve been scrapped in 1935, I think she would’ve been scrapped in 1950 alongside Aquitania. Both of them were built in 1914 and were both massive upgrades to their two sisters. It’s not too far of a stretch to believe Britannic would’ve been profitable like Aquitania
They would’ve been scrapped in 1940 if WWII did not happen
that would be true, after all, she was the 3rd addition to the Olympic class and the Olympic has already proven to be a very profitable ship after ww1
RMS Aquitania Was Actually Launched In 1913 Not 1914 🤓
Aquitania's scrapping was thanks in part to her hull degradation i think .
If Britannic's hull and engines had the integrity to keep going post ww 2 and if she could turn a profit she could live longer if she could even make it to the 60s a night to remember could help keep her afloat.
I will request to you. What if olympic had a long career within 50 years and turn into museum ship
Someone said that Ship average lives are 20 or 25, and Olympic would probably sink before completing 40 years
@@AncientCultist or maybe her engines would give out
@@northrepublicline1881 ok
@@northrepublicline1881 well here's the thing... she was mechanically sound when she was scrapped in 1935, meaning that she would theoretically be perfectly seaworthy for several more years, and if they hadn't scrapped her and kept making slight improvements every now and then, she could theoretically last for 50-55 years if her luck held for that long, or at least that's how i see it...
@@aninkytheorist1133 I wonder how that would play out for Britannic. Say she makes it to the 50s and has a sound hull and machinery. What could happen to her return to passenger service, pleasure cursing gets to be a set for a night to remember
If rhe Britannic had beached, there's only one thing left to happen to a majestic ship such as her. The only sad truth of every British Ship... Ending up being sold for scrap.
This is nit rust xD
If only this would’ve really happened, no one would’ve died and there would at least be a slim chance that one of the Olympians might still be existence. Good job. I’ve been watching your videos for a while now and I really like your work, keep it up!
Poor britannic she woudnt be scrapped maybe she turn into hotel because she is last liner
vegeta rise of saiyan no she isnt, the SS Nomadic is the last White Star Liner,
Mico Carlo Adrian Ruiz i know maybe olympic class 3 sister still exits like queen mary olympic titanic britannic would be museum like nomadic
Like the queen mary
SHE NO, IS HE, BRITANNIC AND THE OLYMPIC CLASS IS NOT FEMALE
vegeta rise of saiyan last liner is goergic and last existing liner is ss nomandic
Love your vids keep up the good work
Can't image if this happen...Love this vid💓 nice one
Britannic struck a mine at 9:12am
And when it struck the mine the storm is not even there
Britannic struck the mine when it was daytime
4:21 No, some people died because when the bomb hit, they fell headfirst. Therefore, it did not save every person. Oh wait. It was a hospital ship, so that means more people likely died from the explosion, and some people just died because of injuries on the land.
As far as i can tell, most of the deaths were the result of the spinning propellers acting as giant blenders against the drifting lifeboats that had been launched without Bartlett's permission, the props basically sucked in any nearby lifeboats and the ripped them to splinters, killing many of the people onboard those unfortunate lifeboats. not everybody on those doomed lifeboats died however, this was certainly the case of Violet Jessop, who had also been onboard Olympic when she collided with HMS Hawke in 1911 she was also on Titanic when the ship sank in 1912, and was then even on Britannic when she struck the mine in 1916.
It would be nice to see Britannic as an ocean liner.I subsribed to you and Shipster.So don't have your fans start a war on who's better.
When Brittanic was returned back into a passenger liner she looked like Titanic and Olympic
Dylanplayz678 Ynaplayz678 yeah..
She would have had the same paint scheme in 1919 yes.
Round-Earth Believer after all they are sister ship's.
YES IM FINALLY GETTING SOME TIME IN THE SPOTLIGHT OTHER MY SISTERS TITANIC AND OLYMPIC!
SUPER SUPER late comment but, she would probably be scrapped just a little bit after olympic considering she was launched about 4 years after her
How the hell were you able to get the ship to be partially sunk and still move? Awesome video by the way. Damn shame she wasn’t able to see her days as a passenger liner, id imagine she would have been beautiful.
Sadly she was originally was going to be a passenger ship before when WW1 started, she was repainted to the hospital colors when she sank
Fun fact: White star line was originally going to name the Britannic to Gigantic but it was changed to Britannic
Noelle L actually the name change thing is just a rumor.
@@xavierlauzac5922 that is true, it is infact, just a rumour...
What if the ship was named Puritanic?? It sounds more Church friendly.
I honestly wonder how big the impact to shore would have been.
One question, what was different in your scenario that the Britannic was able to safely reach Kea? Faster decision making by the Captain?
I’d imagine the portholes not left open, that probably prevented any chance of Britannic’s survival in reality.
@@oscillation9814 Ok, yeah I just wished the guy would say it.
@@Urlocallordandsavior to be perfectly honest with you, closing the portholes would save the ship, but make her rather stuffy inside, after all, she was designed to be a transatlantic ocean liner rather than a hospital ship in the middle of a significantly hotter region
Now she is a home for many fish and Those 32 people who died
brandon the wolf just 30.
She would've made it to Kea saving all on board but one. Because a coal worker was killed by the mine explosion.
I bet the person who was steering the ship said before the impact said:It's a MMMIIINNNEEE!!!!!
5:04 Astern
Oh my good old ship. I miss her to this day. I cant believe she hit a water mine. It was the worst day of my life.
Do more like this, and btw how to sink ship but not too fast?
You based a logo off BnL from WALL-E??!?!?!?!? HOLY OOF!!!
It goes like this OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOF
Very sad to see the last ship get hit by a mine, sister to Titanic and Olympic, 2 sisters lost: Titanic April 15th, 1912 and Britannic 21st November 1916. :(
I would have been wonderful if she would have made it and be fixed and seaworthy again. And hope she would see a life of passenger service until her retirement. Hopefully turned into a museum instead of being scrapped like her sister Olympic.
If only she was an ocean liner it’s sad she died at an early age and never carried the ‘high society’
This probably would have happened if the portholes were all shut, she probably would've lasted longer
true... she was after all, built for use in the freezing north atlantic rather than in warmer areas like where she now rests on the sea floor just miles from the island of kea...
I like the 1912 look to this ship
Because she was constructed two years later.
Christopher R. Really that is so cool
Indeed she was.
if olympic didnt hit the nantucket or didnt got scraped
Awww. I wish thats what happened irl.
nununununuunununnuunuunu they wouldnt need to scrap t its the most cool looking ship i ever seen ill scrap them if they scrap it
What if the Olympic wasn't scrapped in 1937?
L T HORNING yeah she will join titanic in ship theory 1 and britannic ship theory 3 in museum or hotel or something?
She was too old and was costing a lot of money on upkeep. Ships average lives are 20 - 25 years. I am an ex seaman.
Welp you are wrong im a ship expert and she was scrapped in 1935 along with cunards Mauretania.
L T HORNING museum ship is most likely
@@jameslatrobeyup, it was 1935, I can confirm that
How do you get the ship to sit like that In the water so it looks like its sinking
Giovanni De La'O sailing at full speed ahead, at a certain distance have her full stop wile she is drifting and then crash land in top of the island.
Do: if Olympic stayed for 65 years in service (it might beaten the Cunard rivals)
Someone said that ship average lives are 20-25 years, and Olympic would probably sink before even completing 30 years.
@@AncientCultist whoa! jeez dude, this is the Olympic we're talking about, she was literally given the nickname 'The Old Reliable' for a very good reason... and although she lost both her sisters pretty early on, she still would stand a pretty good chance of a long service life. after all she was mechanically sound when she was scrapped in 1935, if you keep updating her whenever she's heavily out of date, she might last a lot longer than a 30 year life span, maybe reaching at best, up to 50-55 if you're really determined to keep her in service, but it would theoretically cost a lot to do so, she was brought into service in 1911 after all...
What if Olympic wasn't scrapped? Maybe make a video?
Remember it was stormy when she left Naples there was only a small break in the storm and let’s say she did get beached she couldn’t have been towed without any fixing because she would’ve most definitely sunk
what if titanics stern was still floating
It would have sank in one single piece
Who would’ve rather had this happen instead of Britannic sinking
im from that island so that would be amazing
I actually think this scenario could have happened if the watertight doors had shut properly.
that could be a possibility, but then again, her keel was bent when the explosion occured which prevented her watertight doors from closing at all, and if all the portholes were left open, she might've sunk anyway due to the portholes letting in water...
What if Normondie did not burn down and capsized
She will be turned into a warship (possibly aircraft carrier) called USS Lafayette.
mrMC well ya but what will happen to her if she survived ww2
Hmm, i think she will be scrapped like any other warships except USS Missouri. Or if not, then she will be bought by Cunard and transformed again into a modern ocean liner since her design and technology were advanced enough to do that. If so, then she will be the second largest and the oldest Cunard liner still alive today.
TurboGoji 101 Turned into a troopship or aircraft carrier (USS Lafayette), serving as a troopship on the European front or being sent to the pacific as an aircraft carrier or serve as an auxiliary carrier in the Atlantic alongside the USS Ranger and torpedoed or surviving the war and most likely being scrapped.
or queen elizabeth?
bruh why 1915-1935 she could have an longer life than her older sisters
It wasn't sunrise when Britannic hit the mine
Well If It Kept Going And Beached And If The Lifeboats Were Being Launched During That Time…
Well More People Would Have Lost They’re Lives Probably
They’re not launched.
I think brittannic might reach kea island if the portholes are not opened and the crew listened to there captain
Yeah, it's like Kup telling Hot Rod to stay away from the Optimus Prime vs Megatron fight in the g1 movie. Because both the Nurse crew and Hot Rod didn't listen to the captain and Kup respectively, they got britannic and Optimus killed.
I would cry 😭
Residants:helps. The britannic to docks*
If you people don't know,The Olympic class looked different.Titanic's gold stripes were ABOVE the black paint.Olympic and maybe Britannic would have traditional White Star colors which would have been a gold stipe at the top portion of the black paint.
Actually before the First World War Olympic's gold stripe was above the black part of her hull just like the Titanic's but after the First World War when the Olympic re-entered service as an ocean liner her gold stripe was lowered to a position similar to the ones seen on earlier White Star Liners such as the RMS Celtic (1901).
One small towing boat Vs that big ship
Britannic: comon comon yes i survive phew
RIP the Olympic class may the spirits that haunt them be at peace
i know i might sound crazy when i say this but... that's possibly the most morbid and sweetest thing in the comments section so far...
Typo in 4:33 but good job on this
I think white (blue) stare lines makes the sexiest ships ever 😍😍😍😍😍😍❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ummmmmmmmm ok?
I’m pretty sure Britannic hit the mine in the morning when it was light not dark
Have you seen the 2000 “Britannic”?
@@Boypogikami132 yes, it’s inaccurate as hell
@@ItsSamHussey so truee
@@ItsSamHussey Exactly. They thought it was a torpedo and they thought it capsized very fast mid-way sinking. Bad example
@@thegamingexpert156 and we all know that she only capsized when her bow impacted the sea floor, just goes to show that sometimes, even films are terrible at showing what really happened...
theory 4 please what if normandie didn't caught on fire
*catch
0:31 who saw mount vesuvius in the distance
I don’t think it only takes 4 days to repair a mine explosion, still very good vid!
It would have been just a quick patch up. The real repair would be done after the voyage
@@Blue-Star-Line that's what i was thinking...
So close britanic so close
Can you make a two vids what if olympic have not be scraped what if quintia have not be scraped
Wouldn’t the ship be listing? Since she hit he mine?
How would she be towed, she would have hull damage from the mine and hitting the island
Did she not sink entirely in the day time..?
My Custom Theory. My Video. My Rules
+Blue Star Line
Empress of Ireland
Theory 4?
She sank in the early morning
I think it might have lived longer than olympic since she was 4 years younger. meaning she would probably be used in WW2
that's what happened with Aquatania, so yeah, this is a possiblity...
There could be a possibility of, if the Britannic never sank, because she had the same age as the Aquitania, she would'nt be scrapped in 1935, and be put to be scrapped in 1940, serving 4 years more alongside the Aquitania in the new Cunard White Star Line, then, in 1939, in the begining of WWII, Britannic would be requised for being a hospital ship once more (like the Aquitania) and being saved from scrap due to the war. In a nutshell, she would have the same history as the Aquitania, and they two would be the only two ocean liners in serving in both world wars.
If Titanic and Britannic collided with each other
Mr Oof TITANIC vs her younger sister BRITANNIC, BRITANNIC survive and TITANIC didn't.
What if they both died at the same time?
What if the Carpathia never saved Titanic's Survivors? (I don't know if someone already asked this.)
or the ships that receive the titanic distress calls and all ships came and helped the passengers..it would be crazy...
@@3rdtk976 That would increase the survivor count (despite Carpathia not assisting).
I wish blue star line will make a brittannic 2 but in ocean liner form like the titanic 2 they will about to make but it’s canceled
Well if only it worked out this way in real life.
why did britannic sink 55 minutes unlike its sister ship titanic sank 2 hours?
well i don't know if he can aswer that
Gerald Putong well I think it's because the mine caused enough damage to bend the ships haul a bit making it impossible to close the watertight doors which were opened for a crew change of coal stoakers, also it was a hot day so many windows and potholes remained opened so it could have contributed, and captain Barlett accelerating the flooding by trying to beach the ship, which I wouldn't see as a mistake since in that time you can't really see what's going on to your ship like in this videos so he made this before realising the ship is sinking way to fast
That's because the engineers and firemen on the Titanic tried to slow down the sinking of their ship.
Titanic had a two degrees list to port (left) most likely because there was a coal fire onboard before she set sail and the smouldering coal was moved away from the starboard side to the port. Some experts say that this caused Titanic to stay afloat longer, otherwise she could've capsized too.
If I am correct, it happened for three main reasons.
1. The mine did something so that the watertight doors couldn't be shut, especially in the bow area.
2. The sped up to beach on Kea but that made water rush in faster
3. The portholes on decks, mostly E deck, were left open by nurses and water rushed in even further.
I have a next ship story requests like the last battle of the bismark,
Maybe if she struck the mine, but the portholes and watertight doors were closed before she struck it, she would have survived and white star line would not have been in a forced merger with cunard
i wish so and titanic avoid iceberg it will be so good dream:(
Britannic goes astern lol XD
Uhhhh brittanic you forgot the people we put in life boats
The driver; HEEEEELLLLLPPP
i wached the moe and it did not make it to the Island and why will it be a the bottom of the sea today.