Designer ranks every London borough's logo from best to worst.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • It's a logo battle royale! In this video, As a graphic designer specialising in lettering and branding, I methodically rate and roast all 32 #London borough councils (plus the City of London's) logo designs.
    It's a challenging job for anyone to take one - and this isn't a reflection on the people or the municipal governments of these councils. Hopefully we learn something along the way!
    #Boroughs #Logos
    Inspired by the thumbnail of Jay Foreman's Unfinished London episode ten - • What's wrong with Lond...
    For more info on the City of London, try CGP Grey's videos:
    • The Secret City inside...
    London's 32 boroughs are:
    Barking and Dagenham
    Barnet
    Bexley
    Brent
    Bromley
    Camden
    Croydon
    Ealing
    Enfield
    Greenwich
    Hackney
    Hammersmith and Fulham
    Haringey
    Harrow
    Havering
    Hillingdon
    Hounslow
    Islington
    Kensington and Chelsea
    Kingston upon Thames
    Lambeth
    Lewisham
    Merton
    Newham
    Redbridge
    Richmond upon Thames
    Southwark
    Sutton
    Tower Hamlets
    Waltham Forest
    Wandsworth
    Westminster
    🛒My UA-cam Gear kit.co/timesne...
    🛒Amazing AI Upscaling topazlabs.com/...
    Music from Streambeats and Epidemic Sound
    www.epidemicso...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 576

  • @harrytodhunter5078
    @harrytodhunter5078 2 роки тому +216

    The phrase “aged like milk but potential for a fine cheese” is phenomenal and I am absolutely stealing it.

  • @pk3ndl3r
    @pk3ndl3r 4 роки тому +920

    Linus, I really loved this video! I co-make the Unfinished London videos with Jay, so came to this as you linked so nicely to our video, but really well executed, very interesting and I really like your presenting-style!

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому +177

      Hi Paul, thank you kindly - I've been a long time fan of the Unfinished London series - it means a lot to me that you and Jay both enjoyed the video! I'm very grateful for Jay sharing it with your audience on twitter too, since your viewers are exactly the kind of curious, thoughtful people I hope to reach on my fledgling channel. Couldn't be happier!

    • @hahasimp
      @hahasimp 3 роки тому +24

      @@LinusBoman And the world hopes for Linus Jay Foreman collab

    • @fastbowler
      @fastbowler 3 роки тому +9

      @@hahasimp Wishing this collab into existence…

    • @Gmackematix
      @Gmackematix 2 роки тому +1

      @@LinusBoman I'm glad you have lots of design expertise to keep you in work when the Michael McIntyre lookalike work dries up! 😉

  • @prangbod
    @prangbod 3 роки тому +137

    "A name being spelled entirely in red tape. Not a great association for a government body" haha

  • @sallynorton7262
    @sallynorton7262 4 роки тому +720

    The London Borough Logos song:
    River, river, river, leaf (H&F, Richmond, Tower Hamlets, Redbridge)
    Text with website underneath (Croydon)
    Fox's head with eagle's palms (Enfield)
    Lots of boring coats of arms (Hillingdon, Hounslow, Havering, Bexley)
    Flower, tree, tree, tree (Greenwich, Ealing, Sutton, Waltham Forest)
    Stolen from the BBC (Barnet)
    Very 90's, round and bold (B&D, Hackney)
    Painted by a 5 year old (Haringey)
    Flappy triangles appeal (Lambeth)
    Happy crown and water wheel (Lewisham, Merton)
    Circle skyline, painty, lame (Wandsworth, Bromley, Harrow)
    Looks like someone signed their name (Southwark)
    Swirly B and swishy N (Brent, Newham)
    Boring coats of arms again (Kingston, K&C, Westminster, Islington)
    Eight blobs no one understands (Camden)
    That completes the... oh, it's hands!

    • @c_lyson03
      @c_lyson03 3 роки тому +28

      jay foreman fan i see

    • @jorgepeterbarton
      @jorgepeterbarton 3 роки тому +15

      Hackney - as found on shipping containers
      Lambeth - need a solicitor?
      Islington - welcome to the open day of this public school

    • @BaldMancTwat
      @BaldMancTwat 3 роки тому +8

      @@c_lyson03 I read the comment in Jay Foreman's voice.

    • @raghavgupta2399
      @raghavgupta2399 2 роки тому +3

      @@jorgepeterbarton Barking and Dagenham- providing cable tv service
      Merton- a happy family farm
      Haringey- wanna be a part of our gang eh?

    • @mutelarsorhougbe4606
      @mutelarsorhougbe4606 Рік тому

      😂😂👏🏽too good

  • @MedlifeCrisis
    @MedlifeCrisis 3 роки тому +592

    Man some of these are truly atrocious. I live in Newham! And you’re right, the logo hasn’t changed how I think about the council. I already thought it was shite.

    • @aben8955
      @aben8955 3 роки тому +9

      I live in Newham too and though I honestly haven't ever given the logo a second thought, I definitely do not think it was the worst one 😂

    • @bobbajosmith9851
      @bobbajosmith9851 3 роки тому +2

      The whole area is :/

    • @hmgkt
      @hmgkt 3 роки тому +1

      Nothing changes in N’aam

    • @ruan13o
      @ruan13o 3 роки тому +6

      Funny you should comment. I always thought Newham's logo should belong to some kind of local medical organisation.

    • @bigfan2710
      @bigfan2710 Рік тому +1

      I think the swoosh is maybe the Thames? But yeah logo pretty much says nothing.

  • @DocShadow660
    @DocShadow660 3 роки тому +126

    As a former Newham resident, I went into this video eagerly anticipating that wet fart of a logo getting the teardown it deserves. I was *not* disappointed.
    At first I thought the current one was a marginal improvement on the previous logo with the thicker swoosh, with the weird pointed ends and the horrible Windows 95-looking fade effect, but, like you said about Harrow, at least that one made me feel something. Even if it was distaste.

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  3 роки тому +28

      Haha, wet fart is an evocative description, though I feel that falsely conveys a logo which *does* leave a lingering impression. 😂 Glad you enjoyed the video Doc!

  • @lunahlulah6772
    @lunahlulah6772 3 роки тому +106

    use of a distinctive colour is also important I think, as it’s used on street signs. Lewisham is known locally as ‘the blue borough’, and you can tell you’re not it in anymore when the street signs turn green in Bromley.

  • @pennybazaar
    @pennybazaar 3 роки тому +95

    I feel like Richmond were making a poor attempt at showing that they're the only borough both sides of the river

  • @oivinf
    @oivinf 3 роки тому +90

    21:30 I'm pretty sure the R is the river Thames and the green elements are meant to symbolise that the borough extends on both sides of the river.
    Also you didn't mention (but probably knew) :
    11:50 Tower Hamlets is the Thames with the White Tower in the back (doesn't even look like it though)
    21:53 The skyline is horrible, but it IS iconic. That's Battersea Power Station made famous by Pink Floyd's "Animals"

    • @AlexanderTrefz
      @AlexanderTrefz Рік тому +9

      Let me tell you sir, to a first approximation, nobody recognises that skyline. Nobody, is looking at Cover Art, ever.

    • @sas.tronaut5055
      @sas.tronaut5055 Рік тому +3

      iconic isn’t the word i would use. there’s nothing about the silhouette that makes the skyline stand out or recognizable

    • @Angs2000
      @Angs2000 11 місяців тому +7

      Even though I'm from Finland and haven't been to England ever, that logo made me think "is that the Battersea Power Station?".

    • @tourmaline07
      @tourmaline07 7 місяців тому +1

      Recognised the Battersea Station in the skyline , of the Wandsworth logo - they should emphasize it more

  • @andy.robinson
    @andy.robinson 3 роки тому +23

    "Winged cow looking at a baguette growing a mohawk" - you have my subscription! 😆

  • @mirieth
    @mirieth 3 роки тому +27

    Really great video.
    I previously worked at Newham (as a designer) and always hated the logo for similar reasons - it's so insipid. Much to my horror I found out while working there it was indeed commissioned and made by an outside design agency (despite having an in-house design team). I don't necessarily mind that it was outsourced, I think it makes sense to have an exterior perspective, but for it to be so bad and that the design team had zero consultation on it is a really damning indictment of the way that place is run. When I was leaving they were looking at a rebrand, and they had earmarked an agency to do it. It wasn't a design agency though, it was a PR agency. So nothing better will come of that I'm sure.
    In a slightly less bitchy and more interesting piece of info, I now work at Tower Hamlets and we updated our logo not long after this video came out to get rid of those wonky lines and jagged edges. It looks markedly better, but we often comment that we doubt anyone but other designers would see the difference.

  • @ebiUsher
    @ebiUsher 3 роки тому +160

    "this tree seems to be sprouting men's sandals" MSFJSKFJDJFJSBD OH NO 😭

  • @Visroker
    @Visroker 2 роки тому +24

    10:00 I find that the logo of Hackney looks like the logo of a steel company. Mainly because logos of such companies here in the Netherlands had similar logos and often used the first letter to create a symmetrical, simple brand logo.
    After all, the logo of Hackney is really well executed!

  • @secretlyaskrull
    @secretlyaskrull 2 роки тому +11

    cool heraldry tidbit! the animal in the Enfield logo is, in fact, an enfield: a heraldic creature with the head of a fox, forelegs of an eagle, torso of a greyhound and a lion, and back legs of a wolf. This makes it a heraldic pun, which is called a cant. The arms of the Borough of Enfield have an enfield, and an enfield is one of the supporters when it's displayed as an achievement of arms.

  • @myamomifrancis
    @myamomifrancis 3 роки тому +8

    I've lived in Newham my whole life. That logo is the perfect description of what it feels like to live here 🤣🤣🤣 Great Video!

  • @ootommo1
    @ootommo1 3 роки тому +18

    The R in the Richmond upon Thames logo represents roughly the path the River Thames takes though its borough.
    TIMESTAMPS:
    Barking and Dagenham 22:25
    Barnet 17:09
    Bexley 15:57
    Brent 12:02
    Bromley 18:15
    Camden 12:29
    Croydon 18:00
    Ealing 19:42
    Enfield 20:31
    Greenwich 13:47
    Hackney 9:57
    Hammersmith and Fulham 13:27
    Haringey 14:24
    Harrow 23:09
    Havering 16:38
    Hillingdon 18:03
    Hounslow 11:25
    Islington 9:28
    Kensington and Chelsea 16:14
    Kingston upon Thames 14:48
    Lambeth 8:12
    Lewisham 14:11
    Merton 20:05
    Newham 24:32
    Redbridge 15:42
    Richmond upon Thames 21:02
    Southwark 17:25
    Sutton 19:50
    Tower Hamlets 11:41
    Waltham Forest 18:30
    Wandsworth 21:45
    Westminster 13:08

  • @arunashamal
    @arunashamal 3 роки тому +31

    The redbridge logo with the image of a leaf brought major nostalgia, early 2000s those photo logos were everywhere.. Also the harrow logo takes me right back to that time. It looks like something from a Trance music video or vengaboys video.

  • @amandacapsicum686
    @amandacapsicum686 3 роки тому +117

    Greenwich missed a trick in not making their "swoosh" match the curve of the River Thames adjacent to the borough like Hammersmith and Fulham did

    • @PianoKwanMan
      @PianoKwanMan 3 роки тому +5

      They could hark back to Prime Meridian

    • @mrcraggle
      @mrcraggle 3 роки тому +19

      As a resident of Greenwich, the logo doesn't really say much about the borough at all. Why not play up the nautical angle or that Greenwich is the centre of the world? Heck, the Shepherd Gate clock would be a great source of inspiration to take from and give the logo more ownership. Greenwich's coat of arms is a much better representation and incorporates much of what I said above that plays into Greenwich's associated history with the military, royalty and astronomical studies.

    • @InstrumentalsBeats
      @InstrumentalsBeats 3 роки тому

      The swoosh is supposed to represent the curve of the river at Greenwich. It's a modernised version of the old logo (which had lines to represent the river)

    • @kbtred51
      @kbtred51 Рік тому

      @@InstrumentalsBeats Is he Australian? Does not seem to recognise the riverside councils due to distaste of similar swoosh style.

  • @young_scouter
    @young_scouter 4 роки тому +179

    I find university logos fascinating because their text element is pretty uniform but they have different approaches to representing what they stand for.
    Around the rise in fees in 2012 many changed their logos to focus on seeming more prestigious. For example Winchester went from a strong local symbol to a crest that says prestige but is weaker in my opinion.

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому +55

      Oh, that would be very interesting to compare! Thanks for the suggestion 👍

    • @MrAcuriteOf1337
      @MrAcuriteOf1337 2 роки тому +4

      Not from Europe, but the University of Illinois swapped over from the "Column I," which evoked the school's status as very strong Engineering and Architecture school, as were its roots and founding intentions, to the "Block I," just to be in-line with other big 10 schools.

  • @flierfy
    @flierfy 3 роки тому +34

    Westminster has a very distinctive version of a W cast into pretty much every lamppost of its territory. I wonder why they don't make this W their logo.

  • @josebabilbao7759
    @josebabilbao7759 4 роки тому +217

    You could do something similar with either the flags of the world, the flags of europe or the counties of england. Also maybe sports teams logos like the premier league teams

    • @BvousBrainSystems
      @BvousBrainSystems 4 роки тому +4

      I tried to think of a terrible place in the UK and my mind immediately went to Scunthorpe. Now I didn't find the Scunthorpe city logo but I did find the Scunthorpe F.C. logo, and... that man is holding the iron bar sideways.
      I have zero taste in logos and watched this whole video thinking I'd have been hard pressed to find anything to say about them, but regardless this is turning out to be a fun activity.

    • @nottmjas
      @nottmjas 3 роки тому +5

      @@BvousBrainSystems Scunthorpe is in North Lincolnshire and its council logo can very seen at the following
      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Lincolnshire_Council
      It reminds me of logos for video production companies in the 90s
      8

    • @BvousBrainSystems
      @BvousBrainSystems 3 роки тому +2

      @@nottmjas Can definitely see it on a VHS tape

    • @_yellow
      @_yellow 3 роки тому +1

      US States?

    • @MrNoosphere
      @MrNoosphere 3 роки тому +1

      I recently learnt the design and study of flags is called Vexillography!

  • @TryinaD
    @TryinaD 3 роки тому +23

    Loved this video! I feel like the Westminster crest is actually pretty charming, if only because it reminds me of an imperfect woodblock print. Feels like I’m in a medieval printing workshop.

    • @royvandermarel3953
      @royvandermarel3953 3 роки тому +5

      If it was a woodblock print (or castiron mold e.g.) it would've been great. Yet it is the original logo, not a handcrafted adaptation. So I get why it was rated lower than it should

  • @RobinKoenig1917
    @RobinKoenig1917 4 роки тому +43

    Jay Forman sent me. Great video, really enjoyed it, will definitely subscribe. :)

    • @RobinKoenig1917
      @RobinKoenig1917 4 роки тому +3

      Also, I googled that Eric Gill guy... Jesus Christ, you weren't kidding.

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому +2

      Haha, yes it's a shame that so many great artists were some of history's great monsters. Yeesh. :[

    • @nottmjas
      @nottmjas 3 роки тому

      @@LinusBoman If I had a choice and a time machine, I would rather spend an evening with Caravaggio, who would make Olly Reed look like a schoolboy in comparison, then even five minutes in the company of a totally uninhibited Eric Gill in his studio. What he would have inferred and sketches and other images I would have seen would have soiled my soul for life.
      As a local government lifer who has worked for a number of, and dealt with even more county, borough and district councils over the past three decades, I am sad enough to be able to recognise most council logos even if the names are removed. I've noticed a trend in their rebranding over the last ten years or so from using bland genertic instantly forgettable motifs to strong memorable visuals with local characteristics, two good examples being Staffordshire CC using the Stafford knot and Leicestershire CC using a fox standing on a capital L. Both I think will stand the test of time. However Lincolnshire CC's and Coventry City Council's latest attempts at utilising the Lincoln imp and Lady Godiva respectively seem lame in comparison but at least the intention was there, unlike many of the logos you constructively criticised here.

  • @ze_rubenator
    @ze_rubenator 3 роки тому +15

    22:00 I kind of disagree. The Battersea Power Station as seen in that skyline is notorious, it features in so many films and photographs. For example it's the subject of the album art on Pink Floyd's Animals.

    • @youmukonpaku3168
      @youmukonpaku3168 Рік тому +3

      had the same response to this, "I'm sorry, did you just tell me that a coal fired power station I can recognize at a glance despite having never been to the UK at all isn't iconic?"

  • @CaeserOct
    @CaeserOct Рік тому +4

    19:02 Waltham Forest reminds me a lot of the city emblems / flags / logos of American suburbs. Something wholesome and neutral and boring haha. Great video! Just discovered your channel from the video on stereotypical Asian fonts and have gone down a rabbit hole since.

  • @jblen
    @jblen 3 роки тому +34

    Today I learned London boroughs have logos... Even though I live in one
    Edit: I guess I have seen them everywhere, I just never associated it as a borough logo. It is a tree, and I only really see it on park signs so it makes sense as the general sign for parks rather than the whole boroughs logo

    • @bobmiah
      @bobmiah 3 роки тому +1

      dont you ever get letters from your council

  • @dearHadrian
    @dearHadrian 3 роки тому +6

    'It looks like something that a middle schooler would draw on the condensation inside a bus window" oh my god your roasts are so hilariously accurate! Loved the video, I'm not even interested in the topic but you talk about it so interestingly :D

  • @brianstafford3969
    @brianstafford3969 4 роки тому +120

    I am so surprised how ugly London's council logos are, considering how wealthy London is. Makes Dublin's council logos look like Picasso's work.

    • @oscarzsy
      @oscarzsy 3 роки тому +16

      Some of the boroughs are extremely poor, I think Newham is the poorest for example. Some areas are rich but definitely not all
      Edit - well, I've just finished the video and I guess that fits lmao

    • @ruan13o
      @ruan13o 3 роки тому +9

      Quite typical of the paralysis of public services. Can't spend too much money on the logo for fear of being accused of wasting money. Too afraid to go for something bold in case it offends people. Probably had too many people consulted which gave too many contradictory wishes. Commissioner of the logo probably had no specialism in graphic design. In the end settles for something 'safe' and inoffensive but ultimately pretty boring.

    • @jc_9787
      @jc_9787 3 роки тому +2

      @@oscarzsy Tower hamlets is the poorest Newham is 2nd and Hackney is 3rd

    • @bobmiah
      @bobmiah 3 роки тому +1

      @@oscarzsy tower hamlets is the poorest borough and still has a decent logo

  • @unltdconciousness
    @unltdconciousness 3 роки тому +7

    I like the typeface of City of London because it evokes an image of London and England from deep history. It is reminiscent of history and legend while maintaining a sense of modernity and progress.

  • @ItzSlamDuncan
    @ItzSlamDuncan 3 роки тому +5

    Your videos amaze me with their quality. I hope you enjoy making them. I'll share them with friends that might find them interesting.

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  3 роки тому

      Thank you, you're too kind!

  •  3 роки тому +4

    Sir, I’ve been binge watching your videos since I’ve found you today. I’ve learned so much about design. Please keep making more videos!

  • @SimonS44
    @SimonS44 4 роки тому +20

    Loving this! Thinking far too much about bad logos around me now

  • @gowerarty
    @gowerarty 3 роки тому +9

    This is really interesting. I am on a community council in Wales (the equivalent of an English parish council) and we've been trying to push for a rebrand since forever. Never really priority though! Community councils might not make for an interesting video but it would certainly be interesting to see your take on Wales' 22 county councils and see what you think of their efforts.

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  3 роки тому +5

      Thanks Arthur - there's a few comments now for Wales actually, so I'll see what I can do!

  • @mantasvilcinskas
    @mantasvilcinskas 4 роки тому +13

    I love that this exists. I love your voice. Lovely

  • @enshen2190
    @enshen2190 3 роки тому +22

    The wandsworth logo is just like “You like animals by that ‘pink Floyd’ band don’t ya? Well..come here!”

    • @georgedoty-williams2085
      @georgedoty-williams2085 3 роки тому +2

      That's an iconic skyline if you ask me

    • @user-wq9pq8yu1b
      @user-wq9pq8yu1b 3 дні тому

      @@georgedoty-williams2085 Loved this video but yeah it doesn't get much more iconic than Battersea Power Station!

  • @Reddsoldier
    @Reddsoldier 3 роки тому +21

    I'd like to see a rundown of the old Borough logos too.
    Haringey's old logo was really really good if you ask me. After dealing with documents and media materials from the Borough, they all used a variation of the "lightning sun" or a lightning bolt from it and you could instantly tell stuff related to the borough. Meanwhile the H they use now is pretty crappy.

  • @arjardine
    @arjardine 2 роки тому +3

    Cracking overview, solid technical, with good history and funny af too - well played

  • @youraveragejoe1
    @youraveragejoe1 2 роки тому +5

    If you think some of these are bad, look at the logo for “Evri” (Hermes delivery rebrand). The letters are all different fonts, widths and designs it’s a nightmare 😂😂

  • @ignatgrz
    @ignatgrz 4 роки тому +30

    Southwark reminded of the logo that Tom Scott has on his website, but on closer look the borough's typography is a lot more awkward.

  • @dansheppard2965
    @dansheppard2965 2 роки тому +8

    I've always loved Derbyshire's logo, the spiral D. It has great ownability and faxibility/faviconability. Sadly it's in plum and white these days rather than the eye-watering purple and orange of the 70s and 80s, but it probably causes fewer seizures in onlookers. I don't know whether I *like* it or not, but once seen never forgotten.

  • @charlieg2262
    @charlieg2262 3 роки тому +6

    I'm born & raised in Hackney, now living in Kingston upon Thames and I can tell you that Hackney's logo isn't the only thing it has over Kingston...

  • @julesfenn4313
    @julesfenn4313 4 роки тому +8

    i know nothing about graphic design, looking at the logos I could only go 'oh pretty, pretty, ugly, pretty'... and that's all the insight I have 😂 but despite my ignorance, I've massively enjoyed the video, it was truly a pleasure to watch!! (and I fee a bit less ignorant now, so thank you about that, too!)

  • @richardavsmith
    @richardavsmith 4 роки тому +26

    Suggestion for another video: UK Train Operating Company logos. (Can do past ones as well, there's a lot of bad ones!)

  • @mattc1uk
    @mattc1uk 3 роки тому +4

    Absolutely loved this video. These are the kind of odd conversations I miss with the brand team at work.

  • @joewilliams5057
    @joewilliams5057 4 роки тому +3

    Great mix of nerdery and accessibility. Your presenting style and voice is lovely too!

  • @cirlu_bd
    @cirlu_bd 3 роки тому +5

    Damn you're so smooth to listen too ! Very interesting video, love being filled with pointless informations that I'll inexplicably remember forever (totally serious, it may not find a use in my life, but knowing all this fills me with joy anyway !)

  • @fishtank39
    @fishtank39 3 роки тому +1

    I'm so glad to stumble into this companion video to the London boroughs one. I was choking on my spit laughing at how you roasted the crest for Bexley lmao

  • @Yossus
    @Yossus 4 роки тому +14

    I see you're fairly new on here but I hope you continue to produce content! This was really interesting and I was fascinated by how you characterised the different fonts and logos because although I find fonts interesting, my brain just doesn't pick up on what they look like 👀 maybe you could do a video on what to look for in a font?

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому +6

      Thank you! This is actually my 3rd or 4th attempt at youtube, depending how you count, but yes, I'm planning to stay the course this time. I'd love to do some basic primers on typography - glad to know that some people would be interested to watch!

  • @pqpqpq5685
    @pqpqpq5685 4 роки тому +2

    Jay Foreman sent me too, I know nothing about graphic design but this was unexpectedly very soothing. Thank you. Southwark & Richmond represent.

  • @fish42
    @fish42 Рік тому

    Something I really appreciate about Linus’s videos is how he lets you know the framework. He checks in so that you know what to expect, without repeating himself or spoiling the content. Good stuff.

  • @MrPlippyplop
    @MrPlippyplop Рік тому

    Very nicely done and shines a light on how the design standards are so low for borough councils. I somewhat covered this topic for my college dissertation at St Martin’s when I looked at the disparity between how areas marketed themselves to tourists versus the actual residents.
    Logos for the former were clearly given much more leeway to present the area in a very positive light and clearly had a different approval process (possibly with different final approvers). I wrote my dissertation in 1996 and was amazed to see the likes of Camden, Merton and a few others hadn’t changed their borough logo.
    I think you’d be fascinated to make a similar video that compares the tourist vs resident logos of the same boroughs.

  • @poundlandvodka
    @poundlandvodka Рік тому +3

    I actually really like the uniqueness of Haringey's logo, although now you mentioned that it looks like red tape that's all I'm gonna think of when I see it

  • @JamesCub88
    @JamesCub88 3 роки тому +4

    i found Jay's video/borough rhyme really funny, but you helped me appreciate the logo isn't just about a drawing. it goes on everywhere and it needs to be adapted to all sorts of applications, including reducing it to a size of a post stamp.
    having said that, i'm surprised you ranked Newham lower than Croydon or Southwark. I can see you dislike swooshes, but they're more inventive than just having your name or a "signature" like the other 2. I'm also surprised Lambeth got so many points. those "triangles"/whatever those yellow things are, are reminiscent of nothing and don't really add much to the logo
    anyway, you did mention personal preference and i guess those are mine. great video

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  3 роки тому +4

      Hey, thanks Diogo. Ultimately any system for ranking visual flair will be subjective, but something I perhaps under-explained was the craftsmanship involved in doing something simple, well. Lambeth's triangle flags may seem simple, but as a designer, I can immediately tell that weeks of tweaking and care went into getting them just right. Contrast that with the examples of "autotrace" that I rail against - it's like the difference between a sandwich made with store bought, mass produced, pre-sliced bread or making a sourdough from scratch. I understand not everyone will appreciate it on the same level, but maybe I should do a video explaining this concept a little clearer. Cheers for checking out the channel!

  • @MinusMOD98
    @MinusMOD98 2 роки тому +5

    The suitability aspect makes me think of when my municipality switched from a birch leaf to just plain (albeit green) text. The birch leaf is a historical symbbl referrng to to the planting of birch trees after the city fire in 1888

  • @cdoakley
    @cdoakley 3 роки тому +1

    Hey Linus... Just wanted to drop by and say how much I'm enjoying your videos. I only discovered your work on UA-cam very recently, but I'm having fun going back through your archive! You make some very interesting comments and always have something worthwhile to say on the subject of graphic design.
    Re: the London Borough logos, I'm broadly in agreement with what you said, especially regarding the Barking and Dagenham logo. I was working for the borough when it introduced the double arc and I was as dumbfounded then as I am now. B&D used to use it's coat of arms much more prior to the late 90's, but when they brought in this unimaginative dross, my heart sank. A great opportunity missed, I'd say.
    One other thing: When I see a logo that has two identical/similar letters together (as in the stylised H and the capital H of the word Hackney), I find it really jarring. What's your thoughts on that? I wondered if you'd mark the logo down because of the close proximity of the two H's. I feel the circular H should be spaced a little further away from the name... is that fair comment?!
    Anyway, keep up the good work... I think your videos are great! (Best wishes from New Zealand...)

    • @krissp8712
      @krissp8712 Рік тому +1

      Same, just discovered the channel recently and Linus has a great archive on offer!

  • @andrelaszlo
    @andrelaszlo 3 роки тому +4

    Brilliant! I also laughed out loud at the poking pinky logo. Harningey is so weird it would go well on a t-shirt or something. Apparently Haringey is "more than just a place. It is an attitude" :D

    • @marrrtin
      @marrrtin 3 роки тому +1

      Haringey should go the whole hog and make it a graffiti tag.

  • @asuka7309
    @asuka7309 3 роки тому +2

    Newham has the Olympic park, the Vic & Albert docks, Thames barrier, AND the Beckton Sewage Treatment Plant and somehow all they could come up with was a generic swoosh...

  • @DadgeCity
    @DadgeCity 3 роки тому +3

    I'd criticise Hackney for using the logo directly to the left of the name since there's a repetition and clash of style between the logo-H and the text-H. I wouldn't omit the text-H, since that would look stupid, but I'd always have the logo larger and centred above the name.

    • @annap8420
      @annap8420 3 роки тому

      True... I have always loved the funny space craft "H" Hackney has, there is something very retro cool and also positive about it... It needs to be made more of.

  • @ikertxikuri
    @ikertxikuri 3 роки тому +1

    You definitely need more subs, the quality of the editing is insane, and it's also equally informative and entertaining

  • @BvousBrainSystems
    @BvousBrainSystems 4 роки тому +1

    The presentation is excellent. I mean both the aesthetic quality of the footage but also the way the information was organized: introduction, goal, rules, explanation of the rules, presentation of the roster, little graph and text to show the scores rather than stating them... lots of good ideas

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому

      Thank you, that's very kind to say!

    • @BvousBrainSystems
      @BvousBrainSystems 4 роки тому

      @@LinusBoman Well it's true.
      Are you starting a UA-cam career?

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому

      @@BvousBrainSystems well, I'm planning on making content on UA-cam, would love to make a career of it, but I feel that's more up to luck than other careers. But I'm committed to making videos that interest me, and hopefully it finds its audience here on UA-cam!

  • @AmericasComic
    @AmericasComic 3 роки тому +2

    I live in New York City and our boroughs don't have logos, the way we distinguish between the areas is each borough has a different guy with a knife at the bus stop.

  • @idontwanttopickone
    @idontwanttopickone 3 роки тому +5

    2:20 - I disagree. The New York Apples sounds like a great name for a sports team and I could totally imagine them having the Apple logo.

    • @mnm1273
      @mnm1273 3 роки тому

      New York Apples is one of the worst bands I've ever heard. Apples? Talk about underwhelming.
      At least it's not racist.

  • @jetsons101
    @jetsons101 Рік тому

    Loved the humor given to the Southwark logo, a kid drawing on the condensation inside a bus window, "priceless." The "W" in the Harrow Council logo could be doing something naughty to the "C" in council, just thinking.

  • @alestrius
    @alestrius Рік тому +1

    The little OUO on the crest in Islington makes me laugh so hard. I'm assuming it's meant to be like, two suns and a moon or something -- anything that ISN'T a little obscenely happy face, but I've just been on the internet too long and it just looks like a personified, excessively happy thing to me. (And then the plant swooshes kinda end up furthering that and looking like arms/hands on hips...)

  • @Anglesandacid
    @Anglesandacid 4 роки тому +3

    Nice - been looking forward to one of these critique videos :)

  • @jamesfresco
    @jamesfresco 3 роки тому +6

    Would love to see you re-design the worst ones!

  • @saif7507
    @saif7507 2 роки тому

    How is this so interesting? I don’t even live in the UK and I’m still nodding away at these critiques!

  • @RAWFUNNYTRUE
    @RAWFUNNYTRUE 3 роки тому +3

    Having spent time in Newham, I could've told you it would've come last without ever seeing the logo at all

  • @Jamesgsgeorge
    @Jamesgsgeorge 3 роки тому +1

    Loved this video, first i've seen from your channel. Perhaps you could do a future video where you do what you would have done for the very worst logos/types? Thanks!

  • @billyshearer117
    @billyshearer117 3 роки тому +6

    Would be great to see UK County Council logos rated. Dorset have a new one, would love to hear your thoughts!

  • @opiejaye
    @opiejaye 3 роки тому +2

    That Newham logo screams "that'll do". Great video!

  • @embrio.
    @embrio. 3 роки тому

    Quality educational material right here. I don't have any personal investment in London borough logo design, but I still clung to your every sass-tastic word.

  • @Vits117
    @Vits117 3 роки тому

    Absolutely brilliant!
    Found your channel not long ago and I've adored it ever since :)

  • @Benny4236
    @Benny4236 3 роки тому +1

    Absolutely great video, keep giving us stuff like this!

  • @lucabrandalesi1265
    @lucabrandalesi1265 3 роки тому

    Me, not a Londoner, not a brit, not a typographer or graphic designer, enjoying these videos a lot

  • @paul_sebastiano
    @paul_sebastiano 3 роки тому +1

    Great video! I'm glad I discovered you channel in its tender infancy.

  • @afh001
    @afh001 4 роки тому +3

    Brilliant video Linus! Miffed at the poor performance of Tower Hamlets...

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому

      There's a lot they're leaving on the table! Still, many worse in the batch! 😂

  • @493HZ
    @493HZ 3 роки тому +1

    Liked this off the bat for being such an original idea

  • @vladcalin4671
    @vladcalin4671 3 роки тому

    You should have way more subscribers man. Nice work, just discovered your channel a few days ago and I am loving it. Keep up the good work!

  • @RobertNowland
    @RobertNowland 3 роки тому +1

    As a graphic design nerd I am in love with these vids!

  • @tombrooks6885
    @tombrooks6885 3 роки тому

    Is it just me or does the production look different in this video? Different camera angle, lighting etc. I really like the change! I know I'm watching these out of production order but I think the way this video looks is an improvement on the others.
    Content wise, great as always. I definitely did not expect to laugh this much in a video about council logos 😀. Keep up the good work!

  • @michaelw9285
    @michaelw9285 3 роки тому +3

    I think the Lambeth lettering is very similar to the Ubuntu typeface - almost a striking resemblance, despite the fact the Ubuntu fonts were released in 2010 (and was designed by Dalton Maag).

  • @awmperry
    @awmperry 3 роки тому +7

    Would be fascinated to hear your thoughts on Securitas’ recent rebrand. It redid the whole trade dress from logo to car livery, and it’s been pretty controversial…

  • @jinglefart
    @jinglefart 3 роки тому

    I like this video I wanted to learn about the logos, I couldn’t find any other video and I’m pleased with this, Nice work :)

  • @bbubbinklm4320
    @bbubbinklm4320 3 роки тому +4

    I think Lewisham is underrated in this personally

  • @richardchoi168
    @richardchoi168 3 роки тому

    this popped up in my feed and i love it. well done analysis and presentation! i’m not so down on the city of london as you are and would put that at the top despite the crest’s weaknesses. i do cringe at the use of two different ampersands in the hammersmith & fulham logo. the large one in blue is disturbingly odd with its array of thicknesses that distracts from the rather nice large h or f and only loosely connects (literally and figuratively) to the unnecessary ribbon element. i’d love to see a modern update to camden, there’s some potential to build from there. nice video, you’ve gained a subscriber!

  • @Rubicon1985
    @Rubicon1985 3 роки тому +3

    Bromley locals have an on-going debate as to whether it's London or Kent (people seem just as passionate about both sides) - I guess this is the council firmly saying it's a borough of London in a very inelegant way! Doesn't have a London postcode but it comes under greater London, TFL as well as Kent - confusing!

    • @matthewbeale5098
      @matthewbeale5098 3 роки тому +1

      As a native to Bromley I say it's both or change it depending on who I'm talking too. Although my friends in Kent refuse to accept it's part of Kent

  • @kirbsmeister2
    @kirbsmeister2 3 роки тому +3

    I feel like you failed to appreciate that the R in the Richmond logo looks like the Thames in Richmond on a map, which I think is kind of clever.

  • @ianmoseley9910
    @ianmoseley9910 3 роки тому +2

    At one time Towere Hamlets divided itself into 7 "neighbourhoods" each with its own colour for everything including the logo.

  • @simoneh1639
    @simoneh1639 3 роки тому

    That was so good! I do like Kensington’s logo but when you put it like that!

  • @panzertorte
    @panzertorte Рік тому

    Fascinating to see what a professional picks up on and considers suitable, personally I'd scrap the whole lot with the notable exceptions of City of London, Islington and Sutton (!)

  • @bryanbondy7827
    @bryanbondy7827 4 роки тому +6

    Sorry for my threat on Twitter to turn you off! But I really just viscerally loathe Haringey's logo. That typeface belongs in a 1960s movie title sequence and it can't age well because it's already vinegar.
    PLEASE DO CANADIAN PROVINCES AND TERRITORIES xx

    • @LinusBoman
      @LinusBoman  4 роки тому +1

      Haringey's logo certainly gets that reaction from people! At least has something to say about how the area wants to see it self, even if it doesn't pull it off with much flair. Personally, I think the hatchet job they did in 2007 taking the original thunderbolt logo and slanting it at an angle with a dark green block down the middle was worse. It just showed no conceptual thinking at all, pretty irredeemable!
      But, Canadian provinces and territories could be interesting! I'm not familiar - do they have logos per se? A quick wikipedia search gives a flag and coat of arms for each, but I'm no vexillologist or specialist in heraldry! But could be a collab if I can find a specialist who'd be interested. :)

    • @fergusturtle6953
      @fergusturtle6953 4 роки тому

      @@LinusBoman Their provincial governments all have logos I believe rather than the actual provinces, similar to this video being the council logos.

    • @bryanbondy7827
      @bryanbondy7827 4 роки тому

      @@LinusBoman I think you'd have to seek out the tourism ministries' logos or perhaps crap on I mean assess city logos such as Ottawa's. I live in Ottawa and I'm curious to know what you think. Btw, having watched to the end, I can't disagree with you. Deathly those bottom few, just deathly.

  • @alnsubuga
    @alnsubuga Рік тому

    Really interesting video! I lived in Camden for over 2 decades and have always thought the logo was chainlink 🤦🏾‍♀️😅

  • @nvrndingsmmr
    @nvrndingsmmr 3 роки тому +2

    I really like the Enfield logo but perhaps it's the fact that I love motorsports! Maybe not so appropriate for a council but certainly very cool and full of potential!

  • @ringdonuts8125
    @ringdonuts8125 4 роки тому +2

    Loved this video! Amusing and informative!

  • @lillemaake
    @lillemaake 4 роки тому +1

    As a person with no graphic design knowledge I find it oddly entertaining and informative. Figured I'll write something to help the algorithm with the engagement and hopefully get you a bit of boost.

  • @JamieBainbridge
    @JamieBainbridge 10 місяців тому

    You are so savage, many laughs had in the second half 😅

  • @BohemianArcade
    @BohemianArcade 3 роки тому +1

    Loved this! So interesting and informative. Thanks for making!

  • @ellieban
    @ellieban 2 місяці тому

    The first thing I thought when I saw the video title was “I bet there’s at least one version of hands clasped in a circle” and yup. And it’s old too 🤣

  • @Redrally
    @Redrally Рік тому

    I remember the old Sutton logo. Proud Sutton resident for...most of my life. It used to be an Oak Tree with very clear acorns - I miss those acorns 😥

    • @Redrally
      @Redrally Рік тому

      IMO Wandsworth should be a few places higher, it has the outline of Battersea Park Power Station - which is really iconic!