Can women travel alone? Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 83

  • @A-human-like-you
    @A-human-like-you Рік тому +6

    That answers 2 very important questions thanks alot 😭

  • @saradigota7201
    @saradigota7201 6 днів тому +2

    Solution; Men travel if u in search for to get married. Ladies, stay safe.

    • @saradigota7201
      @saradigota7201 6 днів тому

      And ofcourse in a halal way; ask the lady polite and in a halal way if she is already married or not, u interested in her otherwise.

  • @Touhidalomtapadar
    @Touhidalomtapadar 7 місяців тому +30

    Most practical scholar I ever seen.

    • @shakilmahmud5996
      @shakilmahmud5996 6 місяців тому +9

      He isn’t a scholar.Also Islam isn’t about being practical by our logic.
      Islam is a way of life legislated by our Lord.
      We just obey the way it is.

    • @Mila_123..17
      @Mila_123..17 5 місяців тому

      💯

    • @tehreemfatima5030
      @tehreemfatima5030 4 місяці тому

      ​@@shakilmahmud5996he is stop lying jahil

    • @makhanikuan
      @makhanikuan 2 місяці тому

      @@shakilmahmud5996legislated by Lord or the nowadays scholars!

    • @appu1sundaram
      @appu1sundaram 2 місяці тому +2

      There is nothing called a practical scholar. Islam is already practical and logical and easy for those who are willing to submit to Allah's will.
      This person is not a scholar.

  • @TheBestowersSlave
    @TheBestowersSlave 8 місяців тому +31

    Be careful respected viewers! This person is doing a nice job but beware he is not a Mufti who is authorized to issue an edic.

    • @tehreemfatima5030
      @tehreemfatima5030 4 місяці тому +5

      But he is scholar of quran so yes he is allowed to

    • @alihaider-gz9iq
      @alihaider-gz9iq 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@tehreemfatima5030 nope

    • @HKhulu
      @HKhulu Місяць тому +1

      ​@@tehreemfatima5030nope he is not

    • @anonymous_5720
      @anonymous_5720 Місяць тому +4

      And who are you? Why should we trust what you are saying?

    • @TheBestowersSlave
      @TheBestowersSlave Місяць тому

      @anonymous_5720 brother do your own research and you will find it easily on Google or may be ChatGPT

  • @alamafroj5106
    @alamafroj5106 11 місяців тому +3

    Thanks sir for your great answer

  • @habibachaudhry6507
    @habibachaudhry6507 3 місяці тому +15

    Then what about the Ahadith mentioned in Sahih Bukhari 1086-1088. Sahih Bukhari 1086 says "Narrated Ibn `Umar:
    The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "A woman should not travel for more than three days except with a Dhi-Mahram (i.e. a male with whom she cannot marry at all, e.g. her brother, father, grandfather, etc.) or her own husband.)"

  • @sangeetaparyani
    @sangeetaparyani 4 місяці тому +3

    As long as your kids irrespective of gender, are capable to go out for jobs, for education,on vacations then that shouldn’t be a problem. This world itself is not, sometimes not even home, that doesn’t mean we don’t let our daughters go out 🙃

    • @Mythbuster_0079
      @Mythbuster_0079 3 місяці тому +3

      In this video it doesn't say that women should not work or educate themselves and go out it is about safety..... And I know even in home but the chances of harassment is increased in our side especially in long journey... But not in short .... It is about safety not boundaries it there is nothing like harassment or assault then what would be the problem.... And in this video he didn't say that should not go ....

    • @sangeetaparyani
      @sangeetaparyani 3 місяці тому

      @@Mythbuster_0079 ok. Can you please let me know for my knowledge what does this mean to be away for not more than 3 days then ? Also some parents aren’t educated enough to know what is good and bad and the burden falls on kids, in this case let’s consider a daughter! If parents not uneducated and still stop girl from working or even going out then that is haram.

    • @Mythbuster_0079
      @Mythbuster_0079 3 місяці тому

      @@sangeetaparyani it is not about haram or halal 😂.... Not in any case or scenario nobody can take the right to educate or work because it is halal and yah what work should to it may haram or halal it is a different thing......
      Any women can go anywhere even in night there is nothing to with it ... The hadith says about their safety concern it doesn't forbid to be educated and be a working independent women even in the time of 7th century women were working and giving zakat it is liable to every muslim.....
      So it was because of safety concern not about haram or halal and even in this video Nauman himself said that u can watch it sis .....

    • @sangeetaparyani
      @sangeetaparyani 3 місяці тому

      @@Mythbuster_0079 🤣🤣 I dint knew I’ll have to take the pain to make you understand by elaborating it. However, let me simplify this for you.
      Let’s suppose A girl whose parents doesn’t want her to go a particular place even for a job, let’s say DELHI, but still the daughter wishes to go. She’s not able to negotiate with parents, cuz her parents think it’s not safe for her to stay there but she feels going on some logical reasons and the family has a clash,then what? What is daughter wants to go goa for adventure and parents who have never seen goes and stop their daughter to go then what? Safety depends on many factors as to how well you can take of yourself even in an unpleasant environment, how cautious you are! Parents will say many things but doesn’t mean we do everything 🙂

    • @sangeetaparyani
      @sangeetaparyani 3 місяці тому

      @@Mythbuster_0079also, let me ask you. In Islam as per Zakir Naik it’s not permissible for a women to be without mehram even on duty. More than 3 days she cannot be without a male if she’s out somewhere. At job, if a male (companion whose known to her) is not able to accompany her then she can choose to have a female by her side as her companion but she cannot be with a man alone. A doctor whose doing surgery for example is surrounded by all males is haram ? A lady advocate in between 10 male advocate is haram. I mean what is this ?

  • @humnaali1761
    @humnaali1761 2 місяці тому +3

    Are adult women with fully developed brains not allowed to solely decide where is safe for them, and where isn't?

    • @Aliveizawesome
      @Aliveizawesome Місяць тому

      The cases get registered on a daily basis for **** say it all. Do we really submit ourselves to Almighty Allah? What's the meaning of the word Muslim?

  • @sanjinaakter7184
    @sanjinaakter7184 3 місяці тому +2

    If you don't find the right person.
    But i heard we created in pairs. Our soul was made with our life partner's soulmate.pls answer

    • @physicslover790
      @physicslover790 2 місяці тому +1

      Ofcourse we are created in pairs.... The world is so big may be she/he is there but you didn't find him/her.

    • @NazishAly
      @NazishAly Місяць тому

      @@physicslover790 This has been discussed by multiple scholars. You can look it up, but if my memory serves, in pairs means Allah made the male species and the female species, just like the day and the night etc. It does not necessarily mean that every single female human has a soulmate. There are many scholars in history who never got married. You can study it. May Allah forgive me if I made a mistake in conveying. Ameen

    • @physicslover790
      @physicslover790 Місяць тому

      @@NazishAly yeah exactly ... this is what I am saying bro... May be they are in there but we didn't find them. Ibn Tammiyah was unmarried throughout his life

    • @samiashabnam272
      @samiashabnam272 Місяць тому +1

      You don't know what is in your takdir, so from your side, you try to do the right thing, and make du'a to get what you want

  • @appu1sundaram
    @appu1sundaram 2 місяці тому +7

    This answer is wrong. Most important thing in Islam is not what you think or i think or so and so Sheikh thinks. What Allah and the Prophet saw has commanded is final and is for up to the end of times. Secondly, this person is not a scholar and ia hugely influenced by western ideas unfortunately. May Allah guide us all. We should beware of whom we take our knowledge and fatwas from. Thirdly, the reasons and wisdom behind every command is numerous. Some of which are mentioned and many we may never know. Only Allah in His infinite Wisdom knows. Just because someone thinks it is okay to allow their children to free mix with their cousins citing the reason that all are pious children, that doesn't make free mixing okay in that particular situation. Who cares what that particular situation is, what a particular so called sheikh does with his family. We want to know what Allah and His Messenger saw has commanded. We hear and we obey. Simple.

  • @AarhamKaisar
    @AarhamKaisar 10 місяців тому +3

    Is he south asian?

  • @THISis.BUSHRA
    @THISis.BUSHRA 3 місяці тому

    I like the coconuts example because i also hate coconets 😂❤

  • @sadzb4609
    @sadzb4609 Місяць тому

    ❤😊

  • @kamelrougi477
    @kamelrougi477 5 місяців тому

    please remove music it's haram

  • @shakilmahmud5996
    @shakilmahmud5996 6 місяців тому +9

    Don't just listen to this guy.
    The way he is misleading the ummah is terrible.
    May Allah guide him and save people from his fitnah.

    • @nyangardi9484
      @nyangardi9484 6 місяців тому +13

      Im sorry but how is he causing fitnah? And how anything he said is against islam?

    • @shakilmahmud5996
      @shakilmahmud5996 6 місяців тому +9

      ​@@nyangardi9484 Women can't travel without adult male mahram is an established ruling of Islam legislated by Allah by his Prophet (SA).All the ulemas have agreed upon this that travelling without mahram is haram.We muslims must obey without any second thought and using any logic.
      Here NAK is saying the ruling is only about the safety of women not haram or halal.Conversation about halal or haram on this topic is off topic.If the place is safe they can go anywhere alone.This is clearly belittling an obligatory act of Islam which can take you out of the fold of Islam.
      Secondly he said marriage is not necessary.But fact is our Prophet (SA) ordered Muslims to get married if they are capable of.He also said marriage is his sunnah.Whoever stay away from his sunnah isn’t a part of his ummah.
      Some scholars didn’t get married is an exception.Exception isn’t an example.
      Now tell me why everything he said isn’t against Islam?

    • @nyangardi9484
      @nyangardi9484 6 місяців тому +6

      @@shakilmahmud5996 they point is women can never truly be safe when traveling alone even men shouldn’t go alone traveling, but some women have no mahram and then maybe they can go to hajj due to organization prepared by the government like the one in my country where they will go in groups

    • @shakilmahmud5996
      @shakilmahmud5996 6 місяців тому +5

      @@nyangardi9484 again sister you need to understand that Islam is already perfect.We don't use our logic.
      Our Prophet (SA) told women not to travel without mahram.This is the end of the discussion.Women can't even go to hajj without mahram.If a woman doesn’t have any mahram to go with her Hajj isn’t obligation upon her.

    • @BIBII888
      @BIBII888 5 місяців тому +5

      ​@@shakilmahmud5996yes they can stop the cap , that Hadith has a historical context, it was forbidden for women to travel because it was dangerous for them

  • @mstamily4007
    @mstamily4007 9 місяців тому

    বাংলা ডাবলিং চাই

    • @shakilmahmud5996
      @shakilmahmud5996 6 місяців тому

      কি দরকার এই ফিতনায় পড়ার?
      উনি ভয়ানক বিভ্রান্ত একজন মানুষ আর হাজার হাজার মুসলিমকে বিভ্রান্ত করছে।
      উনার ভিডিও দেখা থেকে বিরত থাকুন।
      আল্লাহ সবাইকে হেফাজত করুন।