votes : 78% to 22%
narrator: “another close call”
I feel like an idiot... I did the math based on a couple different three way races, came up with a min/max voter of 9... Then looked in description where it say a panel of 9... Then see these comments... 😅
Matt ryan might be the only human on planet earth who's hero was tim couch
I still remember that QB draft class vividly. Was supposed to be super strong when most of em never made it. Culpepper and McNabb I would say had successfull careers while cade Mcnown, akili Smith, tim couch, sean king etc not so much.
The fact that he's the greatest nfl player to ever wear #2 is ridiculous. Ryan had a couple good seasons but overall is trash
@@issajoke2437 I agree but there aren't a lot of 2s to pick from. He kinda got it by default
Jim Brown was so great that he rushed for over 1,500 yards in 3 seasons each and 1 season with over 1,860yrds and what people forget is in his 4 first seasons, it was only a 12 game season and only a 14 game regular season when he played his last 4. And despite the league expansion to 16 regular season games. Brown is still the first and one of the only running backs to have a 100+ rushing TD career. Oh, just to put a topping on his 9 year career, he never MISSED a single game. And the cherry on top, he recieved for 2,500yrds and 20 touchdowns.
“According to our panel” of 9 people...? That’s kind of important information
Better than the pro bowl vote where it's just a popularity contest.
Chris Anderson yo mama said “...it was just a handful” and he answered “if you do the math it’s 9”
By the way, Len Dawson said the Chiefs could Un-Retire the number 16 so that Joe Montana could wear it. But Joe said it’s alright, I’ll just wear 19. Much respect.
IronyAml Len Dawson didnt say he could wear it He refused t let Joe wear it
From What I read I don’t know if I read it right but Len didn’t want them to but the team still offered
0% no love for Micheal Vick, Eli Manning, Julio Jones ☹️ ouch!
Well, they just weren’t better then the opponents. For example, Julio vs Larry. LOL
When Ed Reed tells you that he would give up his HOF spot, that is true respect. All respect to Steve Atwater.
These percentages are a joke...
Out of 9 people. Really. If this was a real vote at least someone would vote julio
7 is bs especially with 0% amd 20 ed reed is better while barry is more humble
Calvin Johnson wasn’t even mention for the best player wearing 81
He had some tough competition I do think he was better than Tim Brown
Calvin Johnson: single season record holder & arguably one of the best receivers to play the game.
Not even on the list.
He's got a tough number. Jay Cutler was a nominee, but not Calvin Johnson
the 3 for 81 shouldve been TO, night train lane, and calvin johnson but i’d say terrell was better
@@bradengugliuzza2298 Tim Brown played for like 20 years and is very high on all the receiving leaderboards. Calvin is a solid choice there, but I understand why Tim Brown is there
Regiane Candido what about Jerry Rice? He is the best that’s right. But CJ isn’t even on the list.
78: Bruce Smith (all time sack leader)
88: Alan Page (first of only 2 defensive players to be league MVP)
Those numbers shocked me.
Anthony Munoz is the best offensive lineman ever and Bruce smith isn’t the best d lineman. Pretty simple.
@@KaiDaGoat yeah I know but I was confused whether he was de or olb. Reggie white is best d line then
I kinda feel like vinatieri should be wayyyy more than 0% considering he is leading scorerr in nfl
@Daniel Coronado your an idiot he is a 4 time superbowl champions 2 of which my patriots won because of him he is also the all time scorer in nfl history he is the greatest kicker in nfl history
Daniel Coronado well how about I say it for you, Vinatieri is the greatest kicker of all time.
@@vroomvroomfam309 that's gonna be our justin tucker when he retires.
Thank you for simply displaying that the NFL did indeed exist WAY before 1980. So many creators on UA-cam seem to miss that fact.
WHO... If I may ask... TF VOTED?!?!
@@suziewheeler6530 they only asked nine people i think (all the % are either 11% (1/9), 56% (5/9) etc.))
This has to be one of the best segments that NFL Throwback has ever uploaded!!! I love this
@@NFLVault 🤔Unless this UA-cam video was made before 1986, you have a HUGE mistake at #27
4:52 fun fact 13 is a lucky number in Italy and Marino is Italian. Kinda wished he won a Superbowl. 🤷♂️
@@thesentinel5523 Wow, I never thought of Montana as an Italian name, being that it's one of our 50 states and Joe Montana seems as American as apple pie. But you're right.
"John Elway is the best player to wear NO.7 in any sport"
Ronaldo: I took that personally
"Gary Anderson - 0%"
That's tough
You know what else is tough that kick he missed in the nfc championship that would of sent to the Vikings to the Super Bowl
It’s funny how they said Steve Atwater wasn’t in the hall of fame but literally a week after this video was posted he was elected to the hall of fame
0:49
Taysom Hill : I can play at multiple positions
Bronko Nagurski : Hold my cleats
I grew up a 49ers fan but I got to point out the absolute humbleness of that last fact on #20. Man he was so entertaining to watch. There will never be another Barry Sanders. I do have to question 73. That should at least be a tie because John Hannah may have been on a bad team but he is arguably the best lineman to ever play the game.
How to qualify as a “deserving winner” according to this comments section:
1. Be decent in the 2000’s
2. That’s it
Bro I was fully expecting Pat Mcafee to be best #1 and they disrespect so much.
If it wasnt for polamalu, #1 wouldve been pat mcafee...
"He probably would've jumped over the lineman, pick me up, and take me to the endzone"
A hate to see Earl Campbell (34) get pushed out, he's one of my all-time favorite backs, but losing to Sweetness? Okay, I'll let it stand. 😃
Hard for Campbell having to go up against the greatest football player of all time.
@@PatSnoop Good thing this conversation wasn't talking about Jim Brown. Easy for a fullback to look good when playing in an offense that potent in an era before substantial integration and while weighing at much as some of the OL. Ol' Jim wouldn't have done that playing for the Phoenix Cardinals in the 1980s.
The only RB more overrated than Jim in the annals of history might be Barry Sanders. Both were good but I would take a few RBs before them in a heartbeat.
Did I just see Jay Cutler involved in a “Best Of” list?
There is nobody in the HOF wearing number 6 so they couldn't do much i guess
If polamalu isn’t 43 imma freak.
Damn straight :)
Big Ben wasn’t even in on the conversation fornumber 7. Top ten all time in every single passing category all time multiple super bowl winner absolutely ridiculous he got left out.
When Vinatieri got 0 percent
Thats fucked up, the number he wares is the amount of rings he has, more than Favre.
If Vick wouldn't have gotten arrested he would be a top 10 qb in all QB statistics
“Elway is the best sports player to wear the number 7”
Every Soccer Player: Am I a joke to you?
@@sliding2k746 what is a joke is saying that elway is a better 7 than cristiano Ronaldo
Congrats to Steve Atwater and Troy Polamalu, both of whom made the Hall of Fame this year, so you can add that to their credentials. And yes, Ken Houston was always in!
Pat McAfee is still SO traumatized by Polamalu that if he ever has kids he won't allow them to be born via a *C-Section*
Cody Robbins Bc Larry Fitzgerald will always be better than Julio Larry Fitzgerald has more tackles than dropped passes
The Marvin Harrison disrespect is LEGENDARY.
Ed Reed only getting 11% is pretty sad
@@butterxo3094 I'd rather have Ed Reed than Barry Sanders on my team.
well there was only 9 people voting so one person voted for him (1/9 = 11%)
Anish R yea I understand I just wish he would’ve been closer to 30% that would’ve done him justice imo
Bruce Smith not being at 78 is so bad, most career sacks in the history of the league
Zack Degnan that completely discredits this list. Anthony Munoz was awesome but watch him against Smith. Smith all day
Anthony Munoz was better bro💀😭Bruce Smith is one of the all time greats but Anthony Munoz is the GOAT lineman and is a top 15 player ever. This makes sense honestly bro
Patrick Willis nor clay Matthews III not being mentioned as a top 3 in the greatest player to wear 52 is crazy.
Wtf Donovan McNabb, Michael Vick, Julio Jones, 0 percent and Calvin Johnson wasn’t even listed
And Kurt Warner at 0 and LT(the rb) also got snubbed by deion sanders, deion cant even come close to LT
Imagine your hero being Tim Couch
Exactly like who tf has tim couch for any QB to be your hero in the nfl
@@jrsmith5080 arent you the kid who took a tom brady joke seriously and got wooooshed for it
Adrian Peterson:well 5th on the all time rushing list should get me something
0%
@@dmar28 dickerson was a better rb than faulk too but ya ap shoulda been top
@@cjsizzle5068 Me too I think Dickerson was a way better Runner than Faulk, Dickerson didn't have a great offensive line or as good of a QB or WR tandem that confuses the defense if they are going to run the ball or pass it
I feel like you can’t talk about Larry Fitzgerald without mentioning how absolutely efficient he was at catching the ball. He also owns a weird stat line that I absolutely love mentioning lol
Fun fact: Larry Fitzgerald has more tackles than he has drops
@Just A Random nigga how am I “so mad” because I called him a dumbass when he really is one🤦🏿♂️
@@godlyxnns Emo dudes are sensitive and think everyone is Mad.
You're not just mad you're "So" mad ... That sounds like something Lindsey Lohan would say in mean girls 🤷♂️
Number 7: "Michael Vick"
Big Ben: Am I a joke to you??
@@devioushenry_ Two Super Bowls and Vick was Big Ben's backup (Not a Steelers fan)
Vick’s just was mainly a scrambler but Big Ben has more Super Bowls but is a better passer
73 without a mention of Joe Thomas? Never missed a snap and has the highest consecutive snaps played, made pro bowl every year. I can’t say he should be over Larry Allen but he should at least be on the list...
#8 Aikman dominated over young in the postseason and rings, should be unanimous be the winner but young did had a dominant performance in the Superbowl.
As a kicker, it really hurt seeing all of the no vote kickers 😭😭😭
@@ianmcilhenny3870 Seriously. I had to straight up pause the video and see if anyone else noticed that. Vinny is considered the GOAT of kickers. He should've been picked over Favre, easily.
Bradshaw: Well 4 super bowls should count for something
0%
lmao 4 Super Bowls he played garbage in. Brady won 6 so he should easily be 100%
"Philip Rivers took number 17 because that is the number of kids he wants to have."
No cap that’s what I always thought it was because you know it’s rivers. But it was actually because he wanted to honor his dad.
*watches all the eagles players get 0%*
Gets to #60
Yes..thats our boy concrete right there!
Believe it or not, but I know Chuck's son, and I actually met Chuck before he died in 2015
The fact that Joe Thomas isn’t even on the screen for 73 is a damn crime
#99 should be Aaron Donald and it ain't even close
And sorry, it's still Lombardi who didn't cheat
One question scientists will never answer
Jay Cutler on this list
Also How did Kurt Warner get 0%????
Who the hell gave Julio 0%!?
Trc_ Sky yes Larry the lobster is a legend but there’s no way Julio should be voted 0% considering he’s gotta be at least top 5 WRs of all time
But if julio is voted that means they think julio is better then larry
8:20 Emmitt was still the best choice for #22, but Paul Krause holds an NFL record that will never be broken and is a better option than Haynes.
#22 Mike Haynes: 46 interceptions, 688 yards, 2TD, 12 Fumble recoveries
#22 Paul Krause: 81 interceptions (NFL record) , 1185 yards, 3TD, 19 Fumble recoveries
That running back for the falcons Butkis is tackling at 20:45 has always tripped me out because even when both his feet was in the air he was still trying to run until his body hit the ground again. 😂😂😂😂
“Being member of the hall is the only thing that brees doesn’t have on his resume”
_________
looks at trophy case: MVP
AARON RODGERS NOT HERE CUZ "TOM BRADY" IS #12 yeah brady is better but they should do a 1A. Rodgers is 1 of the greatest all time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
12: Tom Brady
34: Walter Peyton
56: Lawrence Taylor
78: Anthony Munoz
90: Julius Peppers
4/5 players are in the NFL 100 year all-time team.
Great list, Deacon deserves more love.
I’d like to see a bigger voting sampling then 9 people to validate these results but I appreciate the theme & effort behind the video
This list is so scuffed. Cutting out so many outstanding players.
I sincerely WISH that the NFL would go back to traditional jersey numbers/numbering! I absolutely DISDAIN the current jersey number system in place right now!
The reason ray Lewis actually chose 52 is cause there was 52 cards in a deck he bought
Wow! That was really enjoyable. The fastest 43 minutes I have ever spent on UA-cam. Thanks so much for this, NFL Throwback!!!
The percentages are literally more of a joke then me
We all knew who number 12 was going to be before starting the video.. The GOAT 🐐
The fact that Jay Cutler was even an option for #6 is an insult to football
@@dominiclagioia9120 yes he knows he was but he’s saying he shouldn’t be there
The absolute disrespect to Joe Thomas I mean cmon
John was part of a record setting team the brown have records but not good ones
@Swish Dipper no shit Sherlock a lineman will never win an mvp or an Opoy award
9 year old chiefs fans be like: "WhErE's pAtRiCk MaHoMeS"?
I know. He will probably be better than Bart if he keeps this up, but Bart is definitely better as of now.
@@Lightgreen57 shutup. I don’t care if mahomes is amassing and will go on the win more Super Bowls. But he won’t put up the numbers Bart did. Mahomes needs like 8 more years of his 2018 season. And then He me will be right behind him
@@thebradinator5683 no you shut up. Mahomes is in the early stages of his career and so far is not as accomplished as Bart
Another good candidate for 99 would have been Jerome Brown. Drafted by the Eagles from the University of Miami (FL), he was a force to be reckoned with and made the Pro Bowl two years in a row. Sadly, he and his nephew were killed in a car accident before the 1992 season. May they rest in peace.
I believe that he would have been a Hall of Fame member if Brown had lived to play a full career
I’m surprised on how some of these were unanimous
Its only 9 people voting so probably not much difference between such a small group of people
How is Ed Reed, the greatest free safety of all time, only at 11%?
Charge202 I’m guessing ur a little kid if u don’t know how good sanders was
@@JordanWickkk I'm guessing you're being biased if you don't think Reed wasn't just as good
Gotta give Lorenzo Neal the love he deserves, but a highly underrated player, Antoine Bethea, from the manning era colts teams, is another 41 that quietly and consistently excelled at his position.
81 Calvin Megatron “no hope in hell of covering” Johnson
Not even so much as an honorable mention for Michael Irvin🤷🏾♂️😱
36:14 it’s funny how they thought that was going to actually be his last catch
This is a clean list. Not all unbiased.
I can’t believe Jay Cutler is on a list that consists of All Time greats 😂
@@boblobdobhobrob8649 he won the packers a lot of games against him he bears
Surprised Primetime was unanimous over LT
Also surprised AP didn’t get any votes against Faulk and Darrell Green
I think Aaron Donald will surpass Watt eventually
@@jebuscrust101LT isn’t the best running back but Deion is the best corner, that’s why
I agree with John Elway but I have no clue why Big Ben wasn’t in the conversation, Mike Vick, REALLY.
As much as I don’t like Big Ben, come on he deserves the mention at least.
Andrew He’s accused of it and he’s been known to be rude to the public, but nonetheless he’s a HOF no doubt
Gideon Powers no he isn’t rude to the public, he donates a lot of his salary to charity, and was accused, both chicks did it because of how much money he has
@@lebronium. Yeah, he's guilty. Hasn't been convicted because of how much money he has. Same with Kobe.
What a wonderful history lesson. Thanks 😊
I'm surprised Cris Carter #80 wasn't on the graphic. Happy for Steve Largent though as a Seahawks fan. Steve Largent even gave his blessings to Jerry Rice to wear #80 in his short stint as a Seahawk. He actually came to my high school back in the early 90s and got to shake his hand. He was probably the first Seahawk player to make a big name in the league. One of the greatest WRs of all time.
They keep releasing GREAT vids
BRUCE SMITH GOT SNUBBED
I agree with most the list. But Bruce is the all time sack leader. Bruce should of got that one
The only reason I watched this was to see Bruce Smith. Watch the ‘88 playoff game where he owns Munoz. This gives this list zero credibility
Jim Kelly did not even get mentioned at #12. No argument on Brady getting it, but man the guy was great!
The fact that Shannon Sharp didn't even get a percentage is crazy
His brother was class, too. That all said, Randy Moss was an alien of an athlete
I think Julio Jones should have had a closer percentage towards Larry
Not even close as of now, maybe in a few years this point will be valid
Jamey Cassady Honestly, if Julio keeps on putting up numbers like he is now, he would beat Larry.
Fitzgerald is a beast look who threw the ball to him ANd most importantly when it matterd he always steped up his already great game in the biggest games
great segment. It is rare that NFL films will pay so much attention to lineman(esp, offesnsinve) Glad to see so many big men get a shoutout.
For 81 you forgot Calvin johnson
#1 - QB Warren Moon (Houston Oilers)
#2 - QB Matt Ryan (Atlanta Falcons)
#3 - FB Bronko Nagurski (Chicago Bears)
#4 - QB Brett Favre (Green Bay Packers)
#5 - HB/FB Paul Hornung (Green Bay Packers)
#6 - P Johnny Hekker (Los Angeles Rams)
#7 - QB John Elway (Denver Broncos)
#8 - QB Steve Young (San Francisco 49ers)
#9 - QB Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints)
#10 - QB Fran Tarkenton (Minnesota Vikings)
#11 - WR Larry Fitzgerald (Arizona Cardinals)
#12 - QB Tom Brady (New England Patriots)
#13 - QB Dan Marino (Miami Dolphins)
#14 - QB Otto Graham (Cleveland Browns)
#15 - QB Bart Starr (Green Bay Packers)
#16 - QB Joe Montana (San Francisco 49ers)
#17 - QB Philip Rivers (Los Angeles Chargers)
#18 - QB Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts)
#19 - QB Johnny Unitas (Baltimore Colts)
#20 - RB Barry Sanders (Detroit Lions)
#21 - CB Deion Sanders (Dallas Cowboys)
#22 - RB Emmitt Smith (Dallas Cowboys)
#23 - KR/PR Devin Hester (Chicago Bears)
#24 - CB Champ Bailey (Denver Broncos)
#25 - WR Fred Biletnikoff (Oakland Raiders)
#26 - CB/S Rod Woodson (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#27 - S Steve Atwater (Denver Broncos)
#28 - RB Marshall Faulk (Los Angeles Rams)
#29 - RB Eric Dickerson (Los Angeles Rams)
#30 - RB Terrell Davis (Denver Broncos)
#31 - FB Jim Taylor (Green Bay Packers)
#32 - RB Jim Brown (Cleveland Browns)
#33 - QB Sammy Baugh (Washington Redskins)
#34 - RB Walter Payton (Chicago Bears)
#35 - CB/S Aeneas Williams (St. Louis Rams)
#36 - RB Jerome Bettis (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#37 - RB/KR/DB Doak Walker (Detroit Lions)
#38 - QB Arnie Herber (Green Bay Packers)
#39 - RB/FB Larry Csonka (Miami Dolphins)
#40 - RB Gale Sayers (Chicago Bears)
#41 - FB Lorenzo Neal (San Diego Chargers)
#42 - S Ronnie Lott (San Francisco 49ers)
#43 - S Troy Polamalu (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#44 - RB John Riggins (Washington Redskins)
#45 - S Kenny Easley (Seattle Seahawks)
#46 - TE Todd Christensen (Oakland Raiders)
#47 - CB Mel Blount (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#48 - FB Daryl Johnston (Dallas Cowboys)
#49 - RB/WR Bobby Mitchell (Washington Redskins)
#50 - LB Mike Singletary (Chicago Bears)
#51 - LB Dick Butkus (Chicago Bears)
#52 - LB Ray Lewis (Baltimore Ravens)
#53 - LB Harry Carson (New York Giants)
#54 - DT/LB Randy White (Dallas Cowboys)
#55 - LB Junior Seau (San Diego Chargers)
#56 - LB Lawrence Taylor (New York Giants)
#57 - LB Rickey Jackson (New Orleans Saints)
#58 - LB Jack Lambert (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#59 - LB Luke Kuechly (Carolina Panthers)
#60 - LB/C Chuck Bednarik (Philadelphia Eagles)
#61 - LB Bill George (Chicago Bears)
#62 - C Jim Langer (Miami Dolphins)
#63 - G Gene Upshaw (Oakland Raiders)
#64 - G Randall Mcdaniel (Minnesota Vikings)
#65 - T Gary Zimmerman (Denver Broncos)
#66 - LB Ray Nitschke (Green Bay Packers)
#67 - G Bob Kuechenberg (Miami Dolphins)
#68 - G Will Shields (Kansas City Chiefs)
#69 - DE Jared Allen (Minnesota Vikings)
#70 - LB Sam Huff (New York Giants)
#71 - T Walter Jones (Seattle Seahawks)
#72 - T Dan Dierdorf (St. Louis Cardinals)
#73 - G Larry Allen (Dallas Cowboys)
#74 - T Bruce Matthews (Tennessee Titans)
#75 - DT Joe Green (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#76 - T/C/DT/K Lou Groza (Cleveland Browns)
#77 - RB Harold Grange (Chicago Bears)
#78 - T Anthony Munoz (Cincinnati Bengals)
#79 - T Roosevelt Brown (New York Giants)
#80 - WR Jerry Rice (San Francisco 49ers)
#81 - WR Terrell Owens (San Francisco 49ers)
#82 - WR Raymond Berry (Baltimore Colts)
#83 - LB Ted Hendricks (Oakland Raiders)
#84 - WR Randy Moss (Minnesota Vikings)
#85 - DE Jack Youngblood (Los Angeles Rams)
#86 - DT Buck Buchanan (Kansas City Chiefs)
#87 - TE Rob Gronkowski (New England Patriots)
#88 - TE Tony Gonzalez (Kansas City Chiefs)
#89 - TE Mike Ditka (Chicago Bears)
#90 - DE Julius Peppers (Carolina Panthers)
#91 - LB Kevin Greene (Pittsburgh Steelers)
#92 - DE Reggie White (Green Bay Packers)
#93 - DT John Randle (Minnesota Vikings)
#94 - LB/DE Charles Haley (San Francisco 49ers)
#95 - DE Richard Dent (Chicago Bears)
#96 - DT Cortez Kennedy (Seattle Seahawks)
#97 - LB Cornelius Bennet (Buffalo Bills)
#98 - DE Robert Mathis (Indianapolis Colts)
#99 - DE J.J. Watt (Houston Texans)
#00 - C Jim Otto (Oakland Raiders)
#HC - HC Bill Belichick (New England Patriots)
Yes, I really spent my time doing this.
Puggy well done!
This deserve more likes
Wow 10 for the Bears
The amount of disrespect. You spent all this time to do this, and got 15 likes. What a shame how people are
What I mean is that people just aren’t giving you respect