@kyledoesmusicreacts I can definitely understand why it might be that low for you, for a lot of us ATW10 is her magnum opus, something we had known existed for years even before her masters got stolen and triggered the re-recording project. It's rare to find any two Swifties who 100% agree on every song ranking and everyone's opinions are valid! (Superman off Speak Now is personally my least favorite in her entire discography) I've seen a lot of recommendation that the lyric video and/or the Short Film give the perspective of the song outside of a 30 track album if you're willing to give it another shot/listen.
About Ronan. Taylor found the mothers blog (maya thompson who is cretited as a co writer) and was so touched by it so she reached out to the mom and wrote this song with inspiration from the blog. So she never knew him. All the proceeds go to cancer research and the ronan foundation (50/50). After the taylors versions and stuff she reached out again and asked to place it on an album so it wouldn’t be another stolen song. She has stayed in contact with the family ever since. She has only performed it live twice. One for a cancer gala and once on the 1989 tour when ronans family was in the audience. She has also said she will never perform it without the familys concent. It’s anpther example of who she is as a person. Also the moment i knew is a perfect song. Love your reactions kyle🫶
red taylor's version has the best vault tracks imo ❤ you also should made a similar video to the one you reacted to "if this was a movie", reacting to "eyes open" and "safe & sound", both songs she sang for the hunger games soundtrack, which she also released taylor's versions of, and added to the red taylor's version collection.
I love that you loved Message In a Bottle that much, cause I swear no one else but me appreciated that song when the vault was released. In regards to the reviews; Taylor Swift has a very vocal hater following. What I mean is that as vocal as her fanbase is, her haters can sometimes be even more vocal. Usually the haters will mass review her albums and give them bad ratings. I never rely on Pitchfork, because they tend to give women artists a very low score and POP albums in general get a very low rating from them. Red to me is an amazing album because the listener gets a little bit of everything, but I also acknowledge that I'm biased based on my sentimentality towards an album that I've loved since 2012
1) HOW?!?!? Message in a bottle is such the perfect pop bop - how can people not love it!! 2) Yeah i undertsand that - unfortunately just something that comes with the fame i guess :( - I've also stopped giving pitchfork that much attention aha, they are so harsh for no reason 3) 100% agree - you get a nice little flavour of a few genres which is really cool cuase you get to go on a nice journey
the quality of your videos are great! i love how you actually include the audio. many with such a small following (which - you're underrated) don't include the audio. great video!
@@fifteendozenalleyroses moreso, many don't realize they can just screen record so we can hear the audio. many just play it on their phone and record them reacting to it. making us barely hear it, you know?
Red (Stolen Version) was released October 2012 which means the songs on it were written AT LEAST 6 months in advance. Taylor and Harry were not seen together before November 2012. Being the early days of her relationship with Jake G makes way more sense as she flew out to London to see him November 2010
@@cheezyb92 The song was written by Taylor and Dan Wilson over a two-day period in spring of 2012. Taylor first met Harry March 31, 2012 backstage at the Kids Choice Awards.
Also. Do reputation. We don’t know when taylors versions come out. Yes it could be next but we don’t know when. And it is an epic era that should be done before lover
@@kyledoesmusicreacts it is 😂 she actually released a christmas song called christmas tree farm. If you listen, go to the youtube video on taylors page. And she has a bunch of home videos in the background, so cute
Billie has been trashing Taylor all over the media because she’s a jealous little girl who has 20% of Taylor’s discography and even less accolades. It’s ridiculous for her to do 10% of the work that Taylor does but then turn around and say “she’d never make a 3.5 hour concert”. Maybe because Billie doesn’t have that many hits to fill that amount of time, nor the stage presence that Taylor does. She’s a whiny girl who needs to be quiet while the adults are playing at the top of every chart. No patience for Billie trying to stay relevant in the media by attacking Taylor for her style of concerts and different album variation offerings. She wishes she had that much creativity and freedom to do whatever she wanted like Taylor does.
Yeah, the "I'll get older but your lovers stay my age" isn't true (from the 10 min All Too Well). It's a great line, but it isn't a norm for Jake Gyllenhaal's dating history 🤷
@@kyledoesmusicreacts SO ICONIC and it always will be. And it will 100% apply to far too many men 😂😭 I just don't like fandom members believing everything their idol says as gospel truth and then really hating (as in going beyond just feelings... Stalking these guys online and in real life) because of a line that just isn't true. The guy did plenty of dodgy shyt. Let's dump on him for that Treating him like some predatory creep isn't ok tho. Doesn't stop the line from being 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😊
Don't let people fool you. Taylor grew up RICH. That farm was more like a holiday house farm than a working farm 😂 I think her parents did try to raise her and her brother more normally...but her father is such a huge financeer that he was able to make a huge investment into her first record label and move the entire family from Pennsylvania to Nashville so that Taylor could break into the country music scene. Her family is so well off that I'm pretty sure they knew the Kennedy's before she dated one of the grandsons just after she dated Gyllenhaal. Whereas Gyllenhaal did grow up in wealth amongst Hollywood elite...but he also had a super grounded family that made him and his sister do projects like Habitats for Humanity during their school holidays. Yeah, the lyric in I Bet You Think About Me is misleading and somewhat dodge. It's for dramatic purposes, I suppose 😂
@@kyledoesmusicreacts she is an incredible actor. Again, I think all of this doesn't mean that she is lying or trying to manipulate people. She often says she exaggerates in her earlier lyrics particularly because that is how she was feeling in those moments. I think with Gyllenhaal, she took a serious knock to her self confidence and I am sure his life and world was very different and far more glitzy than what she was used to. It's just important to me to keep it nuanced and balanced in retrospect 😬
They didn’t know the Kennedys lol. Rory Kennedy went to her concert, got a meet and greet and she became friends with the family that way. Taylor’s family was well off but being well off in Southwest PA is EXTREMELY different than being well off in Beverly Hills in a show business family no matter how many volunteer projects you do. Also her dad had 3% stake in a company that barely existed. They didn’t even have an office. I’m not saying they were poor by any means or that having parents who know money management and their jobs be transferred to different offices easily is a leg up most child stars have but trying to paint her family as these well-connected big wigs just isn’t factual.
We should have a drinking 🥃 game for every time Kyle says “production”. Talking during close to the entire album LISTEN was very off putting as your voice overrode Taylor’s. I think you like the way you sound but it would have been nice to hear the song. Isn’t that what a reaction is for? You listen, and then react?? 🤷🏼♀️
that would be a great drinking game!!! personally i like to watch people's reactions as they listen to the song - i find it a bit boring just watching people listening to music saying nothing - if thats not for you there's plenty other reaction channels on YT to watch, go show some love to them ❤
ATW10 that low feels illegal
😭😭😭😭😭 I knew people were going to say that - I cut like a whole minute out of me saying pls don't come for me for it ahaha
@kyledoesmusicreacts I can definitely understand why it might be that low for you, for a lot of us ATW10 is her magnum opus, something we had known existed for years even before her masters got stolen and triggered the re-recording project.
It's rare to find any two Swifties who 100% agree on every song ranking and everyone's opinions are valid! (Superman off Speak Now is personally my least favorite in her entire discography)
I've seen a lot of recommendation that the lyric video and/or the Short Film give the perspective of the song outside of a 30 track album if you're willing to give it another shot/listen.
@@cheezyb92 oh okay okay...i can add it to my list then!!!
About Ronan.
Taylor found the mothers blog (maya thompson who is cretited as a co writer) and was so touched by it so she reached out to the mom and wrote this song with inspiration from the blog. So she never knew him.
All the proceeds go to cancer research and the ronan foundation (50/50). After the taylors versions and stuff she reached out again and asked to place it on an album so it wouldn’t be another stolen song. She has stayed in contact with the family ever since.
She has only performed it live twice. One for a cancer gala and once on the 1989 tour when ronans family was in the audience. She has also said she will never perform it without the familys concent.
It’s anpther example of who she is as a person.
Also the moment i knew is a perfect song.
Love your reactions kyle🫶
omg I was about to go to bed and now I'm about to cry 🥲 ty so much for the info 🙏
@@kyledoesmusicreacts yeah it’s super sad but on a happier not the parents got anpther child shortly after and her middle name is ronan❤️
@@bellapeterson94 Two years later, Poppy Ronan Thompson.
@@Violet316 @bellapeterson94 that is so nice to hear 🥹
red taylor's version has the best vault tracks imo ❤ you also should made a similar video to the one you reacted to "if this was a movie", reacting to "eyes open" and "safe & sound", both songs she sang for the hunger games soundtrack, which she also released taylor's versions of, and added to the red taylor's version collection.
the vault tracks were phenomenal!!! And okay yeah maybe that's a shout ty!!
Kyle pls don't forget to react to Safe & Sound (Taylor's Version) and Eyes Open (Taylor's Version) too. They now "belong" to Red era songs :D
I think thats going to be next week's video atm - I will definitely be checking them out!!!
I love that you loved Message In a Bottle that much, cause I swear no one else but me appreciated that song when the vault was released.
In regards to the reviews; Taylor Swift has a very vocal hater following. What I mean is that as vocal as her fanbase is, her haters can sometimes be even more vocal. Usually the haters will mass review her albums and give them bad ratings. I never rely on Pitchfork, because they tend to give women artists a very low score and POP albums in general get a very low rating from them.
Red to me is an amazing album because the listener gets a little bit of everything, but I also acknowledge that I'm biased based on my sentimentality towards an album that I've loved since 2012
1) HOW?!?!? Message in a bottle is such the perfect pop bop - how can people not love it!!
2) Yeah i undertsand that - unfortunately just something that comes with the fame i guess :( - I've also stopped giving pitchfork that much attention aha, they are so harsh for no reason
3) 100% agree - you get a nice little flavour of a few genres which is really cool cuase you get to go on a nice journey
bit of a more chill editing style - hope you enjoy!!!
Better man is the most relatable song I’ve ever heard 🥲
aaaaand you put it at 28 hahahahah OKaaaaay (I'm gonna bully you on the next live
🤣🤣🤣 hoesntly it's hard to rank 30 songs cause they all change constantly ahaha
the quality of your videos are great! i love how you actually include the audio. many with such a small following (which - you're underrated) don't include the audio. great video!
oh wow ty so much!!!! I'm very happy you enjoyed the video ☺
@@kyledoesmusicreacts of course!!
Having a small following should mean they do include the audio bc they can’t be monetized anyway. That’s so weird
@@fifteendozenalleyroses moreso, many don't realize they can just screen record so we can hear the audio. many just play it on their phone and record them reacting to it. making us barely hear it, you know?
"Come Back… Be Here" is allegedly about Mr. Harry Styles. Which I believe 😊 Love that song 🫶🏼
Ahh okay okay
Red (Stolen Version) was released October 2012 which means the songs on it were written AT LEAST 6 months in advance.
Taylor and Harry were not seen together before November 2012.
Being the early days of her relationship with Jake G makes way more sense as she flew out to London to see him November 2010
@@cheezyb92 The song was written by Taylor and Dan Wilson over a two-day period in spring of 2012. Taylor first met Harry March 31, 2012 backstage at the Kids Choice Awards.
“Not sure who Phoebe Bridgers is”
That’s gotta change. You should make a video reacting to Stranger in the Alps/Punnisher(NOT the record)
🤣🤣 Another one to add to the list then!!!
Also message in a bottle is the first song she did with max martin. Which is her first try at real pop music☺️
and we both know how amazingly that went in the future....*cough*1989*cough*
Now we need a reaction to the all too well short film
I've been told about this!! It's on my list dw
Also. Do reputation. We don’t know when taylors versions come out. Yes it could be next but we don’t know when. And it is an epic era that should be done before lover
Noted ty!!!!!
You have to do reputation. It might be announced soon but possibly only coming out later in the year
Okay I've heard other people say the same so might be best to do it!!
The instrument at the beginning of The Moment I Knew with the piano is a cello. The player is bowing the strings REALLY hard at rhe beginning there 😢
omg you musical genius ty so much
@@kyledoesmusicreacts no worries 😊 I played a cello for two years. Lots of fun and a gorgeous, rich, deep sound 😊
@@emmavink 100% - convincing me to buy one ahahha
@@kyledoesmusicreacts 😂 they are SHITE expensive 😂 I rented mine from the music school I was with at the time.
Love Taylor's Version
are you posting 1989 today?? or a different taylor thing?
it was meant to be 1989 TV P1 - however my video corrupted and i have to edit it all again 🙃so will be next week!!
that sucks i’m sorry!! but based off the songs you liked from the first two albums i have a feeling you may have liked 1989
@@hallefarnsworth4154 that feeling may be correct 👀
She didn’t come from ”nothing” but she was very upper middle class. So she wasn’t like upper class rich. She lived on a christmas tree farm 😂
Ah okay I see I see, great to know ty ☺ maybe I'm weird but I think it's so cool to say that you lived on a Xmas tree farm ahaha
@@kyledoesmusicreacts it is 😂 she actually released a christmas song called christmas tree farm. If you listen, go to the youtube video on taylors page. And she has a bunch of home videos in the background, so cute
Billie Eilish Album "When we all fall asleep where do we go" reaction PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
I love you sm
Ty!!! I will add it to my list!!
@@kyledoesmusicreacts muah !!
Billie has been trashing Taylor all over the media because she’s a jealous little girl who has 20% of Taylor’s discography and even less accolades. It’s ridiculous for her to do 10% of the work that Taylor does but then turn around and say “she’d never make a 3.5 hour concert”. Maybe because Billie doesn’t have that many hits to fill that amount of time, nor the stage presence that Taylor does. She’s a whiny girl who needs to be quiet while the adults are playing at the top of every chart. No patience for Billie trying to stay relevant in the media by attacking Taylor for her style of concerts and different album variation offerings. She wishes she had that much creativity and freedom to do whatever she wanted like Taylor does.
Yeah, the "I'll get older but your lovers stay my age" isn't true (from the 10 min All Too Well). It's a great line, but it isn't a norm for Jake Gyllenhaal's dating history 🤷
it was such an iconic line though 😭😭😭😭😭
@@kyledoesmusicreacts SO ICONIC and it always will be. And it will 100% apply to far too many men 😂😭
I just don't like fandom members believing everything their idol says as gospel truth and then really hating (as in going beyond just feelings... Stalking these guys online and in real life) because of a line that just isn't true.
The guy did plenty of dodgy shyt. Let's dump on him for that Treating him like some predatory creep isn't ok tho.
Doesn't stop the line from being 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😊
Don't let people fool you. Taylor grew up RICH. That farm was more like a holiday house farm than a working farm 😂 I think her parents did try to raise her and her brother more normally...but her father is such a huge financeer that he was able to make a huge investment into her first record label and move the entire family from Pennsylvania to Nashville so that Taylor could break into the country music scene. Her family is so well off that I'm pretty sure they knew the Kennedy's before she dated one of the grandsons just after she dated Gyllenhaal.
Whereas Gyllenhaal did grow up in wealth amongst Hollywood elite...but he also had a super grounded family that made him and his sister do projects like Habitats for Humanity during their school holidays.
Yeah, the lyric in I Bet You Think About Me is misleading and somewhat dodge. It's for dramatic purposes, I suppose 😂
aaahhhhhhh okay i see i see - ty so much for explaining - shes a great actor then 🤣🤣
@@kyledoesmusicreacts she is an incredible actor. Again, I think all of this doesn't mean that she is lying or trying to manipulate people. She often says she exaggerates in her earlier lyrics particularly because that is how she was feeling in those moments.
I think with Gyllenhaal, she took a serious knock to her self confidence and I am sure his life and world was very different and far more glitzy than what she was used to.
It's just important to me to keep it nuanced and balanced in retrospect 😬
@@emmavink amazing point - i feel like its very important to go into things with that mideset
They didn’t know the Kennedys lol. Rory Kennedy went to her concert, got a meet and greet and she became friends with the family that way. Taylor’s family was well off but being well off in Southwest PA is EXTREMELY different than being well off in Beverly Hills in a show business family no matter how many volunteer projects you do. Also her dad had 3% stake in a company that barely existed. They didn’t even have an office. I’m not saying they were poor by any means or that having parents who know money management and their jobs be transferred to different offices easily is a leg up most child stars have but trying to paint her family as these well-connected big wigs just isn’t factual.
We should have a drinking 🥃 game for every time Kyle says “production”. Talking during close to the entire album LISTEN was very off putting as your voice overrode Taylor’s. I think you like the way you sound but it would have been nice to hear the song. Isn’t that what a reaction is for? You listen, and then react?? 🤷🏼♀️
that would be a great drinking game!!! personally i like to watch people's reactions as they listen to the song - i find it a bit boring just watching people listening to music saying nothing - if thats not for you there's plenty other reaction channels on YT to watch, go show some love to them ❤
@@kyledoesmusicreactsI love your vids and the way you react to these albums. I actually prefer it to most other reactors hahaha, neverrrr change 😊🫶
@@sh4dylol omg ty so much 🥹 icl I actually needed to here this rn 🫠